Michael Wittmann: Difference between revisions
m stray ref tag removed |
|||
(945 intermediate revisions by more than 100 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{short description|German tank commander (1914–1944)}} |
|||
{{redirect|Black Baron|other uses|Black Baron (disambiguation)}} |
|||
{{for|the German musicologist|Michael Wittmann (musicologist)}} |
|||
{{Use dmy dates|date=June 2020}} |
|||
{{Infobox military person |
{{Infobox military person |
||
|name= Michael Wittmann |
| name = Michael Wittmann |
||
| |
| birth_date = {{birth date|1914|4|22|df=y}} |
||
| |
| death_date = {{death date and age|1944|8|8|1914|4|22|df=y}} |
||
|image= |
| image = Bundesarchiv Bild 146-1983-108-29, Michael Wittmann.jpg |
||
| image_upright = 0.75 |
|||
|caption=Michael Wittmann |
|||
| caption = Wittmann in 1944 |
|||
|placeofbirth=Vogelthal |
|||
| birth_place = [[Dietfurt|Vogelthal]], [[Kingdom of Bavaria|Bavaria]], [[German Empire]] |
|||
|placeofdeath= Between the towns of [[Cintheaux]] and [[Saint-Aignan-de-Cramesnil|St. Aignan de Cramesnil]] near the farm of Gaumesnil<ref name="Pg416"/> |
|||
| death_place = near [[Saint-Aignan-de-Cramesnil]], [[Normandy]], [[German-occupied France]] |
|||
|placeofburial=[[La Cambe German war cemetery]] (reinterred) |
|||
| placeofburial = [[La Cambe German war cemetery]] (reinterred) |
|||
|nickname=The Black Baron<ref>Reid, p. 412</ref> |
|||
| nickname = |
|||
|allegiance={{flagicon|Nazi Germany}} [[Nazi Germany]] |
|||
| allegiance = {{flag|Nazi Germany}} |
|||
|branch=[[File:Flag Schutzstaffel.svg|23px]] [[Waffen SS]] |
|||
| branch = [[German Army (Wehrmacht)|Heer]] (1934–1936) <br />[[Waffen SS]] (1936–1944) |
|||
|serviceyears=1934 – 1944 |
|||
| serviceyears = 1934–1944 |
|||
|rank=[[Hauptsturmführer]] |
|||
| rank = SS-[[Hauptsturmführer]] |
|||
|commands= |
|||
| commands = |
|||
|unit=[[Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler]] and [[101st SS Heavy Panzer Detachment|Schwere SS-Panzer-Abteilung 101]] |
|||
| unit = [[SS Division Leibstandarte]] <br /> [[101st SS Heavy Panzer Battalion]] |
|||
|battles= [[World War II]]<br/> |
|||
| battles = {{Tree list}} |
|||
*[[September Campaign|Polish Campaign]] |
|||
*[[ |
* [[World War II]] |
||
** [[Eastern Front (World War II)|Eastern Front]] |
|||
*[[Battle of Greece]] |
|||
*[[Operation Barbarossa]] |
*** [[Operation Barbarossa]] |
||
*[[Battle of Kursk]] |
*** [[Battle of Kursk]] |
||
**** [[Operation Citadel]] |
|||
*[[operation Overlord|Battle of Normandy]]{{KIA}} |
|||
** [[Western Front (World War II)|Western Front]] |
|||
|awards=[[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross|Knight's Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords]] |
|||
*** [[Western Allied invasion of France]] |
|||
|laterwork=}} |
|||
**** [[Battle of Normandy]] |
|||
***** [[Battle of Villers-Bocage]] |
|||
'''Michael Wittmann''' (April 22, 1914 – August 8, 1944) was a German [[Waffen-SS]] tank commander during the [[Second World War]]. Wittmann would rise to the rank of SS-[[Hauptsturmführer]] (captain) and was a [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross]] holder. |
|||
***** [[Operation Totalize]] {{KIA}} |
|||
{{tree list/end}} |
|||
He was credited with the destruction of 138 tanks and 132 anti-tank guns, along with an unknown number of other armoured vehicles, making him one of Germany's top scoring panzer aces, together with [[Johannes Bölter]], [[Ernst Barkmann]], [[Otto Carius]] and [[Kurt Knispel]] who was the top scoring ace of the war with 168 tank kills.<ref>Kurowski, p. 125</ref> |
|||
| awards = [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross#Knight's Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords|Knight's Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords]] |
|||
| laterwork = |
|||
Wittmann is most famous for his ambush of elements of the [[British 7th Armoured Division]], during the [[Battle of Villers-Bocage]] on 13 June 1944. While in command of a single [[Tiger I|Panzerkampfwagen VI Tiger]] he destroyed up to 14 tanks and 15 personnel carriers along with 2 anti-tank guns within the space of 15 minutes. |
|||
}} |
|||
'''Michael Wittmann''' (22 April 1914{{spnd}}8 August 1944) was a German [[Waffen-SS]] tank commander during the [[Second World War]]. He is known for his ambush of elements of the [[British 7th Armoured Division]] during the [[Battle of Villers-Bocage]] on 13 June 1944. While in command of a [[Tiger I]] tank, Wittmann destroyed up to 14 tanks, 15 personnel carriers and two anti-tank guns within 15 minutes before the loss of his own tank. |
|||
Wittmann became a cult figure after the war thanks to his accomplishments as a "[[panzer ace]]" (a highly decorated tank commander), part of the portrayal of the [[Waffen-SS in popular culture]]. Historians have mixed opinions about his tactical performance in battle. Some praised his actions at Villers-Bocage, while many others found his abilities lacking, and the praise for his tank kills overstated.{{sfn|Reid|2005|p=411}}<ref>{{Citation |title=Allied Tanks in Normandy 1944 |series=New Vanguard 294 |first=Steven J. |last=Zaloga |date=2021 |publisher=Osprey |page=40 }}</ref> |
|||
The circumstances behind Wittmann’s death have caused some debate and discussion over the years, but it had been historically accepted that Trooper [[Joe Ekins]], the gunner in a [[Sherman Firefly]], of the 1st [[Northamptonshire Yeomanry]] was his killer. However, in recent years, some commentators have suggested that members of the [[Canadian]] [[Les Fusiliers de Sherbrooke|Sherbrooke Fusiliers Regiment]] may have been responsible instead.<ref name= "Pg410-430">Reid, pp. 410-430</ref> |
|||
Although the number is disputed, he is credited with destroying 135 to 138 enemy tanks. German tank kills were recorded as a unit.<ref>{{Cite journal |date=September 1, 2010 |title=Who killed Germany's dreaded 'Black Baron' tank ace? |journal=World War II |volume=25 |issue=3 |pages=Vol. 25 Issue 3, p12, 1 p |via=Gale}}</ref> When he was presented with the ''Oak leaves to his Knights Cross'' by Hitler on 2 February 1944 his total was 117 tanks.{{sfn|Trigg|2019|p=178}} |
|||
==Early life and career== |
|||
Michael Wittmann was born on April 22, 1914 in the village of Vogelthal in the [[Oberpfalz]] region of [[Bavaria]]. He was the second son of local farmer Johann Wittmann and his wife Ursula. In February 1934, Michael joined the Volunteer Labour Service, the FAD (what later became the [[Reichsarbeitsdienst|RAD]]) and on October 30, 1934 he joined the [[German Army]]. He was assigned to the 19. Infantry Regiment based at [[Freising]] by [[Munich]], eventually reaching the rank of [[Gefreiter]] (lance-corporal). In October 1936 the 22-year-old Wittmann joined the [[Allgemeine-SS]]. On April 5, 1937, he was assigned to the premier [[regiment]], later division [[Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler|Leibstandarte-SS ''Adolf Hitler'']] (LSSAH) and was given the rank [[Mann (military rank)|SS-Mann]] (private). A year later, he participated in the occupation of [[Anschluss|Austria]] and the [[Sudetenland]] with an armoured car platoon. |
|||
== |
==Early life and World War II== |
||
===Early War=== |
|||
Michael Wittmann was born in the village of [[Vogelthal]], near [[Dietfurt]] in [[Kingdom of Bavaria|Bavaria]]'s [[Upper Palatinate]], on 22 April 1914. He enlisted in the [[German Army (Wehrmacht)|German Army]] (''Heer'') in 1934 after the [[Adolf Hitler's rise to power|Nazi seizure of power]].{{sfn|Stockert|1998|p=338}} Wittmann joined the [[Schutzstaffel]] (SS) in October 1936 and was assigned to the regiment, later division, [[Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler]] (LSSAH) on 5 April 1937. A year later, he participated in the [[Anschluss|annexation of Austria]], the occupation of [[Sudetenland]], and joined the [[Nazi Party]].{{sfn|Agte|2006|}} |
|||
His first experience of action came in the [[September Campaign|Polish Campaign]], followed by the [[Battle of France]] as a commander of the new self-propelled assault guns, the [[Sturmgeschütz III|Sturmgeschütz III Ausf. A]]. The Greek campaign - [[Battle of Greece|Operation 'Marita']] - was launched on April 6, 1941. Leibstandarte SS ''Adolf Hitler'' (LSSAH) captured the [[Greece|Greek]] capital and formed the spearhead, alongside the 9th [[Panzer]] Division, which punched through the Greek countryside. After three weeks of campaigning, [[Nazi Germany]] had conquered Greece. Wittmann and his unit were sent to [[Czechoslovakia]] for a refit. |
|||
===Eastern Front=== |
===Eastern Front=== |
||
Wittmann's unit was transferred to the [[Eastern Front (World War II)|Eastern Front]] in the spring of 1941 for [[Operation Barbarossa]], the planned invasion of the [[Soviet Union]]. He was assigned to SS Panzer Regiment 1, a tank unit, where he commanded a [[StuG III]] assault gun/tank destroyer as well as a [[Panzer III]] medium tank. By 1943, he commanded a [[Tiger I]] tank, and had become a platoon leader in the heavy company by the time [[Operation Citadel]] and the [[Battle of Kursk]] took place. Attached to the LSSAH, Wittmann's platoon of four Tigers reinforced the division's reconnaissance battalion to screen the division's left flank. On their first day in battle at Kursk, Wittmann and his crew were credited with eight tanks and seven anti-tank guns destroyed.<ref>Gilbert p. 226.</ref> At one point, his tank survived a collision with a burning [[T-34]].{{sfn|Ripley|2004|p=150}} |
|||
[[File:Bundesarchiv Bild 146-1987-074-33, Michael Wittmann und Adolf Hitler.jpg|thumb|right|Wittmann receiving the Swords to his [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross]] from [[Adolf Hitler]].]] |
|||
The rest would not last long, however, as Wittmann's unit was soon dispatched to the [[Eastern Front (World War II)|Eastern Front]] to participate in the invasion of the [[Soviet Union]]. He initially served as a commander of a StuG III assault gun. He was assigned for both officer and tank training in the winter of 1942–43. |
|||
In November 1943, Wittmann, still serving in Leibstandarte’s heavy company, was involved in armored counterattacks against the Russians around [[Zhitomir]]. On their first day in action against the Soviets, Wittman’s crew claimed the destruction of ten T-34s and five anti-tank guns. “By early January 1944 his combined total of destroyed tanks would rise to sixty-six.”<ref>Gilbert p. 255.</ref> |
|||
Returning to the Eastern Front as a newly [[commissioned officer]], Wittmann was reassigned to the SS Panzer Regiment 1, a tank unit with the rank of SS-[[Untersturmführer]] (second lieutenant), where he commanded a [[Panzer III]] tank. By 1943, he commanded a Tiger, and by the time of the [[Battle of Kursk]] ([[Operation Citadel]]), he was a platoon leader. On January 14, 1944, he was awarded the [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross]] and on January 30, the Oak Leaves for his continued excellence in the field. By this time, he had destroyed 88 enemy tanks and a significant number of other armoured vehicles. |
|||
In Agte's book on Wittmann (''Michael Wittmann And The Tiger Commanders Of The Leibstandarte'') it calculates his kills thusly: |
|||
In the 5 days of Zittadelle Wittmann destroyed 'at least' 30 tanks.(page 100) |
|||
'destroyed 13 T34's' on 21 November 1943 (page 130) |
|||
56 enemy tanks in the period July 1943-7/1/44 (page 158) |
|||
In summary: |
|||
[[File:Bundesarchiv Bild 146-1987-074-33, Michael Wittmann und Adolf Hitler.jpg|thumb|upright|left|alt=Wittmann, standing on the left, is shown receiving his Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross from Adolf Hitler standing on the right.| Wittmann receiving the Swords to his [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross]] from [[Adolf Hitler]] in 1944]] |
|||
56 kills on 7/1/44 (page 213) |
|||
On 14 January 1944, Wittmann was awarded the [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross]]. The presentation was made by his divisional commander, SS-''[[Oberführer]]'' [[Theodor Wisch]], who nominated him for the [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves]].{{sfn|Stockert|1998|p=340}} Wittmann was awarded the Oak Leaves on 30 January for the claimed destruction of 117 tanks, making him the 380th member of the German armed forces to receive it. He received the award from [[Adolf Hitler]], who presented it to him at the [[Wolf's Lair]], his headquarters in [[Rastenburg]], on 2 February 1944.{{sfn|Stockert|1998|pp=342–343}} |
|||
66 kills on 9/1/44 (page 181) |
|||
88 kills on 13/1/44 (page 213) |
|||
114-117 kills on 29/1/44 (page 185) |
|||
It would seem over half his total were claimed in a three week period in January 1944. |
|||
===Normandy=== |
===Normandy=== |
||
{{main|Battle of Villers-Bocage}} |
|||
[[File:Bundesarchiv Bild 101I-299-1802-08, Nordfrankreich, Michael Wittmann auf Panzer VI (Tiger I).jpg|thumb|right|alt=A man, wearing dress uniform and a cap, sits on top of a tank barrel; the tank is not fully in view.|Michael Wittman photographed one month prior to Operation Overlord]] |
|||
