View source for Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Quality Article Improvement/Infobox/Archive 2

{{Automatic archive navigator}}
{{collapse top|Discussions archived from a [[Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Quality Article Improvement/Infobox|deleted page]] — do not modify|expand=true}}
{{Infobox classical composer
| name             = Jean Sibelius
| image            = Jean Sibelius, 1913.jpg
| alt              = 
| caption          = Sibelius in 1913
| image_size       = 
| landscape        = <!-- Enter the value yes when using wide, short images. -->
| birth_name       = Johan Julius Christian Sibelius
| birth_date       = {{Birth date|1865|12|08}}
| birth_place      = [[Hämeenlinna]], [[Finland]]
| baptised         = 
| death_date       = {{Death date and age|1957|09|20|1865|12|08}}
| death_place      = [[Ainola]], [[Järvenpää]], Finland
| flourished       = 
| notable_family   = 
| era              = [[Romantic music|Romantic]]
| occupations      = 
| known_for        = 
| list_of_works    = [[List of compositions by Jean Sibelius|List of compositions]]
| spouse           = [[Aino Sibelius]]
}}

{{Infobox person
| name         = Frédéric Chopin
| image        = Frédéric Chopin by Bisson, 1849.png 
| imagesize    = 
| alt          = 
| caption      = Photograph of Chopin by [[Louis-Auguste Bisson|Bisson]], {{circa|1849}}  
| birth_name   = Fryderyk Franciszek Chopin
| birth_date   = {{birth date|1810|03|01|df=y}} {{nowrap|(or possibly 22 February 1810)}}
| birth_place  = [[Żelazowa Wola]], near [[Warsaw]]
| death_date   = {{death date|1849|10|17|df=y}}
| death_place  = [[Place Vendôme]], [[Paris]]
| works        = [[List of compositions by Frédéric Chopin by genre|List of compositions]]
}} 

'''Archive 2015'''

The following discussion was initiated by {{user|Gerda Arendt}} in June 2013.

'''I dream of the day that the [[infobox]] is a simple tool of accessibility.'''

== Table of inclusions of musical composition infoboxes ==

{{tl|infobox musical composition}} {{tl|infobox Bach composition}} {{tl|infobox opera}}

=== 2015 stats ===

{| class="wikitable sortable" style="margin-right: 0;"
! Date !! Composition !! Bach !! Opera 
|-
| 1 Jan 2015 || 256 || 185 || 100
|-
| 2 Feb 2015 || 293 || 186 || 118
|-
| 2 Mar 2015 || 334 || 186 || 123
|-
| 2 Apr 2015 || 349 || 187 || 127
|-
| 2 May 2015 || 357 || 187 || 131
|-
| 2 Jun 2015 || 369 || 187 || 136
|-
| 1 Jul 2015 || 409 || 189 || 143
|-
| 1 Aug 2015 || 422 || 188 || 157
|-
| 30 Aug 2015 || 433 || 193 || 164
|-
| 1 Oct 2015 || 440 || 196 || 170
|-
| 1 Nov 2015 || 444 || 197 || 177
|-
| 1 Dec 2015 || 453 || 199 || 180
|-
| 31 Dec 2015 || 498 || 202 || 184
|-
|}

January: [[Don Giovanni]] --[[User:Gerda Arendt|Gerda Arendt]] ([[User talk:Gerda Arendt|talk]]) 22:37, 1 January 2015 (UTC)

April: [[Lohengrin (opera)|Lohengrin]] --[[User:Gerda Arendt|Gerda Arendt]] ([[User talk:Gerda Arendt|talk]]) 07:00, 2 May 2015 (UTC)

May: [[Beethoven]] --[[User:Gerda Arendt|Gerda Arendt]] ([[User talk:Gerda Arendt|talk]]) 06:03, 2 June 2015 (UTC)

July: [[Das Liebesverbot|The Ban on Love]] --[[User:Gerda Arendt|Gerda Arendt]] ([[User talk:Gerda Arendt|talk]]) 05:32, 1 August 2015 (UTC)

August: [[Geist und Seele wird verwirret, BWV 35]] --[[User:Gerda Arendt|Gerda Arendt]] ([[User talk:Gerda Arendt|talk]]) 06:55, 1 October 2015 (UTC)

