Directorate of Ukraine: Difference between revisions

Directorate of Ukraine
Directorate of Ukraine
; 7th–12th Cabinet of the Ukrainian People’s Republic
	The government of the Ukrainian People's Republic in 1920. Symon Petliura is sitting in the lower row, second from left
Date formed	13 November 1918
Date dissolved	10 November 1920
People and organisations
Head of state	Volodymyr Vynnychenko (until 1919); Symon Petliura (from 1919);
Head of government	Volodymyr Chekhivskyi; Serhiy Ostapenko; Borys Martos; Isaak Mazepa; Vyacheslav Prokopovych;
Member party	Ukrainian Social Democratic Labour Party; Ukrainian Party of Socialist Independists; Independents; Ukrainian National Democratic Alliance; Ukrainian Democratic Party;
History
Incoming formation	Gerbel Government
Outgoing formation	State abolished; Second Rakovsky Government (Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic)
Predecessor	Sergei Gerbel [uk]
Successor	Christian Rakovsky

Browse history interactively

← Previous edit

Content deleted Content added

VisualWikitext

Inline

Latest revision as of 05:18, 9 December 2024

The Directorate, or Directory (Ukrainian: Директорія, romanized: Dyrektoriia) was a provisional collegiate revolutionary state committee of the Ukrainian People's Republic, initially formed on 13–14 November 1918 during a session of the Ukrainian National Union in rebellion against the Ukrainian State.^{[a 1]} During the Anti-Hetman Uprising it was named as the Executive Council of the State Affairs.^{[a 2]} Its authority was extended by the Labor Congress of Ukraine on 23–28 January 1919.

After unsuccessful attempts to gather members of the committee, it dissolved on 10 November 1920. On 12 November 1920 by the Law on the Temporary Supreme Authority and the Legislative System of the UNR, the executive council was reformed into a single-person government position.

Overview

The Directorate was formed until a new council was to be elected to form the professional government. It was decided not to restore functioning of the Central Rada which was favored by the SR-centrists Mykhailo Hrushevsky and Vsevolod Holubovych. The new council, the Labor Congress, appointed the Directorate as the Extraordinary Government Body in the protection of the republic. It was charged to enact laws in the absence of the Labor Congress due to the political situation in the country, while the Council of the People's Ministers was invested with the executive powers. The Directorate consisted of five delegates from various parties and representation groups.

Members

Vynnychenko left the government (10 February 1919) in the hope that the Directorate would establish friendly talks with representatives of the Entente^{[a 3]} while Petliura left the SDPists, thus demonstrating that the Ukrainian government had changed its political agenda and was not the same one that had signed the treaty in Brest-Litovsk on 9 February 1918. In light of that a new Prime Minister was appointed as well, Serhiy Ostapenko, who headed his non-socialist government from 11 February 1919. When talks failed, Ostapenko was replaced by Borys Martos on 9 April 1919.

: Chairman of the Directorate

Name		Term start	Term end
Volodymyr Vynnychenko	Ukrainian Social Democratic Labour Party	14 November 1918	11 February 1919
Symon Petliura	Ukrainian Social Democratic Labour Party (Sich Riflemen delegate)	14 November 1918	10 November 1920
Fedir Shvets	Independent (Peasant Associations delegate)^{[a 4]}	14 November 1918	21 May 1920^{[a 5]}
Andrii Makarenko [uk]	Independent (Railway workers delegate)	14 November 1918	21 May 1920^{[a 5]}
Opanas Andrievsky [uk]	Independent	14 November 1918	29 April 1919^{[a 6]}
Yevhen Petrushevych	Ukrainian National Democratic Alliance	22 January 1919	Unknown^{[a 7]}

List of governments

Over two years (December 1918 to November 1920) there were five governments before the Directorate went into official exile at the end of 1920. Between 15 December and 25 December 1918 a stand-off took place between the Revolutionary Committee in Kyiv and the provisional Executive Council of State Affairs (TRZDS) in Vinnytsia. It took couple of weeks before the new government was formed on December 26 headed by Volodymyr Chekhivsky as President of the Council of People's Ministers (Prime Minister).

