1997 Canadian federal election: Difference between revisions

1997 Canadian federal election
← outgoing members elected members →
301 seats in the House of Commons; 151 seats needed for a majority
	Opinion polls
Turnout	67.0% (3.9pp)
	The Canadian parliament after the 1997 election
Prime Minister before election; Jean Chrétien; Liberal	Prime Minister after election ; Jean Chrétien; Liberal

Browse history interactively

← Previous edit

Content deleted Content added

VisualWikitext

Inline

Latest revision as of 18:09, 30 October 2024

The 1997 Canadian federal election was held on June 2, 1997, to elect members to the House of Commons of the 36th Parliament of Canada. Prime Minister Jean Chrétien's Liberal Party won a second majority government. The Reform Party replaced the Bloc Québécois as the Official Opposition.

The election results closely followed the pattern of the 1993 election. The Liberals swept Ontario, while the Bloc won a majority in Quebec. Reform made sufficient gains in the West to allow Preston Manning to become leader of the Official Opposition, but lost its only seat east of Manitoba. The most significant change was major gains in Atlantic Canada by the New Democratic Party (NDP) and the rump Progressive Conservative Party. The Liberal victory was not in doubt, though some commentators on election night were predicting that the party would be cut down to a minority government and that Chrétien might lose his seat. Chrétien narrowly won his riding, and the Liberals maintained a nine-seat majority thanks to gains in Quebec at the expense of the Bloc. Jean Charest's Tories and Alexa McDonough's NDP both regained official party status in the House of Commons.

This was the first time that five political parties held official party status in a single session of Canada's Parliament, and the only time to date that five different parties have won the popular vote in at least one of the provinces and territories of Canada.

Background

Prime Minister Jean Chrétien announced his approved request by Governor General Roméo LeBlanc to dissolve Parliament on April 26, 1997, with an election to be held on June 2 of that year. Chrétien's election call came three years and five months into Parliament's life, short of both the maximum five year duration and the typical four years between elections. This represented the earliest election call in a majority Parliament since the 1911 election.^[1] Opinion polls at the time predicted that the Liberal Party was expected to win a landslide victory capturing at least 180 to 220 of the 301 seats in the House of Commons, with the fragmentation of the opposition meaning that one party was not expected to be able to defeat the government.^[1]

The election call was controversial both for being early and for occurring during Manitoba's recovery from the Red River Flood earlier in the year. Reg Alcock and several others inside the Liberal Party had opposed the timing of the vote, and the poor results prompted Paul Martin's supporters to organize against Chrétien.

The election was the first to be held with staggered polling hours across the country. Until 1993, polling hours were 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. in each time zone, with a 4.5-hour difference between closing of polls in Newfoundland and those in British Columbia and Yukon, or a three-hour difference between Quebec-Ontario and B.C.-Yukon. With the new staggered hours, it would be three hours between Newfoundland and B.C.-Yukon, but just 30 minutes between Quebec-Ontario and B.C.-Yukon.

Political Parties

Liberal Party

The Liberal Party under Jean Chrétien campaigned on promising to continue to cut the federal deficit to allow for a budget surplus, and then to spend one half of the surplus on repaying Canada's national debt and cutting taxes while the other half of the surplus would be used to increase funding to health care, assistance for Canadian children in poverty, and job creation.^[2] The platform was called Securing Our Future Together.^[3] The Liberal Party was attacked by the opposition parties for failing to keep many of the promises that the party campaigned on in the 1993 federal election.^[4] The Liberals attacked the Progressive Conservatives and the Reform Party for prematurely calling for tax cuts while a deficit still remained while attacking the New Democratic Party for proposing to increase government spending while Canada faced a deficit.^[4]

The Liberals suffered from a number of gaffes in their campaign. In one incident, when Jean Chrétien was questioned by reporters over the cost of the Liberals' election proposal of a national pharmacare program, reporters claimed that Chrétien was unsure of what the cost would be.^[4] Chrétien also turned down invitations for interviews by Canada's national media outlets, the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) and MuchMusic.^[4] In the televised debates between the five major political parties, Chrétien apologized to Canadians for his government having cut funding for social programs to reduce the deficit.^[4]

On election day, the Liberals won with a significantly reduced majority. While they lost much of their support in Atlantic Canada, they won all but two seats in Ontario and improved on their numbers in Quebec. They were only assured of a majority when the final numbers came in from Western Canada.

