Jump to content

Talk:Albanian language: Difference between revisions

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous edit
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
→Mešari: Response
 
(771 intermediate revisions by more than 100 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Old peer review|archive=1}}
{{LanguageTalk}}
{{WikiProject Europe}}
{{WikiProject banner shell|class=C|vital=yes|
1=
{{oldpeerreview}}
{{WikiProject Languages|importance=high}}
'''[[Talk:Albanian language Archive 1|Archive 1]]'''
{{WikiProject Albania|importance=Top}}
{{WikiProject Kosovo|importance=Top}}
{{WikiProject Anthropology|oral-tradition=yes}}
}}
{{contentious topics/page restriction talk notice|protection=semi|e-e}}


{{archives|auto=long|search=yes|bot=MiszaBot I|age=100|index=/Archive index}}
== Kwami's input II ==
{{User:MiszaBot/config
|archiveheader = {{aan}}
|maxarchivesize = 100K
|counter = 4
|minthreadsleft = 4
|algo = old(100d)
|archive = Talk:Albanian language/Archive %(counter)d
}}
{{User:HBC Archive Indexerbot/OptIn
|target=/Archive index
|mask=/Archive <#>
|leading_zeros=0
|indexhere=yes}}


== Inherited roots ==
Hey again - Another two cents.
The section "Historical presence and location" contrasts native words with borrowed loan words of foreign origin, when the more natural comparison would be native words versus commonly inherited ones, since it is an IE language just like Italic Celtic Germanic etc


== Spelling-to-sound: ‹r› ==
*"1.1 How Albanian compares with other languages"
:This isn't quite what I meant. It's a collection of vocabulary, but the words aren't all [[cognate]]s. What I was thinking (and it should probably go later in the article, say in the vocabulary section) will take a bit more research. For other branches of Indo-European, there are specific articles for the branch (Germanic languages, Slavic languages, etc.) which ideally would summarize how the branch developed from proto-Indo-European and maybe how it relates to other branches. But for the Albanian branch, there's just Albanian (maybe that could be your next project - people would appreciate it!). What I thought would be useful would be a list of ''cognates'' showing how Albanian relates to other IE languages. *gw &rarr; /g, z/, etc. Well, most of the details belong in the Indo-European article, which currently has nothing on Albanian, but it would be interesting to have a few of the quirks here too. Even just a list of indigenous Albanian numerals and pronouns, showing their similarities but also divergences from other IE languages, would be interesting. Or maybe some examples of how Albanian can look quite different from Greek, even when the words are related.
*Is the only diff in the phoneme inventories of Gheg and Tosk that Gheg has a set of nasal vowels? Are all the vowels found nasalized? Also not clear from the text or the table if final schwa reduction is a feature of Tosk, or of Gheg compared to Tosk.
*Case: I refer you to [[Balkan_Sprachbund#Syncretism_of_genitive_and_dative|Balkan genitive-dative merger]]. Albanian does not have a genitive case, and it should be removed from the table. Perhaps you could have a note, ''instead of a genitive case, Albanian uses with dative with the preposition X'' or something. The constructions aren't identical in Albanian, unlike Bulgarian, but [[case]] is an inflection of the noun, and Albanian doesn't inflect its nouns specially for a genitive. Or you could leave just the dative row, but label it "genitive/dative", and in a note say ''for the genitive, the preposition X is used''.
*Don't know what you mean by 6 "types" of mood. Should it be 6 moods?
*The word for a negative imperative is 'prohibitive': "In prohibitive clauses [or "negative commands", if you prefer], the particle ''mos'' is used".
*The English pronunciation equivalents are confusing, especially with their odd mixture of capital and lower case letters. I find them illegible. If you want a spelling pronunciation, I have one at [[Asteroid pronunciation key]] that's worked pretty well and which you might use. Or you could simply remove this and stick with the IPA and sound files, which should be enough for anyone.
Cheers, [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 00:58, 9 November 2005 (UTC)


Shouldn't ‹r› actually be {{IPA|/ɽ/}}? It does not sound like an alveolar tap, but like a retroflex flap.
::hello,
::Just a couple of words about colour words in Albanian used in the comparison chart. The word for 'yellow' in standard literary Albanian is 'i verdhë' and not 'i gjelbër/i blertë'(which mean green); 'jeshile' in the green column is just another synonym for 'i gjelbër/i blertë'. However, in various areas in Northern Albania and Kosova, 'i gjelbër' (but to my knowledge not 'i blertë') means 'yellow', while 'i verdhë' means 'green'. To complicate matters further, I personally know of a couple of villages in Kosova where people use 'i verdhë' to mean 'blue'. [[User:84.70.84.73|84.70.84.73]] 15:49, 14 January 2007 (UTC)


== Spelling-to-sound: ‹r› ==
== copy vio and possible pov? ==
First of all the phrase "and by smaller numbers of ethnic Albanians in other parts of the southern Balkans, along the east coast of Italy and in Sicily, in southern Greece, and in Germany, Sweden, the United States, Ukraine, and Belgium." is copy paste from [http://64.233.183.104/search?q=cache:jg-toagRQ9YJ:www.britannica.com/eb/article-9109785+by+smaller+numbers+of+ethnic+Albanians+in+other+parts+of+the+southern+Balkans Britanica], that means using it is a possible copyright violation.


Shouldn't ‹r› actually be {{IPA|/ɽ/}}? It does not sound like an alveolar tap, but like a retroflex flap.
Apart from that I think that the previous phrasing ([http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Albanian_language&diff=prev&oldid=27757716 see here]) is more NPOV. [[User:Matia.gr|+MATIA]] <small>[[User talk:Matia.gr|&#9742;]]</small> 10:43, 9 November 2005 (UTC)


== Spelling-to-sound <gj> and q==
:Could you tell us what's POV about the Britannica quote? [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 11:33, 9 November 2005 (UTC)


Shouldn't it be changed to voiced and voiceless palatal affricates respectively?
[[Arvanites]] are not [[ethnic Albanians]] is a good start... Can you notice any other differences between the two versions? [[User:Matia.gr|+MATIA]] <small>[[User talk:Matia.gr|&#9742;]]</small> 11:37, 9 November 2005 (UTC)


== Albanian stops are unaspirated ==
:This article is not about the Arvanites or their language. We are talking about the (officially inexistant) Çam Muslim and Orthodox communities. I'm sure that that's what [[Britannica]] is talking about and I don't think that Britannica is POV (imagine that). I also highly doubt that it is a possible copyright violation as it is a phrase. If you like, I can ask the Help Desk to check it. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 12:24, 9 November 2005 (UTC)


http://mudrac.ffzg.unizg.hr/~rmatasov/Albanian.pdf That means the english examples should be changed. /p/ is not pronounced like in 'pen', but like in 'spin'.
REX we've been through all these before. The Chams were about 40.000 and they left (let's not get into the reasons now), during the 2nd world war. And the majority of the Cham people were muslims, like the majority of Tosks were christians. All these people are reffered by scholars (for example the editors of Britanica) as Albanians. The majority of "Albanians" (sic) in Greece are not the Chams nor the Albanian workers (since 1992) but the Arvanites. They spoke Arvanitika which some scholars call Albanian, etc. With your search on Albanian language, you 'll see various things that perhaps I've already read, and I think that you'll agree with me. Please give a shot, trying to understand my explanation.


== e and o are higher than the table shows, almost same level or higher than ë ==
As for [[Britannica]] if we could copy-paste it, it would be interesting, but I'm afraid we can't. Read [[Talk:1911 Encyclopædia Britannica]] and [[Wikipedia:1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica]]. Both the 1911 and the current Britannica are excellent encyclopedias but a) we can't copy-paste from the new one because of copyright (we can't even use the name Britannica for citing the 1911) and b) read [[WP:PD#Please_don.27t_data_dump.21|WP:PD]] about bias - I'm not making it up, I'm trying to help you and to discuss that change. [[User:Matia.gr|+MATIA]] <small>[[User talk:Matia.gr|&#9742;]]</small> 12:42, 9 November 2005 (UTC)


http://www.kfs.oeaw.ac.at/publications/2003_moosmueller_granser_the_vowels_of_standard_albanian.pdf
:What about the 30,000 Shqiptarë, don't they exist? Honestly, are you saying that [[Britannica]] has published a ''gross inaccurracy''? I simply fail to see why you are trying to cover up the fact that there are ethnic Albanians in Greece. What about the 600,000 Albanian immigrants, they even outnumber the Arvanites! If you object to quoting Britannica, why didn't you object to the following, which has been there for months and was removed by me [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Albanian_language&diff=prev&oldid=27644090 diff]:''Languages sharing a common origin with [[Tosk language|Tosk]] are spoken in [[Italy|Italian]] and [[Greece|Greek]] enclaves and appear to be related most closely to the dialect of [[Çamëria]] in the extreme south of [[Albania]].'' That is a blatant copypaste of Britannica which under POV processing resulted in that. Or does copypasting individual sentences amount to copyright violation only in selective cases? As far as I know it isn't (5% is allowed). The only think we can do is to ask if it is. Perhaps quoting Ethnologue's figures is a copyvio. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 13:20, 9 November 2005 (UTC)


== Albanian Is a Balto-Slavic Language ==
I'm not trying to cover up anything. I've wrote about the ethnic Albanians who came to work in Greece (check my text for the word 1992). Verify with a wikipedia expert what I wrote if you don't believe what I write, or if you can't understand the links I gave you before. PS Ethnologue allows to be cited as a refference and they are linguists. [[User:Matia.gr|+MATIA]] <small>[[User talk:Matia.gr|&#9742;]]</small> 13:27, 9 November 2005 (UTC)


