Jump to content

René Sudre: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous edit
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
adding photo
 
(12 intermediate revisions by 12 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Use mdy dates|date=December 2019}}
{{Short description|French parapsychologist}}
{{Infobox person
{{Infobox person
| name = René Sudre
| name = René Sudre
| image = René Sudre parapsychologist.png
| image = René Sudre parapsychologist.png
|birth_date = April 19, 1880
| birth_date = April 19, 1880
|birth_place = [[Angoulême]]
| birth_place = [[Angoulême]]
|death_date = 1968
| death_date = 1968
| occupation = [[Journalist]], [[Parapsychology|parapsychologist]]}}
| occupation = Journalist, [[Parapsychology|parapsychologist]], writer}}


'''René Sudre''' (April 19, 1880 - 1968) was a French [[journalist]], [[Parapsychology|parapsychologist]] and writer.
'''René Sudre''' (April 19, 1880 – 1968) was a French journalist, [[Parapsychology|parapsychologist]] and writer.


==Biography==
==Biography==


Sudre was born in [[Angoulême]]. He studied philosophy and science at the [[University of Poitiers]] and the [[University of Paris-Sorbonne]]. He worked as a commenter for [[Radiodiffusion Française]] (1926-1940) and contributed articles to the newspaper ''[[Journal des débats]]'' (1935-1940) and ''[[Revue des Deux Mondes]]''. He was Professor at [[School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences|L'Ecole des hautes Etudes Sociales]] (1931-1940).<ref>[http://www.encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/sudre-rene-1880 "René Sudre"]. Encyclopedia of Occultism and Parapsychology. Retrieved 14 August 2017.</ref>
Sudre was born in [[Angoulême]]. He studied philosophy and science at the [[University of Poitiers]] and the [[University of Paris-Sorbonne]]. He worked as a commenter for [[Radiodiffusion Française]] (1926–1940) and contributed articles to the newspaper ''[[Journal des débats]]'' (1935–1940) and ''[[Revue des Deux Mondes]]''. He was Professor at [[School for Advanced Studies in the Social Sciences|L'Ecole des hautes Etudes Sociales]] (1931–1940).<ref>[http://www.encyclopedia.com/science/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/sudre-rene-1880 "René Sudre"]. Encyclopedia of Occultism and Parapsychology. Retrieved August 14, 2017.</ref>


During 1921-1926 he worked at the [[Institut Métapsychique International]] (IMI). Sudre came into dispute with the spiritualist orientation of the IMI as his books were critical of the spiritualist hypothesis of mediumship. In 1926, he was dismissed from the IMI by director [[Eugéne Osty]].<ref>Lachapelle, Sofie. (2005). ''Attempting Science: The Creation and Early Development of the Institut Métapsychique International in Paris, 1919-1931''. ''[[Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences]]'' 41: 1–24.</ref> Sudre was "strongly anti-spiritualistic".<ref>Ashby, Robert H. (1972). ''The Guidebook for the Study of Psychical Research''. Rider. p. 66</ref> [[Ernesto Bozzano]] attempted to refute Sudre's arguments.<ref>[[Ernesto Bozzano|Bozzano, Ernesto]]. (1926). ''A Propos de l’introduction à la Métapsychique Humaine: Réfutation du livre de René Sudre''. Paris: Jean Meyer.</ref>
During 1921–1926 he worked at the [[Institut Métapsychique International]] (IMI). Sudre came into dispute with the spiritualist orientation of the IMI as his books were critical of the spiritualist hypothesis of mediumship. In 1926, he was dismissed from the IMI by director [[Eugéne Osty]].<ref>Lachapelle, Sofie. (2005). ''Attempting Science: The Creation and Early Development of the Institut Métapsychique International in Paris, 1919–1931''. ''[[Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences]]'' 41: 1–24.</ref> Sudre was "strongly anti-spiritualistic".<ref>Ashby, Robert H. (1972). ''The Guidebook for the Study of Psychical Research''. Rider. p. 66</ref> [[Ernesto Bozzano]] attempted to refute Sudre's arguments.<ref>[[Ernesto Bozzano|Bozzano, Ernesto]]. (1926). ''A Propos de l’introduction à la Métapsychique Humaine: Réfutation du livre de René Sudre''. Paris: Jean Meyer.</ref>


