User:Tabu Makiadi/sandbox: Difference between revisions

Browse history interactively

← Previous edit Next edit →

Content deleted Content added

VisualWikitext

Inline

Revision as of 02:43, 26 August 2024

Tabu Makiadi (talk) 17:27, 11 August 2024 (UTC)

Potential proposals?

Swap Modern monetary theory with Heterodox economics
Swap Allocative efficiency with Economic efficiency
Add Rationing
Add Aggregate Demand
Add Consumer Price Index
Add Distribution
Add Diminishing returns
Add Cartel
Add Efficient market hypothesis
Add ETF
Add Fair trade
Add Fixed Costs: Business expenses that remain constant regardless of the level of production or sales.
Add Marketing Mix (4 Ps): The set of actions or tactics that a company uses to promote its brand or product in the market, typically consisting of Product, Price, Place, and Promotion
Add International economics
Add development economics

Add Stagflation
Add Austerity
Add Ceteris paribus
Add Economic surplus

Economy and law by country removals

Currently, we have 24 "Politics by country," 34 "Economy by country," and 37 "Law by country" articles. I won’t go into the details of each entry, but I want to consider whether some of these articles truly deserve VA5 status. For example, are there specific elements of the Law of the Netherlands or the Law of Romania that are essential for an average, educated person? Should we focus on countries in greater flux, like Economy of Argentina 5, rather than larger economies like Poland or Taiwan? These proposals aim to reduce to 30 the number of "Law" and "Economy by country" entries. If you disagree, let me know if it’s the specific countries selected or if the list is already appropriately sized and doesn’t need significant cuts.

Support

As nominator. Tabu Makiadi (talk) 20:42, 18 August 2024 (UTC)

Oppose

Discuss

For the econ removals, I used List of countries by GDP (PPP) for reference. The proposed economies are the lowest ranked among the ones listed. The Law by country articles have 5 or fewer interwikis.

Various society additions

Add post-structuralism and deconstruction

Major concept in the humanities and the social sciences.

Add Peruvian cuisine

Consistently ranked in the Top 15

Add Erotica
Add Cantar de gesta (forgot the word for this)
Add Imperial House of Japan

Japan’s imperial family is the oldest continuous hereditary monarchy in the world, with an unbroken agnatic line since the early 6th century.

Add Aztec Sun stone
Add Titian’s Venus

Sports removals

Remove Quidditch (real-life sport) Not quite a meme sport, but not significant enough to be here. It’s not even officially called Quidditch anymore.

Support

As nominator. Tabu Makiadi (talk) 19:50, 4 June 2024 (UTC)

Oppose

Discuss

Remove Robot combat Let’s appease our AI overlords

Support

As nominator. Tabu Makiadi (talk) 19:50, 4 June 2024 (UTC)

Oppose

Discuss

Remove Cycle speedway 5 and Fly casting 5

Minor cycle sport and competition fishing competitions respectively

Support

As nominator. Tabu Makiadi (talk) 19:50, 4 June 2024 (UTC)

Oppose

Discuss

Add humanitarian aid Add Cruelty to animals Add Gurdwara

Kenya Ethiopia

Bangladesh Phillippines Thailand Vietnam Iran South Korea

Spain Poland Canada

Hans Geiger Carl Seizz

Remove Harry Kendall Thaw

"He is most notable for murdering the renowned architect Stanford White", who is not VA5, and which has been named, the "trial of the century" but that's a long list

Remove Sebastián Garcilaso de la Vega y Vargas

Lesser known explorer and conquistador. Seems to be most known as the father of Inca Garcilaso de la Vega.

Remove Eugene Klein (philatelist) and Walter Breen

How many stamp or coin collectors should we list? Six are way too many.

Remove André Borschberg

The article states he has broken a few world records, but it has been tagged for self-promotion and lacks sources.

Remove Milton A. Rothman

He founded a Science fiction convention. Not much claim vitality.

Remove Nancy Spungen 5

Some sections are more pressed for space. I would propose removing her considering we don't list Sid Vicious, and he's not a particularly close call.

15,185 to 15,000. Entertainers 2175 - 2150 Social Scientists 1360 - 1350 Miscellaneous 1,200 - 1,150 Health 1140 - 1125

Cullture 1750 - 1850

Remove Sataspes 5

I wish we had more ancient explorers, but everything we know about him comes from a few pages from Herodotus.

Remove John Steuart Curry 5

One of the three great painters of American Regionalism of the first half of the twentieth century. Obviously important, but Being one of the most important people in an art movement does not automatically make you vital. Regionalism is VA5.

