Jump to content

Emergency medical services in Poland: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Line 3: Line 3:
== Standards ==
== Standards ==
===Operating system===
===Operating system===
At the moment, the operating system of Polish [[Emergency medical services|EMS]] is a variant of the Franco-German delivery model, and is physician-led..<ref>{{cite journal|author=Cooke MW, Bridge P, Wilson S.|title=Variation in emergency ambulance dispatch in Western Europe|journal=The Scandinavian Journal of Trauma and Emergency Medicine|volume=9|issue=2|pages=57–66|year=2001}}</ref> Physicians (usually [[anaesthetists]]) respond to most emergency calls, and a great deal of definitive care and even simple physician consultation and discharge occur at the scene. As in the German system, these physicians are often referred to as '''Emergency Physicians'''.<ref>{{citeweb|url=http://www.medycynaratunkowa.com.pl/|title=Polish Society for Emergency Medicine website (in Polish)|accessdate=2009-01-02}}</ref> Emergency medicine has been recognized as a medical specialty since [[1999]]. Due to shortage of specialists in emergency medicine, selected other medical specialists (anesthesiology and intensive care, internal diseases, general surgery, pediatrics, pediatric surgery, orthopaedics and traumatology) are allowed to work in the system until [[2015]]. Unlike the [[Emergency medical services in Germany|German]] system, the physicians do not respond in separate vehicles, instead staffing the appropriate types of ambulances directly. Transportation to [[hospital]] may, or may not, be an outcome. The variation occurs in that the [[physician]] may be supported by either [[paramedics]] or [[nurses]], or some mix of the two roles. Each [[ambulance]] also has a dedicated driver, with minimal medical training. As the system evolves, however, it will be changing. Paramedic-led ambulances will respond to most emergency calls, as in the Anglo-American model,<ref>{{cite journal |author=Dick WF |title=Anglo-American vs. Franco-German
At the moment, the operating system of Polish [[Emergency medical services|EMS]] is similar of the Austrian- Franco-German-Spanish delivery model, and is physician-led and an Integrated EMS of Public Health (IEMS) .<ref>{{cite journal|author=Cooke MW, Bridge P, Wilson S.|title=Variation in emergency ambulance dispatch in Western Europe|journal=The Scandinavian Journal of Trauma and Emergency Medicine|volume=9|issue=2|pages=57–66|year=2001}}</ref> Physicians (usually [[anaesthetists]]) respond to most emergency calls, and a great deal of definitive care and even simple physician consultation and discharge occur at the scene. These physicians are often referred to as '''Emergency Physicians'''.<ref>{{citeweb|url=http://www.medycynaratunkowa.com.pl/|title=Polish Society for Emergency Medicine website (in Polish)|accessdate=2009-01-02}}</ref> Emergency medicine has been recognized as a medical specialty since [[1999]]. Due to shortage of specialists in emergency medicine, selected other medical specialists (anesthesiology and intensive care, internal diseases, general surgery, pediatrics, pediatric surgery, orthopaedics and traumatology) are allowed to work in the system until [[2015]]. Unlike the [[Emergency medical services in Germany|German]] system, the physicians do not respond in separate vehicles, instead staffing the appropriate types of ambulances directly. Transportation to [[hospital]] may, or may not, be an outcome it depends of decision the MICU Physician . The variation occurs in that the [[physician]] may be supported by either [[paramedics]] or [[nurses]], or some mix of the two roles. Each [[ambulance]] also has a dedicated Ambulance Technician who drives, with minimal medical training. As the system evolves, however, it will be changing. Paramedic-led ambulances will respond to most emergency calls, as in the Anglo-American model,<ref>{{cite journal |author=Dick WF |title=Anglo-American vs. Franco-German
emergency medical services system |journal=Prehosp Disaster Med |volume=18 |issue=1 |pages=29–35; discussion 35–7 |year=2003 |pmid=14694898 |doi= |url=}}</ref> with physicians being sent only to those calls where there is a potential threat to life. This change is currently expected to occur in 2010.
emergency medical services system |journal=Prehosp Disaster Med |volume=18 |issue=1 |pages=29–35; discussion 35–7 |year=2003 |pmid=14694898 |doi= |url=}}</ref> with physicians being "sent" only to those calls where there is a potential critical threat to life. This change is currently expected to occur in 2010 but who will decide for extrahospital primary MICU interventions? A Samu french like Physician Regulator? or a Dispatcher?