His book ''Introduction à la Métapsychique Humaine'' (1926) attacked the spiritualist hypothesis and defended an [[Animism|animist]] position of creative forces similar to [[Henri Bergson]].<ref>Asprem, Egil. (2014). ''The Problem of Disenchantment: Scientific Naturalism and Esoteric Discourse, 1900-1939''. Brill Academic Publishers. p. 347. {{ISBN|978-90-04-25192-2}}</ref> Sudre was a loyal friend of [[Harry Price]]. Price described him as "the leading psychist in France."<ref>[[Harry Price|Price, Harry]]. (1942). ''Search for Truth: My Life for Psychical Research''. Collins. p. 121</ref> He was a member of the [[National Laboratory of Psychical Research]].<ref>Valentine, Elizabeth R. ''Institutionalisation and the History of Psychical Research in Great Britain in the 20th Century''. In Anna Lux, Sylvia Paletschek. (2016). ''Okkultismus im Gehäuse: Institutionalisierungen der Parapsychologie im 20. Jahrhundert im internationalen Vergleich''. De Gruyter Oldenbourg. p. 140. {{ISBN|978-3-11-046376-7}}</ref> He was also a member of the [[Society for Psychical Research]] and contributed articles to the ''Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research''. He wrote book reviews for the ''Revue Métapsychique'' (1921-1926). Sudre interpreted mental and physical phenomena of mediums as evidence for [[clairvoyance]] and [[psychic]] forces.<ref name="Dingwall 1960">[[Eric Dingwall|Dingwall, Eric]]. (1960). [http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v188/n4746/pdf/188177a0.pdf ''The Paranormal: A French View'']. ''[[Nature (journal)|Nature]]'' 188: 177.</ref>
His book ''Introduction à la Métapsychique Humaine'' (1926) attacked the spiritualist hypothesis and defended an [[Animism|animist]] position of creative forces similar to [[Henri Bergson]].<ref>Asprem, Egil. (2014). ''The Problem of Disenchantment: Scientific Naturalism and Esoteric Discourse, 1900–1939''. Brill Academic Publishers. p. 347. {{ISBN|978-90-04-25192-2}}</ref> Sudre was a loyal friend of [[Harry Price]]. Price described him as "the leading psychist in France."<ref>[[Harry Price|Price, Harry]]. (1942). ''Search for Truth: My Life for Psychical Research''. Collins. p. 121</ref> He was a member of the [[National Laboratory of Psychical Research]].<ref>Valentine, Elizabeth R. ''Institutionalisation and the History of Psychical Research in Great Britain in the 20th Century''. In Anna Lux, Sylvia Paletschek. (2016). ''Okkultismus im Gehäuse: Institutionalisierungen der Parapsychologie im 20. Jahrhundert im internationalen Vergleich''. De Gruyter Oldenbourg. p. 140. {{ISBN|978-3-11-046376-7}}</ref> He was also a member of the [[Society for Psychical Research]] and contributed articles to the ''Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research''. He wrote book reviews for the ''Revue Métapsychique'' (1921–1926). Sudre interpreted mental and physical phenomena of mediums as evidence for [[clairvoyance]] and [[psychic]] forces.<ref name="Dingwall 1960">[[Eric Dingwall|Dingwall, Eric]]. (1960). [http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v188/n4746/pdf/188177a0.pdf ''The Paranormal: A French View'']. ''[[Nature (journal)|Nature]]'' 188: 177.</ref>


