Jump to content

Starlink in the Russo-Ukrainian War: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
No edit summary
→Reactions over Elon Musk: Walter Isaacson states SpaceX control is in the hands of the US Military. (Presumably only in Ukraine.)
Tag: Reverted
Line 151: Line 151:


US Secretary of State [[Antony Blinken|Anthony Blinken]] has said letting billionaires taking decisions for national partners and allies was "unacceptable" and he was going to dig into it.<ref>{{Cite web|title=Dem Congressman says he’ll “dig into” Musk's role in Ukraine war|url=https://www.msnbc.com/weekends-with-alex-witt/watch/rep-crow-that-is-unacceptable-192652357511|access-date=2023-09-11|website=MSNBC.com|language=en}}</ref> Senator [[Elizabeth Warren]] has called for an investigation on Elon Musk and Starlink in Ukraine.<ref>{{Cite web|last=Macias|first=Amanda|date=2023-09-12|title=Elizabeth Warren calls for an investigation into Musk and Starlink in Ukraine after biography claim|url=https://www.cnbc.com/2023/09/12/warren-calls-for-investigation-into-elon-musk-and-starlink-in-ukraine.html|access-date=2023-09-12|website=CNBC|language=en}}</ref>
US Secretary of State [[Antony Blinken|Anthony Blinken]] has said letting billionaires taking decisions for national partners and allies was "unacceptable" and he was going to dig into it.<ref>{{Cite web|title=Dem Congressman says he’ll “dig into” Musk's role in Ukraine war|url=https://www.msnbc.com/weekends-with-alex-witt/watch/rep-crow-that-is-unacceptable-192652357511|access-date=2023-09-11|website=MSNBC.com|language=en}}</ref> Senator [[Elizabeth Warren]] has called for an investigation on Elon Musk and Starlink in Ukraine.<ref>{{Cite web|last=Macias|first=Amanda|date=2023-09-12|title=Elizabeth Warren calls for an investigation into Musk and Starlink in Ukraine after biography claim|url=https://www.cnbc.com/2023/09/12/warren-calls-for-investigation-into-elon-musk-and-starlink-in-ukraine.html|access-date=2023-09-12|website=CNBC|language=en}}</ref>

In an interview in the FT.com published on 15th September 2023, Walter Isaacson is quoted as stating that SpaceX subsequently cut a deal with the Pentagon that puts control into the hands of the US military. <ref>ft.com</ref>


Following comments he made about Taiwan Musk attracted the criticism of Taiwanese Foreign Minister [[Joseph Wu]] with Wu tweeting "Hope Elon Musk can also ask the CCP to open X to its people. Perhaps he thinks banning it is a good policy, like turning off Starlink to thwart Ukraine’s counterstrike against Russia."<ref>{{cite web |last1=Shan |first1=Lee Ying |title=Taiwan slams Elon Musk, says it’s ‘not for sale’ nor part of China |url=https://www.cnbc.com/2023/09/14/taiwan-slams-elon-musk-says-its-not-for-sale-nor-part-of-china.html |website=cnbc.com |publisher=CNBC |access-date=16 September 2023}}</ref><ref>{{cite web |last1=Davidson |first1=Helen |title=Taiwan tells Elon Musk it is ‘not for sale’ after latest China comments |url=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/sep/14/taiwan-elon-musk-china-comments-response-all-in-summit-los-angeles |website=theguardian.com |publisher=The Guardian |access-date=16 September 2023}}</ref>
Following comments he made about Taiwan Musk attracted the criticism of Taiwanese Foreign Minister [[Joseph Wu]] with Wu tweeting "Hope Elon Musk can also ask the CCP to open X to its people. Perhaps he thinks banning it is a good policy, like turning off Starlink to thwart Ukraine’s counterstrike against Russia."<ref>{{cite web |last1=Shan |first1=Lee Ying |title=Taiwan slams Elon Musk, says it’s ‘not for sale’ nor part of China |url=https://www.cnbc.com/2023/09/14/taiwan-slams-elon-musk-says-its-not-for-sale-nor-part-of-china.html |website=cnbc.com |publisher=CNBC |access-date=16 September 2023}}</ref><ref>{{cite web |last1=Davidson |first1=Helen |title=Taiwan tells Elon Musk it is ‘not for sale’ after latest China comments |url=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/sep/14/taiwan-elon-musk-china-comments-response-all-in-summit-los-angeles |website=theguardian.com |publisher=The Guardian |access-date=16 September 2023}}</ref>

Revision as of 15:03, 16 September 2023

Kyiv Mayor Vitali Klitschko and his brother Wladimir with delivered Starlink terminals during the Battle of Kyiv on March 15, 2022.[1]

In 2022, amidst the Russian invasion, Ukraine requested American aerospace company SpaceX to activate their Starlink satellite internet service in the country to replace internet and communication networks degraded or destroyed during the war.[2][3] Starlink has since been used by Ukrainian civilians, government and military,[3][4] the satellite service has served for humanitarian purposes, as well as defense and attacks on Russian positions.[5]

SpaceX provided and funded Starlink services to Ukraine largely on their own in the beginning.[6][7][8] Starlink expenses for Ukraine are currently covered by the US Department of Defense through a contract with SpaceX.[9]

SpaceX executives have disapproved the use of Starlink for offensive warfare and declined to extend Starlink availability outside of the country's borders, including in Russian-occupied territories like Crimea.[10][5] This stance was criticized by Ukraine as it prevented them from carrying out military operations in those areas.[11][12][13]

In Russia, the use of Starlink to attack Russian targets has been criticized by government officials, while the country's military has repeatedly tried to disrupt Starlink services in Ukraine.[14][9]

