Stop Breaking Down: Difference between revisions
m →Notes |
TheUser225! (talk | contribs) No edit summary Tags: Mobile edit Mobile app edit iOS app edit App full source |
||
(27 intermediate revisions by 16 users not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Short description|Song first recorded by Robert Johnson in 1937}} |
|||
{{Infobox single <!-- See Wikipedia:WikiProject_Songs --> |
|||
{{Infobox song |
|||
| Name = Stop Breakin' Down Blues |
|||
| |
| name = Stop Breakin' Down Blues |
||
| cover = Stop Breakin' Down Blues single cover.jpg |
|||
| Artist = [[Robert Johnson]] |
|||
| caption = Original 78 record label |
|||
| B-side = "Honeymoon Blues" |
|||
| type = single |
|||
| Released = {{Start date|1938}} |
|||
| artist = [[Robert Johnson]] |
|||
| Format = [[Gramophone record|10" 78 rpm record]] |
|||
| released = {{Start date|1938}} |
|||
| Recorded = Dallas, Texas, June 20, 1937 |
|||
| recorded = Dallas, Texas, June 20, 1937 |
|||
| Genre = [[Blues]] |
|||
| genre = [[Blues]] |
|||
| Length = {{Duration|m=2|s=16}} <small>(take 1)</small><br />{{Duration|m=2|s=21}} <small>(take 2)</small> |
|||
| length = |
|||
| Label = [[Vocalion Records|Vocalion]] <small>(no. 04002)</small> |
|||
* {{duration|m=2|s=16}} (take 1) |
|||
| Writer = Robert Johnson |
|||
* {{duration|m=2|s=21}} (take 2) |
|||
| label = [[Vocalion Records|Vocalion]] |
|||
| writer = Robert Johnson |
|||
| producer = [[Don Law]] |
|||
}} |
}} |
||
"'''Stop Breaking Down'''" or "'''Stop Breakin' Down Blues'''" is a [[Delta blues]] song recorded by [[Robert Johnson]] in 1937. |
"'''Stop Breaking Down'''" or "'''Stop Breakin' Down Blues'''" is a [[Delta blues]] song recorded by [[Robert Johnson]] in 1937. An "upbeat boogie with a strong chorus line",{{sfn|Wald|2004|p=179}} the lyrics are partly based on Johnson's experience with certain women:{{sfn|Conforth|Wardlow|2019|p=215}} |
||
{{poemquote|You know the Saturday night women, |
|||
now they love to ape and clown |
|||
They won't do nothin' |
|||
but tear yo' reputation down |
|||
Stop breakin' down |
|||
Please stop breakin' down<ref>{{harvnb|LaVere|1990|p=42}}</ref>}} |
|||
The song shares elements with earlier blues songs and became popular largely through later interpretations by other artists, such as [[Sonny Boy Williamson I]] in 1945 and the [[Rolling Stones]] in 1972. |
|||
==Recording and composition== |
==Recording and composition== |
||
Robert Johnson recorded "Stop Breakin' Down Blues" during his last recording session in 1937 in Dallas, Texas. The song is a solo piece with Johnson providing guitar accompaniment to his vocals. Several songs have been identified as "melodic precedents": "Caught Me Wrong Again" ([[Memphis Minnie]], 1936), "Stop Hanging Around" ([[Buddy Moss]], 1935), and "You Got to Move" (Memphis Minnie and [[Kansas Joe McCoy|Joe McCoy]], 1934). |
Robert Johnson recorded "Stop Breakin' Down Blues" during his last recording session in 1937 in Dallas, Texas. The song is a solo piece with Johnson providing guitar accompaniment to his vocals. Several songs have been identified as "melodic precedents": "Caught Me Wrong Again" ([[Memphis Minnie]], 1936), "Stop Hanging Around" ([[Buddy Moss]], 1935), and "You Got to Move" (Memphis Minnie and [[Kansas Joe McCoy|Joe McCoy]], 1934).{{sfn|Wardlow|Komara|1998|p=206}} |
||
Of his Dallas recordings, it is Johnson's most uptempo song, with "his exhuberant vocal driv[ing] home the story line". |
Of his Dallas recordings, it is Johnson's most uptempo song, with "his exhuberant vocal driv[ing] home the story line".{{sfn|Wald|2004|p=179}} Two takes of the song were recorded, both sounding very similar, although Johnson flubbed the opening verse of the second take. Although the song is played in a fretted guitar style, on both takes Johnson added a brief slide coda that comes across "like a little inside joke".{{sfn|Wald|2004|p=180}} |
