Anting (behavior): Difference between revisions
→Ridding of ectoparasites: Fixed grammar Tags: canned edit summary Mobile edit Mobile app edit Android app edit App select source |
|||
| (21 intermediate revisions by 17 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Short description|Avian maintenance behavior}} |
|||
[[File:Black Drongo I2 IMG 5683.jpg|thumb|A [[black drongo]] in a typical anting posture]] |
[[File:Black Drongo I2 IMG 5683.jpg|thumb|A [[black drongo]] in a typical anting posture]] |
||
'''Anting''' is a [[Comfort behaviour in animals|maintenance |
'''Anting''' is a [[Comfort behaviour in animals|maintenance behavior]] during which [[bird]]s rub insects, usually [[ant]]s, on their feathers and skin. The bird may pick up the insects in its bill and rub them on the body (active anting), or the bird may lie in an area of high density of the insects and perform [[dust bathing]]-like movements (passive anting). The insects secrete liquids containing chemicals such as [[formic acid]], which can act as an [[insecticide]], [[miticide]], [[fungicide]], or [[bactericide]]. Alternatively, anting could make the insects edible by removing the distasteful acid, or possibly supplement the bird's own [[Uropygial gland|preen oil]]. Instead of ants, birds can also use [[millipede]]s. More than 200 species of bird are known to ant.<ref name=":0" /> A possibly related behaviour, [[self-anointing in animals|self-anointing]], is seen in many mammals.<ref name=":0" /> |
||
==History== |
==History== |
||
The first scientific writings of this behaviour dates back to 1831. American ornithologist [[John James Audubon]] described wild juvenile turkeys that "wallowed" in abandoned ant hills. Another description was published by a naturalist in 1847 in a manuscript called "Bird of Jamaica". In it the author describes how ants remove parasites from a tame crow, while the crow is foraging for food.{{citation needed|date=November 2019}} In 1934 an [[Alexander Hugh Chisholm]] described in ''Bird Wonders of Australia'', a strange relationship birds had with ants.<ref name=":0">{{cite journal|last1=Morozov|first1=N.S|date=July 31, 2014|title=Why do birds practice anting?|journal=Uspekhi Sovremennoi Biologii|volume=135|pages=97–112}}</ref> [[Erwin Stresemann]] in German as ''Einemsen'' |
The first scientific writings of this behaviour dates back to 1831. American ornithologist [[John James Audubon]] described wild juvenile turkeys that "wallowed" in abandoned ant hills. Another description was published by a naturalist in 1847 in a manuscript called "Bird of Jamaica". In it the author describes how ants remove parasites from a tame crow, while the crow is foraging for food.{{citation needed|date=November 2019}} In 1934 an [[Alexander Hugh Chisholm]] described in ''Bird Wonders of Australia'', a strange relationship birds had with ants.<ref name=":0">{{cite journal|last1=Morozov|first1=N.S|date=July 31, 2014|title=Why do birds practice anting?|journal=Uspekhi Sovremennoi Biologii|volume=135|pages=97–112}}</ref> The behaviour was described by [[Erwin Stresemann]] in German as ''Einemsen'' in the German ornithology journal ''Ornithologische Monatsberichte'' (Volume XLIII, p. 138) in 1935. Indian ornithologist [[Salim Ali (ornithologist)|Salim Ali]] interpreted an observation by his cousin [[Humayun Abdulali]] in the 1936 volume of ''Journal of the [[Bombay Natural History Society]]'' and included a reference to the Stresemann's paper suggesting that the German term could be translated into English as "anting".<ref>{{cite journal|author=Ali, Salim|year=1936|title=Do birds employ ants to rid themselves of ectoparasites?|url=https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/page/47602998|journal=[[Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society|J. Bombay Nat. Hist. Soc.]]|volume=38|issue=3|pages=628–631}}</ref> |
||
==Modes== |
==Modes== |
||
=== Active === |
=== Active === |
||
[[File:Brahminy Kite Anting 01.jpg|right|thumb|A [[brahminy kite]] anting]] |
[[File:Brahminy Kite Anting 01.jpg|right|thumb|A [[brahminy kite]] anting at lalbagh Botanical Garden in [[Bangalore]], [[India]]]] |
||
