Claude Auchinleck

Sir Claude John Eyre Auchinleck
Nickname(s)	The Auk
Allegiance	United Kingdom
Service / branch	Indian Army
Years of service	1904–1947
Rank	Field Marshal
Commands	1st Battalion, 1st Punjab Regiment (21 Jan 1929 - 31 Jan 1930) Meerut district (1938) 3rd Indian Division (Sep 1939) IV Corps (Jan 1940) C in C, Northern Norway (Apr - Jun 1940) V Corps (Jun 1940) Southern Command (UK) (Jul - Nov 1940) Middle East Command (1941-1942) Commander-in-Chief, India (1941 & 1943-1947)
Battles / wars	World War I: - Egypt (1915) - Mesopotamian campaign Mohmand (1935) World War II: -Norwegian campaign -North African campaign
Awards	GCB (Jan 1945) GCIE (Dec 1940) CB (July 1934) CSI (May 1936) DSO (Jun 1917) OBE (Jun 1919) mentioned in dispatches (1917 & 1934) Legion of Merit, Chief Commander (23 Jul 1948) Virtuti Militari 5th class (15 May 1942) War Cross (1944) Order of the Star of Nepal, 1st Class (1945) Knight Grand Cross of Order of St Olav (19 Mar 1948) 1st Class Order of Cloud and Banner (1947) Grand Officer, Légion d'honneur Croix de guerre (1918 and 1949)

Field Marshal Sir Claude John Eyre Auchinleck, GCB, GCIE, CSI, DSO, OBE (June 21 1884 - March 23 1981), nicknamed The Auk, was a British army commander during World War II. He was a career soldier who spent much of his military career in India, where he developed a love of the country and a lasting affinity for the soldiers he commanded.

Early life and career

The Auchinlecks were an Ulster Scots family from County Fermanagh, where they had settled in the 17th century. Claude Auchinleck was born in Aldershot, son of Colonel John and Mary Auchinleck, while his father's regiment was stationed there. His father died in 1892, when he was eight years old, and Auchinleck grew up in impoverished circumstances, but he was able, through hard work and scholarships, to graduate from Wellington College and the Royal Military Academy, Sandhurst.

Auchinleck applied to join the Indian Army and, having achieved in 1903 a qualifying position in the entrance examination, in 1904 he joined the 62nd Punjab Regiment. He was able to learn Punjabi rapidly and, able to speak fluently with his soldiers, he absorbed a knowledge of local dialects and customs. This familiarity engendered a lasting mutual respect, enhanced by his own personality.

During World War I, he served in the Middle East in Egypt, Palestine and Mesopotamia. Auchinleck's division was the last of four offered by the Indian government and, while en route for France, it was reassigned to defend the Suez Canal from a potential Turkish attack. When the attack occurred in February 1915, Auchinleck's regiment prevented the Turks from crossing the canal and he led a counter-attack which defeated them. The Turks subsequently surrendered.

The 6th Indian Division, of which the 62nd Punjabis were a part, was landed at Basra on 31 December, 1915 for the Mesopotamian campaign. In early 1916 Auchinleck was promoted Acting Major and made second in command of the regiment. North of Basra, the Punjabis were in heavy action in dreadful conditions: cold, rain and mud as well as determined Turkish defence reduced the regiment to 247 men and Auchinleck took temporary command when his regimental commander was wounded. Further hard fighting ensued: the Turkish army inflicted a humiliating reversal on the British and eventual success was hard won. Auchinlek was mentioned in despatches and received the Distinguished Service Order in 1917 for his service in Mesopotamia.

Auchinleck took a number of practical lessons from his experiences in Mesopotamia. Firstly, soldiers' health and well-being was critical to an army's effectiveness and he became convinced of the need of adequate rest, hygiene, good food and medical supplies for the troops. Secondly, he had seen the futility of inadequately prepared attacks against dug-in, well-armed defenders and this fuelled his later reluctance to initiate precipitate actions advocated by his political and military superiors.

