Jump to content

Giovanni Bastianini: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
mNo edit summary
 
(16 intermediate revisions by 11 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{short description|Italian artist (1830-1868)}}
'''Giovanni Bastianini''' (17 September 1830 – 29 June 1868) was an [[Italy|Italian]] [[sculpture|sculptor]] who began his career as a stonecutter in the quarries at [[Fiesole]], and was sent by [[Francesco Inghirami]] to study in [[Florence]], first with [[Pio Fedi]] and then with [[Girolamo Torrini]], with whom he collaborated on a statue of [[Donatello]] for the [[portico]] of the [[Uffizi]]. Bastianini's name became famous in connection with his unmasking as the first widely publicized [[Art forgery|art forger]].
[[File: Michele gordigiani, ritratto dello scultore giovanni bastianin.jpg |thumb|Painting of Giovanni Bastianini by [[Michele Gordigiani]]]]
'''Giovanni Bastianini''' (17 September 1830 – 29 June 1868) was an Italian [[sculpture|sculptor]] who began his career as a stonecutter in the quarries at [[Fiesole]], and was sent by [[Francesco Inghirami]] to study in [[Florence]], first with [[Pio Fedi]] and then with [[Girolamo Torrini]], with whom he collaborated on a statue of [[Donatello]] for the [[portico]] of the [[Uffizi]]. Bastianini's name became famous in connection with his unmasking as the first widely publicized [[Art forgery|art forger]].<ref>{{Cite book |last=Helstosky |first=Carol |url=https://www.google.com/books/edition/Italian_Forgers/j5jsEAAAQBAJ?hl=en&pg=PA20 |title=Italian Forgers: The Art Market and the Weight of the Past in Modern Italy |date=2024-05-15 |publisher=Cornell University Press |isbn=978-1-5017-7459-1 |page=20 |language=en}}</ref>


==Life and career==
==Life and career==
Bastianini admired [[Renaissance]] sculpture, which became his main inspiration. From 1848 to 1866 he was under contract to the Florentine antique dealer, [[Giovanni Freppa]], who supplied him with casts and models as well as a [[stipend]], in exchange for which Bastianini produced numerous neo-Renaissance works, especially busts and bas-reliefs in the style of [[Donatello]], [[Verrocchio]], [[Mino de Fiesole]] and other Italian [[Old Masters]], most of which were sold at modest prices.
Bastianini admired [[Renaissance]] sculpture, which became his main inspiration. From 1848 to 1866 he was under contract to the Florentine antique dealer, [[Giovanni Freppa]], who supplied him with casts and models as well as a [[stipend]], in exchange for which Bastianini produced numerous neo-Renaissance works, especially busts and bas-reliefs in the style of [[Donatello]], [[Verrocchio]], [[Mino da Fiesole]] and other Italian [[Old Masters]], most of which were sold at modest prices.
[[File: Giovanni bastianini, pescatorello 02.jpg|thumb|right|Sculpture by Giovanni Bastianini in the Galleria d'Arte Moderna (Florence)]]

In the early 1860s Freppa and Bastianini grew more ambitious. Following the success of Bastianini's bust of [[Savonarola]], carefully coloured and aged by the sculptor Gaiarini and placed in Inghirami's Florentine villa, where it was "discovered" by the eminent Florentine art dealer Capponi and bought for the nation, Bastianini crafted a portrait bust of the poet [[Girolamo Benivieni]], which Freppa commissioned; exhibited to great acclaim in Paris as "school of [[Verrocchio]]", it was purchased by [[Émilien de Nieuwerkerke|comte de Nieuwerkerke]] for the [[Louvre Museum|Louvre]] at auction for fr 13,600.
In the early 1860s Freppa and Bastianini grew more ambitious. Following the success of Bastianini's bust of [[Savonarola]], carefully coloured and aged by the sculptor Francesco Gaiarini <ref>Brunori, Dionisio. ''Giovanni Bastianini e Paolo Ricci, scultori fiesolani''. Firenze: Tipografia Domenicana, 1906, p. 15, note 3.</ref> and placed in Inghirami's Florentine villa, where it was "discovered" by the eminent Florentine art dealer Capponi and bought for the nation, Bastianini crafted a portrait bust of the poet [[Girolamo Benivieni]], which Freppa commissioned; exhibited to great acclaim in Paris as "school of [[Verrocchio]]", it was purchased by [[Émilien de Nieuwerkerke|comte de Nieuwerkerke]] for the [[Louvre Museum|Louvre]] at auction for fr 13,600.