Anting most commonly occurs on the ground but in some species, birds practice anting on tree branches. A bird will place the tip of its wing on the ground and rub its bill containing an ant from the tip of the wing up.<ref name=":0" /> The tail is usually tucked between the legs and under the body, which results in the bird being unstable. Birds use one ant at a time and only rub a feather once with an ant. However, there are some cases where an ant is used more than once but never exceeds three uses.<ref name=":0" /> There are some exceptions to this as [[starling]]s often take a ball of ants in their bills to be used for anting. Active anting happens very quickly and can often be mistaken for regular feather maintenance. This type of anting can last anywhere from just several minutes to half an hour. Most species of birds practice active anting and do this individually or in small groups. Birds may also use 'substitutes' in active anting. Birds have been seen to use [[snail]]s, [[grasshopper]]s, [[amphipods]] and even [[larvae]].<ref name=":0" /> |
Anting most commonly occurs on the ground but in some species, birds practice anting on tree branches. A bird will place the tip of its wing on the ground and rub its bill containing an ant from the tip of the wing up.<ref name=":0" /> The tail is usually tucked between the legs and under the body, which results in the bird being unstable. Birds use one ant at a time and only rub a feather once with an ant. However, there are some cases where an ant is used more than once but never exceeds three uses.<ref name=":0" /> There are some exceptions to this as [[starling]]s often take a ball of ants in their bills to be used for anting. Active anting happens very quickly and can often be mistaken for regular feather maintenance. This type of anting can last anywhere from just several minutes to half an hour. Most species of birds practice active anting and do this individually or in small groups. Birds may also use 'substitutes' in active anting. Birds have been seen to use [[snail]]s, [[grasshopper]]s, [[amphipods]] and even [[larvae]].<ref name=":0" /> |
||
=== Passive === |
=== Passive === |
||
Passive anting occurs when a bird rubs its wings and tail on an anthill. Once a bird has found an anthill it will then spread both of its wings forward at the same time. It will then sit on its tails which attracts the ants |
Passive anting occurs when a bird rubs its wings and tail on an anthill. Once a bird has found an anthill it will then spread both of its wings forward at the same time. It will then sit on its tails which attracts the ants. Once the ants are on their wing feathers they provoke the ants by rubbing their head or beak through their feathers where the ants are. To prevent ants from crawling onto a bird's head or beak the bird will shake its head very quickly. The birds allow the ants to roam freely around its feathers. This type of anting is less common and is mostly seen in [[European robin|robin]]s and [[raven]]s.<ref name=":0" /> |
||
== Functions == |
== Functions == |
||
=== Ridding of ectoparasites === |
=== Ridding of ectoparasites === |
||
Anting to get rid of ectoparasites is |
Anting to get rid of ectoparasites is one hypothesis for anting in [[songbirds]]. This hypothesis suggests that birds use the chemical secretions that come from ants to control and get rid of parasites in their feathers. [[Microorganisms]] such as [[bacteria]] and [[fungi]] can destroy a bird's feathers if their numbers get large enough. [[Formic acid]] is a commonly produced chemical by ants, and it was found to inhibit growth of feather-destroying [[microorganisms]].<ref name=":1">{{cite journal|last1=Revis|first1=Hannah|date=October 1, 2004|title=Bactericidal and Fungicidal Activity of Ant Chemicals on Feather Parasites: An Evaluation of Anting Behavior as a Method of Self-Medication in Songbirds|journal=The Auk|volume=121|issue=4|pages=1262–1268|doi=10.1093/auk/121.4.1262|doi-access=free}}</ref> However, there is little evidence that chemicals from ants help to remove or deter other [[parasites]] such as [[feather lice]] and [[mites]].<ref name=":1" /> |
||
=== Feather grooming === |
=== Feather grooming === |
||
[[File:Black Woodpecker taking an ant bath - HungaryCS4E4536 (15788008504).jpg|thumb|A [[Black woodpecker]] anting in Hungary]] |
|||
The hypothesis that anting is a form of [[feather maintenance]] suggests that anting brings saliva to the bird's feathers for use in [[preening]]. This helps to remove old [[preen oil]] and other substances.<ref name=":2">{{cite journal|last1=Potter|first1=Eloise|s2cid=85784753|date=October 1970|title=Anting in Wild Birds, Its Frequency and Probable Purpose|journal=The Auk|volume=87|issue=4|pages=692–713|doi=10.2307/4083703|jstor=4083703}}</ref> |