Between the wars, Auchinleck served in India. He was both a student and an instructor at the Staff College at Quetta and also attended the Imperial Defence College. In 1929 he had been appointed to command his regiment which had become in the 1923 reorganisation of the British Indian Army the 1st battalion, 1st Punjab Regiment. In 1933, he took command of the Peshawar Brigade, which was active in the pacification of the adjacent tribal areas. A serious operation in the Mohmand area in 1935, led to the first use of tanks in India. Auchinleck was Mentioned in Despatches and received the CSI and CB for his skill in managing the operation.

In 1938 Major-General Auchinleck was appointed to chair a committee to consider the modernisation, composition and re-equipment of the British Indian Army. The committee's recommendations formed the basis of the 1939 Chatfield Report which outlined the transformation of the Indian Army which grew to over 2,250,000 men by the end of the war from 183,000 in 1939.

World War II

Norway

On the outbreak of war Auchinleck was appointed to command Indian 3rd Infantry Division but in January 1940 was summoned to the United Kingdom to command IV Corps, the only time in the war that a wholly British corps was commanded by an Indian Army officer. In May 1940 Auchinleck took over command of the Anglo-French ground forces in Norway, a military operation that was doomed to fail. After the fall of Norway, in July 1940 he briefly commanded V Corps before becoming General Officer Commander-in-Chief, Southern Command, where he had an uneasy relationship with his subordinate Bernard Montgomery, the new V Corps commander. Montgomery later wrote

"In the 5th Corps I first served under Auchinleck.....I cannot recall that we ever agreed on anything"

In December 1941 Auchinleck was recalled to India to become Commander-in-Chief of the Indian Army.

India 1941-2

When in April 1941 the large British airforce base at Habbaniya in Iraq was threatened by the new pro-Axis regime of Rashid Ali General Archibald Wavell, C-in-C Middle East Command, was reluctant to intervene, despite the urgings of Winston Churchill, because of his pressing commitments in the Western Desert and Greece. Auchinleck, however, acted decisively, sending a battalion of the King's Own Royal Regiment by air to Habbaniya and shipping Indian 10th Infantry Division by sea to Basra. Wavell was prevailed upon by London to send Habforce, a relief column, from the British Mandate of Palestine but by the time it arrived in Habbaniya on 18 May the Anglo-Iraqi War was virtually over.

North Africa

Following the see-saw of Allied and Axis successes and reverses in North Africa, Auchinleck was appointed to succeed General (later Field Marshal) Sir Archibald Wavell as C-in-C Middle East Command in July 1941; Wavell took up Auchinleck's post as C-in-C of the Indian Army, swapping jobs with him.

General Auchinleck as C-in-C Middle East was based in Cairo, with responsibility not just for North Africa but also for Persia and the Middle East; the Eighth Army confronting the German Afrika Corps and the Italian Army was commanded successively by Lieutenant-Generals Sir Alan Cunningham and Neil Ritchie. The first major offensive by Eighth Army following Auchinleck's appointment, Operation Crusader in November 1941 resulted in the defeat of much of the British armour and the breakdown of Cunningham. Auchinleck relieved Cunningham, and ordered the battle to continue. Despite heavy losses, the Eighth Army drove the Axis forces back to El Agheila. Auchinleck then appointed Ritchie to command Eighth Army. While Auchinleck resumed overall strategic direction of the Middle East theatre, he continued to dictate operational matters to Ritchie. In January of 1942 the Afrika Korps struck at the dispersed and weakened British forces, driving them back to the Gazala positions near Tobruk. Rommel's attack at the Battle of Gazala of May 25 1942 resulted in a significant defeat for the British. Eighth Army retreated into Egypt; Tobruk (which was of great political significance to Winston Churchill but of limited military importance to Auchinleck) fell on 21 June. Once more Auchinleck stepped in to take direct command of the Eighth Army, having lost confidence in Ritchie's ability to control and direct his forces. Auchinleck discarded Ritchie's plan to stand at Mersa Matruh, deciding to fight only a delaying action there, while withdrawing to the more easily defendable position at El Alamein. Here Auchinleck tailored a defence that took advantage of the terrain and the few fresh troops at his disposal, and decisively stopped the German/Italian advance in the First Battle of El Alamein. But Auchinleck's Eighth Army was too weak and uncoordinated to actually destroy the Panzer Army Africa, and once stopped, the battles against the Axis through July only served to exhaust both sides.

