Jump to content

Yueban: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
No edit summary
m Disambiguating links to Zhetysu (link changed to Jetisu; link changed to Jetisu) using DisamAssist.
 
(228 intermediate revisions by 83 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{short description|Remnants of northern Xiongnu}}{{Infobox country
'''Chuban''' (Yueban or Üeban) "Weak Huns" was the name used by Chinese historians for the [[Chuy people|Chuy]] tribes: Chuyue, Chumi, Chumuhun, Chuban, and two divisions of [[Shatuo Turks|Shatuo]]. They were also colectively named '''Chuyue''' (Pinyin: Chuyue, Ch. 處月 Chuyue = 'abode of the Moon [god]'). The present endoethnonym of the Chuy descendents is '''Chuy Kiji''', Turkic for "Chuy People"<ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"Ancient Türks"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch.20 http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/OT/ot20.htm (In Russian)</ref>.
|native_name =
|conventional_long_name = Yueban
|common_name = Yueban
|era = 1st millennium
|status =
|year_start = 160
|year_end = 490
|event_start =
|date_start =
|event_end =
|date_end =
|event1 =
|date_event1 =
|event_pre =
|date_pre =
|event_post =
|date_post =
|p1 =
|flag_p1 =
|s1 =
|flag_s1 =
|s2 =
|flag_s2 =
|s3 =
|flag_s3 =
|s4 =
|flag_s4 =
|image_flag =
|flag =
|flag_type =
|image_coat =
|symbol =
|symbol_type =
|image_map = Mongolia III.jpg
|image_map_caption =
|capital =
|national_motto =
|national_anthem =
|common_languages =
|religion =
|currency =
|legislature =
|leader1 =
|leader2 =
|year_leader1 =
|year_leader2 =
|title_leader =
|stat_area1 =
|stat_year1 =
|today = [[Kazakhstan]]
}}
'''Yueban''' ({{zh|c=悅般}}) ([[Middle Chinese]]: */jiuᴇt̚-pˠan/ < [[Eastern Han Chinese|Late Han Chinese]]: */jyat-pɑn/<ref>Schuessler, Axel. 2007. ''An Etymological Dictionary of Old Chinese''. University of Hawaii Press. p. 586, 155</ref>), colloquially: "Weak [[Xiongnu]]", was the name used by Chinese historians for remnants of the Northern Xiongnu<ref>[[Book of Wei]]. Vol. 102. "悅般國,在烏孫西北,去代一萬九百三十里。其先,匈奴北單于之部落也。" Tr. "Yueban State is to the northwest of Wusun, at a distant of 10,930 lĭ from [[Dai (Sixteen Kingdoms)|Dai]]. It formerly [was] the Northern Xiongnu chanyu's tribe."</ref> in [[Jetisu|Zhetysu]], now part of modern-day [[Kazakhstan]]. In Chinese literature they are commonly called Yueban. The Yuebans gained their own visibility after disintegration of the Northern Xiongnu state, because unlike the main body of the Northern Xiongnu, who escaped from the Chinese sphere of knowledge, the Yueban tribes remained closer to China.


The Chuban underwent a strong influence of the [[Sogdian]] culture<ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"History of Hun People"'', Moscow, 'Science', Ch.15 http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/HPH/hph15.htm (In Russian)</ref>. The Chuy-descendent tribe [[Kimek]] was one of the [[Turkic peoples|Turkic]] tribes known from Arab and Persian Middle Age writers as one of the seven tribes in the [[Kimek Khanate]] in the period of 743-1050 AD. The other six constituent tribes per [[Abu Said Gardizi]] (d. 1061) were the [[Kipchaks]], [[Imi]], [[Tatars]], [[Bayandur]], [[Lanikaz]], and [[Ajlad]].
The Yueban emerged after the disintegration of the [[Xiongnu]] confederation. About 480s, the Yueban split into four [[Chuy valley|Chuy]] tribes:<ref name="gumilevica.kulichki.net">Gumilev L.N., ''"Ancient Türks"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch.20 http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/OT/ot20.htm (In Russian)</ref> ''Chuyue'' (處月), ''Chumi'' (處密), ''Chumukun'' (處木昆), and ''Chuban'' (處半).


One Yueban branch, Chuyue, later intermixing with [[Göktürks]], formed the [[Shatuo]] of the Western [[Göktürk Khaganate]].<ref>C. P. Atwood, ''Encyclopedia of Mongolia and the Mongol Empire'', p.424</ref> The Yueban-descended [[Shatuo]] played an important role in Chinese dynastic history. In the 10th century the remaining Shatuo branch of the Chuy tribe possibly joined [[Mongolic languages|Mongolic-speaking]] [[Tatar confederation]] in the territory of the modern [[Mongolia]], and became known as [[Ongud]] or White Tatars<ref>Ozkan Izgi, ''"The ancient cultures of Central Asia and the relations with the Chinese civilization"''//The Turks, Ankara, 2002, p. 98, {{ISBN|975-6782-56-0}}</ref><ref>Paulillo, Mauricio. "White Tatars: The Problem of the Öngũt conversion to Jingjiao and the Uighur Connection" in ''From the Oxus River to the Chinese Shores: Studies on East Syriac Christianity in China and Central Asia (orientalia - patristica - oecumenica)'' Ed. Tang, Winkler. (2013) pp. 237-252</ref> branch of the Tatars.
==Chuban state ==
[[Image:Asia 400ad.jpg|thumb|300px|Asia in 400 AD, showing the Yuehban (Chuban) Khanate and its neighbors.]]


Another Yueban-descended tribe, Chumukun, might be associated with the [[Kimek-Kipchak confederation|Kimek confederation]].
Between 155 and 166 a former vassal tribes of the [[Xiongnu]] known as the [[Xianbei]] united under [[Change of Xianbei names to Han names|Tian-Shih-huai]] and conducted a series of campaigns against Northern Xiongnu dominance, eventually defeating them and forcing the Xiongnu to flee west, which started a series of westward migrations (93-c.380) known collectively as [[Huns]].