None of the pieces had been suspected of being inauthentic, and the deception was eventually revealed by Freppa, who resented not receiving his agreed-upon percentage of the exaggerated price paid by the [[Louvre Museum]]. The Paris press made hay.<ref>"Article after article was printed in the leading journals of Paris, denouncing 'the well-known impostor and forger Bastianini' with all that vituperative eloquence in which our neighbours so highly excel." ("The City of Lilies", ''Temple Bar'', '''37''', 1873:478.</ref>
None of the pieces had been suspected of being inauthentic, and the deception was eventually revealed by Freppa, who resented not receiving his agreed-upon percentage of the exaggerated price paid by the [[Louvre Museum]]. The Paris press made hay.<ref>"Article after article was printed in the leading journals of Paris, denouncing 'the well-known impostor and forger Bastianini' with all that vituperative eloquence in which our neighbours so highly excel." ("The City of Lilies", ''Temple Bar'', '''37''', 1873:478.</ref>
Line 19: Line 21:


==Further reading==
==Further reading==
*{{Cite journal |last=Helstosky |first=Carol |year=2009 |title=Giovanni Bastianini, Art Forgery, and the Market in Nineteenth‐Century Italy |journal=The Journal of Modern History |volume=81 |issue=4 |pages=793–823 |doi=10.1086/605486 |postscript=<!-- Bot inserted parameter. Either remove it; or change its value to "." for the cite to end in a ".", as necessary. --> }}.
*{{Cite journal |last=Helstosky |first=Carol |year=2009 |title=Giovanni Bastianini, Art Forgery, and the Market in Nineteenth‐Century Italy |journal=The Journal of Modern History |volume=81 |issue=4 |pages=793–823 |doi=10.1086/605486 |s2cid=146297018 }}.
*{{cite journal|last=Moskowitz|first=Anita F.|title=The Case of Giovanni Bastianini: A Fair and Balanced View|journal=Artibus et Historiae|year=2004|volume= 25| issue = 50|pages=157–185|jstor=1483793}}
*{{cite journal|last=Moskowitz|first=Anita F.|title=The Case of Giovanni Bastianini: A Fair and Balanced View|journal=Artibus et Historiae|year=2004|volume= 25| issue = 50|pages=157–185|doi=10.2307/1483793|jstor=1483793}}
*{{cite journal|last=Moskowitz|first=Anita F.|title=The Case of Giovanni Bastianni-II: A Hung Jury?|journal=Artibus et Historiae|year=2006|volume= 27| issue = 54|pages=201–217|jstor=20067129}}
*{{cite journal|last=Moskowitz|first=Anita F.|title=The Case of Giovanni Bastianni-II: A Hung Jury?|journal=Artibus et Historiae|year=2006|volume= 27| issue = 54|pages=201–217|doi=10.2307/20067129|jstor=20067129}}
*Moskowitz, Anita F. "Forging authenticity -- Giovanni Bastianini and the Neo-Renaissance in Nineteenth-Century Florence" ISBN 978 88 222 6171 7
*Moskowitz, Anita F. "Forging authenticity -- Giovanni Bastianini and the Neo-Renaissance in Nineteenth-Century Florence" {{ISBN|978 88 222 6171 7}}
* Tina Öcal: Shape-shifters of Transculturation: Giovanni Bastianini’s Forgeries as Embodiment of an Aesthetic Patriotism, in: Faking, Forging, Counterfeiting. Discredited Practices at the Margins of Mimesis, ed. by Becker, Daniel / Fischer, Annalisa / Schmitz, Yola, Bielefeld 2018, pp.&nbsp;111–126.

==External links==
==External links==
* {{Internet Archive author |sname=Giovanni Bastianini}}
* {{Internet Archive author |sname=Giovanni Bastianini}}
Line 33: Line 36:
| accessdate = 2007-07-25 }}
| accessdate = 2007-07-25 }}
* {{cite web
* {{cite web
| title = FORGERIES, A LONG HISTORY
|title = FORGERIES, A LONG HISTORY
| publisher = Museum Security
|publisher = Museum Security
| url = http://www.museum-security.org/forgeries.htm
|url = http://www.museum-security.org/forgeries.htm
| accessdate = 2007-07-25 }}
|accessdate = 2007-07-25
|url-status = dead
|archiveurl = https://web.archive.org/web/20070804234511/http://www.museum-security.org/forgeries.htm
|archivedate = 2007-08-04
}}
*{{cite web
*{{cite web
| title = Notes on Imitation and Forgery
| title = Notes on Imitation and Forgery
Line 47: Line 54:
| newspaper=[[New York Times]]
| newspaper=[[New York Times]]
| date=May 18, 2007
| date=May 18, 2007
| url=http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/18/arts/18forg.html?ex=1337140800&en=17d24295afc3fb5d&ei=5124&partner=permalink&exprod=permalink
| url=https://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/18/arts/18forg.html?ex=1337140800&en=17d24295afc3fb5d&ei=5124&partner=permalink&exprod=permalink
}}
| postscript=<!--None--> }}


{{Authority control}}
{{Authority control}}


{{DEFAULTSORT:Bastianini, Giovanni}}
{{DEFAULTSORT:Bastianini, Giovanni}}
[[Category:Articles with inconsistent citation formats]]
[[Category:1830 births]]
[[Category:1830 births]]
[[Category:1868 deaths]]
[[Category:1868 deaths]]
[[Category:Art forgers]]
[[Category:Art forgers]]
[[Category:19th-century Italian sculptors]]
[[Category:19th-century Italian sculptors]]
[[Category:Italian male sculptors]]
[[Category:19th-century Italian male artists]]

