Jewish geography: Difference between revisions
Capitalization in article description |
|||
| (40 intermediate revisions by 34 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Short description|Game amongst global Jewish community}} |
|||
{{Orphan|date=October 2006}} |
|||
| ⚫ | '''Jewish geography''' is a popular [[game]] sometimes played when [[Jews]] meet each other for the first time and try to identify people they know in common. The game has become something of an informal social [[Norm (sociology)|custom]] in the Jewish community, and it is often surprisingly easy for strangers who play it to discover mutual acquaintances and establish instant context and connection. |
||
American social historian Etan Diamond notes that non-Jews "often find it astonishing that such links are made so easily, but given both the relative smallness of the Jewish community—and the even smaller size of the Orthodox Jewish community—and the extensive overlapping social circles within these communities, it should not surprise too much".<ref name="diamond">{{cite book |author=Diamond |first=Etan |url=https://uncpress.org/book/9780807848890/and-i-will-dwell-in-their-midst/ |title=And I Will Dwell in Their Midst: Orthodox Jews in Suburbia |publisher=[[University of North Carolina Press]] |year=2000 |isbn=978-0-8078-4889-0}}</ref> He gives an example Jewish geography conversation of "You're from [insert name of city here]? Do you know [insert person's name here]?" getting a response of "Sure, he sits behind my uncle in synagogue" or "I met her once at a youth group convention".<ref name="diamond"/> |
|||
| ⚫ | '''Jewish geography''' is a popular |
||
==Similar games== |
|||
As Etan Diamond observes in his [[book]] ''And I Will Dwell in Their Midst: Orthodox Jews in Suburbia'': |
|||
An Israeli version of the game, ''pitsuchim'', has been a common pastime among young Israeli backpackers traveling the world, taking its name from a 1980s television quiz show.<ref name="Caitlin Yoshiko Kandil and Niv Elis">{{cite news|author=Caitlin Yoshiko Kandil and Niv Elis|title=The New (Old) Game of Jewish Geography|work=Moment Magazine|date=November–December 2011}}</ref> |
|||
Another similar social game called "The rule of intertwined Datis" (Hebrew for religious [[orthodox Jews]]) is used by Religious Zionist Orthodox Jews, and a movie mocking the game called by that name has been produced by students of the Ma'ale school for video and media.<ref>[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A6YRPvqm5rc Hok Hadatiyim Hasheluvim] The rule of intertwined Datis (YouTube)</ref> |
|||
<blockquote>This "game" of "Jewish geography" follows a simple pattern. One person asks, "You're from [insert name of city here]? Do you know [insert person's name here]?" The other one usually responds something like, "Sure, he sits behind my uncle in synagogue," or "I met her once at a youth group convention," or "She is really good friends with my sister's college roommate." Non-Jews often find it astonishing that such links are made so easily, but given both the relative smallness of the Jewish community - and the even smaller size of the Orthodox Jewish community - and the extensive overlapping social circles within these communities, it should not surprise too much. [p. xv].<ref>{{cite book |
|||
|url=http://uncpress.unc.edu/chapters/diamond_and.html |
|||
|title=And I Will Dwell in Their Midst: Orthodox Jews in Suburbia |
|||
|author=Etan Diamond |
|||
|publisher=[[University of North Carolina Press]] |
|||
|year=2000}}</ref></blockquote> |
|||
The Jewish geography game can be seen as a form of testing the [[small-world experiment]], [[Stanley Milgram]]'s research into the probability that two randomly selected people would know each other. |
|||
[[Sonia Pressman Fuentes]] describes it in her [[memoir]] ''Eat First - You Don't Know What They'll Give You: The Adventures of an Immigrant Family and Their Feminist Daughter'', "... When two or more Jews meet who share a connection to a particular ... locality ... they will question each other until they find that they know, or know of, at least one other Jew in common."<ref name="Fuentes">{{cite book |
|||
|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=fACXtMrR0nkC&pg=PA312&ots=Fglc-pwdWI&dq=%22jewish+geography%22&sig=ZvvcJfdvK7gIetgb1tgcDyUVNpQ#PPA312,M1 |
|||
|title=Eat First - You Don't Know What They'll Give You: The Adventures of an Immigrant Family and Their Feminist Daughter |
|||
|author=[[Sonia Pressman Fuentes]] |
|||
|publisher=[[Xlibris]] |
|||
|year=1999}}</ref> |
|||
== |
==Origins== |
||
The origins of "Jewish geography" are unclear. [[Sarah Bunin Benor|Sarah Benor]], a linguist and professor of [[Jewish Studies]] at Hebrew Union College has noted "Sometimes that kind of thing is really impossible to find."<ref name="Caitlin Yoshiko Kandil and Niv Elis"/> |
|||
==Analysis== |
|||
{{Synthesis|date=October 2007}} |
{{Synthesis|date=October 2007}} |
||
