Jump to content

RSPCA: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Browse history interactively
← Previous editNext edit →
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Tag: section blanking
m Reverted edits by 80.84.166.47 to last revision by HamburgerRadio (HG)
Line 92: Line 92:


Unlike the RSPCA, local authority employees working for animal welfare, Government Animal Health Officers and the police do have powers to enter in an emergency under the [[Animal Welfare Act]], but normally require a warrant - the RSPCA falls under none of those categories.<ref>http://www.countryside-alliance.org.uk/political/general/enforcement-of-the-animal-welfare-act-2006/ Countryside Alliance</ref> The RSPCA has no powers to prosecute other than by bringing a [[private prosecution]] (again, a right available to any civilian) against those it believes have caused neglect to an animal, though again (and unlike most private citizens) the Society enjoys the benefit of its own legal department, and its own qualified lawyers and veterinary surgeons amongst the resources which facilitate such private prosecutions.<ref>http://www.rspca.org.uk/servlet/Satellite?pagename=RSPCA/RSPCARedirect&pg=prosecutions rspca.org</ref>
Unlike the RSPCA, local authority employees working for animal welfare, Government Animal Health Officers and the police do have powers to enter in an emergency under the [[Animal Welfare Act]], but normally require a warrant - the RSPCA falls under none of those categories.<ref>http://www.countryside-alliance.org.uk/political/general/enforcement-of-the-animal-welfare-act-2006/ Countryside Alliance</ref> The RSPCA has no powers to prosecute other than by bringing a [[private prosecution]] (again, a right available to any civilian) against those it believes have caused neglect to an animal, though again (and unlike most private citizens) the Society enjoys the benefit of its own legal department, and its own qualified lawyers and veterinary surgeons amongst the resources which facilitate such private prosecutions.<ref>http://www.rspca.org.uk/servlet/Satellite?pagename=RSPCA/RSPCARedirect&pg=prosecutions rspca.org</ref>

==Controversy and criticism==
The charity has been criticised for preparing witnesses before trials through the use of [[pro-forma]] statements.<ref>''[[Private Eye]]'' "Down on the Farm" No. 1208 18 April 2008 Pressdram Ltd.</ref>

===Bhaktivedanta Manor Hindu Temple===
Hindu groups have expressed concern over the killing of a cow (named [[Gangotri (cow)|Gangotri]]) by the RSPCA. The cow was being kept at the Bhaktivedanta Manor temple in Hertfordshire when, on December 13, 2007, RSPCA inspectors and a government vet arrived at the temple and administered a lethal injection to the animal. The cow had damaged her hind muscles and could not stand, resulting in [[bed sore]]s, although she was not suffering from any disease.<ref>[http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2007/12/14/ngangotri114.xml Telegraph article]</ref> The temple, donated in 1973 by musician [[George Harrison]], runs The Cow Protection Project where cows and bulls are allowed to die naturally. The RSPCA claimed that a cow was killed to prevent further suffering, however Temple officials claim that:
<blockquote>
"Two veterinary surgeons, one who lived locally and the other a specialist based in Oxford, were regularly supervising the cow’s medical treatment. They were administering medicine themselves, and also guiding the daily care being given by the community members. It is normal farming practise that once a cow is down or cannot walk, she will be killed by the vet because, within a few weeks, physical complications will arise that most farmers don’t have the time to deal with. As a religious community, we made the choice to care, and those two vets chose to support us. Two other vets, who were unfamiliar with the way we work with animals, one of whom was merely a passer-by, gave different opinions. At first, the chief vet responsible for animal welfare in the appropriate government department, known as Defra, also gave a recommendation that the cow be killed. When he made a personal visit to the temple however, and saw how the animal was being cared for, he informed us that no further action would be taken".<ref>[http://www.justiceforgangotri.org/myths-and-facts/ Myths and Facts<!-- Bot generated title -->]</ref>
</blockquote> The temple officials are considering legal action against the RSPCA over its actions.<ref>[http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/faith/article3047068.ece Times Online Article] </ref> On December 26, 2007, about 200 people protested at the RSPCA headquarters in Horsham, West Sussex, while another 700 Hindus held prayers at the Manor.<ref> [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/7160055.stm Hindus protest over cow slaughter]</ref> In December 2008 the RSPCA apologized for the way they had handled the killing of Gangotri.<ref>http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7780665.stm</ref>

