Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/Pepperpiggle: Difference between revisions
Appearance
Content deleted Content added
→Oppose: O |
MalnadachBot (talk | contribs) m Fixed Lint errors. (Task 12) |
||
(9 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
<div class="boilerplate metadata rfa" style="background-color: #fff5f5; margin: 2em 0 0 0; padding: 0 10px 0 10px; border: 1px solid #AAAAAA;"> |
|||
:''The following discussion is preserved as an archive of a [[wikipedia:requests for adminship|request for adminship]] that '''did not succeed'''. <strong style="color:red">Please do not modify it.</strong>[[Category:Unsuccessful requests for adminship|{{SUBPAGENAME}}]] |
|||
===[[Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/Pepperpiggle|Pepperpiggle]]=== |
===[[Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/Pepperpiggle|Pepperpiggle]]=== |
||
'''(3/9/3); [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Requests_for_adminship/Pepperpiggle&diff=349894820&oldid=349892025 Withdrawn by candidate] at 22:55, 14 March 2010 (UTC)''' |
|||
<span class="plainlinks">'''[{{fullurl:Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/Pepperpiggle|action=edit§ion=5}} <font color="#002BB8">Voice your opinion on this candidate</font>]'''</span> ([[Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/Pepperpiggle|talk page]]) |
|||
'''{{rfatally|Pepperpiggle}}<!-- THIS TEMPLATE MUST BE REPLACED WITH THE CLOSING TALLY WHEN CLOSING THIS RFA -->; Scheduled to end 14:50, 21 March 2010 (UTC)''' |
|||
====Nomination==== |
====Nomination==== |
||
{{User|Pepperpiggle}} – Hello, I am Pepperpiggle, and I have been editing Wikipedia for just over 1 year (my [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Guinea_pig&action=historysubmit&diff=274269264&oldid=274088133#Domestic_habitat first edit] was on March 1, 2009), and took [a what I now know is called] a Wikibreak, and resumed editing on May 12th. I feel that I am ready to become an administrator because I have learned from my mistakes, and have experience in quite a few of the Admin areas, (mainly [[WP:AIV|AIV]], but also [[WP:RPP|RPP]], [[WP:AFD|AFD]], and [[WP:UAA|UAA]]). My edits started out small, such as linking pages, but I have grown, to create my own pages (I have created [http://toolserver.org/~soxred93/pages/index.php?name=Pepperpiggle&lang=en&wiki=wikipedia&namespace=0&redirects=noredirects 30 pages], and [http://toolserver.org/~soxred93/pages/index.php?name=Pepperpiggle&lang=en&wiki=wikipedia&namespace=0&redirects=onlyredirects&getall=1 105 redirects]), work against vandals, do some New Page and Random Page patrolling, and working in the admin areas mentioned above. With the admin tools, I would be able to delete pages, rather than having to request them for Speedy Deletion, and other such tasks, which would downsize the work of other admins. I will answer any additional questions you have when I have time. <sup |
{{User|Pepperpiggle}} – <s>Hello, I am Pepperpiggle, and I have been editing Wikipedia for just over 1 year (my [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Guinea_pig&action=historysubmit&diff=274269264&oldid=274088133#Domestic_habitat first edit] was on March 1, 2009), and took [a what I now know is called] a Wikibreak, and resumed editing on May 12th. I feel that I am ready to become an administrator because I have learned from my mistakes, and have experience in quite a few of the Admin areas, (mainly [[WP:AIV|AIV]], but also [[WP:RPP|RPP]], [[WP:AFD|AFD]], and [[WP:UAA|UAA]]). My edits started out small, such as linking pages, but I have grown, to create my own pages (I have created [http://toolserver.org/~soxred93/pages/index.php?name=Pepperpiggle&lang=en&wiki=wikipedia&namespace=0&redirects=noredirects 30 pages], and [http://toolserver.org/~soxred93/pages/index.php?name=Pepperpiggle&lang=en&wiki=wikipedia&namespace=0&redirects=onlyredirects&getall=1 105 redirects]), work against vandals, do some New Page and Random Page patrolling, and working in the admin areas mentioned above. With the admin tools, I would be able to delete pages, rather than having to request them for Speedy Deletion, and other such tasks, which would downsize the work of other admins. I will answer any additional questions you have when I have time. [[User:Pepperpiggle|<sup style="color:orange;">Pepper</sup>]]∙[[User talk:Pepperpiggle|<sub style="color:red;">piggle</sub>]] 14:29, 14 March 2010 (UTC)</s> |
