Forced suicide: Difference between revisions
Curly Turkey (talk | contribs) |
|||
(35 intermediate revisions by 31 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{short description|Execution method in which the victim is forced or incentivised to kill themselves}} |
|||
{{Suicide sidebar}} |
{{Suicide sidebar}} |
||
'''Forced suicide''' is a method of [[execution]] where the victim is coerced into committing [[suicide]] to avoid facing an alternative option they perceive as much worse, such as suffering [[ |
'''Forced suicide''' is a method of [[execution]] where the victim is coerced into committing [[suicide]] to avoid facing an alternative option they perceive as much worse, such as [[Torture murder|being tortured to death]], suffering [[public humiliation]], or having friends or family members imprisoned, tortured or killed. |
||
== In ancient Greece and Rome == |
== In ancient Greece and Rome == |
||
[[File:David - The Death of Socrates.jpg|thumb|''[[The Death of Socrates]]'' by [[Jacques-Louis David]] (1787)]] |
|||
Forced suicide was a common means of execution in ancient [[Ancient Greece|Greece]] and [[Ancient Rome|Rome]]. As a mark of respect it was generally reserved for aristocrats sentenced to death; the victims would either drink [[Conium maculatum|hemlock]] or fall on their swords. Economic motivations prompted some suicides in ancient Rome. A person who was condemned to death would forfeit property to the government. People could evade that provision and let the property pass to their heirs by committing suicide prior to arrest. |
Forced suicide was a common means of execution in ancient [[Ancient Greece|Greece]] and [[Ancient Rome|Rome]]. As a mark of respect it was generally reserved for aristocrats sentenced to death; the victims would either drink [[Conium maculatum|hemlock]] or fall on their swords. Economic motivations prompted some suicides in ancient Rome. A person who was condemned to death would forfeit property to the government. People could evade that provision and let the property pass to their heirs by committing suicide prior to arrest. |
||
One of the most well-known forced suicides is that of the philosopher [[Socrates]], who drank [[Conium maculatum|hemlock]] after his trial for allegedly corrupting the youth of [[Athens]]. The [[Stoicism|Stoic]] philosopher [[Seneca the Younger|Seneca]] also killed himself in response to an order by his pupil, the [[Roman Emperor]] [[Nero]], who himself was forced to commit suicide at a later date. Other famous forced suicides include those of [[Brutus]], [[Mark Antony]], Emperor [[Otho]], and the Roman generals [[Publius Quinctilius Varus|Varus]] and [[Corbulo]]. |
|||
== In Asia == |
== In Asia == |
||
⚫ | The Hindu practice of [[Sati (practice)|sati]], in which a recently widowed woman would immolate herself on her husband's funeral pyre,<ref name="Jack" /><ref name="BGS" /><ref name="IW" /> is not generally considered a type of [[honor killing]].<ref name="Rajan" /><ref name="Mani1998" /> However, the extent up to which Sati was a purely voluntary act or one that was coerced is actively debated. There have been some incidents in recent times, such as the [[Roop Kanwar]] case, in which forced sati was suspected.<ref name="EncycCremation" /> Additional cases are under investigation,<ref name="Mani2003" /> though no evidence of forced suicide has yet been found.<ref name="rediffSati" /><ref name="rediffPyre" /><ref name="BBC-Sati" /> |
||
⚫ | Some instances of Japanese [[seppuku]] fall into this category. The culture practiced by the [[samurai]] expected them to ritually kill themselves if found disloyal, sparing a ''[[daimyō]]'' or ''[[shōgun]]'' the indignity of executing a follower. This was especially the case in the [[Edo period]],{{citation needed|date=May 2017}} and [[Asano Naganori]] was a clear example. |
||
⚫ | The |
||
⚫ | Japanese [[seppuku]] |
||
⚫ | |||
Another famous example is the forced suicide of [[Erwin Rommel]], a field marshal in the [[Wehrmacht#Army|German Army]] during the [[World War II|Second World War]]. After Rommel lost faith in Germany's ability to win the war, and came under suspicion for having taken part in the [[July 20 Plot|July 20, 1944, plot]] to kill [[Adolf Hitler]], he was forced to commit suicide. Due to Rommel's popularity with the German people, Hitler gave him an option to commit suicide with [[cyanide]] or face dishonor and retaliation against his family and staff. Since the guilty verdict had already been entered, the option of facing trial was hopeless, and thus, in order to save his family and his honor, he was forced to take cyanide. |
|||
⚫ | |||
During World War II there were many forced suicides in different military and paramilitary organizations. There is evidence of military failures requiring suicide as a better option than court martial, for example in the [[Winter War]] and at the [[Battle of Stalingrad]]. Several under [[Adolf Hitler]]'s regime also committed suicide. [[Friedrich Paulus]] was promoted with the implication that he would [[Forlorn hope|die in futile military action]] or commit suicide. Suicide missions, in which volunteers were asked for, are well reported in fiction, but levels of compulsion are hard to assess. |
|||
