Proto-Dravidian language: Difference between revisions
Tag: Reverted |
mNo edit summary Tag: Reverted |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Short description|Reconstructed common ancestor of the |
{{Short description|Reconstructed common ancestor of the Tamilian languages}} |
||
{{infobox proto-language |
{{infobox proto-language |
||
|name=Proto- |
|name=Proto-Tamilian |
||
|familycolor= |
|familycolor=Tamilian |
||
|target=[[ |
|target=[[Tamilian languages]] |
||
|era=c. 4th–3rd m. BCE |
|era=c. 4th–3rd m. BCE |
||
|region= Eastern Iran, Pakistan, Western India and [[Deccan Plateau]] |
|region= Eastern Iran, Pakistan, Western India and [[Deccan Plateau]] |
||
|child1=[[Proto South- |
|child1=[[Proto South-Tamilian language|Proto South-Tamilian]] |
||
|child2=Proto South-Central- |
|child2=Proto South-Central-Tamilian |
||
|child3=Proto Central- |
|child3=Proto Central-Tamilian |
||
|child4=Proto North- |
|child4=Proto North-Tamilian |
||
}} |
}} |
||
{{Dravidian}} |
{{Dravidian}} |
||
'''Proto- |
'''Proto-Tamilian''' is the [[linguistic reconstruction]] of the common ancestor of the [[Tamilian languages]] native to the [[Indian subcontinent]].{{sfn|Andronov|2003|p=299}} It is thought to have differentiated into Proto-North Tamilian, Proto-Central Dravidian, and [[Proto-South Dravidian]], although the date of diversification is still debated.{{sfn|Krishnamurti|2003|p=492}} |
||
==History== |
==History== |
||
Revision as of 15:12, 6 January 2024
| Proto-Tamilian | |
|---|---|
| Reconstruction of | Tamilian languages |
| Region | Eastern Iran, Pakistan, Western India and Deccan Plateau |
| Era | c. 4th–3rd m. BCE |
| Lower-order reconstructions |
|
| Part of a series on |
| Dravidian culture and history |
|---|
 |
Proto-Tamilian is the linguistic reconstruction of the common ancestor of the Tamilian languages native to the Indian subcontinent.[1] It is thought to have differentiated into Proto-North Tamilian, Proto-Central Dravidian, and Proto-South Dravidian, although the date of diversification is still debated.[2]
History
As a proto-language, Proto-Dravidian is not itself attested in historical records. Its modern conception is based solely on reconstruction. It is suggested that the language was spoken in the 4th millennium BCE, and started evolving into various branches around 3rd-millennium BCE.[3][full citation needed]
The origin and territory of the Proto-Dravidian speakers is uncertain, but some suggestions have been made based on the reconstructed Proto-Dravidian vocabulary. The reconstruction has been done on the basis of cognate words present in the different branches (Northern, Central and Southern) of the Dravidian language family.[4]
According to Fuller (2007), the botanical vocabulary of Proto-Dravidian is characteristic of the dry deciduous forests of central and peninsular India. For the Southern Dravidians, this region extends from Saurashtra and Central India to South India. It thus represents the general area in which the Dravidians were living before the separation of branches.[4]
According to Franklin Southworth (2005),[5] the Proto-Dravidian vocabulary is characteristic of a rural economy based on agriculture, animal husbandry and hunting. However, there are some indications of a society more complex than a rural one:[6]
- Words for an upper storey and beam
- Metallurgy
- Trade
- Payment of dues (possibly taxes or contributions to religious ceremonies)
- Social stratification
This evidence is not sufficient to determine with certainty the territory of the Proto-Dravidians. These characteristics can be accommodated within multiple contemporary cultures, including:[6]
- 2nd and 3rd millennium BCE Neolithic-Chalcolithic cultures of Elam and Mehrgarh and present-day western Rajasthan, Deccan and other parts of the peninsula.
- Early Indus Valley civilisation sites in Pakistan and later ones in the Saurashtra (Sorath) area of present-day Gujarat.