||
'''I withdraw my nomination.''' [[User:Pepperpiggle|<sup style="color:orange;">Pepper</sup>]]∙[[User talk:Pepperpiggle|<sub style="color:red;">piggle</sub>]] 22:55, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
|||
====Questions for the candidate==== |
====Questions for the candidate==== |
||
Line 48: | Line 52: | ||
{{User:Neurolysis/Counters|Pepperpiggle}} |
{{User:Neurolysis/Counters|Pepperpiggle}} |
||
*Editing stats posted to the talk page. '''[[User:JamieS93|< |
*Editing stats posted to the talk page. '''[[User:JamieS93|<span style="color:#FF66CC;">Jamie</span>]][[User talk:JamieS93|<span style="color:#FF1493;">S93</span>]]'''<sup>❤</sup> 14:54, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
=====Support===== |
=====Support===== |
||
#'''Support''' - I really like the experience level of this candidate. He would do no harm with the mop. '''[[User:NSD|<span style="color:green">Nerdy</span><span style="color:#0F0">Science</span><span style="color:#8bd877">Dude :)</span>]]''' ([[User:NSD/t|✉ click to talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/NerdyScienceDude|my edits]] • [[User:NSD/Guestbook|sign]]) 14:50, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
#'''Support''' - I really like the experience level of this candidate. He would do no harm with the mop. '''[[User:NSD|<span style="color:green">Nerdy</span><span style="color:#0F0">Science</span><span style="color:#8bd877">Dude :)</span>]]''' ([[User:NSD/t|✉ click to talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/NerdyScienceDude|my edits]] • [[User:NSD/Guestbook|sign]]) 14:50, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#'''Support''' Net positive. Meets my "standards." And the CSD experience is fine. I don't think the CSD criteria are that forgettable. Creation experience is fine and of course he has a lot of automated edits- he reverts vandalism. Assuming he werereverting vandals the old fashioned way, and had 1500 non-automated reverts plus 1500 non automated builder edits, then he'd still meet my 3,000 edit threshold. 10 months experience is more than enough. [[User:Dlohcierekim|< |
#'''Support''' Net positive. Meets my "standards." And the CSD experience is fine. I don't think the CSD criteria are that forgettable. Creation experience is fine and of course he has a lot of automated edits- he reverts vandalism. Assuming he werereverting vandals the old fashioned way, and had 1500 non-automated reverts plus 1500 non automated builder edits, then he'd still meet my 3,000 edit threshold. 10 months experience is more than enough. [[User:Dlohcierekim|<span style="color:#00ff00;"> Dloh</span>]][[User_talk:Dlohcierekim|<span style="color:#bb00bb;">cierekim </span>]] 16:04, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#'''Support'''-I'm not one to judge a candidate on their ratio of semi-automated to non-automated edits like some of those below do. Seems to have good experience in admin areas and will make a fine admin overall.--'''''[[User:Skater|<span style="font-family:Chiller;color:#0B610B">SKATER</span>]]''''' [[User_talk:Skater|<sup><span style="font-family:Impact;color:Yellow">'''Speak.'''</span></sup>]] 18:21, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
#'''Support'''-I'm not one to judge a candidate on their ratio of semi-automated to non-automated edits like some of those below do. Seems to have good experience in admin areas and will make a fine admin overall.--'''''[[User:Skater|<span style="font-family:Chiller;color:#0B610B">SKATER</span>]]''''' [[User_talk:Skater|<sup><span style="font-family:Impact;color:Yellow">'''Speak.'''</span></sup>]] 18:21, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
<!-- Please do not submit comments before the RfA starts. Feel free to remove this notice once the RfA has been transcluded. --> |
<!-- Please do not submit comments before the RfA starts. Feel free to remove this notice once the RfA has been transcluded. --> |
||
Line 59: | Line 63: | ||