Reform Party

The Reform Party under Preston Manning campaigned on preserving national unity through decentralization of multiple federal government powers to all of the provinces, cutting taxes, reducing the size of government, reducing spending, and strongly opposing distinct society status for Quebec. Feeling that the general acceptance of deficit reduction at the federal and provincial level had been encouraged by their party, Reform saw a chance to finally make the party a national in scope by making political inroads outside of the west, particularly in Ontario.^[5]^[6] Their platform was titled the Fresh Start for all Canadians.^[7] The Reformers ran a full slate of candidates in Quebec, making this the first and last election in which it would run candidates in every region of Canada.

Reform's campaign ran into multiple problems. The party was repeatedly accused by other parties and the media of holding intolerant views due to comments made by a number of Reform MPs during the writ period.^[5] Critics had accused the party's performance during the 1993–1997 parliament of being disorganized.^[4] Tension between the party's democratic nature and the leader-centric model of modern campaigning led to Manning's leadership abilities being questioned by a number of former members, including Stephen Harper, who accused Manning of inappropriately using a Can$31,000 personal expense allowance as leader.^[8] Some Reform supporters were frustrated by the party's decision to expand its political base into Quebec, as they continued to believe that the party should represent English-speaking Canada, and others from the right-wing and populist faction of the party were angry that Manning punished MPs Bob Ringma and David Chatters for outbursts.^[9] During the campaign the Reform Party released a controversial television advertisement where the faces of four Quebecers, Prime Minister Jean Chrétien, Bloc Québécois leader Gilles Duceppe, Progressive Conservative leader Jean Charest, and Premier of Quebec Lucien Bouchard, were crossed out, followed by a message saying that Quebec politicians had dominated the federal government for too long and that the Reform Party would end this favoritism towards Quebec.^[10] The advertisement was harshly criticized by the other party leaders including accusations that Manning was "intolerant" and a "bigot" for having permitted the advertisement to be aired.^[10]

Reform began the campaign with Can$1.5 million in cash on hand, and had raised a total of Can$8 million. In contrast to the other parties, the vast majority of the money came from donations by individuals or small businesses.^[11]

The results for Reform were a generally considered a minor tactical success. The party won 60 seats to displace the Bloc as Official Opposition, largely by building on its already heavy concentration of support in Western Canada. Strategically, Reform failed to make inroads into eastern Canada and lost its one seat in Ontario, leaving it effectively perceived as a Western regional party, despite making their first significant inroads into rural Ontario.

Bloc Québécois

The Bloc Québécois, under the leadership of Gilles Duceppe, lost its position of Official Opposition, falling to third place. The party's founding leader, Lucien Bouchard, had resigned in the aftermath of the 1995 Quebec referendum in order to become Premier of Quebec. Bouchard had been replaced by Michel Gauthier, but a lack of direction and party infighting caused their poll numbers to plummet, leaving them in danger of being overhauled by both the Liberals and the resurgent Progressive Conservatives. Duceppe, who took over as leader after Gauthier resigned, nonetheless made progress by emphasizing the lack of possibility of constitutional reform. While the party only finished 1.2 percentage points ahead of the Liberals in the province's popular vote, a more efficiently-distributed vote (the Liberal vote was too concentrated in and around Montreal; elsewhere, they split the vote with the Progressive Conservatives) still allowed them capture a comfortable majority of 44 out of Quebec's 75 seats.

New Democratic Party

The New Democratic Party under the leadership of Alexa McDonough regained official party status that the party lost in the 1993 Canadian federal election. The party won the fourth largest share of total votes and won 21 seats. Notably, the party made a substantial showing in Atlantic Canada, a region where it had only elected three MPs in its entire history prior to the election.