===Lack of statutory powers and allegations of police impersonation===
[[Image:Rspca-police-chief-super.png|thumb|right|Comparison of RSPCA Chief Superintendent insignia (left) and British police [[Chief Superintendent]] insignia (right)]]

The RSPCA rank names and rank insignia share similarity with [[Police ranks of the United Kingdom#Rank insignia|British police ranks]], which has led some critics (such as Chris Newman, chairman of the Federation of Companion Animal Societies<ref name=times-invasionofprivacy>http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/law/article1848410.ece</ref>) to suggest an attempt to 'adopt' police powers in the public imagination. Against this suggestion it must be remembered that the 'bath star' and 'royal crown' are used in various combinations to identify British military rank, and have therefore been adopted by many organisations in British and Commonwealth nations to indicate ranks. The same series of rank markings are used not only by the RSPCA and the British police, but also by such disparate organisations as the [[British Army]] (who do have statutory powers) and the [[St John Ambulance]] Brigade (who, like the RSPCA, have no statutory powers).

When [[Richard Girling]] of the [[Times newspaper]] asked about their lack of powers, a spokesman for the RSPCA said "We would prefer you didn’t publish that, but of course its up to you".<ref name=times-invasionofprivacy/> Chris Newman, chairman of the Federation of Companion Animal Societies, claimed that the RSCPA "impersonate police officers and commit trespass. People do believe they have powers of entry";<ref name=times-invasionofprivacy/> however, he did not produce any evidence of such impersonation of police officers, and the Society strongly deny the charge, a spokesman stating: "We would never try to mislead anyone".<ref name=times-invasionofprivacy/>

It is also of note that RSPCA personnel may issue individuals with cautions using the exact or very similar wording to that of arresting police officers, i.e. "You do not have to say anything, but anything you do say will be taken down...." etc. Although no statutory powers are required to issue a caution, doing so in such a manner is likely to lend support to criticisms of RSPCA staff impersonating police officers or other organisations' personnel who do in fact have statutory powers, including those of right of entry and arrest.

===Disability Now===
The RSPCA has also been criticised by ''Disability Now'' magazine for unfairly targeting elderly and disabled people,<ref name=disabilitynow1>http://www.disabilitynow.org.uk/living/features/hounded/</ref> although in the great majority of cases cited by the organisation there is agreement{{Citation needed|date=September 2009}} that animals were allowed to suffer. ''Disability Now'' maintains that the owners of these various animals required help with their disability (which in many cases was mental disability related to depression), whilst the RSPCA maintains that regardless of the cause it has a first duty to prevent the suffering of the animals involved. Both positions have met with judicial support in different court cases and appeals procedures.<ref name=disabilitynow1/>

===Fund-raising in Scotland===

The RSPCA has been criticised by the [[Scottish Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals|Scottish SPCA]] for fund-raising in Scotland and thereby "stealing food from the mouths of animals north of the border by taking donations intended for Scotland."<ref>[http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/7865965.stm Animal groups in bitter cash row] BBC News, 3 January 2009</ref> The RSPCA insists that it does not deliberately advertise in Scotland but that many satellite channels only enabled the organisation to purchase UK-wide advertising. It is however worth noting that in these adverts they do little to ensure Scottish viewers are aware of the distinction thereby encouraging donations from those unaware the Scottish equivalent is a separate organisation. The Scottish SPCA changed its logo in 2005 to make a clearer distinction between itself and the RSPCA in an attempt to prevent legacies being left to its English equivalent by mistake when the Scottish charity was intended.<ref>[http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/4736459.stm New identity for animal charity] BBC News, 1 August 2005</ref>