===Vehicles and equipment===
===Vehicles and equipment===
Line 11: Line 11:
===Training===
===Training===
Since 2006, the evolving legal standard of training for Polish paramedics is a three year Bachelor's degree. As an option, those with substantial prior experience may proceed to a degree, following two years of additional study. This program is available in a number of Polish universities, and will completely replace the prior training standard, which consisted of an assortment of short courses. Short courses of various types continue to be offered, but these are now essentially the typical short courses found elsewhere in EMS, including [[Advanced Cardiac Life Support]] and [[Pediatric Advanced Life Support]], among others.<ref>{{citeweb|url=http://translate.google.ca/translate?hl=en&sl=pl&u=http://www.ratownik-med.prv.pl/&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=2&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3DRatownictwo%2BMedyczne%26hl%3Den%26sa%3DG|title= Polish EMS Education website|accessdate=2009-01-02}}</ref>
Since 2006, the evolving legal standard of training for Polish paramedics is a three year Bachelor's degree. As an option, those with substantial prior experience may proceed to a degree, following two years of additional study. This program is available in a number of Polish universities, and will completely replace the prior training standard, which consisted of an assortment of short courses. Short courses of various types continue to be offered, but these are now essentially the typical short courses found elsewhere in EMS, including [[Advanced Cardiac Life Support]] and [[Pediatric Advanced Life Support]], among others.<ref>{{citeweb|url=http://translate.google.ca/translate?hl=en&sl=pl&u=http://www.ratownik-med.prv.pl/&sa=X&oi=translate&resnum=2&ct=result&prev=/search%3Fq%3DRatownictwo%2BMedyczne%26hl%3Den%26sa%3DG|title= Polish EMS Education website|accessdate=2009-01-02}}</ref>

===Future Medical Regulation of the Polish Emergency System the Polish point of Vue===


==System configuration ==
==System configuration ==

Revision as of 10:03, 31 July 2010

Emergency Medical Services (Template:Lang-pl, RM) in Poland is a service of public pre-hospital emergency healthcare, including (but not limited to) ambulance service, provided by individual Polish cities and counties. These services are typically provided by the local, publicly operated hospital, and funded by the government of Poland. In a number of cases, the hospitals contract these services to private operators. In addition to publicly-funded services, there are also a variety of private-for-profit ambulance services operating independently, as well.[1]

Standards

Operating system

At the moment, the operating system of Polish EMS is similar of the Austrian- Franco-German-Spanish delivery model, and is physician-led and an Integrated EMS of Public Health (IEMS) .[2] Physicians (usually anaesthetists) respond to most emergency calls, and a great deal of definitive care and even simple physician consultation and discharge occur at the scene. These physicians are often referred to as Emergency Physicians.[3] Emergency medicine has been recognized as a medical specialty since 1999. Due to shortage of specialists in emergency medicine, selected other medical specialists (anesthesiology and intensive care, internal diseases, general surgery, pediatrics, pediatric surgery, orthopaedics and traumatology) are allowed to work in the system until 2015. Unlike the German system, the physicians do not respond in separate vehicles, instead staffing the appropriate types of ambulances directly. Transportation to hospital may, or may not, be an outcome it depends of decision the MICU Physician . The variation occurs in that the physician may be supported by either paramedics or nurses, or some mix of the two roles. Each ambulance also has a dedicated Ambulance Technician who drives, with minimal medical training. As the system evolves, however, it will be changing. Paramedic-led ambulances will respond to most emergency calls, as in the Anglo-American model,[4] with physicians being "sent" only to those calls where there is a potential critical threat to life. This change is currently expected to occur in 2010 but who will decide for extrahospital primary MICU interventions? A Samu french like Physician Regulator? or a Dispatcher?

Vehicles and equipment

Poland has voluntarily adopted the majority of the specifications for ambulances of European Standard CEN 1789.[5] Ambulances and equipment used do comply with the technical standards outlined. While design and technical standards are voluntarily complied with, there is no current compliance with the visual identity standards described in the Standard. There are also no immediate plans to do so. While plans are in place for the restructuring of some aspects of the EMS system, these are mostly related to staffing configurations and deployment, which are not covered by the technical Standard. It appears unlikely that the proposed changes will have any effect on Standard compliance.

