Wikipedia:Peer review/Staten Island/archive1: Difference between revisions
Appearance
Content deleted Content added
m moved Wikipedia:Peer review/Staten Island to Wikipedia:Peer review/Staten Island/archive1: Standardising Peer review archive formatting |
m removed a redundant statement I posted on an old account, to reduce page clutter. |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
===[[Staten Island]]=== |
===[[Staten Island]]=== |
||
The introductory paragraph of the article perfectly states why I choose to nominate SI as a feature article; it is a part of New York City, yet in some ways it is quite ''apart'' from it. I found the article very interesting and informative. The only criticism I can level is as follows: |
|||
1) In my opinion, the "Geography" section should be reside closer to the end of the article, instead of the beginning. I feel this because most readers might be put off by reading boring statistics in the first five minutes. We're trying to fire their interest first, then load them with numbers. |
|||
2) A little more information about the island before the construction of the Verazzano Bridge would be nice; such as, when was the bridge that goes to New Jersey constructed? What about the huge fire at the ferry terminal, which occured during the early 1900's? Or a short statement about the plans the city has to construct a brand new space-age computerized ferry terminal, which keeps getting delayed? |
|||
If anyone has anything else to add, or disagrees with what I have said here, let them come forward! By the way, I cannot add much to this article because I am not very good at editing stuff. --[[User:Cormac Canales|Cormac Canales]] 05:09, 15 Feb 2005 (UTC) |
|||
: There are three bridges to New Jersey. The [[Outerbridge Crossing]] to [[Perth Amboy, New Jersey|Perth Amboy]] and the [[Goethals Bridge]] to [[Elizabeth, New Jersey|Elizabeth]] opened in 1928 and the [[Bayonne Bridge]] to [[Bayonne, New Jersey|Bayonne]] in 1931. I can't offer anything current, I haven't lived on the Island since 1978. [[User:RossPatterson|RossPatterson]] 20:17, 19 Feb 2005 (UTC) |
: There are three bridges to New Jersey. The [[Outerbridge Crossing]] to [[Perth Amboy, New Jersey|Perth Amboy]] and the [[Goethals Bridge]] to [[Elizabeth, New Jersey|Elizabeth]] opened in 1928 and the [[Bayonne Bridge]] to [[Bayonne, New Jersey|Bayonne]] in 1931. I can't offer anything current, I haven't lived on the Island since 1978. [[User:RossPatterson|RossPatterson]] 20:17, 19 Feb 2005 (UTC) |
Latest revision as of 17:19, 10 April 2021
- There are three bridges to New Jersey. The Outerbridge Crossing to Perth Amboy and the Goethals Bridge to Elizabeth opened in 1928 and the Bayonne Bridge to Bayonne in 1931. I can't offer anything current, I haven't lived on the Island since 1978. RossPatterson 20:17, 19 Feb 2005 (UTC)
- Four bridges if you include the recently restored Staten Island Railway Bridge, also connecting Staten Island to Elizabeth, New Jersey, and it's the oldest. Digit LeBoid 21:22, 1 August 2006 (UTC)