||
The second take was selected for release on March 20, 1938, with "Honeymoon Blues" as the flip side.{{sfn|LaVere|2011|p=25}}<ref name="Court"/> In 1970, the first take was included on Johnson's ''[[King of the Delta Blues Singers, Vol. II]]'' album. Both were later included on the 1990 box set ''[[The Complete Recordings (Robert Johnson album)|The Complete Recordings]]''.{{sfn|LaVere|1990|p=2}} |
|||
==Recordings by blues artists== |
==Recordings by blues artists== |
||
In 1945, [[Sonny Boy Williamson I]] adapted the tune as an early [[Chicago blues]] with [[Big Maceo]] (piano), [[Tampa Red]] (guitar), and Charles Sanders (drums).<ref>[[RCA Victor]] 20-3047</ref> Titled "Stop Breaking Down", the song featured somewhat different lyrics, including the refrain "I don't believe you really really love me, I think you just like the way my music sounds" in place of Johnson's "The stuff I got it gon' bust your brains out, hoo hoo, it'll make you lose your mind". Williamson's song inspired the versions sung "by most postwar Chicago blues artists".{{sfn|Palmer|1981|p=128}} |
|||
In 1954, [[Baby Boy Warren]] recorded it as a Chicago-style blues shuffle, but used most of Johnson's lyrics |
In 1954, [[Baby Boy Warren]] recorded it as a Chicago-style blues shuffle, but used most of Johnson's lyrics.<ref>Drummond Records 3003</ref> [[Forest City Joe]] recorded the song in 1959, which was released on a compilation album ''The Blues Roll On''.<ref>[[Atlantic Records]] SD 1352</ref> In the late 1960s, [[Junior Wells]] with [[Buddy Guy]] recorded "Stop Breaking Down" for the ''Coming at You Baby'' (1968) and ''Southside Blues Jam'' (1969) albums. Their versions are medleys which incorporate lyrics from "[[Five Long Years]]" and Sonny Boy Williamson's "Stop Breaking Down". [[The White Stripes]] recorded the song for their 1999 [[The White Stripes (album)|self-titled debut album]].<ref name="Handyside"> |
||
{{Cite web |
|||
| url = https://www.allmusic.com/album/the-white-stripes-mw0000246565 |
|||
| last = Handyside |
|||
| first = Chris |
|||
| author-link = Chris Handyside |
|||
| title = ''The White Stripes''{{snd}}Album review |
|||
| website = [[AllMusic]] |
|||
| access-date = March 21, 2022 |
|||
}}</ref> Critic [[Chris Handyside]] identified their choice as inspired and added that [[Jack White]]'s vocal delivery manages to convey Johnson's sense of desperation.<ref name="Handyside"/> |
|||
==The Rolling Stones version== |
|||
==Later renditions== |
|||
{{Infobox song |
|||
[[The Rolling Stones]] recorded "Stop Breaking Down" for their 1972 ''[[Exile on Main St.]]'' album. They interpreted the song somewhat differently from the earlier versions, with prominent [[slide guitar]] work by [[Mick Taylor]] and [[Mick Jagger]] providing the harmonica and guitar.<ref>Of Jagger's guitar part, album recording engineer [[Andy Johns]] explained, "That's why it's a little choppier". Kubernik 2010.</ref> The Rolling Stones' only ever live performance of the song (with [[Robert Cray]] on slide guitar and lead vocals) is included on their ''[[The Rolling Stones: Voodoo Lounge Live]]'' concert DVD. |
|||
| name = Stop Breaking Down |
|||
| artist = [[the Rolling Stones]] |
|||
After the release of ''Exile on Main St.'', [[Allen Klein]] sued the Rolling Stones for breach of settlement because Jagger and Richards had created their version of "Stop Breaking Down" and composed four other songs on the album while they were under contract with his company, [[ABKCO Records|ABKCO]]. ABKCO acquired publishing rights to the songs, giving it a share of the royalties from ''Exile on Main St.'', and was able to publish another album of previously released Rolling Stones songs, [[More Hot Rocks (Big Hits & Fazed Cookies)]].<ref>{{cite book |last=Goodman |first=Fred |date=2015 |title=Allen Klein: The Man Who Bailed Out the Beatles, Made the Stones, and Transformed Rock & Roll |url= |location=Boston, New York |publisher=Houghton Mifflin Harcourt |pages=235-236 |isbn=978-0-547-89686-1}}</ref> |