==Identity and location==
The defeat ended the prominence of the Xiongnu as a major power in inner Asia. Tian-Shih-huai expelled Huns from [[Dzungaria]] to beyond the [[Tarbagatai]], and pushed [[Dingling]] (Gaoche) tribes beyond the Sayan mountains. The defeat had cost the Xiongnu their agricultural dependencies in the "Western Territories" (Xiyu or Xinjian of the Chinese annals), forcing them to find new dependencies, and the Xiongnu split again. The "'''Weak Huns'''" remained in Semirechje, where they established the principality of '''Chuban''' (commonly called ''Yueban'' in Chinese literature), which existed until the 480es CE. The strongest tribes (known to Europeans as "the [[Huns]]) migrated towards Europe, where they conquered the Iranian [[Alans]] and Germanic [[Goths]], and later attacked the [[Roman Empire]]. This Hunnic invasion of Europe led to severe upheavals among European peoples, giving the Huns a reputation in Europe as bandits and robbers, while the Chinese authors characterized them as the most acculturate of all "barbarians". <ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"History of Hun People"'', Moscow, 'Science', Ch.15, http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/HPH/hph15.htm (In Russian)</ref>
[[Yury Zuev]] reconstructed 悅般 ''Yueban'''s underlying form as *''Örpen'' ~ ''Ürpen'', identifiable with the toponym ''Örpün'' mentioned in [[Orkhon inscriptions|Bilge Khagan inscription]].<ref>[https://bitig.kz/?mod=1&tid=1&oid=16&lang=e Bilge Khagan isncription] at [https://bitig.kz/?lang=e Türik Bitig]</ref><ref>Zuev, Yu. A., ''Rannie tyurki: ocherki istorii i ideologii'', Dajk-Press, Almaty, 2004, p. 27, 68-70 (in Russian)</ref> Zuev also compared *''Örpen'' ~ ''Ürpen'' to the [[Zhou (country subdivision)|prefecture]] 咽麫 ''Yànmiàn'' (supposedly from [[Middle Chinese|MC]] < *''iet-mien'' < *''ermen'' ~ ''örmen''?) at the [[Irtysh river|Irtysh]] [[tributary|headwaters]] in the 7th century. Meanwhile, Vladimir Tishin compared 咽麫 ''Yànmiàn'' (< LMC *''ʔjianˊ-mjianˋ'' < EMC *''ʔɛn<sup>H</sup>-mjian<sup>H</sup>'' < *''Emän'') to the names of the Chumukun's "town of Yan" (咽城) and the [[Emil River|Emel River]].<ref>Tishin, V.V (2018). ["Kimäk and Chù-mù-kūn (处木昆): Notes on an Identification" https://doi.org/10.17746/1563-0110.2018.46.3.107-113]. p. 108-109</ref>


Gumilyov further identified ''Yueban'' with the ''Altï Čub Soğdak'' "Six [[Zhou (country subdivision)|Prefectures']] Sogdians".<ref>Gumilyov, L. ''Millenium around the Caspian Sea'' [https://books.google.com/books?id=yfvMAAAAQBAJ&q=%D0%90%D0%BB%D1%82%D1%8B-%D0%A7%D1%83%D0%B1 Ch. 49]. Litres, 2014. in Russian</ref> Meanwhile, Sergey Klyashtorny identified the ''Altï Čub Soğdak'' with the Sogdian-populated "Six Barbarian Prefectures" (六胡州 Liùhúzhōu)<ref>Klyashtorny S. G. ''Ancient Turkic runic monuments as a source on the history of Central Asia'' Moscow, 1964. p. 78-80, 93-94</ref> of ''Lu'' 魯, ''Li'' 麗, ''Han'' 含 (or ''She'' 舍), ''[[Saka|Sai]]'' 塞, ''Yi'' 依, and ''Qi'' 契, established by [[Tang dynasty|Tang]] Chinese in 679<ref>Pulleyblank, E.G. "A Sogdian Colony in Inner Mongolia" ''T'oung Pao'', 2nd Series, Vol. 41, Livr. 4/5 (1952), p. 326-327</ref> from "surrendered Turks" (降突厥),<ref>''New Book of Tang''. Vol. 37</ref> "originally a Sogdian people who had submitted collectively to the Eastern Turks"<ref>Moribe, Y. [https://doi.org/10.14989/155546 "The Sogdian Turks and Shatuo in Daibei during the Late Tang and Five Dynasties Periods"] ''東洋史研究'' Vol. 62, Issue 4. (2004). Pages 660-693</ref> Later on, ''Altï Čub Soğdak'' were mentioned in [[Kul Tegin]] inscription as enemies of the [[Second Turkic Khaganate]],<ref>''[http://bitig.kz/?lang=e&mod=1&tid=1&oid=15&m=1 Kül Tegin Inscription]'' at [http://bitig.kz/?lang=e&mod=0 Türik Bitig]</ref> and they were conquered by [[Bilge Khagan]] in 701. The Six Prefectures also revolted against Tang, until Tang army dispersed them in 722.<ref>Namba Walter, M. "The Sogdians and Buddhism". ''Sino-Platonic Paper'' 174 (2006). p. 16</ref>
'''Chuban''' (Yueban) are those Huns who in the 2nd century CE settled in Tarbagatai. Later Chuban moved to [[Zhetysu|Jeti-su]]. In the 5th century they were conquered by Uigurs and split into four tribes: [[Chuyue]], [[Chumi]], Chumuhun, [[Chuban]].<ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"History of Hun People"'', Moscow, 'Science', Ch.16, http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/HPH/hph16.htm (In Russian)</ref> In the literature, the Chu tribes of Late Antique period are also called by their generic appellation '''Middle Asian Huns'''. The Middle Asian Huns formed a principality in Jeti-su called '''Chuban''' (Yueban). A.N.Bernshtam correlated the Chinese "Yueban" with the tribal name Chuban and with related Chuyue, Chumi, Chumugun, all of them descendants of the Huns. The Chuyue branch, intermixing with [[Uyghur people|Turkuts]], formed a tribe [[Shato Turks|Shato]] in Southern [[Dzungaria]], west from the lake [[Barkul]]. <ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"Ancient Türks"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch.20 http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/OT/ot20.htm (In Russian)</ref>


==Language and customs==
The Chuban (Yueban) Huns took advantage of [[Uar|Avar]] weakness and conquered Jeti-su. Later, some Avars returned to Jeti-su, in cooperation with the [[Mukrins]], a [[Xianbei]] tribe occupied the Tianshan slopes in the 2nd century AD, and retained there their independence for some time as a '''Western Xianbei Horde'''. <ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"Hunnu in China"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1974, Ch. 9, http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/HIC/hic09.htm (In Russian)</ref>
According to the [[Book of Wei]], the Yuebans' language and customs were the same as the [[Tiele people|Gaoche]], who were [[Turkic people|Turkic speakers]]. Yuebans cut their hair and trimmed their ghee-smeared, sun-dried, glossy eyebrows evenly, and washed before meals three times every day.<ref>*{{cite book |last1=Kyzlasov |first1=L. R. |chapter=Northern Nomads |editor1-last=Litvinsky |editor1-first=B. A. |date=1 January 1996 |title=History of Civilizations of Central Asia: The crossroads of civilizations, A.D. 250 to 750 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=883OZBe2sMYC |publisher=[[UNESCO]] |pages=310–320 |isbn=9231032119 }}</ref><ref>''Weishu'', Vol. 102 "其風俗言語與高車同,而其人清潔於胡。俗剪髮齊眉,以醍醐塗之,昱昱然光澤,日三澡漱,然後飲食。"</ref>


