Jump to content

Mr. Popo: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
→Controversy and reception: Fixed false information on the basis of the character being blackface even though he was created based on the description of the middle eastern Djinn
Tags: Reverted Mobile edit Mobile web edit
m Reverted edits by 2600:1700:135D:5090:5D12:6857:C36E:B1BC (talk): please use the talk page (WP:TPHELP) or be bold and fix the problem (HG) (3.4.12)
Line 34: Line 34:
In a retrospective discussion about the character, Ramsey Isler from [[IGN]] suggested that it is easy to label Mr. Popo as a racist caricature if the character is described simply as "the black-skinned, red-lipped, turban-wearing servant of Kami". On one hand, he questioned the likelihood of whether Toriyama intentionally made a racist joke through Mr. Popo, acknowledging an argument from some quarters that Mr. Popo's appearance may have been "a little artistic license for an imaginary character", on the basis that "Japanese animation has a history of exaggerating non-Japanese characters because the Japanese population is not very diverse" and that Japanese society "does not have the kinds of racial sensitivities that the Western world has".<ref name="IGNPopo" /> On the other hand, he also raised questions as to whether a controversial topic which is not intended to be offensive make it any less so, as well as whether explanations like "it's only a joke" or "they don't know any better" absolve wrongful conduct.<ref name="IGNPopo" /> Jack Gardner from ''[[Screen Rant]]'' assessed Mr. Popo as a relic of blackface portrayal which persisted in the manga and animation industries of Japan and the wider Asian world, long after it became a taboo subject in North America following the aftermath of the [[Civil Rights Movement]]. While Gardner acknowledged the subsequent and substantial changes to the highly divisive character, he found it shocking that Mr. Popo would even appear unaltered in an internationally popular syndicated television show in the 1990s.
In a retrospective discussion about the character, Ramsey Isler from [[IGN]] suggested that it is easy to label Mr. Popo as a racist caricature if the character is described simply as "the black-skinned, red-lipped, turban-wearing servant of Kami". On one hand, he questioned the likelihood of whether Toriyama intentionally made a racist joke through Mr. Popo, acknowledging an argument from some quarters that Mr. Popo's appearance may have been "a little artistic license for an imaginary character", on the basis that "Japanese animation has a history of exaggerating non-Japanese characters because the Japanese population is not very diverse" and that Japanese society "does not have the kinds of racial sensitivities that the Western world has".<ref name="IGNPopo" /> On the other hand, he also raised questions as to whether a controversial topic which is not intended to be offensive make it any less so, as well as whether explanations like "it's only a joke" or "they don't know any better" absolve wrongful conduct.<ref name="IGNPopo" /> Jack Gardner from ''[[Screen Rant]]'' assessed Mr. Popo as a relic of blackface portrayal which persisted in the manga and animation industries of Japan and the wider Asian world, long after it became a taboo subject in North America following the aftermath of the [[Civil Rights Movement]]. While Gardner acknowledged the subsequent and substantial changes to the highly divisive character, he found it shocking that Mr. Popo would even appear unaltered in an internationally popular syndicated television show in the 1990s.


Regarding the alteration of Mr. Popo's skin colour in some media depictions, Jemima Sebastian from IGN noted that the change was made for reasons that could never be fully explained, but that many fans would connect it to perceptions of racism.<ref name="Blue" /> Cecilia D'Anastasio from ''[[Kotaku]]'' observed that while there is awareness that the character was not intended to be African-American or inspired by any people with African descents or origins, Mr. Popo's appearance still evokes the image of a "dark-skinned slave with puffy red lips" and the decision to recolour him for American television is indicative of his potentially offensive reception. Which is actually a false statement, Mr Popo was based on the black skinned depiction of the mystical beings known as the Djinn which have been present in the middle east for thousands of years and later became known as the genie <ref name="Cosplayers">{{cite web|last=D'Anastasio|first=Cecilia|title=Black Cosplayers Talk About Self-Doubt|website=Kotaku|date=August 16, 2018|url=https://kotaku.com/black-cosplayers-talk-about-self-doubt-1785451928|access-date=January 29, 2021|archive-date=February 3, 2021|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20210203171345/https://kotaku.com/black-cosplayers-talk-about-self-doubt-1785451928|url-status=live}}</ref>
Regarding the alteration of Mr. Popo's skin colour in some media depictions, Jemima Sebastian from IGN noted that the change was made for reasons that could never be fully explained, but that many fans would connect it to perceptions of racism.<ref name="Blue" /> Cecilia D'Anastasio from ''[[Kotaku]]'' observed that while there is awareness that the character was not intended to be African-American or inspired by any people with African descents or origins, Mr. Popo's appearance still evokes the image of a "dark-skinned slave with puffy red lips" and the decision to recolour him for American television is indicative of his potentially offensive reception.<ref name="Cosplayers">{{cite web|last=D'Anastasio|first=Cecilia|title=Black Cosplayers Talk About Self-Doubt|website=Kotaku|date=August 16, 2018|url=https://kotaku.com/black-cosplayers-talk-about-self-doubt-1785451928|access-date=January 29, 2021|archive-date=February 3, 2021|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20210203171345/https://kotaku.com/black-cosplayers-talk-about-self-doubt-1785451928|url-status=live}}</ref>


