Jump to content

2016 Italian oil drilling referendum: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous edit
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Tense
GreenC bot (talk | contribs)
Bots
2,547,810 edits
Rescued 1 archive link. Wayback Medic 2.5 per WP:URLREQ#xyz.reuters.com
 
(33 intermediate revisions by 22 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Short description|none}} <!-- "none" is a legitimate description when the title is already adequate; see [[WP:SDNONE]] -->
{{Update after|2016|04|18}}
{{Expand Italian|topic=gov|date=March 2020}}
[[File:Italian referendum april 2016.png|thumbnail|right|200px|2016 Referendum ballot paper]]
{{infobox referendum
⚫
A '''referendum on [[petroleum|oil]] and [[natural gas]] [[Oil well|drilling]]''' was held in [[Italy]] on 17 April 2016.<ref>[http://www.ansa.it/english/news/world/2016/02/11/cabinet-sets-drilling-referendum-apr-17_43bb66e5-beba-41e6-b865-36cba72ee985.html Cabinet sets drilling referendum Apr 17] ANSA, 11 February 2016</ref> Over 85% of voters approved repealing of a law that allows gas and oil drilling concessions extracting [[hydrocarbons|Hydrocarbon]] within 12 [[nautical miles]] of the Italian coast to be prolonged until the exhaustion of the useful life of the fields.
|country=Italy
|date=17 April 2016
|title=Do you want to repeal the Article 6, Paragraph 17, Third Sentence, of the legislative decree 3 April 2006, no. 152, "Environmental regulations", as replaced by paragraph 239 of Article 1 of the law of 28 December 2015, no. 208, "Provisions for the formation of the annual and long-term state budget (stability law 2016)", limited to the following words: "for the useful life of the reservoir, in compliance with safety and environmental protection standards"?
|yes=13,334,607
|no=2,198,715
|invalid=273,166
|electorate=50,681,765
|outcome=Proposal failed as voter turnout was below 50%
|image=Italian referendum april 2016.png
|image_width=200
|caption=Ballot paper for [[postal voting]] by overseas voters.
|map=Risultato del referendum del 2016 nelle varie regioni italiane.png
|map_size=250
|map_caption=Result by [[Regions of Italy|region]].
}}

⚫
An abrogative referendum on [[petroleum|oil]] and [[natural gas]] [[Oil well|drilling]] was held in [[Italy]] on 17 April 2016.<ref>[http://www.ansa.it/english/news/world/2016/02/11/cabinet-sets-drilling-referendum-apr-17_43bb66e5-beba-41e6-b865-36cba72ee985.html Cabinet sets drilling referendum Apr 17] ANSA, 11 February 2016</ref> The referendum was on the proposed repealing of a law that allows gas and oil drilling concessions extracting [[hydrocarbons|hydrocarbon]] within 12 [[nautical miles]] of the Italian coast to be prolonged until the exhaustion of the useful life of the fields.

Although 86% voted in favour of repealing the law, the turnout of 31% was below the [[majority]] threshold required to validate the result.<ref>[http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/2dd20816-04eb-11e6-9b51-0fb5e65703ce.html#axzz46B5UHVdo Boost for Renzi as oil drilling poll fails] Financial Times, 17 April 2016</ref>


It was the first referendum requested by at least five [[Regional council (Italy)|Regional Councils]] in the history of the Italian Republic: all 66 previous referendum questions since 1974 were called after the collection of signatures.
It was the first referendum requested by at least five [[Regional council (Italy)|Regional Councils]] in the history of the Italian Republic: all 66 previous referendum questions since 1974 were called after the collection of signatures.
Line 12: Line 31:


===Off-shore production of hydrocarbons in Italy===
===Off-shore production of hydrocarbons in Italy===
[[File:EDISON21.jpg|200px|thumbnail|right|Oil platform "Vega" in the [[Mediterranean Sea]] off the coast of [[Pozzallo]], [[Province of Ragusa|Ragusa]] ([[Sicily]])]]
Within 12 miles, 9 concessions are authorized (with 39 platforms) and their permits have expired and they have asked for an extension: if the "yes" vote wins in the referendum, the 9 expired concessions can not be extended. During 2015 those installations extracted about 622 million [[cubic meter]]s of [[natural gas]] (equivalent to 9% of the national production and 1.1% of total consumption in 2014).
Within 12 miles, 9 concessions are authorized (with 39 platforms) and their permits have expired and they have asked for an extension: if the "yes" vote wins in the referendum, the 9 expired concessions can not be extended. During 2015 those installations extracted about 622 million [[cubic meter]]s of [[natural gas]] (equivalent to 9% of the national production and 1.1% of total consumption in 2014).