==History==
The Jeti-su was also populated by remnants of the [[Yuezhi]] tribes, the [[Tukhsi]] and [[Azi (tribe)|Azi]], whose armies had conquered Bactria centuries before. The Azes lived between [[Suyab]] and Uzket. Mahmud Kashgari, who can be named a founder of comparative linguistics science, in the 11th century listed Tukhsi, a male dynastic tribe of the Az-Tochar composition, as a group of tribes with pure Türkic language. <ref>Yu. Zuev, ''"Early Türks: Sketches of history and ideology"'', Almaty, Daik-Press, 2002, p. 152-153, ISBN 9985-441-52-9</ref>
[[File:Nirun, Tuyuhun, Yueban, Tuoba Wei.jpg|thumb|[[Rouran Khaganate]] and Yueban]]
[[File:Asia 400ad.jpg|thumb|300px|Asia in 400 AD, showing the Yueban Khanate and its neighbors.]]
Between 155 and 166, the [[Xianbei]] (*''Särpi'') (Ch. 鮮卑, Wade–Giles Hsien-pi, Hsien-pei), a former vassal tribe of the [[Xiongnu]], united under [[Xianbei state|Tanshihuai]] conducted a series of campaigns against [[Northern Xiongnu]], eventually defeating them and forcing them to flee west, which started a series of Xiongnu migrations (93 CE - circa 380 CE) westward to southern Siberia and Central Asia.<ref>{{cite journal |first=L. T. |last=Yablonsky |title=Stock-Breeders of the Ancient Khorezm |publisher=Russian Academy of Sciences Institute of Archaeology |journal=Bulletin of Russian Humanities Foundation |year=1999 |volume=Iss. 1–2 |page=198 }}</ref><ref>E.A.Tsvetsinskaya ''"Integrated assessment of landscape evolution in the Amudarya Prisarykamysh delta, 2001</ref>


The defeat ended the prominence of the Xiongnu as a major power in inner Asia. Tanshihuai expelled the Xiongnu from [[Dzungaria]] to beyond the [[Tarbagatai Mountains]], and pushed the [[Dingling]] beyond the [[Sayan Mountains]]. The defeat had cost the Xiongnu their revenue from the [[Silk Road]] in the agricultural dependencies in the [[Tarim Basin]] ("Western Territories", Xiyu or Xinjian of the Chinese annals), forcing them to find new dependencies, and the Xiongnu split again.
In 448 Toba Dao received an embassy from the Chuban (Yueban). Negotiations, recorded in history, meant an alliance which could have had only one purpose, a war with [[Rouran]] Khaganate. If the Chubans (Yueban) would pressure Jujans from the west, the Rourans would lose any freedom to maneuver. Though no direct records exist about the war in Dzungaria, by the course of the events, there was no peace, and the [[Nomadic empire]] of Rouran began to decline. <ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"Hunnu in China"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1974, Ch. 9, http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/HIC/hic09.htm (In Russian)</ref>
Based on his reconstructions of the events of the Chuban (Yueban) history, [[Lev Gumilev|L.N.Gumilev]] argued against a widespread view that the Rouran were the "Abars" ([[uar|Avars]]) who attacked the [[Sabirs]], starting a "[[Great Migration|Great Migration of people]]", because the Chuban (Yueban) state separated the Rouran Empire from the Siberian peoples, and therefore the Rouran territories did not border the Sabirs. <ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"Hunnu in China"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1974, Ch. 9 Note 26, http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/HIC/hic09.htm (In Russian)</ref>


By the 6th century CE the [[Chuy]] [[Hun]], [[uar|Avar]], and [[Mukrins]] tribes merged to form the [[Turgesh]] people. The Chuban (Yueban) state survived to the end of 480s, until its independence was destroyed by the [[Teleuts]], who had split from the Rouran in 487. But the Teleuts' dominance was short-lived, first the [[Hephthalite]] conquered them in 495-496, then Rouran crushed them, and finally in 547, the Turkut [[Uyghur people]] conquered the Teleuts. But the Chuban (Yueban) lived on, forming four tribes - Chuyue, Chumi, Chumuhun and Chuban. These tribes became major players in the later [[Turkic Khaganate|Great Turkic Kaganate]] and thereafter, but at that time the Huns' descendants were already known under new tribal names. <ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"Hunnu in China"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1974, Ch. 9, http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/HIC/hic09.htm (In Russian)</ref>
Tribes known as the "Weak Xiongnu"<ref>''Book of Wei'', vol. 102 "為漢車騎將軍竇憲所逐,北單于度金微山,西走康居,其'''羸弱不能去'''者住龜茲北。" Tr. "Chased by [[Han dynasty|Han]] General-of-Chariot-and-Cavalry [[Dou Xian]], the Northern Chanyu crossed the [[Altai Mountains|Jinwei Mountains]] and fled west to [[Kangju]]. Those [who were] '''gaunt, weak, and unable to run''' settled north of [[Kucha|Qiuci]]."</ref> or Yueban took advantage of the vulnerability of the neighboring Uar (a people possibly linked to the [[Hephthalites]] and/or the "[[Pannonian Avars|Avars]]" who later invaded Eastern Europe) and conquered [[Jetisu|Zhetysu]], where they established the principality of Yueban. Later, some Uar returned to Zhetysu, and in cooperation with the [[Mohe people|Mukrins]], a Xianbei tribe, occupied the Tianshan slopes in the 2nd century, retaining their independence for some time as the Western Xianbei Horde.<ref name="Gumilev Ch. 9">Gumilev L.N., ''"Hunnu in China"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1974, Ch. 9, http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/HIC/hic09.htm (In Russian)</ref> <!--2nd century AD can't be later then 480s AD-->