Latest revision as of 15:49, 20 November 2024

Painting of Giovanni Bastianini by Michele Gordigiani

Giovanni Bastianini (17 September 1830 – 29 June 1868) was an Italian sculptor who began his career as a stonecutter in the quarries at Fiesole, and was sent by Francesco Inghirami to study in Florence, first with Pio Fedi and then with Girolamo Torrini, with whom he collaborated on a statue of Donatello for the portico of the Uffizi. Bastianini's name became famous in connection with his unmasking as the first widely publicized art forger.[1]

Life and career

[edit]

Bastianini admired Renaissance sculpture, which became his main inspiration. From 1848 to 1866 he was under contract to the Florentine antique dealer, Giovanni Freppa, who supplied him with casts and models as well as a stipend, in exchange for which Bastianini produced numerous neo-Renaissance works, especially busts and bas-reliefs in the style of Donatello, Verrocchio, Mino da Fiesole and other Italian Old Masters, most of which were sold at modest prices.

Sculpture by Giovanni Bastianini in the Galleria d'Arte Moderna (Florence)

In the early 1860s Freppa and Bastianini grew more ambitious. Following the success of Bastianini's bust of Savonarola, carefully coloured and aged by the sculptor Francesco Gaiarini [2] and placed in Inghirami's Florentine villa, where it was "discovered" by the eminent Florentine art dealer Capponi and bought for the nation, Bastianini crafted a portrait bust of the poet Girolamo Benivieni, which Freppa commissioned; exhibited to great acclaim in Paris as "school of Verrocchio", it was purchased by comte de Nieuwerkerke for the Louvre at auction for fr 13,600.

None of the pieces had been suspected of being inauthentic, and the deception was eventually revealed by Freppa, who resented not receiving his agreed-upon percentage of the exaggerated price paid by the Louvre Museum. The Paris press made hay.[3]

Many of the owners of Bastianini's pastiches stood by the artistic value of the works. Giovanni Costa, who had contributed to the funding of the Savonarola purchase, allowed that he was glad to hear the artist was living.[4]

Having purchased as genuine works Bastianini forgeries,[5] in 1864 the Victoria and Albert Museum in London knowingly bought a sculpture by Bastianini, as an example of modern work inspired by the best of the past; it is exhibited with other works by Bastianini formerly thought genuine. Bastianini's tin-glazed terracotta Portrait of a Lady in the Della Robbia technique, authenticated by Bernard Berenson as a "15th century Della Robbia bust of Marietta Strozzi" found its way through Joseph Duveen to the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum, Boston.[6]

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ Helstosky, Carol (2024-05-15). Italian Forgers: The Art Market and the Weight of the Past in Modern Italy. Cornell University Press. p. 20. ISBN 978-1-5017-7459-1.
  2. ^ Brunori, Dionisio. Giovanni Bastianini e Paolo Ricci, scultori fiesolani. Firenze: Tipografia Domenicana, 1906, p. 15, note 3.
  3. ^ "Article after article was printed in the leading journals of Paris, denouncing 'the well-known impostor and forger Bastianini' with all that vituperative eloquence in which our neighbours so highly excel." ("The City of Lilies", Temple Bar, 37, 1873:478.
  4. ^ Mark Jones, Fake?: the art of deception British Museum, 1990:197.
  5. ^ Mark Jones, Fake?: the art of deception British Museum, 1990:196, a bas-relief of the Madonna and Child, a pastiche of Antonio Rossellino (for the Virgin) and Desiderio da Settignano (for the Child).
  6. ^ David Sox, Unmasking the Forger: the Dossena deception, 2008:130f.

Further reading

[edit]
  • Helstosky, Carol (2009). "Giovanni Bastianini, Art Forgery, and the Market in Nineteenth‐Century Italy". The Journal of Modern History. 81 (4): 793–823. doi:10.1086/605486. S2CID 146297018..
  • Moskowitz, Anita F. (2004). "The Case of Giovanni Bastianini: A Fair and Balanced View". Artibus et Historiae. 25 (50): 157–185. doi:10.2307/1483793. JSTOR 1483793.
  • Moskowitz, Anita F. (2006). "The Case of Giovanni Bastianni-II: A Hung Jury?". Artibus et Historiae. 27 (54): 201–217. doi:10.2307/20067129. JSTOR 20067129.
  • Moskowitz, Anita F. "Forging authenticity -- Giovanni Bastianini and the Neo-Renaissance in Nineteenth-Century Florence" ISBN 978 88 222 6171 7
  • Tina Öcal: Shape-shifters of Transculturation: Giovanni Bastianini’s Forgeries as Embodiment of an Aesthetic Patriotism, in: Faking, Forging, Counterfeiting. Discredited Practices at the Margins of Mimesis, ed. by Becker, Daniel / Fischer, Annalisa / Schmitz, Yola, Bielefeld 2018, pp. 111–126.
[edit]