The hypothesis that anting is a form of [[feather maintenance]] suggests that anting brings saliva to the bird's feathers for use in [[preening (bird)|preening]]. This helps to remove old [[preen oil]] and other substances.<ref name=":2">{{cite journal|last1=Potter|first1=Eloise|s2cid=85784753|date=October 1970|title=Anting in Wild Birds, Its Frequency and Probable Purpose|journal=The Auk|volume=87|issue=4|pages=692–713|doi=10.2307/4083703|jstor=4083703|doi-access=free}}</ref> |
||
=== Food preparation === |
=== Food preparation === |
||
The food preparation hypothesis suggests that birds rub the ant in its feathers to remove a substance on the ant. Ants produce [[formic acid]] as an [[anti-predator adaptation]]. Thus, when an ant feels threatened, as when in the beak of a bird, it will spray formic acid. It is suggested that birds then rub the ants in their feathers to remove the harmful formic acid. The bird will then ingest the ant. This can be seen in European starlings, ''[[Sturnus vulgaris]]''.<ref name=":3">{{cite journal|last1=Judson|first1=Olivia|title='anting' as food preparation: formic acid is worse on an empty stomach |
The food preparation hypothesis suggests that birds rub the ant in its feathers to remove a substance on the ant. Ants produce [[formic acid]] as an [[anti-predator adaptation]]. Thus, when an ant feels threatened, as when in the beak of a bird, it will spray formic acid. It is suggested that birds then rub the ants in their feathers to remove the harmful formic acid. The bird will then ingest the ant. This can be seen in European starlings, ''[[Sturnus vulgaris]]''.<ref name=":3">{{cite journal|last1=Judson|first1=Olivia|title='anting' as food preparation: formic acid is worse on an empty stomach|journal=Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology|date=1992 |volume=31|issue=6 |pages=437–439|doi=10.1007/BF00170611 |bibcode=1992BEcoS..31..437J }}</ref> |
||
=== Sensory self-stimulation === |
=== Sensory self-stimulation === |
||
Anting has been compared to human activities such as smoking and other external stimuli that serve no biological purpose and is just for [[self-stimulation]]. This hypothesis has been suggested as anting |
Anting has been compared to human activities such as smoking and other external stimuli that serve no biological purpose and is just for [[self-stimulation]]. This hypothesis has been suggested as anting has no obvious function, it is non-adaptive, birds are said to achieve pleasure from anting and anting has characteristics of a [[habit]]. However, there is no definitive evidence that sensory self-stimulation is the purpose of anting in birds. There have been several studies that claim to prove this hypothesis while others say just the opposite.<ref>{{cite journal|last1=Simmons|first1=K.E.L|title=Anting and the problem of self-stimulation|journal=Journal of Zoology|volume=149|issue=2|pages=145–162|doi=10.1111/j.1469-7998.1966.tb03890.x|year=2009}}</ref> |
||
=== Functions in molt === |
=== Functions in molt === |
||
It has been found that [[passerine birds]] [[molt]] in the summer months. These birds often focus much of the anting on their wings and tails. This is where the largest feathers emerge, and it has been suggested that anting helps stimulate the growth of these feathers during molt. Not all birds that ant do so during [[molt]].<ref name=": |
It has been found that [[passerine birds]] [[molt]] in the summer months. These birds often focus much of the anting on their wings and tails. This is where the largest feathers emerge, and it has been suggested that anting helps stimulate the growth of these feathers during molt. Not all birds that ant do so during [[molt]].<ref name=":2"/> |
||
== Species of ants used == |
== Species of ants used == |
||
Ants that spray and produce |
Ants that spray and produce formic acid for defense are used for anting more often than species which do not spray or produce formic acid. Species from the subfamily [[Formicinae]] are the most commonly chosen by birds. Species from [[Dolichoderinae]] and [[Myrmicinae]] subfamilies are also used for anting however, not as common as Formicinae. If given a choice a bird will choose an ant in the subfamily Formicinae over all other species.<ref name=":0" /> In total there are 24 ant species birds use for anting.<ref name=":0" /> |