The term "Jewish geography" not only functions as the name of the game, but also describes the unique smallness and closeness of the worldwide Jewish [[population]]. The Jewish population's "Jewish geography," therefore, is what makes the game possible and lets Jews from different cities, regions, and countries easily discover people they know in common. |
The term "Jewish geography" not only functions as the name of the game, but also describes the unique smallness and closeness of the worldwide Jewish [[population]]. The Jewish population's "Jewish geography," therefore, is what makes the game possible and lets Jews from different cities, regions, and countries easily discover people they know in common. |
||
Both the game and the concept are Jewish-specific examples of the [[six degrees of separation]] [[theory]] proposed by Hungarian writer [[Frigyes Karinthy]] in 1929 and the [[small world phenomenon]] hypothesized by social scientist [[Stanley Milgram]] in 1967. |
Both the game and the concept are Jewish-specific examples of the [[six degrees of separation]] [[theory]] proposed by Hungarian writer [[Frigyes Karinthy]] in 1929 and the [[small world phenomenon]] hypothesized by social scientist [[Stanley Milgram]] in 1967. |
||
| Line 27: | Line 22: | ||
While the accuracy of these theories have been questioned by some, few Jews doubt the validity of "Jewish geography," having observed its connective power firsthand. |
While the accuracy of these theories have been questioned by some, few Jews doubt the validity of "Jewish geography," having observed its connective power firsthand. |
||
==See also== |
|||
The phenomenon can be observed in other insular cultures, including Bahá'ís, Mormons (members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints) and Jehovah's Witnesses. |
|||
* [[Six degrees of separation]] |
|||
== |
==References== |
||
{{reflist}} |
{{reflist}} |
||
[[Category:Jewish culture]] |
[[Category:Jewish culture]] |
||
[[Category:Social networks]] |
[[Category:Social networks]] |
||
[[he:חוק דתיים שלובים]] |
|||
Latest revision as of 04:05, 1 January 2024
Jewish geography is a popular game sometimes played when Jews meet each other for the first time and try to identify people they know in common. The game has become something of an informal social custom in the Jewish community, and it is often surprisingly easy for strangers who play it to discover mutual acquaintances and establish instant context and connection.
American social historian Etan Diamond notes that non-Jews "often find it astonishing that such links are made so easily, but given both the relative smallness of the Jewish community—and the even smaller size of the Orthodox Jewish community—and the extensive overlapping social circles within these communities, it should not surprise too much".[1] He gives an example Jewish geography conversation of "You're from [insert name of city here]? Do you know [insert person's name here]?" getting a response of "Sure, he sits behind my uncle in synagogue" or "I met her once at a youth group convention".[1]
Similar games
[edit]An Israeli version of the game, pitsuchim, has been a common pastime among young Israeli backpackers traveling the world, taking its name from a 1980s television quiz show.[2]
Another similar social game called "The rule of intertwined Datis" (Hebrew for religious orthodox Jews) is used by Religious Zionist Orthodox Jews, and a movie mocking the game called by that name has been produced by students of the Ma'ale school for video and media.[3]
The Jewish geography game can be seen as a form of testing the small-world experiment, Stanley Milgram's research into the probability that two randomly selected people would know each other.
Origins
[edit]The origins of "Jewish geography" are unclear. Sarah Benor, a linguist and professor of Jewish Studies at Hebrew Union College has noted "Sometimes that kind of thing is really impossible to find."[2]
Analysis
[edit] | This article or section possibly contains synthesis of material that does not verifiably mention or relate to the main topic. (October 2007) |
The term "Jewish geography" not only functions as the name of the game, but also describes the unique smallness and closeness of the worldwide Jewish population. The Jewish population's "Jewish geography," therefore, is what makes the game possible and lets Jews from different cities, regions, and countries easily discover people they know in common.
Both the game and the concept are Jewish-specific examples of the six degrees of separation theory proposed by Hungarian writer Frigyes Karinthy in 1929 and the small world phenomenon hypothesized by social scientist Stanley Milgram in 1967.
While the accuracy of these theories have been questioned by some, few Jews doubt the validity of "Jewish geography," having observed its connective power firsthand.
See also
[edit]References
[edit]- ^ a b Diamond, Etan (2000). And I Will Dwell in Their Midst: Orthodox Jews in Suburbia. University of North Carolina Press. ISBN 978-0-8078-4889-0.
- ^ a b Caitlin Yoshiko Kandil and Niv Elis (November–December 2011). "The New (Old) Game of Jewish Geography". Moment Magazine.
- ^ Hok Hadatiyim Hasheluvim The rule of intertwined Datis (YouTube)