In April 1944, the LSSAH's Tiger Company was transferred to [[SS Heavy Panzer Battalion 101]].{{sfn|Reynolds|2002|p=30}} This battalion was assigned to the [[I SS Panzer Corps]] as a corps asset, and was never permanently attached to any division or regiment. Wittmann was appointed commander of the battalion's second company, and held the rank of SS-''[[Obersturmführer]]''.{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=61}} On 7 June, the day after the Allied [[Invasion of Normandy]] began, the battalion was ordered to move from [[Beauvais]] to [[Normandy]]. The move, covering 165 km (105 miles), took five days to complete.{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=57}}{{sfn|Reynolds|2001|pp=80, 99}} |
|||
[[File:Bundesarchiv Bild 101I-299-1804-07, Nordfrankreich, Panzer VI (Tiger I).jpg|thumb|alt=Four tanks move down a tree lined lane in open country.|Wittmann's company, 7 June 1944, en route to [[Morgny]]. Wittmann is standing in the turret of Tiger 205.{{sfn|Agte|2000|p=224–225}}]] |
|||
In April 1944, the LSSAH's Tiger Company was transferred to the [[SS Heavy Panzer Battalion 101]].<ref>Reynolds, p. 30</ref> This battalion was assigned to the [[I SS Panzer Corps]] and was never permanently attached to any division or regiment within the corps.{{Citation needed|date=October 2009}} Wittmann commanded the 2nd Company of the battalion and held the rank of SS-[[Obersturmführer]] (first lieutenant).<ref name="Forty61"/> Following the Allied [[Invasion of Normandy]], the battalion was ordered to move from [[Beauvais]] to [[Normandy]] on 7 June, a move that was completed on 12 June after a five day road march.<ref name="FortyPg57"/><ref name="Reynolds8099">Reynolds, pp. 80, 99</ref> |
|||
Due to the |
Due to the Anglo-American advance south from [[Gold Beach|Gold]] and [[Omaha Beach]]es, the [[352nd Infantry Division (Wehrmacht)|German 352nd Infantry Division]] began to buckle. As the division withdrew south, it opened a 12 km (a 7.5-mile) gap in the front line near [[Caumont-l'Éventé]].{{sfn|Buckley|2007|p=59}}{{sfn|Weigley|1981|pp=109–110}}{{sfn|Taylor|1999|p=9}} [[Sepp Dietrich]], commander of [[1st SS Panzer Corps]], ordered Heavy SS-Panzer Battalion 101, his only reserve, to position itself behind the [[Panzer Lehr Division]] and [[SS Division Hitlerjugend]]. From this position, the battalion could protect the developing open left flank.{{sfn|Reynolds|2001|pp=99–100}} Anticipating the importance the British would assign to the high ground near [[Villers-Bocage, Calvados|Villers-Bocage]],{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=57}} Wittmann's company was positioned near the town.{{sfn|Reynolds|2001|p=100}} It arrived late on 12 June. Nominally composed of 12 tanks, his company was 50 per cent understrength with only six tanks due to losses and mechanical failures{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=61}}{{sfn|Taylor|1999|pp=17–18}} on the hundred-mile road march from the assembly area at Beauvais. |
||
{{sfn|Trigg|2019|pp=178180}} |
|||
The British [[7th Armoured Division (United Kingdom)|7th Armoured Division]] |
The next morning, lead elements of the British [[7th Armoured Division (United Kingdom)|7th Armoured Division]] entered Villers-Bocage. Their objective was to exploit the gap in the front line, seize Villers-Bocage, and capture the nearby ridge (Point 213) in an attempt to force a German withdrawal.{{sfn|Buckley|2006|pp=24–25}}{{sfn|Wilmot|McDevitt|1952|p=308}}{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=47}}{{sfn|D'Este|2004|p=177}}{{sfn|Neillands|2005|p=221}} Wittman had not expected them to arrive so soon and had no time to assemble his company.{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=58}} "Instead I had to act quickly, as I had to assume that the enemy had already spotted me and would destroy me where I stood." Having ordered the rest of the company to hold its ground, he set off with one tank.{{sfn|Taylor|1999|p=38}} |
||
[[File:Bundesarchiv Bild 101I-738-0267-21A, Villers-Bocage, zerstörte Militärfahrzeuge.jpg|thumb|alt=Several destroyed vehicles line the side of a tree- and hedge-lined road. A destroyed gun, twisted metal and debris occupy the foreground.|The wreckage of the British transport column Wittmann engaged, including an anti-tank gun in the foreground.]] |
|||
<blockquote>I had no time to assemble my company; instead I had to act quickly, as I had to assume that the enemy had already spotted me and would destroy me where I stood. I set off with one tank and passed the order to the others not to retreat a single step but to hold their ground.<ref name="Taylor38">Taylor, p. 38</ref></blockquote> |
|||
At approximately 09:00,{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=57}} Wittmann's Tiger emerged from cover onto the main road, [[Route nationale|Route Nationale]] 175, and engaged the rearmost British tanks positioned on Point 213, destroying them.{{sfn|Reynolds|2001|p=103}}{{sfn|Taylor|1999|pp=18–19}} Wittmann then moved towards Villers-Bocage, shooting several unarmed transport vehicles parked along the roadside; the carriers burst into flames as their fuel tanks were ruptured by machine gun and high explosive fire.{{sfn|Taylor|1999|p=19}}{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=60}} Moving into the eastern end of the town, he engaged several light tanks, followed by medium tanks.{{sfn|Taylor|1999|pp=19, 23}} Alerted to Wittmann's actions, light tanks in the middle of the town quickly got off the road, while medium tanks were brought forward.{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=61}} Wittmann, meanwhile, had destroyed another British tank{{sfn|Taylor|1999|p=24}} and two artillery observation post (OP) tanks,<ref group=note>Used as mobile protection for artillery spotting and "one of which had a dummy wooden gun" (Buckley, ''British Armour in the Normandy Campaign'' p26)</ref>{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=137}} followed by a [[scout car]] and a [[half-track]].{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=62}} |
|||
Accounts differ slightly as to what happened next. Historians record that, after destroying the OP tanks, Wittmann duelled briefly without success with a [[Sherman Firefly]] before withdrawing.{{sfn|Taylor|1999|p=30}}{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=64}} His Tiger is then reported to have continued eastwards to the outskirts of the town before being disabled by an anti-tank gun.{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=65}} However, Wittmann said his tank was disabled by an anti-tank gun in the town centre.{{sfn|Taylor|1999|p=38}} |
|||
In less than 15 minutes, 13 or 14 tanks, two anti-tank guns, and 13 to 15 transport vehicles had been destroyed by Heavy SS-Panzer Battalion 101, the majority<ref>{{Cite web |title=Villers-Bocage |url=https://www.battleofnormandytours.com/villers-bocage.html |access-date=2023-11-06 |website=Battle of Normandy Tours |language=en}}</ref> or all<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Mawson |first=Robin |date=March 2005 |title=Normandy 60 years on: myths and legends |journal=Sabretache |volume=46 |issue=1 |via=Gale academic online}}</ref> attributed to Wittmann. He played no further role in the [[Battle of Villers-Bocage]].{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=74}} For his actions during the battle, Wittmann was promoted to SS-''[[Hauptsturmführer]]'', and awarded the [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords]].{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=134}} |
|||
[[File:Bundesarchiv Bild 101I-738-0267-21A, Villers-Bocage, zerstörte Militärfahrzeuge.jpg|thumb|right|alt=Several destroyed vehicles line the side of a tree and hedge lined road. A destroyed gun, twisted metal and debris occupy the foreground.|The wreckage of the British transport column, and an anti-tank gun, that Wittmann engaged.]] |
|||
The [[Nazi propaganda|German propaganda machine]] swiftly credited Wittmann, by then a household name in Germany, with all the British tanks destroyed at Villers-Bocage.{{sfn|Forty|2004|p=134}}{{sfn|Taylor|1999|p=82}} He recorded a radio message on the evening of 13 June, describing the battle and claiming that later counter-attacks had destroyed a British armoured regiment and an infantry battalion.{{sfn|Taylor|1999|p=38}} Doctored images were produced; three joined-together photographs, published in the German army magazine ''[[Signal (magazine)|Signal]]'', gave a false impression of the scale of destruction in the town.{{sfn|Taylor|1999|p=38}} The propaganda campaign was given credence in Germany and abroad, leaving the British convinced that the Battle of Villers-Bocage had been a disaster. In fact, its results were less clear-cut.{{sfn|Taylor|1999|p=82}} The Waffen-SS may have fought with distinction during the Battle of Kursk but could not match the army's success, hence Sepp Dietrich's attempts to manufacture a hero out of Wittmann.{{sfn|Marie|2003|p=59}} |
|||
In less than 15 minutes, 13–14 tanks, two anti-tank guns and 13–15 transport vehicles had been destroyed by the Heavy SS-Panzer Battalion 101, the vast majority attributed to Wittmann.<ref name="Forty66">Forty, p. 66. 5 Cromwell tanks, 1 Sherman Firefly, 3 M5 Stuarts, 1 Sherman OP tank (OP tanks had a dummy gun in place of the main cannon) and, 1 Cromwell OP</ref><ref name="Taylor33">Taylor, p. 33</ref> Wittmann would however play no further role in the [[Battle of Villers-Bocage]].<ref name="Forty74">Forty, p. 74</ref> For his actions during the battle, Wittmann was promoted to SS-[[Hauptsturmführer]] (captain) and awarded Swords to his [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross#Knight's Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords (mit Eichenlaub und Schwertern)|Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross]].<ref name="Forty134">Forty, p. 134</ref> |
|||
===Death=== |
|||
Historian Wolfgang Schneider calls into question Wittmann's tactical ability, claiming "a competent tank company commander does not accumulate so many serious mistakes".<ref name="Marie">Marie, p. 159</ref> Schneider also criticises Wittmann's disposition of his forces before the battle by having his Tigers position themselves in a sunken lane with a vehicle with engine trouble at the head of a stationary column thereby hampering mobility of his unit. It also risked blocking the entire company. However, Schneider saves his real opprobrium for Wittmann’s solitary advance into Villers-Bocage. Although he acknowledges Wittmann's courage, he points out that such an action "goes against all the rules". No intelligence was gathered beforehand, and there was no "centre of gravity" or "concentration of forces" in the attack. Schneider claims that because of Wittmann's actions, "the bulk of the 2nd Company and Mobius 1st Company came up against an enemy who had gone onto the defensive".<ref name="Marie"/> He calls Wittman's "carefree" advance into British-occupied positions "pure folly", and states that "such over hastiness was uncalled for". Schneider goes on to surmise that if Wittmann had properly prepared an assault involving the rest of his company and the 1st Company, far greater results could have been achieved. He concludes with the belief that "thoughtlessness of this kind was to cost [Wittmann] his life on August 9, 1944, near Gaumesnil, during an attack casually launched in open country with an exposed flank."<ref name="Marie"/> |
|||
[[File:Wittmann Tiger 007.jpg|thumb|upright=1.45|alt= A photograph of a wrecked Tiger tank in a field |Photograph of the wrecked Tiger 007, taken by French civilian Serge Varin in 1945, still in the field near Gaumesnil where it had been stopped a year before. The hull of the Tiger had been rolled forward from its original position to remove the tracks. It was originally next to the turret.]] |
|||
{{main|Operation Totalize}} |
|||
On 8 August 1944, [[UK|Anglo]]-[[Canada|Canadian]] forces launched [[Operation Totalize]]. Under the cover of darkness, British and Canadian tanks and troops seized the tactically important high ground near the town of [[Saint-Aignan-de-Cramesnil]]. Here they paused, awaiting an aerial bombardment that would signal the next phase of the attack. Unaware of the reason the Allied forces had halted, SS Hitlerjugend Division Commander [[Kurt Meyer]] ordered a [[counterattack]] to recapture the high ground.{{sfn|Reid|2005|p=410}}{{sfn|Hart|2007|pp=52–69}} |
|||
Wittmann led a group of seven Tiger tanks from Heavy SS-Panzer Battalion 101, supported by additional tanks and infantry. His group of Tigers crossed open terrain towards the high ground. They were ambushed by Allied tanks from two sides. On the right or northeast, British tanks from "A" Squadron 1st [[Northamptonshire Yeomanry]] and "B" Squadron [[144th Regiment Royal Armoured Corps]] were positioned in woods. To the left or west, "A" Squadron [[Sherbrooke Fusiliers Regiment|Sherbrooke Fusilier Regiment]] was located at a chateau courtyard broadside to the attack, where they had knocked firing positions through the stone walls.{{sfn|Reid|2005|pp=52–69, 414}} The attack collapsed as the Canadian tanks destroyed two Tiger tanks, two Panzer IVs and two self-propelled guns in Wittman's force, while British tank fire destroyed three other Tigers.<ref>[https://legionmagazine.com/en/2017/08/42743/ Mark Zuehlke, "Heroes and Villains: Radley-Walters & Wittmann", ''Legion Magazine'', August 8, 2017]</ref> During the ambush, anti-tank shells fired from Canadian tanks penetrated the upper hull of Wittmann's tank, igniting the ammunition. The resulting fire engulfed the tank and [[Jack-in-the-box effect|blew off]] the [[Gun turret|turret]].{{sfn|Reid|2005|p=427}} The destroyed tank's dead crew members were buried in an unmarked grave. In 1983, the German war graves commission located the burial site. Wittmann and his crew were reinterred together at the [[La Cambe German war cemetery]] in France.{{sfn|Stockert|1998|p=346}} |
