Jump to content

Talk:Bantam (poultry): Difference between revisions

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
No edit summary
 
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
The prose of this article seems a bit off. it drops into first person sometimes and the questioning paragraph is an odd thing for an encyclopedia. It also seems to have POV issues feeling a little like pro-bantam propeganda. The information seems good though. It should be noted there actually is an anti-bantam feeling among some too. mainly chicken raisers who don't want bantams to interbreed with their stock.
The prose of this article seems a bit off. it drops into first person sometimes and the questioning paragraph is an odd thing for an encyclopedia. It also seems to have POV issues feeling a little like pro-bantam propeganda. The information seems good though. It should be noted there actually is an anti-bantam feeling among some too. mainly chicken raisers who don't want bantams to interbreed with their stock.

I have never heard of something called a "pekin bantam", and I hhave been a chicken fancier for several years. There is a Pekin duck, and there are bantam breeds with leg feathers such those described in this article, but they are not called pekin bantams. I'm concerned because it is such a common mistake to think "bantam" is a breed, when in fact, it is just a smal version of something. There are some breeds of chicken that only have a bantam version, and many others that come in either bantam or standard. I have Milles Fleurs, which are beautiful, tiny chickens with red, black and white feathers and large feathers all the way down their legs. I suspect this is what the writer of the article is referring to.

Revision as of 14:53, 29 July 2005

The prose of this article seems a bit off. it drops into first person sometimes and the questioning paragraph is an odd thing for an encyclopedia. It also seems to have POV issues feeling a little like pro-bantam propeganda. The information seems good though. It should be noted there actually is an anti-bantam feeling among some too. mainly chicken raisers who don't want bantams to interbreed with their stock.

I have never heard of something called a "pekin bantam", and I hhave been a chicken fancier for several years. There is a Pekin duck, and there are bantam breeds with leg feathers such those described in this article, but they are not called pekin bantams. I'm concerned because it is such a common mistake to think "bantam" is a breed, when in fact, it is just a smal version of something. There are some breeds of chicken that only have a bantam version, and many others that come in either bantam or standard. I have Milles Fleurs, which are beautiful, tiny chickens with red, black and white feathers and large feathers all the way down their legs. I suspect this is what the writer of the article is referring to.