Chewing gum sales ban in Singapore

Chewing gum has generally not been available for sale in Singapore since 1992. Contrary to a common misconception, it is not the consumption of chewing gum that is illegal in Singapore, but rather its importation and sale. It is also permitted for a traveller, whether returning local or tourist, to bring in a small amount of chewing gum for their own personal consumption, although there is a fine for spitting the gum out in an inappropriate public place.

The ban was first enacted under the premiership of Goh Chok Tong. Reasons for the ban included stopping the placement of used chewing gum in inappropriate and costly places, such as the sensors of Mass Rapid Transit (MRT) train doors, inside lock cylinders, and on lift buttons. The ban was relaxed in 2004 when an exception was made for therapeutic, dental, and nicotine chewing gums, which can be bought from a doctor or registered pharmacist.

Origins

Lee Kuan Yew

In his memoirs, Lee Kuan Yew said that in 1983, when he was Prime Minister of Singapore, a proposal for the ban was brought to him by Teh Cheang Wan, then Minister for National Development. Chewing gum was causing maintenance problems in high-rise public-housing apartments, with vandals disposing of spent gum in mailboxes, inside keyholes, and on lift buttons. Chewing gum left on the ground, stairways, and pavements in public areas increased the cost of cleaning and damaged cleaning equipment. Gum stuck on the seats of public buses was also a problem. However, Lee thought that a ban would be "too drastic".

Mass Rapid Transit (MRT) and implementation

In 1987, the $5 billion local railway system, the Mass Rapid Transit (MRT), started operating. It was then the largest public project ever implemented in Singapore.

It was reported that vandals had been sticking chewing gum on the door sensors of MRT trains, preventing the doors from functioning properly and causing disruption to train services. Such incidents were rare but costly, and the culprits were difficult to apprehend. In January 1992, Goh Chok Tong, who had just taken over as Prime Minister, decided on a ban. The restriction on the distribution of chewing gum was enacted in Singapore Statute Chapter 57, the Control of Manufacture Act, which also governs the restriction of certain alcohol and tobacco products.

Results

After the ban was announced, the importation of chewing gum was immediately halted. After a transition period allowing shops to clear existing stock, the sale of chewing gum was completely banned, the penalties being fines of up to S$2,000 for those convicted of selling chewing gum as well as fines and/or jail terms for importers. Extant stocks of gum were confiscated.

When first introduced, the ban caused much controversy and some open defiance. Some people decided to travel to neighbouring countries to buy chewing gum. But no black market for chewing gum in Singapore ever emerged, though some Singaporeans occasionally still manage to bring in some chewing gum from neighbouring countries for their own consumption. After the ban, town councils reported a substantial decrease in chewing-gum litter in public spaces, and chewing gum no longer jammed lift doors or disrupted MRT systems.

The ban has since been partially lifted, as some types of gum are allowable, such as gum chewed for dental health. However, the government refuses to completely lift the ban due to the risk of gum littering again.

International attention

In the mid 1990s, Singapore's laws began to receive international press coverage. US media paid great attention to the case of Michael P. Fay, an American teenager sentenced in 1994 to caning in Singapore for vandalism (using spray paint, not chewing gum). They also drew attention to some of Singapore's other laws, including the "mandatory flushing of public toilets" rule. Confused reporting about these issues led to the myth that the use or importation of chewing gum was itself punishable with caning. In fact, the only penalties provided under Chapter 57 are fines and imprisonment, rarely enforced in practice.

When a BBC reporter suggested that such laws would stifle the people's creativity, Lee Kuan Yew said: "If you can't think because you can't chew, try a banana."

Revision

U.S. President George W. Bush and Singapore Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong sign a free trade agreement in the White House, 6 May 2003. White House photo by Tina Hager.

In 1999, United States President Bill Clinton and Singapore Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong agreed to initiate talks between the two countries for a bilateral free-trade agreement (USS-FTA). The talks later continued under the administration of President George W. Bush.

The Chicago-based Wm. Wrigley Jr. Company enlisted the help of a Washington, D.C. lobbyist and of Illinois Congressman Phil Crane, then-chairman of the United States House Ways and Means Subcommittee on Trade, to get chewing gum on the agenda of the United States-Singapore Free Trade Agreement. This caused a dilemma for the Singapore Government. It recognised the health benefits of certain gums, such as a brand of sugar-free gum that contains calcium lactate to strengthen tooth enamel. Sale of this newly categorised medicinal gum was allowed, provided it was sold by a dentist or pharmacist, who must keep a record of the names of buyers.

Further reading

1. Ho Khai Leong (2003) Shared Responsibilities, Unshared Power: The Politics of Policy-Making in Singapore, ISBN 981-210-218-3.