== See also ==
== See also ==

Revision as of 23:31, 18 December 2023

Mr. Popo
Dragon Ball character
First appearanceDragon Ball chapter #163: "The Sanctuary of Kami-sama" (Weekly Shōnen Jump 1988)
Created byAkira Toriyama
Voiced by

Mr. Popo (ミスター・ポポ, Misutā Popo) is a fictional character from the Dragon Ball manga series created by Akira Toriyama. Within the series, he is a genie who serves as the assistant to Earth's guardian deity and the caretaker of their residence, which is located high above the sky. He first appears in the one hundred sixty-third chapter of the Dragon Ball manga, published in 1988. In the Japanese anime adaptations, his seiyū was Toku Nishio, before Kawazu Yasuhiko took over the role for Dragon Ball Kai. For English language media, he was voiced by Christopher Cason in 1999 and from 2010 on. The character was also voiced by Chris Sabat from 2000 up until 2005.

Mr. Popo's design and humanoid appearance has been criticized as an offensive racist stereotype by some commentators, such as children's book author Carole Boston Weatherford. As a result of the controversy, Mr. Popo's appearance had been modified in some media depictions of the character: his lips are downsized digitally in the American release of the Dragon Ball manga by Viz Media, and his skin is recoloured blue from his original black colour in the CW4Kids TV broadcast of Dragon Ball Kai.

Development

Mr. Popo was initially envisioned by series creator Akira Toriyama as a reptilian humanoid with a chicken-like beak that had several variant designs, including one sketch with curly hair, though all of which were ultimately discarded.[1] Later concept art by Toriyama depict him as a slender man dressed in a manner reminiscent of Namu, an Indian yogi-inspired character who fights series protagonist Goku in a martial arts tournament early in the series.[1] Toriyama ultimately settled on the current design, a portly humanoid with bright facial expressions whose clothing resembles Jinns, supernatural beings from Arabian mythology and Islamic theology.[1] The early concept art sketches of Mr. Popo are included in the 30th Anniversary Dragon Ball Super History Book published in 2016.[2]

According to Toriyama, Mr. Popo has served as an assistant to successive generations of gods who preside over Earth in the Dragon Ball universe, suggesting that he existed long before the "Nameless Namekian" arrived on Earth and subsequently serve as the world's guardian deity.[3] Besides being a skilled practitioner of martial arts, Toriyama noted that Mr. Popo is also responsible for crafting the physical appearance of the wish-granting dragon Shenron, originally created by the Namekian Kami" and summoned from Earth's seven Dragon Balls, as it is derived from a figurine modeled by Mr. Popo.[3]

The North American English releases of the manga series by Viz Media, which saw its first publication in March 2003, reduced the size of Mr. Popo's lips by shading them in completely.[4][5] In 2009, the CW4Kids airing of Dragon Ball Z Kai recoloured Mr. Popo's black skin to be blue and his lips orange-yellow in hue.[6][7]