{{Archive top
::Can I please point out that I myself am Arvanite, or in our own language, Arberesh! We are very much Albanian, but of pre=Ottoman heritage and therefore do not call ourselves Shqiptars. Many Arvanitika people fail to call themselves Albanians because of the association with Shqiptars, which we are not. I find it odd that anyone could say that we don't exist, someobody forgot to tell me I was dead! {{unsigned|82.36.157.223|23:31, 5 June 2006 (UTC)}}
|status = [[WP:NOTFORUM]]
|result = Also: [[WP:DFTT]]. [[User:Austronesier|Austronesier]] ([[User talk:Austronesier|talk]]) 19:04, 1 September 2024 (UTC)
}}
If carefully studied the Albanian language and the Balto-Slvavic languages share the same roots. Linguists in Albania are more interested in politics than language studies. Only a few linguists study Ukrainian, Russian, Belorussian, Bulgarian, Polish, Serbo-Croat and Albanian at the same time. If all these languages were carefully studied the only objective conclusion that could be derived from it is that the Albanian language is a branch of Slavic languages. [[Special:Contributions/2600:1700:36D0:9B0:5179:180A:4CB4:2AF8|2600:1700:36D0:9B0:5179:180A:4CB4:2AF8]] ([[User talk:2600:1700:36D0:9B0:5179:180A:4CB4:2AF8|talk]]) 02:08, 17 August 2024 (UTC)


:Albanian is part of, but a separate branch of, the Indo-European family.
:* "Albanian forms a separate branch of Indo-European and cannot conclusively be closely connected with any other Indo-European language." {{endash}} https://lrc.la.utexas.edu/eieol/albol
:* "...several innovations define Albanian and set it apart from all other branches of IE..." {{endash}} https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/indoeuropean-language-family/albanian/235881199CF63D7E9D60E32DA7362DD9
:* "Albanian (shqip or gjuha shqipe in the language) is an Indo-European language and the only remaining language to represent the old Albanoid branch of Indo-European languages." {{endash}} https://u.osu.edu/discoveringalbania/language/
:[[User:Snowman304|'''Snowman304''']]'''&#124;'''[[User talk:Snowman304|'''talk''']] 02:19, 17 August 2024 (UTC)
::Citations from linguist who specialize on a different area of language and heavily based on what is usually cited by the Albanian linguists who get very angry if something that does not confirm their theories is presented. These citations do not even mention the fact that 70% of Gheg Albanian words who are based in the Slavic languages have been wiped out of the Albanian language since Tosk became the standard language such as mir (Slavic), mirë (Albanian), good (English); kone (Slavic), kene (Gheg Albanian), qene (Tosk Albanian), be (English); bogatu (Slavic), banu gati (Gheg Albanian), behu gati (Tosk Albanian) get ready (English); plujc (Slavic), prush (Gheg Albanian), zjarr (Tosk Albanian), fire (English). This whole page can be filled with similarities but there is no point of including all of them here. If Slavic languages and Albanian were seriously and objectively studied the conclusion would clearly be that the entire grammatical structure and dictionary of the Albanian language is rooted in Slavic. The similarities are so astonishing that there is no other explanation. [[Special:Contributions/2600:1700:36D0:9B0:5179:180A:4CB4:2AF8|2600:1700:36D0:9B0:5179:180A:4CB4:2AF8]] ([[User talk:2600:1700:36D0:9B0:5179:180A:4CB4:2AF8|talk]]) 03:19, 17 August 2024 (UTC)
:::[[WP:OR]] Wikipedia does not work via Original Research. Also im not a slavic speaker but at least i know that Slavic Good it means Dobro not Mir. Mir means Peace so here it goes also the POV pushing and Non Reliable Sourcing.[[User:RoyalHeritageAlb|RoyalHeritageAlb]] ([[User talk:RoyalHeritageAlb|talk]]) 09:43, 17 August 2024 (UTC)
::::Language is language and the Albanians similar to Serbs have the tendency to comingle language with politics. For example, Serbs similar to Albanians claim that the Serbian language has nothing in common with the Croatian language, which in fact is not true it is very similar. They do that for political reasons. The same with the Albanian linguists, they fail to see the resemblance that exists between the Slavic languages and the Albanian language because they believe that somehow it helps them politically by identifying the Albanian language as unique in the midst of other languages when in fact it is not unique but is rooted in the Balto-Slavic languages. The fact is that the Balto-Slavic is the nearest kin of the Albanian language. Objectively speaking there is no dispute about that. Take the alphabet, for example, in addition to the similarity in vocabulary, as clearly seen in my previous comment, the Albanian alphabet has letters that are unique only to the Slavic languages despite the heavy modifications done to the original Albanian alphabet and the introduction of ë since Tosk became the standard Albanian. Despite all of that there are still letters that are unique only to the Slavic and Albanian languages, such as gj(Ð), sh(Š), c(ts), zh(Ž), q (tsh), nj. Just because a letter, for example, is written as gj instead of (Ð) it does not make it different. It is the same letter. [[Special:Contributions/2600:1700:36D0:9B0:A4:4E02:F41C:2727|2600:1700:36D0:9B0:A4:4E02:F41C:2727]] ([[User talk:2600:1700:36D0:9B0:A4:4E02:F41C:2727|talk]]) 15:46, 17 August 2024 (UTC)
:::::How about "rrotkari" translate that to slavic. [[Special:Contributions/2600:8801:222:C600:3D5C:1290:C41D:1CB7|2600:8801:222:C600:3D5C:1290:C41D:1CB7]] ([[User talk:2600:8801:222:C600:3D5C:1290:C41D:1CB7|talk]]) 11:15, 23 August 2024 (UTC)
:Explains why nearly every Messapic word has a cognate in Albanian. 2/10 ragebait. [[Special:Contributions/141.98.141.192|141.98.141.192]] ([[User talk:141.98.141.192|talk]]) 17:59, 1 September 2024 (UTC)
{{Archive bottom}}


== Mešari ==
I think the point here is whether the language of Arvanit is albanian or not. The pre-otoman name of Albania was Arbani and even the albanians of that time called themselves Arbaneshe. In greek you can see the change of B->V which makes is Arvani. Also the Arbanesh or Arberesh (with n->r rotacion in southern tosk dialect)which live nowadays in Itali call themselves, Arberesh and not Albanians. This does not exclude the fact that they are of Albanian origin and they speak Albanian language. - [[User:Aigest|Aigest]] 10:16, 10 September 2007 (UTC)


Mešari which is supposedly the first recorded in the "Albanian" language is entirely based in Latin. "Unë" in "Albanian", uno in Italian, one in English [[https://www.bbc.co.uk/languages/italian/language_notes/un.shtml]]. Pagëzoj in "Albanian", baptismo in Italian, baptize in English [[https://www.google.com/search?q=baptismo+in+english&sca_esv=ff32f5a8439f7af1&ei=Ru9DZ4yWFa-zwt0P07yCuAk&oq=baptismo&gs_lp=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&sclient=gws-wiz-serp]]. Emër in "Albanian", nome in Italian, name in English etc. etc. etc. etc. So, it makes no sense to include the entire translation of Mešari here but clearly the "Albanian" language is not unique but a mix of Latin, Slavic, Greek, and Turkish languages. [[Special:Contributions/2600:1700:36D0:9B0:B878:7B7B:BAC0:B79A|2600:1700:36D0:9B0:B878:7B7B:BAC0:B79A]] ([[User talk:2600:1700:36D0:9B0:B878:7B7B:BAC0:B79A|talk]]) 03:42, 25 November 2024 (UTC)
== Albanian phonetics ==


:I agree. The "Albanian" language is a very beautiful language, and the reason why it is a very beautiful language is because it is a mixed language and traces of Latin, Slavic, Greek and Turkish can be found in it, not because it is unique. [[Special:Contributions/2600:1700:36D0:9B0:B878:7B7B:BAC0:B79A|2600:1700:36D0:9B0:B878:7B7B:BAC0:B79A]] ([[User talk:2600:1700:36D0:9B0:B878:7B7B:BAC0:B79A|talk]]) 04:11, 25 November 2024 (UTC)
I'll repeat a question I posed a few months back, in the hope that somebody has an answer. In the audio examples provided, Albanian ''r'' definitely sounds like an English [[alveolar approximant]] ({{IPA|ɹ}}), not a Spanish [[alveolar flap]] ({{IPA|ɾ}}) as claimed in the article. Can anyone confirm this? No audio is provided for ''rr'' to establish whether it is in fact an [[alveolar trill]] ({{IPA|r}}). Also, ''gj'' and ''q'' are given as the [[voiced palatal plosive|voiced]] ({{IPA|ɟ}}) and [[voiceless palatal plosive]] ({{IPA|c}}) respectively, even though they sound more like the postalveolar affricates [[voiced postalveolar affricate|{{IPA|dʒ}}]] and [[voiceless postalveolar affricate|{{IPA|tʃ}}]] rather than true palatal plosives.--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 13:46, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
::I don't understand the point you're trying to make, and I think you don't know either. Your behavior exhibits signs of self-talking. Perhaps stop edit-warring on this article.

