Jump to content

Suda: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Sskcs (talk | contribs)
59 edits
m fixed typo
Tags: Visual edit Mobile edit Mobile web edit
Line 6: Line 6:


==Title==
==Title==
The exact spelling of the title is disputed.<ref>It is worth noticing that Adler's edition maintains the spelling ''Suida''/Σουΐδα (as Gaisford's and Bekker's editions did), in continuity with the manuscripts, but modern scholarship prefers ''Suda''/Σούδα.</ref> The transmitted title (''paradosis'') is "Suida", which is also attested in [[Eustathius of Thessalonica|Eustathius]]' commentary on [[Homer]]'s epic poems; several conjectures has been made, both defending it and trying to correct it in "Suda".<ref name=":0">{{Cite journal |last=Nuovo |first=Claudia |date=2022 |title=Un’ultima ''teichotaphromachia'' per il lessico ''Suda'' |journal=Jahrbuch der österreichischen Byzantinistik |volume=72 |pages=421-426}}</ref>
The derivation is probably<ref>[[Bertrand Hemmerdinger|Hemmerdinger, Bertrand]] (1998). "Suidas, et non la ''Souda''". In: ''Bollettino dei classici'', 3rd ser. '''19''': 31f. Hemmerdinger defends the name Suidas ({{lang|grc-x-medieval|Σουΐδας}}), arguing that the form {{lang|grc-x-medieval|Σουΐδα/Σοῦδα}} is a [[Doric Greek|Doric]] [[Genitive case|genitive]].</ref> from the Byzantine Greek word ''[[souda]]'', meaning "fortress" or "stronghold", with the alternate name, ''Suidas'', stemming from an error made by [[Eustathius of Thessalonica|Eustathius]], who mistook the title for the author's name.<ref>It is worth noticing that Adler's edition maintains the spelling ''Suida''/Σουΐδα (as Gaisford's and Bekker's editions did), in continuity with the manuscripts, but modern scholarship prefers ''Suda''/Σούδα.</ref> [[Paul Maas (classical scholar)|Paul Maas]] once ironized by suggesting that the title may be connected to the Latin verb ''suda'', the second-person singular imperative of ''sudāre'', meaning "to sweat",<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Maas |first=Paul |date=1932 |title=Der Titel des "Suidas" |url=https://doi.org/10.1515/byzs.1932.32.1.1 |journal=Byzantinische Zeitschrift |volume=32 |issue=1 |pages=1 |doi=10.1515/byzs.1932.32.1.1 |s2cid=191333687 |via=De Gruyter}}</ref> but [[Franz Dölger]] traced its origins back to Byzantine military lexicon (σοῦδα, "ditch, trench", then "fortress").<ref>{{Cite book |last=Dölger |first=Franz |title=Der Titel der sogenannten Suidaslexicons |publisher=Bayerische Akademie des Wissenschaften |year=1936 |series=''Sitzungsberichte der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Philosophisch-Historische Abteilung. Jahrgang'' 1936. ''Heft'' 6 |location=München}}</ref><ref>{{Cite journal |last=Dölger |first=Franz |date=1938 |title=Zur σοῦδα – Frage |journal=Byzantinische Zeitschrift |volume=38 |issue=1 |pages=36–57|doi=10.1515/byzs.1938.38.1.36 |s2cid=191479647}}</ref> Silvio Giuseppe Mercati, on the other hand, suggested a link with the Neo-Latin substantive ''guida'' ("guide"), transliterated in Greek as γουίδα.<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Mercati |first=Silvio Giuseppe |date=1957 |title=Intorno al titolo dei lessici di Suida-Suda e di Papia |journal=Byzantion |volume=25/26/27 |issue=1 |pages=173–93}}</ref>