Progressive Conservative Party

The Progressive Conservative Party under Jean Charest campaigned on securing national unity in Canada by recognizing Quebec as being a distinct society within Canada, along with the proposal of a "New Covenant" for Canadian confederation to be negotiated between the Federal and Provincial governments.^[12] The party's platform included the novelty of being publicly distributed on CD-ROM. Charest and the PCs benefited from rapidly rising in popularity amongst all language groups in Quebec, where voters were found to have preferred Charest over Gilles Duceppe, the leader of the Bloc Québécois.^[13]

The Progressive Conservatives faced multiple difficulties, as the party was not able to apply for federal financial assistance due to it not being an official party. The party's results in their previous bastion of Western Canada remained anemic, and the Reformers remained the dominant conservative political force in the west. Reform also made inroads into rural central and southern Ontario — traditionally the heartland of the Tories' provincial counterparts.

The Progressive Conservatives won the third largest number of the total votes and improved their situation in the House of Commons, regaining official party status after winning 20 seats. Despite finishing about half a point behind Reform in the nationwide popular vote, their only heavy concentrations of support were in Atlantic Canada and Quebec. Elsewhere, like in 1993, their support was too spread out to translate into victories in individual ridings. They only won one seat each in Ontario and Manitoba, and none west of Manitoba. The result, a disappointment for Charest, would lead to his resignation and eventual assumption of leadership of the Liberal Party of Quebec.

Green Party

Support for the Green Party of Canada was 79% higher than at the previous election, with its greatest success in British Columbia, where it received 2% of the vote. The Green Party remained almost entirely off the national media's radar. At 0.43% of the vote, and 1.64% of the vote in the ridings it contested, the Green Party remained a small but growing movement.

Results

Summary of the 1997 House of Commons of Canada election results
Party		Party Leader	Candidates	Seats				Popular vote
Party		Party Leader	Candidates	1993	Dissol.	Elected	% Change	#	%	Change
	Liberal	Jean Chrétien	301	177	174	155	-12.4%	4,994,277	38.46%	-2.78pp
	Reform	Preston Manning	227	52	50	60	+15.4%	2,513,080	19.35%	+0.66pp
	Bloc Québécois	Gilles Duceppe	75	54	50	44	-18.5%	1,385,821	10.67%	-2.85pp
	New Democratic	Alexa McDonough	301	9	9	21	+133.3%	1,434,509	11.05%	+4.17pp
	Progressive Conservative	Jean Charest	301	2	2	20	+900%	2,446,705	18.84%	+2.80pp
	Independent and No Affiliation		76	1	6	1		60,759	0.47%	-0.09pp
	Green	Joan Russow	79	-	-	-	-	55,583	0.43%	+0.18pp
	Natural Law	Neil Paterson	136	-	-	-	-	37,085	0.29%	+x
	Christian Heritage	Ron Gray	53	-	-	-	-	29,085	0.22%	+x
	Canadian Action	Paul T. Hellyer	58	*	-	-	*	17,502	0.13%	*
	Marxist–Leninist	Hardial Bains	65	-	-	-	-	11,468	0.09%	+0.05pp
	Vacant				4
Total			1,672	295	295	301	+2.0%	12,985,874	100%
Sources: http://www.elections.ca History of Federal Ridings since 1867

Notes:

*: Party did not nominate candidates in the previous election.

x: Less than 0.005% of the popular vote

Vote and seat summaries

Popular vote

Liberal			38.46%
Reform			19.35%
PC			18.84%
NDP			11.05%
Bloc Québécois			10.67%
Green			0.43%
Others			1.20%

Seat totals

Liberal			51.50%
Reform			19.93%
Bloc Québécois			14.62%
NDP			6.98%
PC			6.64%
Independents			0.33%

