User:Tristessa de St Ange/Mediation IRC

This page contains details relevant to the Ed Poor out-of-ArbCom-settlement and the series of IRC-based conferences surrounding this.

First Conference

• Scheduled: 10:30, 5th August 2005 (UTC)
• Commenced: 10:23, 5th August 2005 (UTC)
• Concluded: 00:30, 6th August 2005 (UTC)

Agenda

No agenda was decided prior to this conference

Minutes (Brief)

The members met and discussed the points of view of:

• Ed Poor
• Rob Church
• Uninvited Company
• Phroziac

Conference was then adjourned to allow for thinking time.

Minutes (Detailed)

A full log of this, and other conferences, can be found at http://www.anubite.co.uk/edpoor.

Second Conference

• Scheduled: 10:30, 8th August 2005 (UTC)
• Commenced: ??:??, 8th August 2005 (UTC)
• Concluded: 01:04, 9th August 2005 (UTC)

Agenda

1. Revise Points Of View (of Initiators)
   1. Phroziac
   2. Rob Church
   3. Uninvited Company
2. Hear Point Of View
   1. Nicholas Turnbull
3. "Findings Of Fact"
4. Proposed Action
   1. Nicholas Turnbull
   2. Phroziac
   3. Rob Church
   4. Uninvited Company
5. Ed Poor's Response To Proposed Action
   1. Ed Poor's Response
   2. Compromises
6. Conclusion

Minutes (Brief)

The members recapped and clarified the points of view of Phroziac, Rob Church and UninvitedCompany, and then heard the point of view of Nicholas Turnbull. Ed Poor responded to the points raised and the members attempted to propose findings of fact; it was unanimously decided to move to proposing an outcome and to "find facts" to support the proposed outcomes.

Minutes (Detailed)

A full log of this, and other conferences, can be found at http://www.anubite.co.uk/edpoor.

Third Conference

• Scheduled: Undecided at present time

Scheduling

Please could parties post details of when they are not available during the forthcoming week (11-18 Aug 2005) so that I can schedule a final IRC meeting? Assume that the time will be 22:30 GMT (that's 23:30 BST, 18:30 EDT) as usual, for now. Rob Church ^Talk 23:00, 10 August 2005 (UTC)

Ed Poor

• Date

Nicholas Turnbull

• Date

Phroziac

• Date

Rob Church

• 11th Aug - I may be out
• 18th Aug - I will be out

The Uninvited Co.

• Date

Motion to withdraw Request for Arbitration against Ed Poor

As a result of discussion via IRC conference sessions, we are satisfied that Mr. Poor's motives are sound and that he is prepared to pay more attention to community consensus in the future and take more care to avoid causing disruption in the Wikipedia community. On this basis, we feel arbitration would lead to no further gain and that Mr. Poor has shown definite remorse and willingness to modify his behaviour.

We, the undersigned, of Party 1 of the Ed Poor Request for Arbitration, hereby withdraw the request made to the arbitration committee for arbitration.

Signed:

• NicholasTurnbull, Chair: --NicholasTurnbull 19:35, 10 August 2005 (UTC)
• Phroziac: --Phroziac (talk) 20:51, 10 August 2005 (UTC)
• RobChurch: -- Rob Church 19:52, 10 August 2005 (UTC)
• UninvitedCompany:

Useful Links

• Request for Arbitration