Start	End	Prime Minister
1918-12-26	1919-02-13	Chekhivsky
1919-02-13	1919-04-09	Ostapenko
1919-04-09	1919-08-27	Martos
1919-08-27	1920-05-26	Mazepa
1920-05-26	1920-11-12	Prokopovych

History

In December 1918 Hetman of the Ukrainian State Pavlo Skoropadskyi was deposed after the Directorate was established.^[1]^[2]^[3]

Post-Hetmanate recovery

With the defeat of the Central Powers in World War I, Skoropadsky could no longer rely on Germany and Austria-Hungary's support. On 13 November 1918 Skoropadky's opponents set up a rival body known as the Directorate, whose forces were headed by the newly reformed Sich Riflemen. Most of Skoropadsky's troops joined with the Directorate during a month-long Ukrainian Civil War. Skoropadsky then turned to some of the Russian officers who were fighting alongside Anton Denikin, forming them into a Special Corps, but these troops were not able to face the Directorate's troops. On 19 December 1918, the Directorate's troops took Kyiv and overthrew Skoropadsky's regime.

The Directorate re-established the Ukrainian People's Republic (UNR). The new regime was torn between the pro-nationalistic, including the party of peasant-democrats, and the factions for the federal union with Russia. At the end the idea to reestablish the Central Rada was set aside as well as to recover all its legal acts yet the most important one were preserved. On 26 December 1918 the Directorate released its declaration to eliminate the Hetman regime.

By the end of 1918 the Directorate began to be dominated by the Ukrainian military leader, Symon Petliura.

Faced by many enemies on all sides the UNR's army was organised to face each threat. To the North-east were the Bolsheviks, to the south-east were the Russian Whites, to the south-west Romanians who had claims on territory in Bukovina and Halychyna, and the French intervention force took Odessa in December 1918 to fill the power vacuum left by the withdrawing Austrians and Germans. Coming quickly to some understanding with the French and the Romanians, the UNR's army was able to employ more men on other fronts.

Change of powers 1919-1920

With major fighting breaking out in January 1919, the Ukrainians were pushed back and Kyiv fell in February 1919. The government moved to Vinnytsia on 5 February 1919. A political trick took place that the Directorate tried to play with Volodymyr Vynnychenko resignation to demonstrate a change of powers in the Ukrainian government and maybe attain a possible acceptance with the Entente. Symon Petliura has left the party and replaced the Vynnychenko's position who was too well known. Petliura has assumed the position of the Directorate's chairman on 11 February 1919, a week after the government moved to Podolia. The talks, alas, were proved to be without results. By May 1919, the Directorate's armies had been squeezed into a narrow strip of land around Brody. The Directorate then negotiated with the government of Poland, which was attacking the Ukrainians from behind, with this ceasefire, the Ukrainians were able to counter-attack and re-take Podilia and established a new capital in Kamianets-Podilskyi. In July, the UNR's forces were joined by the Western Ukrainian Republic's forces, who had been pushed out of Galicia by the Poles. During that time (May 1919), Denikin and his White Army launched an offensive against the Reds, during the summer and autumn of that year. The White Guards forces pushed the Reds out of the Central and Eastern Ukraine, thus, giving the Directorate another chance to reclaim Kyiv. But the constant Red Guards counter-attacks and a deadly typhus epidemic caused the Petliura forces to be pushed out of Ukraine completely into the well established territory of Poland. A political crisis took place inside the Directorate members of which were heavily interfered in the affairs of the Council of People's Ministers. Because of that, Shvets and Makarenko were sent on the state matters abroad. Later in May 1920, on the request of Petliura to return, they did not reply and were dismissed.

In 1920, the Polish Army reorganized with the help from the two new Ukrainian divisions to prepare an offensive against the Denikin's forces. A UNR-Polish Treaty in April 1920 provided for combined operations between the two armies under overall Polish command while recognizing the Polish sovereignty over the territory of the former West Ukrainian People's Republic with the border passing along the Zbruch river. In the Soviet-Polish war of 1920, the Poles and Ukrainians advanced side by side, and the UNR was set up again when they re-took Kyiv. But less than a month later, the Soviet's summer counter-offensive left the Poles and Ukrainians retreating, an armistice was signed in late 1920. With this great disappointment, the UNR forces launched an attack on their own against the Reds from Polish territory, however that was quickly beaten. They were forced back into Galicia. In 1920 Poland concluded a border dispute by the Treaty of Riga with the Soviet Union, thus, canceling the Treaty of Warsaw. The Treaty of Riga divided Western Ukraine among Poland, Czechoslovakia and Hungary and gave the Soviet Union control over the rest of (current) Ukraine (which became the Ukrainian SSR).^[1]