|||
Following the Battle of Villers-Bocage, [[Adolf Hitler]] requested that Wittmann become a tank instructor, but he refused. In response, Hitler forbade Wittmann to take part in action again.{{Citation needed|date=October 2009}} On 10 July, Wittmann took over command of the battalion as the commanding officer was sent on sick leave.{{Citation needed|date=October 2009}} |
|||
In 2008 a documentary in the ''Battlefield Mysteries'' series examined the final battle. A historian, Norm Christie, interviewed participants; Rad Walters, [[Joe Ekins]] and Ken Tout, and from their testimony and the two German accounts pieced the final battle together. The Tigers left the cover of a hedge near Cintheaux at 12:30 in two prongs; one in the middle of the field with the other—including Wittman—moving more slowly on the right. The British 75mm armed tanks engaged the lead Tiger (Iriohn) hitting it in the transmission, bogies or track and it started going in circles trying to withdraw. Joe Ekins' tank hit the second Tiger on the right side and knocked it out. As the crew escaped and brought out their wounded, they watched another Tiger north of them go up in flames (Kisters). Iriohn partly withdrew but could not get away and was hit by Ekins—"the one that was mulling around." Wittmann signalled "Pull back!" He did not realize that a group of the Sherbrookes were immediately to his right, and in a volley they knocked out the two Tigers beside the road. The commander of the second Tiger recalled the position of Wittmann's tank and specifically the skewed turret. The tank blew up shortly afterwards. Hans Hoflinger in a following Tiger was also attacked by enfilading fire from Sherman Fireflies with powerful 17-pound guns, and had to abandon his tank. He saw the fire and explosion in Wittmann's tank, and that the turret was displaced to the right and tilted down to the front somewhat. None of his crew had gotten out.{{sfn|Trigg|2019|p=256}} Survivors from Dollinger's tank passed by the wreck of Wittmann's tank shortly afterwards. |
|||
==Death== |
|||
In more recent years the 2008 Battlefield Mysteries documentary has been criticized on grounds of inaccuracy and standard of proof. It is largely based on the postulations put forward by Canadian writer Brian Reid's unsubstantiated claims made in 2005. Much of the show is based on speculation and is at odds with the first Investigation conducted by After The Battle military magazine published in 1985. It was the After The Battle that were the first to investigate Wittmann's death and had documentary evidence from the War Diary of the 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry. This only mentions 3 Tigers in the field, numbers 312, 007 and 314 and it does not mention the Sherbrooke Fusiliers who were supposed to be across the field? In a battle this would have been reported. |
|||
[[File:Wittmann Tiger 007.jpg|right|thumb|350px|The only known photograph of the wrecked Tiger 007, taken by French civilian Mr. Serge Varin in 1945, still in the field near Gaumesnil where it had been stopped a year before.]] |
|||
====Speculation surrounding death==== |
|||
Wittmann was killed on 8 August 1944 while taking part in a counterattack ordered by [[Kurt Meyer (Panzermeyer)|Kurt Meyer]], of the [[12th SS Panzer Division]] to retake tactically important high ground near the town of [[Saint-Aignan-de-Cramesnil]]. The town and surrounding high ground had been captured a few hours earlier by Anglo-Canadian forces during [[Operation Totalize]].<ref>Reid, p. 410</ref><ref name= "Pg52-69">Hart, pp. 52-69</ref> Wittmann had decided to participate in the attack as he believed the company commander who was supposed to lead the attack was too inexperienced.<ref name="Agte p258-266">Agte 2000, pp. 258-266.</ref> |
|||
For such a junior officer, an unusual amount of speculation has surrounded Wittmann's death, both as to its cause and the party responsible. Agte states that „the English” could have possibly placed a bounty on him. This is contradicted by Allied records and the testimony of Allied troops involved that he was not singled out during the battle.{{sfn|Reid|2005|p=410}} |
|||
After the war, claims were made by or for the following units as being responsible for Wittmann's death: the [[1st Polish Armoured Division]], the [[4th Canadian Armoured Division]], the [[144th Regiment Royal Armoured Corps]], and the [[RAF Second Tactical Air Force]].{{sfn|Reid|2005|pp=418–420}} |
|||
A group of seven Tiger tanks from the Heavy SS-Panzer Battalion 101, supported by several other tanks, was ambushed by tanks from A Squadron, 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry, A Squadron, the Sherbrooke Fuisilier Regiment, and B Squadron, the 144 [[Royal Armoured Corps]].<ref name= "Pg52-69"/><ref name= "Pg50">After the Battle Magazine, p. 50</ref><ref name= "D to VE Day">Tout, By Tank - D to VE Day</ref><ref name="Reid, p. 414">Reid, p. 414</ref><ref name= "Tout Fine Night">Tout, A Fine Night for Tanks</ref><ref group="Notes" name= "Letter">2</ref> |
|||
[[File:Grave of Michael Wittmann.jpg|thumb|upright=1.2|alt=Photograph of Wittmann's grave marker | Grave of Michael Wittmann in<br> [[La Cambe German war cemetery]], Normandy, France.]] |
|||
The killing shots have long been thought to have come from a Sherman Firefly of ‘3 Troop’, A Squadron, 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry (commander - Sergeant Gordon; gunner - Trooper Joe Ekins), which was positioned in a wood called Delle de la Roque on the advancing Tigers' right flank<ref>Hart, p. 65</ref> at approximately 12:47.<ref>Hart, p. 60</ref> |
|||
[[Nazi propaganda]] reported that Allied aircraft struck Wittmann's tank, stating that he had fallen in combat to the „dreaded [[fighter-bomber]]s”. In a post-war account, French civilian Serge Varin, who took the only known photograph of the destroyed tank, claimed that he found an unexploded rocket nearby and that he saw no other penetration holes in the tank. Historian [[Brian Reid (historian)|Brian Reid]] dismisses this contention as relevant RAF logs make no claim of engaging tanks in the area at that time.{{sfn|Reid|2005|pp=426–429}} This position is supported by the men of Wittmann's unit who stated they did not come under air attack, and by British and Canadian tank crews who also dismissed any involvement by aircraft.{{sfn|Reid|2005|pp=415, 421–423, 425–426}}<!---the page list may need to be trimmed--> |
|||
It appears the shells penetrated the upper hull of the tank and ignited the Tiger's own ammunition, causing a fire which engulfed the tank and then blew off the turret.<ref>Reid, p. 427</ref> |
|||
Prompted by the discovery of Wittmann's remains in 1983 interest in his death was back in the news. In a 1985 issue of ''After the Battle Magazine'', Les Taylor, a wartime member of the 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry, claimed that fellow yeoman [[Joe Ekins]] was responsible for the destruction of Wittmann's tank. Veteran and historian Ken Tout, a member of the same unit, published a similar account crediting Ekins.{{sfn|Reid|2005|pp=423–424}} This became the widely accepted version of events.{{sfn|Reid|2005|p=414}} According to Hart, Ekins's unit was positioned in a wood on the right flank of the advancing Tiger tanks. At approximately 12:47, they engaged them, halting the attack, and killing Wittmann. The turret numbers of the three Tigers were recorded after the battle in the unit War Diary: 312, 007 and 314. Wittman's tank was 007. Pictures of these tanks and their positions were confirmed in photographs taken by French locals and made available to the investigation. These were taken after the war before the tanks were removed for scrap. Brian Reid's account is based on the 1985 ATB investigation but with changes, 5 Tigers instead of 3, the position of Tiger 007 and the position of the Sherbrook Fusiliers. There is no documentation to support any of Reid's claims.{{sfn|Hart|2007|pp=60, 65}} |
|||
===Discredited claims=== |
|||
Reid postulated the possibility that A Squadron of the [[Sherbrooke Fusilier Regiment]], [[2nd Canadian Armoured Brigade]], positioned on the left flank of the advancing German tanks, was responsible instead. Commanded by [[Sydney Valpy Radley-Walters]], the squadron's six 75 mm Shermans and two 17-pounder [[Sherman Fireflies]] were situated on the grounds of a [[chateau]] at Gaumesnil.<ref>{{Cite web |url=https://legionmagazine.com/en/2017/08/42743/ |title=Heroes and Villains : Radley-Walters & Wittmann |last=Zuehlke |first=Mark |website=legionmagazine.com |date=8 August 2017 |access-date=3 September 2019}}</ref> The unit had created firing holes in the property's walls and, based on verbal testimony, engaged the advancing German tanks, including Tigers. The British tanks were between {{convert|1000|m|yd}} and {{convert|1200|m|yd}} away from the German line of advance, whereas the Canadian squadron was less than 150 m (500 feet) away behind a stone wall. Reid argues that due to the Canadians' proximity to the Germans, and the firing angle which precisely coincides with the tank round's entry hole in the Tiger, their troops more than likely destroyed Wittmann's tank. Reid supports this with H. Holfinger's account of the engagement. Holfinger was in a Tiger approximately {{convert|250|m|yd}} behind Wittmann and he said Wittmann's Tiger was destroyed at 12:55. Ekins's crew was credited with the destruction of 3 Tigers at 12:40, 12:47 and 12:52, Wittmann's tank being allegedly the one destroyed at 12:47. Considering Holfinger's account, Reid concludes that the Tiger destroyed at 12:47 could not be that of Wittmann; he also notes that the circumstances surrounding the fate of the Tiger destroyed at 12:52 exclude the possibility that it could have been Wittmann's. Reid's account of the battle has also come under scrutiny as being speculation, offering no actual proof of the events. He does accept that the documented claims of the 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry are correct. Though there are discrepancies with the 1985 investigation with regard to other other details such as the position of Wittmanns tank.{{sfn|Reid|2005|pp=410–430}} |
|||
For such a junior officer, there has been quite a lot of speculation surrounding how he died. At the time of his death, although the majority of Allied soldiers had never heard of him,<ref>Reid, pp. 411-412</ref> Wittmann had become a household name within Germany.<ref name="Forty134"/> |
|||
===Assessment as a tank commander=== |
|||
In 1985, issue 48 of ''After the Battle Magazine'' was published, containing an article on the last battle of Michael Wittmann. In this issue, Les Taylor, another member of the 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry during the war, stated that Joe Ekins was the man who was responsible for the death of Wittmann.<ref name="Pg50"/> |
|||
Some historians and authors of the late twentieth-century found Wittmann's actions at Villers-Bocage impressive, describing his attack as "one of the most amazing engagements in the history of armoured warfare" ([[Max Hastings|Hastings]]), "one of the most devastating single-handed actions of the war" ([[Carlo D'Este|D'Este]]), and "one of the most devastating ambushes in British military history" ([[Antony Beevor|Beevor]]).{{sfn|Hastings|1999|p=157}}{{sfn|D'Este|2004|p=719}}{{sfn|Beevor|2009|p=190}} Historian Stephen Badsey has stated that the ambush Wittmann launched has cast a shadow over the period between D-Day and 13 June in historical accounts.{{sfn|Buckley|2007|p=48}} |
|||
The [[1st Polish Armoured Division]], the [[4th Canadian Armoured Division]], the [[144 Regiment RAC|144 Regiment]] [[Royal Armoured Corps]] and the [[Royal Air Force|RAF]] [[RAF Second Tactical Air Force|Second Tactical Air Force]] have also been the subject of claims to have killed Wittmann. ''No Holding Back'', a book by Brian Reid on Operation Totalize, contains an entire appendix devoted to the death of Michael Wittmann, in which these claims are completely discredited. |
|||
With an unverified record of 130 tanks destroyed,<ref>{{Cite book |first=John |last=Phrados |title=Normandy Crucible: The Decisive Battle that Shaped World War II |date=2021 |page=211 |publisher=[[Amberley Publishing]] |isbn=978-1-4456-7883-2}}</ref> Wittmann has been credited as being the top tank ace of the war.<ref>{{Cite journal |last=David |first=Perlmutter |date=17 May 2010 |title=Face-lifting the death's head: The calculated pictorial legacy of the Waffen-SS and its modern audience |journal=Visual Anthropology |volume=4 |issue=2}}</ref> Others have noted Wittmann may have been Germany's top tank ace,{{sfn|Storr|2011|p=159}} although [[Kurt Knispel]] might have surpassed his tally. |
