Talk:English in computing: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
This article was nominated at [[WP:VFD|Articles for deletion]] on Aug. 26, 2005. The ultimate result of the discussion was basically "'''no consensus'''". For a non-admin, this is a tough call, so I hope I don't get reprimanded too harshly for making it. I closed the VFD, calling the result of the discussion "no consensus, therefore send it back to the drawing board". I feel fairly confident in doing so, since even the nominator noted that the version at the time of closing was significantly different from the version at the time of nomination. I've going to close the VFD, because I don't see that the later discussion was even mildly contentious, but I've also added a {{tl|cleanup}} request to the article, and let those editors working on the article itself decide when to remove it. A record of the VFD discussion can be found [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/English on the Internet|here]]. [[User:TShilo12|Tomer]] <sup><font size=-1 color=129DBC>[[User talk:TShilo12|TALK]]</font></sup> 08:02, September 1, 2005 (UTC) |
This article was nominated at [[WP:VFD|Articles for deletion]] on Aug. 26, 2005. The ultimate result of the discussion was basically "'''no consensus'''". For a non-admin, this is a tough call, so I hope I don't get reprimanded too harshly for making it. I closed the VFD, calling the result of the discussion "no consensus, therefore send it back to the drawing board". I feel fairly confident in doing so, since even the nominator noted that the version at the time of closing was significantly different from the version at the time of nomination. I've going to close the VFD, because I don't see that the later discussion was even mildly contentious, but I've also added a {{tl|cleanup}} request to the article, and let those editors working on the article itself decide when to remove it. A record of the VFD discussion can be found [[Wikipedia:Votes for deletion/English on the Internet|here]]. [[User:TShilo12|Tomer]] <sup><font size=-1 color=129DBC>[[User talk:TShilo12|TALK]]</font></sup> 08:02, September 1, 2005 (UTC) |
||
:Actually, if you look at it after the changes were made it was basically a keep, 5-2 or something, so no worries. It does need to be rounded out which I'll try to get to. [[User:Marskell|Marskell]] 08:44, 1 September 2005 (UTC) |
|||
Revision as of 08:44, 1 September 2005
VFD notification
This article was nominated at Articles for deletion on Aug. 26, 2005. The ultimate result of the discussion was basically "no consensus". For a non-admin, this is a tough call, so I hope I don't get reprimanded too harshly for making it. I closed the VFD, calling the result of the discussion "no consensus, therefore send it back to the drawing board". I feel fairly confident in doing so, since even the nominator noted that the version at the time of closing was significantly different from the version at the time of nomination. I've going to close the VFD, because I don't see that the later discussion was even mildly contentious, but I've also added a {{cleanup}} request to the article, and let those editors working on the article itself decide when to remove it. A record of the VFD discussion can be found here. Tomer TALK 08:02, September 1, 2005 (UTC)
- Actually, if you look at it after the changes were made it was basically a keep, 5-2 or something, so no worries. It does need to be rounded out which I'll try to get to. Marskell 08:44, 1 September 2005 (UTC)