|||
| album = [[Exile on Main St.]] |
|||
| released = {{Start date|1972|05|12}} |
|||
| genre = [[Blues rock]] |
|||
| length = {{Duration|4:34}} |
|||
| label = [[Rolling Stones Records]] |
|||
| writer = [[Robert Johnson]] |
|||
| producer = [[Jimmy Miller]] |
|||
}} |
|||
[[The Rolling Stones]] recorded "Stop Breaking Down" for their 1972 ''[[Exile on Main St.]]'' album. They interpreted the song somewhat differently from the earlier versions, with prominent [[slide guitar]] work by [[Mick Taylor]] and [[Mick Jagger]] providing the harmonica and guitar.{{sfn|Kubernik|2010|ps=: According to album recording engineer [[Andy Johns]], "That's why it's [the second guitar part, played by Jagger, is] a little choppier".}} The Rolling Stones' only live performance of the song (with [[Robert Cray]] on slide guitar and lead vocals) is included on their ''[[The Rolling Stones: Voodoo Lounge Live]]'' concert DVD. |
|||
After the release of ''Exile on Main St.'', [[Allen Klein]] sued the Rolling Stones for breach of settlement because Jagger and Richards had created their version of "Stop Breaking Down" and composed four other songs on the album while they were under contract with his company, [[ABKCO Records|ABKCO]]. ABKCO acquired publishing rights to the songs, giving it a share of the royalties from ''Exile on Main St.'', and was able to publish another album of previously released Rolling Stones songs, ''[[More Hot Rocks (Big Hits & Fazed Cookies)]]''.{{sfn|Goodman|2015|pp=235–236}} |
|||
"Stop Breakin' Down" was also recorded by [[Lucinda Williams]] in 1979 for her first professional release, ''[[Ramblin']]'', a blues cover album (which also includes two more Robert Johnson songs, "[[Ramblin' on My Mind]]" and "Malted Milk Blues"). In 1986, [[Pussy Galore (band)|Pussy Galore]] included the song for their parody of the Rolling Stone's ''Exile on Main St''. [[The Jeff Healey Band]] recorded a rendition for ''[[Cover to Cover (The Jeff Healey Band album)|Cover to Cover]]'', released in 1995. [[The White Stripes]]' 1999 [[The White Stripes (album)|debut album]] features a version of "Stop Breaking Down"; a live version recorded by the BBC is included with their 2002 "[[Dead Leaves and the Dirty Ground]]" single. On his 2004 album, ''[[Me and Mr. Johnson]]'', [[Eric Clapton]] covered this song along with several other Robert Johnson tunes. [[Todd Rundgren]] also included the song on his 2011 tribute album to Robert Johnson, ''Todd Rundgren's Johnson''. |
|||
==Lawsuit over copyright== |
==Lawsuit over copyright== |
||
"Stop Breakin' Down Blues" (along with "[[Love in Vain]]") was the subject of a lawsuit regarding the copyright for the song. In 2000, the court held that the songs were not in the public domain and that legal title belonged to the Estate of Robert Johnson and its successors.<ref> |
"Stop Breakin' Down Blues" (along with "[[Love in Vain]]") was the subject of a lawsuit regarding the copyright for the song. In 2000, the court held that the songs were not in the public domain and that legal title belonged to the Estate of Robert Johnson and its successors.<ref name="Court"> |
||
{{cite web |
{{cite web |
||
| url = http://ftp.resource.org/courts.gov/c/F3/217/217.F3d.684.98-56145.html |
| url = http://ftp.resource.org/courts.gov/c/F3/217/217.F3d.684.98-56145.html |
||
Line 40: | Line 69: | ||
| publisher = [[U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit]] |
| publisher = [[U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit]] |
||
| date = June 26, 2000 |
| date = June 26, 2000 |
||
| |
| access-date = November 12, 2010 |
||
| url-status = dead |
|||
| archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20120325093321/http://ftp.resource.org/courts.gov/c/F3/217/217.F3d.684.98-56145.html |
