Jump to content

Art critic: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Notable art critics: German wiki link
 
(279 intermediate revisions by more than 100 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Short description|Person who specializes in evaluating art}}
[[Image:John Ruskin 1870.jpg|thumb|[[John Ruskin]] (1819-1900)]]
[[File:John Ruskin 1863.jpg|thumb|[[John Ruskin]] (1819–1900), who [[Leo Tolstoy]] described as "one of those rare men who think with their heart." A champion of the work of [[J. M. W. Turner]], Ruskin detested the work of [[James McNeill Whistler]].<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.tate.org.uk/britain/exhibitions/turnerwhistlermonet/wvr.htm|title=Turner Whistler Monet|publisher=[[Tate]]|access-date=2009-04-12|archive-date=2012-01-12|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20120112211617/http://www.tate.org.uk/britain/exhibitions/turnerwhistlermonet/wvr.htm|url-status=dead}}</ref>]]
An '''art critic''' is a person who specializes in evaluating [[art]]. Their written critiques, or reviews, are published in newspapers, magazines, books and on web sites. [[Art collector]]s and patrons often utilize the advice of art critics as a way to enhance their appreciation of the art they are viewing.
An '''art critic''' is a person who is specialized in analyzing, interpreting, and evaluating [[art]]. Their written critiques or reviews contribute to [[art criticism]] and they are published in newspapers, magazines, books, exhibition brochures, and catalogues and on websites. Some of today's art critics use [[art blog]]s and other online platforms in order to connect with a wider audience and expand debate.


==Opinions==
Typically the art critic views art at [[art exhibition|exhibitions]], [[art gallery|galleries]], [[museum]]s or [[artist]]s' [[studio]]s.
Differently from [[art history]], there is not commonly an [[institutionalisation|institutionalized]] training for art critics. Art critics come from different backgrounds and they may or may not be university trained.<ref>James Elkins, ''What happened to art criticism'', Prickley Paradigm Press, 2003, p. 8.</ref> Professional art critics are expected to have a keen eye for art and a thorough knowledge of [[art history]]. Typically the art critic views art at [[art exhibition|exhibitions]], [[art gallery|galleries]], [[museum]]s or [[artist]]s' [[studio]]s and they can be members of the [[International Association of Art Critics]] which has national sections.<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.aica-int.org/spip.php?article3 |title=Organisation Chart 2012–2013 – AICA international |access-date=2013-12-12 |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20131212152149/http://www.aica-int.org/spip.php?article3 |archive-date=2013-12-12 }}</ref> Very rarely art critics earn their living from writing criticism.


The opinions of art critics have the potential to stir debate on art-related topics. Due to this the viewpoints of art critics writing for art publications and newspapers adds to public discourse concerning art and culture. [[Art collector]]s and patrons often rely on the advice of such [[critic]]s as a way to enhance their appreciation of the art they are viewing. Many now-famous and celebrated artists were not recognized by the art critics of their time, often because their art was in a style not yet understood or favored. Conversely, some critics have become particularly important helping to explain and promote new [[art movement]]s – [[Roger Fry]] with the [[Post-Impressionist]] movement and [[Lawrence Alloway]] with [[pop art]] as examples.
Professional art critics are expected to have a keen eye for art and a thorough knowledge of art history. Knowledge, however, provides no guarantee that a critic will know if a [[work of art]], an exhibition, or an artist will stand out in history as "great".


== Controversies ==
The opinions of art critics has the potential to stir debate on art related topics. Due to this the viewpoints of art critics writing for art publications and newspapers adds to public discourse concerning art and culture.