Results by province

Party Name			BC	AB	SK	MB	ON	QC	NB	NS	PE	NL	NT	YK	Total
	Liberal	Seats:	6	2	1	6	101	26	3		4	4	2		155
	Liberal	Popular vote:	28.8	24.0	24.7	34.3	49.5	36.7	32.9	28.4	44.8	37.9	43.1	22.0	38.5
	Reform	Seats:	25	24	8	3									60
	Reform	Vote:	43.1	54.6	36.0	23.7	19.1	0.3	13.1	9.7	1.5	2.5	11.7	25.3	19.4
	Bloc Québécois	Seats:						44							44
	Bloc Québécois	Vote:						37.9							10.7
	New Democrats	Seats:	3		5	4			2	6				1	21
	New Democrats	Vote:	18.2	5.7	30.9	23.2	10.7	2.0	18.4	30.4	15.1	22.0	20.9	28.9	11.0
	Progressive Conservative	Seats:				1	1	5	5	5		3			20
	Progressive Conservative	Vote:	6.2	14.4	7.8	17.8	18.8	22.2	35.0	30.8	38.3	36.8	16.7	13.9	18.8
	Other	Seats:					1								1
	Other	Vote:	0.6	0.2	0.1	0.3	0.6	0.4		0.4		0.5	7.6	8.9	0.5
Total seats:			34	26	14	14	103	75	10	11	4	7	2	1	301
Parties that won no seats:
	Green	Vote:	2.0	0.4			0.4	0.1				0.2			0.4
	Natural Law	Vote:	0.3	0.3	0.2	0.1	0.2	0.3	0.6	0.4	0.1	0.2			0.3
	Christian Heritage	Vote:	0.4	0.1		0.4	0.4				0.2			1.0	0.2
	Canadian Action	Vote:			0.3		0.2								0.1
	Marxist–Leninist	Vote:	0.1			0.2	0.1	0.1							0.1

Source: Elections Canada

Notes

Number of parties: 10
- First appearance: Canadian Action Party
- Final appearance: Reform Party of Canada
- Final appearance before hiatus: Christian Heritage Party of Canada (returned in 2004)
1997 was one of only three elections in Canadian history (the others were 1993 and 2008) where the official Opposition did not have the majority of the opposition's seats. 60 seats were held by the Reform Party, yet 86 seats for the other opposition parties and independents combined.
1997 was the only election to date in which five different parties won the popular vote in a province or territory (the Liberals won in Manitoba, Newfoundland and Labrador, the Northwest Territories, Ontario and Prince Edward Island; Reform in Alberta, British Columbia and Saskatchewan; the BQ in Quebec; the NDP in the Yukon Territory; and the PCs in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia). Consequently, it was also the last time the PCs won a province or territory.

10 closest ridings

Sackville—Eastern Shore, NS: Peter Stoffer, NDP def. Ken Streatch, PC by 41 votes
Bellechasse—Etchemins—Montmagny—L'Islet, QC: Gilbert Normand, Lib def. François Langlois, BQ by 47 votes
Selkirk—Interlake, MB: Howard Hilstrom, Ref def. Jon Gerrard, Lib by 66 votes
Cardigan, PE: Lawrence MacAulay, Lib def. Dan Hughes, PC by 99 votes
Bonaventure—Gaspé—Îles-de-la-Madeleine—Pabok, QC: Yvan Bernier, BQ def. Patrick Gagnon, Lib by 179 votes
Saskatoon—Humboldt, SK: Jim Pankiw, Ref def. Dennis Gruending, NDP by 220 votes
Humber—St. Barbe—Baie Verte, NF: Gerry Byrne, Lib def. Art Bull, PC by 232 votes
Chicoutimi, QC: André Harvey, PC def. Gilbert Fillion, BQ by 317 votes
Frontenac—Mégantic, QC: Jean-Guy Chrétien, BQ def. Manon Lecours, Lib by 465 votes
Simcoe—Grey, ON: Paul Bonwick, Lib def. Paul Shaw, Ref by 481 votes

References

^ ^a ^b "Chrétien sets Canadian election for June 2". CNN. Retrieved April 28, 2010.
^ Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). The Canadian General Election of 1997. Dundurn Press Ltd, 1998. Pp. 45.
^ Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 45.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 46.
^ ^a ^b Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 112.
^ Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 46 and 118
^ Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 118.
^ Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 112
^ Canadian Press. "Mr. George Hickes (Point Douglas), Member Statements". Government of Manitoba. Archived from the original on April 7, 2014. Retrieved October 8, 2008.
^ ^a ^b "Canada poised for vote that may deadlock parliament". CNN. Retrieved April 28, 2010.
^ Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 120.
^ Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 49.
^ Clarke, Harold D.; Kornberg, Allan;Wearing, Peter. A Polity on the Edge: Canada. Pp. 246.