::Also, unë does not mean "one" in Albanian, but "I". Words can seem as Latin as they want to be, still, Alb. "katër" (4) independently evolved from PIE *kʷétur- without Latin influence (quattuor). Also, it's named "Meshari" not "Mesâri". Your statements lack existence and usage of high-quality sources in academic scholarship.
:Well, [http://www.omniglot.com/writing/albanian.htm Omniglot] seems to indicate that everything is as they are on the article now. I am more concerned about the tables on [[Greek language]]. Are there [[voiced palatal plosive|voiced]] ({{IPA|ɟ}}) and [[voiceless palatal plosive]]s ({{IPA|c}}) in Greek? If so, can you provide us with some kind of source? I can't find anything. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 13:59, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
::Thanks. [[User:AlexBachmann|AlexBachmann]] ([[User talk:AlexBachmann|talk]]) 19:53, 25 November 2024 (UTC)
::To my ears, the audio samples in the relevant articles for [[voiceless palatal plosive|{{IPA|c}}]] and [[voiced palatal plosive|{{IPA|ɟ}}]] are the second consonants in κακιά and μαγκιά, which would mean that Greek does indeed have true palatal plosives. In the case of Albanian it would appear that the symbols are instead being used for postalveolar affricates, perhaps to distinguish ''q'' and ''gj'' from ''ç'' and ''xh''. Do ''q'' and ''ç'', and ''gj'' and ''xh'', really sound different? The audio samples for ''shqip'' and ''tungjatjeta'' in this article definitely sound much more like [{{IPA|ʃtʃip}}] and [{{IPA|tun dʒat jɛ ta}}].--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 14:15, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
:::I just checked your Omniglot reference and in fact ''both'' ''ç'' and ''q'' are assigned the IPA symbol for the [[voiceless postalveolar affricate|{{IPA|tʃ}}]], as I correctly suspected. However, it assigns [[voiced palatal plosive|{{IPA|ɟ}}]] to ''gj'' and [[voiced postalveolar affricate|{{IPA|dʒ}}]] to ''xh''. Now that ''is'' intriguing! :)--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 14:21, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
Isn't that [[WP:NOR|original research]]? κακιά and μαγκιά sound like /kakja/ and /magja/ to me. Also, I was in Cyprus the other day and it sounded quite different (wanna know how)? I'll require a definete source for the presence of those sounds in Greek, or I'll change due to lack of sources. Omniglot denies the existence of those phonemes [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 15:55, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
:No, /kakja/ and /magja/ is how foreigners like you would pronounce those words in Greece. The Greeks pronounce them with a single chop of the tongue.--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 16:52, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
Not really, I have lived in Greece for 11 years, I know how it's pronounced, just in the same way that I know that in Tirana, qen (dog) is pronounced exectly like the Greek word κεν (your version). It is pronounced chen in Shkoder I think, it depends on the dialect. Do find a source. There is no evidence to support the existence of those phonemes in Greek. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 17:01, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
:Actually, you have just proved to yourself that those phonemes do exist. If Greek ''κεν'' is pronounced "exactly" the same as Albanian ''qen'', as you claim, and Albanian ''q'' is the [[voiceless palatal plosive]], as you claim, then by your own admission it exists in Greek too. But Omniglot claims Albanian ''q'' is pronounced [[voiceless postalveolar affricate|{{IPA|tʃ}}]], while ''κεν'' is not, in standard Greek at least.--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 17:17, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
According to Omniglot, if there were a Greek word κεν, it would be pronounced /kεn/. Maybe that should be made clear in the article [[Greek language]], that palatat plosives don't exist in Greek. If they do, please provide evidence. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 17:22, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
:Omniglot does not dispute the existence of those sounds in Greek, it simply fails to mention what happens to k and g before the front vowels e and i. It is not an exhaustive analysis of Greek phonology.--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 17:17, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
Really, then why don't we add [[click consonant|clicks]] to the [[Greek language]] article? There is no source that says that there isn't. This is an encyclopaedia, you don't build encyclopaedias by natural deduction. It's not for me to prove that those sounds don't exist. It's for you to prove that they do exist. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 17:28, 9 November 2005 (UTC)

Oops, would you look at [http://www.phon.ucl.ac.uk/home/johnm/ips/chapter4/ips4-4.htm that]. The [[University of London]] obviously has no problem in saying that "q" is a voiceless palatal plosive. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 17:41, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
:I guess we have a clash of sources. ''Mais quoi de faire''?--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 17:43, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
Not really. Omniglot is a private website run by an amateur polyglot. The UCL obviously carries more weight, AND says that r is a voiced alveolar tap, that rr is voiced alveolar trill, that gj is a voiced palatal plosive, that q is a voiceless palatal plosive etc. Who shall prevail? [[WP:RC]] [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 17:46, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
:So I guess you can't use Omniglot to justify your claims that there are no palatal plosives in Greek. Thanks for the clarification.--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 17:49, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
I guess so. What a pity that I created and added those [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Greek_language&diff=8732696&oldid=8559501 tables] to the [[Greek language]] article claiming the existence of palatal plosives in Greek. I kinda knew that all along :-))) [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 17:53, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
:You're a stirrer. But I knew that already.--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 17:56, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
What do you mean? I was just begining to doubt how much truth there is in my "original research" on the [[Greek language]]. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 17:58, 9 November 2005 (UTC)
:Hearing it all around you for 11 years means that you probably know better than any "respectable" source written by some academic in a distant land.--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 18:00, 9 November 2005 (UTC)

Umm, if κ and γκ are palatal before ε, but not elsewhere, and there is no [k] or [g] before ε, then they're allophones, not phonemes. You could as easily claim that English has palatal stops in words like ''key'', but it would be inappropriate to add them has separate consonants. [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 23:34, 9 November 2005 (UTC)

:No, they're also palatal before [[Iota|ι]]. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 23:47, 9 November 2005 (UTC)

Sorry, should have said "before ''ε, η, υ,'' and ''ι''". Palatal before front vowels, velar elsewhere. This is very common allophony. It could lead to a phonemic split eventually, as it did in English and the Romance languages.

Also, I wouldn't place too much confidence in the University of London page either. (Omniglot truly is unreliable, so we need not even go there except to get ideas to check out elsewhere.) The problem is that it is very common to give 'close enough' phonemic correspondances, and this page appears to be a homework assignment for an elementary linguistics class. The author could easily have copied the example from some other source without knowing anything of the language. (They might have had the palatal symbols merely for convenience, like you see for the Indic languages, and the author could have taken them at face value and added unjustified IPA descriptions. This happens all the time!) Or s/he could have simplified things to make the problem more accessible to the students. What you really need is a detailed phonetic description of these sounds, rather than just IPA labels. Indic langages don't have palatal stops, even though they're listed with the phonemes /c/ and {{IPA|/ɟ/}} in dozens of references. I'm not trying to claim that Albanian doesn't have these sounds - I've never heard the language - but this isn't a convincing reference. However, there would be no need for the letters ''q'' and ''gj'' if they weren't phonemes, so I think the alphabet itself is reasonably good evidence that they are ''somehow'' different from ''ç'' and ''xh''. And without any better reference, we might as well leave them as palatals. I just think we should confirm this if we can. [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 23:54, 9 November 2005 (UTC)

Sorry, I take some of that back. If Rex can attest that Albanian ''qen'' is pronounced as Greek ''κεν'' (that is, that it is a pure stop and not aspirated or an affricate), and furthermore that ''q'' is pronounced the same way before all other Albanian vowels, then this would be confirmation of the existance of palatal stops in Albanian, even if technically original research that should be supported elsewhere if possible. [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 23:58, 9 November 2005 (UTC)

:Sorry, I didn't clarify it enough. "Γκ" and "κ" are palatal only before [[Close front unrounded vowel]]s and [[Open-mid front unrounded vowel]]s. Everywhere else, they're /k/ and /g/. Also, "q" and "gj" are palatal plosives (in standard Albanian at least). Proof: "çaj" means [[tea]] and "qaj" means [[cry]]. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 00:08, 10 November 2005 (UTC)

::That doesn't prove that ''q'' is a palatal stop, only that it contrasts with ''ç'' (I presume you could just as easily contrast it with ''k''). This leaves open the possibility that it is a palatal affricate, for example, as in some registers of Hungarian, or that it's a palatalized velar stop, etc. I'm more interested in how the ''q'' or ''qaj'' compares to the ''κ'' of ''κεν''. [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 00:16, 10 November 2005 (UTC)
:It sounds the same. All Albanian letters always sound the same, that was [[Enver Hoxha]]'s intention when he standardised the alphabet. It is intended to be idiot-proof (ie accessible by anyone). And to answer your previous question, "q" in "qen" sounds the same as "q" in "qaj" which is in turn different (only slightly) from "ç" in "çaj". [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 00:28, 10 November 2005 (UTC)

:It should be noted however that "q" is pronounced the same as "ç" in certain dialects. I think [[Kosovo]] is one of those places, but I don't know for sure. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 00:31, 10 November 2005 (UTC)
:::I think you're onto something, [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]]. The audio sample provided makes ''q'' sound a lot like a Cretan κ in κενό rather than a standard Greek one. It would appear that Albanian ''q'' and ''gj'' are most likely the [[voiceless alveolo-palatal affricate|voiceless]] ({{IPA|ʨ}}) and [[voiced alveolo-palatal affricate]] ({{IPA|ʥ}}) that contrast with ''ç'' and ''xh'', the [[voiceless postalveolar affricate|voiceless]] ({{IPA|tʃ}}) and [[voiced postalveolar affricate]] ({{IPA|dʒ}}) respectively, as in [[Serbian language|Serbian]].--[[User:Theathenae|Theathenae]] 13:08, 11 November 2005 (UTC)

I just downloaded the files (they weren't playable in IE either), and yes, they sure do sound like affricates, not stops. The sound quality isn't the best, and they're said rather quickly, though. Rex, if you can find sound samples of Mandarin, could you listen to retroflex ''zh'' vs. alveolo-palatal ''j'', and tell us if that's anything like the difference between Albanian ''ç'' and ''q''? [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 21:01, 11 November 2005 (UTC)

:Yes, I'll do that. You can listen to Albanian radio at [http://www.europaelire.org/ www.europaelire.org] and at [http://www.bbc.co.uk/albanian/ www.bbc.co.uk/albanian]. I doubt it will help, but you may be able to pick out the letters q or gj. I know for a fact that the first words on the BBC one include ''BBC në Shqip''. It's a bit original research I know, but listen to it and tell me what you think the q is in Shqip. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 21:09, 11 November 2005 (UTC)

The Chinese ''zh'' and ''j'' don't exist in Albanian. I have listened to both of them. Especially the ''j'', it is totally different from ''q''. Chinese ''J'' sounds more like /ts/. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 21:20, 11 November 2005 (UTC)