Under the 12 mile limit, there are 17 other concessions expiring between 2017 and 2027, which in 2015 extracted 1.21 billion cubic meters of gas (17.6% of national production and 2.1 % of national consumption in 2014) and 500,000 [[Tonne|tons]] of [[petroleum|oil]] (about 9.1% of national production and 0.8% of consumption in 2014). These concessions, in the event of a victory for 'yes' in the referendum, will not be extended after 2027.
Under the 12 mile limit, there are 17 other concessions expiring between 2017 and 2027, which in 2015 extracted 1.21 billion cubic meters of gas (17.6% of national production and 2.1% of national consumption in 2014) and 500,000 [[Tonne|tons]] of [[petroleum|oil]] (about 9.1% of national production and 0.8% of consumption in 2014). These concessions, in the event of a victory for 'yes' in the referendum, will not be extended after 2027.


{|class="wikitable sortable" style="width:60%; float:center;"
{|class="wikitable sortable"
|+Extraction of hydrocarbons in the offshore platforms located within 12 miles from the coast (2015)<ref name=entro12miglia>{{cite web|url=http://unmig.sviluppoeconomico.gov.it/unmig/strutturemarine/limite.asp?on=true|title=Elenco delle piattaforme marine e strutture assimilabili - entro 12 miglia|website=Ministero dello sviluppo economico|access-date=2016-03-15}}</ref>
|+Extraction of hydrocarbons in the offshore platforms located within 12 miles from the coast (2015)<ref name=entro12miglia>{{cite web|url=http://unmig.sviluppoeconomico.gov.it/unmig/strutturemarine/limite.asp?on=true|title=Elenco delle piattaforme marine e strutture assimilabili - entro 12 miglia|website=Ministero dello sviluppo economico|access-date=2016-03-15|archive-url=https://archive.today/20160317043814/http://unmig.sviluppoeconomico.gov.it/unmig/strutturemarine/limite.asp?on=true|archive-date=2016-03-17|url-status=dead}}</ref>
|-
|-
!Marine zone<br>(Region)!![[Natural gas]]<br>([[Cubic metre|m³]])!![[Natural gasoline]]<br>(kg)!![[Petroleum]]<br>(kg)
!Marine zone<br />(Region)!![[Natural gas]]<br />([[Cubic metre|m³]])!![[Natural gasoline]]<br />(kg)!![[Petroleum]]<br />(kg)
|-
|-
|A – [[Emilia-Romagna]]<ref group="A">Concessions: A.C 1.AG, A.C 2.AS, A.C 3.AS, A.C 4.AS, A.C 5.AV, A.C 8.ME, A.C 17.AG, A.C 21.AG, A.C 26.EA, A.C 27.EA, A.C 29.EA, A.C 30.EA and CERVIA MARE.</ref>
|A – [[Emilia-Romagna]]<ref group="A">Concessions: A.C 1.AG, A.C 2.AS, A.C 3.AS, A.C 4.AS, A.C 5.AV, A.C 8.ME, A.C 17.AG, A.C 21.AG, A.C 26.EA, A.C 27.EA, A.C 29.EA, A.C 30.EA and CERVIA MARE.</ref>
Line 48: Line 66:
|-
|-
|''Production percentage of the national consumption''
|''Production percentage of the national consumption''
|style="text-align: right;"| ''2,27%''
|style="text-align: right;"| ''2.27%''
|style="text-align: center;" colspan="2"| ''0,91%''
|style="text-align: center;" colspan="2"| ''0.91%''
|-
|-
|National consumption (2015)
|National consumption (2015)
|style="text-align: right;"| {{formatnum:~66900000000}}<ref name=":1">{{cite news|url=http://www.qualenergia.it/articoli/20160112-i-consumi-di-gas-italia-tornano-crescere-dopo-4-anni|title=I consumi di gas in Italia tornano a crescere dopo 4 anni|date=2016-01-12|website=Qualenergia}}</ref>
|style="text-align: right;"| ~{{formatnum:66900000000}}<ref name=":1">{{cite news|url=http://www.qualenergia.it/articoli/20160112-i-consumi-di-gas-italia-tornano-crescere-dopo-4-anni|title=I consumi di gas in Italia tornano a crescere dopo 4 anni|date=2016-01-12|website=Qualenergia}}</ref>
| style="text-align: center;" colspan="2"|{{formatnum:59809999998}}<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.unionepetrolifera.it/?page_id=471|title=Consumi petroliferi mensili 2015|website=[[Unione petrolifera]]|date=2016-03-09|access-date=2016-03-18}}</ref>
| style="text-align: center;" colspan="2"|{{formatnum:59809999998}}<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.unionepetrolifera.it/?page_id=471|title=Consumi petroliferi mensili 2015|website=[[Unione petrolifera]]|date=2016-03-09|access-date=2016-03-18}}</ref>
|-
|-
|}
|}