October: [[Johann Sebastian Bach]] --[[User:Gerda Arendt|Gerda Arendt]] ([[User talk:Gerda Arendt|talk]]) 08:43, 1 November 2015 (UTC)

November: <s>[[Joseph (opera)]]</s> --[[User:Gerda Arendt|Gerda Arendt]] ([[User talk:Gerda Arendt|talk]]) 07:55, 1 December 2015 (UTC)

December: Sibelius --[[User:Gerda Arendt|Gerda Arendt]] ([[User talk:Gerda Arendt|talk]]) 08:21, 1 January 2016 (UTC)

== Discussions and reverts ==

The dates indicate when an infobox was installed that was later reverted, or suggested but not accepted. The colour red indicates no infobox.

=== 2015 ===

{| class="wikitable sortable" style="margin-right: 0;"
! Article !! type !! date
|-
| {{diff|Michael Tippett|640614583|640584304|Michael Tippett}}  || style="background: red" | person || 2 Jan TFA 
|-
| [[Ian Bostridge]] || person || 17 Jan
|-
| {{diff|Rose Leclerc|643534791|629055493|Rose Leclerc}} || style="background: red" | person || 21 Jan
|-
| {{diff|Albert Ketèlbey|644525796||Albert Ketèlbey}} || person || 28 Jan
|-
| {{diff|Adoration of the Shepherds (Domenichino)|646686362||Adoration of the Shepherds (Domenichino)}} || artwork || 11 Feb
|-
| {{diff|Franz_Liszt|646938004|645808911|Franz Liszt}} || style="background: red" | person || 13 Feb
|-
| {{diff|Lulu Wang|650453575||Lulu Wang}} || person || 8 Mar
|-
| [[James Joyce]] || style="background: red" | person || [[Talk:James Joyce#RfC: Should this article have an infobox?|3 Jun RfC]]
|-
| [[Mass in C major (Beethoven)]] || composition || 22 Jun
|-
| [[Lohengrin (opera)]] || opera || 27 Aug
|-
| [[Die Laune des Verliebten]] || opera || 27 Aug
|-
| [[Die Hochzeit]] || opera || 27 Aug
|-
| [[Männerlist größer als Frauenlist]] || opera || 27 Aug
|-
| [[Tannhäuser (opera)]] || opera || 27 Aug
|-
| [[Rienzi]] || opera || 27 Aug
|-
| [[The Marriage of Figaro]] || opera || 16 Sep
|-
| {{diff|Gioachino Rossini|686673281|685616637|Gioachino Rossini}} || style="background: red" | person || 20 Dec
|-
| {{diff|Eileen Sharp|694020680|694016340|Eileen Sharp}} || style="background: red" | musical artist || 6 Dec
|-
|}