:Just want to add my experience about Albanian /{{IPA|ɟ}}/, /{{IPA|dʒ}}/, /{{IPA|c}}/ and /{{IPA|tʃ}}/. I am Italian, but I've been a dozen of times in Albania. I am always very curious about language matters, and tried to learn the most I could of Albanian.<br>
:Once I asked a young girl from the area of Gramsh to teach me the difference between those sounds and she repeatedly pronounced the word 'paqe' (peace) in the correct way and — to put in evidence the difference — as it was written 'paçe'. Well, to my ear there was no difference, but she laughed a lot because in her opinion the difference were clear.<br>
:It is known that if two sounds are allophones in the sound system of one's mother-tongue there is the possibility that it is not discriminable for him when in other language these are different phonemes.<br>
:This often happens to Italians when try to learn English. It is hard for us to distinguish the words 'sing' and 'sin' as in Italian {{IPA|[ŋ]}} is an allophone of {{IPA|/n/}}. The same happens for us with French city names "Cannes" and "Caen". There is plenty of exemples like this.<br>
:All of this to say that what seems not discriminable for strangers can be absolutely evident for those who speek a certain language.<br>
:Finally, I think that the exemple brought by Rex on the words "çaj" and "qaj" is the definitive proof that closes the argument.<br>
: [[User:Ninonino|Ninonino]] 09:38, 14 November 2005 (UTC)

== Genitive-dative case ==

I'm moving this discussion over from my talk page so everyone has access to it. [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 19:42, 12 November 2005 (UTC)
-----
Hello, I saw your edits to [[Albanian language]]. I'm concerned that they may be a bit [[WP:NOR|original research]]. I have a recent Albanian grammar book in front of me right now and it clearly says that there exists a "gjinore" (genetive) and a "dhanore" (dative). If you look at [[Balkan linguistic union#Case system]], it says that ''in the Balkan languages, the genitive and dative cases (or corresponding prepositional constructions) are merged'', it doesn't say that a genetive case does not exist. You say that ''the equivalent of a genitive is formed by using the prepositions i/e/të/së with the dative''. Your version seems to imply that a genetive does not exist. While this may be true as far as linguists are concerned, it's a rather novel way to look at it, since the genetive is listed in every Albanian gramar book. Also, if you look at [[Romanian grammar]], they list a genetive there as well. Now I'm no linguist, but it does seem like original research and would make Wikipedia stand out like white amongst black if this novel apprach is taken. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 12:29, 10 November 2005 (UTC)

:We can do further referencing with the Balkan Sprachbund. Meanwhile, can you give me a single noun in Albanian that has a genitive? Do any of the books that claim a genitive give a single example? (The fact that the Albanian language has separate names for genitive and dative may only mean that it translated these from Latin or Greek.)

:I once found an Aymara grammar that showed the language had the exact case system of Latin. Unfortunately, Aymara is nothing like that - the author simply assumed that all languages had Latin grammar. [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 19:57, 10 November 2005 (UTC)
Yes, but it also may not. This all seems like original research to me. In Romanian (and I know this for a fact) nominative and accusative are always identical and genetive and dative are always identical. Why can we say that Romanian has two cases instead of four. The Balkan Sprachbund is about the two cases being identical. That doesn't mean that the genetive no longer exists. [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 20:08, 10 November 2005 (UTC)

:Well, yes: If Romanian has two cases, we should say it has two cases. Why, does the article say it has four? And yes, if Albanian has a single genitive-dative case, then it has one case, not two.

:I think you might be confusing the roles that case plays with morphological case itself. Hungarian is supposed to have 25 cases (there is debate about whether this is true, but that's irrelevant for my argument). Spanish has no case at all in its nouns. However, using prepositions, Spanish may well be able express the 25 cases of Hungarian. That is, the case roles may exist in both languages. Or perhaps Spanish with prepositions can only express half of the case roles of Hungarian: we still wouldn't say that Spanish has 12 cases. Spanish nouns don't inflect for case at all, and case is an ''inflectional'' category.

:Take the English clause ''Mary! John just gave the dog a bone''. Now, the case ''roles'' (that is, the equivalent cases in Latin) are vocative (Mary), nominative (John), dative (the dog), and accusative (a bone). But this has nothing to do with the English case system: English only has a genitive vs. non-genitive. There is no dative, or vocative, or accusative in English nouns, and it would be misleading to have a table of English case that listed
::nominative: ''the dog''. accusative: ''the dog''. genitive: ''the dog's''. dative: ''to the dog''. vocative: ''O dog!''. ablative: ''from the dog''. instrumental: ''with the dog'', etc.
:This completely misrepresents the English language, but seems to be what we're doing with Albanian. [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 20:31, 10 November 2005 (UTC)

:Okay, check out [[Romanian nouns#Case]]. They talk about ''syntactic case'' and ''morphological case''. The latter is 'case' in the traditional sense, and they say that nominative = accusative is one case, and that genitive = dative is a second case. Syntactic case (case roles) is a more ambiguous concept, and one where different authors are likely to disagree substantially depending on their theoretical bases. But morphological case is straightforward (do the nouns have a separate inflection, or do the not?), and this is what is normally illustrated in case tables. And ''voilà'', the Romanian case table only has two entries (not counting the vocative, which we left out of the Albanian description). [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 20:44, 10 November 2005 (UTC)
Maybe, however, on what authority are we saying that this "one case" is called dative and not genetive. It could be the other way around... After all, in Greek the "one case" is the genetive (modern greek). [[User:REX|Rex]]<sup>([[User talk:REX|talk]])</sup>[[Image:Flag of Albania.svg|25px]] 20:47, 10 November 2005 (UTC)

:Call it genitive-dative if you like. (That's what they do in the Romanian article.) The label isn't important. The reason I chose the word 'dative' was because the genitive role is conveyed with a preposition, and I had assumed therefore that a bare noun would be interpreted as dative. If you believe that's not the case (ahem!), please correct it. [[User:Kwamikagami|kwami]] 21:05, 10 November 2005 (UTC)

You say: "The equivalent of a genitive is formed by using the prepositions ''i/e/të/së'' with the dative.". This seems to me that it is not exact. ''i/e/të/së'' are called "nyje përaparme" that can be translated as "preposited articles" and, as you surely know, are used also with the adjectives. Prepositions are called "parafjala" and are for exemple ''nga, tek, në, nëpër, me, për'' and so on.<br>
I have in front of me a grammar written by Gjovalin Shkurtaj where cases are listed as five (nominative, accusative, dative, genitive and ablative). Gjovalin Shkurtaj was listed in the article we are discussing as a well known albanologist (the old article stated: ...and Gjovalin Shkurtaj who is probably the most distinguished socio-linguist in Albania today. He is the head of the Department of Linguistics at Tirana University). Now the Albanology section has been deleted.
I think that Kwami's point of view on the dative-genitive merging is substantially correct, but it is a linguistical point of view and contrasts with the sense that Albanians have of their own language. They are tought at school that Albanian has five cases and will be surprised to read that they have only four (and would regard it as an error).<br> With respect to all. [[User:Ninonino|ninonino]], 13 November 2005 (UTC).
==Spanish - nariz==
*I thought that I should point out that in the newly added Spanish words (How Albanian compares...) the word ''nariz'' "nose" is from Latin ''naris, nares'' "nostril" and not from ''nasus'' "nose" (as the French form is).--[[User:Hraefen|Hraefen]] 15:49, 27 December 2005 (UTC)

I don't see the point of the extensive table. I understand that it is useful to put Albanian in its Indo-European context, but in a general encyclopedia article like this, it is pointless to include every IE language you can think of, unless it makes a particular point: if, for example, some Albanian form can only be connected to Tocharian or Old Prussian and no other attested IE form. I have trimmed the table, but it could probably stand further trimming. The languages that are most relevant are: representatives of several IE branches (ideally as old as possible, so Latin rather than French etc.), and languages which have been in contact with Albanian since IE unity, notably Greek, South Slavic, Romanian, and Italian (to show borrowings). But the current table doesn't show borrowings.... --[[User:Macrakis|Macrakis]] 16:09, 27 December 2005 (UTC)

== paragraph ==
This paragraph:

Some eminent scholars in the field of Albanian language have been [[Johann Georg von Hahn]], [[Franz Bopp]], [[Gustav Meyer]], [[Norbert Jokl]], [[Eqrem Çabej]], [[Stuart Edward Mann]], [[Carlo Tagliavini]], [[Waclaw Cimochowski|Wacław Cimochowski]], [[Eric Pratt Hamp]], [[Agnija Desnickaja]], [[Martin Camaj]] and [[Gjovalin Shkurtaj]]. Gjovalin Shkurtaj is probably the most distinguished socio-linguist in Albania today, and he is the head of the Department of Linguistics at Tirana University.

used to be in the article. If anyone wants perhaps it can be re-phrased and re-inserted. <small>[[User talk:Matia.gr|talk to]]</small> [[User:Matia.gr|+MATIA]] 13:40, 14 February 2006 (UTC)

== ''Colloquial Albanian'' book ==

I listed it in the references, but according to http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/customer-reviews/0415056632/103-9290820-5194205?%5Fencoding=UTF8 :

" Many phrases taught are described as old fashioned by my Albanian friends, or from a less popular dialect. [...]Terms and reading (on the cassette) are from Kosovo. The standard, unified dialect from the capital is different."