Normative Acts

At the first stage, the Directorate recovered all of the rights of peasants and workers that were established by the laws passed by the Central Rada:

Until the complete solution of the Land Reform, the Directory of the Ukrainian People's Republic declares that all small peasant's holdings and all worker's holdings to be left for use of their previous owners, while the rest of lands to be transferred to the peasant with little or no land holdings with the priorities to those who joined the Republican forces against the struggle with the former Hetman. The Supreme subordination over the land is carried by the Directory of the Ukrainian People's Republic. This statement concerns also the monastery, church, and government land holdings. For introduction of the Reform there was organized the People's Land Committee...

The Directorate canceled all the codes of the former Hetmanate government concerning workers policies. The eight-hour working day was reestablished as well as the practice of cooperative agreements, the rights on coalition and activist strikes, and various other normative acts.

Notes

^ Map
^ Ukrainian: Рада Завідуючих Державними Справами, romanized: Rada Zaviduiuchykh Derzhavnymy Spravamy
^ Others speculate that Vynnychenko left because of political disagreements with Petliura over state affairs .
^ The Peasant Association had close ties with the Ukrainian Socialist-Revolutionary Party.
^ ^a ^b Shvets and Makarenko left the country on state matters on 15 November 1919. When Petliura asked them to return they never responded and were excluded from their duties and obligations. (21 May 1920)
^ Resigned due to the Oskilko Affair
^ Joined the Directorate in accordance with a resolution of the Labor Congress following the unification of the two Ukrainian states (22 January 1919), but he did not actually participate in the Directorate's work and eventually resigned from it.^{[citation needed]}

References

^ ^a ^b Eastern Europe and the Commonwealth of Independent States: 1999, Routledge, 1999, ISBN 1857430581 (page 849)
^ Orest Subtelny, Ukraine: A History, Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1988, ISBN 0-8020-5808-6
^ Kenez, Peter (2004). Red Attack, White Resistance; Civil War in South Russia 1918. Washington, DC: New Academia Publishing. pp. 272–274. ISBN 9780974493442.

Documents

Central State Archives of public organization in Ukraine (TsDAHO), ф. Central Committee of the Communist Party of Ukraine #1, оп. 20, спр. 103, sheet. 1-3.
TsDAHO України, ф. #43, оп. 1, спр. 3, sheet. 2-3.

Publications

Освободительная война против немецко-австрийских окупантов. Разгром буржуазно-националистической директории. (Liberation war against the German-Austrians. Defeat of the Bourgeoisie-Nationalistic Directory.). vol.1, part 1 (875 pages). Гражданская война на Украине (The civil war in Ukraine). Kyiv, 1967.
Симоненко Р.Г., Реєнт О.П. Українсько-російські переговори в Москві (січень–лютий 1918р.).Збірник документів.–Київ: інститут історії України НАН України, 1996 р. – 86 с.
Документи трагічної історії України (1917—1927рр.)/Редактор-упорядник П.П. Бачинський. -К., 1999. -640 с.
Izvestiya VTsIK. #5, 10 January 1919; #7, 12 January 1919.

