Talk:Princess Victoria/Archive

Requested move

Talk:Princess Victoria of the United Kingdom — Princess Victoria of the United Kingdom → Victoria of the United Kingdom (disambiguation) – ... and vice versa, to preserve respective page histories. In a nutshell, "Princess" is the older article, but doesn't comply with the naming conventions; "Victoria" is NC-compliant, but lacks the long and illustrious (or otherwise) page history of the older article. Merge notices have been disputed due to concerns in this area. Hopefully a move (and if necessary, a swap) will keep everyone happy. (Note the and vice versa, please.) Alai 02:40, 20 September 2005 (UTC)

---

Approval summary

Please state which of the following options you can approve of, and an optional one sentence summary, then sign your vote with ~~~~. Feel free to add additional choices. This is a summary, not a replacement, of the discussion which follows. Changes of approval as a result of discussion are welcome, but should be indicated by striking out approvals, rather than removing them.

Victoria of the United Kingdom (disambiguation)

• Approve. This is approximately as good as the current heading. Will serve the same purpose, and conforms with NC. Arrigo 21:41, 20 September 2005 (UTC)

Princess Victoria of the United Kingdom

• Approve. This is acceptable heading that serves its purpose. Cannot be said to be against NC as each of those persons wrere so named at some stage of their lives. Arrigo 21:43, 20 September 2005 (UTC)

Discussion

Add any additional comments

It seems that there are other editors who feel more strongly than me what is the correct heading for this page. My concern and wish is to keep this page saved (with its edit history), and I accept the heading of these two altyernatives which is decided by others. However, if more optons come, I will oppose if such is untenable. Arrigo 21:45, 20 September 2005 (UTC)