Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PiX Bros: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 22:58, 21 October 2007

PiX Bros

This is a video game that has no substantial information about it published in any reliable sources (those with a reputation for fact-checking). The only sources for it are either trivial listings (download sites), blog mentions (LinuxJuegos), wikis (Ubuntu Italy), or other unreliable sources (some personal Japanese website on a free web host). Even conflict of interest aside (I believe the article creator is one of the game's developers), there is no coverage from any reliable publications that demonstrates any notability or ability to fact-check the article without original research. Also nominating PiX Frogger and PiX Pang for the same reasons. Wickethewok 20:00, 20 October 2007 (UTC)[reply]

Hello, I'm the one who created those articles and I'm also the director of the group PiX Juegos. Also, about Conflict of Interest, I must say that we're a group that developes open source games that are published for free and we have no benefits from all this, just we want to create games for the open source community. Well, I don't understand why those sources aren't perfectly reliable. Some of them are blogs, wellknown blogs that bring PiX Juegos' page many people that are interested in those games. And also, the italian Ubuntu wiki doesn't let anyone modify it, just people from the LoCo, so I think it's not the same as any other wiki. Anyway, I wanted to demostrate the notability of the games by showing links of english, italian and even japanese people reviewing them, I think it's enough. By the way, I created those pages in order to have those games included in this list: Alphabetical list of open source games‎ Panreyes 22:58, 21 October 2007 (UTC)[reply]

@@ Line 4: / Line 4: @@
 :{{la|PiX Bros}} – <includeonly>([[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/PiX Bros|View AfD]])</includeonly><noinclude>([[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Log/2007 October 20#{{anchorencode:PiX Bros}}|View log]])</noinclude>
 This is a video game that has no substantial information about it published in any reliable sources (those with a reputation for fact-checking).  The only sources for it are either trivial listings (download sites), blog mentions (LinuxJuegos), wikis (Ubuntu Italy), or other unreliable sources (some personal Japanese website on a free web host).  Even [[WP:COI|conflict of interest]] aside (I believe the article creator is one of the game's developers), there is no coverage from any reliable publications that demonstrates any [[WP:N|notability]] or ability to fact-check the article without original research.  Also nominating [[PiX Frogger]] and [[PiX Pang]] for the same reasons. [[User:Wickethewok|Wickethewok]] 20:00, 20 October 2007 (UTC)
+Hello, I'm the one who created those articles and I'm also the director of the group PiX Juegos. Also, about Conflict of Interest, I must say that we're a group that developes open source games that are published for free and we have no benefits from all this, just we want to create games for the open source community.
+Well, I don't understand why those sources aren't perfectly reliable. Some of them are blogs, wellknown blogs that bring PiX Juegos' page many people that are interested in those games. And also, the italian Ubuntu wiki doesn't let anyone modify it, just people from the LoCo, so I think it's not the same as any other wiki.
+Anyway, I wanted to demostrate the notability of the games by showing links of english, italian and even japanese people reviewing them, I think it's enough. By the way, I created those pages in order to have those games included in this list: [[Alphabetical list of open source games‎]]
+[[User:Panreyes|Panreyes]] 22:58, 21 October 2007 (UTC)