|||
| archive-date = March 25, 2012 |
|||
}}</ref> |
}}</ref> |
||
Line 47: | Line 79: | ||
==References== |
==References== |
||
*{{cite |
*{{cite book |
||
| last1 = Conforth |
|||
| first1 = Bruce |
|||
| author-link1 = Bruce Conforth |
|||
| last2 = Wardlow |
|||
| first2 = Gayle Dean |
|||
| author-link2 = Gayle Dean Wardlow |
|||
| year = 2019 |
|||
| title = Up Jumped the Devil: The Real Life of Robert Johnson |
|||
| publisher = [[Chicago Review Press]] |
|||
| isbn = 978-1-64160-094-1}} |
|||
*{{cite book |
|||
| last = Goodman |
|||
| first = Fred |
|||
| year = 2015 |
|||
| title = Allen Klein: The Man Who Bailed Out the Beatles, Made the Stones, and Transformed Rock & Roll |
|||
| location = Boston, Massachusetts |
|||
| publisher = Houghton Mifflin Harcourt |
|||
|isbn = 978-0-547-89686-1}} |
|||
*{{cite magazine |
|||
| last = Kubernik |
| last = Kubernik |
||
| first = Harvey |
| first = Harvey |
||
| title = Engineer Andy Johns discusses the making of |
| title = Engineer Andy Johns discusses the making of the Rolling Stones' "Exile on Main Street' |
||
| |
| magazine = [[Goldmine (magazine)|Goldmine]] |
||
| date = May 8, 2010}} |
| date = May 8, 2010}} |
||
*{{cite AV media notes |
*{{cite AV media notes |
||
Line 60: | Line 111: | ||
| type = Box set booklet |
| type = Box set booklet |
||
| year = 1990 |
| year = 1990 |
||
| publisher = Columbia Records |
| publisher = [[Columbia Records]] |
||
| id = C2K 46222 |
| id = C2K 46222 |
||
| oclc = 24547399}} |
|||
*{{cite book |
|||
*{{Cite AV media notes |
|||
| last1 = Wardlow |
|||
| title = The Centennial Collection |
|||
| first1 = Gayle Dean |
|||
| others = [[Robert Johnson]] |
|||
| authorlink1 = Gayle Dean Wardlow |
|||
| |
| first = Stephen |
||
| |
| last = LaVere |
||
| |
| type = Box set booklet |
||
| year = 2011 |
|||
| publisher = Miller Freeman Books |
|||
| location = New York City |
|||
| year = 1998 |
|||
| publisher = [[Columbia Records]] |
|||
| isbn = 0-87930-552-5}} |
|||
| id = 88697859072-11 |
|||
| oclc = 977691110}} |
|||
*{{cite book |
*{{cite book |
||
| last = Palmer |
| last = Palmer |
||
| first = Robert |
| first = Robert |
||
| |
| author-link = Robert Palmer (American writer) |
||
| title = Deep Blues |
| title = Deep Blues |
||
| publisher = Penguin Books |
| publisher = Penguin Books |
||
| year = 1981 |
| year = 1981 |
||
| isbn = 0-14-006223-8 |
| isbn = 0-14-006223-8 |
||
| url = https://archive.org/details/deepblues00palm}} |
|||
*{{cite book |
*{{cite book |
||
| last = Wald |
| last = Wald |
||
| first = Elijah |
| first = Elijah |
||
| |
| author-link = Elijah Wald |
||
| title = Escaping the Delta: Robert Johnson and the Invention of the Blues |
| title = Escaping the Delta: Robert Johnson and the Invention of the Blues |
||
| publisher = Harper |
| publisher = Harper |
||
| year = 2004 |
| year = 2004 |
||
| isbn = 978-0-06-052427-2}} |
| isbn = 978-0-06-052427-2}} |
||
*{{cite book |
|||
| last1 = Wardlow |
|||
| first1 = Gayle Dean |
|||
|author-link1= Gayle Dean Wardlow |
|||
| last2 = Komara |
|||
| first2 = Edward M. |
|||
| title = Chasin' That Devil Music |
|||
| publisher = [[Miller Freeman Books]] |
|||
| year = 1998 |
|||
| isbn = 0-87930-552-5 |
|||
| url = https://archive.org/details/chasinthatdevilm00ward}} |
|||
{{Robert Johnson}} |
{{Robert Johnson}} |
||
{{Sonny Boy Williamson I}} |
{{Sonny Boy Williamson I}} |
||
{{Exile on Main St.}} |
{{Exile on Main St.}} |
||
{{Authority control}} |
|||
[[Category:1937 songs]] |
[[Category:1937 songs]] |
||
Line 100: | Line 166: | ||
[[Category:The White Stripes songs]] |
[[Category:The White Stripes songs]] |
||
[[Category:Blues songs]] |
[[Category:Blues songs]] |
||
[[Category:Song recordings produced by Don Law]] |
Latest revision as of 05:34, 15 November 2024
"Stop Breakin' Down Blues" | |
---|---|
Single by Robert Johnson | |
Released | 1938 |