Voice acting

Mr. Popo is voiced by Toku Nishio in the original series and Yasuhiko Kawazu in Kai. Prior to Kawazu, Dai Matsumoto voiced him in Budokai 3 and Budokai Tenkaichi. In English, he was voiced by Alvin Sanders in the Ocean dub, and by Chris Cason and Christopher Sabat in the Funimation dubs. Cason's lines as Popo in the original airings of Dragon Ball Z were dubbed over by Sabat by the time the remastered DVDs were released, only for Cason to take over again as Mr. Popo in Kai. Other English voice actors include Doug Rand, who voiced Mr. Popo in the AB Groupe dub of the sixth DBZ film; Apollo Abraham, who was heard in the obscure Philippine dub of said film by Creative Products Corp.; and David Alan Pettitt, who lent his voice in the Blue Water dubs of Dragon Ball and Dragon Ball GT. Sabat in particular is fond of the character, and was hopeful that the character would eventually be added into the roster of the popular fighting game Dragon Ball FighterZ as part of future downloadable content.[8]

Appearances

A supporting character who has few overall appearances within the series, Mr. Popo's duties consist of looking after Kami, tending to his residence, and reconstructing Shenron if the dragon's physical form is destroyed. He also tends to an ancient butterfly garden that he cultivated thousands of years prior to the events of the series. In Dragon Ball, Popo is far stronger than Son Goku when he first arrives at Kami's Palace. He trains Goku for three years until the boy learns everything he knows. Some of the techniques Goku developed under the tutelage of Mr. Popo include the Chou Kamehameha, a more lethal version of his signature attack. In Dragon Ball Z, he helps Bulma, Krillin, and Gohan by divulging the location of Kami's old starship to facilitate their journey to Planet Namek. He then serves Dende as his attendant upon the latter's ascension as Earth's new guardian deity later in the narrative.

Mr. Popo has demonstrated the ability to magically create objects from seemingly out of thin air, for example a flying carpet which he uses as transportation in the anime story arc Garlic Junior Saga, though the character is also depicted as capable of flight or levitation using ki. Unlike series protagonist Goku, Mr. Popo can teleport instantly to a desired location without requiring the use of an energy signature to home in on. In the Dragon Ball Z anime, Mr. Popo has a brief match with Son Goten and Trunks who have transformed into Super Saiyan form where he holds his own, blocking or dodging several hits and even appearing unfazed after being struck by a kick.

Controversy and reception

The Dragon Ball media franchise, particularly the anime adaptation of Dragon Ball Z, has long been popular with black communities around the world, as well as hip hop culture and art movement.[9][10][11] For many African Americans who grew up watching Dragon Ball anime, Mr. Popo is regarded as the only notable example of black representation in the series.[7][12] Nevertheless, by the early 2000s some commentators began referring to Mr. Popo as a derogatory stereotype in the style of blackface, a controversial form of makeup historically associated with stage and film caricatures of African Americans, or a representation of the antiquated racial term sambo.[4] In her article written for The Christian Science Monitor in May 2000, Weatherford alleged that Mr. Popo represents a depiction of individuals with African heritage from a white supremacist perspective, and that characters like him are known to a far-reaching audience of children through cartoons and product tie-ins. She suggested that such stereotypical characters could adversely affect the malleable self-image of black children, and noted to her bemusement that "racist stereotypes that would shock Americans don't raise an eyebrow in much of Asia".[13] In 2001, the Jim Crow Museum of Racist Memorabilia at Ferris State University declared that Mr. Popo is an example of a racist caricature in modern fiction.[14] The Jim Crow Museum later published on their official website a letter written in response to their article from a reader who disagreed with their assertion that characters like Mr. Popo are deliberately anti-black in design.[15]

In a retrospective discussion about the character, Ramsey Isler from IGN suggested that it is easy to label Mr. Popo as a racist caricature if the character is described simply as "the black-skinned, red-lipped, turban-wearing servant of Kami". On one hand, he questioned the likelihood of whether Toriyama intentionally made a racist joke through Mr. Popo, acknowledging an argument from some quarters that Mr. Popo's appearance may have been "a little artistic license for an imaginary character", on the basis that "Japanese animation has a history of exaggerating non-Japanese characters because the Japanese population is not very diverse" and that Japanese society "does not have the kinds of racial sensitivities that the Western world has".[4] On the other hand, he also raised questions as to whether a controversial topic which is not intended to be offensive make it any less so, as well as whether explanations like "it's only a joke" or "they don't know any better" absolve wrongful conduct.[4] Jack Gardner from Screen Rant assessed Mr. Popo as a relic of blackface portrayal which persisted in the manga and animation industries of Japan and the wider Asian world, long after it became a taboo subject in North America following the aftermath of the Civil Rights Movement. While Gardner acknowledged the subsequent and substantial changes to the highly divisive character, he found it shocking that Mr. Popo would even appear unaltered in an internationally popular syndicated television show in the 1990s.