Zhetysu was also populated by the [[Az (people)|Azi]] (who lived between [[Suyab]] and [[Uzkent]]) and the [[Tuhsi]]. The ''Azi'' and ''Tuhsi'' are sometimes linked to [[Asii]]{{efn|Czegéldy (apud Golden 1992:53) compares Tuhsi to the name Duhs-As of a tribe among the medieval Eastern-Iranian-speaking [[Alans]]}}<ref>Golden, Peter B. ''An Introduction to the History of Turkic Peoples'' (1992). p. 53, 142</ref><ref>Kubarev, G.V. "A Runic Inscription at Kalbak-Tash II, Central Altai, with Reference to the Location of the Az Tribe" in [[Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia]] 44/4 (2016). p. 97-98 of 92–101</ref> and [[Tushara|Tukharas]];<ref>Prakash, B. ''[https://www.indianculture.gov.in/flipbook/20203 Political and social movements in Ancient Punjab]'' (1964) p. 96.</ref> [[Indo-European migrations|Indo-European peoples]] who had conquered [[Bactria]] six centuries earlier, and formed the [[Kushan Empire]]. According to Persian historian [[Gardizi]], Azi and Tuhsi were remnants of [[Türgesh]],<ref>{{cite book |last=Gumilyov |first=L. |title=Searches for an Imaginary Kingdom: The trefoil of the Bird's Eye View |chapter-url=http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/English/sik2b.htm |chapter=The Shattered Silence (961–1100) }}</ref><ref>Zuev, Yu.A. (2002) ''Early Turks: Sketches of history and ideology'' Daik Press, Almaty. p. 153 (in Russian)</ref> along with [[Khalaj people|Khalaj]].<ref>Pylypchuk, Ya. "Turks and Muslims: From Confrontation to Conversion to Islam (End of VII century - Beginning of XI Century)" in ''UDK'' 94 (4): 95 (4). In Ukrainian</ref> [[Karakhanid]] linguist [[Mahmud Kashgari]] described Tuhsi as a dynastic tribe of Turkic-speaking [[Monolingualism|monoglots]].<ref>{{cite book |first=Yu. |last=Zuev |title=Early Türks: Sketches of history and ideology |location=Almaty |publisher=Daik-Press |year=2002 |pages=152–153}} (in Russian)</ref> This may suggest that Indo-European peoples underwent [[language replacement]], in the form of "[[Turkification]]", had occurred. The ''Azi'' were also alternatively proposed to be [[Yeniseian languages|Yeniseian]]-speaking, as [[Vasily Bartold]] noted the similarities between [[Old Turkic]] 𐰔 ''Az'' and the ethnonym ''Assan'' of a people who spoke an extinct Yeniseic [[Kott language|Kott]] dialect.<ref>{{cite book |last=Barthold |first=Wilhelm |title=Zwölf Vorlesungen über die Geschichte der Türken Mittelasiens |trans-title=Twelve Lectures on the History of the Turks of Central Asia |location=Berlin |publisher=Arthur Collignon |series=Deutsche Gesellschaft für Islamkunde |year=1935 |page=37 |oclc=2221089 }}</ref>
==Altai Chumuhuns==


In 448 the [[Emperor Taiwu of Northern Wei]] received an envoy from the Yueban to negotiate a war with the [[Rouran]]. If the Yueban would pressure them from the west, the Rouran would lose any freedom to maneuver. Though no direct records exist about the war in Dzungaria, by the course of the events, there was no peace, and the nomadic empire of Rouran began to decline.<ref name="Gumilev Ch. 9" />
An 8th century Tibetan geographer called Chumuhuns in Altai and south of it ''Ibilkur'', and associated them with Külüg-Külchur, they were the only one of Chuy Huns tribes that in the middle of the 8th century preserved their independence, in spite of being sandwiched between [[Karluks]] and [[Türgeshes]]. Their possessions were on the west side of [[Tarbagatai]] range. <ref>Bacot J. ''"Reconnaissance en Haute Asie Seplentrionale par cinq envoyes ouigours au VIII siecle"'' // JA, Vol. 254, No 2,. 1956, p.147, in Gumilev L.N., ''"Ancient Türks"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch.27 http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/OT/ot27.htm (In Russian)</ref>

In the late 5th century the Yueban were attacked by the [[Tiele people|Tiele]], who had split from the Rouran in 487. The Yueban principality ceased to existed during the 480s and split into four tribes, known as the Chuyue, Chumi, Chumuhun, and Chuban.<ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"History of Hun People"'', Moscow, 'Science', Ch.16, http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/HPH/hph16.htm (In Russian)</ref> The dominance of Yueban's Tiele enemies was short-lived: first, the [[Hephthalites]] conquered the Tiele (495-496), followed by the Rouran in 530s<ref>Golden, Peter B. (1992). An Introduction to the History of the Turkic People. Otto Harrassowitz, Wiesbaden. p. 79</ref> and finally in 551, the Turks, as Rouran's vassals, again quelled Tiele's rebellion.<ref>Duan, "Dingling, Gaoju and Tiele", p. 346–347</ref>

Nevertheless, the four splinter tribes still became major players in the [[First Turkic Khaganate]].<ref name="Gumilev Ch. 9" /> After the First Khaganate's disintegration, Chumukun were in the [[Duolu]] wing, whereas Chuban were in both Duolu and [[Nushibi]] wings of the [[Western Turkic Khaganate]] ''On Oq'' (Ten Arrows) elites.<ref>[[Old Book of Tang]]. Vol. 194</ref><ref>[[Tongdian]] vol. 199</ref> Much later, Chuyue branch, intermixing with [[Göktürk]] remnants, formed the Shatuo tribe in Southern [[Dzungaria]], west of [[Barköl Kazakh Autonomous County#Lake Barkol|Lake Barkol]].<ref name="gumilevica.kulichki.net"/>

An 8th-century Tibetan geographer mentioned Chumuhuns in Altai and south of it as the ''Ibilkur'', and associated them with Külüg-Külchur. They were the only Chuy tribe that in the middle of the 8th century preserved their independence, in spite of being sandwiched between [[Karluks]] and Turgesh. Their possessions were on the west side of the [[Tarbagatai Mountains|Tarbagatai]] range.<ref>Bacot J. ''"Reconnaissance en Haute Asie Seplentrionale par cinq envoyes ouigours au VIII siecle"'' // JA, Vol. 254, No 2,. 1956, p.147, in Gumilev L.N., ''"Ancient Türks"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch.27 http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/OT/ot27.htm (In Russian)</ref> Chinese chroniclers listed ''Chumukun'' (處木昆), led by a *''Külüg čor'' ([屈]律啜 ''[Qu]lü chuo''), as the first of five [[Duolu]] tribes in the On-Ok union.<ref>Tongdian, Vol. 199</ref><ref>Old Book of Tang, Vol. 194</ref><ref>{{cite journal|last=Dobrovits|first=Mihály|title=On the Titulature of Western Turkic Chieftains|url=https://www.academia.edu/38067945|date=2014–2015|journal=Archivum Eurasiae Archivi Aevii|volume=21|publisher=Otto-Harassowitz Verlag|location= Wiesbaden}}</ref><ref>Tishin, V.V. (2018). [https://doi.org/10.17746/1563-0110.2018.46.3.107-113 "Kimäk and Chù-mù-kūn (处木昆): Notes on an Identification"]</ref>