Recorded | Dallas, Texas, June 20, 1937 |
Genre | Blues |
Length |
|
Label | Vocalion |
Songwriter(s) | Robert Johnson |
Producer(s) | Don Law |
"Stop Breaking Down" or "Stop Breakin' Down Blues" is a Delta blues song recorded by Robert Johnson in 1937. An "upbeat boogie with a strong chorus line",[1] the lyrics are partly based on Johnson's experience with certain women:[2]
You know the Saturday night women,
now they love to ape and clown
They won't do nothin'
but tear yo' reputation down
Stop breakin' down
Please stop breakin' down[3]
The song shares elements with earlier blues songs and became popular largely through later interpretations by other artists, such as Sonny Boy Williamson I in 1945 and the Rolling Stones in 1972.
Recording and composition
[edit]Robert Johnson recorded "Stop Breakin' Down Blues" during his last recording session in 1937 in Dallas, Texas. The song is a solo piece with Johnson providing guitar accompaniment to his vocals. Several songs have been identified as "melodic precedents": "Caught Me Wrong Again" (Memphis Minnie, 1936), "Stop Hanging Around" (Buddy Moss, 1935), and "You Got to Move" (Memphis Minnie and Joe McCoy, 1934).[4]
Of his Dallas recordings, it is Johnson's most uptempo song, with "his exhuberant vocal driv[ing] home the story line".[1] Two takes of the song were recorded, both sounding very similar, although Johnson flubbed the opening verse of the second take. Although the song is played in a fretted guitar style, on both takes Johnson added a brief slide coda that comes across "like a little inside joke".[5]
The second take was selected for release on March 20, 1938, with "Honeymoon Blues" as the flip side.[6][7] In 1970, the first take was included on Johnson's King of the Delta Blues Singers, Vol. II album. Both were later included on the 1990 box set The Complete Recordings.[8]
Recordings by blues artists
[edit]In 1945, Sonny Boy Williamson I adapted the tune as an early Chicago blues with Big Maceo (piano), Tampa Red (guitar), and Charles Sanders (drums).[9] Titled "Stop Breaking Down", the song featured somewhat different lyrics, including the refrain "I don't believe you really really love me, I think you just like the way my music sounds" in place of Johnson's "The stuff I got it gon' bust your brains out, hoo hoo, it'll make you lose your mind". Williamson's song inspired the versions sung "by most postwar Chicago blues artists".[10]
In 1954, Baby Boy Warren recorded it as a Chicago-style blues shuffle, but used most of Johnson's lyrics.[11] Forest City Joe recorded the song in 1959, which was released on a compilation album The Blues Roll On.[12] In the late 1960s, Junior Wells with Buddy Guy recorded "Stop Breaking Down" for the Coming at You Baby (1968) and Southside Blues Jam (1969) albums. Their versions are medleys which incorporate lyrics from "Five Long Years" and Sonny Boy Williamson's "Stop Breaking Down". The White Stripes recorded the song for their 1999 self-titled debut album.[13] Critic Chris Handyside identified their choice as inspired and added that Jack White's vocal delivery manages to convey Johnson's sense of desperation.[13]
The Rolling Stones version
[edit]"Stop Breaking Down" | |
---|---|
Song by the Rolling Stones | |
from the album Exile on Main St. | |
Released | May 12, 1972 |
Genre | Blues rock |
Length | 4:34 |
Label | Rolling Stones Records |
Songwriter(s) | Robert Johnson |
Producer(s) | Jimmy Miller |
The Rolling Stones recorded "Stop Breaking Down" for their 1972 Exile on Main St. album. They interpreted the song somewhat differently from the earlier versions, with prominent slide guitar work by Mick Taylor and Mick Jagger providing the harmonica and guitar.[14] The Rolling Stones' only live performance of the song (with Robert Cray on slide guitar and lead vocals) is included on their The Rolling Stones: Voodoo Lounge Live concert DVD.