==See also==
==See also==

Revision as of 00:43, 31 October 2009

This article is about the original RSPCA in England and Wales. Similarly named societies in other countries are listed (with links) at the SPCA disambiguation page.
Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Founded1824
FounderRichard Martin, William Wilberforce, Reverend Arthur Broome
Location

The Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA) is a charity in England and Wales that promotes animal welfare. It is the oldest and largest animal welfare organisation in the world[1] and is one of the largest charities in the UK. Queen Elizabeth II is its patron.[2]

Founded as the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) in 1824, it adopted its current name after being granted royal status by Queen Victoria in 1840. It has inspired the creation of similar groups in other nations, starting with the Ulster Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals in Northern Ireland and including the Scottish Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (Scottish SPCA or SSPCA), Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Australia, the Royal New Zealand Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RNZSPCA), and the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.

The RSPCA is funded entirely by voluntary donations and in 2006 reported an income in excess of £110 million[3].

History

The Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals was founded in 1824 by a group of twenty-two reformers led by Richard Martin MP (who would thereby earn the nickname Humanity Dick), William Wilberforce MP and the Reverend Arthur Broome originally as a society to support the working of Richard Martin's Act. This Act had been passed in Parliament on 22 July 1822 and was against cruelty to farm animals, particularly cattle. The group assembled at the "Old Slaughters" Coffee House in London to create a society with the will and authority to enforce the new law.[4]

The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals was the first animal welfare charity to be founded in the world. It was granted its royal status by Queen Victoria in 1840 to become the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals.[5]

William Wilberforce was already famous from his work to abolish slavery in the British Empire.

At first the organisation did not employ Inspectors. A committee inspected the markets, slaughterhouses and the conduct of city coachmen. Rev Arthur Broome, from his own funds, employed a Mr Wheeler and his assistant, Charles Teasdall. In 1824 they brought sixty three offenders before the Courts.[6]

In the late 1830s the Society began the tradition of the Inspector, which is the image best known of the RSPCA today. By 1841 there were five Inspectors, each paid a guinea a week, based in London, who travelled to various parts of the country bringing suspected offenders before the Courts.[7]

RSPCA lobbied parliament throughout the 19th century resulting in a number of pieces of legislation. The Cruelty to Animals Act 1835 amended Martin's Act and outlawed baiting. In 1876 the Cruelty to Animals Act was passed to control animal experimentation. In 1911 Parliament passed Sir George Greenwood's Animal Protection Act.

Since then the RSPCA in England/Wales, in Australia and the other independent SPCA groups around the world have continued to play an active role, both in the creation of animal welfare legislation and in its enforcement.

Structure today

The 1830s introduction of Inspectors also encouraged local supporters of the RSPCA to band together. Supporters were able to form a local 'Branch', and if the Branch raised sufficient funds then it could employ an Inspector. Today there are 172 local Branches of the RSPCA, which are locally funded.

Branches

Local Branches are responsible for a range of animal facilities, depending upon the fund-raising capacity of the Branch. These local facilities include almost 100 animal clinics and welfare centres (including 4 specialist wildlife centres). The branches run, between them, 207 charity shops for fund raising purposes. Local branches are also responsible for local staffing. There is a certain reliance on volunteer staff members for fund-raising, secretarial, and administrative duties, whilst other staff must be employed. Local staff include: Veterinary Staff: Hospital & Clinic Assistants, Veterinary Nurses, Veterinary Surgeons (almost all are full-time). General Staff: Fund-raisers, administrators, secretaries (a large proportion are volunteers). Animal Care Assistants: ACAs, senior ACAs, Animal Centre Managers (many full-time, but supported by volunteers). Animal Collection Officers: ACO’s were previously designated a distinctive green uniform, but can now be seen in white shirt and black tie along with blue jumper.[citation needed] They are required to demonstrate animal-handling skills and a basic understanding of wildlife, although there are no specific educational qualifications a 3 year valid driving license is required as well as 'robust physical health'. They are also expected to carry out euthanasia (subject to training after 3 months employment) where necessary, although they must undertake a criminal records bureau check and the attendance of an ethics course.[8] Staff or volunteers wishing to train as Inspectors are required to demonstrate certain minimum standards in formal education.