Through his company SpaceX and division Starlink, Elon Musk's involvement in the Russo-Ukrainian War has been significant, and met with concerns.[15]

Background

Starlink is a branch of American aerospace company SpaceX. They operate a large satellite Internet constellation in low-earth orbit consisting of thousands of satellites.[16] Starlink satellites have been launched regularly since 2019, often 60 per launch at a time.[17]

In February 2022, in the early days of the Russian invasion and amidst the Battle of Kyiv, Russia was conducting conventional offensives and cyberattacks against Ukraine's communication infrastructure.[15] On February 24, an hour before the Russian invasion, cyberattacks outed the satellite Internet Viasat that provided communications to Ukraine.[18] In order to defend themselves and to maintain Internet connectivity during the war, Ukrainian officials deemed Starlink a potential solution.[15]

Unlike conventional satellite internet like Viasat, Starlink internet access works in a network fragmented into individual parts.[18][19] The internet is beamed down on a specific dish having limited range giving internet access in the limited area of the dish, like a personal Internet hotspot.[19][20][3]

Because Starlink uses the narrow beam of the Ku and Ka bands, the Starlink antennas are physically small.[21] Any signal that intends to jam Starlink needs a precise aim into the antenna.[21] This requires the attacker to get close to Ukrainian troops, in visual range of the terminals.[21] The data carried over the network is also encrypted, with software in the terminal programmed to block off signals without the encryption.[21] If the Starlink antenna steers itself towards another Starlink satellite in view, it could point away from the jamming source.[21] This entire system prevents Starlink from being able to be taken out a single attack by Russia.[19][18]

On February 26, the Ukrainian government and Ukrainian minister Mykhailo Fedorov asked Elon Musk on Twitter to provide Starlink assistance to Ukraine.[22][23] Musk agreed, and SpaceX responded by activating country-wide service, with the first shipment of Starlink terminals arriving two days later on February 28.[22]

By requesting Starlink, Ukrainians tech executives did not think about Musk's potential personal control over the war when they would become dependent on the satellite constellation.[15] SpaceX had been negotiating with Ukraine for the launch of Starlink a month and a half before the invasion, SpaceX President Gwynne Shotwell said.[24] According to her, SpaceX was waiting for an official letter with permission.[24]

Civilian use

Starlink providing Internet to residents of Kupiansk after the battle that ended in September 2022. There were still no communications, power and water supply in the city.[25]

Starlink activated their service in Ukraine in February 2022 and removed the usual monthly subscription fee for the country.[26][27] Detailed Starlink guides were shared online for Ukrainians after its arrival.[23] Ukrainian regulators allowed Starlink to be used by anyone, including ordinary citizens and businesses.[23]

Civilians have no reason to use Starlink other than in emergency and damaged regions with no good internet coverage, because Starlink is expensive by Ukrainian standards.[23] Despite this, Ukrainian officials have declared in 2023 that Starlink was now the core of their communication infrastructure.[28]

Ukrainian civilians have relied on Starlink to contact the outside world.[29] Starlink's personal connectivity hotspot has been said useful for journalists, resistance groups and the elected government.[3]

Starlink dishes and associated terminals can also be rigged to run off a car battery in such areas.[5]

By April 2022, Starlink was officially registered and the Ukrainian government relied on it for various communication needs.[23][5] Starlink was used to transmit the President Zelenskyy's broadcast[5] and communication between Ukrainian mobile operators back on.[23] Ukrainian officials noted people would have had to wait several months for Internet to be restored otherwise.[23]

Starlink has been used to run parts of Ukrainian society like schools, hospitals[19] (the which received 600 terminals in a month from SpaceX[23]), the trains of Ukrainian Railways,[30] operation of critical energy and telecommunications facilities, support of the sowing season, and return of de-occupied territories to life.[31] 150,000 people were using the system every day in May 2022.[5] Minister Fedorov remarked in 2023 that Starlink had saved lived by keeping the energy infrastructure running for doctors performing surgeries.[12]

By June, Starlink had helped restore mobile communication in the Kyiv Oblast[30] and had been used to report on the worsening conditions inside the city in the siege of Mariupol.[32][33] At the time, Starlink was still the only mean of secure civilian and military communications in cities like Lysychansk and Severodonetsk which had not had phone coverage since April.[20] There, civilians could connect with their families while soldiers could FaceTime their spouses from their base under-attack, using the service.[20] Later in November 2022 during the liberation of Kherson, Starlink also allowed phone and internet service to resume within a few days.[5]

Military use

Starlink was first requested during the Battle of Kyiv in early 2022.[34] Since its activation, Starlink been used to carry out military operations in Ukraine.[31] Starlink has been seen in use at numerous Ukrainian bases and been called "the essential backbone" of communication on Ukrainian battlefields.[35][15] There is currently no official US legislative mechanism to authorize or restrain a military use of Starlink.[36]

In March 2022, SpaceX director of Starlink operations reported that Starlink kits allowed Ukraine Armed Forces to continue operating theater command centers. These kits were vital and needed, as Russia focused on attacking Ukrainian comms infrastructure. The same month, the company provided voice connections for a Ukrainian special operations brigade. Starlink was also used to connect the Ukrainian military to the US Joint Special Operations Command.[citation needed] The same month, two helicopters of Operation Air Corridor carried Ukrainian Special Forces fighters, weaponry and the first Starlink terminal behind enemies lines to besieged Mariupol.[33][32]

File:UA 36th marine bde Starlink 01.jpg
Artilleryman of the 36th Mykhailo Bilynskyi Marine Brigade installing a Starlink terminal.[37]