According to James Elkins<ref>James Elkins, "Introduction" in ''Is Art History Global?'', dir. James Elkins, Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, 2007, pp. 5–15.</ref> there is a distinction between art criticism and art history based on institutional, contextual, and commercial criteria; the history of [[art criticism]] is taught in universities, but the practice of art criticism is excluded institutionally from academia. An experience-related article is Agnieszka Gratza.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.theguardian.com/culture-professionals-network/culture-professionals-blog/2013/oct/17/frieze-art-critic-academia-journalism|title=Frieze or faculty? One art critic's move from academia to journalism|first=Agnieszka|last=Gratza|date=17 October 2013|work=[[The Guardian]]}}</ref> Always according to James Elkins in smaller and developing countries, newspaper art criticism normally serves as art history. James Elkins's perspective portraits his personal link to [[art history]] and [[art historians]] and in ''What happened to art criticism'' he furthermore highlights the gap between art historians and art critics by suggesting that the first rarely cite the second as a source and that the second miss an academic discipline to refer to.<ref>James Elkins, ''What Happened to Art Criticism'', Prickley Paradigm Press, 2003, pp. 4–5, 9.</ref>
Many now famous and celebrated artists were not recognized by the art critics of their time, often because their art was in a style not yet understood or favored. Conversely, some critics, called [[militant critic|militant critics]] have helped to explain and promote new [[art movements]] &mdash; [[Roger Fry]] with the [[Post-Impressionist]] movement for example.