Groups

Local Branches, their staff, and the Inspectors who work in them, report through a structured chain of command, divided geographically into 'Groups'. A Group is headed by a Chief Inspector. Each Chief Inspector might typically be responsible for around 7 Inspectors, 3 ACOs, and 1 specialist Inspector (Port Inspector, or Market Inspector, for example) working with several local Branches.[9]

Regions

The Groups are collected into five 'Regions' (North, East, Wales & West, South & South West, South East), each headed by a Superintendent. Despite being geographically large areas, the regional Superintendents are expected to have a broad understanding of operations throughout their regions.[10]

National

At the national level, there is a 'National Control Centre', which receives all calls from members of the public, and tasks local Inspectors or Animal collection officers to respond to urgent calls by means of an airwaves set. Additionally the 'National Headquarters' located at Horsham in West Sussex houses several general 'Departments', each with a departmental head, usually a Chief Superintendent. These national Departments include, for example, 'Training', 'Operations', and 'Special Operations'. The Chief Superintendents, as Heads of Department, report to the Chief Officer (the senior member of the uniformed Inspectorate) and the Society's 'Directors'. The current Chief Officer is felix singh.

Rank insignia

Template:RSPCA rank table

Mission statement and charitable status

The RSPCA is a registered charity (no. 219099) that receives no lottery or state aid. In 2006 it had an annual expenditure of £95.5 million, placing it in the top 40 of UK charities.[11] Its annual running costs are funded exclusively by voluntary donations and legacies.

The RSPCA as a charity will, by all lawful means, prevent cruelty, promote kindness to and alleviate suffering of animals.

The RSPCA intends to achieve its mission by

  • effecting strong branch, regional, national and international organisations dedicated to providing a public service, delivering effective relief of animal suffering and enforcing the law
  • working tirelessly to reduce the harmful impact of human activities on animals through education, campaigning and the application of ethics, science and law
  • striving for the highest levels of efficiency, effectiveness and integrity
  • urging that, save where the public benefit requires, humankind should not intentionally cause suffering to any animal when it is not for its own benefit, or cause suffering by neglect. This applies whatever the animal, or the situation in which it finds itself.[12]

Thanks to the opportunities it provides for the personal development of young people, the RSPCA is a member of The National Council for Voluntary Youth Services (NCVYS)[13].

Functions

The RSPCA operates a number of sites that can hold lost, neglected, injured or otherwise homeless animals. Only if an animal cannot be returned or re-homed is it put down. The majority of animals killed by the RSPCA are sick or injured to an extent that it is the only humane course of action. It also operates specialist veterinary hospitals and clinics, as well as animal collection centres.

RSPCA inspectors respond to calls from the public to investigate alleged mistreatment of animals. These officers are normal civilians and have no special rights nor statutory powers. Like other civilians, they may not enter anyone's premises without permission; they do, however, benefit (unlike other citizens) from specialist training and equipment, and a regular interaction with local police forces, which enables them more easily than most to seek assistance from the local police force, which may ask a magistrate for a search warrant, to enter private homes.