#Sadly, oppose because candidate does not have a great deal of experience in adminey areas and has only about 1.5k not automated edits. Sorry, insufficient experience for me. [[user:Pmlineditor|<span style="color: green;">'''Pmlineditor'''</span>]] [[user talk:Pmlineditor|<span style="color: #50C878; font-size: 22px;">'''∞'''</span>]] 15:05, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
#Sadly, oppose because candidate does not have a great deal of experience in adminey areas and has only about 1.5k not automated edits. Sorry, insufficient experience for me. [[user:Pmlineditor|<span style="color: green;">'''Pmlineditor'''</span>]] [[user talk:Pmlineditor|<span style="color: #50C878; font-size: 22px;">'''∞'''</span>]] 15:05, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#Awesome vandal fighter but not yet ready for the mop, I would suggest more experience in Admin related areas. ''<B>-- [[User:RP459|<span style="color:DarkBlue">RP459</span>]]</B>'' <sup>[[User talk:RP459|<span style="color:DarkGreen">Talk</span>]]</sup>/<sub>[[Special:Contributions/RP459|<span style="color:#660000">Contributions</span>]]</sub> 15:29, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
#Awesome vandal fighter but not yet ready for the mop, I would suggest more experience in Admin related areas. ''<B>-- [[User:RP459|<span style="color:DarkBlue">RP459</span>]]</B>'' <sup>[[User talk:RP459|<span style="color:DarkGreen">Talk</span>]]</sup>/<sub>[[Special:Contributions/RP459|<span style="color:#660000">Contributions</span>]]</sub> 15:29, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#'''[[User:Smithers7/RfA|Oppose]]''' - I don't like the deleted edit numbers. Sorry. < |
#'''[[User:Smithers7/RfA|Oppose]]''' - I don't like the deleted edit numbers. Sorry. <span style="font-family:Batik Regular;"><big>'''[[User:Smithers7|<span style="color:black;">smithers</span>]]''' - [[User talk:Smithers7|<span style="color:black;">talk</span>]]</big></span> 15:31, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#:If you're talking about his ~350 deleted contribs, nearly all of them were successful CSD tags. Of the remaining handful, none of them were pages he created, or otherwise problematic from what I saw. Best, '''[[User:JamieS93|< |
#:If you're talking about his ~350 deleted contribs, nearly all of them were successful CSD tags. Of the remaining handful, none of them were pages he created, or otherwise problematic from what I saw. Best, '''[[User:JamieS93|<span style="color:#FF66CC;">Jamie</span>]][[User talk:JamieS93|<span style="color:#FF1493;">S93</span>]]'''<sup>❤</sup> 15:39, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#::I should have gone a little further in the rationale, sorry. I also don't understand that gap between the one deletion in February and the several in December. There also hasn't been any deletions since February, to my understanding... Three months can make someone easily forget some of the weird criteria. < |
#::I should have gone a little further in the rationale, sorry. I also don't understand that gap between the one deletion in February and the several in December. There also hasn't been any deletions since February, to my understanding... Three months can make someone easily forget some of the weird criteria. <span style="font-family:Batik Regular;"><big>'''[[User:Smithers7|<span style="color:black;">smithers</span>]]''' - [[User talk:Smithers7|<span style="color:black;">talk</span>]]</big></span> 15:54, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#:::The candidate's [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:DeletedContributions/Pepperpiggle deleted contributions] (sorry, admins only) contain entries for ''each'' month since September 2009. There is no gap between December and February. <small><span style="padding:2px;border:1px solid #000000">[[User:Frank|<span style="color:cyan;background:blue"> Frank </span>]] {{!}} [[user_talk:Frank|<span style="color:blue;background:cyan"> talk </span>]]</span></small> 16:12, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