|||
Examination of the armoured divisions' war diaries revealed that they were too far north of St. Aignan de Cramesnil to have taken any part in the defeat of the German armoured counterattack. Investigation also ruled out the 144 Royal Armoured Corps; although they did take part in defeating the counterattack, they were positioned around Cramesnil and therefore out of effective range of Wittmann’s tank. The regiment did originally claim that they destroyed two Tigers during this German counterattack. However, their commanding officer changed this claim to one Tiger and one Panzer IV destroyed, post-battle.<ref>Reid, pp. 418-20</ref> |
|||
Jim Storr, writing in ''The Human Face of War'', notes that Wittman's attack on the British regiment at Bocage went beyond just a bad day of tanks losses for the British. He claims that the shock of losses to the British regiment had operational and strategic effect for the operation.{{sfn|Storr|2011|p=163}} Trigg says that in twenty or so minutes, Wittmann and his Tiger basically ended [[Operation Perch]].{{sfn|Trigg|2019|p=178}} |
|||
The main source of controversy surrounding Wittmann's demise comes from the claim that he was killed when an [[RP-3]] rocket from a [[Royal Air Force]] [[Hawker Typhoon]] struck his tank. |
|||
With his action in particular at Villers Bocage, A.D. Harvey, writing in ''Military History'', compared him to Sergeant [[Alvin York]], the famed American soldier of the [[First World War]]; both single-handedly destroyed large amounts of the enemy. Harvey noted that with a total of 138 tanks and 132 armoured vehicles destroyed, this tally made him the most successful tank commander in military history.<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Harvey |first=A. D. |date=2002 |title=Soldiers with a Special Flair |journal=The RUSI Journal |volume=147 |issue=1 |pages=61 |doi=10.1080/03071840208446742 |via=Taylor and Francis online}}</ref> |
|||
This myth, originating in German propaganda, stated Wittmann had fallen in combat to the ''dreaded [[fighter-bomber]]s''. This was further enhanced when a French civilian, Serge Varin, who took the only known photo of the destroyed Tiger, stated that in his opinion the tank had been destroyed by an air attack. He said he had found an unexploded rocket nearby and could not see any other penetration holes, other than the one on the upper hull. However, some accounts describe this as an exit hole and state the engine was intact and not damaged from any explosion. |
|||
German tank commander and historian {{interlanguage link|Wolfgang Schneider|de|Wolfgang Schneider (Militärhistoriker)}} is not as impressed. In analyzing Wittmann's actions at Villers-Bocage, he called into question his tactical ability. Schneider states: "a competent tank company commander does not accumulate so many serious mistakes".{{sfn|Marie|2003|p=159}} He highlights how Wittmann gathered his forces in a sunken lane with a broken-down tank at the head of the column, thereby hampering his unit's mobility. The solitary advance into Villers-Bocage was heavily criticized as it breached "all the rules". No intelligence was obtained, and there was no "centre of gravity" or "concentration of forces" in the attack. Schneider argues that due to Wittmann's rash actions: "the bulk of the 2nd Company and Mobius 1st Company came up against an enemy who had gone onto the defensive".{{sfn|Marie|2003|p=159}} He calls Wittmann's "carefree" advance into British-occupied positions "pure folly", and says "such over hastiness was uncalled for." He concludes that had a properly prepared assault been launched involving the rest of his company, and the 1st Company, far greater results could have been achieved. Finally, Schneider opines that: "thoughtlessness of this kind was to cost [Wittmann] his life ... during an attack casually launched in open country with an exposed flank."{{sfn|Marie|2003|p=159}} |
|||
Brian Reid has also discredited this explanation after examining the logs of the RAF Second Tactical Air Force. Reid notes that they made no claim of engaging or destroying any tanks in the area during the battle.<ref>Reid, pp. 426-429<br/>PRO, Air 25/709, 84 Group RAF Operations Record Book August 1944, pg 8 Serial 18, 8 August 1944<br/>PRO, Air 25/698, 83 Group RAF Operations Record Book August 1944<br/>PRO, 2 TAF Operations Record Book, Sheet 28, 8 August 44<br/>PRO, 83 group Operations Record Book, August 8, 1944</ref> He concludes: |
|||
<blockquote> |
|||
"...no tanks were claimed destroyed or damaged in the forward areas by immediate support aircraft"<ref name= "Pg429">Reid, p. 429</ref> |
|||
</blockquote> |
|||
<blockquote> |
|||
"...the only tanks claimed were by Typhoons on armed reconnaissance missions in areas away from the actual battle. Therefore Wittmann and his crew almost assuredly did not fall victim to an attack from the air."<ref name= "Pg429"/> |
|||
</blockquote> |
|||
Reid also notes that Kurt Meyer, the divisional commander of the [[12th SS Panzer Division Hitlerjugend]] who had ordered the Schwere SS-Panzer-Abteilung 101 to counterattack, |
|||
<blockquote> |
|||
"…made a point of remarking on the Allies' failure to use their tactical fighters on the morning of August 8."<ref>Reid, p. 426</ref> |
|||
</blockquote> |
|||
Historian [[Sönke Neitzel]] describes Wittmann as the "supposedly successful" <!---''angeblich erfolgreichsten''--> tank commander of World War II and attests to "hero worshipping" around Wittmann. According to Neitzel, numbers of successes, by highly decorated tank commanders, should be read with caution as it is rarely possible to determine reliably, in the heat of battle, how many tanks were destroyed by whom.{{sfn|Neitzel|2002|p=413}} |
|||
There is also no evidence to support any other aircraft outside of the Second Tactical Airforce attacked the tank. |
|||
Historian [[Steven Zaloga]] credits Wittmann with around 135 tank kills and points out that he achieved 120 of these in 1943, operating a Tiger I tank on the Eastern Front. Having advantages both in firepower and in armor, the Tiger I was "nearly invulnerable in a frontal engagement" against any of the Soviet tanks of that time, and Wittmann thus could destroy opposing tanks from a safe distance.{{sfn|Zaloga|2015|pp=3–4}} Zaloga concludes that "Most of the 'tank aces' of World War II were simply lucky enough to have an invulnerable tank with a powerful gun." German documents from 1944 state that Allied technology had caught up with the Tiger I and "no longer can it prance around, oblivious to the laws of tank tactics". Zaloga believes that Wittmann's fate reflected that new reality: after his transfer to France, his crew only lasted two months, and was destroyed either by a British [[medium tank]], the up-gunned Sherman Firefly, or a standard 75mm-equipped Sherman.{{sfn|Zaloga|2015|pp=3–4, 221}} The 75mm's armour piercing round was more than enough to have penetrated his Tiger's thin rear upper deck armour from less than 150 m (500 feet) and all of the Sherbrooke-Fusilier's records were lost shortly after the battle when an American aircraft negligently bombed the vehicle that contained these documents. There is therefore there is no documented record for the claims of the Sherbrooke Fusiliers and so must be treated with caution. |
|||
The final piece of evidence, which rules out air attack upon the attacking German tanks, comes from eyewitness testimony. German tank crews and other members of the Schwere SS-Panzer-Abteilung 101, such as Alfred Bahlo, Hans Dollinger, Hans Höflinger and Doctor Rabe, along with Allied tankers such as [[Tom Boardman, Baron Boardman|Captain Boardman]], Trooper Ekins and Major [[S.V. Radley-Walters|Radley-Walters]] have all stated in interviews (as well as other media such as letters) that the Tiger tanks came under tank attack only and do not mention any air attacks.<ref name= "Pg50"/><ref name= "D to VE Day"/><ref name= "Tout Fine Night"/><ref group="Notes" name= "Letter"/><ref>Reid, pp. 415, 421–423 & 425</ref> |
|||
Writing in 2013, British historian [[John Buckley (historian)|John Buckley]] criticised the accounts which many historians continue to provide of the fighting around Villers-Bocage. Buckley argued that by wrongly attributing the entire German success to Wittmann, "many historians through to today continue to repackage unquestioningly Nazi propaganda".{{sfn|Buckley|2013|p=70}} The British lost 22 Cromwell and Stuart tanks at the battle of Villers Bocage. But a British counter attack later in the day ended with the destruction of five Tiger I tanks and up to eight Panzer IV tanks. |
|||
===The most recent claim=== |
|||
==Awards== |
|||
After discrediting the main claimants other than Joe Ekins, Brian Reid then discusses another possibility, as there was another armoured regiment much closer to Wittmann’s tank. ''A Squadron'' of The [[Sherbrooke Fusiliers Regiment]], [[2nd Canadian Armoured Brigade]], commanded by Major [[Sydney Radley-Walters]], was positioned in the chateau grounds at Gaumesnil. This area, south of Hill 112, is parallel with the Delle de la Roque woods and the location of Joe Ekin’s Firefly. The regiment at this time was made up of several [[Lend-Lease Sherman tanks#British nomenclature|Sherman III]] and 2 [[Lend-Lease Sherman tanks#British nomenclature|Sherman VC]], whose tankers had created firing holes in the property's wall. From this position, based on verbal testimony of the Canadian tankers, they engaged several tanks (including Tigers) and self-propelled guns driving up the main road and across the open ground towards Hill 112.<ref name= "Pg410-430">Reid, pp. 410-430</ref> |
|||
* [[Iron Cross]] (1939) 2nd Class (12 July 1941) & 1st Class (8 September 1941){{sfn|Agte|2000|p=206}} |
|||
* [[Panzer Badge]] in Silver |
|||
* [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords]] |
|||
** Knight's Cross on 14 January 1944{{sfn|Scherzer|2007|p=793}} |
|||
** Oak Leaves on 30 January 1944{{sfn|Fellgiebel|2000|p=77}} |
|||
** Swords on 22 June 1944{{sfn|Scherzer|2007|p=793}} |
|||
[[File:Bundesarchiv Bild 101I-299-1802-08, Nordfrankreich, Michael Wittmann auf Panzer VI (Tiger I).jpg|thumb|upright=0.85|alt=A man, wearing dress uniform and a cap, sits on top of a tank barrel|Michael Wittmann sitting on top of a Tiger I, Northern France, May 1944]] |
|||
Reid puts forth the opinion that, with the range Joe Ekins would have to fire over to hit Wittmann’s tank,<ref name="Pg416"/> the proximity of the Sherbrooke Fusiliers Regiment to the tank, no other evidence to suggest anything other than tank-to-tank combat, that the latter are most likely responsible for Wittmann's death.<ref name= "Pg410-430"/> Because of changes in land use from orchards to ploughed fields since 1944, it is problematic to establish the exact location of Ekin's Firefly at the beginning of the engagement and even more difficult to know the position of the claimed kill shot as Ekins' tank moved during the engagement. At a minimum, the 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry was positioned over {{convert|1000|m|yd}} away, possibly as much as {{convert|1200|m|yd}}, while the Canadian tanks were only around {{convert|500|m|yd}} away.<ref name= "Pg429"/> Recent field studies that located the exact position of the Sherbrooke tanks puts the range at less than {{convert|150|yd|m}} and the firing angle from their position behind the Chateau's now removed east wall coincides exactly with the damage area to Wittman's Tiger in the left rear engine compartment. There are no official Canadian records to back up this position due to the Regimental Headquarters halftrack being destroyed by a stray USAAF bomb.<ref name="Reid, p. 414"/> |
|||
==In popular culture== |
|||
Ken Tout, who at the time of Operation Totalize, was a member of C Squadron of the 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry, published a postwar account of the battle and of Wittmann’s demise. Tout credited Joe Ekins at that time. However, when researching his new book on the subject, he interviewed former members of A Squadron, Sherbrooke Fusiliers. In this book, for the first time, he does not claim Wittmann for the 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry and acknowledges that other regiments were in the area at the time and had engaged the attacking Tigers.<ref name= "Tout Fine Night"/><ref>Reid, p. 423</ref> |
|||
{{Main|Waffen-SS in popular culture}} |
|||
Wittmann is often featured in books on the battles in Normandy. Several websites are dedicated to him, along with books by authors such as [[Patrick Agte]] and [[Franz Kurowski]].{{sfn|Reid|2005|pp=410–412}}{{sfn|Smelser|Davies|2008|pp=173–178}} The former is an author and publisher affiliated with the pro-Waffen-SS revisionist history group [[HIAG]],{{sfn|Antifa-Infoblatt|2001}} while the latter is a prolific author who lauded decorated Waffen-SS men.{{sfn|Smelser|Davies|2008|pp=173–178}} |
|||