" This book is NOT the proper albanian to learn. This was written in Kosovo dialect, which is only used in Kosovo Yugoslavia. An Albanian from Albania or Montenegro will not fully understand you and most likely make fun of you"

I don't remember if the book's author states which sort of Albanian (s)he is teaching. The back cover only says "Albanian": http://www.amazon.com/gp/reader/0415056632/ref=sib_rdr_bc/103-9290820-5194205?%5Fencoding=UTF8&p=S0AS&j=0#reader-page One can see a few sample pages here: http://www.amazon.com/gp/reader/0415056632/ref=sib_rdr_ex/103-9290820-5194205?%5Fencoding=UTF8&p=S00X&j=0#reader-page (perhaps this is a temporary link which won't work for you, but you can follow the "excerpt" link at http://www.amazon.com/gp/reader/0415056632/ref=sib_dp_pt/103-9290820-5194205#reader-link ) [[User:Apokrif|Apokrif]] 13:55, 15 February 2006 (UTC)

:From the example pages that I read, that language is not the language which is mostly spoken in Kosovo, it is much closer to the standard language. [[User:Ilir pz|ilir_pz]] 00:10, 6 June 2006 (UTC)

== Albanian colours ==
===kuq - red===

The Latin word for scarlet, coccinus is a loan from Greek kokkinos -> kokkos (kermes berries), Welsh has coch for red, and Albanian has kuq. Are kuq, kokkos, and coch cognates or are the Albanian and Welsh terms borrowed from Latin? It would be interesting if someone could find out. [[User:Imperial78|Imperial78]] 09:18, 1 April 2006 (UTC)

=== zi - black ===

Albanian '''zi''' and Welsh '''du''' /di/ sound so similar that if they are not cognates from PIE does anyone have an alternative explanation? [[User:Xhyljen|Xhyljen]] 12:34, 9 November 2006 (UTC)

=== your answer is below ===

All you need to do is scroll down one post, but here it is: Albanian ''zi'' 'black' (notice the fuller plural forms ''zinj'', ''zeza'') is from reconstructed Proto-Albanian *''džedi'', from Indo-European *''gwed-'', which gave OE ''cwēad'' "bad", MHG ''quāt'' "dirt", Lith ''gé(.)da'' "shame", OSl ''gadǔkǔ'' "disgusting", ''gadǔ'' "reptile, worm"

Welsh ''du'' "dark", cognate with Irish ''dub'', is from Proto-Celtic *''dubios'', which is akin to E ''deaf'', and Gk ''typhlós'' "blind".

[[User:Flibjib8|Flibjib8]] 17:10, 10 November 2006 (UTC)

== comparison chart ==

i have added blertë to the list with gjelbër for 'green', and i have annotated the notes, since only kuq, verdhë, and gjelbër are borrowings (coccum, viridis, galbinus). the similarities with welsh are due to both languages borrowing the same words from latin, which therefore leads to the similarities between romanian and italian with albanian, since both are descendants of latin. though this does not include Alb zi 'black' and Welsh du, which are from entirely different sources (see below).

specific etymologies are:

- muaj 'month' < Proto-Albanian *môsnja; cf. Eng month, Lat mensis, OIr mí, Skt más, Arm amis, OSl měšecĭ, Lith ménesis

- ri 'new, young, recent' < Proto-Albanian *rija; cf. ON o,rr "quick", OSax aru "id"

- nënë 'mother'; cf. Welsh nain 'grandmother', Lat nonna 'id', Gk nânnê 'maternal aunt', nínnê 'grandmother', Bulg neni 'the other one', Russ nyanya 'child's guardian', Farsi nana 'mother', Skt naná 'mother'

- motër < Proto-Albanian *mâter; cf. Eng mother, Lat māter, Ir mathair, Gk mátér, OSl mati, Skt mātá, Toch A macar

- natë < Proto-Albanian *nakti; cf. Eng night, Lat nox, Welsh nos, Gk nýx, OSl noštĭ, Lith naktìs, Skt nákt, Hitt nekuz, Toch A naktim

- hundë - ?

- tre < Proto-Albanian *treje; cf. Eng three, Lat tres, Ir trí, etc.

- zi/zezë < *zëi < Proto-Albanian *džedi; cf. OEng cwéad 'bad', MHGer quât 'dirt', Lith géda 'shame', OSl gadǔkǔ 'disgusting', gadǔ 'reptile, worm'

- blertë < OAlb blerë < Proto-Albanian *blôra; cf. Lat flōrus 'shining, bright', Welsh blawr 'grey'

- ujk < OAlb ulk < Proto-Albanian *(w)ulka; cf. Lat lupus 'wolf', Gk lýkos, Skt vr.ka, Lith vil~kas, Latv vìlks, OSl vlŭkŭ, Av vəhrkō, Eng wolf, Welsh gweilgi 'torrent'

Welsh du 'dark, black', akin to Old Irish dub, comes from Proto-Celtic dubos; cf. E deaf, Gk typhlós 'blind'

[[User:71.74.209.129|71.74.209.129]] 03:06, 13 June 2006 (UTC)
[[User:Flibjib8|Flibjib8]] 21:43, 23 July 2006 (UTC)

:Maybe dumb question: how does hundë relate to nose? I see the nd, but I am curious about the rest of the word. [[User:Jpaulm|Jpaulm]] 17:19, 5 July 2006 (UTC)

=== jpaulm hundë ===

hundë means 'nose' but is not in any way related to most of the words for nose in the other indo-european languages. i didn't make the chart, but i can only assume the purpose of putting it in, just like comparing 'kuq', ''nënë'', or ''blertë'' is to show words that are not related to most other indo-european languages, to convey the mixture in albanian.

i sadly do not have access right now to orel's albanian etymological dictionary, so i can't give you an etymology of the word. all i can say is that the initial h- probably comes from an sk-, based on what else i know about albanian etymology. so, clearly, no relation to NOSE.

[[User:Flibjib8|Flibjib8]] 21:34, 23 July 2006 (UTC)

== history ==

I rewrote the history section, though I kept a portion of it at the end. [[User:71.74.209.129|71.74.209.129]] 03:07, 14 June 2006 (UTC)

== dialects ==

i have added specific information about the major characteristics that differentiate Tosk and Gheg and a number of other characteristics for other dialects in the dialect section. nothing was lost or altered. [[User:Flibjib8|Flibjib8]] 19:59, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
:[[Albanian dialects]] --[[User:Poemsnewly|Poemsnewly]] 16:45, 22 March 2007 (UTC)

== display problem ==

On my browser (Firefox 1.5.0.6) The "Indoeuropean languages" box overlaps the section comparing the Albanian language to other Indoeuropean languages. Looks really bad. If the problem isn't just a prob with my browser, then perhaps judicious use of <nowiki><p><br clear="all" /></p></nowiki> might help.
[[User:Ling.Nut|Ling.Nut]] 02:31, 14 August 2006 (UTC)

== The word 'jan' ==
The aritcle states that the word 'jan' is delivered through the roma gipsies. Well, i think that the word 'jan' is from the persian word of same meaning, as the word is used in turkish, urdu, persian, hindi and some dialects of kurdish, and that it is delivered to albanian through the ottoman empire. Hamid, 21:30, 28 september 2006 {{unsigned|87.51.211.94|19:29, 28 September 2006 (UTC)}}

== vocabulary ==

for whoever added the "vocabulary" section, you should be aware that you are quoting dated material. i realize that it is accepted practice to quote this bit as often as possible when in Albania, as if to establish some sort of solid link to the past, but to presume that 1) Albanian has not significantly changed in 2000 years and that 2) the modern Albanian word forms, which if truly represented in the names listed (Thetis, Dhea, Malion, etc), would discount all etymological reconstructions that attach it to indo-european, is entirely preposterous.

Take for instance Thetis, supposedly equivalent to Alb ''det'' "sea". Notice the fuller forms of Italo-Albanian ''dejt, dejët'' and dialectal ''dēt'', both of which indicate a much larger or fuller form, and this probably just 1000 years ago. The typical reconstruction is *''deubeta'', related to English ''depth''. Further, a modern ''d'' cannot come from a former ''th''. The two cannot be linked.

please research and then revise or remove this section or i will do it for you.

[[User:Flibjib8|Flibjib8]] 04:37, 19 November 2006 (UTC)

:Νοne of these words are illyrian
:They have not found illyrian inscriptions except the messapic!

:Thetis (greek goddess of the sea) The etymology of her name (from tithemi (τίθημι), "to set up, establish"

:ylis - ylli - Star
:Bardylis - White Star
:Thetis (goddess of the sea)- Deti - Sea
:Emathia - e madhia - big, Great
:Malion - Mali - Mountain
:Dhea ( Gea equivalent) - Dheu - Ground, Earth, (Mother Earth)
:Di,Diti - Dita - Day
:{{unsigned|Dardanos|15:10, 6 January 2007 (UTC)}}


What are these mystical 12th century manuscripts that are mentioned in the vocabulary section? Does the one allegedly found in the Vatican mean the same one that was "found" couple of years ago and then revealed as a hoax? The Athonite manuscript was also news to me. Does it really mean (Balkan)Albanian or rather Caucasian Albanian? I would like to see the sources.[[User:213.216.208.231|213.216.208.231]] 10:14, 30 November 2006 (UTC)

BTW, "la lingua Albanesca" cannot be Latin, since Latin does not have article "la".[[User:213.216.208.231|213.216.208.231]] 09:53, 1 December 2006 (UTC)

:Caucasian Albanians are Serbian % Greek propaganda, trying to link the modern Albanians with Caucasian roots. The name for present Albanians (Illyrians) are called "albanians" because of Roman more frequent contact with Illyrian tribe called P/Bardhini (look the Illyrian tribes). This tribe was originally named Bardhin and has the meaning "The white" (only in Albanian language), and that is the explanation why the Romans named this tribe in their recordings and maps, with the same meaning in Latin language with Albanians (white ones).
:For Greek audience here, the explanation can be something like this: the Helen tribes were named Greeks, because Greek tribe had the more frequent contact with Romans, and the people who spoke that language were called Greeks. {{unsigned|Mnegro|21:26, 5 July 2007 (UTC)}}

