Starship flight test 3

This article is about the 2024 full-up Starship+Super Heavy third flight test. For the 2020 third flight test of the Starship segment, see List of Starship upper stage flight tests.

Starship flight test 3

Video of Starship during flight test 3
Mission type	Flight test
Operator	SpaceX
Mission duration	49 minutes, 35 seconds (achieved) 1 hour, 4 minutes, 39 seconds (planned)
Orbits completed	<1
Spacecraft properties
Spacecraft	Starship Ship 28
Spacecraft type	Starship
Manufacturer	SpaceX
Start of mission
Launch date	13:25, March 14, 2024 (2024-03-14T13:25) UTC (8:25 am CDT)
Rocket	Super Heavy (B10)
Launch site	Starbase, OLP-A
End of mission
Destroyed	14:14:35, March 14, 2024 (2024-03-14T14:14:35) UTC (9:14:35 am CDT)
Orbital parameters
Regime	Suborbital
Periapsis altitude	-54 km
Apoapsis altitude	234 km (145 mi)
Inclination	26.5°
Mission patch SpaceX Starship flight tests

Starship flight test 3 was the third flight test of the SpaceX Starship launch vehicle. SpaceX performed the flight test on March 14, 2024.

Starship successfully completed a full-duration second stage burn, reaching the intended orbital velocity for the first time, but broke up during re-entry in the atmosphere.

Background

Further information: SpaceX Starship integrated flight test 2 § Aftermath

Changes from the previous flight

After the second flight test in November 2023 ended in the destruction of both the Super Heavy booster and the Starship spacecraft, 17 significant changes were made to the vehicles, including upgrading the ship to an electric thrust vector control (TVC) system (the booster had received similar upgrades for the second flight test) and delaying the vent of liquid oxygen (LOX) to after Starship engine cutoff (SECO).

SpaceX upgraded the orbital tank farm with additional subcoolers and pumps to increase the propellant flow rate. In addition, two water tanks were removed and scrapped. Steel plates have been added to concrete at the base of the launch tower due to erosion from the engines. A concrete wall has replaced the HESCO barriers previously protecting the tank farm.

Development prior to launch

Testing of the Flight 3 vehicles began just under a month after second flight test, with S28 and B10 undergoing their individual static fire tests in late December 2023. The FAA closed its mishap investigation of the second flight test on February 26, 2024. In the mishap report, SpaceX identified 17 corrective actions, of which ten were for the Starship upper stage and seven for the Super Heavy booster. Booster 10 and S28 conducted a wet dress rehearsal on March 3, 2024. On March 5, 2024, SpaceX announced that they were targeting a launch date of March 14, 2024, pending regulatory approval. On March 13, 2024, the FAA granted the launch license for this flight, the third flight test.

Flight profile

Starship flight test 3 launched from the SpaceX Starbase facility along the South Texas coast around 8:25 CDT. As with the second flight test, ignition of all 33 booster engines and stage separation were both successful. B10 conducted a boostback burn. However, 6 engines began shutting down unexpectedly causing a premature boostback shutdown; the planned landing in the Gulf of Mexico was not successful due to the same six engines that failed before being disabled leaving seven engines commanded to startup with two successfully reaching ignition. Following the failures, SpaceX reported that the booster was destroyed at an estimated altitude of approximately 462 meters (1,516 ft). The cause of these failures was determined by SpaceX to be filter blockage of liquid oxygen to the engines. A similar problem occurred in the second flight test, leading Booster 10 to get upgraded filtering.

The Starship spacecraft itself reached space and the intended orbital velocity. It then conducted several tests after engine cutoff, including a successful propellant transfer demo and payload dispenser test. It attempted to re-enter the atmosphere over the Indian Ocean, and at an altitude of around 65 km, all telemetry from Ship 28 stopped, indicating a loss of the vehicle. According to SpaceX, S28 was experiencing excessive roll rates causing it to have an "off-nominal entry". This was caused by clogging of the valves responsible for roll control on Starship.