* [[Paul Maas (classical scholar)|Paul Maas]] advocated for the Σοῦδα spelling, connecting it to the Latin verb ''suda'', the second-person singular imperative of ''sudāre'', "to sweat".<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Maas |first=Paul |date=1932 |title=Der Titel des "Suidas" |url=https://doi.org/10.1515/byzs.1932.32.1.1 |journal=Byzantinische Zeitschrift |volume=32 |issue=1 |pages=1 |doi=10.1515/byzs.1932.32.1.1 |s2cid=191333687 |via=De Gruyter}}</ref>
* [[Franz Dölger]] also defended Σοῦδα, tracing its origins back to Byzantine military lexicon (σοῦδα, "ditch, trench", then "fortress").<ref>{{Cite book |last=Dölger |first=Franz |title=Der Titel der sogenannten Suidaslexicons |publisher=Bayerische Akademie des Wissenschaften |year=1936 |series=''Sitzungsberichte der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Philosophisch-Historische Abteilung. Jahrgang'' 1936. ''Heft'' 6 |location=München}}</ref><ref>{{Cite journal |last=Dölger |first=Franz |date=1938 |title=Zur σοῦδα – Frage |journal=Byzantinische Zeitschrift |volume=38 |issue=1 |pages=36–57 |doi=10.1515/byzs.1938.38.1.36 |s2cid=191479647}}</ref>
* [[Henri Grégoire (historian)|Henri Grégoire]], starting from a critique to Dölger's interpretation, defended a proposal advanced by one of his pupils, and explained the word Σοῦδα as the acrostic of Συναγογὴ ὁνομάτων ὑπὸ διαφόρων ἀνδρῶν σοφῶν, "Collection of names (words) by different learned men", or alternatively Συναγογὴ ὁνομαστικῆς ὕλης δι' ἀλφαβήτου, "Collection of lexicographical material in alphabetical order".<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Grégoire |first=Henri |date=1937 |title=Suidas et son mystère |journal=Les études classiques |volume=6 |pages=346–355}}</ref><ref>{{Cite journal |last=Grégoire |first=Henri |date=1937 |title=Étymologies byzantino-latines |journal=Byzantion |volume=12 |pages=293–300; 658–666}}</ref><ref>{{Cite journal |last=Grégoire |first=Henri |date=1938 |title=La teichotaphromachia |journal=Byzantion |volume=13 |pages=389–391}}</ref><ref>{{Cite journal |last=Grégoire |first=Henri |date=1944-1945 |title=La fin d’une controverse: koptō taphron, taphrokopō |journal=Byzantion |volume=17 |pages=330–331}}</ref> This suggestion was also supported by French Hellenist and Byzantinist [[Alphonse Dain]].<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Dain |first=Alphonse |date=1937 |title=Suda dans les traités militaires |journal=Annuaire de l’Institut de Philologie et d’Histoire Orientales et Slaves |volume=5 |pages=233–241}}</ref>
* [[Silvio Giuseppe Mercati]] wrote on the matter twice: firstly in an article appeared in the academic journal ''Byzantion'',<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Mercati |first=Silvio Giuseppe |date=1957 |title=Intorno al titolo dei lessici di Suida-Suda e di Papia |journal=Byzantion |volume=25/26/27 |issue=1 |pages=173–93}}</ref> and later in an expanded version of the same.<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Mercati |first=Silvio Giuseppe |date=1960 |title=Intorno al titolo dei lessici di Suida-Suda e di Papia |journal=Atti della Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Memorie, Classe di scienze morali, storiche e filologiche |volume=8 |issue=10 |pages=3-50}}</ref> He suggested a link with the Neo-Latin substantive ''guida'' ("guide"), transliterated in Greek as γουίδα and later miswritten as σουίδα. This interpretation was strongly criticized by Dölger, who also refused to publish Mercati's first article on the ''Byzantinische Zeitschrift''; on the other hand, Giuseppe Schirò supported it.<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Schirò |first=Giuseppe |date=1958 |title=Da Suida-Suda a Guida |journal=Archivio Storico per la Calabria e la Lucania |volume=27 |pages=171–176}}</ref><ref>{{Cite journal |last=Schirò |first=Giuseppe |date=1962 |title=Si torna a Suida (= Guida) |journal=Rivista di cultura classica e medioevale |volume=4 |pages=240–241}}</ref>
* [[Bertrand Hemmerdinger]] interpreted Σουΐδας as a [[Doric Greek|Doric]] [[Genitive case|genitive]].<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Hemmerdinger |first=Bertrand |date=1998 |title=Suidas, et non la Souda |journal=Bollettino dei classici, 3rd series |volume=19 |pages=31-32}}</ref>