==Gallery==
== Some famous art critics ==
<gallery widths="140px" heights="140px">
[[Image:Guillaume Apollinaire 1914.jpg|thumb|[[Guillaume Apollinaire]] (1880-1918)]]
File:Denisdiderot.jpg|[[Jean-Honoré Fragonard]], ''Portrait of [[Denis Diderot]],'' 1769, [[Louvre]], [[Paris]]. His [[art criticism]] was highly influential. His ''Essais sur la peinture'' was described by [[Johann Wolfgang von Goethe]], as "a magnificent work, which speaks even more helpfully to the poet than to the painter, though to the painter too it is as a blazing torch." Diderot's favorite painter was [[Jean-Baptiste Greuze]].<ref>[[Edmond de Goncourt|Edmond]] and [[Jules de Goncourt]], ''French Eighteenth-Century Painters.'' Cornell Paperbacks, 1981, pp. 222–225. {{ISBN|0-8014-9218-1}}</ref>
File:John Neal by Sarah Miriam Peale 1823 Portland Museum of Art.jpg|Portrait of [[John Neal (writer)|John Neal]] by [[Sarah Miriam Peale]], 1823. Neal is regarded as the first American art critic<ref>{{Cite book | publisher = Pennsylvania State College | last = Dickson | first = Harold Edward | title = Observations on American Art: Selections from the Writings of John Neal (1793–1876) | location = State College, Pennsylvania | year = 1943 | page = ix}}</ref><ref>{{cite book | last = Sears | first = Donald A. | title = John Neal | publisher = Twayne Publishers | location = Boston, Massachusetts | year = 1978 | isbn = 080-5-7723-08 | page = 118}}</ref> and was also an influential writer and literary critic.
File:Charles Baudelaire 1855 Nadar.jpg|[[Charles Baudelaire]] 1855, Photo by [[Nadar]]. Baudelaire is associated with the [[Decadent movement]]. His book of poetry ''[[Les Fleurs du mal]]'' is acknowledged as a classic of [[French literature]]<ref>Joanna Richardson, ''Baudelaire'', St. Martin's Press, New York, 1994, p. 191, {{ISBN|0-312-11476-1}}.</ref>
File:Portrait of Zacharie Astruc (1866) - Edouard Manet (Kunsthalle Bremen).jpg|[[Édouard Manet]], ''Portrait of [[Zacharie Astruc]]'' 1866, [[Kunsthalle Bremen]]. He was a strong defender of [[Gustave Courbet]], and was one of the first to recognize the talent of [[Édouard Manet]]. He also defended [[Claude Monet]], [[James McNeill Whistler]], [[Carolus-Duran]], [[Fantin-Latour]], and [[Alphonse Legros]].
File:Manet, Edouard - Portrait of Emile Zola.jpg|[[Édouard Manet]], ''Portrait of [[Émile Zola]]'', 1868, [[Musée d'Orsay]]. Émile Zola (1840-1902) was an influential French [[writer]], and art critic. He was a major figure in the exoneration of the falsely accused and convicted army officer [[Alfred Dreyfus]].<ref>[//fr.wikisource.org/wiki/J’accuse…! J'accuse letter] at French [[wikisource]]</ref>
File:Aurier, Albert, BNF Gallica.jpg|[[Albert Aurier]], c. 1890, Wrote about [[Vincent van Gogh]], and [[Paul Gauguin]].<ref>{{cite web|url=http://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/15544/11504206.pdf?sequence=1|title=G.-Albert Aurier, Critic and Theorist of Symbolist Art|last=Lunn|first=Margaret Rauschenbach|publisher=[[Massachusetts Institute of Technology]]|date=15 October 1982|type=PhD thesis|format=PDF|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110604233631/http://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/15544/11504206.pdf?sequence=1|archive-date=4 June 2011|url-status=dead}}</ref>
File:Signac - Portrait de Félix Fénéon.jpg|[[Paul Signac]], ''[[Opus 217. Against the Enamel of a Background Rhythmic with Beats and Angles, Tones, and Tints, Portrait of M. Félix Fénéon in 1890|Félix Fénéon]],'' 1890. A French [[anarchist]] and art critic in Paris during the late 1800s. He [[Neologism|coined]] the term "[[Neo-impressionism]]" in 1886.
File:Clive Bell.jpg|Portrait of [[Clive Bell]] (1881-1964), by [[Roger Fry]] (1924 c.)<ref>{{Cite book |url=http://www.oxfordreference.com/abstract/10.1093/acref/9780199754694.001.0001/acref-9780199754694-e-179 |title=Bell, Arthur Clive Heward – Oxford Reference |language=en |doi=10.1093/acref/9780199754694.001.0001 |access-date=2018-09-17|year=2006 |isbn=9780199754694 |editor-last1=Grayling |editor-last2=Goulder |editor-last3=Pyle |editor-first1=A.C |editor-first2=Naomi |editor-first3=Andrew }}</ref>
File:Guillaume Apollinaire 1914.jpg|[[Guillaume Apollinaire]] (1880–1918), 1914, French poet, writer and art critic he is credited with coining the word [[surrealism]]
File:Modigliani, Picasso and André Salmon.jpg|[[André Salmon]], Modigliani, and [[Pablo Picasso]] in Montparnasse (1916), photographed by [[Jean Cocteau]]
File:Roger Fry self-portrait.jpg|[[Roger Fry]] ''[[Self-portrait]],'' 1928. He was described by [[Kenneth Clark]] as "incomparably the greatest influence on taste since [[John Ruskin|Ruskin]]... In so far as taste can be changed by one man, it was changed by Roger Fry".<ref>{{cite encyclopedia|editor=Ian Chilvers|chapter=Fry, Roger|page=169|encyclopedia=The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Art and Artists|location=Oxford and New York|publisher=Oxford University Press|year=1990|chapter-url=https://archive.org/details/conciseoxforddic00chil/page/168/mode/2up|chapter-url-access=registration}}</ref>
File:Leo Stein.jpg|[[Leo Stein]] (1872–1947), art collector/critic, elder brother of [[Gertrude Stein]]. Photo by [[Carl Van Vechten]], November 9, 1937
File:Frank O'Hara (photo portrait).jpg|[[Frank O'Hara]] (1926-1966),<ref name="test">[https://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/07/arts/design/07rivers.html], Refurbished Reputation for a Nervy Painter.</ref> [[Larry Rivers]], delivered one of the eulogies, along with [[Bill Berkson]], [[Edwin Denby (poet)|Edwin Denby]], and [[René d'Harnoncourt]].<ref>From "A Short Chronology", in Donald Allen: ''The Collected Poems of Frank O'Hara''.</ref>
File:Arthur Danto, 2012.jpg|[[Arthur Danto]], (1924-2013), Danto laid the groundwork for an institutional definition of art<ref>This theory has been described as an "influential theory about the nature of art", according to [http://philosophynow.org/issues/99/News_November_December_2013 Philosophy Now, November 2013]</ref>
File:John Berger-2009 (6).jpg|[[John Berger]], (1926-2017),<ref name="John Berger obituary">{{Cite news |url=https://www.theguardian.com/books/2017/jan/02/john-berger-obituary |title=John Berger obituary |work=The Guardian |date=2 January 2017 |access-date=3 January 2017}}</ref><ref name="newstatesman">{{Cite news |url=http://www.newstatesman.com/culture/2015/06/i-think-dead-are-us-john-berger-88 |title=I think the dead are with us": John Berger at 88 |work=The New Statesman |date=11 June 2015 |access-date=3 January 2017}}</ref>
</gallery>


