View source for Talk:Antisemitism in the Arab world

{{WikiProject banner shell|class=B|1=
{{WikiProject Religion|importance=Mid|Interfaith=yes}}
{{WikiProject Israel|importance=high}}
{{WikiProject Palestine|importance=High|attention=yes}}
{{WikiProject Jewish history|importance=mid}}
{{WikiProject Arab world|importance=high}}
{{WikiProject Judaism|importance=mid}}
{{WikiProject Ethnic groups|importance=mid}}
{{WikiProject Discrimination|importance=mid}}
}}
{{Warning antisemitism Arabs}}
{{Archives|banner=yes|auto=long|search=yes|bot=Lowercase sigmabot III|age=3|units=months|index=/Archive index}}
{{User:MiszaBot/config
|archiveheader = {{aan}}
|maxarchivesize = 100K
|counter = 3
|minthreadsleft = 10
|minthreadstoarchive = 1
|algo = old(90d)
|archive = Talk:Antisemitism in the Arab world/Archive %(counter)d
}}
{{ARBPIA}}
{{User:HBC Archive Indexerbot/OptIn
|target=/Archive index
|mask=/Archive <#>
|leading_zeros=0
|indexhere=yes}}
{{Broken anchors|links=
* <nowiki>[[Yellow badge#Medieval Catholic Europe|Catholic ordinances]]</nowiki>  The anchor (#Medieval Catholic Europe) is no longer available because it was [[Special:Diff/1003074979|deleted by a user]] before. <!-- {"title":"Medieval Catholic Europe","appear":{"revid":562010912,"parentid":560868403,"timestamp":"2013-06-28T19:34:42Z","replaced_anchors":{"Medieval Christian Europe":"Medieval Catholic Europe"},"removed_section_titles":["Medieval Christian Europe","Medieval Christian Europe"],"added_section_titles":["Medieval Catholic Europe","Medieval Catholic Europe"]},"disappear":{"revid":1003074979,"parentid":1003011199,"timestamp":"2021-01-27T08:24:36Z","replaced_anchors":{"Medieval and Early Modern Europe":"Medieval and early modern Europe"},"removed_section_titles":["Islamic world","Medieval Catholic Europe","Nazi Germany and Axis Powers","Islamic world","Medieval and Early Modern Europe","Nazi Germany and Axis Powers"],"added_section_titles":["Caliphates","Medieval and early modern Europe","Axis Powers","Caliphates","Medieval and early modern Europe","Axis Powers"]}} -->
}}

== Why the insistence on using increasingly oxymoronic/archaic term "anti-semitism"?==
Why not its functional & more accurate synonym, anti-Jewish? The insistence on using "anti-semitism" to describe conflict between two Semitic groups comes across as a deliberate attempt to provoke or flummox the reader.  <!-- Template:Unsigned IP --><small class="autosigned">—&nbsp;Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[Special:Contributions/2601:1C0:C801:9FA0:B9BA:D85E:9C25:1575|2601:1C0:C801:9FA0:B9BA:D85E:9C25:1575]] ([[User talk:2601:1C0:C801:9FA0:B9BA:D85E:9C25:1575#top|talk]]) 02:09, 2 February 2019 (UTC)</small> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->
{{Warning antisemitism Arabs}}