Literature

Антонов-Овсієнко В. Записки о гражданской войне. В 3 – х томах –Москва – Л.Государственное военное издательство, 1932г. -т 3–350 с., т.4 1933 –343с.
Vynnychenko V. Diary. Edmonton, 1975.
Vynnychenko V. Відродження нації (Revival of a nation). vol.3 (535 pages), Kyiv, 1990.
Denikin A.N. Очерки русской смуты (Overview of the Russian mutiny). Вопросы истории (Questions of History) #5, 1994.
Rafes M.G. Два года революции на Украине (Two years of revolution in Ukraine). 168 pages. Moscow, 1920.
Революция на Украине (Revolution in Ukraine). По мемуарам белых (by the memoirs of the White movement). Госиздат (Gosizdat). Moscow, Leningrad, 1930.
Skoropadsky P. Спомини (Memories). Україна (112 pages). Kyiv, 1992.
Doroshenko D. Мої спомини про недавнє минуле (1914–1920 рр.) (My memories of the past not long ago) vol.3-4 (537 pages), Lviv, 1923.
Шаповал М. Гетьманщина і Директорія: уривок із споминів журналу Вітчизна. 1997 р. №5-6 –125-141 с., №12 –131-136 с.
Эренбург Н. "Люди. Годы. Жизнь. Воспоминания" в 3-х томах т.1 Москва, 1990г.
Білан Ю.Я. Героїчна боротьба трудящих України проти внутрішньої контрреволюції та іноземних інтервентів у 1918–1920 роках. Київ, 1957 47 с.
Великий Жовтень і громадянська війна на Україні. "Єнциклопедичний довідник". Київ, 1987 р. — 632 с.
Верстюк В.Ф. Махновщина. Київ, Наукова думка, 1991 р.,368 с.
Hrushevsky M. Ілюстрована історія України. Київ, Золоті ворота,1991 р.,572 с.
Hunchak T. Україна 1 половини ХХ століття.Київ,Либідь,1993 р.,288 с.
Dontsov D. Міжнародне положення України і Росії. -Київ,Вид.робітничої книгарні, 1918 р. –23 с.
Doroshenko D. Історія України. Ужгород, 1932 р. т.2 424 с.
Ідеї і люди визвольних змагань 1917-23 р., Н. -Й., 1962,398 с.
Історія України.Київ,1997,424с.
Історія Української РСР. Київ, 1958, т.2, 655 с.
Історія України. Львів, Фенікс, 1991, 167 с.
Історія України.Київ, 1995, т.2 494 с.
Історія України. Львів, Світ, 1996, 488 с.
Лихолат А.В. Разгром буржуазно-националистической директории на Украине. Москва, 1949, 215 с.
Мірчук П. Українсько-Московська війна(1917—1920). Торонто, 1957, 80 с.
Нагаєвський І.Історія Української держави двадцятого століття. Київ, Український письменник, 1993, 413 с.
Полонська–Василенко Н. Історія України. Київ, Либідь, 1995, 608 с.
Павленко Ю.В., Храмов Ю. Українська державність у 1917—1919 рр., Київ, 1995, 262 с.
Солдатенко В.Ф. Українська революція: концепція та історіографія (1919–29). Київ, Книга пам’яті України, Просвіта, 1999, 507с.
Солуха П. Договір з Москвою проти Гетьмана Павла Скоропадського. б-м., 1973, 378 с.
Стахів М. Україна в добі Директорії. УНР, Торонто, т.1, 1962, 272 с.,т.2 1963, 248 с., т.3 1963, 276 с.
Стахів М. Україна проти більшовиків: нариси з історії агресії Совєстської Росії. Книга 2, Тернопіль 1993, 246 с.
Супруненко Н.И. Очерки истории гражданской войни и иностранной военной интервенции на Украине. Москва, "Наука", 1966, 455 с.
Україна: 1917—1922. Довідник. Київ, 1993, 128с.
Khrystiuk P. Замітки і матеріали до історії української революції 1917–1920 р. Нью-Йорк. 1969, т.3, 160 с., т.4 192 с.
Шевчук Г.М. Розгром іноземних інтервентів на півдні України і в Криму (листопад 1918 – квітень 1919 р.) Київ, 1959, 177 с.

External links

(in English) Historical overview of the Directorate at Encyclopedia of Ukraine
(in Ukrainian) A.Skromnitsky, "Relations of the Directorate of Ukraine with the Soviet Russia (november 1918 - april 1919)". 9 September 2006.
(in Russian) Biographical listing of most of the historical personalities at Hrono
Valeriy Soldatenko (member-correspondent of NAN Ukraine). Directory and Recovery of UPR. #47(727), December 20-26, 2008 (in Ukrainian)

[1] Map

[2] Ukrainian: Рада Завідуючих Державними Справами, romanized: Rada Zaviduiuchykh Derzhavnymy Spravamy

[3] Others speculate that Vynnychenko left because of political disagreements with Petliura over state affairs .

[4] The Peasant Association had close ties with the Ukrainian Socialist-Revolutionary Party.