Based on a reconstruction of Yueban history, [[Lev Gumilev]] argued against a then-widespread view that the Rouran were synonymous with the "[[Pannonian Avars|Avars]]" or "Pseudo-Avars" (who attacked the Sabirs before invading Eastern Europe), because the Rouran would have had to pass through the Yueban state to attack the Sabirs.<ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"Hunnu in China"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1974, Ch. 9 Note 26, http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/HIC/hic09.htm (In Russian)</ref>


==Theism, spirits, and magic==
==Theism, spirits, and magic==
No records address Chuy Huns' religion, shamanic cures, and magic, though Chinese annals depict outward religious rites and magic. A narration about Yuebans tells about sorcerers, able to cause frost and rainstorm. During a war with Jujans, Yueban sorcerers incited a snowstorm against Jujans, who had so many frost-bitten that they had to stop their campaign and retreat. A similar legend is later told about [[Uar|Avar]] sorcerers in a war with [[Francs]], and [[Naiman]] sorcerers against [[Chingis-Khan]]. <ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"Ancient Türks"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch.7 http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/OT/ot07.htm (In Russian)</ref>
No records address the Yueban religion, though Chinese annals depict some manifestations of religious rites and magic. A narration about the Yuebans tells about sorcerers, able to cause frost and rainstorm. During a war with the Rouran, Chuban sorcerers incited a snowstorm against them, making the Rouran so frostbitten they had to stop their campaign and retreat. A similar legend is later told about the [[Avars (Carpathians)|Eurasian Avars]] sorcerers in their war with the [[Franks]], and [[Naimans|Naiman]] sorcerers against [[Chingis-Khan]].<ref>Gumilev L.N., ''"Ancient Türks"'', Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch.7 http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/OT/ot07.htm (In Russian)</ref>


The reigning clan of western Türkic initially Manichaean [[Chigils|Chigil]] (Persian ''cihil "forty"'') tribe was [[Shato Turks|Shato]] (Persian ''Sada "Hundred"''), which later founded the Chinese state Hou-Tang ([[Later Tang]], 923-936) in Northern China, and adopted a Chinese surname Li. Türks-Shato had a predominant Dragon cult. Later Tang's glorious founder Li Keiun also came from the Dragon tribe. The annals even noted that the Shato were praying "old services following the custom of the North" at the Thunder-mountain, at the Gates of Dragon. <ref>Yu. Zuev, ''"Early Türks: Sketches of history and ideology"'', Almaty, Daik-Press, 2002, p. 145, ISBN 9985-441-52-9</ref>
The [[Manichaean]] [[Chigils|Chuyue]] tribe's descendants, Shatuo, later founded the Chinese state [[Later Tang|Hou Tang]] (923-936) in Northern China, and adopted a Chinese surname Li (李). The Shatuo had a predominant Dragon cult. Later Tang's founder [[Li Keyong]] also came from the Dragon tribe. The annals even noted that the Shatuo were praying "old services following the custom of the North" at the Thunder-mountain, at the Gates of Dragon.<ref>Yu. Zuev, ''"Early Türks: Sketches of history and ideology"'', Almaty, Daik-Press, 2002, p. 145, {{Listed Invalid ISBN|9985-4-4152-9}}</ref> Within China, Chuy Shatuo became active adherents and protectors of [[Buddhism]] and [[Taoism]], and initiated construction of many Buddhist temples. Subsequent to Shatuo, most of these temples were demolished.<ref>Ozkan Izgi, ''"The ancient cultures of Central Asia and the relations with the Chinese civilization"''//The Turks, Ankara, 2002, p. 100</ref>

==Legacy==
The Chuyue (處月) were often identified with the ''[[Chigils|Čigil]]'',<ref>Golden, P.B. (1992) ''An Introduction to the History of the Turkic Peoples'' in ''Turcologica'' (9). p. 199</ref><ref>Zuev, "Early Turks: Essays of history and ideology", Almaty, Daik-Press, 2002, p. 145, 250</ref><ref>Lee, J.Y. (2018) "Some remarks on the Turkicisation of the Mongols in post-Mongol Central Asia and the Qipchaq Steppe" in ''Acta Orientalia'' 71(2). p. 129 of 121-144</ref> a [[Middle Turkic]]-speaking tribe "opposing [[Byzantine Empire|Rūm]]" mentioned by 10th century Karakhanid scholar [[Mahmud al-Kashgari]];<ref name="Kaśğari 1982 p. 82-83">Maħmūd al-Kaśğari. "Dīwān Luğāt al-Turk". Edited & translated by [[Robert Dankoff]] in collaboration with James Kelly. In ''Sources of Oriental Languages and Literature''. Part I. (1982). p. 82-83</ref> still, Atwood (2010) doubts this Chuyue-Chigil identification and notes that Chuyue is phonetically closer to the Chunghyl "bones" of the [[Yugurs]].<ref>Atwood, Christopher P. (2010). "The Notion of Tribe in Medieval China: Ouyang Xiu and the Shatup Dynastic Myth". Miscellanea Asiatica: p. 602, n. 27 of 593–621.</ref>

The Chumi (處密) tribe may be identified with the ''Čömül'', another tribe opposing Rūm and spoke both [[Middle Turkic]] and their own "gibberish" (Ar. رَطَانَة‎ ''raṭāna'').<ref name="Kaśğari 1982 p. 82-83"/><ref>Bailey, H. W. "Turks in Khotanese Texts", in ''The Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland'', No. 1 (Jan., 1939), pp. 87</ref>

The Chumukun (處木昆) were identified by Gumilyov with the [[Kimek-Kipchak confederation|Kimek]] (which existed in the period of 743-1050 AD).<ref>Gumilev L.N. ''Ancient Turks'', Moscow, 'Science', 1967, [http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/OT/ot27.htm Ch. 27] (in Russian)</ref><ref>Tishin, V.V (2018). [https://doi.org/10.17746/1563-0110.2018.46.3.107-113 "Kimäk and Chù-mù-kūn (处木昆): Notes on an Identification"]</ref> [[Abu Said Gardizi]] (d. 1061) listed the [[Kimek-Kipchak confederation|Kimek khaganate]]'s seven constituents as [[Imi]], [[Yemek]]s, [[Tatars]], [[Bayandur]], [[Kipchaks]], [[Lanikaz]], and [[Ajlad]]. Much later, both Chumukun and [[Kipchaks]] would possibly contribute to the ethnogenesis of the [[Cumans|Polovtsy]].<ref>Gumilyov, L. (2009) ''Searches for an Imaginary Kingdom: The Legend of the Kingdom of Prester John'' [http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/English/sik5b.htm#sik5para14 ch. 14] (in English; translated by R.E.F. Smith)</ref>


