User:Tabu Makiadi/sandbox: Difference between revisions
Tabu Makiadi (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Tabu Makiadi (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| (9 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 8: | Line 8: | ||
;Add Consumer Price Index |
;Add Consumer Price Index |
||
;Add Distribution |
;Add Distribution |
||
;Add Remittance |
|||
;Add FDI |
|||
;Add Diminishing returns |
;Add Diminishing returns |
||
;Add Cartel |
;Add Cartel |
||
| Line 23: | Line 25: | ||
;Add Economic surplus |
;Add Economic surplus |
||
== Economy and law by country removals == |
|||
Currently, we have 24 "Politics by country," 34 "Economy by country," and 37 "Law by country" articles. I won’t go into the details of each entry, but I want to consider whether some of these articles truly deserve VA5 status. For example, are there specific elements of the {{VA link|Law of the Netherlands}} or the {{VA link|Law of Romania}} that are essential for an average, educated person? Should we focus on countries in greater flux, like {{VA link|Economy of Argentina}}, rather than larger economies like Poland or Taiwan? These proposals aim to reduce to 30 the number of "Law" and "Economy by country" entries. If you disagree, let me know if it’s the specific countries selected or if the list is already appropriately sized and doesn’t need significant cuts. |
|||
*{{VA link|Economy of the Republic of Ireland}} |
|||
*{{VA link|Economy of Switzerland}} |
|||
*{{VA link|Economy of South Africa}} |
|||
*{{VA link|Economy of Argentina}} |
|||
*{{VA link|Law of Venezuela}} |
|||
*{{VA link|Law of Sweden}} |
|||
*{{VA link|Law of Mexico}} |
|||
*{{VA link|Law of Romania}} |
|||
*{{VA link|Law of Iraq}} |
|||
*{{VA link|Law of Taiwan}} |
|||
*{{VA link|Law of the Netherlands}} |
|||
;Support |
|||
#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 20:42, 18 August 2024 (UTC) |
|||
;Oppose |
|||
;Discuss |
|||
*For the econ removals, I used [[List of countries by GDP (PPP)]] for reference. The proposed economies are the lowest ranked among the ones listed. The Law by country articles have 5 or fewer interwikis. |
|||
==Various society additions== |
|||
;Add post-structuralism and deconstruction |
|||
Major concept in the humanities and the social sciences. |
|||
;Add Peruvian cuisine |
;Add Peruvian cuisine |
||
Consistently ranked in the Top 15 |
Consistently ranked in the Top 15 |
||
;Add Erotica |
;Add Erotica |
||
;Add Cantar de gesta (forgot the word for this) |
;Add Cantar de gesta (forgot the word for this) |
||
;Add Imperial House of Japan |
|||
Japan’s imperial family is the oldest continuous hereditary monarchy in the world, with an unbroken agnatic line since the early 6th century. |
|||
;Add Aztec Sun stone |
;Add Aztec Sun stone |
||
;Add Titian’s Venus |
|||
| Line 92: | Line 64: | ||
;Discuss |
;Discuss |
||
Case Western Reserve University |
|||
Add humanitarian aid |
|||
Baylor University |
|||
Add Cruelty to animals |
|||
University of North Carolina |
|||
Add Gurdwara |
|||
Claremont Colleges |
|||
Pomona College |
|||
Kenya |
|||
Ethiopia |
|||
{{}} |
|||
Bangladesh |
|||
Media strategy |
|||
Phillippines |
|||
News council |
|||
Thailand |
|||
Network media |
|||
Vietnam |
|||
Residual media |
|||
Iran |
|||
Sunday magazine |
|||
South Korea |
|||
Gustav Le Bon |
|||
Spain |
|||
Henry Fayol |
|||
Poland |
|||
Acemoglu |
|||
Canada |
|||
Mariátegui |
|||
Claudia Goldin |
|||
== Remove {{VA link|Nancy Spungen}} == |
|||
Hans Geiger |
|||
Some sections are more pressed for space. I would propose removing her considering we don't list Sid Vicious, and he's not a particularly close call. |