After the release of Exile on Main St., Allen Klein sued the Rolling Stones for breach of settlement because Jagger and Richards had created their version of "Stop Breaking Down" and composed four other songs on the album while they were under contract with his company, ABKCO. ABKCO acquired publishing rights to the songs, giving it a share of the royalties from Exile on Main St., and was able to publish another album of previously released Rolling Stones songs, More Hot Rocks (Big Hits & Fazed Cookies).[15]
Lawsuit over copyright
[edit]"Stop Breakin' Down Blues" (along with "Love in Vain") was the subject of a lawsuit regarding the copyright for the song. In 2000, the court held that the songs were not in the public domain and that legal title belonged to the Estate of Robert Johnson and its successors.[7]
Notes
[edit]- ^ a b Wald 2004, p. 179.
- ^ Conforth & Wardlow 2019, p. 215.
- ^ LaVere 1990, p. 42
- ^ Wardlow & Komara 1998, p. 206.
- ^ Wald 2004, p. 180.
- ^ LaVere 2011, p. 25.
- ^ a b "ABKCO Music v. Stephen LaVere". U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. June 26, 2000. Archived from the original on March 25, 2012. Retrieved November 12, 2010.
- ^ LaVere 1990, p. 2.
- ^ RCA Victor 20-3047
- ^ Palmer 1981, p. 128.
- ^ Drummond Records 3003
- ^ Atlantic Records SD 1352
- ^ a b Handyside, Chris. "The White Stripes – Album review". AllMusic. Retrieved March 21, 2022.
- ^ Kubernik 2010: According to album recording engineer Andy Johns, "That's why it's [the second guitar part, played by Jagger, is] a little choppier".
- ^ Goodman 2015, pp. 235–236.
References
[edit]- Conforth, Bruce; Wardlow, Gayle Dean (2019). Up Jumped the Devil: The Real Life of Robert Johnson. Chicago Review Press. ISBN 978-1-64160-094-1.
- Goodman, Fred (2015). Allen Klein: The Man Who Bailed Out the Beatles, Made the Stones, and Transformed Rock & Roll. Boston, Massachusetts: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. ISBN 978-0-547-89686-1.
- Kubernik, Harvey (May 8, 2010). "Engineer Andy Johns discusses the making of the Rolling Stones' "Exile on Main Street'". Goldmine.
- LaVere, Stephen (1990). The Complete Recordings (Box set booklet). Robert Johnson. Columbia Records. OCLC 24547399. C2K 46222.
- LaVere, Stephen (2011). The Centennial Collection (Box set booklet). Robert Johnson. New York City: Columbia Records. OCLC 977691110. 88697859072-11.
- Palmer, Robert (1981). Deep Blues. Penguin Books. ISBN 0-14-006223-8.
- Wald, Elijah (2004). Escaping the Delta: Robert Johnson and the Invention of the Blues. Harper. ISBN 978-0-06-052427-2.
- Wardlow, Gayle Dean; Komara, Edward M. (1998). Chasin' That Devil Music. Miller Freeman Books. ISBN 0-87930-552-5.