Poema Morale: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
expansion |
HeyElliott (talk | contribs) |
||
| (39 intermediate revisions by 16 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Use dmy dates|date=April 2022}} |
|||
The ''' |
The '''{{Lang|enm|Poema Morale}}''' ("Conduct of life"<ref name=conti>{{cite journal|last=Conti|first=Aidan|year=2006|title=The Gem-Bearing Serpents of the Trinity Homilies: An Analogue for Gower's Confessio Amantis|journal=[[Modern Philology]]|volume=106|issue=1|pages=109–16|doi=10.1086/597251 |jstor=10.1086/597251|hdl=1956/6586 |s2cid=161613808 |hdl-access=free}}</ref> or "Moral Ode"<ref name=Sciacca/>) is an early [[Middle English]] moral poem outlining proper Christian conduct. The poem was popular enough to have survived in seven manuscripts, including the homiletic collections known as the [[Lambeth Homilies]] and [[Trinity Homilies]],<ref name=treharne>{{cite web|url=http://www.le.ac.uk/english/em1060to1220/mss/EM.CTC.B.14.52.htm|title=Cambridge, Trinity College, B. 14. 52|last=Treharne|first=Elaine|date=June 2012|work=The Production and Use of English Manuscripts 1060 to 1220|accessdate=5 September 2012}}</ref> both dating from around 1200. |
||
==Content and form== |
==Content and form== |
||
The narrator, a wise, old man, reflects on his life and his many failures; the homily ends with a description of the [[Last Judgment]] and the joys of heaven.<ref name=holtei/> Both personal sin and collective guilt (scholars have compared the narrator's stance to that of the [[Peterborough Chronicle]]r) are of concern.<ref name=Dunn/> |
|||
| ⚫ | The poem is sometimes referred to as a sermon,<ref name= |
||
| ⚫ | The poem is sometimes referred to as a sermon,<ref name=Harsch>{{cite web|url=http://www2.hs-augsburg.de/~harsch/anglica/Chronology/12thC/PoemaMorale/poe_intr.html|title=Poema Morale, ca. 1170|last=Harsch|first=Ulrich|work=Bibliotheca Augustana|publisher=Fachhochschule Augsburg|accessdate=5 September 2012}}</ref> sometimes as a homiletic narrative.<ref name=holtei>{{cite web|url=http://user.phil-fak.uni-duesseldorf.de/~holteir/companion/Navigation/Anonymous_Texts/Poema_Morale/poema_morale.html|title=Poema Morale|editor-last=Holtei|editor-first=Rainer |year=2002|work=A Companion to ME Literature|publisher=Heinrich-Heine-University, Düsseldorf|accessdate=5 September 2012}}</ref> It contains, in its longest version, 200 rhymed couplets.<ref name=Harsch/> |
||
The lengths of the different versions of the poem vary greatly: the shortest is 270, the longest 400 lines; different manuscript versions also differ in wording. The Lambeth version is considered the oldest.<ref name=Dunn>{{cite book|last=Dunn|first=Charles W.|title=Middle English Literature|url=https://archive.org/details/middleenglishlit00dunn|url-access=registration|accessdate=5 September 2012|year=1990|publisher=Garland|isbn=9780824052973|pages=[https://archive.org/details/middleenglishlit00dunn/page/46 46]–48}}</ref> In fact, there is so much "metrical, lexical and scribal variation" that it seems there is no "correct" version: "each copy represents a reshaping within an established rhythmical and metrical structure."<ref name=Sciacca>{{cite book|last=Sciacca|first=Claudia di|editor=Merja Stenroos|others=Martti Mäkinen, Inge Srheim|title=Language Contact and Development Around the North Sea|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=k0mAoV-K52MC&pg=PA181|accessdate=6 September 2012|year=2012|publisher=John Benjamins |isbn=9789027248398|pages=169–86|chapter=For Heaven's Sake: The Scandinavian contribution to a semantic field in Old and Middle English}}</ref> |
|||
Though a seventeenth-century identification between the ''Poema'' and ''[[The Proverbs of Alfred]]'' by [[Gerard Langbaine the elder|Langbaine]] was proven erroneous (Langbaine was led astray because he had an expectation of finding the Alfredian proverbs in the manuscript known as [[Bodleian Library]] Digby 4). There are, however, connections between the ''Poema'' and the Proverbs: a couplet of the ''Poema'' was written (in the same hand as the main text) in the margin of a manuscript containing the Proverbs ([[Maidstone Museum & Art Gallery|Maidstone Museum]] A.13).<ref name=Proverbs/> On that same page are marginal notes listing and glossing Middle English characters and their names, a list also found in McClean 123, which preserves a full version of the ''Poema''; whether this is a gloss for the scribe or the reader is not clear.<ref>{{cite journal|last=Brown|first=Carleton|year=1926|title=The Maidstone Text of the ''Proverbs of Alfred''|journal=[[Modern Language Review]]|volume=21|issue=3|pages=249–60|jstor=3714778|doi=10.2307/3714778}}</ref> |