||
== Substitutes of ants == |
== Substitutes of ants == |
||
Some birds participate in this anting behaviour but with other organisms and even objects. Some of the organisms birds use are [[Oxychilus alliarius|garlic snails]], [[amphipods]], [[millipedes]], dermapterans, [[caterpillars]], [[grasshoppers]], hemipterans, [[mealworm]] larvae, and [[wasps]].<ref name=": |
Some birds participate in this anting behaviour but with other organisms and even objects. Some of the organisms birds use are [[Oxychilus alliarius|garlic snails]], [[amphipods]], [[millipedes]], dermapterans, [[caterpillars]], [[grasshoppers]], hemipterans, [[mealworm]] larvae, and [[wasps]].<ref name=":0" /> |
||
==Related behaviours== |
==Related behaviours== |
||
| Line 41: | Line 43: | ||
[[dust bath|Dusting]] with soil from ant-hills has been considered by some as equivalent to anting.<ref name=j5/> |
[[dust bath|Dusting]] with soil from ant-hills has been considered by some as equivalent to anting.<ref name=j5/> |
||
Some birds like [[Antbird#Behaviour|antbird]]s and [[Northern flicker#Diet|flicker]]s not only ant, but also consume the ants as an important part of their diet. Other opportunist ant-eating birds include [[Old World sparrow|sparrow]]s, [[wren]]s, [[grouse]] and [[starlings]].<ref>{{cite book|last=Taber|first=Stephen Welton|title=The World of the Harvester Ants | series = W.L. Moody, jr. Natural History Series | publisher=Texas A&M University Press|year=1998|volume=23}}</ref> European honey-buzzards have been found to gather fresh maple branches on the ground and then spread themselves over it and it has been suggested that this might be a case of [[Tool use by animals|tool-use]] to attract ants for anting.<ref>{{cite journal|doi=10.1371/journal.pone.0206843|pmid=30462689|pmc=6248935|title=Non-foraging tool use in European Honey-buzzards: An experimental test|journal=PLOS ONE|volume=13|issue=11|pages=e0206843|year=2018|last1=Camacho|first1=Carlos|last2=Potti|first2=Jaime|bibcode=2018PLoSO..1306843C}}</ref> |
Some birds like [[Antbird#Behaviour|antbird]]s and [[Northern flicker#Diet|flicker]]s not only ant, but also consume the ants as an important part of their diet. Other opportunist ant-eating birds include [[Old World sparrow|sparrow]]s, [[wren]]s, [[grouse]] and [[starlings]].<ref>{{cite book|last=Taber|first=Stephen Welton|title=The World of the Harvester Ants | series = W.L. Moody, jr. Natural History Series | publisher=Texas A&M University Press|year=1998|volume=23}}</ref> European honey-buzzards have been found to gather fresh maple branches on the ground and then spread themselves over it and it has been suggested that this might be a case of [[Tool use by animals|tool-use]] to attract ants for anting.<ref>{{cite journal|doi=10.1371/journal.pone.0206843|pmid=30462689|pmc=6248935|title=Non-foraging tool use in European Honey-buzzards: An experimental test|journal=PLOS ONE|volume=13|issue=11|pages=e0206843|year=2018|last1=Camacho|first1=Carlos|last2=Potti|first2=Jaime|bibcode=2018PLoSO..1306843C|doi-access=free}}</ref> |
||
Similar to anting may be the observed habit some birds show of picking up cigarette butts, sometimes lit, and rubbing themselves with them.<ref>{{cite journal|author=Simmons, K.E.L.|title=A review of the anting-behaviour of passerine birds|journal=British Birds| volume=50| issue=10|pages=401–424| year=1957|url=https://www.britishbirds.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/article_files/V50/V50_N10/V50_N10_P401_424_A060.pdf}}</ref><ref>{{cite journal|author=Goodwin, Derek|year=1955| journal=Avicultural Magazine|volume=61|pages=21–25|title=Anting}}</ref> |
Similar to anting may be the observed habit some birds show of picking up cigarette butts, sometimes lit, and rubbing themselves with them.<ref>{{cite journal|author=Simmons, K.E.L.|title=A review of the anting-behaviour of passerine birds|journal=British Birds| volume=50| issue=10|pages=401–424| year=1957|url=https://www.britishbirds.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/article_files/V50/V50_N10/V50_N10_P401_424_A060.pdf}}</ref><ref>{{cite journal|author=Goodwin, Derek|year=1955| journal=Avicultural Magazine|volume=61|pages=21–25|title=Anting}}</ref> |
||
Latest revision as of 09:23, 17 December 2024