[shvets-5] Shvets and Makarenko left the country on state matters on 15 November 1919. When Petliura asked them to return they never responded and were excluded from their duties and obligations. (21 May 1920)

[6] Resigned due to the Oskilko Affair

[7] Joined the Directorate in accordance with a resolution of the Labor Congress following the unification of the two Ukrainian states (22 January 1919), but he did not actually participate in the Directorate's work and eventually resigned from it.^{[citation needed]}

[endSkoro-8] Eastern Europe and the Commonwealth of Independent States: 1999, Routledge, 1999, ISBN 1857430581 (page 849)

[Orest-9] Orest Subtelny, Ukraine: A History, Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1988, ISBN 0-8020-5808-6

[pk-10] Kenez, Peter (2004). Red Attack, White Resistance; Civil War in South Russia 1918. Washington, DC: New Academia Publishing. pp. 272–274. ISBN 9780974493442.

[a 1]

[a 2]

[a 3]

[a 4]

[a 5]

[a 6]

[a 7]

[1]

[2]

[3]

v t e Modern Ukraine after the Russian Revolution (1917–1921)
Universals (Central Council of Ukraine) Treaty of Brest-Litovsk Act Zluky
Ukrainian national states	Ukrainian People's Republic Ukrainian State Ukrainian People's Republic (led by Directorate)
Crimean national states	Crimean People's Republic Crimean Regional Government
Soviet states	Ukrainian People's Republic of Soviets Ukrainian Soviet Republic Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic Taurida Soviet Socialist Republic Odessa Soviet Republic Donetsk–Krivoy Rog Soviet Republic Galician Soviet Socialist Republic
Other territories	West Ukrainian People's Republic Makhnovshchina Kholodny Yar Republic Kuban People's Republic
Parliaments	Central Council of Ukraine Minor Council Directorate Constituent Assembly Central Executive Committee of Ukraine
Political parties	Ukrainian Socialist Parties USDLP independent left Socialists-Sovereigns UPSF UPSR Borotbists Ukrainian Social Democratic Party Ukrainian Radical Party Soviet of Peasants Deputies Ukrainian Peasant Society Soviet of Workers Deputies Soviet of Soldiers Deputies Jewish Socialist Parties Fareynikte The Bund Poalei Zion Polish Socialist Parties Polish Democratic Center Party Polish Socialist Party Russian Socialist Parties Socialist Revolutionary Party Left Bolsheviks Mensheviks Ukrainian National Democratic Alliance
Major figures	Mykhailo Hrushevsky Volodymyr Vynnychenko Vsevolod Holubovych Symon Petliura Pavlo Skoropadskyi Noman Çelebicihan Yukhym Medvediev Volodymyr Zatonsky Georgiy Pyatakov Yuri Gaven Béla Kun Nestor Makhno Maria Nikiforova
All-Ukrainian National Congress Congress of the Enslaved Peoples of Russia All-Ukrainian Congress of Soviets Labor Congress of Ukraine

v t e All Cabinets of Ukraine*
Ukrainian People's Republic (1917–20)	Vynnychenko I (1917) Vynnychenko II (1917–18) Holubovych (1918) Vasylenko (1918) Lyzohub (1918) Gerbel (1918) Chekhivsky (1919) Ostapenko (1919) Martos (1919) Mazepa (1920) Prokopovych (1920) Livytskyi (1920)
Ukrainian SSR (1917–91)	People's Secretariat (1917–18) Provisional Workers' and Peasants' Government (1918–19) Rakovsky I Revolutionary Committee (1919–20) Rakovsky II (1920–23) Chubar (1923–34) Lyubchenko (1934–37) Bondarenko–Marchak (1937–38) Korotchenko I (1938–39) Korniyets (1939–44) Khrushchev (1944–47) Korotchenko II (1948–54) Kalchenko I (1954–57) Kalchenko II (1957–61) Shcherbytsky I (1961–63) Kazanets (1963–65) Shcherbytsky II (1965–68) Shcherbytsky III (1968–72) Lyashko I (1972–76) Lyashko II (1976–81) Lyashko III (1981–86) Masol I (1987–90)
Ukraine (1991–present)	Fokin (1990–92) Kuchma (1992–93) Masol II (1994–95) Marchuk (1995–96) Lazarenko (1996–97) Pustovoitenko (1997–99) Yushchenko (1999–2001) Kinakh (2001–02) Yanukovych I (2002–04) Tymoshenko I (2005) Yekhanurov (2005–06) Yanukovych II (2006–07) Tymoshenko II (2007–10) Azarov I (2010–12) Azarov II (2012–14) Yatsenyuk I (2014) Yatsenyuk II (2014–16) Groysman (2016–19) Honcharuk (2019–20) Shmyhal (2020–present)
*Acting cabinets not included