Training

Since 2006, the evolving legal standard of training for Polish paramedics is a three year Bachelor's degree. As an option, those with substantial prior experience may proceed to a degree, following two years of additional study. This program is available in a number of Polish universities, and will completely replace the prior training standard, which consisted of an assortment of short courses. Short courses of various types continue to be offered, but these are now essentially the typical short courses found elsewhere in EMS, including Advanced Cardiac Life Support and Pediatric Advanced Life Support, among others.[6]

Future Medical Regulation of the Polish Emergency System the Polish point of Vue

System configuration

Ratownictwo Medyczne service delivery units

  • Pogotowie Ratunkowe (EMS stations)
  • Lotnicze Pogotowie Ratunkowe (LPR) (Air ambulance stations)[7]
  • Fire Brigade - In the Polish system firefighters provide a level of tiered response to assist Polish EMS in exceptional circumstances, including fires and motor vehicle accidents. The training provided to Polish firefighters is limited to first aid and what might be described as ABC (medicine). As a result, their participation in emergency medical responses is less common than what those in North America would be accustomed to.[8]

Vehicles

Land ambulance

The vehicles of the Polish EMS system come in a wide variety of shapes and sizes. As a member of the European Union, Poland has decided to ratify most aspects of the requirements of European standard CEN 1789 for ambulances, as reflected in the Polish EN 1789 (Classes A-C) Standard.[9] The visual identity requirements of the European standard for ambulances are not yet being followed. The three major types of vehicle are:

  • The patient transport ambulance (T), which is smaller, conforms to European Class A, and contains less staff and equipment.
  • The ambulans reanimacyjny (R) (English: resuscitation ambulance) , is a larger van used for serious emergencies. This unit type is the first choice for response to emergencies that appear to be immediately life-threatening. While some CEN 1789 Class B vehicles are still present in the system, the objective is to ultimately ensure that this type of ambulance is always a Class C.
  • The ambulans wypadkowy (W) (English: emergency ambulance) , is a van-type ambulance used for emergencies when a Type R ambulance is unavailable. They are used for physician consultation calls or for non-emergency transport. These vehicles conform to the CEN 1789 Class B standard, although sometimes Class C ambulances are seen in this role.

In addition, the system also operates specialty ambulances which are equipped for and dedicated to neonatal transport (Type N), which are not used for any other purpose.

Air ambulance

Polish Lotnicze Pogotowie Ratunkowe (LPR) currently operates about 18 helicopter air ambulances strategically located in large cities throughout Poland.[10] In addition, fixed wing aircraft are used for longer distance transports. Many of the aircraft used continue to be of the old era of Soviet domination, however, this is gradually changing. The government of Poland placed an order for 23 new Eurocopter EC-135 aircraft in August, 2008, with delivery expected in 2009-2010. Now (july 2010) LPR use 6 new EC-135.[11] These will replace all of the old Soviet-era aircraft, and will bring Poland into full compliance with the existing European Standard JAR OPS-3 for air ambulances.[12]

Equipment

Polish paramedics at work

The basic required equipment of the Type R and Type W ambulances (and in the future the Type S and Type P ambulances) is as follows. This equipment is obligatory and represents minimal requirements:

Communications

All ambulances in Poland are dispatched from centralized regional dispatch centers (Polish: Centrum Powiadamiania Ratunkowego)(CPR). The traditional standardized emergency telephone number for ambulances in Poland in the POTS telephone system is 999. The standard European Emergency Number, 1-1-2 also works in Poland, including mobile systems, and is gradually replacing 999. Calls are then triaged by interview process, and the closest and most correct type of ambulance resource is sent to the call. E112 is a location-enhanced version of 112. The telecom operator transmits the location information to the emergency centre. The EU Directive E112 (2003) requires mobile phone networks to provide emergency services with whatever information they have about the location a mobile call was made.[13] This directive is based on the American Federal Communications Commission's Enhanced 911 ruling in 2001.[14]

System changes

Current staffing

In Poland, there were two types of emergency ambulances, type R (now S), and type W (P),[15] which are staffed as follows:

  • Ambulance type S (specialized) - 3 people including a physician, paramedic or nurse, and a driver-paramedic.
  • Ambulance type P - 3 including a physician or paramedic or nurse, 1 paramedic or nurse, and a driver-paramedic. Or 2 people Nurse or paramedic and driver-paramedic.