== Notable art critics ==
{{main list|List of art critics}}[[:nl:Erik_de_Smedt|Erik de Smedt]]{{Div col|colwidth=18em}}
* [[Christopher Allen (critic)|Christopher Allen]]
* [[Lawrence Alloway]]
* [[Lawrence Alloway]]
* [[Guillaume Apollinaire]]
* [[Guillaume Apollinaire]]
* [[Henriette Arasse]]
* [[Zacharie Astruc]]
* [[Albert Aurier]]
* [[Charles Baudelaire]]
* [[Michael Baxandall]]
* [[Sister Wendy Beckett]]
* [[Sister Wendy Beckett]]
* [[Andrew Berardini]]
* [[Clive Bell]]
* [[Clive Bell]]
* [[Charles Baudelaire]]
* [[Andrew Berardini]]
* [[Bernard Berenson]]
* [[John Berger]]
* [[Vasily Botkin]]
* [[John Canaday]]
* [[John Canaday]]
* [[Champfleury]]
* [[Kenneth Clark]]
* [[T. J. Clark (art historian)|T. J. Clark]]
* [[Robert Coates (critic)|Robert Coates]]
* [[Clarence Cook]]
* [[Clarence Cook]]
* [[Douglas Cooper (art historian)|Douglas Cooper]]
* [[Royal Cortissoz]]
* [[Thomas Craven]]
* [[Arthur Danto]]
* [[Arthur Danto]]
* [[Manny Farber]]
* [[G. Roger Denson]]
* [[Sergei Diaghilev]]
* [[Denis Diderot]]
* [[John Elderfield]]
* [[James Elkins (art historian)|James Elkins]]
* [[Félix Fénéon]]
* [[Félix Fénéon]]
* [[Hal Foster (art critic)|Hal Foster]]
* [[Peter Frank]]
* [[Peter Frank (art critic)|Peter Frank]]
* [[Michael Fried]]
* [[Michael Fried]]
* [[B. H. Friedman]]
* [[Roger Fry]]
* [[Roger Fry]]
* [[Mat Gleason]]
* [[Peter Fuller]]
* [Adam Gopnik]]
* [[Théophile Gautier]]
* [[Blake Gopnik]]
* [[Stepan Gedeonov]]
* [[Gustave Geffroy]]
* [[Clement Greenberg]]
* [[Clement Greenberg]]
* [[Dmitry Grigorovich (writer)|Dmitry Grigorovich]]
* [[Boris Groys]]
* [[Ichirō Hariu]]
* [[Dave Hickey]]
* [[Dave Hickey]]
* [[Robert Hughes]]
* [[Robert Hughes (critic)|Robert Hughes]]
* [[Edouard Jaguer]]
* [[Édouard Jaguer]]
* [[Chris Kraus]]
* [[Michael Kimmelman]]
* [[Michael Kimmelman]]
* [[:de:Gottfried Knapp|Gottfried Knapp]]
* [[Hilton Kramer]]
* [[Hilton Kramer]]
* [[Rosalind Krauss]]
* [[Rosalind E. Krauss]]
* [[Carrie Lovelace]]
* [[R. Siva Kumar]]
* [[Libby Lumpkin]]
* [[Donald Kuspit]]
* [[Julien Leclercq (poet)|Julien Leclercq]]
* [[Maureen Mullarkey]]
* [[Louis Leroy]]
* [[Lucy R. Lippard]]
* [[Giovanni Lista]]
* [[George Loukomski]]
* [[Sergey Makovsky]]
* [[Nancy Marmer]]
* [[Camille Mauclair]]
* [[Octave Mirbeau]]
* [[Robert C. Morgan]]
* [[Robert C. Morgan]]
* [[Suzanne Muchnic]]
* [[John Neal (writer)|John Neal]]
* [[Linda Nochlin]]
* [[Frank O'Hara]]
* [[Saul Ostrow]]
* [[Jed Perl]]
* [[Adrian Prakhov]]
* [[Griselda Pollock]]
* [[Nikolay Punin]]
* [[Arlene Raven]]
* [[Herbert Read]]
* [[Herbert Read]]
* [[Pierre Restany]]
* [[Pierre Restany]]
* [[John Rewald]]
* [[Rainer Maria Rilke]]
* [[Daniel Robbins (art historian)|Daniel Robbins]]
* [[Barbara Rose]]
* [[Barbara Rose]]
* [[Harold Rosenberg]]
* [[Harold Rosenberg]]
* [[John Ruskin]]]
* [[Robert Rosenblum]]
* [[John Ruskin]]
* [[John Russell (art critic)|John Russell]]
* [[Frank Rutter]]
* [[Frank Rutter]]
* [[André Salmon]]
* [[Jerry Saltz]]
* [[Irving Sandler]]
* [[Meyer Schapiro]]
* [[Peter Schjeldahl]]
* [[Brian Sewell]]
* [[Brian Sewell]]
* [[Roberta Smith]]
* [[Rafael Squirru]]
* [[Rafael Squirru]]
* [[Vladimir Stasov]]
* [[Leo Stein]]
* [[Leo Steinberg]]
* [[Aleksey Suvorin]]
* [[Michel Tapié]]
* [[Michel Tapié]]
* [[Théophile Thoré-Bürger]]
* [[Éric Troncy]]
* [[Tristan Tzara]]
* [[Kirk Varnedoe]]
* [[Louis Vauxcelles]]
* [[Boris Vipper]]
* [[Karen Wilkin]]
* [[Karen Wilkin]]
* [[Linda Yablonsky]]
* [[Émile Zola]]
* [[Zenia Zed]]
* [[Ticio Escobar]]
{{div col end}}