|||
Carl Seizz |
|||
;Support |
|||
#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 20:55, 1 September 2024 (UTC) |
|||
;Oppose |
|||
;Discuss |
|||
== Remove {{VA link|Harry Kendall Thaw}} == |
|||
"He is most notable for murdering the renowned architect [[Stanford White]]", who is not VA5, and which has been named, the "[[trial of the century]]" but that's a long list |
|||
== Remove {{VA link|Sebastián Garcilaso de la Vega y Vargas}} == |
|||
Lesser known explorer and conquistador. Seems to be most known as the father of Inca Garcilaso de la Vega. |
|||
Jean-Baptiste-Camille Corot |
|||
== Remove {{VA link|Eugene Klein (philatelist)}} and {{VA link|Walter Breen}} == |
|||
Kanye West |
|||
How many stamp or coin collectors should we list? Six are way too many. |
|||
Liu Xiaobo |
|||
Henry Kissinger |
|||
François de La Rochefoucauld |
|||
Eric Heiden and Luciana Aymar |
|||
== Remove {{VA link|André Borschberg}} == |
|||
For starters, we would still have another person representing the sport: ___ and ___ |
|||
The article states he has broken a few world records, but it has been tagged for self-promotion and lacks sources. |
|||
You could argue that they are not all that different from the others in terms of the achievements of the person holding the spot, but that seems to me to be more of a reason to remove them than otherwise. I don't enjoy going against gender parity, but (along with Marta) she's the only South American woman we list. I would rather have someone like Gabriela Mistral or Eva Perón, who's also Argentinian and a widely known figure in global pop culture. Maybe also Juana de la Cruz, who is not South American but is increasingly seen as the greatest writer of the Colonial-era Americas. |
|||
== Remove {{VA link|Milton A. Rothman}} == |
|||
He founded a Science fiction convention. Not much claim vitality. |
|||
== Remove {{VA link|Nancy Spungen}} == |
|||
Some sections are more pressed for space. I would propose removing her considering we don't list Sid Vicious, and he's not a particularly close call. |
|||
15,185 to 15,000. |
15,185 to 15,000. |
||
| Line 142: | Line 112: | ||
== Remove {{VA link|Sataspes}} == |
== Remove {{VA link|Sataspes}} == |
||
I wish we had more ancient explorers, but everything we know about him comes from a few pages from Herodotus. |
I wish we had more ancient explorers, but everything we know about him comes from a few pages from Herodotus. |
||
=== Remove {{VA link|John Steuart Curry}} === |
|||
One of the three great painters of American Regionalism of the first half of the twentieth century. Obviously important, but Being one of the most important people in an art movement does not automatically make you vital. Regionalism is VA5. |
|||
=== Remove {{VA link|Ron Galella}} === |
|||
We don't list Paparazzi. |
|||
=== Remove {{VA link|Richard Prince}} === |
|||
Best known for Cowboy photo |
|||
=== Remove {{VA link|Carleton Watkins}} === |
|||
Not among the 19th century's most important photographers. |
|||
=== Remove {{VA link|Lady Pink}} === |
|||
Graffiti artist. |
|||
=== Remove {{VA link|Shōji Hamada}} === |
|||
Pottery maker. |
|||
2NE1 |
|||
=== Remove {{VA link|William Billings}} === |
|||
"Regarded as the first American choral composer" |
|||
=== Remove {{VA link|Silver Horn}} === |
|||
Native American artist. 1 interwiki |
|||
=== Remove {{VA link|Chicago (band)}} and {{VA link|Foreigner (band)}}=== |
|||
My Journey proposal failed |
|||
=== Remove {{VA link|DeFord Bailey}} and {{VA link|Slim Dusty}}=== |
|||
Latest revision as of 00:16, 21 October 2024
Tabu Makiadi (talk) 17:27, 11 August 2024 (UTC)
Potential proposals?