"The Auk", as he was known, appointed a number of senior commanders who proved to be unsuitable for their positions, and command arrangements were often characterised by bitter personality clashes. Auchinleck was an Indian Army officer and was criticised for apparently having little direct experience or understanding of British and Dominion troops. Nonetheless, he was the first British officer to put together a combination of training and method that worked against the enemy. Since the war, Auchinleck's success at Alamein in July has been accepted as the key moment in the entire desert war - the turning point after which the Germans enjoyed no major success.

Auchinleck's desire for the Eighth Army to fight in mobile 'Brigade Groups' rather than Divisions was resisted by many subordinates. His controversial chief of staff, Major-General Dorman-Smith, was regarded with considerable distrust by many of the senior commanders in Eighth Army, particularly the old guard who were wary of the new methods of mobile warfare. Critically, the failure of British armour to coordinate with infantry had led to a number of disasters, and these were largely, and unfairly, pinned on Auchinleck. By July 1942 Auchinleck had lost the confidence of Dominion commanders and relations with his British commanders had become strained.

Like his foe Rommel (and his predecessor Wavell and successor Montgomery), Auchinleck was subjected to constant political interference, having to weather a barrage of hectoring telegrams and instructions from Prime Minister Churchill throughout late 1941 and the spring and summer of 1942. Churchill constantly sought an offensive from Auchinleck, and was (understandably) downcast at the military reverses in Egypt and Cyrenaica. Churchill was desperate for some sort of British victory before the planned Allied landings in North Africa, Operation Torch, scheduled for November 1942. He badgered Auchinleck immediately after the Eighth Army had all but exhausted itself after the first battle of El Alamein. Churchill and the Chief of the Imperial General Staff, Alan Brooke, flew to Cairo in early August 1942, to meet Auchinleck, but it is now obvious that Churchill and Brooke had already lost confidence in Auchinleck.

He was replaced as C-in-C Middle East Command by General Sir Harold Alexander (later Field Marshal Earl Alexander of Tunis) and as GOC Eighth Army by Lieutenant-General William Gott, who was killed in Egypt before taking up command. On Gott's death, Lieutenant-General (later Field Marshal Viscount) Bernard Montgomery was appointed commander of the Eighth Army. Auchinleck's reputation (along with that of many other officers) subsequently suffered at the hands of Montgomery and others.

India

Churchill offered Auchinleck command of the newly created Persia and Iraq Command (this having been hived off Alexander's command), but the Auk declined this post, possibly as Tenth Army, which at the time, formed the bulk of the troops, was commanded by his Indian Army friend and colleague Lieut.-General Sir Edward Quinan. His stated reasons were more pragmatic, that the new arrangements would not be workable in practice, and were set out in his letter to the CIGS dated 14 August, 1942. The post was accepted in his stead by General Sir Henry Maitland Wilson. Instead he returned to India, where he spent almost a year "unemployed" before in 1943 being again appointed Commander-in-Chief of the Indian Army, General Wavell meanwhile having been appointed Viceroy. C-in-C India had become a rear area appointment with the prosecution of the Burma Campaign the responsibility of the Supreme Commander, Admiral Louis Mountbatten. Nevertheless, Auchinleck played an important role and made the supply of Fourteenth Army, with probably the worst lines of communication of the war, his immediate priority; as William Slim, commander of the Fourteenth Army was later to write:

"It was a good day for us when he [Auchinleck] took command of India, our main base, recruiting area and training ground. The Fourteenth Army, from its birth to its final victory, owed much to his unselfish support and never-failing understanding. Without him and what he and the Army of India did for us we could not have existed, let alone conquered"

Auchinleck continued in the post after the end of the war, being promoted Field Marshal in June 1946.

Post-war life

Auchinleck as C-in-C of the Indian Army, with the then Viceroy Wavell and Montgomery.

Much against his own convictions, Auchinleck helped prepare the future Indian and Pakistani armies prior to Partition scheduled for August 1947. In November 1945, Auchinleck was forced to commute the sentence of transportation for life awarded to three officers of the Indian National Army in face of growing unease and unrest both within the Indian Population, and the British Indian Army. In 1946 he was promoted to field marshal but he refused to accept a peerage, lest he be thought associated with a policy (i.e. Partition) that he thought fundamentally dishonourable. Having disagreed sharply with Lord Mountbatten, the last Viceroy of India, he resigned as C-in-C and retired in 1947. In 1948 the Auk returned to Britain, his wife having left him for Air Chief Marshal Sir Richard Peirse in 1946.