=== 2014 ===

{| class="wikitable sortable" style="margin-right: 0;"
! Article
! type 
! date
|-
| [[Symphony No. 5 (Bruckner)]] || composition 
|-
| [[Symphony No. 8 (Bruckner)]] || composition 
|-
| [[Symphony No. 1 (Bruckner)]] || composition 
|-
| [[Missa in B minor (Bach)]] || Bach
|-
| {{diff|Trayvon Martin|590155892|589712286|Trayvon Martin}} || person || 11 Jan
|-
| {{diff|Polish Requiem|596935863|588748970|Polish Requiem}} || composition || 24 Feb
|-
| {{diff|Franciszek Mączyński|602304739|591174959|Franciszek Mączyński}} || ibox || 1 Apr
|-
| {{diff|John McCabe (composer)|605048523|582434926|John McCabe}} || style="background: red" | person || 20 Apr
|-
| {{diff|Toilet paper orientation|607526289|605412361|Toilet paper orientation}} || style="background: red" | ibox|| 7 May
|-
| [[Talk:Georges Bizet#Question to the Consensus|Talk:Georges Bizet]] || style="background: red" | person || 20 May
|-
| [[Richard Adeney]] || person 
|-
| [[String Quartet (Bruckner)]] || composition
|-
| [[String Quintet (Bruckner)]] || composition
|-
| [[Anna Kravtchenko]] || person 
|-
| [[José Carlos Cocarelli]] || person (10 cases)
|-
| {{diff|Sophie Dahl|618840921|609990860|Sophie Dahl}} || style="background: red" | person || 28 Jul
|-
| {{diff|Frédéric Chopin|622753180|622751386|Chopin}} || style="background: red" | person || 25 Aug
|-
| {{diff|Herr Gott, Beherrscher aller Dinge, BWV 120a|623422960|592599870|Herr Gott, Beherrscher aller Dinge, BWV 120a}} || Bach || 30 Aug
|-
| [[Intermezzo in D minor (Bruckner)]] || composition 
|-
| [[Rondo in C minor (Bruckner)]] || composition
|-
| [[Locus iste (Bruckner)]] || composition
|-
| {{diff|Bach's church music in Latin|531306105|486791596|Missa (Bach)}} || style="background: red" | Bach || 26 Oct
|-
| [[Missa, BWV 233]] || style="background: red" | Bach (4) || 26 Oct
|-
| {{diff|Colleen Evans|631454575|631239261|Colleen Evans}} || style="background: red" | person || [[Talk:Colleen Evans]] 28 Oct + 6
|-
| {{diff|W. B. Yeats|635252310|634950829|Yeats}} || style="background: red" | person || 24 Nov
|-
| {{diff|Ludwig van Beethoven|635894176|635074684|Beethoven}} || person || 29 Nov
|-
| {{diff|John Gielgud|636577348|635415560|John Gielgud}} || style="background: red" | person || 4 Dec
|-
|}

=== 2013 ===

The numbered articles were presented (with more detail) as evidence in the arbcom case in 2013.