==Reception==
==Reception==


Professor John Cohen in the ''[[New Scientist]]'' for a review of ''Treatise on Parapsychology'' (1960) disputed Sudre's belief that clairvoyance had been established by science but praised the book for "demolishing" the spiritualist hypothesis of mediumship. Cohen noted that the book "ranks among the very best of its kind that have appeared on either side of the Atlantic".<ref>Cohen, John. (1960). [https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=OlJ07-6VkuwC&pg=PA306&dq=%22treatise+on+parapsychology%22&hl=en&sa=X&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=%22treatise%20on%20parapsychology%22&f=false ''Treatise on Parapsychology'']. ''[[New Scientist]]''. 28 July. pp. 306-307. Retrieved 14 August 2017.</ref>
Professor John Cohen in the ''[[New Scientist]]'' for a review of ''Treatise on Parapsychology'' (1960) disputed Sudre's belief that clairvoyance had been established by science but praised the book for "demolishing" the spiritualist hypothesis of mediumship. Cohen noted that the book "ranks among the very best of its kind that have appeared on either side of the Atlantic".<ref>Cohen, John. (1960). [https://books.google.com/books?id=OlJ07-6VkuwC&dq=%22treatise+on+parapsychology%22&pg=PA306 ''Treatise on Parapsychology'']. ''[[New Scientist]]''. July 28. pp. 306–307. Retrieved August 14, 2017.</ref>


Criticism of ''Treatise on Parapsychology'' came from [[Eric Dingwall]]. In a review for ''[[Nature (journal)|Nature]]'' he noted that Sudre was credulous in accepting [[Materialization (paranormal)|materializations]] and psychic photographs as genuine. Sudre failed to cite the evidence of fraud in mediumship, he was also criticized for defending phenomena at [[Borley Rectory]] as 'incontestably genuine' and ignoring evidence to the contrary.<ref name="Dingwall 1960"/>
Criticism of ''Treatise on Parapsychology'' came from [[Eric Dingwall]]. In a review for ''[[Nature (journal)|Nature]]'' he noted that Sudre was credulous in accepting [[Materialization (paranormal)|materializations]] and psychic photographs as genuine. Sudre failed to cite the evidence of fraud in mediumship, he was also criticized for defending phenomena at [[Borley Rectory]] as 'incontestably genuine' and ignoring evidence to the contrary.<ref name="Dingwall 1960"/>
Line 28: Line 30:
*''Le Huitième Art: Mission de la Radio'' (1945)
*''Le Huitième Art: Mission de la Radio'' (1945)
*''Personnages d’au-delà'' (1946)
*''Personnages d’au-delà'' (1946)
*''Les Nouvelles Énigmes de l’univers'' (1951)
*''Traité de Parapsychologie'' [Translated by [[Celia Green]] as ''Treatise on Parapsychology''] (1956, 1960)
*''Traité de Parapsychologie'' [Translated by [[Celia Green]] as ''Treatise on Parapsychology''] (1956, 1960)
*''Parapsychology'' (1962)
*''Parapsychology'' (1962)
Line 36: Line 39:
==Further reading==
==Further reading==


*Renaud Evrard. (2009). ''René Sudre (1880-1968): The Metapsychist's Quill''. Journal of the Society for Psychical Research 73: 207-222.
*Renaud Evrard. (2009). ''René Sudre (1880–1968): The Metapsychist's Quill''. Journal of the Society for Psychical Research 73: 207–222.
*[[William Henry Salter]]. (1958). ''Review of Traité de Parapsychologie''. Journal of the Society for Psychical Research 39: 87-88.
*[[William Henry Salter]]. (1958). ''Review of Traité de Parapsychologie''. Journal of the Society for Psychical Research 39: 87–88.


{{Authority control}}
{{Parapsychology|state=collapsed}}


{{DEFAULTSORT:Sudre, Rene}}
[[Category:1880 births]]
[[Category:1880 births]]
[[Category:1968 deaths]]
[[Category:1968 deaths]]
[[Category:French journalists]]
[[Category:French parapsychologists]]
[[Category:Parapsychologists]]
[[Category:Paris-Sorbonne University alumni]]
[[Category:Paris-Sorbonne University alumni]]
[[Category:People from Angoulême]]
[[Category:People from Angoulême]]
[[Category:University of Poitiers alumni]]
[[Category:University of Poitiers alumni]]
[[Category:20th-century French journalists]]

Latest revision as of 02:13, 1 June 2023

René Sudre
BornApril 19, 1880
Angoulême
Died1968
Occupation(s)Journalist, parapsychologist, writer

René Sudre (April 19, 1880 – 1968) was a French journalist, parapsychologist and writer.