Although a somewhat dour character, he was known as a generous and welcoming host. Despite being a general for longer than almost any other soldier, he was never pompous, and hated all forms of display and affectation. Above all, he was a soldier of the utmost integrity, whose reputation, unlike that of many Allied officers, has grown with passing years. In retirement, The Auk moved to Marrakesh, where he lived quietly in a modest flat for many years, taking his morning coffee (it is said) like everybody else in the local cafe in the square, where he was known by all simply as le marechal. He was befriended and aided for by Corporal Malcolm James Millward, a serving soldier in the Queen's Regiment for three and a half years up until the death of Sir Claude in 1981.

Army career summary

• Commissioned 62nd Punjab Regiment, India, 1904
• Promoted Captain, 1912
• Promoted Acting Major, second in command 62nd Punjab Regiment, 1916
• Acting Lieutenant-Colonel, temporary commander 62nd Punjab Regiment, 1917
• Promoted Major, GSO2 Mesopotamia, 1918
• Temporary Lieutenant-Colonel, GSO1 Mesopotamia, 1919
• Brevett Lieutenant-Colonel, Kurdistan, 1919
• Deputy Assistant Quartermaster-General, India, 1923 - 1924
• Imperial Defence College, 1927
• Commanding Officer 1st Battalion 1st Punjab Regiment, 1929 - 1930
• Promoted Colonel, 1930
• Instructor at Command and Staff College, Quetta, India, 1930 - 1933
• Honorary Colonel 1st bn 1st Punjab Regiment, 1933
• Temporary Brigadier, Commanding Officer Peshawar Brigade, 1933 - 1936
• Promoted Major-General, 1935
• Deputy Chief General Staff, India, 1936 - 1938
• Chairman, Expert Committee on the Defence of India, 1938
• District Officer Commanding Meerut District, India, 1938 - 1940
• Honorary Colonel 1st battalion 4th Bombay Grenadiers, 1939
• General Officer Commanding IV Corps, 1940
• Promoted Lieutenant-General, 1940
• General Officer Commanding Northern Norway, 1940
• General Officer Commanding V Corps, 1940
• General Officer Commander-in-Chief Southern Command, 1940
• Commander-in-Chief, India, Promoted General, 1941
• Honorary Colonel Inniskilling Fusiliers, 1941
• Commander-in-Chief Middle East Command, 1941 - 1942
• Aide-de-Camp General to the King, 1941 - 1946
• Temporary General Officer Commanding Eighth Army, 1942
• Commander-in-Chief, India, 1943 - 1947
• Honorary Colonel 4th Bombay Grenadiers, 1944
• Promoted Field Marshal, 1946
• Supreme Commander in India & Pakistan, 1947
• Retired 1947

References

• Ammentorp, Steen. "Generals of World War II". Retrieved 2007-09-28. {{cite web}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help)
• Houterman, Hans. "World War II unit histories and officers". Retrieved 2007-09-28. {{cite web}}: Unknown parameter |coauthors= ignored (|author= suggested) (help)
• Keegan (ed), John (1991). Churchill's Generals. London: Cassell Military. pp. p131. ISBN 0-304-36712-5. {{cite book}}: |last= has generic name (help); |pages= has extra text (help); Unknown parameter |coauthors= ignored (|author= suggested) (help)
• Mackenzie, Compton (1951). Eastern Epic. Chatto & Windus, London. pp. 623 pages.
• Mead, Richard (2007). Churchill's Lions: A biographical guide to the key British generals of World War II. Stroud (UK): Spellmount. pp. 544 pages. ISBN 978-1-86227-431-0.
• Slim, Field Marshal Viscount (1972). Defeat into Victory. London: Cassell. ISBN 0-304-29114-5. {{cite book}}: Unknown parameter |origdate= ignored (|orig-date= suggested) (help)
• "Orders of Battle.com". Retrieved 2007-09-28.