Around that time, the Ukrainian military began to use Starlink to help connect and fly drones to attack Russian forces.[38] Starlink was also used to send back video to correct artillery fire.[35] Starlink enabled mobile networks with encrypted group chats connecting Ukrainian commanders to their soldiers on the battlefield.[5] The soldiers upload real-time images of potential targets while the commanders decide where to strike.[5]

In April and May 2022, Starlink had key telecommunications role in the Siege of Azovstal, helping Ukrainian defenders to resist Russian troops in Mariupol.[33] Thousands of Ukrainian troops cut off in Mariupol were able to use Starlink to send and publish online photos and videos to the outside world, before they had to surrender in May.[20]

In May 2022, a Starlink-enabled Ukrainian Internet app was the key component of a successful new artillery fire coordination system.[39]

By June 2022, Starlink was used in various ways. Starlink enabled the connection between a Ukrainian army commander and a spotter on the roof of a building miles away.[20] In a instance in the same village, the password for the building's Starlink terminal was written in big letters in the basement for easy access.[20]

On September 30, 2022, Ukrainian forces reported major Starlink outages across the front line, due to restrictions by SpaceX, resulting in "catastrophic" losses of communication.[40] With several Ukrainian officials criticizing Starlink, speaking of widespread connection failures.[40] (see below: § Restrictions). A Ukrainian naval drone with a Starlink terminal attached to its stern washed up in Crimea that same month.[5]

In October 2022, seven similar drones were used to mount a successful attack on the Sevastopol Naval base, where the Russian Black Sea fleet is stationed.[5] Meanwhile, Starlink services had to be requested by Ukrainian forces as new areas were liberated.[35]

In February 2023, Fedorov reported "no problems with the operation of Starlink uplink terminals in Ukraine."[41] A ministry official familiar with the situation said cities near the war's front lines found no indications of trouble with Starlink coverage.[12]

Ukrainian soldiers have praised Starlink, for reasons such as preventing their army from collapsing in disarray or the war from being lost.[5][20]

Funding

Ukraine incurred minimal expenses for Starlink satellite services, as SpaceX, the Pentagon and other countries and entities contributed to covering the costs.[35] The more expensive part of the costs is not the terminals but the ongoing connectivity.[35] The terminals themselves cost $1500 and $2500 for the two models sent to Ukraine, more expensive than the consumer models on Starlink’s website.[35] Meanwhile, service in Ukraine is just $60 per month, cheaper than the usual monthly price above $90.[42][43]

Early US support for Starlink came via the USAID which spent roughly $3 million on hardware and services in Ukraine.[44][35] The largest single contributor of terminals is Poland with payment for almost 9,000 individual terminals.[45][44] Other contributors include the UK, France, Germany, Czechia, NGOs and crowdfunding.[45][44][35][41] Some volunteers and foreign companies independently purchased Starlink equipment for Ukraine.[23]

By 6 April 2022, SpaceX had sent 5000 Starlink terminals. 3667 or 73% of those were donated by SpaceX, which also removed the monthly service fees, while USAID had purchased the balance of the terminals.[46][6]

By mid August 2022, Ukraine internet service was being provided by more than 20,000 Starlink terminals.[35] 85% of the 20,000 terminals in Ukraine were paid (sometimes partially) for by countries like the US or Poland, or other entities.[35][45][44] Those entities also paid for about 30% of the Internet connectivity, which SpaceX says $4500 dollars each month per unit for the most advanced service.[35] At the time, the US had provided almost 1,700 terminals.[35] The same month, Musk tweeted the operation had cost SpaceX $80 million and would exceed $100 million by the end of year.[35]

By December 2022, Ukraine had secured additional funding for Starlink from several European countries, and a Ukrainian official stated that "all financial issues have been resolved."[8]

In early 2023, SpaceX made a deal with the US and European governments to pay for another 100,000 new satellite dishes to Ukraine.[35]

In February 2023, Ukrainian minister Mykhailo Fedorov called Musk "one of the biggest private donors of [Ukraine's] future victory," estimating SpaceX's contributions at the time as over $100 million.[12][41]

Pentagon deal

In July 2022, Chief Commander of the Armed Forces of Ukraine Valerii Zaluzhnyi directly requested to Elon Musk 6,200 more Starlink terminals for the Ukrainian military and intelligence services and 500 per month going forward to offset the losses.[35] SpaceX responded by asking Zaluzhniy to ask the Department of Defense.[35] An outside consultant for SpaceX said the company "faced difficult decisions" and did not think SpaceX had the financial ability to provide any additional terminals or service requested by the Ukrainian General.[35]

In September 2022, SpaceX wrote in a letter to the Pentagon "We are not in a position to further donate terminals to Ukraine, or fund the existing terminals for an indefinite period of time", asking the Pentagon to take over financing.[47][48] These costs totaled to $124 million for the remainder of 2022, and would reach almost $380 million million for a full year according to the senior defense official.[35] At the time, some senior defense officials at the Pentagon were worried Musk could turn off Starlink in Ukraine, which would have impacted the Ukrainians.[15]

By October 2022, SpaceX said it had paid for about 70% of the service provided to Ukraine and claims to have offered that highest level – $4,500 a month – to all terminals in Ukraine, despite the majority only having signed on for the cheaper $500 per month service.[35] Which CNN noted represented 1.3% of the service rate SpaceX said it needed the Pentagon to start paying.[35] This was interpreted by CNN as an attempt by SpaceX to obtain government funding, or a disinterest in the war.[35]

On October 14, 2022, Musk warned the service was costing Starlink $20 million per month and stated it could not go on indefinitely.[7][49][50]