#:::The candidate's [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:DeletedContributions/Pepperpiggle deleted contributions] (sorry, admins only) contain entries for ''each'' month since September 2009. There is no gap between December and February. <small><span style="padding:2px;border:1px solid #000000">[[User:Frank|<span style="color:cyan;background:blue"> Frank </span>]] {{!}} [[user_talk:Frank|<span style="color:blue;background:cyan"> talk </span>]]</span></small> 16:12, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#::::There is no notifications to author then, and that isn't right on its own either. < |
#::::There is no notifications to author then, and that isn't right on its own either. <span style="font-family:Batik Regular;"><big>'''[[User:Smithers7|<span style="color:black;">smithers</span>]]''' - [[User talk:Smithers7|<span style="color:black;">talk</span>]]</big></span> 17:52, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#'''Oppose'''. Would like to see a bit more experience, in multiple capacities. -- '''[[User:Cirt|Cirt]]''' ([[User talk:Cirt|talk]]) 16:13, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
#'''Oppose'''. Would like to see a bit more experience, in multiple capacities. -- '''[[User:Cirt|Cirt]]''' ([[User talk:Cirt|talk]]) 16:13, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#'''Oppose''': solid editor, but I'd like to see some more experience in many areas. With [http://toolserver.org/~soxred93/autoedits/index.php?name=pepperpiggle 60% automated edits], this makes the non-auto edit count low, at around 1700. Maybe with a few more months of experience (I'm not concerned about percentage of automated edits, just the number of non-auto edits and therefore experience) I'll be motivated to support. Regards, [[User:Airplaneman|<span style="font-family:Arial;color:blue;size=2">Airplaneman</span>]] ''<sup>[[User talk:Airplaneman|<span style="font-family:Times New Roman;color:#33dd44">talk</span>]]</sup>'' 16:58, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
#'''Oppose''': solid editor, but I'd like to see some more experience in many areas. With [http://toolserver.org/~soxred93/autoedits/index.php?name=pepperpiggle 60% automated edits], this makes the non-auto edit count low, at around 1700. Maybe with a few more months of experience (I'm not concerned about percentage of automated edits, just the number of non-auto edits and therefore experience) I'll be motivated to support. Regards, [[User:Airplaneman|<span style="font-family:Arial;color:blue;size=2">Airplaneman</span>]] ''<sup>[[User talk:Airplaneman|<span style="font-family:Times New Roman;color:#33dd44">talk</span>]]</sup>'' 16:58, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#'''Oppose'''. Per above. Concerns with judgement, experience, breadth of exposure, policy knowledge, and high proportion of automated to non-automated edits. -'''[[User:Fastily|<span style= |
#'''Oppose'''. Per above. Concerns with judgement, experience, breadth of exposure, policy knowledge, and high proportion of automated to non-automated edits. -<span style="font-family:Trebuchet MS;">'''[[User:Fastily|<span style="color:#4B0082;"><big>F</big><small>ASTILY<sub>sock</sub></small></span>]]'''<sup><small>[[User talk:Fastily|<span style="color:#4B0082;">(T<small>ALK</small>)</span>]]</small></sup></span> 17:20, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#'''Oppose''': It looks like your edits in the mainspace and talkpages are primarily related to reverting. Autoedit count is high. Unsure on knowledge of policy & lack of evidence to support this user. (See [[User:MWOAP/RfA voting]]) -- < |
#'''Oppose''': It looks like your edits in the mainspace and talkpages are primarily related to reverting. Autoedit count is high. Unsure on knowledge of policy & lack of evidence to support this user. (See [[User:MWOAP/RfA voting]]) -- <span style="color:green;">/[[User:MWOAP|<span style="color:green;">MWOAP</span>]]|</span><span style="color:blue;">[[User_Talk:MWOAP|<span style="color:blue;">Notify Me</span>]]\</span> 20:28, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#'''Oppose'''. Not because of any weakness in anything the candidate has done; vandal-fighting and page patrolling are essential contributions to the project. But I do feel that an administrator needs a wider range of experience to get a full understanding of the project and its policies. That experience would, for example, include some (but not all) of XfD, DRV and content work. I'd suggest coming back in a few months with a broader range of experience. --[[User:Mkativerata|Mkativerata]] ([[User talk:Mkativerata|talk]]) 22:16, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
