Neue Marx-Lektüre: Difference between revisions
mNo edit summary |
mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
{{More citations needed|date=July 2023}} |
{{More citations needed|date=July 2023}} |
||
{{Use British English Oxford spelling|date=January 2020}} |
{{Use British English Oxford spelling|date=January 2020}} |
||
{{Marxism|common |
{{Marxism|common variants}} |
||
'''{{lang|de|Neue Marx-Lektüre}}''' (German for "New Reading of Marx") or '''NML''' is a revival and interpretation of [[Karl Marx]]'s [[critique of political economy]], which originated during the mid-[[1960s]] in both [[Western Bloc|Western]] and [[Eastern Bloc|Eastern Europe]] and opposed both [[Marxist–Leninist]] and [[social democratic]] interpretations of Marx. {{Lang|de|Neue Marx-Lektüre}} covers a loose group of authors primarily from [[German-speaking countries]] who reject certain historicizing and empiricist interpretations of Marx's analysis of economic forms{{What|date=December 2022}}, many of which are argued to spring from [[Friedrich Engels]] role in the early Marxist workers' movement. |
'''{{lang|de|Neue Marx-Lektüre}}''' (German for "New Reading of Marx") or '''NML''' is a revival and interpretation of [[Karl Marx]]'s [[critique of political economy]], which originated during the mid-[[1960s]] in both [[Western Bloc|Western]] and [[Eastern Bloc|Eastern Europe]] and opposed both [[Marxist–Leninist]] and [[social democratic]] interpretations of Marx. {{Lang|de|Neue Marx-Lektüre}} covers a loose group of authors primarily from [[German-speaking countries]] who reject certain historicizing and empiricist interpretations of Marx's analysis of economic forms{{What|date=December 2022}}, many of which are argued to spring from [[Friedrich Engels]] role in the early Marxist workers' movement. |
||
Revision as of 11:02, 7 December 2023
 | This article provides insufficient context for those unfamiliar with the subject. (December 2022) |
 | This article needs additional citations for verification. (July 2023) |
| Part of a series on |
| Marxism |
|---|
 |
Neue Marx-Lektüre (German for "New Reading of Marx") or NML is a revival and interpretation of Karl Marx's critique of political economy, which originated during the mid-1960s in both Western and Eastern Europe and opposed both Marxist–Leninist and social democratic interpretations of Marx. Neue Marx-Lektüre covers a loose group of authors primarily from German-speaking countries who reject certain historicizing and empiricist interpretations of Marx's analysis of economic forms[clarification needed], many of which are argued to spring from Friedrich Engels role in the early Marxist workers' movement.
Overview
Neue Marx-Lektüre includes a loose group of authors mainly in German-speaking countries, who revise the historicising and empiricist interpretation of Marx's analysis of economic forms, which goes back to the work of Friedrich Engels.[1] The term has been used since around 1997 and comes from work by Hans-Georg Backhaus.[2] Other names for this inner-Marxist trend include Neomarxismus (Neo-Marxism), kritischer Marxismus (Critical Marxism), Kapitallogik (Capital Logic), Hegelmarxismus (Hegel Marxism) or Marxismus als Sozialwissenschaft (Marxism as a Social Science).[3]
The school of thought is influenced especially the work of the early Soviet thinkers Evgeny Pashukanis and Isaak Illich Rubin, as well as the critical theory of Theodor Adorno. Ingo Elbe traces the origins of the school of thought to the 1960s,[1] with the works of Helmut Reichelt and Hans-Georg Backhaus in the 1970s and 1980s, and the writings of Michael Heinrich in the 1990s being of high importance, and consequently produced at the turn of the millennium a partly academic, partly off-academic debate concerning the question of value.[1] These authors depart in a number of respects from the traditional reading of Marx related to the workers' movement, the bourgeois state and state socialism.
The Neue Marx-Lektüre rejects
- Pre-monetary theories of value, which "share the idea of an initial stage of generalized exchange without money, and have in common a historical reading of the form of value."[4] NML claims instead that "Marx wanted to show that it was not possible to construct a non-contradictory concept of a pre-monetary market economy organized on the basis of the division of labour. The concept of a pre-monetary commodity cannot be thought."[4]
- Conceptions of the state as a manipulative instrument of a ruling class. Instead, the Staatsableitungsdebatte (state derivation debate) has an understanding of the state as a structurally necessary, but relatively separated part of capitalism.[5]
- Determinist theories of history which lead to the anticipation of a revolution to be accomplished by the proletariat. In opposition to this idea, capital is considered as an "automatic subject", which exists in a sham as well in a real form.