==See also==
==See also==
[[Chigils]] Turks
*[[Chigils]]
*[[Kimek]]
*[[History of the central steppe]]


==References==
==Notes==
{{notelist}}
<references/>


==References==
[[Category:Turkic peoples]]
<references />


[[zh:悅般]]
[[Category:Xiongnu]]

Latest revision as of 20:13, 1 September 2024

Yueban
160–490
Historical era1st millennium
• Established
160
• Disestablished
490
Today part ofKazakhstan

Yueban (Chinese: 悅般) (Middle Chinese: */jiuᴇt̚-pˠan/ < Late Han Chinese: */jyat-pɑn/[1]), colloquially: "Weak Xiongnu", was the name used by Chinese historians for remnants of the Northern Xiongnu[2] in Zhetysu, now part of modern-day Kazakhstan. In Chinese literature they are commonly called Yueban. The Yuebans gained their own visibility after disintegration of the Northern Xiongnu state, because unlike the main body of the Northern Xiongnu, who escaped from the Chinese sphere of knowledge, the Yueban tribes remained closer to China.

The Yueban emerged after the disintegration of the Xiongnu confederation. About 480s, the Yueban split into four Chuy tribes:[3] Chuyue (處月), Chumi (處密), Chumukun (處木昆), and Chuban (處半).

One Yueban branch, Chuyue, later intermixing with Göktürks, formed the Shatuo of the Western Göktürk Khaganate.[4] The Yueban-descended Shatuo played an important role in Chinese dynastic history. In the 10th century the remaining Shatuo branch of the Chuy tribe possibly joined Mongolic-speaking Tatar confederation in the territory of the modern Mongolia, and became known as Ongud or White Tatars[5][6] branch of the Tatars.

Another Yueban-descended tribe, Chumukun, might be associated with the Kimek confederation.

Identity and location

[edit]

Yury Zuev reconstructed 悅般 Yueban's underlying form as *Örpen ~ Ürpen, identifiable with the toponym Örpün mentioned in Bilge Khagan inscription.[7][8] Zuev also compared *Örpen ~ Ürpen to the prefecture 咽麫 Yànmiàn (supposedly from MC < *iet-mien < *ermen ~ örmen?) at the Irtysh headwaters in the 7th century. Meanwhile, Vladimir Tishin compared 咽麫 Yànmiàn (< LMC *ʔjianˊ-mjianˋ < EMC *ʔɛnH-mjianH < *Emän) to the names of the Chumukun's "town of Yan" (咽城) and the Emel River.[9]

Gumilyov further identified Yueban with the Altï Čub Soğdak "Six Prefectures' Sogdians".[10] Meanwhile, Sergey Klyashtorny identified the Altï Čub Soğdak with the Sogdian-populated "Six Barbarian Prefectures" (六胡州 Liùhúzhōu)[11] of Lu 魯, Li 麗, Han 含 (or She 舍), Sai 塞, Yi 依, and Qi 契, established by Tang Chinese in 679[12] from "surrendered Turks" (降突厥),[13] "originally a Sogdian people who had submitted collectively to the Eastern Turks"[14] Later on, Altï Čub Soğdak were mentioned in Kul Tegin inscription as enemies of the Second Turkic Khaganate,[15] and they were conquered by Bilge Khagan in 701. The Six Prefectures also revolted against Tang, until Tang army dispersed them in 722.[16]

Language and customs

[edit]

According to the Book of Wei, the Yuebans' language and customs were the same as the Gaoche, who were Turkic speakers. Yuebans cut their hair and trimmed their ghee-smeared, sun-dried, glossy eyebrows evenly, and washed before meals three times every day.[17][18]

History

[edit]
Rouran Khaganate and Yueban
Asia in 400 AD, showing the Yueban Khanate and its neighbors.

Between 155 and 166, the Xianbei (*Särpi) (Ch. 鮮卑, Wade–Giles Hsien-pi, Hsien-pei), a former vassal tribe of the Xiongnu, united under Tanshihuai conducted a series of campaigns against Northern Xiongnu, eventually defeating them and forcing them to flee west, which started a series of Xiongnu migrations (93 CE - circa 380 CE) westward to southern Siberia and Central Asia.[19][20]

The defeat ended the prominence of the Xiongnu as a major power in inner Asia. Tanshihuai expelled the Xiongnu from Dzungaria to beyond the Tarbagatai Mountains, and pushed the Dingling beyond the Sayan Mountains. The defeat had cost the Xiongnu their revenue from the Silk Road in the agricultural dependencies in the Tarim Basin ("Western Territories", Xiyu or Xinjian of the Chinese annals), forcing them to find new dependencies, and the Xiongnu split again.

Tribes known as the "Weak Xiongnu"[21] or Yueban took advantage of the vulnerability of the neighboring Uar (a people possibly linked to the Hephthalites and/or the "Avars" who later invaded Eastern Europe) and conquered Zhetysu, where they established the principality of Yueban. Later, some Uar returned to Zhetysu, and in cooperation with the Mukrins, a Xianbei tribe, occupied the Tianshan slopes in the 2nd century, retaining their independence for some time as the Western Xianbei Horde.[22]

Zhetysu was also populated by the Azi (who lived between Suyab and Uzkent) and the Tuhsi. The Azi and Tuhsi are sometimes linked to Asii[a][23][24] and Tukharas;[25] Indo-European peoples who had conquered Bactria six centuries earlier, and formed the Kushan Empire. According to Persian historian Gardizi, Azi and Tuhsi were remnants of Türgesh,[26][27] along with Khalaj.[28] Karakhanid linguist Mahmud Kashgari described Tuhsi as a dynastic tribe of Turkic-speaking monoglots.[29] This may suggest that Indo-European peoples underwent language replacement, in the form of "Turkification", had occurred. The Azi were also alternatively proposed to be Yeniseian-speaking, as Vasily Bartold noted the similarities between Old Turkic 𐰔 Az and the ethnonym Assan of a people who spoke an extinct Yeniseic Kott dialect.[30]

In 448 the Emperor Taiwu of Northern Wei received an envoy from the Yueban to negotiate a war with the Rouran. If the Yueban would pressure them from the west, the Rouran would lose any freedom to maneuver. Though no direct records exist about the war in Dzungaria, by the course of the events, there was no peace, and the nomadic empire of Rouran began to decline.[22]