With the Tigers caught in a crossfire between the Northamptonshire Yeomanry and the Sherbrooke Fusiliers Regiment, it is understandable that both regiments claimed to have destroyed his tank. The significant hole in the belief that Ekins was Wittman's killer is that, if Wittman's Tiger was one of three Tigers engaged and destroyed by Ekins that afternoon - a truly remarkable feat of tank gunnery, who then is responsible for one of the three Tigers nearest to where Ekins fired from. He killed three Tigers and if one was Wittman's, someone else had to engage and kill one of these three destroyed Tigers within {{convert|800|yd|m}} of Ekins position. There is no record or claim by any other Allied tank for any of these three Tigers. |
|||
===Cult status=== |
|||
In the appendix of “No Holding Back”, devoted to Wittmann’s demise, there is a topographical map<ref name= "Pg416">Reid, p. 416</ref> of the engagement, diagrams of the tank<ref>Reid, p. 413</ref> and the location of the shell strike.<ref>Reid, pp. 427-428</ref> |
|||
Wittmann became a cult figure after the war thanks to his accomplishments as a "[[panzer ace]]" (a highly decorated tank commander) in the portrayal of the [[Waffen-SS in popular culture]]. Historian Stephen Hart said that "the Wittmann legend [has] become well-established" and "continues to stimulate huge public interest".{{sfn|Hart|2007|p=needed}} Military historian [[Steven Zaloga]] refers to Wittmann as "the hero of all Nazi fanboys". He discusses the popular perception of a tank-versus-tank engagement as an "armoured joust"—two opponents facing each other—with the "more valiant or better-armed the eventual victor". Zaloga contends that the perception is nothing but "romantic nonsense". According to him, most successful tank commanders were "bushwhackers", having a battlefield advantage rather than a technical one: a tank crew that could engage its opponent before the latter spotted it often came out on top.{{sfn|Zaloga|2015|pp=3–4}} |
|||
Wittmann is featured by Kurowski in his 1992 book ''[[Panzer Aces]]'', an ahistorical and hagiographic account of the combat careers of highly decorated Nazi tank commanders.{{sfn|Smelser|Davies|2008|pp=175–176, 251}} Smelser and Davies describe Kurowski's version of the war on the Eastern Front as "well-nigh chivalrous", with German troops "showing concerns for the Russian wounded, despite the many atrocities" of the Soviets against the Germans.{{sfn|Smelser|Davies|2008|pp=173–178}} In one of Kurowski's accounts, Wittmann takes out eighteen tanks in a single engagement, for which [[Sepp Dietrich]], the commanding officer, presents him with an [[Iron Cross]] and inquires whether Wittmann has a request. Without hesitation, Wittmann asks for assistance for a wounded Russian soldier he has spotted. Many similar acts of "humanity" are present in the book, amounting to a distorted image of the German fighting men.{{sfn|Smelser|Davies|2008|pp=173–178, 251}} |
|||
In fact, in late 2008 and again on March 9, 2009, the History Television channel in Canada broadcast an hour long investigation into the various claims of who fired the killing shot in the Wittmann affair. "Battlefield Mysteries," hosted by historian Norm Christie, examined the evidence in great detail and conclusively proved that it had to be a tank belonging to the Sherbrooke Fusiliers of the 2nd Canadian Armoured Brigade. Using all of the evidence currently available, and working from the very field that Wittmann was killed in, Christie used global positioning hardware to measure the distances to almost the exact meter and found that the Northamptonshire Yeomanry's tanks were almost a full kilometer (970 meters) from Wittmann's Tiger tank, but had nevertheless killed three closer Tigers involved in the counterattack, corroborating Tout's and Ekins' account. However, Wittmann's tank, furthest from the Northamptonshire Yeomanry, was found to have been only 143 meters (a mere 469 feet) from the position of the Canadian Sherbrooke Fusiliers' Sherman Fireflies and that the Tiger had received the mortal wound in its left rear quadrant, its lightly armoured Achilles heel. It is impossible for the Northamptonshire Yeomanry to have fired a shot from the opposite direction and hit his tank from the side the Canadians were on. Indeed, they were a kilometer away and 180 degrees out of position, while the Canadian tanks were by far the closest to Wittmann's Tiger--dead meat for their Firefly's 17 pounder gun at such close range. Moreover, it was likely a regular Sherman's 75 mm 6 pounder gun since three out of four Shermans were ''not'' Fireflies, and also considering the closeness of Wittmann's Tiger and the thin armour in the position it was penetrated. Bearing in mind the fact that German eyewitnesses testified that Wittmann's gun was turned somewhat to the right before the turret blew off, and that the death blow arrived from his left, Wittmann and his crew likely never knew what killed them. They had simply committed unwitting suicide by entering a gauntlet they didn't even know existed. |
|||
Christie included an interview with Sherbrooke Fusiliers' commanding officer, retired-General Sidney Radley-Walters, who saw Wittmann's tank violently explode and hurl its turret into the air, all the while burning fiercely from a shot made by one of his squadron's Shermans. He was not sure which of his tanks fired the shot, as it was the middle of a fierce German counterattack and there were other enemy armoured vehicles coming down the main roadway, immediately in front of his position and leading to the German position a mile or so further south (up the roadway to his right), but there is no other even vaguely reasonable conclusion to be reached. |
|||
Ironically, no one knew it was Wittmann they had killed until many years after the event. |
|||
===Burial=== |
|||
[[File:LaCambe2.JPG|thumb|right|150px|Grave of Michael Wittmann with the crew of Tiger 007, La Cambe Cemetery, France.]] |
|||
The German war graves commission, either with help of veterans from the [[101st SS Heavy Panzer Detachment|s.SS-Pz Abt. 101]] or from the author of ''Panzers in Normandy – Then and Now'', located Wittmann and his crew's unmarked grave in 1983. They were then reinterred together at the German war cemetery of [[La Cambe German war cemetery|La Cambe]] in France.<ref name=Lefevre>{{cite book| first=Eric|last=Lefevre|authorlink=| coauthors=R. Cooke (translator)| series=| title=Panzers in Normandy: Then and Now|publisher=After the Battle| date=| origdate=1983| isbn=0-90091-329-0}}</ref> |
|||
==Personal life== |
|||
On March 1, 1944, Wittmann married Hildegard Burmester in [[Lüneburg]]. |
|||
==Summary of SS career== |
|||
===Dates of rank=== |
|||
* SS-[[Mann (military rank)|Mann]]: April 1, 1937 |
|||
* SS-[[Sturmmann]]: November 11, 1937 |
|||
* SS-[[Unterscharführer]]: April 20, 1939 |
|||
* SS-[[Oberscharführer]]: November 9, 1941 |
|||
* SS-[[Untersturmführer]]: December 21, 1942 |
|||
* SS-[[Obersturmführer]]: January 30, 1944 |
|||
* SS-[[Hauptsturmführer]]: June 21, 1944 |
|||
===Notable decorations=== |
|||
* [[Iron Cross]] (1939) |
|||
** 2nd Class (12 July 1941)<ref name="Agte p206">Agte 2000, p. 206.</ref> |
|||
** 1st Class (8 September 1941)<ref name="Agte p206"/> |
|||
* [[Totenkopfring|SS-Honour Ring]] |
|||
* [[Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross|Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords]] |
|||
** Knight's Cross on 14 January 1944 as SS-''[[Untersturmführer]]'' and section leader in the 13.(schwere)/SS-Panzer-Regiment 1<ref name="Scherzer p793">Scherzer 2007, p. 793.</ref> |
|||
** 380th Oak Leaves on 30 January 1944 as SS-''Untersturmführer'' and section leader in the 13.(schwere)/SS-Panzer-Regiment 1<ref name="Scherzer p793"/> |
|||
** 71st Swords on 22 June 1944 as SS-''[[Obersturmführer]]'' and chief of the 2./schwere SS-Panzer-Abteilung 101<ref name="Scherzer p793"/> |
|||
* [[Wound Badge]] in Black (20 August 1941)<ref name="Agte p206"/> |
|||
* [[Panzer Badge]] in Silver (21 November 1941)<ref name="Agte p206"/> |
|||
* [[Eastern Front Medal]] (1942) |
|||
* [[Sudetenland Medal]] (1938) |
|||
* [[Anschluss Medal]] (1938) |
|||
* [[Orders, decorations, and medals of Bulgaria#Orders|Soldier's Cross Of The Order Of Bravery 2nd Class]] (Tsardom Of Bulgaria) (1941) |
|||
* Mentioned in the [[Wehrmachtbericht]] on January 13, 1944 |
|||
* [[SS Long Service Award]] |
|||
===Reference in the ''Wehrmachtbericht''=== |
|||
{|class="wikitable" |
|||
! Date |
|||
! Original German ''Wehrmachtbericht'' wording |
|||
! Direct English translation |
|||
|- |
|||
| 13 January 1944 || ''SS-Untersturmführer Wittmann in einer SS-Panzerdivision schoß am 9. Januar an der Ostfront mit seinem "Tiger"-Panzer seinen 66. feindlichen Panzer ab.''<ref>''Die Wehrmachtberichte 1939-1945 Band 3'', p. 10.</ref> || SS-''Untersturmführer'' Wittmann in a SS-''Panzerdivision'' on January 9 destroyed his 66th enemy tank with his "Tiger"-tank on the eastern front. |
|||
|} |
|||
==See also== |
|||
[[Balthasar Woll|Bobby Woll]] - Wittmann's gunner for a long period of time. |
|||
==Notes== |
==Notes== |
||
{{notelist}} |
|||
{{Portal box|Biography|World War II}} |
|||
{{reflist|group=note}} |
|||
;Footnotes |
|||
{{Reflist|group="Notes"}} |
|||
;Citations |
|||
{{Reflist|3}} |
|||
'''Citations''' |
|||
==References== |
|||
{{Reflist|20em}} |
|||
==References== |
|||
{{Refbegin}} |
{{Refbegin}} |
||
* {{Cite book |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Patrick |last=Agte |title=Michael Wittmann erfolgreichster Panzerkommandant im Zweiten Weltkrieg und die Tiger der Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler |publisher=Deutsche Verlagsgesellschaft Preußisch Oldendorf |year=2000 |language=German |isbn=ISBN 3-920722-18-3}} |
|||
|first=Patrick |
|||
*{{cite book| first=|last=After the Battle Magazine|authorlink=| coauthors=| series=After the Battle Magazine| title=Issue 48: Germany Surrenders|publisher=After the Battle| date=| origdate=1985| isbn=}} |
|||
|last=Agte |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Stephen A|last=Hart|authorlink=| coauthors=| series=| title=Sherman Firefly vs Tiger: Normandy 1944|publisher=Osprey Publishing| year=2007| origdate=| isbn=1-84603-150-8}} |
|||
|title=Michael Wittmann erfolgreichster Panzerkommandant im Zweiten Weltkrieg und die Tiger der Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler |
|||
*{{cite book| first=George|last=Forty|authorlink=| coauthors=| series=Battle Zone Normandy| title=Villers Bocage|publisher=Sutton Publishing| year=2004| origdate= | isbn=0-75093-012-8}} |
|||
|publisher=Deutsche Verlagsgesellschaft Preußisch Oldendorf |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Franz|last=Kurowski|authorlink=| coauthors=| series=| title=''Panzer Aces: German Tank Commanders of WWII|publisher=Stackpole Books| year=2004| origdate=| isbn=0-81173-173-1}} |
|||
|year=2000 |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Eric|last=Lefevre|authorlink=| coauthors=R. Cooke (translator)| series=| title=Panzers in Normandy: Then and Now|publisher=After the Battle| date=| origdate=1983| isbn=0-90091-329-0}} |
|||
|language=de |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Brian|last=Reid|authorlink=| coauthors=| series=| title=No Holding Back: Operation Totalize, Normandy, August 1944|publisher=| date=| origdate=2005| isbn=1-89694-140-0}} |
|||
|isbn=3-92072-218-3 |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Henri|last=Marie|authorlink=| coauthors=| series=| title=Villers Bocage, Normandy 1944|publisher=Heimdal| year=2003| origdate=| isbn=2-84048-173-1}} |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{cite book| first=Veit|last=Scherzer|authorlink=| coauthors=| series=| title=Die Ritterkreuzträger 1939–1945 Die Inhaber des Ritterkreuzes des Eisernen Kreuzes 1939 von Heer, Luftwaffe, Kriegsmarine, Waffen-SS, Volkssturm sowie mit Deutschland verbündeter Streitkräfte nach den Unterlagen des Bundesarchives|year=2007|language=German |location=Jena, Germany |publisher=Scherzers Miltaer-Verlag| isbn=978-3-938845-17-2}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Daniel|last=Taylor|authorlink=| coauthors=| series=| title=Villers-Bocage Through the Lens|publisher=After the Battle| year=1999| origdate=| isbn=1-87006-707-X}} |
|||
|last=Agte |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Ken|last=Tout|authorlink=| coauthors=| series=| title=A Fine Night for Tanks: The Road to Falaise|publisher=Sutton Publishing Ltd| year=2002| origdate=1998| isbn=0-75093-189-2}} |
|||
|first=Patrick |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Ken|last=Tout|authorlink=| coauthors=| series=| title=By Tank - D to VE Days|publisher=Robert Hale Ltd| year=2007| origdate=| isbn=0-70908-148-0}} |
|||
|publisher=[[Stackpole Books]] |
|||
* {{cite book| title=Die Wehrmachtberichte 1939–1945 Band 3, 1. Januar 1944 bis 9. Mai 1945| language=German |location=München |publisher=Deutscher Taschenbuch Verlag GmbH & Co. KG|year=1985| isbn=3-423-05944-3}} |
|||
|title=Michael Wittmann and the Waffen SS Tiger Commanders of the Leibstandarte in World War II, Volume 1 |
|||
* {{cite book| title=Helden der Wehrmacht - Unsterbliche deutsche Soldaten| language=German| location=München, Germany| publisher=FZ-Verlag GmbH| year=2004| isbn=3-924309-53-1}} |
|||
|year=2006 |
|||
|location=Mechanicsburg, PA |
|||