^ Only contested seats in Quebec.

External links

[cnn.com-2] "Chrétien sets Canadian election for June 2". CNN. Retrieved April 28, 2010.

[3] Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). The Canadian General Election of 1997. Dundurn Press Ltd, 1998. Pp. 45.

[4] Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 45.

[Frizzell,_Alan_1998._Pp._46-5] ^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 46.

[Frizzell,_Alan_1998._Pp._112-6] Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 112.

[7] Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 46 and 118

[8] Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 118.

[9] Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 112

[10] Canadian Press. "Mr. George Hickes (Point Douglas), Member Statements". Government of Manitoba. Archived from the original on April 7, 2014. Retrieved October 8, 2008.

[2cnn.com-11] "Canada poised for vote that may deadlock parliament". CNN. Retrieved April 28, 2010.

[12] Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 120.

[13] Frizzell, Alan (ed.); Pammett, Jon H (ed.). 1998. Pp. 49.

[14] Clarke, Harold D.; Kornberg, Allan;Wearing, Peter. A Polity on the Edge: Canada. Pp. 246.

[1] Only contested seats in Quebec.

[i]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

v t e 1997 Canadian federal election
Outgoing: Liberal majority Result: Liberal majority
Bloc Québécois (Gilles Duceppe) Canadian Action (Paul Hellyer, candidates) Christian Heritage (Ron Gray, candidates) Green (Joan Russow, candidates) Independent candidates Liberal (Jean Chrétien, candidates) Marxist–Leninist (Hardial Bains, candidates) Natural Law (Neil Paterson, candidates) New Democrats (Alexa McDonough, candidates) Progressive Conservative (Jean Charest, candidates) Reform (Preston Manning, candidates) Rhinoceros (de-registered, candidates) Bold indicates parties with members elected to the House of Commons.
Results overview Results by riding Results by student MPs who stood down MPs who lost their seat Newspaper endorsements Other endorsements Opinion polling (by constituency) Star candidate Timeline

v t e Federal elections and referendums in Canada
General elections	1867 1872 1874 1878 1882 1887 1891 1896 1900 1904 1908 1911 1917 1921 1925 1926 1930 1935 1940 1945 1949 1953 1957 1958 1962 1963 1965 1968 1972 1974 1979 1980 1984 1988 1993 1997 2000 2004 2006 2008 2011 2015 2019 2021 2025
By-elections	1st (1867–1872) 2nd (1873–1874) 3rd (1874–1878) 4th (1879–1882) 5th (1883–1887) 6th (1887–1891) 7th (1891–1896) 8th (1896–1900) 9th (1901–1904) 10th (1905–1908) 11th (1909–1911) 12th (1911–1917) 13th (1918–1921) 14th (1921–1925) 15th (1926) 16th (1926–1930) 17th (1930–1935) 18th (1936–1940) 19th (1940–1945) 20th (1945–1949) 21st (1949–1953) 22nd (1953–1957) 23rd (1957–1958) 24th (1958–1962) 25th (1962–1963) 26th (1963–1965) 27th (1965–1968) 28th (1968–1972) 29th (1973–1974; no by-elections) 30th (1974–1979) 31st (1979) 32nd (1980–1984) 33rd (1984–1988) 34th (1988–1993) 35th (1994–1997) 36th (1997–2000) 37th (2000–2004) 38th (2004–2006) 39th (2006–2008) 40th (2008–2011) 41st (2011–2015) 42nd (2015–2019) 43rd (2019–2021) 44th (2021–present)
Referendums	1898 1942 1992
Federal political parties Federal electoral districts Historical federal electoral districts