In the late 5th century the Yueban were attacked by the Tiele, who had split from the Rouran in 487. The Yueban principality ceased to existed during the 480s and split into four tribes, known as the Chuyue, Chumi, Chumuhun, and Chuban.[31] The dominance of Yueban's Tiele enemies was short-lived: first, the Hephthalites conquered the Tiele (495-496), followed by the Rouran in 530s[32] and finally in 551, the Turks, as Rouran's vassals, again quelled Tiele's rebellion.[33]

Nevertheless, the four splinter tribes still became major players in the First Turkic Khaganate.[22] After the First Khaganate's disintegration, Chumukun were in the Duolu wing, whereas Chuban were in both Duolu and Nushibi wings of the Western Turkic Khaganate On Oq (Ten Arrows) elites.[34][35] Much later, Chuyue branch, intermixing with Göktürk remnants, formed the Shatuo tribe in Southern Dzungaria, west of Lake Barkol.[3]

An 8th-century Tibetan geographer mentioned Chumuhuns in Altai and south of it as the Ibilkur, and associated them with Külüg-Külchur. They were the only Chuy tribe that in the middle of the 8th century preserved their independence, in spite of being sandwiched between Karluks and Turgesh. Their possessions were on the west side of the Tarbagatai range.[36] Chinese chroniclers listed Chumukun (處木昆), led by a *Külüg čor ([屈]律啜 [Qu]lü chuo), as the first of five Duolu tribes in the On-Ok union.[37][38][39][40]

Based on a reconstruction of Yueban history, Lev Gumilev argued against a then-widespread view that the Rouran were synonymous with the "Avars" or "Pseudo-Avars" (who attacked the Sabirs before invading Eastern Europe), because the Rouran would have had to pass through the Yueban state to attack the Sabirs.[41]

Theism, spirits, and magic

[edit]

No records address the Yueban religion, though Chinese annals depict some manifestations of religious rites and magic. A narration about the Yuebans tells about sorcerers, able to cause frost and rainstorm. During a war with the Rouran, Chuban sorcerers incited a snowstorm against them, making the Rouran so frostbitten they had to stop their campaign and retreat. A similar legend is later told about the Eurasian Avars sorcerers in their war with the Franks, and Naiman sorcerers against Chingis-Khan.[42]

The Manichaean Chuyue tribe's descendants, Shatuo, later founded the Chinese state Hou Tang (923-936) in Northern China, and adopted a Chinese surname Li (李). The Shatuo had a predominant Dragon cult. Later Tang's founder Li Keyong also came from the Dragon tribe. The annals even noted that the Shatuo were praying "old services following the custom of the North" at the Thunder-mountain, at the Gates of Dragon.[43] Within China, Chuy Shatuo became active adherents and protectors of Buddhism and Taoism, and initiated construction of many Buddhist temples. Subsequent to Shatuo, most of these temples were demolished.[44]

Legacy

[edit]

The Chuyue (處月) were often identified with the Čigil,[45][46][47] a Middle Turkic-speaking tribe "opposing Rūm" mentioned by 10th century Karakhanid scholar Mahmud al-Kashgari;[48] still, Atwood (2010) doubts this Chuyue-Chigil identification and notes that Chuyue is phonetically closer to the Chunghyl "bones" of the Yugurs.[49]

The Chumi (處密) tribe may be identified with the Čömül, another tribe opposing Rūm and spoke both Middle Turkic and their own "gibberish" (Ar. رَطَانَة‎ raṭāna).[48][50]

The Chumukun (處木昆) were identified by Gumilyov with the Kimek (which existed in the period of 743-1050 AD).[51][52] Abu Said Gardizi (d. 1061) listed the Kimek khaganate's seven constituents as Imi, Yemeks, Tatars, Bayandur, Kipchaks, Lanikaz, and Ajlad. Much later, both Chumukun and Kipchaks would possibly contribute to the ethnogenesis of the Polovtsy.[53]

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ Czegéldy (apud Golden 1992:53) compares Tuhsi to the name Duhs-As of a tribe among the medieval Eastern-Iranian-speaking Alans