- Asko Parpola identifies Proto-North Dravidians with the Indus Valley civilization (IVC) and the Meluhha people mentioned in Sumerian records, and has suggested that the word "Meluhha" derives from the Dravidian words mel(u)-akam ("highland country, high abode").[7]
- Loan words identified in Sumerian such as the words for ivory and sesame are considered to be derived from Proto-Dravidian and spread from IVC to Mesopotamia due to trade.[8][9]
Phonology
Vowels
Proto-Dravidian contrasted between five short and long vowels: *a, *ā, *i, *ī, *u, *ū, *e, *ē, *o, *ō. The sequences *ai and *au are treated as *ay and *av (or *aw).[10]
Consonants
Proto-Dravidian has been reconstructed as having the following consonant phonemes:[11][12][13]
| Labial | Dental | Alveolar | Retroflex | Palatal | Velar | Glottal | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nasals | *m | *n | (*ṉ)[a] | *ṇ | *ñ | ||
| Plosive | *p | *t | *ṯ | *ṭ | *c | *k | |
| Semivowel | *w | *y | *H | ||||
| Rhotic | *r | *ẓ[b] | |||||
| Lateral | *l | *ḷ |
The singular alveolar plosive *ṯ developed into an alveolar trill /r/ in many of the South and South Central languages, it later merged with the tap in many of them; Tulu has /d͡ʒ, d̪, ɾ/ as reflexes, Manda-Kui made it /d͡ʒ/ and Hill-Maria Gondi made it /ʁ/. *ṯṯ and *nṯ became /r̥, nr/ in Konda and [tr, ndr] in many Tamil dialects apart from them, other didnt rhotacised it, instead either preserving them or merging it with other set of stops like dentals in Kannada, retroflexes in Telugu or palatals in Manda-Kui and some languages of Kerala[14]. Central made all alveolars dental which is one of the features distinguishing it from South Central branch and North made it /r, s/.[13][15] For example, Tamil āṟu, Tulu āji, Naiki sādi, Kui hāja; Tamil puṟṟu, Tulu puñca, Kannada huttu, Naiki puṭṭa, Konda puRi, Malto pute; Tamil onṟu, Tulu oñji, Pengo ronje, Brahui asi.
Velar nasal *ṅ occurred only before *k in Proto-Dravidian (as in many of its daughter languages). Therefore, it is not considered a separate phoneme in Proto-Dravidian. However, it attained phonemic status in languages like Malayalam, Gondi, Konda and Pengo because the original sequence *ṅk was simplified to *ṅ or *ṅṅ.[16]
The glottal fricative *H has been proposed by Krishnamurti (2003) to account for the Old Tamil Aytam (Āytam) and other Dravidian comparative phonological phenomena.
P.S. Subrahmanyam reconstructs 6 nasals for PD compared to 4 by Krishnamurti and also doesn't agree with the laryngeal.[17]
The Northern Dravidian languages Kurukh, Malto and Brahui cannot easily be derived from the traditional Proto-Dravidian phonological system. McAlpin (2003) proposes that they branched off from an earlier stage of Proto-Dravidian than the conventional reconstruction, which would apply only to the other languages. He suggests reconstructing a richer system of dorsal stop consonants:
| Early Proto-Dravidian | Late Proto-Dravidian (Proto-Non-North Dravidian) |
Proto-Kurukh-Malto | Brahui |
|---|---|---|---|
| *c | *c | *c | |
| *kʲ | *c | *k | k |
| *k | *k | *k | k |
| *q | *k | *q | x k / _i(ː) |
Numerals
Vocabulary
Crop plants