== Fake list of pogroms ==

I am removing:
: Nevertheless, pogroms spread through the Middle East and North Africa: Aleppo (1850, 1875), Damascus (1840, 1848, 1890), Beirut (1862, 1874), Dayr al-Qamar (1847), Jaffa (1876), Jerusalem (1847, 1870 and 1895), Cairo (1844, 1890, 1901–02), Mansura (1877), Alexandria (1870, 1882, 1901–07), Port Said (1903, 1908), and Damanhur (1871, 1873, 1877, 1891). —— Yossef Bodansky. ''Islamic Anti-Semitism as a Political Instrument'' Co-Produced by The Ariel Center for Policy Research and The Freeman Center for Strategic Studies, 1999. {{ISBN|978-0-9671391-0-4}}, see also ''The Encyclopedia of World History'' By Peter N. Stearns, William Leonard Langer p. 527. 2001.
Reasons:
# [[Yossef Bodansky]] is not a historian but a neocon with a penchant for conspiracy theories.[https://oilprice.com/Geopolitics/International/Did-the-White-House-Help-Plan-the-Syrian-Chemical-Attack.html] He is best known for his ultra-fringe claim that Osama bin-Laden had nuclear weapons (see his article).
# The individual items Jerusalem (1870, 1895) and Jaffa (1876) come not from Bodansky but from the weak tertiary encyclopedia that is not an acceptable source. In any case, it does not confirm pogroms in those years and I challenge anyone to prove that they happened. I searched multiple detailed sources including contemporary Jewish newspapers. There is also a direct statement in the [[Shaw Commission]] report that no such events happened (p150).
# Leaving those three items aside, the list was added in [https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Antisemitism_in_the_Arab_world&diff=137203048&oldid=137202511 2007] and soon pruned to remove non-Arab locations. Looking at the original list, we see a perfect match with Bernard Lewis, ''The Jews of Islam'', p158. This is evidently Bodansky's source, and Lewis is reliable. However, Lewis does not identify them as pogroms but as blood libels. Blood libels may or may not be accompanied by pogroms, so let's look at a few examples.
# Jerusalem 1847. There is a detailed account on pages 107–110 of James and Elizabeth Finn, ''Stirring Times'', Vol 1. Summary from Simon Montefiore, ''Biography of Jerusalem'': "In 1847, a Christian Arab boy attacked a Jewish youth who threw back a pebble which grazed the Arab boy’s foot. The Greek Orthodox traditionally the most anti-Semitic community, quickly backed by the Muslim mufti and qadi, accused the Jews of procuring Christian blood to bake the Passover biscuits: the blood libel had come to Jerusalem, but the sultan’s ban, granted to Montefiore after the Damascus affair, proved decisive." No actual violence mentioned in either source. No pogrom.
# Cairo 1844. Norman Stillman, ''The Jews of Arab Lands'', p106: "Muslims in Cairo accused the Jews of murdering a Christian for his blood. This time, however, Muhammad Ali quickly stepped in to prevent any violence and to see that justice was done." Encyclopedia Judaica, v15, p530: "In 1844 a blood libel occurred in Egypt when the Jews of Cairo were accused of murdering a Christian. Only the firmness of Muhammad Ali prevented the outbreak of violence." No pogrom.
# Mansura 1877. Jacob Landau, ''The Jews in nineteenth-century Egypt'', p39: (summary) After a Muslim child disappeared, the Jews were accused and a mob came to search for the child in the synagogue and Jewish homes. The child was found elsewhere and the Muslim inciters were given a large fine. This event was undoubtedly terrifying for the Jews, but neither Landau nor the primary source he gives (''La Levanon'', May 16, 1877, p320) mention any injuries. No pogrom. 
# Alexandria 1870. Jacob Landau, ''The Jews in nineteenth-century Egypt'', pp182–183: (summary) A Maltese citizen accused a Jew of kidnapping his daughter. The Jew was arrested and put on trial. No pogrom.
# Dayr al-Qamar 1847. Norman Stillman, ''The Jews of Arab Lands'', p106: A blood libel by local Maronites did not "[end] in tragedy". No pogrom.
# Aleppo 1850. Yaron Harel. Jewish-Christian relations in Aleppo as background for the Jewish response to the events of October 1850, ''International Journal of Middle East Studies'', Vol. 30, No. 1 (Feb., 1998), pp77–96 provides a very detailed account. Muslim rioters attacked the Christian quarter, killing many. The riots were put down with much death and destruction. Harel shows that reports that the Jewish quarter was also attacked were not true, based on a contemporary Jewish account and other evidence. The riots resulted from Muslim political hatred of Christians, and in this opinion the Jews sided with the Muslims. "Moreover, Muslims encouraged Jews to take revenge on their Christian enemies when the latter harassed them with libelous accusations". Harel mentions a blood libel made by Christians in 1853, but "[t]he court, composed of three Muslim notables, ruled unequivocally that the accusation was a libelous falsehood". No pogrom.
# My aim is to discredit the claim that Bodansky's list is a list of pogroms. I don't intend to give the impression that there was never any violence against Jews. Some of these blood libels led to violence, but I did not find any examples involving mass casualties and none that are called pogroms by academic sources (except Damascus 1840 which rightfully has its own paragraph). The usual is like Damanhur 1873. Norman Stillman, ''The Jews of Arab Lands'', pp426–7: "the native Turks entered the School, beating the Jews who were found there, breaking the Ark of the Holy Law". In Port Said 1892, a Greek mob inflamed by rumors that Jews had kidnapped a Greek girl beat up an elderly Jew who then died of shock. Windows were broken, rioters arrested, no other serious injuries (Jacob M. Landau, Ritual murder accusations and persecutions of Jews in 19th century Egypt, ''Sefunot'', v5 1961, 417–460). I don't believe these qualify as pogroms and in any case the sources don't call them that.
I have information on most of the other incidents too, but enough is enough. Bodansky's list is fake. [[User:Zero0000|Zero]]<sup><small>[[User_talk:Zero0000|talk]]</small></sup> 03:51, 19 October 2020 (UTC)
: Perhaps it would be better to keep them, just change "pogroms" to "blood libels", in those cases where it is applicable? [[User:Debresser|Debresser]] ([[User talk:Debresser|talk]]) 14:30, 19 October 2020 (UTC)
::[https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Antisemitism_in_the_Arab_world&type=revision&diff=984346437&oldid=984260915 DONE].  {{tick}} --[[User:GHcool|GHcool]] ([[User talk:GHcool|talk]]) 16:57, 19 October 2020 (UTC)