Thus, the authors of the Neue Marx-Lektüre contrast themselves from the dominant neoclassical school of economics and maintain the relevance of Marx's approach. In particular, they insist that the microeconomic approaches of the neoclassic theory of economy can't explain the constitution, maintenance and dynamics of the economic value-relations, and can only exhibit insufficient theoretical means when it comes to macro-economic constructs such as e.g. the gross national income. They claim that Marx, although unable to answer these questions, nevertheless provides a higher degree of reflection and awareness of the problems, which has to be recovered in a critical manner for the contemporary discussion.
See also
References
- ^ a b c Anders, Johann Friedrich (September 2017). "Die Neue Marx-Lektüre – Anspruch und Wirklichkeit" [The new Marx reading - claim and reality]. Z. Zeitschrift Marxistische Erneuerung (in German) (111). Retrieved 22 July 2023.
- ^ Backhaus, Hans-Georg (1997). Dialektik der Wertform [Dialectics of Value] (in German). Freiburg. p. 9.
{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) - ^ Elbe, Ingo [in German] (2008). Marx im Westen [Marx in the West] (in German). Berlin. p. 13.
{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) - ^ a b Bellofiore, Riccardo; Riva, Tommaso Redolfi (2015). "The Neue Marx-Lektüre: Putting the critique of political economy back into the critique of society". Radical Philosophy (189). ISSN 0300-211X.
- ^ Elbe, Ingo [in German]. "Between Marx, Marxism and Marxisms. Ways of Reading Marx's Theory" (PDF).
Bibliography
- Helmut Reichelt, Zur logischen Struktur des Kapitalbegriffs bei Karl Marx [On the logical structure of the concept of capital according to Marx]. Dissertation of 10 July 1968, Faculty of Economics and Social Science, Universität Frankfurt am Main, 1968, p. 265; fourth revised edition, with a preface by Iring Fetscher, Frankfurt am Main: Europäische Verlagsanstalt, 1973 (Politische Ökonomie); Freiburg im Breisgau: Ça Ira, 2001, ISBN 3-924627-76-2.
- Heinrich, Michael (2012). An Introduction to the Three Volumes of Karl Marx's Capital. Translated by Locascio, Alexander. New York: Monthly Review Press. p. 240. ISBN 978-1-58367-291-4. OCLC 812923956.; Die Wissenschaft vom Wert [The economics of value] (dissertation) VSA-Verlag, 1991; second, revised edition: Westfälisches Dampfboot, 2003
- Hans-Georg Backhaus: Dialektik der Wertform. Untersuchungen zur Marxschen Ökonomiekritik [Dialectic of value: investigations of Marxist economic criticism], Freiburg im Breisgau 1997, ISBN 3-924627-52-5.
- Helmut Reichelt, Neue Marx-Lektüre. Zur Kritik sozialwissenschaftlicher Logik [New reading of Marx: On critique of social-scientific logic], Hamburg 2008, ISBN 978-3-89965-287-1.