Regarding the alteration of Mr. Popo's skin colour in some media depictions, Jemima Sebastian from IGN noted that the change was made for reasons that could never be fully explained, but that many fans would connect it to perceptions of racism.[6] Cecilia D'Anastasio from Kotaku observed that while there is awareness that the character was not intended to be African-American or inspired by any people with African descents or origins, Mr. Popo's appearance still evokes the image of a "dark-skinned slave with puffy red lips" and the decision to recolour him for American television is indicative of his potentially offensive reception.[12]

See also

  • Jynx, a fictional species of Pokémon also accused of being a racist caricature

References

  1. ^ a b c Olivares, Edgar (July 22, 2020). "Mr. Popo originalmente iba a ser un pollo mutante" [Mr. Popo originally was going to be a mutant chicken]. Código Espagueti (in Spanish). Archived from the original on February 3, 2021. Retrieved January 30, 2021.
  2. ^ Toriyama, Akira (2016). 30th Anniversary ドラゴンボール超史集: SUPER HISTORY BOOK. Bandai Namco Entertainment. ISBN 978-4087925050.
  3. ^ a b Sebastian, Jemima (January 20, 2021). "Dragon Ball: ¿quién fue el creador de la imagen de Shenlong?" [Dragon Ball: who was the creator of the image of Shenlong?]. IGN Latin America (in Spanish). Archived from the original on January 20, 2021. Retrieved January 29, 2021.
  4. ^ a b c d Isler, Ramsey (April 11, 2008). "What's Wrong With Dragon Ball Z Part Two". IGN. Archived from the original on June 20, 2016. Retrieved May 28, 2019.
  5. ^ Gardner, Jack (March 8, 2019). "Dragon Ball Abridged Was Better Than The Anime". Screen Rant. Archived from the original on November 1, 2021. Retrieved January 30, 2021.
  6. ^ a b Sebastian, Jemima (October 5, 2020). "Dragon Ball: Mr. Popo alguna vez tuvo la piel azul y no sólo en el anime" [Dragon Ball: Mr. Popo once had blue skin and not only in the anime]. IGN Latin America (in Spanish). Archived from the original on December 1, 2020. Retrieved January 29, 2021.
  7. ^ a b "What Black Anime Fans Can Teach Us About Race in America". August 5, 2015. Archived from the original on August 8, 2020. Retrieved October 24, 2018.
  8. ^ Dennis, Catrina (February 11, 2018). "Christopher Sabat Wants Mr. Popo in Dragon Ball FighterZ". Comicbook.com. Archived from the original on November 9, 2020. Retrieved October 24, 2018.
  9. ^ Jackson, Gita (November 15, 2017). "Why Black Men Love Dragon Ball Z". Kotaku. Archived from the original on October 30, 2021. Retrieved January 29, 2021.
  10. ^ Gramuglia, Anthony (2017). "Why So Many Hip-Hop Artists Love Dragon Ball". CBR.com. Archived from the original on February 24, 2020. Retrieved January 29, 2021.
  11. ^ Osmond, Andrew (October 2, 2020). "Video on Black Representation in Anime Posted By Guardian Newspaper". Anime News Network. Archived from the original on November 22, 2020. Retrieved January 29, 2021.
  12. ^ a b D'Anastasio, Cecilia (August 16, 2018). "Black Cosplayers Talk About Self-Doubt". Kotaku. Archived from the original on February 3, 2021. Retrieved January 29, 2021.
  13. ^ Weatherford, Carole Boston (May 4, 2000). "Japan's bigoted exports to kids". The Christian Science Monitor. Archived from the original on October 16, 2019. Retrieved May 28, 2019.
  14. ^ Pilgrim, David (January 2001). "New Racist Forms of the 21st Century". ferris.edu. Ferris State University. Archived from the original on May 4, 2009. Retrieved June 28, 2013.
  15. ^ ""Anti-Black Images" in Japanese Animation". ferris.edu. Ferris State University. December 3, 2006. Archived from the original on February 27, 2021. Retrieved January 29, 2021.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=Mr._Popo&oldid=1190622818"