Space Western: Difference between revisions
TheLastAmigo (talk | contribs) |
|||
Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
The Turkey City Lexicon,<ref>[http://www.sfwa.org/writing/turkeycity.html A Primer for SF Workshops]</ref> a document produced by the [[Turkey City Writer's Workshop|Turkey City science fiction writers' workshop]], condemns the space Western as "The most pernicious suite of 'Used Furniture' [that is, use of a pre-established background instead of a freshly created world]." |
The Turkey City Lexicon,<ref>[http://www.sfwa.org/writing/turkeycity.html A Primer for SF Workshops]</ref> a document produced by the [[Turkey City Writer's Workshop|Turkey City science fiction writers' workshop]], condemns the space Western as "The most pernicious suite of 'Used Furniture' [that is, use of a pre-established background instead of a freshly created world]." |
||
[[Galaxy Science Fiction]] ran an ad on its back cover, "You |
[[Galaxy Science Fiction]] ran an ad on its back cover, "You'll never see it in Galaxy", which gave the beginnings of make-believe parallel Western and SF stories featuring a character named Bat Durston.<ref>[Galaxy Science Fiction, Vol. 1 No. 1, October 1950]</ref> From this ad stemmed the derisive term "Bat Durston" to refer to the subgenre.{{Fact|date=December 2008}} A Bat Durston is always a derogatory term, indicating that the entire story could be transplanted to the West without more than cosmetic changes. If the story uses Western motifs but contains a speculative element that can not be removed without redoing the plot, it may be a space Western but not a Bat Durston. |
||
==Notable examples== |
==Notable examples== |
Revision as of 00:17, 7 May 2009
This article needs additional citations for verification. (January 2009) |
This article possibly contains original research. (January 2009) |
Space Western is a subgenre of science fiction, primarily grounded in film and television, that transposes themes of American Western books and film to a backdrop of futuristic space frontiers; it is the complement of the science fiction Western, which transposes science fiction themes onto an American Western setting.
"The Final Frontier" as a backdrop
This term supposes that the future of space exploration will be much like the taming of the old west of America. In some cases this may quite literally include frontier towns, train heists, and horses. The short-lived television series Firefly (and subsequent sequel film, Serenity) includes "core" worlds which consist of large high-tech cities and "border" worlds which are uncivilized and unindustrialized, violent, and often dusty. In other cases, only some places in the world have a Western feel, such as Planet Gunsmoke in Trigun. Outlaws thrive in the unmonitored wilderness of the frontier in the conventional western genre, and the space western is no different; outlaws are often a consistent theme.
To some, Western frontier themes or "cowboyish" characters are enough to establish a story or setting as a space Western. Star Trek depicts space as "the Final Frontier". Indeed, the prequel series Star Trek: Enterprise (2001-2005) shows a disorganized and untamed galaxy, from which the peaceful United Federation of Planets would later be established. The StarCraft world setting was designed to feel rough and frontier-like, but contains no obvious visual or thematic throwbacks to Westerns.
Criticisms
This "frontier stories" view of the future is only one of many ways to look at space exploration, and not one embraced by all science fiction writers.
The Turkey City Lexicon,[1] a document produced by the Turkey City science fiction writers' workshop, condemns the space Western as "The most pernicious suite of 'Used Furniture' [that is, use of a pre-established background instead of a freshly created world]."
Galaxy Science Fiction ran an ad on its back cover, "You'll never see it in Galaxy", which gave the beginnings of make-believe parallel Western and SF stories featuring a character named Bat Durston.[2] From this ad stemmed the derisive term "Bat Durston" to refer to the subgenre.[citation needed] A Bat Durston is always a derogatory term, indicating that the entire story could be transplanted to the West without more than cosmetic changes. If the story uses Western motifs but contains a speculative element that can not be removed without redoing the plot, it may be a space Western but not a Bat Durston.