During the discussions between the Pentagon and SpaceX in October 2022, the Deputy Pentagon Press Secretary was asked about the invocation of the Defense Production Act against Starlink in Ukraine.[51] This law allows the government to give orders to private companies for national defense, and take action to restrict hoarding of needed supplies.[52] The Defense secretary answered that she was not aware of this law being looked into being invoked for Starlink or any SATCOM capability.[51]

The Pentagon deal was then leaked in the press, while Musk was sharing a controversial Ukraine peace plan.[53] The situation garnered negative reactions in the medias, and a Ukrainian ambassador publicly told him to "fuck off".[53] Musk then reconsidered the deal and tweeted on October 15 that SpaceX would continue to fund Starlink service in Ukraine for free.[50] According to biographer Walter Isaacson, Shotwell was furious at Musk's reversal, asserting "The Pentagon had a $145 million check ready to hand to me, literally."[54] Quoted by Isaacson, Shotwell stated "Elon succumbed to the bullshit on Twitter and to the haters at the Pentagon who leaked the story."[54]

Musk then complained "Even though Starlink is still losing money & other companies are getting billions of taxpayer $, we’ll just keep funding Ukraine govt for free."[55]

In late 2022, Shotwell's SpaceX continued to make arrangements with government agencies to pay for increased Starlink service in Ukraine, with the terms of service being established by the military and the CIA.[21] Those arrangements prompted the creation of Starshield, revealed in Janurary 2023.[21][56] This separate Starlink service is specially destined for government entities and military agencies, solving SpaceX's issues with using the Starlink civilian network as a weapon in Ukraine.[21][56][57] While enabling the DoD to own or lease Starshield satellites for partners such as Ukraine.[56] Starshield will also have the usual requirements for mobile military systems like encryptions and anti-jam capabilities for which Starlink was not necessarily adapted for in the Ukraine war.[21]

In June 2023, the Department of Defense officialized the contract with Shotwell's SpaceX to buy Starlink satellite services for Ukraine.[9] The deal includes the Pentagon buying 400-500 Starlink terminals for Ukraine, giving the Pentagon control of where Starlink works inside the country without fear of interruption.[58] Following the contract, The Pentagon stated Starlink was a "vital layer in Ukraine's overall communications network" amidst "a range of global partners to ensure Ukraine has the capabilities they need."[9]

Restrictions

Approximate Starlink coverage of Ukraine as of September 2023, according to the official map on the Starlink website.[59] Areas along the Belarusian and Russian borders, Crimea, and parts of the Donbas are not covered. All covered areas of Ukraine are at capacity.[59]

SpaceX has continued to restrict the use of Starlink Internet services outside the borders of Ukraine, including in Russian-occupied territories in Ukraine.[59] It has done so using geofencing, which consists in accurately limiting the availability of the service to only certain areas.[28] SpaceX has also limited Ukraine's ability to use Starlink for military purposes such as drone control.[60]

A US Department of Defense official said in 2022 that other entities existed to provide communications on the battlefields in Ukraine as an alternative to Starlink.[61] Starshield, a separate military-focused version of Starlink, seems to have been the solution chosen by the DoD and SpaceX against the restrictions.[57][56]

Motives

SpaceX CEO Elon Musk has vowed against the use of his company's Starlink for the military.[54] He has openly declared Starlink was not meant to be involved in wars, citing peaceful activities like entertainment or online school instead of drone strikes.[54] Gwynne Shotwell, President of SpaceX and Starlink, largely aligns to this viewpoint.[10]

Starlink legal documents claim it is not for use in weaponry as a military use of Starlink bring it under US export control laws like the International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR) or the Export Administration Regulations (EAR).[62]

On February 8, 2023 Gwynne Shotwell, President of Starlink, announced that the company had taken measures to prevent the use of Starlink service to control combat drones.[63]SpaceX restricted the licensing of Starlink communication technology to exclude direct military use of Starlink on weapon systems. The limitation restricted use by Ukraine of Starlink antennas on uncrewed surface vehicles, potentially shifting the balance of power in the naval war in the Black Sea.[64] The same month, Elon Musk re-itered on Twitter "We will not enable escalation of conflict that may lead to WW3".[15]

Shotwell has stated that "Ukrainians have leveraged [Starlink] in ways that were unintentional and not part of any agreement", as the free service was intended for humanitarian and defense purposes such as "providing broadband internet to hospitals, banks and families affected by Russia's invasion".[63][10] Shotwell explained that her company agreed with Ukraine's military using Starlink for communications but never intended to have them use it as a weapon.[10] She added "But then they started putting them on f---ing drones trying to blow up Russian ships. I’m happy to donate services for ambulances and hospitals and mothers [...] But it’s wrong to pay for military drone strikes."[19]

Shotwell's statement drew criticism from supporters and politicians of Ukraine such as President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and Mykhailo Podolyak.[12] A Ukrainian military official called her statement "strange" given that the country's use of Starlink as a combat tool is well-established.[12] Podolyak commented that companies had to decide if they were "on the side of the right to freedom" or "on the Russian Federation's side and its 'right' to kill and seize territories".[11][60]

Consequences

The first communications black-outs caused by the restrictions happened in October 2022 when Ukrainian soldiers moved into Russian-contested areas in Southern Ukraine.[19][15] Starlink did not work very close or beyond the frontline into Russian-controlled territories.[40][15] Ukrainian and American officials said this caused units to become isolated, commanders risking themselves to get in radio range of the front lines, higher operational costs and loss of lives.[15][19] The loss of communications prevented the Ukrainian military to defend themselves and coordinate their attacks in those areas, and had to retreat as a result.[15][19] Outages were acute in Kherson and Zaporizhzhia and occured also in Kharkiv and the Donbas.[40] Starlink still functioned in newly-liberated territory east of Izyum and in the southern Kherson region.[40]