Below are some crop plants that have been found in the Southern Neolithic complex of Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh, along with their Proto-Dravidian or Proto-South Dravidian reconstructions by Southworth (2005). In some cases, the proto-form glosses differ from the species identified from archaeological sites. For example, the two Southern Neolithic staple grasses Brachiaria ramosa and Setaria verticillata respectively correspond to the reconstructed Proto-Dravidian forms for Sorghum vulgare and Setaria italica as early Dravidian speakers shifted to millet species that were later introduced to South India.[5]
| Common name | Scientific name | Reconstruction level | Proto-form | Gloss of proto-form |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| horsegram | Macrotyloma uniflorum | Late Proto-Dravidian | *koḷ | horsegram |
| green gram | Vigna radiata | Late Proto-Dravidian | *pac-Vt/Vl | green gram |
| black gram | Vigna cf. mungo; Vigna trilobata | Late Proto-Dravidian | *uẓ-untu, *min(t) | black gram |
| hyacinth bean | Lablab purpureus | Proto-Tamil | *ava-rai | Dolichos lablab |
| pigeonpea | Cajanus cajan | Late Proto-Dravidian | *tu-var | pigeonpea |
| Common name | Scientific name | Reconstruction level | Proto-form | Gloss of proto-form |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| browntop millet | Brachiaria ramosa | Late Proto-Dravidian | *conna-l | sorghum |
| bristly foxtail | Setaria verticillata | Late Proto-Dravidian | *kot-V | Setaria italica |
| sawa millet | Echinochloa cf. colona | |||
| yellow foxtail | Setaria pumila | |||
| little millet | Panicum sumatrense | |||
| kodo millet | Paspalum scrobiculatum | Proto-South Dravidian | *(v)ār/ar-Vk | pearl millet |
| millet | Pennisetum glaucum | Proto-South Dravidian | *kam-pu | bulrush millet |
| finger millet | Eleusine coracana | Proto-South Dravidian | *ira(k) | ragi |
| Common name | Scientific name | Reconstruction level | Proto-form | Gloss of proto-form |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| barley | Hordeum vulgare | |||
| wheat | Triticum | Late Proto-Dravidian? | *kūli | wheat |
| rice | Oryza sp. | Late Proto-Dravidian? | *(v)ar-iñci | rice |
| Common name | Scientific name | Reconstruction level | Proto-form | Gloss of proto-form |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| jujube | Zizyphus sp. | Late Proto-Dravidian | *irak- | jujube |
| fig | Ficus sp. | Late Proto-Dravidian | *cuv- | fig |
| java plum | cf. Syzygium cumini | Late Proto-Dravidian | *ñēr-al | jambu |
| globe cucumber | Cucumis cf. prophetarum | |||
| luffa | cf. Luffa cylindrica | Late Proto-Dravidian | *pīr | |
| flax | Linum usitatissimum | Proto-South Dravidian | *ak-V-ce | |
| cotton | Gossypium sp. | Proto-South Dravidian | *par-utti | |
| okra | Abelmoschus sp. | |||
| parenchyma fragments | Early Proto-Dravidian | *kic-ampu |
| Common name | Scientific name | Reconstruction level | Proto-form | Gloss of proto-form |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| onion/garlic | Allium sp. | Early Proto-Dravidian | *uḷḷi | |
| eggplant | Solanum sp. | Early Proto-Dravidian | *vaẓ-Vt | |
| sesame | Sesamum indicum | Late Proto-Dravidian | *nū(v)- | sesame |
| sugarcane | Saccharum sp. | Early Proto-Dravidian | *cet-Vkk | |
| hemp | Cannabis sp. | Late Proto-Dravidian ? | *boy-Vl |
Basic vocabulary
Basic vocabulary of Proto-Tamil selected from Krishnamurti (2003):[18]
| gloss | Proto-Tamil |
|---|---|
| one | *on-ṯu |
| one (adj.) | *ōr-/*or-V- |
| two | *īr/*ir-V |
| three (adj.) | *muH-/*mū- |