|||
At least one echo of the ''Poema'' was noted in the ''[[Ancrene Wisse]]''.<ref name=Proverbs>{{cite book|title=The Proverbs of Alfred|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=ZS0xLDwXETQC&pg=PA10|year=1931|publisher=Haskell|location=New York|pages=10, 63}}</ref> The twelfth-century ''[[Ormulum]]'' has the same meter as the ''Poema'', but, in the estimation of at least one critic, the ''Ormulum'' lacks the occasional vigor and "personal feeling" found in the ''Poema''.<ref>{{cite book|last=Daiches|first=David|title=A Critical History of English Literature: from the beginnings to the sixteenth century|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=Vw3pHYZuF68C&pg=PA42|accessdate=6 September 2012|year=1979|publisher=Allied Publishers|isbn=9788170230465|page=42}}</ref> |
|||
===Meter=== |
|||
Following a Latin model, the ''Poema'' employs a [[Heptameter|septenary line]],<ref>{{cite book|last1=Myers|first1=Jack|last2=Wukasch|first2=Don C.|title=Dictionary of Poetic Terms|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=wUTP0ZP7yy8C&pg=PA329|accessdate=6 September 2012|year=2003|publisher=U of North Texas P|isbn=9781574411669|page=329}}</ref> "a seven-foot line usually in trochaic rhythm"; according to [[R. D. Fulk]] and others this is possibly the first example of that line in English.<ref name="Fulk2002">{{cite journal|last=Fulk|first=Robert D.|year=2002|title=Early Middle English Evidence for Old English Meter: Resolution in Poema morale|journal=[[Journal of Germanic Linguistics]]|volume=14|issue=4|issn=1470-5427|doi=10.1017/S147054270200017X|s2cid=170857828 }}</ref> According to Joseph Malof, this Latin-derived meter in subsequent instances is transformed into the looser seven-stress line (proving the dominance in English of stress over syllable) that became the English [[common metre]], the standard line used in ballads.<ref>{{cite journal|last=Malof|first=Joseph|year=1964|title=The Native Rhythm of English Meters|journal=[[Texas Studies in Literature and Language]]|volume=5|issue=4|pages=580–94|jstor=40753790}}</ref> |
|||
==Manuscripts== |
|||
Seven manuscripts contain the poem,<ref name=Sciacca/><ref name=Laing>{{cite book|last=Laing|first=Margaret|editor=Irma Taavitsainen|title=Placing Middle English in Context|chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=SIzqSvfvwp0C&pg=PA119|accessdate=6 September 2012|year=2000|publisher=Walter de Gruyter|isbn=9783110167801|pages=97–124|chapter='Never the twain shall meet': Early Middle English--the East-West divide}}</ref> six of which were used in the compilation of the [[Middle English Dictionary]].<ref>{{cite web|url=http://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/m/mec/hyp-idx?type=byte&size=First+100&byte=3764883&ms=%3CMS%20REF%3D%22Oxford%2C%20Bodleian%20Library%2C%20Digby%22%3E%3CCITE%3E4%3C%2FCITE%3E%3C%2FMS%3E|title=Entry for "Poema Morale" in Middle English Compendium HyperBibliography|work=[[Middle English Dictionary]]|publisher=[[University of Michigan]]|accessdate=6 September 2012}}</ref> |
|||
*Cambridge, Fitzwilliam Museum, McClean 123 (M) |
|||
*Cambridge, Trinity College B.14.52 (335) (T) |
|||
*London, British Library, Egerton 613 |
|||
**contains two versions: fols. 7r-12v (E), fols. 64r-70v (e) |
|||
*London, Lambeth Palace Library 487 (L) |
|||
*Oxford, Bodleian Library, Digby 4 (D) |
|||
*Oxford, Jesus College 29, Part 2 (J) |
|||
In addition, snippets are found in three other manuscripts.<ref name=Sciacca/> |
|||
==Editions== |
|||
The first modern critical study and edition (which used six manuscripts) was Hermann Lewin's 1881 ''Das mittelenglische Poema morale''.<ref name=Lewin>{{cite book|last=Lewin|first=Hermann|title=Das mittelenglische Poema morale: Im kritischen Text, nach den sechs vorhandenen Handschriften zum ersten Male hrsg. von hermann Lewin|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=eMUUJsOeMnEC|accessdate=5 September 2012|year=1881|publisher=M. Niemeyer}}</ref> Lewin did not yet have the version from Cambridge, [[Fitzwilliam Museum]] MS McClean 123, a manuscript given to the museum in 1904; the version of the {{Lang|enm|Poema Morale}} in it was not described until 1907.<ref name="Paues1907">{{cite journal|last=Paues|first=Anna C.|year=1907|title=A Newly Discovered Manuscript of the ''Poema Morale''|journal=[[Anglia (journal)|Anglia: Zeitschrift für englische Philologie]]|volume=1907|issue=30|pages=217–237|issn=0340-5222|doi=10.1515/angl.1907.1907.30.217|s2cid=161593276 |url=https://zenodo.org/record/1448746}}</ref> |