Coming reforms

Ambulance type (P) in Bydgoszcz's street - unit P1

The government of Poland has mandated significant changes within the EMS system. These will include more paramedic-led ambulances and less physician-led ambulances. The proposed system will more closely resemble the Anglo-American model, with ALS and BLS units, except that this would be something of a poor analogy. Polish paramedics do perform ALS skills without a physician present, so a better description might be "ALS" and "More ALS". These changes are proposed to occur in 2010, with the acquisition of some 600 new ambulances by the Polish government; the result of industrial action by Polish paramedics.[16] Patient transport ambulances (Type T) and neonatal transport ambulances (Type N) will remain in their current configurations. The new types of ambulances and staffing patterns will be as follows:

  • The ambulans specialistyczny (S) (English: specialist ambulance) will be a larger van used for serious emergencies. This will be used only for potentially life-threatening responses. Standard personnel staffing will consist of a doctor (with emergency medicine specialization), two paramedics or nurses, and a driver/orderly. The vehicle used will be in all cases a CEN 1789 Class C ambulance. The new ambulance category, Type S will replace the Type R ambulance in the "More ALS" category.
  • The ambulans podstawowy (P) (English: basic ambulance) will be a standard van-type ambulance used for emergency responses when a Type S unit is unavailable, and for lower priority emergency calls. Such vehicles will not be used for consultations, or for non-emergency transport. Standard staffing of personnel will consist of 2 paramedics and a driver/orderly. The new category, Type P will replace the old Type W vehicle configuration. Type P ambulances will conform to, at minimum, CEN 1789 Class B, with the option at a local level to use Class C vehicles instead.

References

  1. ^ "Falck Website". Retrieved 2009-01-05.
  2. ^ Cooke MW, Bridge P, Wilson S. (2001). "Variation in emergency ambulance dispatch in Western Europe". The Scandinavian Journal of Trauma and Emergency Medicine. 9 (2): 57–66.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  3. ^ "Polish Society for Emergency Medicine website (in Polish)". Retrieved 2009-01-02.
  4. ^ Dick WF (2003). "Anglo-American vs. Franco-German emergency medical services system". Prehosp Disaster Med. 18 (1): 29–35, discussion 35–7. PMID 14694898. {{cite journal}}: line feed character in |title= at position 34 (help)
  5. ^ Committee on European Standards (2007). "Medical Vehicles and their Equipment 2" ([dead link]). Cen En 1789.
  6. ^ "Polish EMS Education website". Retrieved 2009-01-02.
  7. ^ "LPR website (translated from Polish)". Retrieved 2009-01-05.
  8. ^ "Polish National Fire Service website (translated from Polish)". Retrieved 2009-01-05.
  9. ^ Ferreira, Hignett, JS (2005). "Reviewing Ambulance Design for Clinical Efficiency and Paramedic Safety" (PDF). Applied Ergonomics. 3: 97–105.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  10. ^ "LPR homepage (in Polish)". Retrieved 2009-01-03.
  11. ^ "Poland's Ministry of Health Orders 23 EC-135s for Nationwide Emergency Medical Service". Retrieved 2009-01-05.
  12. ^ "Helicopter Aeromedical Transport: The Advent of JAR OPS3". Retrieved 2009-01-05.
  13. ^ "European Commission Technical Specification TSGS#21(03)0372" (PDF). Retrieved 2009-01-03.
  14. ^ "Enhanced 911 (FCC website)". Retrieved 2009-01-03.
  15. ^ Guła P, Hładki W, Górski K, Popławska M (2008). "[Simplified schema of action of the ambulance rescue services during mass casualty]". Prz. Lek. (in Polish). 65 (1): 1–3. PMID 18669100.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  16. ^ "Medical rescue workers stage protest for better conditions and pay". Retrieved 2009-01-05.

See also