Other suggestions include Jan Sajdak's theory that σοῦδα / σουίδα may derive from [[sanskrit]] ''suvidyā'' (which he translated into Latin: ''perfecta cumulataque scientia'', "collected and systemized knowledge");<ref>{{Cite book |last=Sajdak |first=Jan |title=Wielka literatura powszechna Trzaski, Everta i Michalskiego |date=1933 |editor-last=Lam |editor-first=S. |volume=4. Literatury słowiańskie, literatura bizantyjska i nowogrecka |location=Warszawa |pages=723 |chapter=Literatura Bizantyńska |editor-last2=Brückner |editor-first2=A.}}</ref><ref>{{Cite journal |last=Sajdak |first=Jan |date=1934 |title=Liber Suda |journal=Poznańskie Towarzystwo Przyjaciół Nauk. Prace Komisji Filologicznej |volume=7 |pages=249–272}}</ref> Giuseppe Scarpat's link to an unidentified Judas, the supposed author of the Lexicon;<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Scarpat |first=Giuseppe |date=1960-1961 |title=Una nuova ipotesi sull’autore del lessico detto di Suida |journal=Atti del sodalizio glottologico milanese |volume=14 |pages=3–11.}}</ref> and Hans Gerstinger's explaination which points at Russian ''sudá'' "here", as the answer to the question "τί ποῦ κεῖται;" "what is it and where is it?".<ref>{{Cite journal |last=Gerstringer |first=Hans |date=1961 |title=Review of: S. G. Mercati, Intorno al titolo dei lessici di Suida-Suda e di Papia, Atti della Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Memorie, Classe di scienze morali, storiche e filologiche VIII, 10 (1960) 3–50 |journal=Gnomon |volume=50 |pages=783–785}}</ref> The most recent explanation as of 2024 has been advanced by Claudia Nuovo, who defended Σοῦδα on palaeographical, philological and historical grounds.<ref name=":0" />


==Content and sources==
==Content and sources==

Revision as of 14:16, 28 July 2024

For other uses, see Suda (disambiguation) and Souda (disambiguation).

First page of an early printed edition of the Suda

The Suda or Souda (/ˈsuːdə/; Template:Lang-grc-x-medieval; Template:Lang-la)[1] is a large 10th-century Byzantine encyclopedia of the ancient Mediterranean world, formerly attributed to an author called Soudas (Σούδας) or Souidas (Σουίδας). It is an encyclopedic lexicon, written in Greek, with 30,000 entries, many drawing from ancient sources that have since been lost, and often derived from medieval Christian compilers.

Title

The exact spelling of the title is disputed.[2] The transmitted title (paradosis) is "Suida", which is also attested in Eustathius' commentary on Homer's epic poems; several conjectures has been made, both defending it and trying to correct it in "Suda".[3]

  • Paul Maas advocated for the Σοῦδα spelling, connecting it to the Latin verb suda, the second-person singular imperative of sudāre, "to sweat".[4]
  • Franz Dölger also defended Σοῦδα, tracing its origins back to Byzantine military lexicon (σοῦδα, "ditch, trench", then "fortress").[5][6]
  • Henri Grégoire, starting from a critique to Dölger's interpretation, defended a proposal advanced by one of his pupils, and explained the word Σοῦδα as the acrostic of Συναγογὴ ὁνομάτων ὑπὸ διαφόρων ἀνδρῶν σοφῶν, "Collection of names (words) by different learned men", or alternatively Συναγογὴ ὁνομαστικῆς ὕλης δι' ἀλφαβήτου, "Collection of lexicographical material in alphabetical order".[7][8][9][10] This suggestion was also supported by French Hellenist and Byzantinist Alphonse Dain.[11]
  • Silvio Giuseppe Mercati wrote on the matter twice: firstly in an article appeared in the academic journal Byzantion,[12] and later in an expanded version of the same.[13] He suggested a link with the Neo-Latin substantive guida ("guide"), transliterated in Greek as γουίδα and later miswritten as σουίδα. This interpretation was strongly criticized by Dölger, who also refused to publish Mercati's first article on the Byzantinische Zeitschrift; on the other hand, Giuseppe Schirò supported it.[14][15]
  • Bertrand Hemmerdinger interpreted Σουΐδας as a Doric genitive.[16]

Other suggestions include Jan Sajdak's theory that σοῦδα / σουίδα may derive from sanskrit suvidyā (which he translated into Latin: perfecta cumulataque scientia, "collected and systemized knowledge");[17][18] Giuseppe Scarpat's link to an unidentified Judas, the supposed author of the Lexicon;[19] and Hans Gerstinger's explaination which points at Russian sudá "here", as the answer to the question "τί ποῦ κεῖται;" "what is it and where is it?".[20] The most recent explanation as of 2024 has been advanced by Claudia Nuovo, who defended Σοῦδα on palaeographical, philological and historical grounds.[3]

Content and sources

pecus est Suidas, sed pecus aurei velleris
[Suidas is cattle, but cattle with a golden fleece]

— Lipsius

The Suda is somewhere between a grammatical dictionary and an encyclopedia in the modern sense. It explains the source, derivation, and meaning of words according to the philology of its period, using such earlier authorities as Harpocration and Helladios.[21][22] It is a rich source of ancient and Byzantine history and life, although not every article is of equal quality, and it is an "uncritical" compilation.[21]