|isbn=978-0-8117-3334-2 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{cite book | last = Gilbert | first = Adrian | title = Waffen-SS: Hitler's Army at War | publisher = Da Capo Press | year = 2019 | isbn = 978-0-306-82466-1}} |
|||
* {{cite web |
|||
| website=Antifa-Infoblatt |
|||
| url = https://www.antifainfoblatt.de/artikel/%C2%BBder-freiwillige%C2%AB-next-generation |
|||
| title = ''Der Freiwillige'': The next generation |
|||
| date = 2001 |
|||
| access-date = 8 December 2015 |
|||
| language = de |
|||
| ref = {{harvid|Antifa-Infoblatt|2001}} |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Antony |
|||
|last=Beevor |
|||
|author-link=Antony Beevor |
|||
|title=D-Day: The Battle for Normandy |
|||
|publisher=[[Viking Press]] |
|||
|location=London |
|||
|year=2009 |
|||
|isbn=978-0-670-88703-3 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=John |
|||
|last=Buckley |
|||
|title=British Armour in the Normandy Campaign 1944 |
|||
|publisher=[[Taylor & Francis]] |
|||
|location=London |
|||
|year=2006 |
|||
|orig-year=2004 |
|||
|isbn=0-415-40773-7 |
|||
|oclc=154699922 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|last=Buckley |
|||
|first=John |
|||
|title=The Normandy Campaign 1944: Sixty Years on |
|||
|publisher=[[Routledge]] |
|||
|location=London |
|||
|year=2007 |
|||
|orig-year=2006 |
|||
|isbn=978-0-415-44942-7 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{cite book|last1=Buckley|first1=John|title=Monty's Men : The British Army and the Liberation of Europe|year=2013|publisher=[[Yale University Press]]|location=New Haven|isbn=978-0300134490}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Carlo |
|||
|last=D'Este |
|||
|author-link=Carlo D'Este |
|||
|title=Decision in Normandy: The Real Story of Montgomery and the Allied Campaign |
|||
|location=London |
|||
|publisher=[[Penguin Books]] |
|||
|year=2004 |
|||
|orig-year=1983 |
|||
|isbn=0-14-101761-9 |
|||
|oclc=44772546 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|last=Fellgiebel |
|||
|first=Walther-Peer |
|||
|year=2000 |
|||
|orig-year=1986 |
|||
|title=Die Träger des Ritterkreuzes des Eisernen Kreuzes 1939–1945 |
|||
|trans-title= The Bearers of the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross 1939–1945 |
|||
|language=de |
|||
|location=Friedberg, Germany |
|||
|publisher=Podzun-Pallas |
|||
|isbn=978-3-7909-0284-6 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Stephen A |
|||
|last=Hart |
|||
|title=Sherman Firefly vs Tiger: Normandy 1944 |
|||
|publisher=[[Osprey Publishing]] |
|||
|series=Duel |
|||
|year=2007 |
|||
|isbn=978-1-84603-150-2 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=George |
|||
|last=Forty |
|||
|series=Battle Zone Normandy |
|||
|title=Villers Bocage |
|||
|publisher=[[Sutton Publishing]] |
|||
|year=2004 |
|||
|isbn=0-7509-3012-8 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Max |
|||
|last=Hastings |
|||
|title=Overlord: D-Day and the Battle for Normandy 1944 |
|||
|series=Pan Grand Strategy Series |
|||
|publisher=[[Pan Books]] |
|||
|location=London |
|||
|year=1999 |
|||
|orig-year=1984 |
|||
|isbn=0-330-39012-0 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Henri |
|||
|last=Marie |
|||
|title=Villers Bocage, Normandy 1944 |
|||
|publisher=Heimdal |
|||
|year=2003 |
|||
|isbn=2-84048-173-1 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Robin |
|||
|last=Neillands |
|||
|author-link=Robin Neillands |
|||
|title=The Desert Rats: 7th Armoured Division, 1940–1945 |
|||
|publisher=[[Aurum Press]] |
|||
|location=London |
|||
|orig-year=1995 |
|||
|year=2005 |
|||
|isbn=978-1-84513-115-9 |
|||
}} |
|||
*{{Cite journal |
|||
|last=Neitzel |
|||
|first=Sönke |
|||
|author-link=Sönke Neitzel |
|||
|journal=[[Militärgeschichtliche Zeitschrift]] |
|||
|volume= 61 |
|||
|year=2002 |
|||
|title=Des Forschens noch wert? Anmerkungen zur Operationsgeschichte der Waffen-SS |
|||
|pages=403–429 |
|||
|doi=10.1524/mgzs.2002.61.2.403 |
|||
|s2cid=185691597 |
|||
|doi-access=free |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Brian |
|||
|last=Reid |
|||
|title=No Holding Back: Operation Totalize, Normandy, August 1944 |
|||
|year=2005 |
|||
|publisher=Robin Brass Studio |
|||
|isbn=1-896941-40-0 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|last1=Smelser |
|||
|first1=Ronald |
|||
|last2=Davies |
|||
|first2=Edward J. |
|||
|author-link1=Ronald Smelser |
|||
|author-link2=Edward J. Davies |
|||
|year=2008 |
|||
|title=[[The Myth of the Eastern Front: The Nazi-Soviet War in American Popular Culture]] |
|||
|location= New York |
|||
|publisher=[[Cambridge University Press]] |
|||
|isbn=978-0-521-83365-3 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|last=Ripley |
|||
|first=Tim |
|||
|title=The Waffen-SS At War: Hitler's Praetorians 1925–1945 |
|||
|year=2004 |
|||
|publisher=[[Zenith Imprint]] |
|||
|isbn=0-7603-2068-3 |
|||
|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=0TrWrxxDkf8C&q=%22T-34%22+ram |
|||
|access-date=18 February 2011 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Michael |
|||
|last=Reynolds |
|||
|title=Steel Inferno: I SS Panzer Corps in Normandy |
|||
|publisher=[[Da Capo Press]] |
|||
|year=2001 |
|||
|orig-year=1997 |
|||
|isbn=1-885119-44-5 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Michael |
|||
|last=Reynolds |
|||
|title=Sons of the Reich: The History of II SS Panzer Corps in Normandy, Arnhem, the Ardennes and on the Eastern Front |
|||
|location=Havertown |
|||
|publisher=[[Casemate Publishers]] and Book Distributors |
|||
|year=2002 |
|||
|isbn=0-9711709-3-2 |
|||
|oclc=50208471 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|last=Scherzer |
|||
|first=Veit |
|||
|year=2007 |
|||
|title=Die Ritterkreuzträger 1939–1945 |
|||
|trans-title=The Knight's Cross Bearers 1939–1945 |
|||
|language=de |
|||
|location=Jena, Germany |
|||
|publisher=Scherzers Militaer-Verlag |
|||
|isbn=978-3-938845-17-2 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|last=Stockert |
|||
|first=Peter |
|||
|year=1998 |
|||
|title=Die Eichenlaubträger 1939–1945 Band 4 |
|||
|trans-title=The Oak Leaves Bearers 1939–1945 Volume 4 |
|||
|language=de |
|||
|location=Bad Friedrichshall, Germany |
|||
|publisher=Friedrichshaller Rundblick |
|||
|isbn=978-3-932915-03-1 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{cite book |last1=Storr |first1=Jim |title=The Human Face of War |date=2011 |publisher=Bloomsbury Academic |isbn=978-1-4411-8750-5 }} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Daniel |
|||
|last=Taylor |
|||
|title=Villers-Bocage Through the Lens |
|||
|publisher=[[After the Battle]] |
|||
|year=1999 |
|||
|isbn=1-870067-07-X |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{cite book |last=Trigg |first=Jonathan |date=2019 |title= D-Day Through German Eyes: How the Wehrmacht Lost France |accessdate= |edition= |origyear= |publisher= Amberley Publishing |location= Stroud, Gloucestershire, UK |isbn= 978-1-4456-9944-8 |oclc= |page= |pages= }} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first=Russell F. |
|||
|last=Weigley |
|||
|title=Eisenhower's Lieutenants: The Campaigns of France and Germany, 1944–1945 |
|||
|publisher=[[Sidgwick & Jackson]] |
|||
|isbn=0-283-98801-0 |
|||
|location=London |
|||
|year=1981 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
|first1=C. |
|||
|last1=Wilmot |
|||
|author-link=Chester Wilmot |
|||
|first2=C. D. |
|||
|last2=McDevitt |
|||
|title=The Struggle For Europe |
|||
|publisher=[[HarperCollins|Collins]] |
|||
|location=London |
|||
|edition=Wordsworth, 1997 |
|||
|year=1952 |
|||
|isbn=1-85326-677-9 |
|||
|oclc=39697844 |
|||
}} |
|||
* {{cite book |
|||
| last = Zaloga |
|||
| first = Steven |
|||
| author-link = Steven Zaloga |
|||
| year = 2015 |
|||
| title = Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II |
|||
|location = Mechanicsburg, PA |
|||
| publisher = [[Stackpole Books]] |
|||
| isbn = 978-0-8117-1437-2 |
|||
}} |
|||
* [https://legionmagazine.com/en/2017/08/42743/ Zuehlke, Mark (2017) "Heroes and Villains: Radley-Walters & Wittmann", ''Legion Magazine'', August 8, 2017] |
|||
{{Refend}} |
{{Refend}} |
||
== |
==Further reading== |
||
* {{PND|119260573}} |
|||
{{Commons category|Michael Wittmann}} |
|||
*{{cite web|url=http://www.alanhamby.com/aces.shtml|title=Tiger I Information Centre: top scoring Tiger aces| last=Hamby| first=Alan}} |
|||
*{{cite web|url=http://www.panzerace.net/english/index.asp|title=Panzer ace website| last=Joshua| first=Rick D}} |
|||
*{{cite web|url=http://www.achtungpanzer.com/gen3.htm|title=Achtung Panzer: Michael Wittmann profile| last=Parada| first=George}} |
|||
*[http://www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GSln=wittmann&GSfn=michael&GSbyrel=in&GSdyrel=in&GScntry=7&GSob=n&GRid=11947& Michael Wittman's grave] |
|||
*[http://wittmannvekins.books.officelive.com/default.aspx Joe Ekin's View] |
|||
*{{cite book|last=After the Battle Magazine| series=[[After the Battle]] Magazine| title=Issue 48: Germany Surrenders|publisher=After the Battle| year=1985}} |
|||
{{KCwithOLandSW}} |
|||
* {{Cite book |
|||
{{KCwithOL}} |
|||
|first=Eric |
|||
|last=Lefevre |
|||
|others=R. Cooke (trans.) |
|||
|title=Panzers in Normandy: Then and Now |
|||
|publisher=[[After the Battle]] |
|||
|year=1983 |
|||
|isbn=0-900913-29-0 |
|||
}} |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Ken|last=Tout| title=A Fine Night for Tanks: The Road to Falaise|publisher=[[Sutton Publishing]] Ltd| year=2002| orig-year=1998| isbn=0-7509-3189-2}} |
|||
*{{cite book| first=Ken|last=Tout| title=By Tank – D to VE Days|publisher=[[Robert Hale Ltd]]| year=2007| isbn=978-0-7090-8148-7}} |
|||
{{Authority control}} |
|||
{{Persondata <!-- Metadata: see [[Wikipedia:Persondata]]. --> |
|||
{{Subject bar |
|||
| NAME = Wittmann, Michael |
|||
| portal1=Biography |
|||
| ALTERNATIVE NAMES = |
|||
| commons=y |
|||
| SHORT DESCRIPTION = |
|||
| DATE OF BIRTH = 22 April 1914 |
|||
| PLACE OF BIRTH = Vogelthal |
|||
| DATE OF DEATH = 8 August 1944 |
|||
| PLACE OF DEATH = Between the towns of [[Cintheaux]] and [[Saint-Aignan-de-Cramesnil|St. Aignan de Cramesnil]] near the farm of Gaumesnil |
|||
}} |
}} |
||
{{DEFAULTSORT:Wittmann, Michael}} |
{{DEFAULTSORT:Wittmann, Michael}} |
||
[[Category:Propaganda legends]] |
|||
[[Category:1914 births]] |
[[Category:1914 births]] |
||
[[Category:1944 deaths]] |
[[Category:1944 deaths]] |
||
[[Category:People from |
[[Category:People from Neumarkt (district)]] |
||
[[Category: |
[[Category:Military personnel from the Kingdom of Bavaria]] |
||
[[Category:SS-Hauptsturmführer]] |
|||
[[Category:Military personnel referenced in the Wehrmachtbericht]] |
|||
[[Category:SS officers]] |
|||
[[Category:Panzer commanders]] |
[[Category:Panzer commanders]] |
||
[[Category:Recipients of the Knight's Cross]] |
[[Category:Recipients of the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords]] |
||
[[Category:Waffen-SS personnel killed in action]] |
|||
[[Category:Burials at La Cambe German war cemetery]] |
|||
{{Link GA|et}} |
|||
[[Category:Military personnel from Bavaria]] |
|||
[[bg:Михаел Витман]] |
|||
[[ca:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[cs:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[da:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[de:Michael Wittmann (SS-Panzerkommandant)]] |
|||
[[et:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[el:Μίχαελ Βίττμαν]] |
|||
[[es:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[fr:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[ko:미하엘 비트만]] |
|||
[[io:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[it:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[he:מיכאל ויטמן]] |
|||
[[hu:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[nl:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[ja:ミハエル・ヴィットマン]] |
|||
[[no:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[pl:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[pt:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[ru:Виттман, Михаэль]] |
|||
[[sl:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[sr:Михаел Витман]] |
|||
[[fi:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[sv:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[tr:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[vi:Michael Wittmann]] |
|||
[[zh:米歇尔·魏特曼]] |
Latest revision as of 12:04, 5 January 2025
Michael Wittmann | |
---|---|
Born | Vogelthal, Bavaria, German Empire | 22 April 1914
Died | 8 August 1944 near Saint-Aignan-de-Cramesnil, Normandy, German-occupied France | (aged 30)
Buried | La Cambe German war cemetery (reinterred) |
Allegiance | Nazi Germany |
Service | Heer (1934–1936) Waffen SS (1936–1944) |
Years of service | 1934–1944 |
Rank | SS-Hauptsturmführer |
Unit | SS Division Leibstandarte 101st SS Heavy Panzer Battalion |
Battles / wars | |
Awards | Knight's Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords |
Michael Wittmann (22 April 1914 – 8 August 1944) was a German Waffen-SS tank commander during the Second World War. He is known for his ambush of elements of the British 7th Armoured Division during the Battle of Villers-Bocage on 13 June 1944. While in command of a Tiger I tank, Wittmann destroyed up to 14 tanks, 15 personnel carriers and two anti-tank guns within 15 minutes before the loss of his own tank.