| four (adj.) | *nāl/*nal-V- |
| five (adj.) | *cay-m- |
| six (adj.) | *caṯ-V |
| seven (adj.) | *eẓ-V |
| eight (adj.) | *eṇ |
| nine, 9/10 | *toḷ-/*toṇ- |
| ten minus one | *on-patV |
| ten (adj.) | *paH- |
| head, hair, top | *tal-ay |
| cheek | *kap-Vḷ |
| eye | *kaṇ |
| eyeball | *kuṭ-V/*kuṇṭ-V |
| ear | *kew-i |
| nose, beak | *mū-nk(k)u/-nc- |
| tooth | *pal |
| mouth[a] | *wāy |
| hand, arm | *kay |
| leg, foot | *kāl |
| heart, kidney | *kuṇṭV |
| liver | *taẓ-Vnk-/-nkk |
| milk, breast | *pāl |
| bone | *el-V-mp/-nk |
| bone marrow | *mūḷ-V- |
| excrement | *piy/*pī |
| house | *il |
| husband | *maẓc-a- |
| man, husband | *māy-tt-/*mā-cc- |
| woman | *peṇ |
| name | *pin-cc-Vr |
| sky | *wān-am |
| sun | *en-ṯ- |
| sun | *pōẓ/*poẓ-u-tu |
| moon, moonlight | *nel-a-nc/-ncc |
| month | *nel-V- |
| star | *cukk-V |
| star | *miHn |
| cloud | *muy-il |
| water | *nīr |
| river, stream | *yĀtu |
| lake | *kuḷ-am/-Vnc- |
| sea, ocean | *kaṭ-al |
| stone | *kal |
| wind | *waḷi |
| day | *nāḷ |
| night | *nāḷ/*naḷ-V- |
| year | *yAṇṭ-u |
| tree | *mar-am/-an |
| fruit, pod | *kāy |
| forest | *kā(-n), kā-ṭu |
| grass | *pul |
| thatched grass | *pīr |
| dog | *naH-ay/-att/-kuẓi |
| animal, beast, deer | *mā |
| deer | *kur-V-c- |
| tiger | *pul-i |
| rat | *el-i |
| snake | *pāmpu |
| meat | *iṯ-ay-cci |
| meat | *ū/*uy |
| oil, ghee | *ney |
| fish | *mīn |
| louse | *pēn |
| mosquito | *nuẓ-Vḷ/-nk- |
| wing | *ceṯ-ank-/-ankk- |
| black | *cir- |
| white | *weḷ/*weṇ |
| red | *kem |
| sweet (adj./n.) | *in- |
| sour | *puḷ- |
| bitter; bitterness | *kac (> kay) |
| to eat, drink | *uHṇ-/*ūṇ- |
| to eat | *tiHn- |
| to come | *waH-/*waH-r |
| to walk | *naṭ-a |
| to give | *ciy-/*cī- |
| to die | *caH- ~ *ceH- |
| to sleep | *kū-r- |
| to sleep | *tuñc- |
| to count | *eṇ |
- ^ Also 'edge, beak, mouth of vessel, aperture, blade of sword'.
See also
References
- ^ Andronov 2003, p. 299.
- ^ Krishnamurti 2003, p. 492.
- ^ History and Archaeology. vol. 1, no. 1–2. Department of Ancient History, Culture, and Archaeology, University of Allahabad. 1980. p. 234. OCLC 11579254.
- ^ a b McIntosh 2008, p. 353.
- ^ a b Southworth 2005.
- ^ a b McIntosh 2008, p. 353-354.
- ^ Parpola & Parpola 1975, p. 217-225.
- ^ McIntosh 2008, p. 354.
- ^ Ansumali Mukhopadhyay 2021.
- ^ Baldi 1990, p. 342.
- ^ Subrahmanyam 1983, p. 40.
- ^ Zvelebil 1990.
- ^ a b Krishnamurti 2003.
- ^ http://www.languageinindia.com/july2013/ravisankarkeralatriballanguages.pdf
- ^ https://www.tamildigitallibrary.in/admin/assets/book/TVA_BOK_0012142_Dravidian_comparative_phonology.pdf
- ^ Subrahmanyam 1983.
- ^ https://www.academia.edu/23734414/Professor_P_S_Subrahmanyam_1939_2016_the_distinguished_Dravidian_linguist_A_short_profile_and_his_publications
- ^ Krishnamurti 2003, p. [page needed].
Works cited
- Andronov, Mikhail Sergeevich (2003). A Comparative Grammar of the Dravidian Languages. Otto Harrassowitz Verlag. ISBN 978-3-447-04455-4.
- Ansumali Mukhopadhyay, Bahata (December 2021). "Ancestral Dravidian languages in Indus Civilization: ultraconserved Dravidian tooth-word reveals deep linguistic ancestry and supports genetics". Humanities and Social Sciences Communications. 8 (1): 193. doi:10.1057/s41599-021-00868-w. S2CID 236901972.
- Baldi, Philip (1990). Linguistic Change and Reconstruction Methodology. Walter de Gruyter. p. 342. ISBN 3-11-011908-0.