Unlike the RSPCA, local authority employees working for animal welfare, Government Animal Health Officers and the police do have powers to enter in an emergency under the Animal Welfare Act, but normally require a warrant - the RSPCA falls under none of those categories.[14] The RSPCA has no powers to prosecute other than by bringing a private prosecution (again, a right available to any civilian) against those it believes have caused neglect to an animal, though again (and unlike most private citizens) the Society enjoys the benefit of its own legal department, and its own qualified lawyers and veterinary surgeons amongst the resources which facilitate such private prosecutions.[15]

Controversy and criticism

The charity has been criticised for preparing witnesses before trials through the use of pro-forma statements.[16]

Bhaktivedanta Manor Hindu Temple

Hindu groups have expressed concern over the killing of a cow (named Gangotri) by the RSPCA. The cow was being kept at the Bhaktivedanta Manor temple in Hertfordshire when, on December 13, 2007, RSPCA inspectors and a government vet arrived at the temple and administered a lethal injection to the animal. The cow had damaged her hind muscles and could not stand, resulting in bed sores, although she was not suffering from any disease.[17] The temple, donated in 1973 by musician George Harrison, runs The Cow Protection Project where cows and bulls are allowed to die naturally. The RSPCA claimed that a cow was killed to prevent further suffering, however Temple officials claim that:

"Two veterinary surgeons, one who lived locally and the other a specialist based in Oxford, were regularly supervising the cow’s medical treatment. They were administering medicine themselves, and also guiding the daily care being given by the community members. It is normal farming practise that once a cow is down or cannot walk, she will be killed by the vet because, within a few weeks, physical complications will arise that most farmers don’t have the time to deal with. As a religious community, we made the choice to care, and those two vets chose to support us. Two other vets, who were unfamiliar with the way we work with animals, one of whom was merely a passer-by, gave different opinions. At first, the chief vet responsible for animal welfare in the appropriate government department, known as Defra, also gave a recommendation that the cow be killed. When he made a personal visit to the temple however, and saw how the animal was being cared for, he informed us that no further action would be taken".[18]

The temple officials are considering legal action against the RSPCA over its actions.[19] On December 26, 2007, about 200 people protested at the RSPCA headquarters in Horsham, West Sussex, while another 700 Hindus held prayers at the Manor.[20] In December 2008 the RSPCA apologized for the way they had handled the killing of Gangotri.[21]

Lack of statutory powers and allegations of police impersonation

Comparison of RSPCA Chief Superintendent insignia (left) and British police Chief Superintendent insignia (right)

The RSPCA rank names and rank insignia share similarity with British police ranks, which has led some critics (such as Chris Newman, chairman of the Federation of Companion Animal Societies[22]) to suggest an attempt to 'adopt' police powers in the public imagination. Against this suggestion it must be remembered that the 'bath star' and 'royal crown' are used in various combinations to identify British military rank, and have therefore been adopted by many organisations in British and Commonwealth nations to indicate ranks. The same series of rank markings are used not only by the RSPCA and the British police, but also by such disparate organisations as the British Army (who do have statutory powers) and the St John Ambulance Brigade (who, like the RSPCA, have no statutory powers).

When Richard Girling of the Times newspaper asked about their lack of powers, a spokesman for the RSPCA said "We would prefer you didn’t publish that, but of course its up to you".[22] Chris Newman, chairman of the Federation of Companion Animal Societies, claimed that the RSCPA "impersonate police officers and commit trespass. People do believe they have powers of entry";[22] however, he did not produce any evidence of such impersonation of police officers, and the Society strongly deny the charge, a spokesman stating: "We would never try to mislead anyone".[22]

It is also of note that RSPCA personnel may issue individuals with cautions using the exact or very similar wording to that of arresting police officers, i.e. "You do not have to say anything, but anything you do say will be taken down...." etc. Although no statutory powers are required to issue a caution, doing so in such a manner is likely to lend support to criticisms of RSPCA staff impersonating police officers or other organisations' personnel who do in fact have statutory powers, including those of right of entry and arrest.