Wittmann became a cult figure after the war thanks to his accomplishments as a "panzer ace" (a highly decorated tank commander), part of the portrayal of the Waffen-SS in popular culture. Historians have mixed opinions about his tactical performance in battle. Some praised his actions at Villers-Bocage, while many others found his abilities lacking, and the praise for his tank kills overstated.[1][2]
Although the number is disputed, he is credited with destroying 135 to 138 enemy tanks. German tank kills were recorded as a unit.[3] When he was presented with the Oak leaves to his Knights Cross by Hitler on 2 February 1944 his total was 117 tanks.[4]
Early life and World War II
[edit]Michael Wittmann was born in the village of Vogelthal, near Dietfurt in Bavaria's Upper Palatinate, on 22 April 1914. He enlisted in the German Army (Heer) in 1934 after the Nazi seizure of power.[5] Wittmann joined the Schutzstaffel (SS) in October 1936 and was assigned to the regiment, later division, Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler (LSSAH) on 5 April 1937. A year later, he participated in the annexation of Austria, the occupation of Sudetenland, and joined the Nazi Party.[6]
Eastern Front
[edit]Wittmann's unit was transferred to the Eastern Front in the spring of 1941 for Operation Barbarossa, the planned invasion of the Soviet Union. He was assigned to SS Panzer Regiment 1, a tank unit, where he commanded a StuG III assault gun/tank destroyer as well as a Panzer III medium tank. By 1943, he commanded a Tiger I tank, and had become a platoon leader in the heavy company by the time Operation Citadel and the Battle of Kursk took place. Attached to the LSSAH, Wittmann's platoon of four Tigers reinforced the division's reconnaissance battalion to screen the division's left flank. On their first day in battle at Kursk, Wittmann and his crew were credited with eight tanks and seven anti-tank guns destroyed.[7] At one point, his tank survived a collision with a burning T-34.[8]
In November 1943, Wittmann, still serving in Leibstandarte’s heavy company, was involved in armored counterattacks against the Russians around Zhitomir. On their first day in action against the Soviets, Wittman’s crew claimed the destruction of ten T-34s and five anti-tank guns. “By early January 1944 his combined total of destroyed tanks would rise to sixty-six.”[9]
On 14 January 1944, Wittmann was awarded the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross. The presentation was made by his divisional commander, SS-Oberführer Theodor Wisch, who nominated him for the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves.[10] Wittmann was awarded the Oak Leaves on 30 January for the claimed destruction of 117 tanks, making him the 380th member of the German armed forces to receive it. He received the award from Adolf Hitler, who presented it to him at the Wolf's Lair, his headquarters in Rastenburg, on 2 February 1944.[11]
Normandy
[edit]In April 1944, the LSSAH's Tiger Company was transferred to SS Heavy Panzer Battalion 101.[12] This battalion was assigned to the I SS Panzer Corps as a corps asset, and was never permanently attached to any division or regiment. Wittmann was appointed commander of the battalion's second company, and held the rank of SS-Obersturmführer.[13] On 7 June, the day after the Allied Invasion of Normandy began, the battalion was ordered to move from Beauvais to Normandy. The move, covering 165 km (105 miles), took five days to complete.[14][15]
Due to the Anglo-American advance south from Gold and Omaha Beaches, the German 352nd Infantry Division began to buckle. As the division withdrew south, it opened a 12 km (a 7.5-mile) gap in the front line near Caumont-l'Éventé.[17][18][19] Sepp Dietrich, commander of 1st SS Panzer Corps, ordered Heavy SS-Panzer Battalion 101, his only reserve, to position itself behind the Panzer Lehr Division and SS Division Hitlerjugend. From this position, the battalion could protect the developing open left flank.[20] Anticipating the importance the British would assign to the high ground near Villers-Bocage,[14] Wittmann's company was positioned near the town.[21] It arrived late on 12 June. Nominally composed of 12 tanks, his company was 50 per cent understrength with only six tanks due to losses and mechanical failures[13][22] on the hundred-mile road march from the assembly area at Beauvais. [23]
The next morning, lead elements of the British 7th Armoured Division entered Villers-Bocage. Their objective was to exploit the gap in the front line, seize Villers-Bocage, and capture the nearby ridge (Point 213) in an attempt to force a German withdrawal.[24][25][26][27][28] Wittman had not expected them to arrive so soon and had no time to assemble his company.[29] "Instead I had to act quickly, as I had to assume that the enemy had already spotted me and would destroy me where I stood." Having ordered the rest of the company to hold its ground, he set off with one tank.[30]
At approximately 09:00,[14] Wittmann's Tiger emerged from cover onto the main road, Route Nationale 175, and engaged the rearmost British tanks positioned on Point 213, destroying them.[31][32] Wittmann then moved towards Villers-Bocage, shooting several unarmed transport vehicles parked along the roadside; the carriers burst into flames as their fuel tanks were ruptured by machine gun and high explosive fire.[33][34] Moving into the eastern end of the town, he engaged several light tanks, followed by medium tanks.[35] Alerted to Wittmann's actions, light tanks in the middle of the town quickly got off the road, while medium tanks were brought forward.[13] Wittmann, meanwhile, had destroyed another British tank[36] and two artillery observation post (OP) tanks,[note 1][37] followed by a scout car and a half-track.[38]
Accounts differ slightly as to what happened next. Historians record that, after destroying the OP tanks, Wittmann duelled briefly without success with a Sherman Firefly before withdrawing.[39][40] His Tiger is then reported to have continued eastwards to the outskirts of the town before being disabled by an anti-tank gun.[41] However, Wittmann said his tank was disabled by an anti-tank gun in the town centre.[30]
In less than 15 minutes, 13 or 14 tanks, two anti-tank guns, and 13 to 15 transport vehicles had been destroyed by Heavy SS-Panzer Battalion 101, the majority[42] or all[43] attributed to Wittmann. He played no further role in the Battle of Villers-Bocage.[44] For his actions during the battle, Wittmann was promoted to SS-Hauptsturmführer, and awarded the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords.[45]
The German propaganda machine swiftly credited Wittmann, by then a household name in Germany, with all the British tanks destroyed at Villers-Bocage.[45][46] He recorded a radio message on the evening of 13 June, describing the battle and claiming that later counter-attacks had destroyed a British armoured regiment and an infantry battalion.[30] Doctored images were produced; three joined-together photographs, published in the German army magazine Signal, gave a false impression of the scale of destruction in the town.[30] The propaganda campaign was given credence in Germany and abroad, leaving the British convinced that the Battle of Villers-Bocage had been a disaster. In fact, its results were less clear-cut.[46] The Waffen-SS may have fought with distinction during the Battle of Kursk but could not match the army's success, hence Sepp Dietrich's attempts to manufacture a hero out of Wittmann.[47]
Death
[edit]On 8 August 1944, Anglo-Canadian forces launched Operation Totalize. Under the cover of darkness, British and Canadian tanks and troops seized the tactically important high ground near the town of Saint-Aignan-de-Cramesnil. Here they paused, awaiting an aerial bombardment that would signal the next phase of the attack. Unaware of the reason the Allied forces had halted, SS Hitlerjugend Division Commander Kurt Meyer ordered a counterattack to recapture the high ground.[48][49]
Wittmann led a group of seven Tiger tanks from Heavy SS-Panzer Battalion 101, supported by additional tanks and infantry. His group of Tigers crossed open terrain towards the high ground. They were ambushed by Allied tanks from two sides. On the right or northeast, British tanks from "A" Squadron 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry and "B" Squadron 144th Regiment Royal Armoured Corps were positioned in woods. To the left or west, "A" Squadron Sherbrooke Fusilier Regiment was located at a chateau courtyard broadside to the attack, where they had knocked firing positions through the stone walls.[50] The attack collapsed as the Canadian tanks destroyed two Tiger tanks, two Panzer IVs and two self-propelled guns in Wittman's force, while British tank fire destroyed three other Tigers.[51] During the ambush, anti-tank shells fired from Canadian tanks penetrated the upper hull of Wittmann's tank, igniting the ammunition. The resulting fire engulfed the tank and blew off the turret.[52] The destroyed tank's dead crew members were buried in an unmarked grave. In 1983, the German war graves commission located the burial site. Wittmann and his crew were reinterred together at the La Cambe German war cemetery in France.[53]
In 2008 a documentary in the Battlefield Mysteries series examined the final battle. A historian, Norm Christie, interviewed participants; Rad Walters, Joe Ekins and Ken Tout, and from their testimony and the two German accounts pieced the final battle together. The Tigers left the cover of a hedge near Cintheaux at 12:30 in two prongs; one in the middle of the field with the other—including Wittman—moving more slowly on the right. The British 75mm armed tanks engaged the lead Tiger (Iriohn) hitting it in the transmission, bogies or track and it started going in circles trying to withdraw. Joe Ekins' tank hit the second Tiger on the right side and knocked it out. As the crew escaped and brought out their wounded, they watched another Tiger north of them go up in flames (Kisters). Iriohn partly withdrew but could not get away and was hit by Ekins—"the one that was mulling around." Wittmann signalled "Pull back!" He did not realize that a group of the Sherbrookes were immediately to his right, and in a volley they knocked out the two Tigers beside the road. The commander of the second Tiger recalled the position of Wittmann's tank and specifically the skewed turret. The tank blew up shortly afterwards. Hans Hoflinger in a following Tiger was also attacked by enfilading fire from Sherman Fireflies with powerful 17-pound guns, and had to abandon his tank. He saw the fire and explosion in Wittmann's tank, and that the turret was displaced to the right and tilted down to the front somewhat. None of his crew had gotten out.[54] Survivors from Dollinger's tank passed by the wreck of Wittmann's tank shortly afterwards. In more recent years the 2008 Battlefield Mysteries documentary has been criticized on grounds of inaccuracy and standard of proof. It is largely based on the postulations put forward by Canadian writer Brian Reid's unsubstantiated claims made in 2005. Much of the show is based on speculation and is at odds with the first Investigation conducted by After The Battle military magazine published in 1985. It was the After The Battle that were the first to investigate Wittmann's death and had documentary evidence from the War Diary of the 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry. This only mentions 3 Tigers in the field, numbers 312, 007 and 314 and it does not mention the Sherbrooke Fusiliers who were supposed to be across the field? In a battle this would have been reported.
Speculation surrounding death
[edit]For such a junior officer, an unusual amount of speculation has surrounded Wittmann's death, both as to its cause and the party responsible. Agte states that „the English” could have possibly placed a bounty on him. This is contradicted by Allied records and the testimony of Allied troops involved that he was not singled out during the battle.[48]
After the war, claims were made by or for the following units as being responsible for Wittmann's death: the 1st Polish Armoured Division, the 4th Canadian Armoured Division, the 144th Regiment Royal Armoured Corps, and the RAF Second Tactical Air Force.[55]
Nazi propaganda reported that Allied aircraft struck Wittmann's tank, stating that he had fallen in combat to the „dreaded fighter-bombers”. In a post-war account, French civilian Serge Varin, who took the only known photograph of the destroyed tank, claimed that he found an unexploded rocket nearby and that he saw no other penetration holes in the tank. Historian Brian Reid dismisses this contention as relevant RAF logs make no claim of engaging tanks in the area at that time.[56] This position is supported by the men of Wittmann's unit who stated they did not come under air attack, and by British and Canadian tank crews who also dismissed any involvement by aircraft.[57]
Prompted by the discovery of Wittmann's remains in 1983 interest in his death was back in the news. In a 1985 issue of After the Battle Magazine, Les Taylor, a wartime member of the 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry, claimed that fellow yeoman Joe Ekins was responsible for the destruction of Wittmann's tank. Veteran and historian Ken Tout, a member of the same unit, published a similar account crediting Ekins.[58] This became the widely accepted version of events.[59] According to Hart, Ekins's unit was positioned in a wood on the right flank of the advancing Tiger tanks. At approximately 12:47, they engaged them, halting the attack, and killing Wittmann. The turret numbers of the three Tigers were recorded after the battle in the unit War Diary: 312, 007 and 314. Wittman's tank was 007. Pictures of these tanks and their positions were confirmed in photographs taken by French locals and made available to the investigation. These were taken after the war before the tanks were removed for scrap. Brian Reid's account is based on the 1985 ATB investigation but with changes, 5 Tigers instead of 3, the position of Tiger 007 and the position of the Sherbrook Fusiliers. There is no documentation to support any of Reid's claims.[60]
Reid postulated the possibility that A Squadron of the Sherbrooke Fusilier Regiment, 2nd Canadian Armoured Brigade, positioned on the left flank of the advancing German tanks, was responsible instead. Commanded by Sydney Valpy Radley-Walters, the squadron's six 75 mm Shermans and two 17-pounder Sherman Fireflies were situated on the grounds of a chateau at Gaumesnil.[61] The unit had created firing holes in the property's walls and, based on verbal testimony, engaged the advancing German tanks, including Tigers. The British tanks were between 1,000 metres (1,100 yd) and 1,200 metres (1,300 yd) away from the German line of advance, whereas the Canadian squadron was less than 150 m (500 feet) away behind a stone wall. Reid argues that due to the Canadians' proximity to the Germans, and the firing angle which precisely coincides with the tank round's entry hole in the Tiger, their troops more than likely destroyed Wittmann's tank. Reid supports this with H. Holfinger's account of the engagement. Holfinger was in a Tiger approximately 250 metres (270 yd) behind Wittmann and he said Wittmann's Tiger was destroyed at 12:55. Ekins's crew was credited with the destruction of 3 Tigers at 12:40, 12:47 and 12:52, Wittmann's tank being allegedly the one destroyed at 12:47. Considering Holfinger's account, Reid concludes that the Tiger destroyed at 12:47 could not be that of Wittmann; he also notes that the circumstances surrounding the fate of the Tiger destroyed at 12:52 exclude the possibility that it could have been Wittmann's. Reid's account of the battle has also come under scrutiny as being speculation, offering no actual proof of the events. He does accept that the documented claims of the 1st Northamptonshire Yeomanry are correct. Though there are discrepancies with the 1985 investigation with regard to other other details such as the position of Wittmanns tank.[62]
Assessment as a tank commander
[edit]Some historians and authors of the late twentieth-century found Wittmann's actions at Villers-Bocage impressive, describing his attack as "one of the most amazing engagements in the history of armoured warfare" (Hastings), "one of the most devastating single-handed actions of the war" (D'Este), and "one of the most devastating ambushes in British military history" (Beevor).[63][64][65] Historian Stephen Badsey has stated that the ambush Wittmann launched has cast a shadow over the period between D-Day and 13 June in historical accounts.[66]
With an unverified record of 130 tanks destroyed,[67] Wittmann has been credited as being the top tank ace of the war.[68] Others have noted Wittmann may have been Germany's top tank ace,[69] although Kurt Knispel might have surpassed his tally.
Jim Storr, writing in The Human Face of War, notes that Wittman's attack on the British regiment at Bocage went beyond just a bad day of tanks losses for the British. He claims that the shock of losses to the British regiment had operational and strategic effect for the operation.[70] Trigg says that in twenty or so minutes, Wittmann and his Tiger basically ended Operation Perch.[4]
With his action in particular at Villers Bocage, A.D. Harvey, writing in Military History, compared him to Sergeant Alvin York, the famed American soldier of the First World War; both single-handedly destroyed large amounts of the enemy. Harvey noted that with a total of 138 tanks and 132 armoured vehicles destroyed, this tally made him the most successful tank commander in military history.[71]
German tank commander and historian Wolfgang Schneider is not as impressed. In analyzing Wittmann's actions at Villers-Bocage, he called into question his tactical ability. Schneider states: "a competent tank company commander does not accumulate so many serious mistakes".[72] He highlights how Wittmann gathered his forces in a sunken lane with a broken-down tank at the head of the column, thereby hampering his unit's mobility. The solitary advance into Villers-Bocage was heavily criticized as it breached "all the rules". No intelligence was obtained, and there was no "centre of gravity" or "concentration of forces" in the attack. Schneider argues that due to Wittmann's rash actions: "the bulk of the 2nd Company and Mobius 1st Company came up against an enemy who had gone onto the defensive".[72] He calls Wittmann's "carefree" advance into British-occupied positions "pure folly", and says "such over hastiness was uncalled for." He concludes that had a properly prepared assault been launched involving the rest of his company, and the 1st Company, far greater results could have been achieved. Finally, Schneider opines that: "thoughtlessness of this kind was to cost [Wittmann] his life ... during an attack casually launched in open country with an exposed flank."[72]
Historian Sönke Neitzel describes Wittmann as the "supposedly successful" tank commander of World War II and attests to "hero worshipping" around Wittmann. According to Neitzel, numbers of successes, by highly decorated tank commanders, should be read with caution as it is rarely possible to determine reliably, in the heat of battle, how many tanks were destroyed by whom.[73]
Historian Steven Zaloga credits Wittmann with around 135 tank kills and points out that he achieved 120 of these in 1943, operating a Tiger I tank on the Eastern Front. Having advantages both in firepower and in armor, the Tiger I was "nearly invulnerable in a frontal engagement" against any of the Soviet tanks of that time, and Wittmann thus could destroy opposing tanks from a safe distance.[74] Zaloga concludes that "Most of the 'tank aces' of World War II were simply lucky enough to have an invulnerable tank with a powerful gun." German documents from 1944 state that Allied technology had caught up with the Tiger I and "no longer can it prance around, oblivious to the laws of tank tactics". Zaloga believes that Wittmann's fate reflected that new reality: after his transfer to France, his crew only lasted two months, and was destroyed either by a British medium tank, the up-gunned Sherman Firefly, or a standard 75mm-equipped Sherman.[75] The 75mm's armour piercing round was more than enough to have penetrated his Tiger's thin rear upper deck armour from less than 150 m (500 feet) and all of the Sherbrooke-Fusilier's records were lost shortly after the battle when an American aircraft negligently bombed the vehicle that contained these documents. There is therefore there is no documented record for the claims of the Sherbrooke Fusiliers and so must be treated with caution.
