Jump to content

List of HDL simulators: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
m Spelling.
added historic note on Speedsim
Line 31: Line 31:
|- ||
|- ||
| [http://www.dolphin-integration.com/medal/smash/smash_overview.php SMASH] || [http://www.dolphin-integration.com Dolphin Integration] || V1995, VHDL-1993 || SMASH is a mixed-signal, multi-language simulator for IC or PCB designs. It uses [[SPICE]] syntax for analog descriptions, Verilog-HDL and VHDL for digital, Verilog-A/AMS, VHDL-AMS and ABCD (a combination of SPICE and C) for analog behavioral, and C for DSP algorithms.
| [http://www.dolphin-integration.com/medal/smash/smash_overview.php SMASH] || [http://www.dolphin-integration.com Dolphin Integration] || V1995, VHDL-1993 || SMASH is a mixed-signal, multi-language simulator for IC or PCB designs. It uses [[SPICE]] syntax for analog descriptions, Verilog-HDL and VHDL for digital, Verilog-A/AMS, VHDL-AMS and ABCD (a combination of SPICE and C) for analog behavioral, and C for DSP algorithms.
|- ||
| Speedsim || [[Cadence Design Systems]] || V1995 || Cycle based simulator originally developed at DEC. The DEC developers spun off to form Quickturn Design Systems. Quickturn was later acquired by Cadence, who discontinued the product in 2005. Speedsim featured an innovative slotted bit-slice architecture that supported simulation of up to 32 tests in parallel.
|- ||
|- ||
| [http://www.fintronic.com/ Super-FinSim] || [http://www.fintronic.com/ Fintronic] || V2001 || This simulator is available on multi-platform, claiming IEEE 1364-2001 compliant.
| [http://www.fintronic.com/ Super-FinSim] || [http://www.fintronic.com/ Fintronic] || V2001 || This simulator is available on multi-platform, claiming IEEE 1364-2001 compliant.

Revision as of 21:20, 15 October 2010

Verilog simulators are software packages that emulate the Verilog hardware description language. Verilog simulation software has come a long way since its early origin as a single proprietary product offered by one company. Today, Verilog simulators are available from many vendors, at all price points. For desktop/personal use, Aldec, Mentor, LogicSim, SynaptiCAD, and others offer reasonably priced (<$5000 USD) tool-suites for the Windows 2000/XP platform. The suites bundle the simulator engine with a complete development environment: text editor, waveform viewer, and RTL-level browser. Additionally, limited-functionality editions of the Aldec and ModelSim simulator are downloadable free of charge, from their respective OEM partners (Actel, Altera, Lattice Semiconductor, Xilinx, etc.) For those desiring open-source software, there is Icarus Verilog, among others.

Beyond the desktop level, enterprise-level simulators offer faster simulation runtime, more robust support for mixed-language (VHDL and Verilog) simulation, and most importantly, are validated for timing-accurate (SDF-annotated) gate-level simulation. The last point is critical for the ASIC tapeout process, when a design-database is released to manufacturing. (Semiconductor foundries stipulate the usage of tools chosen from an approved list, in order for the customer's design to receive signoff status. Although the customer is not required to perform any signoff checking, the tremendous cost of a wafer order has generally ensured thorough design-validation on the part of the customer.) The three major signoff-grade simulators include Cadence Incisive Enterprise Simulator, Mentor ModelSim/SE, and Synopsys VCS. Pricing is not published publicly, but all three vendors are known to charge $25,000-$100,000 USD per seat, 1-year time-based license.

FPGA vendors do not require expensive enterprise simulators for their design flow. In fact, most vendors include an OEM version of a third-party HDL simulator in their design suite. The bundled simulator is taken from an entry-level or low-capacity edition, and bundled with the FPGA vendor's device libraries. For designs targeting high-capacity FPGA, a standalone simulator is recommended, as the OEM-version may lack the capacity or speed to effectively handle large designs.

Below is a list of simulators that implement the Verilog hardware description language:

Commercial Simulators

List of Verilog Simulators in Alphabetical Order by Name
Simulator Name Author/Company Languages Description
Active-HDL/Riviera Aldec VHDL-2002, V2001, SV2005 A simulator with complete design environment well suited for FPGA-applications. Aldec licenses Active-HDL to FPGA-vendors, and the underlying engine can be found in the design-suites of those vendors. While ActiveHDL is a low-cost product, Aldec also offers a more expensive, higher-performance simulator called "Riviera."
CVC Pragmatic C Software V2001, V2005 CVC is a high performance Verilog HDL compiled simulator. CVC has the ability to simulate in either interpreted or compiled mode. When simulated in compiled mode its performance rivals that of any other simulator.
Incisive Enterprise Simulator ('big 3') Cadence Design Systems VHDL-2002, V2001, SV2005 Cadence initially acquired Gateway Design, thereby acquiring Verilog-XL. In response to competition from faster simulators, Cadence developed its own compiled-language simulator, NC-Verilog. The modern version of the NCsim family, called Incisive Enterprise Simulator, includes Verilog, VHDL, and SystemVerilog support and boasts some unique features (such as support for the e verification language) and a fast SystemC simulation kernel. As one of the 'big 3' simulators, Incisive Enterprise Simulator is qualified for ASIC (validation) sign-off at nearly all semiconductor fabs.
ISE Simulator Xilinx VHDL-93, V2001 Xilinx's simulator comes bundled with the ISE Design Suite. Though considered one of the least expensive simulators, ISE Simulator (ISim) provides support for mixed-mode language simulation including, but not limited to, simulation of designs targeted for Xilinx's FPGAs and CPLDs.
ModelSim ('big 3') Mentor Graphics VHDL-2002, V2001, SV2005 The original Modeltech (VHDL) simulator already commanded a loyal userbase, and attracted many new users with the first mixed-language simulator capable of simulating VHDL and Verilog design entities together. However, as the Verilog component of ModelSim is neither the fastest nor most fully featured simulator on the market, competition from Synopsys and Cadence, led to a continual decrease in ModelSim popularity. As one of the 'big 3' simulators ModelSim/SE is qualified for ASIC (validation) sign-off at nearly all semiconductor fabs.
PureSpeed Frontline V1995 The simulator had a revenue of up to $7 million at one time (1995). Famed by its 'regional cycle-based' simulation concept. It has a cycle-based counterpart called 'pure cycle'. FrontLine was sold to Avant!, which was later acquired by Synopsys. Synopsys discontinued Purespeed in favor of its well-established VCS simulator.
Quartus II Simulator Altera VHDL-1993, V2001, SV2005 Altera's simulator bundled with the Quartus II design software. Supports Verilog, VHDL and AHDL.
SILOS Simucad Design Automation V2001 As one of the low-cost Verilog simulators, Silos III enjoyed great popularity in the 1990s. Simucad's most current version, Silos-X, is sold as part of a tool-suite.
SMASH Dolphin Integration V1995, VHDL-1993 SMASH is a mixed-signal, multi-language simulator for IC or PCB designs. It uses SPICE syntax for analog descriptions, Verilog-HDL and VHDL for digital, Verilog-A/AMS, VHDL-AMS and ABCD (a combination of SPICE and C) for analog behavioral, and C for DSP algorithms.
Speedsim Cadence Design Systems V1995 Cycle based simulator originally developed at DEC. The DEC developers spun off to form Quickturn Design Systems. Quickturn was later acquired by Cadence, who discontinued the product in 2005. Speedsim featured an innovative slotted bit-slice architecture that supported simulation of up to 32 tests in parallel.
Super-FinSim Fintronic V2001 This simulator is available on multi-platform, claiming IEEE 1364-2001 compliant.
VCS ('big 3') Synopsys VHDL-2002, V2001, SV2005 Originally developed by John Sanguinetti, Peter Eichenberger and Michael McNamara under the startup company Chronologic Simulation, VCS (Verilog Compiled code Simulator) was purchased by Synopsys, where development continued. Due to a strategic decision to support SystemVerilog (instead of SystemC), and the timely acquisition of Superlog (the forerunner to SystemVerilog), Synopsys/VCS was the first SystemVerilog simulator in the market. As one of the 'big 3' simulators, VCS is qualified for ASIC (validation) sign-off at nearly all semiconductor fabs.
Verilogger Extreme, Verilogger Pro SynaptiCAD V2001,V1995 Verilogger Pro is a low-cost interpreted simulator based on Elliot Mednick's VeriWell code base. Verilogger Extreme is a newer, compiled-code simulator that is Verilog-2001 compliant and much faster than Pro.
Verilog-XL Cadence V1995 The original Verilog simulator, Gateway Design's Verilog-XL was the first (and only, for a time) Verilog simulator to be qualified for ASIC (validation) sign-off. After its acquisition by Cadence Design Systems, Verilog-XL changed very little over the years, retaining an interpreted language engine, and freezing language-support at Verilog-1995. Cadence recommends Incisive Enterprise Simulator for new design projects, as XL no longer receives active development. Nevertheless, XL continues to find use in companies with large codebases of legacy Verilog. Many early Verilog codebases will only simulate properly in Verilog-XL, due to variation in language implementation of other simulators.
Veritak Sugawara Systems V2001 It is low-cost and Windows-based only. It boasts a built-in waveform viewer and fast execution.
Z01X WinterLogic V2001 Developed as a fault simulator WinterLogic is providing free licenses to the logic simulator.

Some commercial simulators (such as ModelSim) are available in student, or evaluation/demo editions. These editions generally have many features disabled, arbitrary limits on simulation design size, but are offered free of charge.

Open-source Simulators

List of Verilog Simulators in Alphabetical Order
Simulator Name Author/Company Supported Languages Description
GPL Cver Pragmatic C Software V1995, minimal V2001 This is a GPL open-source simulator. It is a pure simulator. This simulator is not fully IEEE 1364-2001 compliant. It does not support generate and constant functions.
Icarus Verilog Stephen Williams V1995, minimal V2001, minimal V2005 This simulator is not fully IEEE 1364-2001 compliant. It does not support constant functions.
Verilator Veripool Synthesizable V2001, synthesizable V2005, minimal synthesizable SV2005 This is a very high speed open-source simulator that compiles synthesizable Verilog to C++/SystemC.
VeriWell Elliot Mednick V1995 This simulator used to be commercial, but has recently become GPL open-source. Compliance with 1364 is not well documented. It is not fully compliant with IEEE 1364-1995.
LIFTING A. Bosio, G. Di Natale (LIRMM) V1995 LIFTING (LIRMM Fault Simulator) is an open-source simulator able to perform both logic and fault simulation for single/multiple stuck-at faults and single event upset (SEU) on digital circuits described in Verilog.

Key

Tag Description
V1995 IEEE 1364-1995 Verilog
V2001 IEEE 1364-2001 Verilog
V2005 IEEE 1364-2005 Verilog
SV2005 IEEE 1800-2005 SystemVerilog
SV2009 IEEE 1800-2009 SystemVerilog
VHDL-1987 IEEE 1076-1987 VHDL
VHDL-1993 IEEE 1076-1993 VHDL
VHDL-2002 IEEE 1076-2002 VHDL
VHDL-2008 IEEE 1076-2008 VHDL

See also