Further reading
English
- Bidet, Jacques (2008). "New Interpretations of Capital". In Bidet, Jacques; Kouvelakis, Stathis (eds.). Critical Companion to Contemporary Marxism. Historical materialism book series 16. BRILL. pp. 369–384. ISBN 978-90-04-14598-6., ISBN 978-90-04-14598-6
- Sotiropoulos, Dimitris P., Milios J. Political economy of contemporary capitalism and its crisis: demystifying finance. Routledge, 2015. ISBN 9781138901117
- Heinrich, Michael, and Alexander Locascio. An Introduction to the Three Volumes of Karl Marx's Capital. Monthly Review P, 2012. ISBN 9781583672884
German
- Ingo Elbe: Marx im Westen. Die neue Marx-Lektüre in der Bundesrepublik seit 1965, Berlin 2008, ISBN 978-3-05-004470-5
- sample, table of contents and introduction (33 pages pdf)
- Hendrik Wallat: Theoriegeschichte der neuen Marx-Lektüre, review of Marx im Westen (10 pages pdf)
- Michael Heinrich: Wie das Marxsche Kapital lesen?, Schmetterling Verlag, 1st edition 2008
- Michael Heinrich: "Die Wissenschaft vom Wert: Die Marxsche Kritik der politischen Ökonomie zwischen wissenschaftlicher Revolution und klassischer Tradition" ISBN 978-3896914545
- Michael Heinrich:Kritik der politischen Ökonomie - Eine Einführung, Schmetterling Verlag, 3rd edition 2005
- Hanno Pahl: Das Geld in der modernen Wirtschaft. Marx und Luhmann im Vergleich, Frankfurt 2008, ISBN 978-3-593-38607-2
- Jan Hoff, Alexis Petrioli, Ingo Stützle, Frieder Otto Wolf (Hrsg.): Das Kapital neu lesen. Beiträge zur radikalen Philosophie, Westfälisches Dampfboot, Münster 2006, ISBN 3-89691-605-X, ISBN 978-3-89691-605-1
- sample with table of contents, introduction and epilog (34 pages pdf)
- Wolfgang Fritz Haug: Die »Neue Kapital-Lektüre« der monetären Werttheorie, review of Das Kapital neu Lesen (15 pages pdf)
- Lars Meyer: Absoluter Wert und allgemeiner Wille. Zur Selbstbegründung dialektischer Gesellschaftstheorie, Bielefeld 2005, ISBN 978-3-89942-224-5.
- Joachim Hirsch:Der Staat der Bürgerlichen Gesellschaft: Zum Staatsverständnis von Karl Marx, Frankfurt 2008, ISBN 978-3-832-93226-8
- Christine Kirchhoff, Hanno Pahl, Christoph Engemann, Judith Heckel, Lars Meyer (Hg.): Gesellschaft als Verkehrung. Perspektiven einer neuen Marx-Lektüre. Festschrift für Helmut Reichelt, Freiburg 2004, ISBN 3-924627-26-6.
- Jan Hoff: Kritik der klassischen politischen Ökonomie. Zur Rezeption der werttheoretischen Ansätze ökonomischer Klassiker durch Karl Marx, Cologne 2004, ISBN 3-89438-314-3.
- Dieter Wolf: Kritische Theorie und Kritik der politischen Ökonomie. Eine kritische Auseinandersetzung mit Schriften von Hans-Georg Backhaus und Helmut Reichelt. In: Dieter Wolf, Heinz Paragenings: Zur Konfusion des Wertbegriffs. Beiträge zur „Kapital“-Diskussion, Argument Verlag, Hamburg 2004, ISBN 978-3-88619-651-7 (Berliner Verein zur Förderung der MEGA-Edition e.V., Wissenschaftliche Mitteilungen Heft 3)
- Dieter Wolf: Zur Methode in Marx’ „Kapital“ unter besonderer Berücksichtigung ihres logisch-systematischen Charakters. Zum Methodenstreit zwischen Wolfgang Fritz Haug und Michael Heinrich. In: Ingo Elbe, Tobias Reichardt, Dieter Wolf: Gesellschaftliche Praxis und ihre wissenschaftliche Darstellung. Beiträge zur Kapital-Diskussion. Wissenschaftliche Mitteilungen. Heft 6. Argument Verlag, Hamburg, 2008. ISBN 978-3-88619-655-5 Hrsg.: Carl-Erich Vollgraf, Richard Sperl & Rolf Hecker.
External links
- Ingo Elbe: Zwischen Marx, Marxismus und Marxismen – Lesarten der Marxschen Theorie (pdf)
- GegenStandpunkt: Wie man „Das Kapital“ nicht schon wieder neu lesen sollte. Zur „Einführung in die Kritik der politischen Ökonomie“ von Michael Heinrich (pdf), GegenStandpunkt – Politische Vierteljahreszeits chrift 2/2008.
- Dieter Wolf:Die Wertform und die dialektische Methode. Zur Deutung der Dialektik der Wertform durch Hans-Georg Backhaus In: Der dialektische Widerspruch im Kapital" Ein Beitrag zur Marxschen Werttheorie. Hamburg, 2002, ISBN 3-87975-889-1, S. 151ff.