Writing in 2013, British historian John Buckley criticised the accounts which many historians continue to provide of the fighting around Villers-Bocage. Buckley argued that by wrongly attributing the entire German success to Wittmann, "many historians through to today continue to repackage unquestioningly Nazi propaganda".[76] The British lost 22 Cromwell and Stuart tanks at the battle of Villers Bocage. But a British counter attack later in the day ended with the destruction of five Tiger I tanks and up to eight Panzer IV tanks.
Awards
[edit]- Iron Cross (1939) 2nd Class (12 July 1941) & 1st Class (8 September 1941)[77]
- Panzer Badge in Silver
- Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords
In popular culture
[edit]Wittmann is often featured in books on the battles in Normandy. Several websites are dedicated to him, along with books by authors such as Patrick Agte and Franz Kurowski.[80][81] The former is an author and publisher affiliated with the pro-Waffen-SS revisionist history group HIAG,[82] while the latter is a prolific author who lauded decorated Waffen-SS men.[81]
Cult status
[edit]Wittmann became a cult figure after the war thanks to his accomplishments as a "panzer ace" (a highly decorated tank commander) in the portrayal of the Waffen-SS in popular culture. Historian Stephen Hart said that "the Wittmann legend [has] become well-established" and "continues to stimulate huge public interest".[83] Military historian Steven Zaloga refers to Wittmann as "the hero of all Nazi fanboys". He discusses the popular perception of a tank-versus-tank engagement as an "armoured joust"—two opponents facing each other—with the "more valiant or better-armed the eventual victor". Zaloga contends that the perception is nothing but "romantic nonsense". According to him, most successful tank commanders were "bushwhackers", having a battlefield advantage rather than a technical one: a tank crew that could engage its opponent before the latter spotted it often came out on top.[74]
Wittmann is featured by Kurowski in his 1992 book Panzer Aces, an ahistorical and hagiographic account of the combat careers of highly decorated Nazi tank commanders.[84] Smelser and Davies describe Kurowski's version of the war on the Eastern Front as "well-nigh chivalrous", with German troops "showing concerns for the Russian wounded, despite the many atrocities" of the Soviets against the Germans.[81] In one of Kurowski's accounts, Wittmann takes out eighteen tanks in a single engagement, for which Sepp Dietrich, the commanding officer, presents him with an Iron Cross and inquires whether Wittmann has a request. Without hesitation, Wittmann asks for assistance for a wounded Russian soldier he has spotted. Many similar acts of "humanity" are present in the book, amounting to a distorted image of the German fighting men.[85]
Notes
[edit]- ^ Used as mobile protection for artillery spotting and "one of which had a dummy wooden gun" (Buckley, British Armour in the Normandy Campaign p26)
Citations
- ^ Reid 2005, p. 411.
- ^ Zaloga, Steven J. (2021), Allied Tanks in Normandy 1944, New Vanguard 294, Osprey, p. 40
- ^ "Who killed Germany's dreaded 'Black Baron' tank ace?". World War II. 25 (3): Vol. 25 Issue 3, p12, 1 p. 1 September 2010 – via Gale.
- ^ a b Trigg 2019, p. 178.
- ^ Stockert 1998, p. 338.
- ^ Agte 2006.
- ^ Gilbert p. 226.
- ^ Ripley 2004, p. 150.
- ^ Gilbert p. 255.
- ^ Stockert 1998, p. 340.
- ^ Stockert 1998, pp. 342–343.
- ^ Reynolds 2002, p. 30.
- ^ a b c Forty 2004, p. 61.
- ^ a b c Forty 2004, p. 57.
- ^ Reynolds 2001, pp. 80, 99.
- ^ Agte 2000, p. 224–225.
- ^ Buckley 2007, p. 59.
- ^ Weigley 1981, pp. 109–110.
- ^ Taylor 1999, p. 9.
- ^ Reynolds 2001, pp. 99–100.
- ^ Reynolds 2001, p. 100.
- ^ Taylor 1999, pp. 17–18.
- ^ Trigg 2019, pp. 178180.
- ^ Buckley 2006, pp. 24–25.
- ^ Wilmot & McDevitt 1952, p. 308.
- ^ Forty 2004, p. 47.
- ^ D'Este 2004, p. 177.
- ^ Neillands 2005, p. 221.
- ^ Forty 2004, p. 58.
- ^ a b c d Taylor 1999, p. 38.
- ^ Reynolds 2001, p. 103.
- ^ Taylor 1999, pp. 18–19.
- ^ Taylor 1999, p. 19.
- ^ Forty 2004, p. 60.
- ^ Taylor 1999, pp. 19, 23.
- ^ Taylor 1999, p. 24.
- ^ Forty 2004, p. 137.
- ^ Forty 2004, p. 62.
- ^ Taylor 1999, p. 30.
- ^ Forty 2004, p. 64.
- ^ Forty 2004, p. 65.
- ^ "Villers-Bocage". Battle of Normandy Tours. Retrieved 6 November 2023.
- ^ Mawson, Robin (March 2005). "Normandy 60 years on: myths and legends". Sabretache. 46 (1) – via Gale academic online.
- ^ Forty 2004, p. 74.
- ^ a b Forty 2004, p. 134.
- ^ a b Taylor 1999, p. 82.
- ^ Marie 2003, p. 59.
- ^ a b Reid 2005, p. 410.
- ^ Hart 2007, pp. 52–69.
- ^ Reid 2005, pp. 52–69, 414.
- ^ Mark Zuehlke, "Heroes and Villains: Radley-Walters & Wittmann", Legion Magazine, August 8, 2017
- ^ Reid 2005, p. 427.
- ^ Stockert 1998, p. 346.
- ^ Trigg 2019, p. 256.
- ^ Reid 2005, pp. 418–420.
- ^ Reid 2005, pp. 426–429.
- ^ Reid 2005, pp. 415, 421–423, 425–426.
- ^ Reid 2005, pp. 423–424.
- ^ Reid 2005, p. 414.
- ^ Hart 2007, pp. 60, 65.
- ^ Zuehlke, Mark (8 August 2017). "Heroes and Villains : Radley-Walters & Wittmann". legionmagazine.com. Retrieved 3 September 2019.
- ^ Reid 2005, pp. 410–430.
- ^ Hastings 1999, p. 157.
- ^ D'Este 2004, p. 719.
- ^ Beevor 2009, p. 190.
- ^ Buckley 2007, p. 48.
- ^ Phrados, John (2021). Normandy Crucible: The Decisive Battle that Shaped World War II. Amberley Publishing. p. 211. ISBN 978-1-4456-7883-2.
- ^ David, Perlmutter (17 May 2010). "Face-lifting the death's head: The calculated pictorial legacy of the Waffen-SS and its modern audience". Visual Anthropology. 4 (2).
- ^ Storr 2011, p. 159.
- ^ Storr 2011, p. 163.
- ^ Harvey, A. D. (2002). "Soldiers with a Special Flair". The RUSI Journal. 147 (1): 61. doi:10.1080/03071840208446742 – via Taylor and Francis online.
- ^ a b c Marie 2003, p. 159.
- ^ Neitzel 2002, p. 413.
- ^ a b Zaloga 2015, pp. 3–4.
- ^ Zaloga 2015, pp. 3–4, 221.
- ^ Buckley 2013, p. 70.
- ^ Agte 2000, p. 206.
- ^ a b Scherzer 2007, p. 793.
- ^ Fellgiebel 2000, p. 77.
- ^ Reid 2005, pp. 410–412.
- ^ a b c Smelser & Davies 2008, pp. 173–178.
- ^ Antifa-Infoblatt 2001.
- ^ Hart 2007, p. needed.
- ^ Smelser & Davies 2008, pp. 175–176, 251.
- ^ Smelser & Davies 2008, pp. 173–178, 251.
References
[edit]- Agte, Patrick (2000). Michael Wittmann erfolgreichster Panzerkommandant im Zweiten Weltkrieg und die Tiger der Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler (in German). Deutsche Verlagsgesellschaft Preußisch Oldendorf. ISBN 3-92072-218-3.
- Agte, Patrick (2006). Michael Wittmann and the Waffen SS Tiger Commanders of the Leibstandarte in World War II, Volume 1. Mechanicsburg, PA: Stackpole Books. ISBN 978-0-8117-3334-2.
- Gilbert, Adrian (2019). Waffen-SS: Hitler's Army at War. Da Capo Press. ISBN 978-0-306-82466-1.
- "Der Freiwillige: The next generation". Antifa-Infoblatt (in German). 2001. Retrieved 8 December 2015.
- Beevor, Antony (2009). D-Day: The Battle for Normandy. London: Viking Press. ISBN 978-0-670-88703-3.
- Buckley, John (2006) [2004]. British Armour in the Normandy Campaign 1944. London: Taylor & Francis. ISBN 0-415-40773-7. OCLC 154699922.
- Buckley, John (2007) [2006]. The Normandy Campaign 1944: Sixty Years on. London: Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-44942-7.
- Buckley, John (2013). Monty's Men : The British Army and the Liberation of Europe. New Haven: Yale University Press. ISBN 978-0300134490.
- D'Este, Carlo (2004) [1983]. Decision in Normandy: The Real Story of Montgomery and the Allied Campaign. London: Penguin Books. ISBN 0-14-101761-9. OCLC 44772546.
- Fellgiebel, Walther-Peer (2000) [1986]. Die Träger des Ritterkreuzes des Eisernen Kreuzes 1939–1945 [The Bearers of the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross 1939–1945] (in German). Friedberg, Germany: Podzun-Pallas. ISBN 978-3-7909-0284-6.
- Hart, Stephen A (2007). Sherman Firefly vs Tiger: Normandy 1944. Duel. Osprey Publishing. ISBN 978-1-84603-150-2.
- Forty, George (2004). Villers Bocage. Battle Zone Normandy. Sutton Publishing. ISBN 0-7509-3012-8.
- Hastings, Max (1999) [1984]. Overlord: D-Day and the Battle for Normandy 1944. Pan Grand Strategy Series. London: Pan Books. ISBN 0-330-39012-0.
- Marie, Henri (2003). Villers Bocage, Normandy 1944. Heimdal. ISBN 2-84048-173-1.
- Neillands, Robin (2005) [1995]. The Desert Rats: 7th Armoured Division, 1940–1945. London: Aurum Press. ISBN 978-1-84513-115-9.
- Neitzel, Sönke (2002). "Des Forschens noch wert? Anmerkungen zur Operationsgeschichte der Waffen-SS". Militärgeschichtliche Zeitschrift. 61: 403–429. doi:10.1524/mgzs.2002.61.2.403. S2CID 185691597.
- Reid, Brian (2005). No Holding Back: Operation Totalize, Normandy, August 1944. Robin Brass Studio. ISBN 1-896941-40-0.
- Smelser, Ronald; Davies, Edward J. (2008). The Myth of the Eastern Front: The Nazi-Soviet War in American Popular Culture. New York: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-83365-3.
- Ripley, Tim (2004). The Waffen-SS At War: Hitler's Praetorians 1925–1945. Zenith Imprint. ISBN 0-7603-2068-3. Retrieved 18 February 2011.
- Reynolds, Michael (2001) [1997]. Steel Inferno: I SS Panzer Corps in Normandy. Da Capo Press. ISBN 1-885119-44-5.
- Reynolds, Michael (2002). Sons of the Reich: The History of II SS Panzer Corps in Normandy, Arnhem, the Ardennes and on the Eastern Front. Havertown: Casemate Publishers and Book Distributors. ISBN 0-9711709-3-2. OCLC 50208471.
- Scherzer, Veit (2007). Die Ritterkreuzträger 1939–1945 [The Knight's Cross Bearers 1939–1945] (in German). Jena, Germany: Scherzers Militaer-Verlag. ISBN 978-3-938845-17-2.
- Stockert, Peter (1998). Die Eichenlaubträger 1939–1945 Band 4 [The Oak Leaves Bearers 1939–1945 Volume 4] (in German). Bad Friedrichshall, Germany: Friedrichshaller Rundblick. ISBN 978-3-932915-03-1.
- Storr, Jim (2011). The Human Face of War. Bloomsbury Academic. ISBN 978-1-4411-8750-5.
- Taylor, Daniel (1999). Villers-Bocage Through the Lens. After the Battle. ISBN 1-870067-07-X.
- Trigg, Jonathan (2019). D-Day Through German Eyes: How the Wehrmacht Lost France. Stroud, Gloucestershire, UK: Amberley Publishing. ISBN 978-1-4456-9944-8.
- Weigley, Russell F. (1981). Eisenhower's Lieutenants: The Campaigns of France and Germany, 1944–1945. London: Sidgwick & Jackson. ISBN 0-283-98801-0.
- Wilmot, C.; McDevitt, C. D. (1952). The Struggle For Europe (Wordsworth, 1997 ed.). London: Collins. ISBN 1-85326-677-9. OCLC 39697844.
- Zaloga, Steven (2015). Armored Champion: The Top Tanks of World War II. Mechanicsburg, PA: Stackpole Books. ISBN 978-0-8117-1437-2.
- Zuehlke, Mark (2017) "Heroes and Villains: Radley-Walters & Wittmann", Legion Magazine, August 8, 2017
Further reading
[edit]- After the Battle Magazine (1985). Issue 48: Germany Surrenders. After the Battle Magazine. After the Battle.
- Lefevre, Eric (1983). Panzers in Normandy: Then and Now. R. Cooke (trans.). After the Battle. ISBN 0-900913-29-0.
- Tout, Ken (2002) [1998]. A Fine Night for Tanks: The Road to Falaise. Sutton Publishing Ltd. ISBN 0-7509-3189-2.
- Tout, Ken (2007). By Tank – D to VE Days. Robert Hale Ltd. ISBN 978-0-7090-8148-7.
- Propaganda legends
- 1914 births
- 1944 deaths
- People from Neumarkt (district)
- Military personnel from the Kingdom of Bavaria
- SS-Hauptsturmführer
- Panzer commanders
- Recipients of the Knight's Cross of the Iron Cross with Oak Leaves and Swords
- Waffen-SS personnel killed in action
- Burials at La Cambe German war cemetery
- Military personnel from Bavaria