Senior defense officials at the Pentagon tried to solution the problem in several meetings but were not used to have no leverage on a private entity.[15] The Pentagon saw the solution in a contractual arrangement with SpaceX as the company would not be able to cease Starlink services in Ukraine on their own decision.[15] (see above: § Pentagon deal)

Crimea

According to the official map of Starlink coverage on their website and other sources, Starlink has never been activated in Crimea.[19][40][65]

However in September 2022, a Ukrainian unmanned surface vehicle (USV) with a Starlink terminal attached to its stern washed up in the Crimean city of Sevastopol.[5] The naval drone has been assumed to be for reconnaissance, but may also appeared to carry munitions and act as a bomb.[66] Several experts noted that the sensors on the front of the naval drone could be used as a laser range finder to help in targeting.[66]

In late October 2022, seven other black submarine drones were used to mount a successful drone attack on the Sevastopol Naval base in Crimea, where the Russian Black Sea fleet is stationed.[5][67]

In 2022, an emergency request by Ukrainian officials to activate Starlink up to Sevastopol was rejected by Elon Musk.[5][13] Musk had talked with the Russian ambassador to the US, who warned him an attack on Crimea would be met with a nuclear response.[68]

Six Ukrainian submarines drones strapped with explosives were attempting a sneak attack the Russian fleet in Sevastopol using Starlink to guide them to target.[35] Musk's biographer Isaacson had claimed Musk had told his engineers to turn off Starlink coverage within 100 kilometers of the Crimean coast[35], though Isaacson has retracted the claim.[69] According to CNN, Ukraine thought the coverage was activated up to Crimea but it was not, thus Musk did not disable any existing coverage.[69] Some drones lost connectivity and washed ashore without exploding, others returned to Ukraine undamaged.[68]

Elon Musk tweeted that the obvious intent was to sink most of the Russian fleet at anchor. He said that if he had agreed to the Ukrainians' request, then SpaceX would be in a major act of war and conflict escalation.[35] Musk also compared a successful hypothetical Ukrainian sinking of the Russian fleet to a "mini-Pearl Harbor".[70] The Atlantic noted that a week later another Ukrainian attack using a different communications system did hit their targets in the port of Sevastopol, causing deterrence from the Russian Navy without escalation.[68]

Minister Fedorov asked Musk to turn the coverage back on but he declined. Mykhailo Podolyak responded that civilians and children were being killed as a result,[28] adding that this was "the price of a cocktail of ignorance and big ego".[28]

To address concerns from DC, Musk explained in a call with Biden's security adviser and the US Russian ambassador, that he did not wish Starlink to be used offensively.[71] Musk told Pentagon officials that he spoke with Vladimir Putin.[72] Anne Applebaum wrote in The Atlantic that Musk's influence had been played by Russian disinformation, the latter having already been used in the Invasion of Ukraine as part of Russia's information war.[68]

Russian response

Russia has tried to cut off and jam internet services in Ukraine, including attempts to block Starlink in the region.[9] Russian cyberattacks against Starlink appear to have been ineffective compared to other satellite services.[5] Reasons advanced include SpaceX's speed of response and Starlink engineers' ability to defeat Russian jamming.[5] The director for electronic warfare at the US Secretary of Defense described the speed of the software response he witnessed to one attack as "eye-watering".[5]

In October 2022, amidst Ukrainian counteroffensives in the Battle of Donbas, Russian forces reportedly disrupted a Ukrainian Starlink system in the Soledar-Bakhmut area after they destroyed a shortwave repeater.[73] The same month, Starlink terminals were subject to Russian cyberattacks which were quickly prevented by hardening the service's software.[21][9] It has been argued that the successful cyberattack has shown Starlink's vulnerabilities, even if the response was quick.[21]

In early May 2022, the Russian head of Roscosmos and politician Dmitry Rogozin said Elon Musk will be held responsible "as an adult" for having provided the Armed Forces of Ukraine with Starlink satellites.[14][20]

In August 2023, during Ukraine's counteroffensive, a Five Eyes report found that Russian hackers planted malwares designed to steal data to Starlink from the Android tablets of Ukrainian soldiers.[74] Ukrainian Security Services said to have blocked some of the hacking attempts and conceded Russians had captured tablets on the battlefield and planted malwares on them.[74]

Reactions over Elon Musk

The involvement of Elon Musk (founder of SpaceX and Starlink) in the Russo-Ukrainian War has been met with concerns.[15] His influence has been described as "more like a nation state than an individual".[19] A Pentagon insider commented in 2022 that "Elon Musk hasn't been elected, no one decided to give him that power. He has it because of the technology and company he built".[35]

After Isaacson falsely claimed Elon Musk had actively prevented Ukrainian submarine drone attacks on Crimea (a claim he then retracted and corrected, see § Crimea)[69], Ronan Farrow argued that "There was little precedent for a civilian becoming the arbiter of a war between nations" while the government has no level of control over his decisions.[19][15] Walter Isaacson talked about "the complexities of critical military infrastructure being controlled by an often well-intentioned but mercurial private citizen".[75]

Musk has claimed then denied to have talked to Russian President Vladimir Putin,[72][76] and the latter and other Russian officials showed appreciation for him following his Western media backlash for having prevented drone attacks on Crimea.[77][78]

US Secretary of State Anthony Blinken has said letting billionaires taking decisions for national partners and allies was "unacceptable" and he was going to dig into it.[79] Senator Elizabeth Warren has called for an investigation on Elon Musk and Starlink in Ukraine.[80]