Remove Ron Galella 5

We don't list Paparazzi.

Remove Richard Prince 5

Best known for Cowboy photo

Remove Carleton Watkins 5

Not among the 19th century most important photographers.

Remove Lady Pink 5

Graffiti artist.

Remove Shōji Hamada 5

Pottery maker.

Remove William Billings 5

Regarded as the first American choral composer

Remove Silver Horn 5

Native American artist. 1 interwiki

Remove Helen Forrest 5

Big band singer

@@ Line 146: / Line 146: @@
 One of the three great painters of American Regionalism of the first half of the twentieth century. Obviously important, but Being one of the most important people in an art movement does not automatically make you vital. Regionalism is VA5.
+=== Remove {{VA link|Ron Galella}} ===
+We don't list Paparazzi.
-=== Remove {{VA link|H. G. Peter}} ===
+=== Remove {{VA link|Richard Prince}} ===
-Interestingly, the [[Wonder Woman]] article (which names him as a co-creator) mentions him only once in the article’s body, and it’s in the first sentence. We already list a fairly high number of American newspaper cartoonists of this period. Note that co-creator {{VA link|William Moulton Marston}} is listed over 30 times in that article's body and is also VA5.
+Best known for Cowboy photo
-;Support
+=== Remove {{VA link|Carleton Watkins}} ===
-#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 02:20, 26 August 2024 (UTC)
+Not among the 19th century most important photographers.
+=== Remove {{VA link|Lady Pink}} ===
-;Oppose
+Graffiti artist.
+=== Remove {{VA link|Shōji Hamada}} ===
-;Discuss
+Pottery maker.
-=== Remove {{VA link|Cardi B}} ===
+=== Remove {{VA link|William Billings}} ===
+Regarded as the first American choral composer
-She has released only 1 album. I like her music but I don’t think she has the trajectory to be listed yet.
+=== Remove {{VA link|Silver Horn}} ===
-;Support
+Native American artist. 1 interwiki
-#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 02:20, 26 August 2024 (UTC)
+=== Remove {{VA link|Helen Forrest}} ===
+Big band singer
-;Oppose
-;Discuss
-=== Remove {{VA link|Deadmau5}} ===
-Famous during the late 2000s/early 2010s, but not enough of a lasting influence to be vital, I would say. Some of you have expressed that our electronic musicians list is somewhat short. I am open to swapping him for someone else.
-;Support
-#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 02:20, 26 August 2024 (UTC)
-;Oppose
-;Discuss
-=== Remove {{VA link|Natori Shunsen}} ===
-He doesn’t appear to be among the most significant Japanese woodblock printers, of which we already list a few.
-;Support
-#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 02:20, 26 August 2024 (UTC)
-;Oppose
-;Discuss
-=== Remove {{VA link|Francis Greenway}} ===
-The article names several projects he worked on, but he was the architect for only a few of them, towards the end of his life. I’ve noted a considerable number of Australians who are carefully picked, and their articles are in good shape, but are not quite at the standard of vitality we are trying to establish.
-;Support
-#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 02:20, 26 August 2024 (UTC)
-;Oppose
-;Discuss
-=== Remove {{VA link|Russell Drysdale}} ===
-Similar to the above. 9 interwikis.
-;Support
-#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 02:20, 26 August 2024 (UTC)
-;Oppose
-;Discuss
-=== Remove {{VA link|Bob Loveless}} ===
-Knife designer. “Popularized the hollow ground drop point blade”. Just 1 interwiki.
-;Support
-#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 02:20, 26 August 2024 (UTC)
-;Oppose
-;Discuss
-=== Remove {{VA link|Lucienne Day}} ===
-Relatively obscure British textile designer. 4 interwikis.
-;Support
-#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 02:20, 26 August 2024 (UTC)
-;Oppose
-;Discuss
-=== Remove {{VA link|Felipe Pinglo Alva}} ===
-Very few page views. Even the Spanish Wikipedia has only one short article dedicated to his songs—his signature song.
-;Support
-#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 02:20, 26 August 2024 (UTC)
-;Oppose
-;Discuss
-=== Remove {{VA link|f(x) (musical group)}} ===
-I know K-Pop is huge, but we have a high number of acts from the 2010s that probably have not established vitality yet, considering how cautious we have been towards English-speaking pop stars from this period.
-;Support
-#As nominator. [[User:Tabu Makiadi|Tabu Makiadi]] ([[User talk:Tabu Makiadi|talk]]) 02:20, 26 August 2024 (UTC)
-;Oppose
-;Discuss