#'''Oppose'''. Not because of any weakness in anything the candidate has done; vandal-fighting and page patrolling are essential contributions to the project. But I do feel that an administrator needs a wider range of experience to get a full understanding of the project and its policies. That experience would, for example, include some (but not all) of XfD, DRV and content work. I'd suggest coming back in a few months with a broader range of experience. --[[User:Mkativerata|Mkativerata]] ([[User talk:Mkativerata|talk]]) 22:16, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#'''Oppose''' - per experience in admin-related areas and lots of automated contributions. [[User:December21st2012Freak|< |
#'''Oppose''' - per experience in admin-related areas and lots of automated contributions. [[User:December21st2012Freak|<span style="color:#922724;">'''December21st2012Freak'''</span>]] <sup>[[user talk:December21st2012Freak|<span style="color:#008080;">''Talk to me''</span>]]</sup> at 22:39, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
=====Neutral===== |
=====Neutral===== |
||
#OK on the cooling aspect, User not being admin coached makes me wonder why I shouldn't support, yet the experience on Wikipedia is long enough to be worth the wait so that I can't really oppose on this vote either. Neutral as it stands for me. [[User:Minimac|< |
#OK on the cooling aspect, User not being admin coached makes me wonder why I shouldn't support, yet the experience on Wikipedia is long enough to be worth the wait so that I can't really oppose on this vote either. Neutral as it stands for me. [[User:Minimac|<span style="color:#002BB8;">Minima</span>]][[Special:Contributions/Minimac|<span style="color:#002BB8;">c</span>]] ([[User talk:Minimac|<span style="color:#002BB8;">talk</span>]]) 15:24, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#'''Comment'''The two show case articles with the most edits of Pepperpiggle [[Seth Low Pierrepont State Park Reserve|1]] and [[Titicus River|2]]need both wikfy-ing and the references and links are both not up to the standard, this makes me feel that the experinece in the mainspace is not enough.--[[User:Stone|Stone]] ([[User talk:Stone|talk]]) 20:51, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
#'''Comment'''The two show case articles with the most edits of Pepperpiggle [[Seth Low Pierrepont State Park Reserve|1]] and [[Titicus River|2]]need both wikfy-ing and the references and links are both not up to the standard, this makes me feel that the experinece in the mainspace is not enough.--[[User:Stone|Stone]] ([[User talk:Stone|talk]]) 20:51, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
||
#Just concerned about breadth of experience. They're a dedicated vandal fighter, which I truly appreciate, but that alone isn't enough to make me support, and I'm not seeing much else to go on. I would like to see either more admin-related work or more (non-reverting) article work. Neutral for now; I want to lean ''support'', but I haven't seen any convincing reason to do so. [[User:Swarm|<span style='color:black'><b><u><i><big>S</big>warm</i></u></b></span>]]<sup>([[User talk:Swarm|<span style="color:green;">'''Talk'''</span>]])</sup> 21:54, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |
#Just concerned about breadth of experience. They're a dedicated vandal fighter, which I truly appreciate, but that alone isn't enough to make me support, and I'm not seeing much else to go on. I would like to see either more admin-related work or more (non-reverting) article work. Neutral for now; I want to lean ''support'', but I haven't seen any convincing reason to do so. [[User:Swarm|<span style='color:black'><b><u><i><big>S</big>warm</i></u></b></span>]]<sup>([[User talk:Swarm|<span style="color:green;">'''Talk'''</span>]])</sup> 21:54, 14 March 2010 (UTC) |