Privative adjective: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
creating page |
Citation bot (talk | contribs) Alter: pages. Formatted dashes. | Use this bot. Report bugs. | Suggested by Superegz | Category:Grammar | #UCB_Category 196/210 |
||
| (7 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
In [[linguistics]], a '''privative adjective''' is an [[adjective]] which seems to exclude members of the [[extension (semantics)|extension]] of the [[noun]] which it |
In [[linguistics]], a '''privative adjective''' is an [[adjective]] which seems to exclude members of the [[extension (semantics)|extension]] of the [[noun]] which it modifies. For instance, "fake" is privative since a "fake nose" is not an actual nose. Other examples in English include "pretend", "fictitious", and "artificial". The defining feature of privative adjectives is shown below in set theoretic notation.<ref name="m">{{cite book |last=Morzycki|first= Marcin|date=2016|title=Modification |url=https://morzycki.github.io/work/papers/modification_book.pdf|publisher=Cambridge University Press |pages=25–26}}</ref><ref name= "ck">{{cite encyclopedia |last=Kennedy |first=Chris |editor-last1=Graff Fara |editor-first1=Delia | editor-last2=Russell |editor-first2=Gillian |encyclopedia=The Routledge Companion to Philosophy of Language |title=Adjectives |url=http://semantics.uchicago.edu/kennedy/docs/routledge.pdf|year=2012 |publisher= Routledge}}</ref> |
||
# An adjective <math>\text{Adj}</math> is ''privative'' if for any noun <math>\text{N}</math>, we have that <math>[\![ \text{Adj N} ]\!] \cap [\![\text{N}]\!] = \emptyset</math>. |
|||
Privative adjectives are non-[[subsective modifier|subsective]], but behave differently from ordinary non-subsectives in important respects, at least in [[English grammar|English]]. While ordinary non-subsectives such as the [[linguistic modality|modal]] adjective "alleged" can only be used in [[attributive adjective|attributive position]], privative adjectives can be used either in attributive or [[predicative adjective|predicative position]]. In this regard, privative adjectives pattern more like [[intersective adjective]]s such as "blue".<ref name = "m" /> |
Privative adjectives are non-[[subsective modifier|subsective]], but behave differently from ordinary non-subsectives in important respects, at least in [[English grammar|English]]. While ordinary non-subsectives such as the [[linguistic modality|modal]] adjective "alleged" can only be used in [[attributive adjective|attributive position]], privative adjectives can be used either in attributive or [[predicative adjective|predicative position]]. In this regard, privative adjectives pattern more like [[intersective adjective]]s such as "blue".<ref name = "m" /> |
||
| Line 12: | Line 14: | ||
# That pig is blue. (intersective, predicative) |
# That pig is blue. (intersective, predicative) |
||
In part because of this pattern, [[Barbara Partee|Partee |
In part because of this pattern, [[Barbara Partee|Partee]] (1997) argued that privative adjectives are in fact intersective adjectives which [[coercion (linguistics)|coerce]] a broader interpretation of the nouns they modify. On this analysis, listeners treat fake noses as falling within the extension of the noun "nose" because refusing to do so would render the expression "fake nose" self-contradictory.<ref name = "m" /> |
||
== See also == |
== See also == |
||
| Line 24: | Line 26: | ||
{{Reflist}} |
{{Reflist}} |
||
| ⚫ | |||
{{lexical categories|state=collapsed}} |
{{lexical categories|state=collapsed}} |
||
| Line 29: | Line 32: | ||
[[Category:Semantics]] |
[[Category:Semantics]] |
||
[[Category:Adjectives by type]] |
[[Category:Adjectives by type]] |
||
[[Category:Formal semantics (natural language)]] |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
Latest revision as of 02:52, 7 March 2023
In linguistics, a privative adjective is an adjective which seems to exclude members of the extension of the noun which it modifies. For instance, "fake" is privative since a "fake nose" is not an actual nose. Other examples in English include "pretend", "fictitious", and "artificial". The defining feature of privative adjectives is shown below in set theoretic notation.[1][2]
- An adjective is privative if for any noun , we have that .
![{\displaystyle [\![{\text{Adj N}}]\!]\cap [\![{\text{N}}]\!]=\emptyset }](https://wikimedia.org/enwiki/api/rest_v1/media/math/render/svg/49f15a04c4fda99134c43e27639a105361aee727)
Privative adjectives are non-subsective, but behave differently from ordinary non-subsectives in important respects, at least in English. While ordinary non-subsectives such as the modal adjective "alleged" can only be used in attributive position, privative adjectives can be used either in attributive or predicative position. In this regard, privative adjectives pattern more like intersective adjectives such as "blue".[1]
- Sara is an alleged spy. (non-subsective, attributive)
- #Sara is alleged. (non-subsective, predicative)
- That is a fake nose. (privative, attributive)
- That nose is fake. (privative, predicative)
- That is a blue pig. (intersective, attributive)
- That pig is blue. (intersective, predicative)
In part because of this pattern, Partee (1997) argued that privative adjectives are in fact intersective adjectives which coerce a broader interpretation of the nouns they modify. On this analysis, listeners treat fake noses as falling within the extension of the noun "nose" because refusing to do so would render the expression "fake nose" self-contradictory.[1]
See also
[edit]References
[edit]- ^ a b c Morzycki, Marcin (2016). Modification (PDF). Cambridge University Press. pp. 25–26.
- ^ Kennedy, Chris (2012). "Adjectives" (PDF). In Graff Fara, Delia; Russell, Gillian (eds.). The Routledge Companion to Philosophy of Language. Routledge.