[edit]- Swap Modern monetary theory with Heterodox economics
- Swap Allocative efficiency with Economic efficiency
- Add Rationing
- Add Aggregate Demand
- Add Consumer Price Index
- Add Distribution
- Add Remittance
- Add FDI
- Add Diminishing returns
- Add Cartel
- Add Efficient market hypothesis
- Add ETF
- Add Fair trade
- Add Fixed Costs
- Business expenses that remain constant regardless of the level of production or sales.
- Add Marketing Mix (4 Ps)
- The set of actions or tactics that a company uses to promote its brand or product in the market, typically consisting of Product, Price, Place, and Promotion
- Add International economics
- Add development economics
- Add Stagflation
- Add Austerity
- Add Ceteris paribus
- Add Economic surplus
- Add Peruvian cuisine
Consistently ranked in the Top 15
- Add Erotica
- Add Cantar de gesta (forgot the word for this)
- Add Aztec Sun stone
Sports removals
[edit]Remove Quidditch (real-life sport) Not quite a meme sport, but not significant enough to be here. It’s not even officially called Quidditch anymore.
- Support
- As nominator. Tabu Makiadi (talk) 19:50, 4 June 2024 (UTC)
- Oppose
- Discuss
Remove Robot combat
Let’s appease our AI overlords
- Support
- As nominator. Tabu Makiadi (talk) 19:50, 4 June 2024 (UTC)
- Oppose
- Discuss
Remove Cycle speedway 
5 and Fly casting 5
[edit]
Minor cycle sport and competition fishing competitions respectively
- Support
- As nominator. Tabu Makiadi (talk) 19:50, 4 June 2024 (UTC)
- Oppose
- Discuss
Case Western Reserve University
Baylor University University of North Carolina Claremont Colleges Pomona College
{{}}
Media strategy
News council
Network media
Residual media Sunday magazine
Gustav Le Bon Henry Fayol Acemoglu Mariátegui Claudia Goldin
Remove Nancy Spungen 5
[edit]Some sections are more pressed for space. I would propose removing her considering we don't list Sid Vicious, and he's not a particularly close call.
- Support
- As nominator. Tabu Makiadi (talk) 20:55, 1 September 2024 (UTC)
- Oppose
- Discuss
Jean-Baptiste-Camille Corot
Kanye West
Liu Xiaobo
Henry Kissinger
François de La Rochefoucauld
Eric Heiden and Luciana Aymar For starters, we would still have another person representing the sport: ___ and ___ You could argue that they are not all that different from the others in terms of the achievements of the person holding the spot, but that seems to me to be more of a reason to remove them than otherwise. I don't enjoy going against gender parity, but (along with Marta) she's the only South American woman we list. I would rather have someone like Gabriela Mistral or Eva Perón, who's also Argentinian and a widely known figure in global pop culture. Maybe also Juana de la Cruz, who is not South American but is increasingly seen as the greatest writer of the Colonial-era Americas.
15,185 to 15,000. Entertainers 2175 - 2150 Social Scientists 1360 - 1350 Miscellaneous 1,200 - 1,150 Health 1140 - 1125
Cullture 1750 - 1850
I wish we had more ancient explorers, but everything we know about him comes from a few pages from Herodotus.
Remove John Steuart Curry 5
[edit]One of the three great painters of American Regionalism of the first half of the twentieth century. Obviously important, but Being one of the most important people in an art movement does not automatically make you vital. Regionalism is VA5.
Remove Ron Galella 5
[edit]We don't list Paparazzi.
Remove Richard Prince 5
[edit]Best known for Cowboy photo
Remove Carleton Watkins 5
[edit]Not among the 19th century's most important photographers.
Graffiti artist.
Remove Shōji Hamada 5
[edit]Pottery maker.
2NE1
Remove William Billings 5
[edit]"Regarded as the first American choral composer"
Remove Silver Horn 5
[edit]Native American artist. 1 interwiki
Remove Chicago (band) 5 and Foreigner (band) 5
[edit]My Journey proposal failed