[[Erwin Rommel]], a German military leader during [[World War II]], was implicated in a [[20 July plot|plot]] to assassinate [[Adolf Hitler]] in 1944. On Hitler's orders, two generals went to Rommel's home and offered him a choice of either going through a public trial (which would inevitably lead to his execution and the punishment of his family) or taking his own life by swallowing [[cyanide]] (in which case he would receive a hero's funeral and his family would be spared imprisonment). Rommel opted for suicide on 14 October 1944; details of his fate were confirmed by his widow and son after the end of the war.<ref>{{Cite book|last=Marshall|first=Charles F.|title=A Ramble Through My War: Anzio and Other Joys|publisher=Louisiana State University Press|year=1998|isbn=9780807122822|edition=1st|pages=230–232}}</ref> |
|||
== As a substitute for honor killings == |
== As a substitute for honor killings == |
||
A forced suicide may be a substitute for an [[honor killing]] when a woman violates the ''[[namus]]'' in conservative Middle Eastern societies. In 2006, the [[United Nations]] investigated reports of forced suicides of |
A forced suicide may be a substitute for an [[honor killing]] when a woman violates the ''[[namus]]'' in some conservative Middle Eastern societies. In 2006, the [[United Nations]] investigated reports of forced suicides of women in southeastern [[Turkey]].<ref name="BBCforced" /> |
||
== References == |
== References == |
||
Line 31: | Line 29: | ||
| author = Hawley, John C. |
| author = Hawley, John C. |
||
| title = Sati, the blessing and the curse: the burning of wives in India |
| title = Sati, the blessing and the curse: the burning of wives in India |
||
| url = https://archive.org/details/satiblessingcurs00hawl_499 |
|||
| url-access = limited |
|||
| publisher = Oxford University Press |
| publisher = Oxford University Press |
||
| location = Oxford [Oxfordshire] |
| location = Oxford [Oxfordshire] |
||
| year = 1994 |
| year = 1994 |
||
| pages = 102, 166 |
| pages = [https://archive.org/details/satiblessingcurs00hawl_499/page/n116 102], 166 |
||
| isbn = 0-19-507774-1 |
| isbn = 0-19-507774-1 |
||
| oclc = |
|||
| doi = |
|||
| accessdate = 2008-02-11 |
|||
}} |
}} |
||
</ref> |
</ref> |
||
Line 50: | Line 47: | ||
| year = 2004 |
| year = 2004 |
||
| isbn = 0-252-02997-6 |
| isbn = 0-252-02997-6 |
||
| oclc = |
|||
| doi = |
|||
| accessdate = 2008-02-11 |
|||
| page = 103 |
| page = 103 |
||
}} |
}} |
||
Line 62: | Line 56: | ||
| title = Immolating Women: A Global History from Ancient Times to the Present |
| title = Immolating Women: A Global History from Ancient Times to the Present |
||
| publisher = Orient Longman |
| publisher = Orient Longman |
||
| location = |
|||
| year = 2005 |
| year = 2005 |
||
| isbn = 81-7824-134-X |
| isbn = 81-7824-134-X |
||
| oclc = |
|||
| doi = |
|||
| page = 320 |
| page = 320 |
||
}} |
}} |
||
Line 85: | Line 76: | ||
<ref name="Mani2003"> |
<ref name="Mani2003"> |
||
{{cite book |
{{cite book |
||
| author = Mani, Lata |
| author = Mani, Lata |
||
| editor = Kim, Seung-Kyung |
|||
| editor2 = McCann, Carole R. |
|||
| title = "Multiple Mediations" in Feminist theory reader: local and global perspectives |
| title = "Multiple Mediations" in Feminist theory reader: local and global perspectives |
||
| publisher = Routledge |
| publisher = Routledge |
||
| location = New York |
| location = New York |
||
| year = 2003 |
| year = 2003 |
||
| pages = 373–4 |
| pages = [https://archive.org/details/feministtheoryre0000unse/page/373 373–4] |
||
| isbn = 0-415-93152-5 |
| isbn = 0-415-93152-5 |
||
| url = https://archive.org/details/feministtheoryre0000unse/page/373 |
|||
| oclc = |
|||
| doi = |
|||
| accessdate = 2008-02-09 |
|||
}} |
}} |
||
</ref> |
</ref> |
||
Line 102: | Line 93: | ||
| title = Woman commits Sati in Uttar Pradesh |
| title = Woman commits Sati in Uttar Pradesh |
||
| url = http://www.rediff.com/news/2006/may/20sati.htm |
| url = http://www.rediff.com/news/2006/may/20sati.htm |
||
| |
| work = rediff.com |
||
| |
| access-date = 2008-02-08 |
||
}} |
}} |
||
</ref> |
</ref> |
||
Line 110: | Line 101: | ||
{{cite web |
{{cite web |
||
| title = Woman dies after jumping into husband's funeral pyre |
| title = Woman dies after jumping into husband's funeral pyre |
||
| |
| work = rediff.com |
||
| url = http://www.rediff.com/news/2006/aug/22pyre.htm |
| url = http://www.rediff.com/news/2006/aug/22pyre.htm |
||
| |
| access-date = 2006-08-22 |
||
}} |
}} |
||
</ref> |
</ref> |
||
Line 122: | Line 113: | ||
| publisher = bbc.co.uk |
| publisher = bbc.co.uk |
||
| url = http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/5278898.stm |
| url = http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/5278898.stm |
||
| |
| access-date = 2008-02-08 |
||
}} |
}} |
||
</ref> |
</ref> |
||
Line 133: | Line 124: | ||
{{Capital punishment}} |
{{Capital punishment}} |
||
{{Suicide navbox}} |
{{Suicide navbox}} |
||
[[Category:Execution methods]] |
[[Category:Execution methods]] |
||
[[Category:Forced suicides| ]] |
[[Category:Forced suicides| ]] |
Latest revision as of 21:57, 5 November 2024
Suicide |
---|
Forced suicide is a method of execution where the victim is coerced into committing suicide to avoid facing an alternative option they perceive as much worse, such as being tortured to death, suffering public humiliation, or having friends or family members imprisoned, tortured or killed.