{| class="wikitable sortable" style="margin-right: 0;"
! !! Article !! type !! date
|-
| 1 || {{nowrap|[[Symphony No. 1 (Bruckner)]]}} || composition || (2007)
|-
|  || {{diff|Robert Stoepel|541984203|536566782|Robert Stoepel}} || person
|-
|  || {{diff|Orlando furioso (Vivaldi)|545062507|544005457|Orlando furioso}} || opera
|-
|  || {{diff|Motezuma|545073369|544718864|Motezuma}} || opera
|-
| 2 || [[Philipp Glass]] || musician
|-
|  || {{diff|John Le Mesurier|549953007|549949550|John Le Mesurier}} || style="background: red" | person
|-
| 3 || [[Andreas Scholl]] || person 
|-
| 4 || [[Arthur Worsley]] || person 
|-
| 5 || [[Carleton W. Angell]] || person 
|-
| 6 || [[Forsbrook Pendant]] || artwork 
|-
| 7 || [[Dancing Barry]] || person 
|-
| 8 || [[Mass in B minor structure]] || Bach 
|-
| 9 || [[BWV 105]] || style="background: red" | Bach 
|-
| 10 || [[Robert Callahan (judge)]] || person 
|-
| 11 || [[Hans Severus Ziegler]] || person 
|-
| 12 || [[Lloyd Hartman Elliott]] || person 
|-
| 13 || [[Howell Conant]] || person 
|-
| 14 || [[Messiah structure]] || composition 
|-
| 15 || [[Christopher Pinchbeck]] || person 
|-
| 16 || [[Russian Symphony Orchestra Society]] || musical artist 
|-
| 17 || [[Renaissance Theatre Company]] || organization 
|-
| 18 || [[Messiah Part I]] || composition 
|-
| 19 || [[Cathedral of Blessed Mother Teresa in Pristina]] || church 
|-
| 20 || [[Robert Stoepel]] || person 
|-
| 21 || [[Peter Planyavsky]] || person 
|-
| 22 || [[Penns Hall]] || building 
|-
| 23 || [[Reginald Aspinwall]] || person 
|-
| 24 || [[Johann Sebastian Bach]] || person  
|-
| 25 || [[George Frideric Handel]] || person 
|-
| 26 || [[St Matthew Passion structure]] || Bach 
|-
| 27 || [[Holzhausenschlösschen]] || building 
|-
| 28 || [[Sparrow Mass]] || style="background: red" | composition 
|-
| 29 || [[BWV 103]] || Bach 
|-
| 30 || [[St Mary's, Bryanston Square]] || church  
|-
| 31 || [[St. Severin, Keitum]] || church 
|-
| 32 || [[Jochem Hendricks]] || person 
|-
| 33 || [[Sally Ryan]] || person 
|-
| 34 || [[The Rite of Spring]] || composition 
|-
| 35 || [[Carmen]] || opera
|-
| 36 || [[Nixon in China (opera)]] || opera
|-
| 37 || [[Das Rheingold]] || opera || {{diff|Das Rheingold|678094779|667743847|27 Aug 2015}}
|-
| 38 || [[L'incoronazione di Poppea]] || opera
|-
| 39 || {{diff|La Navarraise|560748550|541330423|La Navarraise}} || opera
|-
| 40 || [[Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg]] || opera || {{diff|Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg|678092992|670939409|27 Aug 2015}}
|-
| 41 || {{diff|Joseph (opera)|695625270|693445269|Joseph (opera)}} || style="background: red" | opera || 22 Jun
|-
| 42 || [[Die Walküre]] || opera || {{diff|Die Walküre|678094975|675975040|27 Aug 2015}}
|-
| 43 || [[Die Feen]] || opera || {{diff|Die Feen|678099502|678093134|27 Aug 2015}}
|-
| 44 || [[Falstaff (opera)]] || opera 
|-
| 45 || [[Don Carlos]] || opera 
|-
| 46 || [[Rigoletto]] || opera 
|-
| 47 || [[Das Liebesverbot]] || opera || {{diff|Das Liebesverbot|678093244|672559578|27 Aug 2015}}
|-
| 48 || [[Mont Juic (suite)]] || composition 
|-
| 49 || [[Fatinitza]] || opera 
|-
|  || {{diff|William Burges|564402154|564401113|William Burges}} || person
|-
| 50 || [[Götterdämmerung]] || opera || {{diff|Götterdämmerung|678095229|667882374|25 Aug 2015}}
|-
| 51 || [[Cantata academica]] || composition
|-
| 52 || [[Siegfried (opera)|Siegfried]] || opera || {{diff|Siegfried (opera)|678095040|669047300|25 Aug 2015}}
|-
| 53 || [[Der Ring des Nibelungen]] || opera || {{diff|Der Ring des Nibelungen|678094386|677903436|25 Aug 2015}}
|-
| 54 || [[Geist und Seele wird verwirret, BWV 35]] || Bach
|-
| 55 || [[Giuseppe Verdi]] || person || t 13 Aug
|-
| 56 || [[Peter Warlock]] || person 
|-
| 57 || [[BWV 71]] || Bach 
|-
| 58 || [[Symphony No. 8 (Dvořák)]] || composition 
|-
| 59 || [[Cello Concerto (Elgar)]] || style="background: red" | composition 
|-
|  || {{diff|Romeo and Juliet (Tchaikovsky)|571069197|562180112|Romeo and Juliet (Tchaikovsky)}} || style="background: red" | composition 
|-
| || {{diff|Joseph Priestley|571209538|571208803|Joseph Priestley}} || style="background: red" | person || {{nowrap|2 Sep 2013}}
|-
| || {{diff|Victor Bruns|585190394|585187950|Victor Bruns}} || person || 
|-
| || [[Jauchzet Gott in allen Landen, BWV 51]] || Bach || 4 Sep
|-
| || [[Ich geh und suche mit Verlangen, BWV 49]] || Bach || 10 Oct
|-
|}

