Elterngeld: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
→External links: fix |
No edit summary Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit Advanced mobile edit |
||
| (40 intermediate revisions by 23 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Short description|European state child support scheme}} |
|||
| ⚫ | '''Elterngeld''' (translated literally from |
||
{{Use dmy dates|date=October 2020}} |
|||
{{title language|de}} |
|||
{{Verification|date=August 2024}} |
|||
| ⚫ | '''{{lang|de|Elterngeld}}''' ({{IPA|de|ˈɛltɐnˌɡɛlt|lang|De-Elterngeld.ogg}}; translated literally from German as "parents' money") is a tax-financed payment for [[wikt:couple|couples]] which pays an amount of money to support the costs of bringing up a child. Modern {{lang|de|Elterngeld}} schemes originated in Germany and have been adopted in France and across [[Scandinavia]]. |
||
It generally does not provide full support of the costs of bringing up a child. It is only provided for a limited period, ranging from until one year after birth until 18 years of age in Norway. The amount of Elterngeld granted depends in some places on the income of the parents. |
It generally does not provide full support of the costs of bringing up a child. It is only provided for a limited period, ranging from until one year after birth until 18 years of age in Norway. The amount of {{lang|de|Elterngeld}} granted depends in some places on the income of the parents. |
||
==Need for== |
==Need for== |
||
The need for Elterngeld schemes is illustrated by the declining birth rates in Western European countries. For instance, in Germany the present birth rate is 1.3 children per woman, which is below what is calculated at the economically stable rate of 2.1 children per woman. |
The need for {{lang|de|Elterngeld}} schemes is illustrated by the declining birth rates in Western European countries. For instance, in Germany the present birth rate is 1.3 children per woman, which is below what is calculated at the economically stable rate of 2.1 children per woman. Twenty-five European Union states currently have birth rates below this level. The issues behind the declining birth rate include the higher costs of maintaining a child, and the greater dependence within the household budget economically on women. |
||
==Criticism== |
==Criticism== |
||
Elterngeld is effectively a third state-level subsidy for some |
{{lang|de|Elterngeld}} is effectively a third state-level subsidy for some parents—on top of maternity allowance and state income benefits. Economists argue that this has created a complex and costly system of state benefit which could be simplified and reduced in expenses. |
||
Economists and critics also argue that the allowance creates shifting birth patterns. In December 2006, media reports suggested that German parents were seeking ways to delay the births of their children until |
Economists and critics also argue that the allowance creates shifting birth patterns. In December 2006, media reports suggested that German parents were seeking ways to delay the births of their children until 1 January 2007, so that they would gain access to {{lang|de|Elterngeld}} of up to 25,200 euros (two thirds of their former salary for up to a year), up from 7,200 euros per annum.<ref name="news.bbc.co.uk">[http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/6211737.stm BBC NEWS | World | Europe | Pregnant Germans seek cash bonus<!-- Bot generated title -->]</ref> |
||
==Countries== |
==Countries== |
||
* |
*Germany – up to 25,200 euros for up to 14 months (two thirds of their former salary with a minimum at 300 euros and a cap at 1,800 euros per month, each parent can receive the payment for a maximum of 12 months) from 1 January 2007 on<ref name="news.bbc.co.uk"/> See more: [[Elterngeld (Germany)]] |
||
* |
*France – an allowance of 750 euros per month for one year from September 2005.{{Citation needed|reason=where is this number from?|date=February 2017}} The money is focused on existing parents producing more children than on first-time parents, with present discussion around allowances for third children. This has meant a higher birth rate at lower cost to the state than in other countries. The French government's goal is to raise the birth rate from 1.9 children per woman to at least 2.1 children per woman |
||
*[[Sweden]] |
*[[Sweden]] – up to one year at 80 percent wage-level compensation.{{Citation needed|date=February 2017}} Further four months can an overall basic amount be paid. Additionally the parents may shorten their work time without wage adjustment over up to two hours daily, until the child is eight years old. The increase of the birth rate in Sweden is attributed to this practice. Most other Scandinavian countries follow similar percentage level of salary Elterngeld payment levels{{Citation needed|date=February 2017}} |
||
*[[Norway]] |
*[[Norway]] – up to two years at 80 percent wage-level compensation, or alternatively for 42 weeks at 100 percent (this is for maternity leave, not monthly payment until age of 18){{Citation needed|date=February 2017}} |
||
*[[Finland]] |
*[[Finland]] – parents' money is paid for nine months{{Citation needed|date=February 2017}} |
||
*[[Denmark]] |
*[[Denmark]] – for at least six months{{Citation needed|date=February 2017}} |
||
==Elterngeld and gender== |
=={{lang|de|Elterngeld}} and gender== |
||
Several proposals have been offered to use {{lang|de|Elterngeld}}-style payments to combat the effects of [[sex-selective abortion]] in Asia. |
|||