==Referendum initiative==
==Referendum initiative==
The referendum was proposed by several [[Regions of Italy|regional governments]] after the national government passed a law allowing drilling concessions to last until oilfields or gasfields are empty.<ref name=R>[http://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-italy-drilling-referendum-idUKKCN0UX2K4 Italy's constitutional court gives green light to referendum on drilling] Reuters, 19 January 2016</ref> On 19 January 2016 the [[Constitutional Court of Italy|Constitutional Court]] approved the referendum.<ref name=R/> On 12 February the [[Five Star Movement]] asked President [[Sergio Mattarella]] to delay the referendum until June to allow it to be held alongside [[Italian local elections, 2016|local elections]] in order to raise turnout and save money.<ref>http://www.ansa.it/english/news/politics/2016/02/12/m5s-appeals-to-mattarella-on-drilling_61b9440e-2ee3-4d5c-88ec-1e41469d273a.html</ref>
The referendum was proposed by several [[Regions of Italy|regional governments]] after the national government passed a law allowing drilling concessions to last until oilfields or gasfields are empty.<ref name=R>[https://web.archive.org/web/20160207041127/http://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-italy-drilling-referendum-idUKKCN0UX2K4 Italy's constitutional court gives green light to referendum on drilling] Reuters, 19 January 2016</ref> On 19 January 2016 the [[Constitutional Court of Italy|Constitutional Court]] approved the referendum.<ref name=R/> On 12 February the [[Five Star Movement]] asked President [[Sergio Mattarella]] to delay the referendum until June to allow it to be held alongside [[2016 Italian local elections|local elections]] in order to raise turnout and save money.<ref>[http://www.ansa.it/english/news/politics/2016/02/12/m5s-appeals-to-mattarella-on-drilling_61b9440e-2ee3-4d5c-88ec-1e41469d273a.html M5S appeals to Mattarella on drilling] ANSA, 12 February 2016</ref>


==Position of main political parties==
==Position of main political parties==
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
!width=5% |Choice
!Choice
!width=13% |Parties
!Parties
!width=3% |Leaders
!Leaders
|-
|-
! rowspan=8|{{tick|15}} Yes
! rowspan=8|{{tick|15}} Yes
Line 86: Line 104:
|-
|-
| [[Federation of the Greens]] (''Federazione dei Verdi'', FdV)
| [[Federation of the Greens]] (''Federazione dei Verdi'', FdV)
| Giobbe Covatta
| [[Giobbe Covatta]]
|-
|-
| [[Possible (Italy)|Possible]] (''Possibile'')
| [[Possible (Italy)|Possible]] (''Possibile'')
Line 117: Line 135:
! style="width:110px;" rowspan="2"| Date
! style="width:110px;" rowspan="2"| Date
! style="width:120px;" rowspan="2"| Polling firm
! style="width:120px;" rowspan="2"| Polling firm
! style="width:35px;"| {{tick|12}}<br>Yes
! style="width:35px;"| {{tick|12}}<br />Yes
! style="width:35px;"| {{cross|12}}<br>No
! style="width:35px;"| {{cross|12}}<br />No
! style="width:25px;" rowspan="2"| Lead
! style="width:25px;" rowspan="2"| Lead
|-
|-
Line 150: Line 168:


==Results==
==Results==
{{Referendum results
{| class=wikitable style=text-align:right
|for=13334607
!Choice
|against=2198715
!Votes
|invalid=273166
!%
|electorate=50681765
|-
|source={{URL|1=http://elezionistorico.interno.it/index.php?tpel=F&dtel=17/04/2016&tpa=Y&tpe=A&lev0=0&levsut0=0&es0=N&ms=S|2=Ministry of the Interior}}
|align=left|{{tick|15px}} '''Yes'''||'''13,334,764'''||'''85.8'''
}}
|-

|align=left|{{cross|15px}} No||2,198,805||14.2
{{Bar box
|-
|title=Votes as a percentage of the electorate
|align=left|Invalid/blank votes||273,219||–
|titlebar=#ddd
|-
|width=500px
|align=left|'''Total'''||'''15,806,788'''||'''100'''
|barwidth=450px
|-
|bars=
|align=left|Registered voters/turnout||50,675,406||31.2
{{Bar percent|{{tick|12}} Yes|#088A29|26.31}}
|-
{{Bar percent|{{cross|12}} No|#E90000|4.34}}
|align=left colspan=3|Source: [http://elezioni.interno.it/referendum/scrutini/20160417/FX01000.htm Ministry of the Interior]
|}
}}


==Notes==
==Notes==
Line 176: Line 194:
{{Italian elections}}
{{Italian elections}}


[[Category:2016 in Italy]]
[[Category:2016 elections in Italy|Oil]]
[[Category:2016 referendums]]
[[Category:2016 referendums|Italy]]
[[Category:Referendums in Italy|2016]]
[[Category:Referendums in Italy]]
[[Category:Energy in Italy]]
[[Category:Oil wells]]
[[Category:Oil wells]]
[[Category:Energy policy referendums]]
[[Category:April 2016 events in Italy|Oil]]

Latest revision as of 17:44, 12 September 2024

2016 Italian oil drilling referendum
17 April 2016
Do you want to repeal the Article 6, Paragraph 17, Third Sentence, of the legislative decree 3 April 2006, no. 152, "Environmental regulations", as replaced by paragraph 239 of Article 1 of the law of 28 December 2015, no. 208, "Provisions for the formation of the annual and long-term state budget (stability law 2016)", limited to the following words: "for the useful life of the reservoir, in compliance with safety and environmental protection standards"?
Ballot paper for postal voting by overseas voters.
OutcomeProposal failed as voter turnout was below 50%
Results
Choice
 Votes %
Yes 13,334,607 85.85%
No 2,198,715 14.15%
Valid votes 15,533,322 98.27%
Invalid or blank votes 273,166 1.73%
Total votes 15,806,488 100.00%
Registered voters/turnout 50,681,765 31.19%
Result by region.

An abrogative referendum on oil and natural gas drilling was held in Italy on 17 April 2016.[1] The referendum was on the proposed repealing of a law that allows gas and oil drilling concessions extracting hydrocarbon within 12 nautical miles of the Italian coast to be prolonged until the exhaustion of the useful life of the fields.

Although 86% voted in favour of repealing the law, the turnout of 31% was below the majority threshold required to validate the result.[2]

It was the first referendum requested by at least five Regional Councils in the history of the Italian Republic: all 66 previous referendum questions since 1974 were called after the collection of signatures.

Background

[edit]
Gas platform "Annamaria B" in the Adriatic Sea off the coast of Ravenna (Emilia-Romagna)

The search for hydrocarbon liquids and/or gases in the Italian sea is possible - with some restrictions for the coastal and environmental protection - only in certain "marine areas" identified by the Italian Parliament or by the Ministry of Economic Development. From 2013, new drilling is prohibited in the Tyrrhenian Sea, in the marine protected areas and in the waters within 12 nautical miles from the coast; however, the concessions approved before 2013 may continue until all of the resources are extracted.

Italy authorized a total of 79 offshore platforms: 31 are located over 12 miles from and 48 within 12 miles.

Off-shore production of hydrocarbons in Italy

[edit]

Within 12 miles, 9 concessions are authorized (with 39 platforms) and their permits have expired and they have asked for an extension: if the "yes" vote wins in the referendum, the 9 expired concessions can not be extended. During 2015 those installations extracted about 622 million cubic meters of natural gas (equivalent to 9% of the national production and 1.1% of total consumption in 2014).

Under the 12 mile limit, there are 17 other concessions expiring between 2017 and 2027, which in 2015 extracted 1.21 billion cubic meters of gas (17.6% of national production and 2.1% of national consumption in 2014) and 500,000 tons of oil (about 9.1% of national production and 0.8% of consumption in 2014). These concessions, in the event of a victory for 'yes' in the referendum, will not be extended after 2027.