- Fuller, Dorian Q. (2007). "Non-human genetics, agricultural origins and historical linguistics in South Asia". The Evolution and History of Human Populations in South Asia. Vertebrate Paleobiology and Paleoanthropology Series. pp. 393–443. doi:10.1007/1-4020-5562-5_18. ISBN 978-1-4020-5561-4.
- Krishnamurti, Bhadriraju (2003). The Dravidian Languages. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-1-139-43533-8.
- McAlpin, David W. (2003). "Velars, Uvulars and the Northern Dravidian hypothesis". Journal of the American Oriental Society. 123 (3): 521–546. doi:10.2307/3217749. JSTOR 3217749.
- McIntosh, Jane (2008). The Ancient Indus Valley: New Perspectives. ABC-CLIO. ISBN 978-1-57607-907-2.
- Parpola, Asko; Parpola, Simo (1975). "On the relationship of the Sumerian toponym Meluhha and Sanskrit mleccha". Studia Orientalia. 46: 205–238.
- Southworth, Franklin C. (2005). Proto-Dravidian Agriculture (PDF). 7th ESCA Round Table Conference, Kyoto, June 2005.
- Subrahmanyam, P.S. (1983). Dravidian Comparative Phonology. Annamalai University.
- Zvelebil, Kamil (1990). Dravidian Linguistics: An Introduction. Pondicherry Institute of Linguistics and Culture.
Further reading
- Andronov, M. (1964). "Lexicostatistic analysis of the chronology of disintegration of proto-Dravidian". Indo-Iranian Journal. 7 (2): 170–186. doi:10.1163/000000064791616433. S2CID 161229771.
- Blažek, Václav (2009). "Dravidian numeral" (PDF). Journal of Language Relationship. 1: 69–80.
- Chandrasekaran, Periannan (7 January 2016). "Pleonastic Compounding: An Ancient Dravidian Word Structure". Electronic Journal of Vedic Studies. 18 (1): 1–59 Seiten. doi:10.11588/ejvs.2011.1.319.
- Emeneau, M. B. (April 1988). "Proto-Dravidian *c- and Its Developments". Journal of the American Oriental Society. 108 (2): 239–268. doi:10.2307/603651. JSTOR 603651.
- Kobayashi, Masato (2021). "Viewing Proto-Dravidian from the Northeast". Journal of the American Oriental Society. 140 (2): 467–482. doi:10.7817/jameroriesoci.140.2.0467. S2CID 226670756..
- Kolipakam, Vishnupriya; Jordan, Fiona M.; Dunn, Michael; Greenhill, Simon J.; Bouckaert, Remco; Gray, Russell D.; Verkerk, Annemarie (March 2018). "A Bayesian phylogenetic study of the Dravidian language family". Royal Society Open Science. 5 (3): 171504. Bibcode:2018RSOS....571504K. doi:10.1098/rsos.171504. PMC 5882685. PMID 29657761. S2CID 4844024.
- Sankaran, C. R. (1939). "Reconstruction of the Proto-Dravidian Pronouns". Bulletin of the Deccan College Research Institute. 1 (1): 96–105. JSTOR 42929233.
- Southworth, Franklin (December 2011). "Rice in Dravidian". Rice. 4 (3–4): 142–148. doi:10.1007/s12284-011-9076-9. S2CID 12983737.
- Subramoniam, V. I. (1968). "A Problem in the Reconstruction of the Proto Dravidian Nasal Phonemes". Pratidanam: Indian, Iranian, and Indo-European studies presented to Franciscus Bernardus Jacobus Kuiper on his sixtieth birthday. pp. 344–358. doi:10.1515/9783112415306-047. ISBN 9783112415306.
- Subrahmanyam, P.S. (2006). "Proto-Dravidian Short, High, and Mid Vowels: Mergers in South Dravidian and Telugu-Kuwi". Bulletin of the Deccan College Research Institute. 66/67: 291–303. JSTOR 42931454.
- Wells, Bryan K.; Fuls, Andreas (2015). "Proto-Dravidian and the Indus Script". The Archaeology and Epigraphy of Indus Writing. Archaeopress. pp. 77–99. ISBN 978-1-78491-046-4. JSTOR j.ctvr43jmf.14.
External links
- T. Burrow (1984). Dravidian Etymological Dictionary, 2nd Edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-864326-5. Retrieved 2008-10-26.