Disability Now

The RSPCA has also been criticised by Disability Now magazine for unfairly targeting elderly and disabled people,[23] although in the great majority of cases cited by the organisation there is agreement[citation needed] that animals were allowed to suffer. Disability Now maintains that the owners of these various animals required help with their disability (which in many cases was mental disability related to depression), whilst the RSPCA maintains that regardless of the cause it has a first duty to prevent the suffering of the animals involved. Both positions have met with judicial support in different court cases and appeals procedures.[23]

Fund-raising in Scotland

The RSPCA has been criticised by the Scottish SPCA for fund-raising in Scotland and thereby "stealing food from the mouths of animals north of the border by taking donations intended for Scotland."[24] The RSPCA insists that it does not deliberately advertise in Scotland but that many satellite channels only enabled the organisation to purchase UK-wide advertising. It is however worth noting that in these adverts they do little to ensure Scottish viewers are aware of the distinction thereby encouraging donations from those unaware the Scottish equivalent is a separate organisation. The Scottish SPCA changed its logo in 2005 to make a clearer distinction between itself and the RSPCA in an attempt to prevent legacies being left to its English equivalent by mistake when the Scottish charity was intended.[25]

See also

Further reading

  • Who Cares For Animals: 150 years of the RSPCA by Antony Brown.[26]
  • Animal Experimentation: A Guide to the Issues Vaughan Monamy, Cambridge University Press

References

  1. ^ http://www.rspca.org.uk/servlet/Satellite?pagename=RSPCA/RSPCARedirect&pg=FundraisingHomepage Retrieved on 2009-01-30
  2. ^ http://www.rspca.org.uk/servlet/Satellite?pagename=RSPCA/RSPCARedirect&pg=about_the_rspca&marker=1&articleId=1144060334919 Retrieved on 2008-09-30
  3. ^ http://www.guidestar.org.uk/gs_summary.aspx?CCReg=219099 Retrieved on 2009-01-30
  4. ^ http://www.animallaw.info/historical/articles/arukrspcahist.htm retrieved on 2008-03-24
  5. ^ http://www.rspca-durham.org.uk/history.html Retrieved on 2008-03-24
  6. ^ http://www.animallaw.info/historical/articles/arukrspcahist.htm Retrieved on 2008-03-24
  7. ^ http://www.rspca.org.au/about/history_origins.asp Retrieved on 2008-03-24
  8. ^ Animal collection officer requirements are outlined on the RSPCA careers page[1].
  9. ^ This typical Group structure is outlined in the RSPCA job description document available on-line here.
  10. ^ This RSPCA web page includes a regional map of the five regions.
  11. ^ Charities Direct
  12. ^ http://www.rspca.org.uk/servlet/Satellite?pagename=RSPCA/RSPCARedirect&pg=about_the_rspca&marker=1&articleId=1163248954407 Retrieved on 2008-03-24
  13. ^ Full list of NCVYS members
  14. ^ http://www.countryside-alliance.org.uk/political/general/enforcement-of-the-animal-welfare-act-2006/ Countryside Alliance
  15. ^ http://www.rspca.org.uk/servlet/Satellite?pagename=RSPCA/RSPCARedirect&pg=prosecutions rspca.org
  16. ^ Private Eye "Down on the Farm" No. 1208 18 April 2008 Pressdram Ltd.
  17. ^ Telegraph article
  18. ^ Myths and Facts
  19. ^ Times Online Article
  20. ^ Hindus protest over cow slaughter
  21. ^ http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7780665.stm
  22. ^ a b c d http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/law/article1848410.ece
  23. ^ a b http://www.disabilitynow.org.uk/living/features/hounded/
  24. ^ Animal groups in bitter cash row BBC News, 3 January 2009
  25. ^ New identity for animal charity BBC News, 1 August 2005
  26. ^ Detail from a copy of the book, published by Heinemann of London in 1974 with an ISBN of 434 90189 X. The chapters relate to the Origin of the Society, and finishes with prospects for the future, with a foreword by John Hobhouse (Chairman of the RSPCA). Appendix section includes a List of Past Presidents and Accounts information.

Video clips

Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/enwiki/w/index.php?title=RSPCA&oldid=323020722"