In an interview in the FT.com published on 15th September 2023, Walter Isaacson is quoted as stating that SpaceX subsequently cut a deal with the Pentagon that puts control into the hands of the US military. [81]

Following comments he made about Taiwan Musk attracted the criticism of Taiwanese Foreign Minister Joseph Wu with Wu tweeting "Hope Elon Musk can also ask the CCP to open X to its people. Perhaps he thinks banning it is a good policy, like turning off Starlink to thwart Ukraine’s counterstrike against Russia."[82][83]

Supplies

This is a dynamic list and may never be able to satisfy particular standards for completeness. You can help by adding missing items with reliable sources.
  • The first shipment of Starlink terminals arrived on February 28, 2022 during the Battle of Kyiv.[84]
  • 2,000 terminals were sent via Poland in the early days of the war. With 6,000 more terminals and dishes shipped a few days after.[citation needed]
  • By 6 April 2022, SpaceX had sent over 5000 Starlink terminals to Ukraine to allow Ukrainians access to the Starlink network.[85]
  • In June 2022, Ukraine received a new batch of antennae for Ukrainian intelligence units.[86]
  • In July 2022, European countries had sent Starlink terminals to Ukraine from their own supplies.[87] That month, 15,000 Starlink terminals were operating in Ukraine.[75]
  • By mid August 2022, Ukraine internet service was being provided by more than 20,000 Starlink terminals.[35]
  • In December 2022, SpaceX had sent 22,000 Starlink terminals to Ukraine since the war began.[21]
  • In February 2023, 10,000 Starlink terminals provided by the German government arrived in Ukraine.[12][41]