I can agree with the fact that trying to explain old words with actual Albanian is a little bit difficult, but also there are cases that some of the old words have not passed many changes through milleniums. For example number three, or day, night, mother. In the case the name Dhemetra, is very logic to explain it with dhe-metra, which means earth-mother. http://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demetra you can see even the link where dheghom is I.E name for earth and it is still used in Albanian in the form of "Dhe". And for the change matera-moter (sister) in Albanian is a well known fact and you can find o lot of articles as a reference.</br>
Another explanation you can find for the goddes Aphrodite, which in Albanian language is the name of the star and explains that the day is approaching(afro-approaching dit-day). The people used with astronomy which know the position of the planet and its appearance on the sky can see the explanation there. This star(planet) in the sky starts shining when the day is approaching. - [[User:Aigest|Aigest]] 10:51, 10 September 2007 (UTC)

== similarity to finnish and french languages ==

who here besides me sees a similarity to the finnish and french languages? because from what i see, most albanian place names always have those two dots on them, like most finnish place names, Example: Kotla-Jaarve, and i also noticed a similarity between written shiqp and the french language in a book about albania i read. <small>—The preceding [[Wikipedia:Sign your posts on talk pages|unsigned]] comment was added by [[Special:Contributions/71.175.1.237|71.175.1.237]] ([[User talk:71.175.1.237|talk]]) 16:41, 15 January 2007 (UTC).</small><!-- HagermanBot Auto-Unsigned -->

:None whosoever. <span style="background-color: #FFFF80; color: #800000">''[[User:Rursus|Rursus]]''</span> 07:46, 14 March 2007 (UTC)

== Dialects cleanup request ==

The dialects section is repetitious, unclear (multiple dialects are one dialect), and could be better organized. &#8212;[[User:Largoplazo|Largo Plazo]] 18:30, 18 January 2007 (UTC)
:I think what it needs is some rewording as subdialects, etc. [[User:Azalea pomp|Azalea pomp]] 04:32, 7 February 2007 (UTC)

== Cognates to Dacian and Thracian? ==
'''History''' section says that the cognates with ''Illyrian'' are few. Have anyone tried to map the cognates with Dacian and the cognates with Thracian? <span style="background-color: #FFFF80; color: #800000">''[[User:Rursus|Rursus]]''</span> 07:56, 14 March 2007 (UTC)
:Many people have. The problem is that the data are sparse and hard to interpret. There are also many cranks in this field. If you find [[WP:Reliable sources]] on relationships with Dacian and Thracian, let's discuss them.... --[[User:Macrakis|Macrakis]] 13:39, 14 March 2007 (UTC)
::Yes. I'll read [[WP:Reliable sources]]. Evaluating a source to be reliable, requires experience and a sound method. <span style="background-color: #FFFF80; color: #800000">''[[User:Rursus|Rursus]]''</span> 09:22, 22 March 2007 (UTC)

== Albanian r ==
Most sources list is an an alveolar tap, but are there any sources which list it as an alveolar approximant? [[User:Azalea pomp|azalea pomp]] 07:45, 17 March 2007 (UTC)

== Table of comparisons ==
The table of comparisons is fouled up. The columns for Albanian words often align with the wrong other languages columns. The person who created the table should fix it. Or it should be totally removed. {{unsigned|71.146.40.86|21:34, 17 March 2007 (UTC)}}

== Mental Note about serb trollers ==
I see that serbs take their battle even in wikipedia, no surprise from my side however be observant.[[User:Trojani|Trojani]] 06:16, 4 May 2007 (UTC)

== Bear in Albanian and Gaulish ==

If you take a look here: [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artio]] you can see that bear (the animal) in Gaulish is believed to be pronounced Artiu. In Albanian it's called Ari or Ariu. Thought it was an interesting find :-)[[User:213.112.155.156|213.112.155.156]] 20:23, 28 June 2007 (UTC)

:The Celtic words for bear, (cf. Old Irish ''arth'', Welsh ''arth'', Old Breton ''arzh''), and Albanian ''ari, arush'' "bear" (< Proto-Albanian *''arina''), Old Albanian ''ar'' (< Proto-Albanian *''ara''), are all cognates with Latin ''ursus'', Greek ''árktos'', Sanskrit ''r.'ks.as'', Avestan arša, Armenian ''arj^'', Hittite ''h_artagga'', Afgh ''yə'ž''.

:[[User:Flibjib8|Flibjib8]] 15:53, 14 August 2007 (UTC)

== Total speakers ==

The current article <small>([http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Albanian_language&oldid=142662024 as of 13:47, 5 July 2007 UTC])</small> mentions 15 million speakers in the lead, and 10 to 15 million in the infobox. But the reference used (Ethnologue) mentions 6 million.

Regardless of what the real number is, it would be much appreciated if the text is modified to match the reference, or if the reference is changed or amended to explain the discrepancy. I didn't edit it myself because I'm not familiar with the topic and didn't find any discussion about this issue in the talk pages to guide me. - Thanks already, [[User:Ev|Ev]] 19:00, 5 July 2007 (UTC)

:I have [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Albanian_language&diff=167587704&oldid=167448703 edited the article] to reflect the ca. 6 millions mentioned by the source (Ethnologue). However, the list of countries of the infobox adds up to 7.4 million. The discrepancy still remains. - Best regads, [[User:Ev|Ev]] 07:37, 28 October 2007 (UTC)

:I have [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Albanian_language&curid=3002&diff=167737283&oldid=167710880 reverted] the [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Albanian_language&diff=167710880&oldid=167587704 edit] by [[User:Bibliophilus|Bibliophilus]] that tripled the Albanian-speaking population & misrepresented the Ethnologue reference. If you think that Ethnologue's numbers are inaccurate, please, discuss the issue here instead of simply modifying the article. If you haven't done so yet, please familiarize yourself with our [[Wikipedia:Neutral point of view|neutral point of view]], [[Wikipedia:Verifiability|verifiability]] & [[Wikipedia:No original research|no original research]] core polices first. - Best regards, [[User:Ev|Ev]] 00:07, 29 October 2007 (UTC)

:I have [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Albanian_language&diff=prev&oldid=167813316 reverted], yet again, the same [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Albanian_language&diff=prev&oldid=167804519 edit] by [[User:Bibliophilus|Bibliophilus]]. Please, keep in mind that per our [[Wikipedia:Verifiability|verifiability]] policy "[t]he threshold for inclusion in Wikipedia is '''verifiability, not truth'''." To be included in the article, the claim that the total number of Albanian speakers is the triple of that [http://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Albanian_language&oldid=167813316#References mentioned by Ethnologue] would need to be attributed to a [[Wikipedia:Reliable sources|reliable, published source]] using an [[Wikipedia:Citing sources|inline citation]]. Otherwise, such content would constitute [[Wikipedia:No original research|original research]] on our part. - Regards, [[User:Ev|Ev]] 10:42, 29 October 2007 (UTC)

===10-15 million speakers? LOL===
Does tha include imaginary speakers that exist only in the fevered imagination of albanian nationalists? someone please fix this and give a correct figure. <small>—Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[User:24.23.131.247|24.23.131.247]] ([[User talk:24.23.131.247|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/24.23.131.247|contribs]]) 07:41, 27 July 2007 (UTC)</small><!-- Template:Unsigned -->
:Actually they like 17 million a bit better... All the info on wiki totals to about 8.17 million. I'm sure they could find a source claiming about 2 million in Greece about 5 million in Serbia (Kosovo) 3 million in Italy. Its f*cking ridiculous. I don't understand why they feel the need to inflate their numbers. They could say "Currently we're just above 8 million but with the populations in Western Macedonia and Kosovo reproducing faster than fruit flies we can expect the number to triple by tomorrow. So lets just say 24 million." <small>—Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[Special:Contributions/24.250.136.39|24.250.136.39]] ([[User talk:24.250.136.39|talk]]) 11:26, 12 October 2007 (UTC)</small><!-- Template:UnsignedIP --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->

:Its just been increased to 16 - 20 million. Its getting ridiculous. Who ever is doing this - just accept that your language hase ~8 M speakers and move on with your life. <small>—Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[User:Gkmx|Gkmx]] ([[User talk:Gkmx|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Gkmx|contribs]]) 15:08, 21 October 2007 (UTC)</small><!-- Template:Unsigned --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->

::We have left for too long unguarded our articles, so you serbs and greeks have fixed the figures how you wanted to. Now is time for justice. Albania's population is 3,7 millions. Kosova's is 2,5. In Macedonia there are 40% of the total population of 2,2 million. In Greece there are 650,000 albanian immigrants and 700,000 albanian arvanites and chams. In Turkey (you should know better) there are millions of deported albanians from the Sandjak of Nish, Kosova and Chamuria. We have the highest population growth and the youngest population in Europe. Why you feel so surprised? <small>—Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[User:Bibliophilus|Bibliophilus]] ([[User talk:Bibliophilus|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Bibliophilus|contribs]]) 20:46, 25 October 2007 (UTC)</small><!-- Template:Unsigned --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->

== Removal of discussion from article ==

I've removed the following from the article:
<cite>Note: Aside from ''kuq'', ''verdhë'', and ''gjelbër'', these Albanian words are directly inherited from Proto-Indo-European. Albanian ''motër'' is cognate with the Indo-European root for "mother", probably the result of a derived form (< *''motrë'' < *''mātrā'' < through *''māterea'') meaning "maternal", and by extension "uterine sister", akin to Welsh ''modryb'' "aunt, lit. mother's sister". Note: That Albanian "moter" is akin to Welsh "modryb" is a complete flight of fancy. Also for the information of people who do NOT know Albanian: "gjelber" does NOT mean "giallo" or "yellow"; and "verdhe" does NOT mean "verde" or "green" !!! Rather the other way round! Why don't you consult Albanian -speaking natives instead of brandishing those "facts"? I corrected you once and you decided to cancel my editing but your table still contains mistakes! Can I trust the rest of this article?</cite>

I can't tell where the discussion begins and where the content ends so I removed it all. Please keep discussion on the talk page and not in the article.