Notable examples
The influence of Westerns on Gene Roddenberry's original concept for Star Trek can be seen in the series' opening narration: "Space, the final frontier ...". Roddenberry pitched Star Trek to network executives as "Wagon Train to the stars."[3]
Tatooine is the quintessential frontier world in the Star Wars universe and the Mos Eisley Cantina is reminiscent of the saloons in old Westerns. In many Western films, the saloon is where alliances are established, and in Star Wars the cantina is the setting for the forging of an important alliance between Luke Skywalker and Han Solo. Han Solo is depicted as cowboyish in both dress and attitude. He displays archetypical characteristics of the American movie cowboy — toughness, independence, and skill with a gun. Han Solo, Boba Fett, and Jango Fett can all be viewed as gunslingers in the Star Wars universe. In Westerns, bounty hunters are commonly depicted as romantic figures, such as the so-called Man with No Name played by Clint Eastwood. George Lucas attributes the character of Boba Fett to The Man with No Name in the DVD commentary on The Empire Strikes Back.
The Adventures of the Galaxy Rangers is another example, this time in cartoon form, of the Space Western theme. The opening trailer shows Texas Rangers-like heroes riding across a prairie landscape on robotic horses. Spaceships and sixguns both figure prominently throughout.
In the Bravestarr universe, the culture and landscape of the colony world where the series is set bears a remarkable resemblance to the culture of the American Old West. And in one episode set on Earth, the city of London resembles Victorian England, lending a steampunk flavor to the series.
One recent hybrid of Westerns and science fiction is the television series Firefly and its cinematic follow-up Serenity. This series not only used Western ideas such as the lawless frontier and the spiritually wounded veteran, but also included Western elements in costuming, design and dialogue (such as the Moses Brothers Self-Defense Engine Frontier Model B). The back-story of Firefly has been called a deliberate echo of the post-American-Civil-War setting of many Westerns, with a hero who fought for the losing side. Director Joss Whedon remarks in the audio commentary about the various Westerns which influenced him and which techniques -- from dialogue to camerawork -- he tried to capture.
Books
- Santiago: a Myth of the Far Future by Mike Resnick
- Northwest Smith by C.L. Moore (short story collection)
- Time Enough For Love by Robert A. Heinlein
- Girl in Landscape by Jonathan Lethem
- Earthman's Burden sequence by Poul Anderson and Gordon R. Dickson
Short stories
- "On The High Frontier" by Michael F. Flynn, Analog, April 1992
Comics
- Death Hawk by Mark Ellis, Adam Hughes and Rik Levins.
- Jonah Hex, a Western comics hero, was for a time transported to a post-apocalyptic 21st century.
- Star Rangers by Mark Ellis and Jim Mooney
- Trigun
Film
- The American Astronaut
- Battle Beyond the Stars, a pastiche of The Magnificent Seven in space
- Bravestarr: The Legend
- Futureworld
- Galaxina
- Ghosts of Mars
- Moon Zero Two
- Oblivion
- Outland
- Serenity - The movie sequel of the short-lived Firefly series.
- Star Trek V: The Final Frontier - the scenes on Nimbus III are heavily influenced by Westerns
- Star Wars
- Stingray Sam
- Titan AE
Games
Television
- The Adventures of the Galaxy Rangers - Syndicated 80s cartoon about interplanetary law enforcers with wild West aesthetics
- Beyond Westworld
- BraveStarr - Syndicated 80s cartoon about high-tech action on a wild West-style colony planet
- Cowboy Bebop - anime
- Firefly - tv show
- Gun X Sword - anime
- Outlaw Star - anime
- Trigun - anime
- Saber Rider and the Star Sheriffs
- Silverhawks - Animated sci-fi series that included a guitar-playing cyborg cowboy named Bluegrass.
- Space Rangers - Short run series about maintaining law and order in the frontier of space in the year 2104
- Wild Arms - anime
Footnotes
- ^ A Primer for SF Workshops
- ^ [Galaxy Science Fiction, Vol. 1 No. 1, October 1950]
- ^ Remembering Gene Roddenberry
References
- Gunn, James (1995). "Teaching Science Fiction". Center for the Study of Science Fiction. University of Kansas. Retrieved 2006-01-15.
- Priestley, J. B. (December 5, 1953) "Thoughts in the Wilderness." New Statesman, p. 712. Cited in Padlipsky, Michael A. (1960), "More Than Pulp(?): Science Fiction and the Problem of Literary Value", undergraduate thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology. URL accessed on January 15, 2006.