See also

References

  1. ^ Kitsoft. "Віталій Кличко: Пристрої глобальної супутникової системи Starlink уже в Києві". Офіційний портал КМДА - Головна (in Ukrainian). Retrieved September 11, 2023.
  2. ^ Elon Musk says SpaceX's Starlink satellites active over Ukraine after request from embattled country's leaders, The Independent (26 February 2022)
  3. ^ a b c d "Elon Musk's Starlink arrives in Ukraine but what next?". BBC News. March 1, 2022. Archived from the original on July 9, 2022. Retrieved July 12, 2022.
  4. ^ Sabbagh, Dan (February 9, 2023). "Fury in Ukraine as Elon Musk's SpaceX limits Starlink use for drones". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved May 20, 2023.
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r "How Elon Musk's satellites have saved Ukraine and changed warfare". The Economist. ISSN 0013-0613. Retrieved June 6, 2023.
  6. ^ a b "SpaceX, USAID deliver 5,000 satellite internet terminals to Ukraine". Reuters. April 6, 2022. Retrieved June 6, 2023.
  7. ^ a b Matthew Luxmoore (October 14, 2022). "Elon Musk said the cost of maintaining Starlink terminals in Ukraine is approaching $20 million a month and SpaceX can't fund the service indefinitely". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved October 14, 2022. Elon Musk said the cost of maintaining Starlink terminals in Ukraine is approaching $20 million a month and SpaceX can't fund the service indefinitely [...] President Volodymyr Zelensky took to Twitter to question Mr. Musk's allegiances
  8. ^ a b Brodkin, Jon (December 20, 2022). "Ukraine to get 10,000 more Starlink antennas; funding problems are "resolved"". Ars Technica. Retrieved May 19, 2023.
  9. ^ a b c d e f Stone, Mike; Roulette, Joey (June 1, 2023). "SpaceX's Starlink wins Pentagon contract for satellite services to Ukraine". Reuters. Retrieved June 1, 2023.
  10. ^ a b c d Roulette, Joey (February 9, 2023). "SpaceX curbed Ukraine's use of Starlink internet for drones -company president". Reuters. Retrieved February 9, 2023.
  11. ^ a b Sabbagh, Dan (February 9, 2023). "Fury in Ukraine as Elon Musk's SpaceX limits Starlink use for drones". The Guardian.
  12. ^ a b c d e f g Bajak, Frank (February 9, 2023). "Musk deputy's words on Starlink 'weaponization' vex Ukraine". AP News. Retrieved September 16, 2023.
  13. ^ a b Borger, Julian (September 7, 2023). "Elon Musk ordered Starlink to be turned off during Ukraine offensive, book says". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  14. ^ a b "Ілон Маск відреагував на погрози Рогозіна нібито через постачання Starlink українській армії". LIGA (in Ukrainian). May 9, 2022. Archived from the original on June 11, 2022. Retrieved July 12, 2022.
  15. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o Farrow, Ronan (August 21, 2023). "Elon Musk's Shadow Rule". The New Yorker. ISSN 0028-792X. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  16. ^ Grush, Loren (February 15, 2018). "SpaceX is about to launch two of its space Internet satellites – the first of nearly 12,000". The Verge. Archived from the original on June 16, 2019. Retrieved February 16, 2018.
  17. ^ "Starlink Press Kit" (PDF). spacex.com. May 15, 2019. Archived (PDF) from the original on May 15, 2019. Retrieved May 23, 2019.
  18. ^ a b c Sheetz, Michael (February 28, 2022). "Viasat believes 'cyber event' is disrupting its satellite-internet service in Ukraine". CNBC. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  19. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Mosley, Tonya (August 23, 2023). "Ronan Farrow says Elon Musk has become an 'arbiter' of the war in Ukraine". www.npr.org. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  20. ^ a b c d e f g h Trofimov, Yaroslav; Maidenberg, Micah; FitzGerald, Drew (July 16, 2022). "Ukraine Leans on Elon Musk's Starlink in Fight Against Russia". Wall Street Journal. ISSN 0099-9660. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  21. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l Team, ESD Editorial (May 30, 2023). "Ukraine's Favourite Dish". euro-sd.com. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  22. ^ a b c d e f g h i "Starlink в Україні: кому доступний інтернет від SpaceX та як ним користуватися". The Village Україна. April 29, 2022. Archived from the original on April 29, 2022. Retrieved July 12, 2022.
  23. ^ a b Foust, Jeff (March 8, 2022). "SpaceX worked for weeks to begin Starlink service in Ukraine". SpaceNews. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  24. ^ "Як живе звільнений від окупантів Куп'янськ: фоторепортаж". РБК-Украина (in Ukrainian). Retrieved September 11, 2023.
  25. ^ Jin, Hyunjoo (February 27, 2022). "Musk says Starlink active in Ukraine as Russian invasion disrupts internet". Reuters. Retrieved September 12, 2023.
  26. ^ Antoniuk, Daryna (September 3, 2022). "How Elon Musk's Starlink satellite internet keeps Ukraine online". Kyiv Independent. Retrieved September 4, 2022.
  27. ^ a b c d Kim, Victoria (September 8, 2023). "Elon Musk Acknowledges Withholding Satellite Service to Thwart Ukrainian Attack". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  28. ^ "How Elon Musk's Starlink satellite internet keeps Ukraine online". The Kyiv Independent. September 3, 2022. Retrieved June 6, 2023.
  29. ^ a b "Втратити вежі й мільярди, отримати Starlink: як мобільні оператори повертають зв'язок". LIGA (in Ukrainian). May 16, 2022. Archived from the original on June 19, 2022. Retrieved July 12, 2022.
  30. ^ a b "Starlink intends to open representative office in Ukraine – Ukrainian minister". Interfax-Ukraine. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  31. ^ a b Schwirtz, Michael (July 24, 2022). "Last Stand at Azovstal: Inside the Siege That Shaped the Ukraine War". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved October 15, 2022.
  32. ^ a b c Landry, Carole (July 25, 2022). "Inside the Azovstal Siege". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved October 15, 2022.
  33. ^ Sheetz, Michael (February 28, 2022). "SpaceX shipment of Starlink satellite-internet dishes arrives in Ukraine, government official says". CNBC. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  34. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z Marquardt, Alex (October 13, 2022). "Exclusive: Musk's SpaceX says it can no longer pay for critical satellite services in Ukraine, asks Pentagon to pick up the tab | CNN Politics". CNN.
  35. ^ "What Does Starlink's Participation in Ukrainian Defense Reveal About U.S. Space Policy?". Default. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  36. ^ "36 окрема бригада морської піхоти імені контрадмірала Михайла Білинського on Facebook". www.facebook.com. Retrieved September 11, 2023.
  37. ^ Parker, Charlie. "Specialist Ukrainian drone unit picks off invading Russian forces as they sleep". The Times. ISSN 0140-0460. Archived from the original on May 9, 2022. Retrieved July 12, 2022.
  38. ^ "Krieg in der Ukraine: Die Erfolgsgeschichte der ukrainischen Artillerie". YouTube.
  39. ^ a b c d e f Srivastava, Mehul; Miller, Christopher; Olearchyk, Roman; Schwartz, Felicia (October 7, 2022). "Ukrainian forces report Starlink outages during push against Russia". Financial Times. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  40. ^ a b c d "Михайло Федоров: Зараз на кіберфронті у війні з Росією перевага на нашому боці". РБК-Украина (in Ukrainian). Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  41. ^ "How much do Starlink plans cost, and are they worth it?". Android Authority. June 14, 2023. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  42. ^ "Starlink Internet Review 2023: Plans, Pricing, and Speeds". SatelliteInternet.com. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  43. ^ a b c d "U.S. quietly paying millions to send Starlink terminals to Ukraine, contrary to SpaceX claims". The Washington Post. April 8, 2022. Archived from the original on April 10, 2022.