'''Note: If you cannot [[WP:CITE|cite]] your sources, the info shouldn't be included at all'''

&nbsp;--'''[[User:M2Ys4U|M2Ys4U]]''' <sup>(<font color="green">[[User talk:M2Ys4U|talk]]</font>)</sup> 01:41, 19 July 2007 (UTC)

:This is sourced : The law formulated in 1892 by J. Wackernagel, according to which unstressed parts of the sentence tend to occupy a position after the first stressed word normally situated at the beginning of a sentence qualifies Albanian as the oldest living Indo European language.Dodona <small>—Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[User:217.24.246.61|217.24.246.61]] ([[User talk:217.24.246.61|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/217.24.246.61|contribs]]) 20:01, 5 August 2007 (UTC)</small><!-- Template:Unsigned -->

==Illyrian==
That Albanien derives from Illyrian is of course a current theory, but saying that ''"Most scholars believe that Albanian derives from the [[Illyrian language]]"'' is a bit too strong. Most scholars, in my experience, are very cautious on the topic of classificating Albanian. Personally, I also think the Illyrian theory may be the most likely, but saying that ''most scholars'' think so is a bit strong. [[User:JdeJ|JdeJ]] 17:01, 8 August 2007 (UTC)
:Most scolars say what?
:I'm not saying that the Albanian Language might not be related to a older Language which may be what we try to call Illyrian but who are the "most scolars"?
:Could this be precised please? <small>—Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[Special:Contributions/87.185.55.70|87.185.55.70]] ([[User talk:87.185.55.70|talk]]) 18:15, 7 September 2007 (UTC)</small><!-- Template:UnsignedIP --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->

== als = Alemannisch or Albanian Tosk? ==

As the ISO 639-3 code "als", which is used for years by the [[Alemannic German]] wikipedia http://als.wikipedia.org/ , had recently been assigned to Tosk Albanian, we have an inconsistency which is discussed at [[Wikipedia talk:User categories for discussion]] (and elsewhere). A simple solution could be to file a request to have the Albanian codes changed, to ones beginning with "sq" rather than "al".

{| class="wikitable"
|-
! code !! now !! better
|-
| alb || Albanian ISO 639-2 || Albanian
|-
| aln || Gheg || [[Low Alemannic German]] ('''''N'''ieder'''al'''emannische Sprache'')
|-
| aae || Arbëreshë || Arbëreshë?
|-
| aat || Arvanitika || Arvanitika?
|-
| als || Tosk || [[Alemannic German]] ('''''Al'''emannische '''S'''prache'') or [[Alsatian]]
|-
| sqe || - || Arbëreshë?
|-
| sqb || - || Arbëreshë?
|-
| sqg || - || Gheg
|-
| sqi || [[Shqip]] Albanian || [[Shqip]] Albanian
|-
| sqr || - || [[Soqotri]]
|-
| sqt || [[Soqotri]] || Tosk
|-
| sqv || - || Arvanitika?
|-
|}

Does this make sense? --&nbsp;[[User:Matthead|Matthead]]&nbsp;[[User_talk:Matthead|<sup>discuß!</sup>]]&nbsp;&nbsp;[[EU|<font style="color:#ffff00;background:#0000cc;">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;O&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;</font>]]&nbsp; &nbsp; 05:18, 13 October 2007 (UTC)

==More noble? What?==
<i>But Albanian is notabily higher developed and more noble than any slavic language, especially than the serbian one which has been created during the 1900-s.</i>

What the heck does that mean? I'm pretty sure "higher developed and more noble" is not an accepted philological description. I smell Albanian nationalism. [[User:Borkingchikapa|Borkingchikapa]] 15:08, 25 October 2007 (UTC)

:How come you didnt smelled serbian nationalism at the original text calling the ethnic albanian region of Kosova with the provocative term "Kosovo i Metohija". <small>—Preceding [[Wikipedia:Signatures|unsigned]] comment added by [[User:Bibliophilus|Bibliophilus]] ([[User talk:Bibliophilus|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/Bibliophilus|contribs]]) 20:42, 25 October 2007 (UTC)</small><!-- Template:Unsigned --> <!--Autosigned by SineBot-->

::First of all, a territory can not have a nationality, only peoples can have it (if they choose to). Second word Kosovo/Kosova has Slavic origin, and Metohija has Greek origin paradoxical (second paradox is that Metohija is bigger than Kosovo). Third, Albanians do live in Serbia in other territories, not only on administrative province under UN protection Kosovo and Metohija. So Kosovo without Metohija is like Herzegovina without Bosnia (not Bosnia without Herzegovina because Herzegovina is smaller part of that state).

== Albanian language branch ==

One site, www.krysstal.com/langfams says that Albanian falls within the Illyric language branch, along with the dead languages Illyric and Mesapian. I haven't checked other sources but if others might, I propose this heading be changed and that the extinct languages be added.

[[User:Parmadil|Parmadil]] 05:16, 15 November 2007 (UTC)

:[http://www.krysstal.com/langfams_indoeuro.html The site] only states that ''[t]he ancient Illyric and Mesapian languages [...] <u>are considered by some</u> to be an extinct member of [the Illyric] branch'', without mentioning who helds this opinion, or presenting this theory as the predominant view, much less asserting it as an established fact.

:In any case, since this is a rather contentious issue, I believe it would require much better [[WP:RS|sources]] -preferably printed ones- to even mention the issue in the article. Sources that clearly explain exactly who considers these languages related -as opposed to ''some''-. - Best regards, [[User:Ev|Ev]] 22:10, 15 November 2007 (UTC)
::As of now Albanian is best left as an independent branch of Indo-European. There is simply not enough of Illyrian, Dacian, or Thracian to know for certain. Since all are IE languages, they all are related anyway. There simply is not a consensus on the branching of IE or how many of these extinct poorly documented languages are related to the living PIE languages. But, if I had to put money on it, I would say Albanian descends from Illyrian. The geography makes a lot more sense. Albanian probably had a secondary satemization sound change or perhaps inter-dialect borrowings? I am not sure if there is any historical move of Dacians into present day Albania. Perhaps Dacian and Illyrian were closely related anyway. Heck, anyone has about the same guess until more data is found... [[User:Azalea pomp|Azalea pomp]] ([[User talk:Azalea pomp|talk]]) 07:54, 17 November 2007 (UTC)

== Thracian Link on Albanian ==

[http://linguistlist.org/forms/langs/LLDescription.cfm?code=txh%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20&CFTREEITEMKEY=txh+++++++++++++++]

The Thracian Language: "An ancient language of Southern Balkans, belonging to the Satem group of Indo-European. This language '''is the most likely ancestor of modern Albanian''' (which is also a Satem language), though the evidence is scanty. 1st Millennium BC - 500 AD." [[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 22:17, 21 December 2007 (UTC)
==Albanian was called also Epirotic==
In the literature of Pjeter Bogdani Albanian(Shqip) also was addressed as Epirotic language although written in Gege dialect--[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 12:15, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:Show the source,please and remember it was a geographic unhistorical term if referring to albanians.Epirotes were Greek.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 12:20, 26 December 2007 (UTC)

Cuneus Prophetarum (The Band of the Prophets) of Pjeter Bogdani Albanian Academy of Science 2005 was written in Italian and Epirotic language , the Albanian language was addressed often as Epirotic or “Shqip” --[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 12:28, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:As a geographical term.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 12:30, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
Jo,No or Oxi, do not pervert the source --[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 12:47, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:The source is wrong as epirotes were Greek and albanian had this as a geographical term.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 12:49, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:They -the albanian dialects/languages-were called Turkalbanian as well.Would you like to add it as well?I can source it with hundreds of books.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 12:54, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
::In this book Pjeter Bogdani a native Albanian from Macedonia was consider successor of Great Alexander and Gjergj Kastrioti ,read it and stop racism--[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 13:43, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:Albanian natiolistic dreams.Epirotes and Macedons were NW greeks.[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Megistias#3rd_party_material_for_use_in_Epirus_and_other NW greeks].[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 15:18, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:Barleti is a primary source and thus not acceptable.The other author is making nationalistic claims.The whole thing is pov pushing.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 15:23, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
::Read it and stop racisem and insulting Albanians and ''The Band of the Prophets Concerning Christ, Saviour of the World and his Gospel Truth, edited in Italian and Epirotic and divided into two parts by Pjetër Bogdani of Macedonia, student of the Holy Congregation of the Propaganda Fide, doctor of philosophy and holy theology, formerly Bishop of Shkodra and Administrator of Antivari and now Archbishop of Skopje and Administrator of all the Kingdom of Serbia''--[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 19:18, 26 December 2007 (UTC)

He lived 17 century and can not be an Albanian nationalist --[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 19:25, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:He is a primary source and NO original research.You cant use him As well and all he said was wrong as modern science has proven.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 19:27, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:They are tosk and Gheg now.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 19:34, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
::Try to understand please they are the same race, anyway the book was written in Gege dialect which is Albanian as it is the Tosk dialect and also was called Epirotic language--[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 19:46, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:It was a geographic term and a historical anachronism.Epirotes were Greek.Albanians came at the area at 1000 AD.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 19:49, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
::This is another discussion but if you speak with one from Epir will not agree with you and then Greek , Albanian are the same race and brothers , what make the same people enemy is the politic but this is temporary --[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 20:02, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
::Sorry , I forgot the religion but now we are multi -religious --[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 20:06, 26 December 2007 (UTC)

:Wiki is about history,knowledge and secondary reliable sources.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 20:04, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:Yes i agree with you --[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 20:06, 26 December 2007 (UTC)

No, are not primary source and not my original work, if you care to read the books, read also primary and secondary source controversy. I am leaving your last version and stop racism and insulting me , can you tell me you image of normal person?!--[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 12:21, 27 December 2007 (UTC)