|||
==References== |
==References== |
||
| Line 10: | Line 37: | ||
*[http://www2.hs-augsburg.de/~harsch/anglica/Chronology/12thC/PoemaMorale/poe_poem.html Online text] from Lambeth MS 487 |
*[http://www2.hs-augsburg.de/~harsch/anglica/Chronology/12thC/PoemaMorale/poe_poem.html Online text] from Lambeth MS 487 |
||
{{Middle English devotional literature}} |
|||
{{DEFAULTSORT:Poema Morale}} |
|||
[[Category:Homiletics]] |
|||
[[Category:Middle English poems]] |
|||
[[Category:Christian sermons]] |
|||
[[Category:Christian poetry]] |
|||
Latest revision as of 00:12, 3 May 2023
The Poema Morale ("Conduct of life"[1] or "Moral Ode"[2]) is an early Middle English moral poem outlining proper Christian conduct. The poem was popular enough to have survived in seven manuscripts, including the homiletic collections known as the Lambeth Homilies and Trinity Homilies,[3] both dating from around 1200.
Content and form
[edit]The narrator, a wise, old man, reflects on his life and his many failures; the homily ends with a description of the Last Judgment and the joys of heaven.[4] Both personal sin and collective guilt (scholars have compared the narrator's stance to that of the Peterborough Chronicler) are of concern.[5]
The poem is sometimes referred to as a sermon,[6] sometimes as a homiletic narrative.[4] It contains, in its longest version, 200 rhymed couplets.[6]
The lengths of the different versions of the poem vary greatly: the shortest is 270, the longest 400 lines; different manuscript versions also differ in wording. The Lambeth version is considered the oldest.[5] In fact, there is so much "metrical, lexical and scribal variation" that it seems there is no "correct" version: "each copy represents a reshaping within an established rhythmical and metrical structure."[2]
Though a seventeenth-century identification between the Poema and The Proverbs of Alfred by Langbaine was proven erroneous (Langbaine was led astray because he had an expectation of finding the Alfredian proverbs in the manuscript known as Bodleian Library Digby 4). There are, however, connections between the Poema and the Proverbs: a couplet of the Poema was written (in the same hand as the main text) in the margin of a manuscript containing the Proverbs (Maidstone Museum A.13).[7] On that same page are marginal notes listing and glossing Middle English characters and their names, a list also found in McClean 123, which preserves a full version of the Poema; whether this is a gloss for the scribe or the reader is not clear.[8]
At least one echo of the Poema was noted in the Ancrene Wisse.[7] The twelfth-century Ormulum has the same meter as the Poema, but, in the estimation of at least one critic, the Ormulum lacks the occasional vigor and "personal feeling" found in the Poema.[9]
Meter
[edit]Following a Latin model, the Poema employs a septenary line,[10] "a seven-foot line usually in trochaic rhythm"; according to R. D. Fulk and others this is possibly the first example of that line in English.[11] According to Joseph Malof, this Latin-derived meter in subsequent instances is transformed into the looser seven-stress line (proving the dominance in English of stress over syllable) that became the English common metre, the standard line used in ballads.[12]
Manuscripts
[edit]Seven manuscripts contain the poem,[2][13] six of which were used in the compilation of the Middle English Dictionary.[14]
- Cambridge, Fitzwilliam Museum, McClean 123 (M)
- Cambridge, Trinity College B.14.52 (335) (T)
- London, British Library, Egerton 613
- contains two versions: fols. 7r-12v (E), fols. 64r-70v (e)
- London, Lambeth Palace Library 487 (L)
- Oxford, Bodleian Library, Digby 4 (D)
- Oxford, Jesus College 29, Part 2 (J)
In addition, snippets are found in three other manuscripts.[2]
Editions
[edit]The first modern critical study and edition (which used six manuscripts) was Hermann Lewin's 1881 Das mittelenglische Poema morale.[15] Lewin did not yet have the version from Cambridge, Fitzwilliam Museum MS McClean 123, a manuscript given to the museum in 1904; the version of the Poema Morale in it was not described until 1907.[16]
References
[edit]- ^ Conti, Aidan (2006). "The Gem-Bearing Serpents of the Trinity Homilies: An Analogue for Gower's Confessio Amantis". Modern Philology. 106 (1): 109–16. doi:10.1086/597251. hdl:1956/6586. JSTOR 10.1086/597251. S2CID 161613808.