Much of the work is probably interpolated,[21] and passages that refer to Michael Psellos (c. 1017–1078) are deemed interpolations which were added in later copies.[21]

Biographical notices

This lexicon contains numerous biographical notices on political, ecclesiastical, and literary figures of the Byzantine Empire to the tenth century, those biographical entries being condensations from the works of Hesychius of Miletus, as the author himself avers. Other sources were the encyclopedia of Constantine VII Porphyrogenitus (reigned 912–959) for the figures in ancient history, excerpts of John of Antioch (seventh century) for Roman history, the chronicle of Hamartolus (Georgios Monachos, 9th century) for the Byzantine age[22][21][24], the biographies of Diogenes Laërtius, and the works of Athenaeus and Philostratus. Other principal sources include a lexicon by "Eudemus," perhaps derived from the work On Rhetorical Language by Eudemus of Argos.[25]

Lost scholia

The lexicon copiously draws from scholia to the classics (Homer, Aristophanes, Thucydides, Sophocles, etc.), and for later writers, Polybius, Josephus, the Chronicon Paschale, George Syncellus, George Hamartolus, and so on.[21][22] The Suda quotes or paraphrases these sources at length. Since many of the originals are lost, the Suda serves as an invaluable repository of literary history, and this preservation of the "literary history" is more vital than the lexicographical compilation itself, by some estimation.[22]

Organization

Page from Vaticanus graecus 1296

The lexicon is arranged alphabetically with some slight deviations from common vowel order and place in the Greek alphabet[21] (including at each case the homophonous digraphs, e.g. αι, ει, οι, that had been previously, earlier in the history of Greek, distinct diphthongs or vowels) according to a system (formerly common in many languages) called antistoichia (ἀντιστοιχία); namely the letters follow phonetically in order of sound according the pronunciation of the tenth century, which was similar to that of Modern Greek. The order is:

α, β, γ, δ, αι, ε, ζ, ει, η, ι, θ, κ, λ, μ, ν, ξ, ο, ω, π, ρ, σ, τ, οι, υ, φ, χ, ψ[26]

In addition, double letters are treated as single for the purposes of collation (as gemination had ceased to be distinctive). The system is not difficult to learn and remember, but some editors—for example, Immanuel Bekker – rearranged the Suda alphabetically.

Background

Little is known about the compiler of the Suda. He probably lived in the second half of the 10th century, because the death of emperor John I Tzimiskes and his succession by Basil II and Constantine VIII are mentioned in the entry under "Adam" which is appended with a brief chronology of the world.[21] At any rate, the work must have appeared by the 12th century, since it is frequently quoted from and alluded to by Eustathius who lived from about 1115 AD to about 1195 or 1196.[21] It has also been stated that the work was a collective work, thus not having had a single author, and that the name which it is known under does not refer to a specific person.[27]

The work deals with biblical as well as pagan subjects, from which it is inferred that the writer was a Christian.[21] In any case, it lacks definite guidelines besides some minor interest in religious matters.[27]

The standard printed edition was compiled by Danish classical scholar Ada Adler in the first half of the twentieth century. A modern collaborative English translation, the Suda On Line, was completed on 21 July 2014.[28]

The Suda has a near-contemporaneous Islamic parallel, the Kitab al-Fehrest of Ibn al-Nadim. Compare also the Latin Speculum Maius, authored in the 13th century by Vincent of Beauvais.

Editions

  • Küster, Ludolf, ed. (1705). Suidae Lexicon, Graece & Latine. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.: vol. 1, vol. 2, vol. 3.
  • Gaisford, Thomas, ed. (1834). Suidae Lexicon. Oxford: Oxford University Press.: vol. 1 (A–Θ), vol. 2 (Κ–Ψ), vol. 3 (Indices).
  • Bekker, Immanuel, ed. (1854). Suidae Lexicon. Berlin: G. Reimer.
  • Adler, Ada, ed. (1928–38). Suidae Lexicon. Leipzig: B. G. Teubner. Reprinted 1967–71, Stuttgart.