Extraction of hydrocarbons in the offshore platforms located within 12 miles from the coast (2015)[3]
Marine zone
(Region)		 Natural gas
(m³)		 Natural gasoline
(kg)		 Petroleum
(kg)
A – Emilia-Romagna[A 1] 935,758,382 140,487 0
B – Marche and Abruzzo[A 2] 54,004,511 436,237 295,826,731
C – Sicily[A 3] 4,625,021 0 247,054,152
D – Calabria[A 4] 622,667,455 0 0
Total production within 12 nautical miles (2015)[3] 1,518,932,151 576,724 542,880,883
Production percentage of the national consumption 2.27% 0.91%
National consumption (2015) ~66,900,000,000[4] 59,809,999,998[5]

Referendum initiative

[edit]

The referendum was proposed by several regional governments after the national government passed a law allowing drilling concessions to last until oilfields or gasfields are empty.[6] On 19 January 2016 the Constitutional Court approved the referendum.[6] On 12 February the Five Star Movement asked President Sergio Mattarella to delay the referendum until June to allow it to be held alongside local elections in order to raise turnout and save money.[7]

Position of main political parties

[edit]
Choice Parties Leaders
checkY Yes Five Star Movement (Movimento Cinque Stelle, M5S) Beppe Grillo
Forward Italy (Forza Italia, FI) Silvio Berlusconi
Northern League (Lega Nord, LN) Matteo Salvini
Italian Left (Sinistra Italiana, SI) TBD
Brothers of Italy (Fratelli d'Italia, FdI) Giorgia Meloni
Italy of Values (Italia dei Valori, IdV) Ignazio Messina
Federation of the Greens (Federazione dei Verdi, FdV) Giobbe Covatta
Possible (Possibile) Giuseppe Civati
☒N No Movement for Autonomies (Movimento per le Autonomie, MpA) Raffaele Lombardo
The Megaphone (Il Megafono) Rosario Crocetta
Abstention Democratic Party (Partito Democratico, PD) Matteo Renzi
New Centre-Right (Nuovo Centrodestra, NCD) Angelino Alfano
Civic Choice (Scelta Civica, SC) Enrico Zanetti
Union of the Centre (Unione di Centro, UdC) Pierferdinando Casini

Opinion polls

[edit]
Date Polling firm checkY
Yes 		☒N
No 		Lead
28 Mar 2016 Piepoli 82.3 17.7 64.6
22 Mar 2016 Demopolis 74.0 26.0 48.0
15-16 Feb 2016 SWG 78.0 22.0 56.0
9-11 Dec 2015 Ixè 72.3 27.7 44.6

Results

[edit]
ChoiceVotes%
For13,334,60785.85
Against2,198,71514.15
Total15,533,322100.00
Valid votes15,533,32298.27
Invalid/blank votes273,1661.73
Total votes15,806,488100.00
Registered voters/turnout50,681,76531.19
Source: Ministry of the Interior
Votes as a percentage of the electorate
checkY Yes
 
 26.31%
☒N No
 
 4.34%

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ Concessions: A.C 1.AG, A.C 2.AS, A.C 3.AS, A.C 4.AS, A.C 5.AV, A.C 8.ME, A.C 17.AG, A.C 21.AG, A.C 26.EA, A.C 27.EA, A.C 29.EA, A.C 30.EA and CERVIA MARE.
  2. ^ Concessions: B.C 1.LF, B.C 3.AS, B.C 5.AS, B.C 7.LF and B.C 8.LF.
  3. ^ Concessions: C.C 1.AG, C.C 3.AG and C.C 6.AG.
  4. ^ Concessions: D.C 1.AG and D.C 4.AG.

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Cabinet sets drilling referendum Apr 17 ANSA, 11 February 2016
  2. ^ Boost for Renzi as oil drilling poll fails Financial Times, 17 April 2016
  3. ^ a b "Elenco delle piattaforme marine e strutture assimilabili - entro 12 miglia". Ministero dello sviluppo economico. Archived from the original on 2016-03-17. Retrieved 2016-03-15.
  4. ^ "I consumi di gas in Italia tornano a crescere dopo 4 anni". Qualenergia. 2016-01-12.
  5. ^ "Consumi petroliferi mensili 2015". Unione petrolifera. 2016-03-09. Retrieved 2016-03-18.
  6. ^ a b Italy's constitutional court gives green light to referendum on drilling Reuters, 19 January 2016
  7. ^ M5S appeals to Mattarella on drilling ANSA, 12 February 2016
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=2016_Italian_oil_drilling_referendum&oldid=1245378072"