Talk:Maya priesthood: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
{{WP Mesoamerica|class=start|importance=low|attention=yes}} |
{{WP Mesoamerica|class=start|importance=low|attention=yes}} |
||
Please note that I have edited this entry to include links to a large variety of related topics. (I will also add some links that point to this article from other relevant entries). An issue that remains unclear in this entry is the question of whether there is a difference between [[priests]] and [[shamans]], both in a theoretical sense and in the ancient Maya world itself. Is there a meaningful distinction between Maya priests and Maya shamans? If so (and I think there ''is''), what can be added to this entry to highlight the distinction between a [[priesthood]] and the "free-agent" nature of [[ |
Please note that I have edited this entry to include links to a large variety of related topics. (I will also add some links that point to this article from other relevant entries). An issue that remains unclear in this entry is the question of whether there is a difference between [[priests]] and [[shamans]], both in a theoretical sense and in the ancient Maya world itself. Is there a meaningful distinction between Maya priests and Maya shamans? If so (and I think there ''is''), what can be added to this entry to highlight the distinction between a [[priesthood]] and the "free-agent" nature of [[shamans]]? The citations from Thompson and Sharer are good, but these are both old and dated references (especially Thompson, now more than 50 years old its conception). This entry could be brought up-to-date with better terminology, especially with reference to specific traditions. The general issue of orthography needs to be dealt with, since Thompson's spellings of Yucatec Maya terms depart from current standards. In general, this is a good start. However, it needs to be much more firmly integrated into Wikipedia's structure. [[User:Hoopes|Hoopes]] ([[User talk:Hoopes|talk]]) 21:24, 29 September 2008 (UTC) |
Revision as of 21:25, 29 September 2008
This article was nominated for deletion on 22 September 2008 (UTC). The result of the discussion was keep. |
Mesoamerica (inactive) | ||||
|
Please note that I have edited this entry to include links to a large variety of related topics. (I will also add some links that point to this article from other relevant entries). An issue that remains unclear in this entry is the question of whether there is a difference between priests and shamans, both in a theoretical sense and in the ancient Maya world itself. Is there a meaningful distinction between Maya priests and Maya shamans? If so (and I think there is), what can be added to this entry to highlight the distinction between a priesthood and the "free-agent" nature of shamans? The citations from Thompson and Sharer are good, but these are both old and dated references (especially Thompson, now more than 50 years old its conception). This entry could be brought up-to-date with better terminology, especially with reference to specific traditions. The general issue of orthography needs to be dealt with, since Thompson's spellings of Yucatec Maya terms depart from current standards. In general, this is a good start. However, it needs to be much more firmly integrated into Wikipedia's structure. Hoopes (talk) 21:24, 29 September 2008 (UTC)