In ancient Greece and Rome
[edit]Forced suicide was a common means of execution in ancient Greece and Rome. As a mark of respect it was generally reserved for aristocrats sentenced to death; the victims would either drink hemlock or fall on their swords. Economic motivations prompted some suicides in ancient Rome. A person who was condemned to death would forfeit property to the government. People could evade that provision and let the property pass to their heirs by committing suicide prior to arrest.
One of the most well-known forced suicides is that of the philosopher Socrates, who drank hemlock after his trial for allegedly corrupting the youth of Athens. The Stoic philosopher Seneca also killed himself in response to an order by his pupil, the Roman Emperor Nero, who himself was forced to commit suicide at a later date. Other famous forced suicides include those of Brutus, Mark Antony, Emperor Otho, and the Roman generals Varus and Corbulo.
In Asia
[edit]The Hindu practice of sati, in which a recently widowed woman would immolate herself on her husband's funeral pyre,[1][2][3] is not generally considered a type of honor killing.[4][5] However, the extent up to which Sati was a purely voluntary act or one that was coerced is actively debated. There have been some incidents in recent times, such as the Roop Kanwar case, in which forced sati was suspected.[6] Additional cases are under investigation,[7] though no evidence of forced suicide has yet been found.[8][9][10]
Some instances of Japanese seppuku fall into this category. The culture practiced by the samurai expected them to ritually kill themselves if found disloyal, sparing a daimyō or shōgun the indignity of executing a follower. This was especially the case in the Edo period,[citation needed] and Asano Naganori was a clear example.
In Europe
[edit]Erwin Rommel, a German military leader during World War II, was implicated in a plot to assassinate Adolf Hitler in 1944. On Hitler's orders, two generals went to Rommel's home and offered him a choice of either going through a public trial (which would inevitably lead to his execution and the punishment of his family) or taking his own life by swallowing cyanide (in which case he would receive a hero's funeral and his family would be spared imprisonment). Rommel opted for suicide on 14 October 1944; details of his fate were confirmed by his widow and son after the end of the war.[11]
As a substitute for honor killings
[edit]A forced suicide may be a substitute for an honor killing when a woman violates the namus in some conservative Middle Eastern societies. In 2006, the United Nations investigated reports of forced suicides of women in southeastern Turkey.[12]
References
[edit]- ^ Hawley, John C. (1994). Sati, the blessing and the curse: the burning of wives in India. Oxford [Oxfordshire]: Oxford University Press. pp. 102, 166. ISBN 0-19-507774-1.
- ^ Smith, Bonnie G. (2004). Women's history in global perspective. Urbana: University of Illinois Press. p. 103. ISBN 0-252-02997-6.
- ^ Jörg Fisch (2005). Immolating Women: A Global History from Ancient Times to the Present. Orient Longman. p. 320. ISBN 81-7824-134-X.
- ^ Rajeswari Sunder Rajan, Real and Imagined Women, Routledge, 1993.
- ^ Lata Mani: Contentious Traditions: The Debate on Sati in Colonial India. Berkeley & Los Angeles, 1998
- ^ Douglas James Davies and Lewis H. Mates (eds.), Encyclopedia of Cremation, p371, Ashgate Publishing, 2005.
- ^ Mani, Lata (2003). Kim, Seung-Kyung; McCann, Carole R. (eds.). "Multiple Mediations" in Feminist theory reader: local and global perspectives. New York: Routledge. pp. 373–4. ISBN 0-415-93152-5.
- ^ "Woman commits Sati in Uttar Pradesh". rediff.com. Retrieved 2008-02-08.
- ^ "Woman dies after jumping into husband's funeral pyre". rediff.com. Retrieved 2006-08-22.
- ^ "Visitors flock to 'sati' village". bbc.co.uk. 2006-08-23. Retrieved 2008-02-08.
- ^ Marshall, Charles F. (1998). A Ramble Through My War: Anzio and Other Joys (1st ed.). Louisiana State University Press. pp. 230–232. ISBN 9780807122822.
- ^ "UN probes Turkey 'forced suicide", BBC News, 2006-05-24.