Flight timeline

Time	Event	14 March 2024
−01:15:00	SpaceX Flight Director conducts a poll and verifies go for propellant loading	Success
−00:53:00	Starship oxidizer loading (liquid oxygen) underway	Success
−00:51:00	Starship fuel loading (liquid methane) underway	Success
−00:42:00	Super Heavy oxidizer loading (liquid oxygen) underway	Success
−00:41:00	Super Heavy fuel loading (liquid methane) underway	Success
−00:19:40	Booster engine chill	Success
−00:03:30	Booster propellant load complete	Success
−00:02:50	Ship propellant load complete	Success
−00:00:30	SpaceX flight director verifies GO for launch	Success
−00:00:10	Flame deflector activation	Success
−00:00:03	Booster engine ignition	Success
00:00:02	Liftoff	Success
00:00:52	Max q (moment of peak mechanical stress on the rocket)	Success
00:02:42	Booster Main Engine Cut Off (MECO)	Success
00:02:44	Starship engine ignition and stage separation (hot-staging)	Success
00:02:55	Booster boostback burn startup	Success
00:03:50	Booster boostback burn shutdown	6 engines shut down due to LOX filter blockage, causing the burn to end prematurely
00:06:36	Booster is transonic	Achieved later than planned due to off nominal trajectory caused by early boostback shutdown
00:06:46	Booster landing burn startup	7 engines commanded to start, only 2 ignited
00:07:04	Booster landing burn shutdown	Loss of telemetry from booster at approximately 462 m (1,516 ft)
00:08:35	Starship engine cutoff (SECO)	Success
00:11:56	Payload door open	Success
00:24:31	Propellant transfer demo	Success
00:28:21	Payload door close	Success
00:40:46	Raptor in-space relight demo	Skipped due to loss of roll control
00:49:05	Starship entry	Stuck roll control valve during coast phase resulted in loss of control and vehicle telemetry was lost at an altitude of 65 km (40 mi)
01:02:16	Starship is transonic	—
01:03:04	Starship is subsonic	—
01:04:39	Starship splashdown	—

Aftermath

After the launch, SpaceX confirmed that Super Heavy was destroyed at 462 m above sea level over the Gulf of Mexico. The status of the payload door test became one of the focuses of unofficial interpretations of the flight in YouTube and news articles, due to a perceived issue seen from the flight video concerning the payload door. SpaceX's account of the launch states that the payload test had been a success.

Gwynne Shotwell, president and chief operating officer of SpaceX, said the company was still investigating the data and what went wrong in the third flight test, but that the fourth flight test could launch soon, possibly by early May.

NASA chief Bill Nelson praised SpaceX for "a successful test flight". He also stated, "Today we are making great strides through Artemis to return humanity to the Moon - then look onward to Mars." SpaceX founder and CEO Elon Musk also praised the team and stated "Starship will take humanity to Mars."

On March 14, 2024, the FAA declared that a mishap had occurred involving both the upper stage and booster, triggering the start of a SpaceX-led investigation overseen by the FAA. The agency's associate administrator for commercial space transportation, Kelvin Coleman, said on March 18 that he did not anticipate any major issues that could delay the investigation. Additionally, there was talk for the FAA to begin issuing a "portfolio of launches", authorizing multiple launches rather than a single launch at a time, as part of a broader effort to streamline the launch license process in response to criticism from SpaceX and Congress that the FAA was moving too slow on approving them. The next launch license will likely require modification, but Coleman said the FAA may be able to first complete a public safety determination, finding that there were no flaws in critical safety systems on the March launch that would have endangered the safety of the uninvolved public. If so, “that would decouple the mishap investigation from the license modification, and that means that we could get the license modification done while the mishap investigation is ongoing.” However, both are still needed in order for a launch license to be granted.

On April 5, SpaceX requested that the FAA agree that the third flight test mishap did not present a public safety issue. On May 11, SpaceX founder and CEO Elon Musk stated that the fourth Starship launch could occur in 3-5 weeks, bringing the date forward to early-mid June. The FAA investigation and launch license remained pending. On May 17, the FAA made a statement that if the FAA agrees no public safety issues were involved in the mishap, SpaceX may return to flight while the third flight test investigation remains open, provided all other license requirements are met. This statement does not constitute SpaceX being granted a Launch License.

On May 24, SpaceX released a blog post stating the results from flight 3. According to SpaceX, during the boostback burn, 6 engines began to shut down, causing an early boostback shutdown. The vehicle prevented these engines from performing the landing burn, leaving only 7 engines. 2 of the engines were able to successfully ignite. The vehicle had lower than expected thrust, and it was lost at an altitude of 462 meters. The main likely cause of the boostback shutdown was due to filter blockage in the liquid oxygen intake, leading to loss of pressure in the oxygen turbopumps. According to SpaceX, several minutes after the ship engine cutoff (SECO), the valves responsible for the roll control thrusters were clogged. This precluded the in flight raptor relight test. Due to the unplanned roll, the ship experienced much higher heat loads in both unprotected and tiled sections.

In order to mitigate these issues, SpaceX has implemented hardware changes to the booster liquid oxygen tank to improve propellant filtration. SpaceX has also added more roll control thrusters on the ship for redundancy. Additionally, hardware and software changes were implemented to improve Raptor startup reliability.