== See also ==
==See also==
* [[Art criticism]]
*[[List of art critics]]


==References==
[[Category:Art critics| ]]
{{Reflist}}
[[Category:American art critics]]


==External links==
[[mk:Ликовен критичар]]
*{{Commons category-inline|Art critics}}
[[ja:美術評論家]]
*[https://web.archive.org/web/20110116065925/http://www.friezefoundation.org/talks/detail/empathy_and_criticality/ Good audio version of symposium on contemporary (2007) art criticism entitled "Empathy and Criticality", sponsored by the Frieze Foundation]

{{Art world |state=autocollapse}}
{{Authority control}}

{{DEFAULTSORT:Art Critic}}
[[Category:Art critics| ]]
[[Category:Art occupations|critic]]

Latest revision as of 16:39, 28 November 2024

John Ruskin (1819–1900), who Leo Tolstoy described as "one of those rare men who think with their heart." A champion of the work of J. M. W. Turner, Ruskin detested the work of James McNeill Whistler.[1]

An art critic is a person who is specialized in analyzing, interpreting, and evaluating art. Their written critiques or reviews contribute to art criticism and they are published in newspapers, magazines, books, exhibition brochures, and catalogues and on websites. Some of today's art critics use art blogs and other online platforms in order to connect with a wider audience and expand debate.

Opinions

[edit]

Differently from art history, there is not commonly an institutionalized training for art critics. Art critics come from different backgrounds and they may or may not be university trained.[2] Professional art critics are expected to have a keen eye for art and a thorough knowledge of art history. Typically the art critic views art at exhibitions, galleries, museums or artists' studios and they can be members of the International Association of Art Critics which has national sections.[3] Very rarely art critics earn their living from writing criticism.