  44. ^ a b c "Elon Musk: SpaceX Has Spent $80M to Support Ukraine with Starlink".
  45. ^ Office of Press Relations (April 5, 2022). "USAID SAFEGUARDS INTERNET ACCESS IN UKRAINE THROUGH PUBLIC-PRIVATE-PARTNERSHIP WITH SPACEX". USAID. US Government. Archived from the original on April 5, 2022. Retrieved October 4, 2022. SpaceX donated 3,667 terminals and the internet service itself, and USAID purchased the additional 1,333 terminals
  46. ^ "The Pentagon will pay for SpaceX's Starlink in Ukraine months after Elon Musk complained and asked it to pick up the bill". Business Insider. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  47. ^ "Musk says SpaceX can no longer fund internet service Ukrainian military uses in war". PBS NewsHour. October 14, 2022. Retrieved June 6, 2023.
  48. ^ Metz, Cade; Vinograd, Cassandra; Cooper, Helene (October 14, 2022). "Elon Musk says SpaceX can't fund internet service in Ukraine 'indefinitely,' stirring controversy". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved October 15, 2022.
  49. ^ a b Metz, Cade (October 15, 2022). "Elon Musk Drops Threat to Halt Internet Service in Ukraine". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved October 15, 2022.
  50. ^ a b "Sabrina Singh, Deputy Pentagon Press Secretary, Holds a Press Briefing". U.S. Department of Defense. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  51. ^ "What Is the Defense Production Act?". Council on Foreign Relations. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  52. ^ a b Thorbecke, Catherine (October 3, 2022). "'F--- off,' ambassador tells Elon Musk after unveiling Ukraine 'peace' plan | CNN Business". CNN. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  53. ^ a b c d Kay, Grace. "SpaceX president was reportedly upset that Elon Musk kept financing Starlink in Ukraine before Pentagon deal: 'Elon succumbed to the bullshit on Twitter'". Business Insider. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  54. ^ "Elon Musk says he denied Ukraine satellite request to avoid complicity in "major act of war" vs. Russia - CBS News". www.cbsnews.com. September 8, 2023. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  55. ^ a b c d Erwin, Sandra (January 19, 2023). "With Starshield, SpaceX readies for battle". SpaceNews. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  56. ^ a b "SpaceX - Starshield". www.spacex.com. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  57. ^ Satariano, Adam; Reinhard, Scott; Metz, Cade; Frenkel, Sheera; Khurana, Malika (July 28, 2023). "Elon Musk's Unmatched Power in the Stars". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved September 12, 2023.
  58. ^ a b c "Starlink Coverage Map". Starlink. Retrieved September 11, 2023.
  59. ^ a b "Ukraine war: Elon Musk's SpaceX firm bars Kyiv from using Starlink tech for drone control". BBC News. February 9, 2023. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  60. ^ "Sabrina Singh, Deputy Pentagon Press Secretary, Holds a Press Briefing". U.S. Department of Defense. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  61. ^ "Starlink Terms of Service". Starlink. p. 8. Compliance. Archived from the original on September 9, 2023. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  62. ^ a b Staff, A. O. L. "SpaceX limits Starlink use in Ukraine, company president says". www.aol.com. Retrieved February 10, 2023.
  63. ^ Sutton, HI (February 15, 2023). "Starlink Limits Ukraine's Maritime Drones At Time Of New Russian Threat". Naval News. Retrieved February 15, 2023.
  64. ^ "Starlink". Starlink. Retrieved September 11, 2023.
  65. ^ a b Gault, Matthew (September 26, 2022). "Mysterious Sea Drone Surfaces in Crimea". Vice. Retrieved September 10, 2023.
  66. ^ Ozberk, Tayfun (August 23, 2023). "Ukraine's new underwater drone Marichka breaks cover". Naval News. Retrieved September 12, 2023.
  67. ^ a b c d Applebaum, Anne (September 11, 2023). "What Russia Got by Scaring Elon Musk". The Atlantic. Retrieved September 12, 2023.
  68. ^ a b c Darcy, Oliver (September 12, 2023). "An explosive Elon Musk biography is just hitting shelves. But the book's acclaimed author is already walking back a major claim | CNN Business". CNN. Retrieved September 15, 2023.
  69. ^ "Musk says he refused Kyiv request for Starlink use in attack on Russia". Reuters. September 8, 2023. Retrieved September 16, 2023.
  70. ^ Lyngaas, Sean (September 7, 2023). "CNN Exclusive: 'How am I in this war?': New Musk biography offers fresh details about the billionaire's Ukraine dilemma | CNN Politics". CNN. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  71. ^ a b "Elon Musk spoke with Vladimir Putin directly, Pentagon official says". The Independent. August 22, 2023. Retrieved September 12, 2023.
  72. ^ "RUSSIAN OFFENSIVE CAMPAIGN ASSESSMENT, OCTOBER 15". The Institute for the Study of War. October 15, 2022. Retrieved November 29, 2022.
  73. ^ a b Lyngaas, Sean (August 31, 2023). "Russian military hackers take aim at Ukrainian soldiers' battle plans, US and allies say | CNN Politics". CNN. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  74. ^ a b "Opinion | 'How am I in this war?': The untold story of Elon Musk's support for Ukraine". Washington Post. September 7, 2023. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  75. ^ "Elon Musk denies he spoke to Putin about Ukraine war". BBC News. October 12, 2022. Retrieved September 12, 2023.
  76. ^ "Putin hails Elon Musk as an 'outstanding person' and businessman". Reuters. September 12, 2023. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  77. ^ Capoot, Ashley (September 9, 2023). "Elon Musk biographer moves to 'clarify' details about Ukraine and Starlink after backlash". CNBC. Retrieved September 14, 2023.
  78. ^ "Dem Congressman says he'll "dig into" Musk's role in Ukraine war". MSNBC.com. Retrieved September 11, 2023.
  79. ^ Macias, Amanda (September 12, 2023). "Elizabeth Warren calls for an investigation into Musk and Starlink in Ukraine after biography claim". CNBC. Retrieved September 12, 2023.
  80. ^ ft.com
  81. ^ Shan, Lee Ying. "Taiwan slams Elon Musk, says it's 'not for sale' nor part of China". cnbc.com. CNBC. Retrieved September 16, 2023.
  82. ^ Davidson, Helen. "Taiwan tells Elon Musk it is 'not for sale' after latest China comments". theguardian.com. The Guardian. Retrieved September 16, 2023.
  83. ^ "В Україні запрацював супутниковий інтернет від Ілона Маска – Starlink. Яка швидкість та чи становить це небезпеку — Forbes.ua". forbes.ua (in Ukrainian). March 2, 2022. Retrieved September 9, 2023.
  84. ^ "U.S. Sends 5,000 SpaceX Starlink Internet Terminals to Ukraine". Bloomberg. April 6, 2022. Retrieved April 8, 2022.
  85. ^ Zaxid.net (June 12, 2022). "Ілон Маск передав партію Starlink для українських розвідників". ZAXID.NET (in Ukrainian). Archived from the original on July 11, 2022. Retrieved July 12, 2022.
  86. ^ "Elon Musk's Starlink is keeping Ukrainians online when traditional Internet fails". Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Archived from the original on June 4, 2022. Retrieved July 12, 2022.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Starlink_in_the_Russo-Ukrainian_War&oldid=1175663430"