=== Before ===

{| class="wikitable sortable" style="margin-right: 0;"
! Article !! type !! date
|-
| {{diff|Frank Sinatra|31807581|31739661|Frank Sinatra}} || person || 18 Dec 2005
|-
| {{diff|Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart|51842651|51812788|Mozart}} || style="background: red" | person || 6 May 2006
|-
| {{nowrap|{{diff|Laurence_Olivier|55144720|54732878|Laurence Olivier}}}} || style="background: red" | person || 25 May 2006
|-
| {{diff|Rod_Steiger|62516336|62396400|Rod Steiger}} || style="background: red" | person || 7 July 2006
|-
| {{diff|Jean Sibelius|66940779|66927290|Jean Sibelius}} || style="background: red" | person || 31 Jul 2006
|-
| {{diff|Cary Grant|57064172|57062297|Cary Grant}} || style="background: red" | person || 6 Jun 2006 - {{diff|Cary Grant|725418797|725416603|15 Jun 2016}}
|-
| {{diff|Catherine Zeta-Jones|69591561|69590617|Catherine Zeta-Jones}} || person || 14 August 2006
|-
| {{diff|Deepika Padukone|71051328|70617295|Deepika Padukone}} || style="background: red" | person || 21 August 2006, {{diff|Deepika Padukone|631725614|631725325|30 Oct 2014}}
|-
| {{nowrap|{{diff|Peter Sellers|87411201|87099063|Peter Sellers}}}} || person || 12 Nov 2006
|-
| {{diff|George Formby|108389816|108277964|George Formby}} || style="background: red" | person || 15 Feb 2007
|-
| {{diff|Daisy Dormer|108376865|86054661|Daisy Dormer}} || person || 15 Feb 2007
|-
| {{diff|Georg_Solti|116545091|115771467|Georg Solti}} || style="background: red" | person || 20 Mar 2007
|-
| {{nowrap|{{diff|Isaac Stern|146274428|145163744|Isaac Stern}}}} || style="background: red" | person || 22 Jul 2007
|-
| {{diff|Kenneth_Horne|158945186|149216055|Kenneth Horne}} || style="background: red" | person || 19 Sep 2007
|-
| {{nowrap|{{diff|Richard Harris (composer)|222713199|188961757|Richard Harris (composer)}}}} || style="background: red" | person || 30 June 2008
|-
| [[Victor Bedikian]] || style="background: red" | ibox || [https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Victor_Bedikian&oldid=321907189 25 October 2009]
|-
| {{diff|Samuel Barber|330124657|327856147|Samuel Barber}} || style="background: red" | person || 6 Dec 2009
|-
| [[Test Match Sofa]] || radio show || 7 Dec 2010
|-
| {{diff|Blues dance|461155300|461154421|Blues dance}} || style="background: red" | ibox || 17 Nov 2011
|-
| [[Noël Coward]] || style="background: red" | person || 2 Dec 2011, RfC 15 Aug 2016, closed 29 Aug, but
|-
| [[Character of the Happy Warrior]] || ibox, now poem ||
|-
| [[I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud]] || ibox, now poem ||
|-
| {{diff|Camille Saint-Saëns|493288474|493230920|Camille Saint-Saëns}} || style="background: red" | person || 12 May 2012
|-
| [[Poor Susan]] || ibox, now poem ||
|-
| {{diff|Ian Fleming|504402338|504396653|Ian Fleming}} || style="background: red" | person || 27 Jul 2012
|-
| {{diff|Josephine Butler|506574058|496423548|Josephine Butler}} || style="background: red" | person || 9 Aug 2012
|-
|}

latest entry --[[User:Gerda Arendt|Gerda Arendt]] ([[User talk:Gerda Arendt|talk]]) 07:38, 29 August 2016 (UTC)

== Why we use infoboxes ==

Where is the links to the stats on the percentage of wikipedia articles with infoboxes and also where is that cool list of good reasons to have infoboxes?  Can we link them here for easy access?  [[User:Montanabw|<span style="color:#006600;">Montanabw</span>]][[User talk:Montanabw|<sup style="color:purple;">(talk)</sup>]] 19:44, 2 February 2015 (UTC)
:[[Wikipedia:WikiProject Infoboxes/Statistics]], but please note it is well out of date. <span class="vcard"><span class="fn">[[User:Pigsonthewing|Andy Mabbett]]</span> (<span class="nickname">Pigsonthewing</span>); [[User talk:Pigsonthewing|Talk to Andy]]; [[Special:Contributions/Pigsonthewing|Andy's edits]]</span> 22:08, 2 February 2015 (UTC)
:Also [[Wikipedia:WikiProject Infoboxes#Benefits of infoboxes]]. <span class="vcard"><span class="fn">[[User:Pigsonthewing|Andy Mabbett]]</span> (<span class="nickname">Pigsonthewing</span>); [[User talk:Pigsonthewing|Talk to Andy]]; [[Special:Contributions/Pigsonthewing|Andy's edits]]</span> 22:12, 2 February 2015 (UTC)