== Names of the Albanians and their Language ==

Turkalbanians and Turkalbanian language.These were also the names for 500 years because of the Connection of Albanians with islam and their great roles in the Ottoman empire as lords.Source,Sarandos Kargakos-Albanians,Arvanites & Greeks,The studies.ISBN ISBN: 9789600801729,Ethnikē bibliothēkē Των Hetaireia Makedonikōn Spoudōn,Makedonika apomnēmoneumata kai diplomatika paraskēnia.,Aphieroma, 1821-1871 Των Dēm. Gr Tsakōnas,Thessaliká chroniká,[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 15:53, 26 December 2007 (UTC)

Yes they were lords and you must know they were and are lords of Greece as well ,read famous Arvanites --[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 19:23, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:You dont belong here.Apologise for your insults.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 19:25, 26 December 2007 (UTC)

I may report you to administrator but I do not like the role of spy, so I hope they see you and dam you --[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 19:28, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:Report me immediately.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 19:29, 26 December 2007 (UTC)
:Stop putting words in my mouth,lying and disrupting.And see what original research is.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 12:22, 27 December 2007 (UTC)
::so please see to your talk page where you consider me insame , the abnormal is you here and your delusions , you know nothing about Epir and Macedonia and ethnic people that leave there, you are a criminal and liars , you commit a crime each time that try to change history and maps--[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 12:30, 27 December 2007 (UTC)
:Read wikipedia rules please and stop insults.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 12:32, 27 December 2007 (UTC)
: stop you to insult me and do not try to be smart, you claims of territories that belong to Greece when I gave you very sourced view , there are letters inside the book from the other writer even from Serbian Kingdom nation where Albanian language is addressed as Epirotic and stop delete my edits but read fist the book, but of course you must know first Albanian which most of you Greek know very well--[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 12:59, 27 December 2007 (UTC)
Apologias for insulting Albanians as Turkish Islamist etc very sick and racist view of yours --[[User:Besa Arvanon|Besa Arvanon]] ([[User talk:Besa Arvanon|talk]]) 13:01, 27 December 2007 (UTC)
:The name isn't insulting but a historical name because of Albanian achievements in the context of the Ottoman empire as Muslims.It was used with no offense even than is it indicated religious and "political" affiliations.I haven't insulted you or the Albanians.Turkish and Islamists arent evil or bad as you imply.[[User:Megistias|Megistias]] ([[User talk:Megistias|talk]]) 15:14, 27 December 2007 (UTC)

== Albanian placenames ==

Could somebody tell me, why in Albanian most places have at least two or more names? See: Shkodër/Shkodra, Vlorë/Vlora, Prizren/Prizreni, Kosovë/Kosova, Enver/Enveri, Prishtinë/Prishtina. I see, e.g. that most people say "Kosova" when they are talking about this part of the world. What does "Kosovë" stand for?
Thought it was the difference between the [[Gheg Albanian|Gheg]] and [[Tosk Albanian|Tosk]] dialects, but somebody told me it's rather the distinction between the definite and the indefinite form. My questions are:
* Why double names? (for reasons of dialect or grammar? high standard - low standard? etc.)
* Do Kosovo-Albanians rather prefer using the definite forms (or do they prefer any grammatical version) other than Albanian Albanians do?
* Is there a difference between Kosovo and Albanian language use?
* Which placename should be mentioned first when mentioning it in a table or on a map?
Thanks a lot for any help! --[[Special:Contributions/88.117.30.189|88.117.30.189]] ([[User talk:88.117.30.189|talk]]) 12:22, 28 December 2007 (UTC)

Latest revision as of 19:53, 25 November 2024


Inherited roots

[edit]

The section "Historical presence and location" contrasts native words with borrowed loan words of foreign origin, when the more natural comparison would be native words versus commonly inherited ones, since it is an IE language just like Italic Celtic Germanic etc

Spelling-to-sound: ‹r›

[edit]

Shouldn't ‹r› actually be /ɽ/? It does not sound like an alveolar tap, but like a retroflex flap.

Spelling-to-sound: ‹r›

[edit]

Shouldn't ‹r› actually be /ɽ/? It does not sound like an alveolar tap, but like a retroflex flap.

Spelling-to-sound <gj> and q

[edit]

Shouldn't it be changed to voiced and voiceless palatal affricates respectively?

Albanian stops are unaspirated

[edit]

http://mudrac.ffzg.unizg.hr/~rmatasov/Albanian.pdf That means the english examples should be changed. /p/ is not pronounced like in 'pen', but like in 'spin'.

e and o are higher than the table shows, almost same level or higher than ë

[edit]

http://www.kfs.oeaw.ac.at/publications/2003_moosmueller_granser_the_vowels_of_standard_albanian.pdf

Albanian Is a Balto-Slavic Language

[edit]
WP:NOTFORUM
Also: WP:DFTT. Austronesier (talk) 19:04, 1 September 2024 (UTC)[reply]

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

If carefully studied the Albanian language and the Balto-Slvavic languages share the same roots. Linguists in Albania are more interested in politics than language studies. Only a few linguists study Ukrainian, Russian, Belorussian, Bulgarian, Polish, Serbo-Croat and Albanian at the same time. If all these languages were carefully studied the only objective conclusion that could be derived from it is that the Albanian language is a branch of Slavic languages. 2600:1700:36D0:9B0:5179:180A:4CB4:2AF8 (talk) 02:08, 17 August 2024 (UTC)[reply]

Albanian is part of, but a separate branch of, the Indo-European family.
Snowman304|talk 02:19, 17 August 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Citations from linguist who specialize on a different area of language and heavily based on what is usually cited by the Albanian linguists who get very angry if something that does not confirm their theories is presented. These citations do not even mention the fact that 70% of Gheg Albanian words who are based in the Slavic languages have been wiped out of the Albanian language since Tosk became the standard language such as mir (Slavic), mirë (Albanian), good (English); kone (Slavic), kene (Gheg Albanian), qene (Tosk Albanian), be (English); bogatu (Slavic), banu gati (Gheg Albanian), behu gati (Tosk Albanian) get ready (English); plujc (Slavic), prush (Gheg Albanian), zjarr (Tosk Albanian), fire (English). This whole page can be filled with similarities but there is no point of including all of them here. If Slavic languages and Albanian were seriously and objectively studied the conclusion would clearly be that the entire grammatical structure and dictionary of the Albanian language is rooted in Slavic. The similarities are so astonishing that there is no other explanation. 2600:1700:36D0:9B0:5179:180A:4CB4:2AF8 (talk) 03:19, 17 August 2024 (UTC)[reply]
WP:OR Wikipedia does not work via Original Research. Also im not a slavic speaker but at least i know that Slavic Good it means Dobro not Mir. Mir means Peace so here it goes also the POV pushing and Non Reliable Sourcing.RoyalHeritageAlb (talk) 09:43, 17 August 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Language is language and the Albanians similar to Serbs have the tendency to comingle language with politics. For example, Serbs similar to Albanians claim that the Serbian language has nothing in common with the Croatian language, which in fact is not true it is very similar. They do that for political reasons. The same with the Albanian linguists, they fail to see the resemblance that exists between the Slavic languages and the Albanian language because they believe that somehow it helps them politically by identifying the Albanian language as unique in the midst of other languages when in fact it is not unique but is rooted in the Balto-Slavic languages. The fact is that the Balto-Slavic is the nearest kin of the Albanian language. Objectively speaking there is no dispute about that. Take the alphabet, for example, in addition to the similarity in vocabulary, as clearly seen in my previous comment, the Albanian alphabet has letters that are unique only to the Slavic languages despite the heavy modifications done to the original Albanian alphabet and the introduction of ë since Tosk became the standard Albanian. Despite all of that there are still letters that are unique only to the Slavic and Albanian languages, such as gj(Ð), sh(Š), c(ts), zh(Ž), q (tsh), nj. Just because a letter, for example, is written as gj instead of (Ð) it does not make it different. It is the same letter. 2600:1700:36D0:9B0:A4:4E02:F41C:2727 (talk) 15:46, 17 August 2024 (UTC)[reply]
How about "rrotkari" translate that to slavic. 2600:8801:222:C600:3D5C:1290:C41D:1CB7 (talk) 11:15, 23 August 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Explains why nearly every Messapic word has a cognate in Albanian. 2/10 ragebait. 141.98.141.192 (talk) 17:59, 1 September 2024 (UTC)[reply]
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Mešari

[edit]

Mešari which is supposedly the first recorded in the "Albanian" language is entirely based in Latin. "Unë" in "Albanian", uno in Italian, one in English [[1]]. Pagëzoj in "Albanian", baptismo in Italian, baptize in English [[2]]. Emër in "Albanian", nome in Italian, name in English etc. etc. etc. etc. So, it makes no sense to include the entire translation of Mešari here but clearly the "Albanian" language is not unique but a mix of Latin, Slavic, Greek, and Turkish languages. 2600:1700:36D0:9B0:B878:7B7B:BAC0:B79A (talk) 03:42, 25 November 2024 (UTC)[reply]

I agree. The "Albanian" language is a very beautiful language, and the reason why it is a very beautiful language is because it is a mixed language and traces of Latin, Slavic, Greek and Turkish can be found in it, not because it is unique. 2600:1700:36D0:9B0:B878:7B7B:BAC0:B79A (talk) 04:11, 25 November 2024 (UTC)[reply]
I don't understand the point you're trying to make, and I think you don't know either. Your behavior exhibits signs of self-talking. Perhaps stop edit-warring on this article.
Also, unë does not mean "one" in Albanian, but "I". Words can seem as Latin as they want to be, still, Alb. "katër" (4) independently evolved from PIE *kʷétur- without Latin influence (quattuor). Also, it's named "Meshari" not "Mesâri". Your statements lack existence and usage of high-quality sources in academic scholarship.
Thanks. AlexBachmann (talk) 19:53, 25 November 2024 (UTC)[reply]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Talk:Albanian_language&oldid=1259550960"