Marit ayin: Difference between revisions
m →Judge your fellow favorably: Citation needed tag |
m Dating maintenance tags: {{Citation needed}} |
||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
== Judge your fellow favorably == |
== Judge your fellow favorably == |
||
There is a principle in Judaism called ''dan l'kaf zechus'' or judge your fellow favorably.<ref>Talmud Shavuot Pg. 30</ref> The principle of ''marit ayin'' seems to be in contradiction with this principle as if one is performing an action that may look forbidden, it should not be worried that an onlooker will think a forbidden action is being performed as we should judge him favorably that he will judge his fellow individual favorably that he is indeed not performing a wrongful act. However, the truth is that the rabbinic prohibition was not put into place because one may think his fellow man is committing a sin, but rather because he may mistakenly think that the action that he wrongly sees taking place is indeed permissible and thus commits the wrongful action himself in error{{Citation needed}}. |
There is a principle in Judaism called ''dan l'kaf zechus'' or judge your fellow favorably.<ref>Talmud Shavuot Pg. 30</ref> The principle of ''marit ayin'' seems to be in contradiction with this principle as if one is performing an action that may look forbidden, it should not be worried that an onlooker will think a forbidden action is being performed as we should judge him favorably that he will judge his fellow individual favorably that he is indeed not performing a wrongful act. However, the truth is that the rabbinic prohibition was not put into place because one may think his fellow man is committing a sin, but rather because he may mistakenly think that the action that he wrongly sees taking place is indeed permissible and thus commits the wrongful action himself in error{{Citation needed|date=August 2022}}. |
||
== Changes over time == |
== Changes over time == |
||
Revision as of 11:03, 30 August 2022
Mar'it-ayin (Mish.: מַרְאִית הָעַיִן; Modern Template:Lang-he 'appearance to the eye'; Ashkenazic transliteration: maris ayin), is a concept in halakha (Jewish law) which states that certain actions which might seem to observers to be in violation of Jewish law, but in reality are fully permissible, are themselves not allowed due to rabbinic enactments that were put in place to prevent onlookers from arriving at a false conclusion.[1] For example, according to the Torah law, the blood of an animal is forbidden to eat, but the blood of a fish is permissible. However, according to the principle of marit ayin, it is forbidden to eat the blood of fish as an onlooker may believe the blood being eaten is from an animal, and may thus believe that animal blood is allowed to be eaten.[2]
In private
There is a disagreement in the Talmud as to whether the concept of marit ayin applies in private. Beit Shamai believes that marit ayin applies even in private, whereas Beit Hillel believes that marit ayin does not apply in private.[3]
Does not always apply
According to Rabbi Moshe Feinstein in his book Igrot Moshe, marit ayin applies only when "Someone thinks that I violated something, or he thinks that I inappropriately ate something non-kosher. However, it does not include doing something permitted that people may mistakenly think is forbidden due to the fact that they do not know the Jewish law."[4] Therefore, a permitted act which an onlooker might mistake for a different, forbidden act is a case of marit ayin and thus not allowed. However, an act which is allowed, which an onlooker might believe is forbidden, is not a case of marit ayin.
Sepharadim
According to Maran the Rishon Lezion Chacham Ovadia Yosef zt"l, "marit ayin" applies only when the onlooker may mistakenly interpret the action as something that is an isur d'oraita. [5] For example, if a person is eating what appears to be a chicken parmesan sandwich, where the cheese is actually vegan cheese (quite common nowadays) made from cashews and the like, the onlooker may mistakenly interpret that the person is eating an actual chicken parmesan sandwich made from dairy cheese. However, since the prohibition of eating chicken and dairy together is an isur d'rabbanan, there is no concern of marit ayin for the person eating such a sandwich. However, if he were eating a meatball sandwich with the same vegan cheese, an onlooker may mistakenly interpret that the person is eating an actual meatball parmesan sandwich made from dairy cheese. Since the prohibition of eating the meat of a cow and dairy together is an isur d'oraita, there is a concern of marit ayin for the person eating such a sandwich. For further clarification please ask your local Rabbi/halachic authority.
Judge your fellow favorably
There is a principle in Judaism called dan l'kaf zechus or judge your fellow favorably.[6] The principle of marit ayin seems to be in contradiction with this principle as if one is performing an action that may look forbidden, it should not be worried that an onlooker will think a forbidden action is being performed as we should judge him favorably that he will judge his fellow individual favorably that he is indeed not performing a wrongful act. However, the truth is that the rabbinic prohibition was not put into place because one may think his fellow man is committing a sin, but rather because he may mistakenly think that the action that he wrongly sees taking place is indeed permissible and thus commits the wrongful action himself in error[citation needed].
Changes over time
According to the Shulchan Aruch, if something which was prohibited in the times of the Talmud because of marit ayin is no longer a concern due to modern day circumstances, the prohibition is cancelled.[7] For example, in the times of the Talmud having soy milk, or non-dairy creamer, during the same meal as meat would have been prohibited because it was likely to think that the person was in violation of the laws of kosher. However, since it is well known today that people use non-dairy creamer, there is no issue of marit ayin, and the prohibition is cancelled.
Examples
Some examples of marit ayin include:[8][9]
- Eating or drinking kosher food at a non-kosher restaurant
- Killing and eating an animal that is ben pekuah without shechita
- Hanging up wet clothes on Shabbat, since people may think they were washed that day
See also
References
- ^ Minchas Shlomo 2-3:53.
- ^ Talmud Keritut Pg. 21
- ^ Talmud Beitzah Pg. 9
- ^ Igros Moshe O.C. 1:96.
- ^ Yabia Omer VI, YD 8
- ^ Talmud Shavuot Pg. 30
- ^ Igros Moshe O.C. Pg. 243:2
- ^ "Marit Ayin: Avoiding the Appearance of Violating the Law". My Jewish Learning. Retrieved 2020-05-10.
- ^ admin, Author (2011-12-11). "What Will the Neighbors Think? – Understanding the Halachos of Maris Ayin". RabbiKaganoff.com. Retrieved 2020-05-10.
{{cite web}}:|first=has generic name (help)