See also

References

Citations
  1. ^ Gaisford Thomas, ed., (1834), Suidae Lexicon, 3 vols.
  2. ^ It is worth noticing that Adler's edition maintains the spelling Suida/Σουΐδα (as Gaisford's and Bekker's editions did), in continuity with the manuscripts, but modern scholarship prefers Suda/Σούδα.
  3. ^ a b Nuovo, Claudia (2022). "Un'ultima teichotaphromachia per il lessico Suda". Jahrbuch der österreichischen Byzantinistik. 72: 421–426.
  4. ^ Maas, Paul (1932). "Der Titel des "Suidas"". Byzantinische Zeitschrift. 32 (1): 1. doi:10.1515/byzs.1932.32.1.1. S2CID 191333687 – via De Gruyter.
  5. ^ Dölger, Franz (1936). Der Titel der sogenannten Suidaslexicons. Sitzungsberichte der Bayerischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Philosophisch-Historische Abteilung. Jahrgang 1936. Heft 6. München: Bayerische Akademie des Wissenschaften.
  6. ^ Dölger, Franz (1938). "Zur σοῦδα – Frage". Byzantinische Zeitschrift. 38 (1): 36–57. doi:10.1515/byzs.1938.38.1.36. S2CID 191479647.
  7. ^ Grégoire, Henri (1937). "Suidas et son mystère". Les études classiques. 6: 346–355.
  8. ^ Grégoire, Henri (1937). "Étymologies byzantino-latines". Byzantion. 12: 293–300, 658–666.
  9. ^ Grégoire, Henri (1938). "La teichotaphromachia". Byzantion. 13: 389–391.
  10. ^ Grégoire, Henri (1944–1945). "La fin d'une controverse: koptō taphron, taphrokopō". Byzantion. 17: 330–331.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: date format (link)
  11. ^ Dain, Alphonse (1937). "Suda dans les traités militaires". Annuaire de l’Institut de Philologie et d’Histoire Orientales et Slaves. 5: 233–241.
  12. ^ Mercati, Silvio Giuseppe (1957). "Intorno al titolo dei lessici di Suida-Suda e di Papia". Byzantion. 25/26/27 (1): 173–93.
  13. ^ Mercati, Silvio Giuseppe (1960). "Intorno al titolo dei lessici di Suida-Suda e di Papia". Atti della Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Memorie, Classe di scienze morali, storiche e filologiche. 8 (10): 3–50.
  14. ^ Schirò, Giuseppe (1958). "Da Suida-Suda a Guida". Archivio Storico per la Calabria e la Lucania. 27: 171–176.
  15. ^ Schirò, Giuseppe (1962). "Si torna a Suida (= Guida)". Rivista di cultura classica e medioevale. 4: 240–241.
  16. ^ Hemmerdinger, Bertrand (1998). "Suidas, et non la Souda". Bollettino dei classici, 3rd series. 19: 31–32.
  17. ^ Sajdak, Jan (1933). "Literatura Bizantyńska". In Lam, S.; Brückner, A. (eds.). Wielka literatura powszechna Trzaski, Everta i Michalskiego. Vol. 4. Literatury słowiańskie, literatura bizantyjska i nowogrecka. Warszawa. p. 723.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  18. ^ Sajdak, Jan (1934). "Liber Suda". Poznańskie Towarzystwo Przyjaciół Nauk. Prace Komisji Filologicznej. 7: 249–272.
  19. ^ Scarpat, Giuseppe (1960–1961). "Una nuova ipotesi sull'autore del lessico detto di Suida". Atti del sodalizio glottologico milanese. 14: 3–11.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: date format (link)
  20. ^ Gerstringer, Hans (1961). "Review of: S. G. Mercati, Intorno al titolo dei lessici di Suida-Suda e di Papia, Atti della Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Memorie, Classe di scienze morali, storiche e filologiche VIII, 10 (1960) 3–50". Gnomon. 50: 783–785.
  21. ^ a b c d e f g h i j Chisholm (1911).
  22. ^ a b c d Herbermann (1913).
  23. ^ Krumbacher, Karl (1897), Byzantinische Literatur, p. 566, cited by Herbermann (1913)
  24. ^ Karl Krumbacher concluded the two main biographical sources were "Constantine VII for ancient history, Hamartolus (Georgios Monarchos) for the Byzantine age".[23]
  25. ^ Krumbacher, Karl, Geschichte der byzantinischen Litteratur, pp. 268f.
  26. ^ Gaisford, Thomas, ed., (1853) (Suidae lexicon: Graecè et Latinè, Volume 1, Part 1, page XXXIX (in Greek and Latin)
  27. ^ a b Mazzucchi 2020.
  28. ^ "The History of the Suda On Line". Stoa. Retrieved 10 July 2015. A translation of the last of the Suda's 31000+ entries was submitted to the database on July 21, 2014 and vetted the next day. Also Mahoney, Anne (2009). "Tachypaedia Byzantina: The Suda On Line as Collaborative Encyclopedia". Digital Humanities Quarterly. 3 (1). Archived from the original on Dec 9, 2023.
Bibliography
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Suda&oldid=1237177657"