== [[:Talk:Ilhan_Omar#RFC]] has an [[WP:RFC|RFC]]==

<div class="floatleft" style="margin-bottom:0">[[File:Ambox warning orange.svg|48px|alt=|link=]]</div>'''[[:Talk:Ilhan_Omar#RFC]]''' has an RFC for possible consensus. A discussion is taking place. If you would like to participate in the discussion, you are invited to add your comments on the '''[[discussion page|discussion page]]'''.<!-- Template:Rfc notice--> Thank you. [[User:Benevolent human|Benevolent human]] ([[User talk:Benevolent human|talk]]) 00:38, 13 June 2021 (UTC)

== Edit Request ==

{{edit extended-protected|Antisemitism in the Arab world|answered=yes}}
Please add the following to the front of the "Israeli Arabs" section:  

Of all groups surveyed, a 2010 Pew Research global poll found that Israeli Arabs have the lowest rate of anti-Jewish attitudes in the Middle East.<ref>{{cite web |title=Pew global survey |url=pewresearch.org/global/2010/02/04/chapter-3-views-of-religious-groups/ |website=Pew Research Center |access-date=18 September 2021}}</ref>  

[[User:Scharb|Scharb]] ([[User talk:Scharb|talk]]) 18:58, 19 September 2021 (UTC)
:{{done}}<!-- Template:EEp --> [[User:ScottishFinnishRadish|ScottishFinnishRadish]] ([[User talk:ScottishFinnishRadish|talk]]) 11:04, 21 September 2021 (UTC)

{{reflist-talk}}

== The first paragraph needs improvement ==
The real reasons there’s so much antisemitism in the Middle East: [[Nakba]], [[Killings and massacres during the 1948 Palestine war]], [[Israeli torture in the occupied territories]], [[Israeli demolition of Palestinian property]], [[Price tag attack policy]], [[Zionist political violence]], [[Jewish religious terrorism]], [[Blockade of the Gaza Strip]], [[Dahiya doctrine]], etc. I think this article would be improved if these things were mentioned in the first paragraph. [[User:ILoveHirasawaYui|ILoveHirasawaYui]] ([[User talk:ILoveHirasawaYui|talk]]) 05:45, 13 June 2022 (UTC)

: This is not a useful suggestion. Articles are based on what reliable sources say, not on what editors believe. [[User:Zero0000|Zero]]<sup><small>[[User_talk:Zero0000|talk]]</small></sup> 12:01, 13 June 2022 (UTC)

== Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 5 May 2023 ==

{{edit extended-protected|Antisemitism in the Arab world|answered=yes}}
 [[Special:Contributions/2001:56A:7D26:6D00:8CE4:BE49:E78F:9B36|2001:56A:7D26:6D00:8CE4:BE49:E78F:9B36]] ([[User talk:2001:56A:7D26:6D00:8CE4:BE49:E78F:9B36|talk]]) 04:42, 5 May 2023 (UTC)
Arabs cannot be antisemitic as Arabs are semites
{{Warning antisemitism Arabs}}

== [[:Timeline of antisemitism]] has an [[WP:RFC|RfC]]==

<div class="floatleft" style="margin-bottom:0">[[File:Ambox warning orange.svg|48px|alt=|link=]]</div>'''[[:Timeline of antisemitism]]''' has an RfC for possible consensus. A discussion is taking place. If you would like to participate in the discussion, you are invited to add your comments on the '''[[Talk: Timeline of antisemitism#Request for Comment: Is the imposition of the Dhimmi status and jizya upon Jews antisemitism?|discussion page]]'''.<!-- Template:Rfc notice--> Thank you. [[User:Patsw|patsw]] ([[User talk:Patsw|talk]]) 23:28, 16 January 2024 (UTC)

== edit proposal: ==

edit request: add this image under "Yemen":

[[:File:Ansar Allah fighters.jpg]] [[Special:Contributions/192.114.1.67|192.114.1.67]] ([[User talk:192.114.1.67|talk]]) 14:05, 9 June 2024 (UTC)

== Why start with rise?  ==

Even before providing a general overview or describing what the article is about, it starts with a claim about a "growing problem." Shouldn't that be at least paragraph two? This smacks of bias against the Muslim world. Antisemitism in Christianity doesn't start with the same kind of narrative.  [[User:Jamabdi|Jamabdi]] ([[User talk:Jamabdi|talk]]) 23:45, 18 September 2024 (UTC)