Anting is a maintenance behavior during which birds rub insects, usually ants, on their feathers and skin. The bird may pick up the insects in its bill and rub them on the body (active anting), or the bird may lie in an area of high density of the insects and perform dust bathing-like movements (passive anting). The insects secrete liquids containing chemicals such as formic acid, which can act as an insecticide, miticide, fungicide, or bactericide. Alternatively, anting could make the insects edible by removing the distasteful acid, or possibly supplement the bird's own preen oil. Instead of ants, birds can also use millipedes. More than 200 species of bird are known to ant.[1] A possibly related behaviour, self-anointing, is seen in many mammals.[1]
History
[edit]The first scientific writings of this behaviour dates back to 1831. American ornithologist John James Audubon described wild juvenile turkeys that "wallowed" in abandoned ant hills. Another description was published by a naturalist in 1847 in a manuscript called "Bird of Jamaica". In it the author describes how ants remove parasites from a tame crow, while the crow is foraging for food.[citation needed] In 1934 an Alexander Hugh Chisholm described in Bird Wonders of Australia, a strange relationship birds had with ants.[1] The behaviour was described by Erwin Stresemann in German as Einemsen in the German ornithology journal Ornithologische Monatsberichte (Volume XLIII, p. 138) in 1935. Indian ornithologist Salim Ali interpreted an observation by his cousin Humayun Abdulali in the 1936 volume of Journal of the Bombay Natural History Society and included a reference to the Stresemann's paper suggesting that the German term could be translated into English as "anting".[2]
Modes
[edit]Active
[edit]
Anting most commonly occurs on the ground but in some species, birds practice anting on tree branches. A bird will place the tip of its wing on the ground and rub its bill containing an ant from the tip of the wing up.[1] The tail is usually tucked between the legs and under the body, which results in the bird being unstable. Birds use one ant at a time and only rub a feather once with an ant. However, there are some cases where an ant is used more than once but never exceeds three uses.[1] There are some exceptions to this as starlings often take a ball of ants in their bills to be used for anting. Active anting happens very quickly and can often be mistaken for regular feather maintenance. This type of anting can last anywhere from just several minutes to half an hour. Most species of birds practice active anting and do this individually or in small groups. Birds may also use 'substitutes' in active anting. Birds have been seen to use snails, grasshoppers, amphipods and even larvae.[1]
Passive
[edit]Passive anting occurs when a bird rubs its wings and tail on an anthill. Once a bird has found an anthill it will then spread both of its wings forward at the same time. It will then sit on its tails which attracts the ants. Once the ants are on their wing feathers they provoke the ants by rubbing their head or beak through their feathers where the ants are. To prevent ants from crawling onto a bird's head or beak the bird will shake its head very quickly. The birds allow the ants to roam freely around its feathers. This type of anting is less common and is mostly seen in robins and ravens.[1]
Functions
[edit]Ridding of ectoparasites
[edit]Anting to get rid of ectoparasites is one hypothesis for anting in songbirds. This hypothesis suggests that birds use the chemical secretions that come from ants to control and get rid of parasites in their feathers. Microorganisms such as bacteria and fungi can destroy a bird's feathers if their numbers get large enough. Formic acid is a commonly produced chemical by ants, and it was found to inhibit growth of feather-destroying microorganisms.[3] However, there is little evidence that chemicals from ants help to remove or deter other parasites such as feather lice and mites.[3]
Feather grooming
[edit].jpg)
The hypothesis that anting is a form of feather maintenance suggests that anting brings saliva to the bird's feathers for use in preening. This helps to remove old preen oil and other substances.[4]
Food preparation
[edit]The food preparation hypothesis suggests that birds rub the ant in its feathers to remove a substance on the ant. Ants produce formic acid as an anti-predator adaptation. Thus, when an ant feels threatened, as when in the beak of a bird, it will spray formic acid. It is suggested that birds then rub the ants in their feathers to remove the harmful formic acid. The bird will then ingest the ant. This can be seen in European starlings, Sturnus vulgaris.[5]