- ^ a b c d Sciacca, Claudia di (2012). "For Heaven's Sake: The Scandinavian contribution to a semantic field in Old and Middle English". In Merja Stenroos (ed.). Language Contact and Development Around the North Sea. Martti Mäkinen, Inge Srheim. John Benjamins. pp. 169–86. ISBN 9789027248398. Retrieved 6 September 2012.
- ^ Treharne, Elaine (June 2012). "Cambridge, Trinity College, B. 14. 52". The Production and Use of English Manuscripts 1060 to 1220. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
- ^ a b Holtei, Rainer, ed. (2002). "Poema Morale". A Companion to ME Literature. Heinrich-Heine-University, Düsseldorf. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
- ^ a b Dunn, Charles W. (1990). Middle English Literature. Garland. pp. 46–48. ISBN 9780824052973. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
- ^ a b Harsch, Ulrich. "Poema Morale, ca. 1170". Bibliotheca Augustana. Fachhochschule Augsburg. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
- ^ a b The Proverbs of Alfred. New York: Haskell. 1931. pp. 10, 63.
- ^ Brown, Carleton (1926). "The Maidstone Text of the Proverbs of Alfred". Modern Language Review. 21 (3): 249–60. doi:10.2307/3714778. JSTOR 3714778.
- ^ Daiches, David (1979). A Critical History of English Literature: from the beginnings to the sixteenth century. Allied Publishers. p. 42. ISBN 9788170230465. Retrieved 6 September 2012.
- ^ Myers, Jack; Wukasch, Don C. (2003). Dictionary of Poetic Terms. U of North Texas P. p. 329. ISBN 9781574411669. Retrieved 6 September 2012.
- ^ Fulk, Robert D. (2002). "Early Middle English Evidence for Old English Meter: Resolution in Poema morale". Journal of Germanic Linguistics. 14 (4). doi:10.1017/S147054270200017X. ISSN 1470-5427. S2CID 170857828.
- ^ Malof, Joseph (1964). "The Native Rhythm of English Meters". Texas Studies in Literature and Language. 5 (4): 580–94. JSTOR 40753790.
- ^ Laing, Margaret (2000). "'Never the twain shall meet': Early Middle English--the East-West divide". In Irma Taavitsainen (ed.). Placing Middle English in Context. Walter de Gruyter. pp. 97–124. ISBN 9783110167801. Retrieved 6 September 2012.
- ^ "Entry for "Poema Morale" in Middle English Compendium HyperBibliography". Middle English Dictionary. University of Michigan. Retrieved 6 September 2012.
- ^ Lewin, Hermann (1881). Das mittelenglische Poema morale: Im kritischen Text, nach den sechs vorhandenen Handschriften zum ersten Male hrsg. von hermann Lewin. M. Niemeyer. Retrieved 5 September 2012.
- ^ Paues, Anna C. (1907). "A Newly Discovered Manuscript of the Poema Morale". Anglia: Zeitschrift für englische Philologie. 1907 (30): 217–237. doi:10.1515/angl.1907.1907.30.217. ISSN 0340-5222. S2CID 161593276.
External links
[edit]- Online text from Lambeth MS 487