The opinions of art critics have the potential to stir debate on art-related topics. Due to this the viewpoints of art critics writing for art publications and newspapers adds to public discourse concerning art and culture. Art collectors and patrons often rely on the advice of such critics as a way to enhance their appreciation of the art they are viewing. Many now-famous and celebrated artists were not recognized by the art critics of their time, often because their art was in a style not yet understood or favored. Conversely, some critics have become particularly important helping to explain and promote new art movementsRoger Fry with the Post-Impressionist movement and Lawrence Alloway with pop art as examples.

Controversies

[edit]

According to James Elkins[4] there is a distinction between art criticism and art history based on institutional, contextual, and commercial criteria; the history of art criticism is taught in universities, but the practice of art criticism is excluded institutionally from academia. An experience-related article is Agnieszka Gratza.[5] Always according to James Elkins in smaller and developing countries, newspaper art criticism normally serves as art history. James Elkins's perspective portraits his personal link to art history and art historians and in What happened to art criticism he furthermore highlights the gap between art historians and art critics by suggesting that the first rarely cite the second as a source and that the second miss an academic discipline to refer to.[6]

[edit]

Notable art critics

[edit]

Erik de Smedt

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ "Turner Whistler Monet". Tate. Archived from the original on 2012-01-12. Retrieved 2009-04-12.
  2. ^ James Elkins, What happened to art criticism, Prickley Paradigm Press, 2003, p. 8.
  3. ^ "Organisation Chart 2012–2013 – AICA international". Archived from the original on 2013-12-12. Retrieved 2013-12-12.
  4. ^ James Elkins, "Introduction" in Is Art History Global?, dir. James Elkins, Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, 2007, pp. 5–15.
  5. ^ Gratza, Agnieszka (17 October 2013). "Frieze or faculty? One art critic's move from academia to journalism". The Guardian.
  6. ^ James Elkins, What Happened to Art Criticism, Prickley Paradigm Press, 2003, pp. 4–5, 9.
  7. ^ Edmond and Jules de Goncourt, French Eighteenth-Century Painters. Cornell Paperbacks, 1981, pp. 222–225. ISBN 0-8014-9218-1
  8. ^ Dickson, Harold Edward (1943). Observations on American Art: Selections from the Writings of John Neal (1793–1876). State College, Pennsylvania: Pennsylvania State College. p. ix.
  9. ^ Sears, Donald A. (1978). John Neal. Boston, Massachusetts: Twayne Publishers. p. 118. ISBN 080-5-7723-08.
  10. ^ Joanna Richardson, Baudelaire, St. Martin's Press, New York, 1994, p. 191, ISBN 0-312-11476-1.
  11. ^ J'accuse letter at French wikisource
  12. ^ Lunn, Margaret Rauschenbach (15 October 1982). "G.-Albert Aurier, Critic and Theorist of Symbolist Art" (PDF) (PhD thesis). Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Archived from the original (PDF) on 4 June 2011.
  13. ^ Grayling, A.C; Goulder, Naomi; Pyle, Andrew, eds. (2006). Bell, Arthur Clive Heward – Oxford Reference. doi:10.1093/acref/9780199754694.001.0001. ISBN 9780199754694. Retrieved 2018-09-17.
  14. ^ Ian Chilvers, ed. (1990). "Fry, Roger". The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Art and Artists. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. p. 169.
  15. ^ [1], Refurbished Reputation for a Nervy Painter.
  16. ^ From "A Short Chronology", in Donald Allen: The Collected Poems of Frank O'Hara.
  17. ^ This theory has been described as an "influential theory about the nature of art", according to Philosophy Now, November 2013
  18. ^ "John Berger obituary". The Guardian. 2 January 2017. Retrieved 3 January 2017.
  19. ^ "I think the dead are with us": John Berger at 88". The New Statesman. 11 June 2015. Retrieved 3 January 2017.
[edit]