Several proposals have been offered to use elterngeld-style payments to combat the effects of [[sex-selective abortion]] in Asia. As population ethicist [[Jacob Appel]] of Brown University has argued: {{quote|''By distributing cash to those couples who have girls—possibly in annual increments, to ensure that girls are not simply born and abandoned—nations can counterbalance the financial impetus that drives a preference for boys. As a result, some women may turn away from aborting girls. At the same time, other women who might have had no initial preference between genders will choose to have girls in the hope of reaping the pecuniary advantages. In the end, a perfect balance can be achieved—with the cash incentive set at precisely the correct rate to ensure global gender parity. Needless to say, if female babies are worth their weight in rupees and yuan, economic and educational opportunities may soon follow. Since such funds will inevitably arise from public revenues, one might also view such “girl-subsidies” as taxes on boys, equally true but far less marketable.''<ref>Appel, Jacob M.[http://www.opposingviews.com/articles/opinion-want-a-daughter-try-paying-for-her Want a Daughter? Try Paying for Her], August 26, 2009</ref>}} |
|||
==References== |
==References== |
||
| Line 27: | Line 31: | ||
==External links== |
==External links== |
||
*[ |
*[https://familienportal.de/familienportal/familienleistungen/elterngeld German government information page on Elterngeld] |
||
*[http://www.elterngeldrechner.de/ Elterngeld calculator for German citizens] |
*[http://www.elterngeldrechner.de/ Elterngeld calculator for German citizens] |
||
*[http://www.norwegen.or.at/policy/family/benefits/benefits.htm Elterngeld scheme information for Norwegian parents] |
*[http://www.norwegen.or.at/policy/family/benefits/benefits.htm Elterngeld scheme information for Norwegian parents] |
||
*[http://www.sfi.dk/Default.aspx?ID=3172 International Network on Leave Policy and Research] |
*[http://www.sfi.dk/Default.aspx?ID=3172 International Network on Leave Policy and Research] |
||
[[Category: |
[[Category:Government aid programs]] |
||
[[Category: |
[[Category:Society of Germany]] |
||
[[Category: |
[[Category:Culture of Europe]] |
||
[[Category:Economy of Sweden]] |
|||
[[Category:Economy of Denmark]] |
|||
[[Category:Economy of Finland]] |
|||
[[Category:Public finance of Norway]] |
|||
[[de:Elterngeld]] |
|||
[[fr:Politique familiale française]] |
|||
[[no:Foreldrepenger]] |
|||
[[sv:Föräldraledighet]] |
|||
[[nl:Ouderschapsverlof]] |
|||
Latest revision as of 14:55, 28 October 2024
 | This article needs additional citations for verification. (August 2024) |
Elterngeld (German: [ˈɛltɐnˌɡɛlt] ⓘ; translated literally from German as "parents' money") is a tax-financed payment for couples which pays an amount of money to support the costs of bringing up a child. Modern Elterngeld schemes originated in Germany and have been adopted in France and across Scandinavia.
It generally does not provide full support of the costs of bringing up a child. It is only provided for a limited period, ranging from until one year after birth until 18 years of age in Norway. The amount of Elterngeld granted depends in some places on the income of the parents.
Need for
[edit]The need for Elterngeld schemes is illustrated by the declining birth rates in Western European countries. For instance, in Germany the present birth rate is 1.3 children per woman, which is below what is calculated at the economically stable rate of 2.1 children per woman. Twenty-five European Union states currently have birth rates below this level. The issues behind the declining birth rate include the higher costs of maintaining a child, and the greater dependence within the household budget economically on women.
Criticism
[edit]Elterngeld is effectively a third state-level subsidy for some parents—on top of maternity allowance and state income benefits. Economists argue that this has created a complex and costly system of state benefit which could be simplified and reduced in expenses.
Economists and critics also argue that the allowance creates shifting birth patterns. In December 2006, media reports suggested that German parents were seeking ways to delay the births of their children until 1 January 2007, so that they would gain access to Elterngeld of up to 25,200 euros (two thirds of their former salary for up to a year), up from 7,200 euros per annum.[1]
Countries
[edit]- Germany – up to 25,200 euros for up to 14 months (two thirds of their former salary with a minimum at 300 euros and a cap at 1,800 euros per month, each parent can receive the payment for a maximum of 12 months) from 1 January 2007 on[1] See more: Elterngeld (Germany)
- France – an allowance of 750 euros per month for one year from September 2005.[citation needed] The money is focused on existing parents producing more children than on first-time parents, with present discussion around allowances for third children. This has meant a higher birth rate at lower cost to the state than in other countries. The French government's goal is to raise the birth rate from 1.9 children per woman to at least 2.1 children per woman
- Sweden – up to one year at 80 percent wage-level compensation.[citation needed] Further four months can an overall basic amount be paid. Additionally the parents may shorten their work time without wage adjustment over up to two hours daily, until the child is eight years old. The increase of the birth rate in Sweden is attributed to this practice. Most other Scandinavian countries follow similar percentage level of salary Elterngeld payment levels[citation needed]
- Norway – up to two years at 80 percent wage-level compensation, or alternatively for 42 weeks at 100 percent (this is for maternity leave, not monthly payment until age of 18)[citation needed]
- Finland – parents' money is paid for nine months[citation needed]
- Denmark – for at least six months[citation needed]
Elterngeld and gender
[edit]Several proposals have been offered to use Elterngeld-style payments to combat the effects of sex-selective abortion in Asia.