Sensory self-stimulation
[edit]Anting has been compared to human activities such as smoking and other external stimuli that serve no biological purpose and is just for self-stimulation. This hypothesis has been suggested as anting has no obvious function, it is non-adaptive, birds are said to achieve pleasure from anting and anting has characteristics of a habit. However, there is no definitive evidence that sensory self-stimulation is the purpose of anting in birds. There have been several studies that claim to prove this hypothesis while others say just the opposite.[6]
Functions in molt
[edit]It has been found that passerine birds molt in the summer months. These birds often focus much of the anting on their wings and tails. This is where the largest feathers emerge, and it has been suggested that anting helps stimulate the growth of these feathers during molt. Not all birds that ant do so during molt.[4]
Species of ants used
[edit]Ants that spray and produce formic acid for defense are used for anting more often than species which do not spray or produce formic acid. Species from the subfamily Formicinae are the most commonly chosen by birds. Species from Dolichoderinae and Myrmicinae subfamilies are also used for anting however, not as common as Formicinae. If given a choice a bird will choose an ant in the subfamily Formicinae over all other species.[1] In total there are 24 ant species birds use for anting.[1]
Substitutes of ants
[edit]Some birds participate in this anting behaviour but with other organisms and even objects. Some of the organisms birds use are garlic snails, amphipods, millipedes, dermapterans, caterpillars, grasshoppers, hemipterans, mealworm larvae, and wasps.[1]
Related behaviours
[edit]Dusting with soil from ant-hills has been considered by some as equivalent to anting.[7]
Some birds like antbirds and flickers not only ant, but also consume the ants as an important part of their diet. Other opportunist ant-eating birds include sparrows, wrens, grouse and starlings.[8] European honey-buzzards have been found to gather fresh maple branches on the ground and then spread themselves over it and it has been suggested that this might be a case of tool-use to attract ants for anting.[9]
Similar to anting may be the observed habit some birds show of picking up cigarette butts, sometimes lit, and rubbing themselves with them.[10][11]
References
[edit]- ^ a b c d e f g h i j Morozov, N.S (July 31, 2014). "Why do birds practice anting?". Uspekhi Sovremennoi Biologii. 135: 97–112.
- ^ Ali, Salim (1936). "Do birds employ ants to rid themselves of ectoparasites?". J. Bombay Nat. Hist. Soc. 38 (3): 628–631.
- ^ a b Revis, Hannah (October 1, 2004). "Bactericidal and Fungicidal Activity of Ant Chemicals on Feather Parasites: An Evaluation of Anting Behavior as a Method of Self-Medication in Songbirds". The Auk. 121 (4): 1262–1268. doi:10.1093/auk/121.4.1262.
- ^ a b Potter, Eloise (October 1970). "Anting in Wild Birds, Its Frequency and Probable Purpose". The Auk. 87 (4): 692–713. doi:10.2307/4083703. JSTOR 4083703. S2CID 85784753.
- ^ Judson, Olivia (1992). "'anting' as food preparation: formic acid is worse on an empty stomach". Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology. 31 (6): 437–439. Bibcode:1992BEcoS..31..437J. doi:10.1007/BF00170611.
- ^ Simmons, K.E.L (2009). "Anting and the problem of self-stimulation". Journal of Zoology. 149 (2): 145–162. doi:10.1111/j.1469-7998.1966.tb03890.x.
- ^ Kelso, L.; Nice, Margaret M. (1963). "A Russian contribution to anting and feather mites" (PDF). The Wilson Bulletin. 75 (1): 23–26.
- ^ Taber, Stephen Welton (1998). The World of the Harvester Ants. W.L. Moody, jr. Natural History Series. Vol. 23. Texas A&M University Press.
- ^ Camacho, Carlos; Potti, Jaime (2018). "Non-foraging tool use in European Honey-buzzards: An experimental test". PLOS ONE. 13 (11): e0206843. Bibcode:2018PLoSO..1306843C. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0206843. PMC 6248935. PMID 30462689.
- ^ Simmons, K.E.L. (1957). "A review of the anting-behaviour of passerine birds" (PDF). British Birds. 50 (10): 401–424.
- ^ Goodwin, Derek (1955). "Anting". Avicultural Magazine. 61: 21–25.