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Schuessler, Axel. 2007. An Etymological Dictionary of Old Chinese. University of Hawaii Press. p. 586, 155
  2. ^ Book of Wei. Vol. 102. "悅般國,在烏孫西北,去代一萬九百三十里。其先,匈奴北單于之部落也。" Tr. "Yueban State is to the northwest of Wusun, at a distant of 10,930 lĭ from Dai. It formerly [was] the Northern Xiongnu chanyu's tribe."
  3. ^ a b Gumilev L.N., "Ancient Türks", Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch.20 http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/OT/ot20.htm (In Russian)
  4. ^ C. P. Atwood, Encyclopedia of Mongolia and the Mongol Empire, p.424
  5. ^ Ozkan Izgi, "The ancient cultures of Central Asia and the relations with the Chinese civilization"//The Turks, Ankara, 2002, p. 98, ISBN 975-6782-56-0
  6. ^ Paulillo, Mauricio. "White Tatars: The Problem of the Öngũt conversion to Jingjiao and the Uighur Connection" in From the Oxus River to the Chinese Shores: Studies on East Syriac Christianity in China and Central Asia (orientalia - patristica - oecumenica) Ed. Tang, Winkler. (2013) pp. 237-252
  7. ^ Bilge Khagan isncription at Türik Bitig
  8. ^ Zuev, Yu. A., Rannie tyurki: ocherki istorii i ideologii, Dajk-Press, Almaty, 2004, p. 27, 68-70 (in Russian)
  9. ^ Tishin, V.V (2018). ["Kimäk and Chù-mù-kūn (处木昆): Notes on an Identification" https://doi.org/10.17746/1563-0110.2018.46.3.107-113]. p. 108-109
  10. ^ Gumilyov, L. Millenium around the Caspian Sea Ch. 49. Litres, 2014. in Russian
  11. ^ Klyashtorny S. G. Ancient Turkic runic monuments as a source on the history of Central Asia Moscow, 1964. p. 78-80, 93-94
  12. ^ Pulleyblank, E.G. "A Sogdian Colony in Inner Mongolia" T'oung Pao, 2nd Series, Vol. 41, Livr. 4/5 (1952), p. 326-327
  13. ^ New Book of Tang. Vol. 37
  14. ^ Moribe, Y. "The Sogdian Turks and Shatuo in Daibei during the Late Tang and Five Dynasties Periods" 東洋史研究 Vol. 62, Issue 4. (2004). Pages 660-693
  15. ^ Kül Tegin Inscription at Türik Bitig
  16. ^ Namba Walter, M. "The Sogdians and Buddhism". Sino-Platonic Paper 174 (2006). p. 16
  17. ^ *Kyzlasov, L. R. (1 January 1996). "Northern Nomads". In Litvinsky, B. A. (ed.). History of Civilizations of Central Asia: The crossroads of civilizations, A.D. 250 to 750. UNESCO. pp. 310–320. ISBN 9231032119.
  18. ^ Weishu, Vol. 102 "其風俗言語與高車同,而其人清潔於胡。俗剪髮齊眉,以醍醐塗之,昱昱然光澤,日三澡漱,然後飲食。"
  19. ^ Yablonsky, L. T. (1999). "Stock-Breeders of the Ancient Khorezm". Bulletin of Russian Humanities Foundation. Iss. 1–2. Russian Academy of Sciences Institute of Archaeology: 198. {{cite journal}}: |volume= has extra text (help)
  20. ^ E.A.Tsvetsinskaya "Integrated assessment of landscape evolution in the Amudarya Prisarykamysh delta, 2001
  21. ^ Book of Wei, vol. 102 "為漢車騎將軍竇憲所逐,北單于度金微山,西走康居,其羸弱不能去者住龜茲北。" Tr. "Chased by Han General-of-Chariot-and-Cavalry Dou Xian, the Northern Chanyu crossed the Jinwei Mountains and fled west to Kangju. Those [who were] gaunt, weak, and unable to run settled north of Qiuci."
  22. ^ a b c Gumilev L.N., "Hunnu in China", Moscow, 'Science', 1974, Ch. 9, http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/HIC/hic09.htm (In Russian)
  23. ^ Golden, Peter B. An Introduction to the History of Turkic Peoples (1992). p. 53, 142
  24. ^ Kubarev, G.V. "A Runic Inscription at Kalbak-Tash II, Central Altai, with Reference to the Location of the Az Tribe" in Archaeology, Ethnology and Anthropology of Eurasia 44/4 (2016). p. 97-98 of 92–101
  25. ^ Prakash, B. Political and social movements in Ancient Punjab (1964) p. 96.
  26. ^ Gumilyov, L. "The Shattered Silence (961–1100)". Searches for an Imaginary Kingdom: The trefoil of the Bird's Eye View.
  27. ^ Zuev, Yu.A. (2002) Early Turks: Sketches of history and ideology Daik Press, Almaty. p. 153 (in Russian)
  28. ^ Pylypchuk, Ya. "Turks and Muslims: From Confrontation to Conversion to Islam (End of VII century - Beginning of XI Century)" in UDK 94 (4): 95 (4). In Ukrainian
  29. ^ Zuev, Yu. (2002). Early Türks: Sketches of history and ideology. Almaty: Daik-Press. pp. 152–153. (in Russian)
  30. ^ Barthold, Wilhelm (1935). Zwölf Vorlesungen über die Geschichte der Türken Mittelasiens [Twelve Lectures on the History of the Turks of Central Asia]. Deutsche Gesellschaft für Islamkunde. Berlin: Arthur Collignon. p. 37. OCLC 2221089.
  31. ^ Gumilev L.N., "History of Hun People", Moscow, 'Science', Ch.16, http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/HPH/hph16.htm (In Russian)
  32. ^ Golden, Peter B. (1992). An Introduction to the History of the Turkic People. Otto Harrassowitz, Wiesbaden. p. 79
  33. ^ Duan, "Dingling, Gaoju and Tiele", p. 346–347
  34. ^ Old Book of Tang. Vol. 194
  35. ^ Tongdian vol. 199
  36. ^ Bacot J. "Reconnaissance en Haute Asie Seplentrionale par cinq envoyes ouigours au VIII siecle" // JA, Vol. 254, No 2,. 1956, p.147, in Gumilev L.N., "Ancient Türks", Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch.27 http://gumilevica.kulichki.net/OT/ot27.htm (In Russian)
  37. ^ Tongdian, Vol. 199
  38. ^ Old Book of Tang, Vol. 194
  39. ^ Dobrovits, Mihály (2014–2015). "On the Titulature of Western Turkic Chieftains". Archivum Eurasiae Archivi Aevii. 21. Wiesbaden: Otto-Harassowitz Verlag.
  40. ^ Tishin, V.V. (2018). "Kimäk and Chù-mù-kūn (处木昆): Notes on an Identification"
  41. ^ Gumilev L.N., "Hunnu in China", Moscow, 'Science', 1974, Ch. 9 Note 26, http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/HIC/hic09.htm (In Russian)
  42. ^ Gumilev L.N., "Ancient Türks", Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch.7 http://gumilevica.kulichki.com/OT/ot07.htm (In Russian)
  43. ^ Yu. Zuev, "Early Türks: Sketches of history and ideology", Almaty, Daik-Press, 2002, p. 145, ISBN 9985-4-4152-9
  44. ^ Ozkan Izgi, "The ancient cultures of Central Asia and the relations with the Chinese civilization"//The Turks, Ankara, 2002, p. 100
  45. ^ Golden, P.B. (1992) An Introduction to the History of the Turkic Peoples in Turcologica (9). p. 199
  46. ^ Zuev, "Early Turks: Essays of history and ideology", Almaty, Daik-Press, 2002, p. 145, 250
  47. ^ Lee, J.Y. (2018) "Some remarks on the Turkicisation of the Mongols in post-Mongol Central Asia and the Qipchaq Steppe" in Acta Orientalia 71(2). p. 129 of 121-144
  48. ^ a b Maħmūd al-Kaśğari. "Dīwān Luğāt al-Turk". Edited & translated by Robert Dankoff in collaboration with James Kelly. In Sources of Oriental Languages and Literature. Part I. (1982). p. 82-83
  49. ^ Atwood, Christopher P. (2010). "The Notion of Tribe in Medieval China: Ouyang Xiu and the Shatup Dynastic Myth". Miscellanea Asiatica: p. 602, n. 27 of 593–621.
  50. ^ Bailey, H. W. "Turks in Khotanese Texts", in The Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland, No. 1 (Jan., 1939), pp. 87
  51. ^ Gumilev L.N. Ancient Turks, Moscow, 'Science', 1967, Ch. 27 (in Russian)
  52. ^ Tishin, V.V (2018). "Kimäk and Chù-mù-kūn (处木昆): Notes on an Identification"
  53. ^ Gumilyov, L. (2009) Searches for an Imaginary Kingdom: The Legend of the Kingdom of Prester John ch. 14 (in English; translated by R.E.F. Smith)