Biography

[edit]

Sudre was born in Angoulême. He studied philosophy and science at the University of Poitiers and the University of Paris-Sorbonne. He worked as a commenter for Radiodiffusion Française (1926–1940) and contributed articles to the newspaper Journal des débats (1935–1940) and Revue des Deux Mondes. He was Professor at L'Ecole des hautes Etudes Sociales (1931–1940).[1]

During 1921–1926 he worked at the Institut Métapsychique International (IMI). Sudre came into dispute with the spiritualist orientation of the IMI as his books were critical of the spiritualist hypothesis of mediumship. In 1926, he was dismissed from the IMI by director Eugéne Osty.[2] Sudre was "strongly anti-spiritualistic".[3] Ernesto Bozzano attempted to refute Sudre's arguments.[4]

His book Introduction à la Métapsychique Humaine (1926) attacked the spiritualist hypothesis and defended an animist position of creative forces similar to Henri Bergson.[5] Sudre was a loyal friend of Harry Price. Price described him as "the leading psychist in France."[6] He was a member of the National Laboratory of Psychical Research.[7] He was also a member of the Society for Psychical Research and contributed articles to the Journal of the American Society for Psychical Research. He wrote book reviews for the Revue Métapsychique (1921–1926). Sudre interpreted mental and physical phenomena of mediums as evidence for clairvoyance and psychic forces.[8]

Reception

[edit]

Professor John Cohen in the New Scientist for a review of Treatise on Parapsychology (1960) disputed Sudre's belief that clairvoyance had been established by science but praised the book for "demolishing" the spiritualist hypothesis of mediumship. Cohen noted that the book "ranks among the very best of its kind that have appeared on either side of the Atlantic".[9]

Criticism of Treatise on Parapsychology came from Eric Dingwall. In a review for Nature he noted that Sudre was credulous in accepting materializations and psychic photographs as genuine. Sudre failed to cite the evidence of fraud in mediumship, he was also criticized for defending phenomena at Borley Rectory as 'incontestably genuine' and ignoring evidence to the contrary.[8]

Publications

[edit]
  • Introduction à la Métapsychique Humaine (1926)
  • Le Huitième Art: Mission de la Radio (1945)
  • Personnages d’au-delà (1946)
  • Les Nouvelles Énigmes de l’univers (1951)
  • Traité de Parapsychologie [Translated by Celia Green as Treatise on Parapsychology] (1956, 1960)
  • Parapsychology (1962)

References

[edit]
  1. ^ "René Sudre". Encyclopedia of Occultism and Parapsychology. Retrieved August 14, 2017.
  2. ^ Lachapelle, Sofie. (2005). Attempting Science: The Creation and Early Development of the Institut Métapsychique International in Paris, 1919–1931. Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 41: 1–24.
  3. ^ Ashby, Robert H. (1972). The Guidebook for the Study of Psychical Research. Rider. p. 66
  4. ^ Bozzano, Ernesto. (1926). A Propos de l’introduction à la Métapsychique Humaine: Réfutation du livre de René Sudre. Paris: Jean Meyer.
  5. ^ Asprem, Egil. (2014). The Problem of Disenchantment: Scientific Naturalism and Esoteric Discourse, 1900–1939. Brill Academic Publishers. p. 347. ISBN 978-90-04-25192-2
  6. ^ Price, Harry. (1942). Search for Truth: My Life for Psychical Research. Collins. p. 121
  7. ^ Valentine, Elizabeth R. Institutionalisation and the History of Psychical Research in Great Britain in the 20th Century. In Anna Lux, Sylvia Paletschek. (2016). Okkultismus im Gehäuse: Institutionalisierungen der Parapsychologie im 20. Jahrhundert im internationalen Vergleich. De Gruyter Oldenbourg. p. 140. ISBN 978-3-11-046376-7
  8. ^ a b Dingwall, Eric. (1960). The Paranormal: A French View. Nature 188: 177.
  9. ^ Cohen, John. (1960). Treatise on Parapsychology. New Scientist. July 28. pp. 306–307. Retrieved August 14, 2017.

Further reading

[edit]
  • Renaud Evrard. (2009). René Sudre (1880–1968): The Metapsychist's Quill. Journal of the Society for Psychical Research 73: 207–222.
  • William Henry Salter. (1958). Review of Traité de Parapsychologie. Journal of the Society for Psychical Research 39: 87–88.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=René_Sudre&oldid=1157959928"