User:Monty845/ACE2011: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 23:34, 27 November 2011

Candidates: Candidate guide; Candidate statements; Questions for the candidates; Discuss the candidates

Voter guides
These guides represent only the views of their authors. All guides written responsibly, seriously and in good faith are welcome for inclusion. Elonka Monty845 Master&Expert Heimstern NuclearWarfare Joe Gazz84 Sven Manguard HJ Mitchell Badger Drink Rschen7754 Carcharoth Guerillero Ealdgyth SandyGeorgia RegentsPark Kiefer.Wolfowitz Wizardman William M. Connolley

The following is a summary of other voter guides made for the 2011 Arbcom Election.

I am considering any level of support as a support for those with multiple levels of support, and likewise for oppose. In my opinion, when faced with the three choices of vote at the ballot box, that is how a voter is likely to respond.
To the extent that a guide writer appears to have decided to remain neutral, I am recording it is a no vote.
There are a few instances where a guide writer made a recommendation to others, but indicated they would vote otherwise; in such cases I have used the recommendation.
Please let me know if you spot any errors; I will try to keep it up to date as the other guide writers continue to assess the candidates. (Also, feel free to fix any errors or make updates if you don't want to wait for me, as very little of the content is my subjective opinion)
Voter guides play no official role in the actual selection of Arbs, all that matters is the vote. The guides only matter in so much as they are likely to influence some voters.
I plan to compare guide support with the voting results when they become available.

Candidate	Badger Drink	Carcharoth	Ealdgyth	Elonka	Guerillero	Heimstern	HJ Mitchell	Hurricanefan25	Joe Gazz84	Kiefer.Wolfowitz	NuclearWarfare	RegentsPark	Rschen7754	SandyGeorgia	Sven Manguard	William M. Connolley	Wizardman	Support Percent (S/(S+O))
Courcelles	Strong support	Probable support	Support	Probable Support	Support	Lean Support	Support	Support	Abstain	Indomitable Support	Support	Support	Support	Support	Support	Oppose	Support	94%
Hersfold	Support	Undecided	Neutral	Undecided	Support	Undecided	Likely Support	Weak Support	Likely Support	Happily Support	Support	Neutral	Support	Abstain	Support	Oppose	Support	91%
Risker	Oppose	Probable support	Support	Probable support	Support	Support	Slightly Reluctant Support	Strong Support	Support	Strong Support	Support	Support	Neutral	Support	Strong Support	Strong Oppose	Support	88%
AGK	Strong support	Probable support	Support	Probable oppose	Abstain	Plan to Support	Support	No Vote	Likely Support	Strong Support	Support	Strong Support	Neutral	Abstain	Support	Oppose	Support	85%
SilkTork	Strong support	Probable oppose	Support	No Info	No Info	Undecided	Support	Oppose	Abstain	Strong Support	Support	Support	Neutral	Support	No vote	Support	Support	82%
Roger Davies	Support	Probable support	Neutral	No Info	No Info	Lean Oppose	Support	Strong Oppose	Abstain	Strong Support	Support	Support	Support	Support	Strong Oppose	Oppose	Support	69%
Kirill Lokshin	Support	Probable oppose	Neutral	Probable support	Support	Lean support	Undecided	Weak Oppose	Abstain	Indomitable Support	Oppose	Neutral	Support	Support	No Vote	Oppose	Support	66%
Worm That Turned	Strong Oppose	Probable support	Oppose	Undecided	Abstain	Undecided	Undecided	Support	Support	Firmly oppose	Abstain	Oppose	Support	Oppose	Support	Support	Abstain	55%
Top 8 candidates above 50% support in the actual vote will be seated per the supplemental RFC
Panyd	Oppose	Undecided	Oppose	No Info	No Info	Undecided	Abstain	Weak Support	Strong support	Resolutely oppose	Oppose	No Info	Neutral	Oppose	Support	Oppose	Abstain	33%
DeltaQuad	Support	Probable oppose	Oppose	No Info	No Info	Lean Oppose	Undecided	Weak Oppose	No Vote	Tactical Support	Oppose	No Info	Support	Oppose	No Vote	Oppose	Oppose	27%
Jclemens	Strong Oppose	Undecided	Neutral	Probable support	Abstain	Oppose	Probably Support	Oppose	Abstain	Happily Support	Oppose	No Info	Oppose	Abstain	Oppose	Strong Oppose	Oppose	27%
Coren	Oppose	Probable oppose	Neutral	Probable support	Oppose	Undecided	Oppose	Oppose	Abstain	Indomitable Support	Abstain	Oppose	Support	Oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Oppose	23%
Eluchil404	Oppose	Probable oppose	Oppose	No Info	No Info	Undecided	Oppose	Oppose	Abstain	Resolutely oppose	Abstain	Oppose	Support	Oppose	Oppose	Support	Oppose	16%
Kww	Strong support	Probable oppose	Oppose	No Info	No Info	Most likely Oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Likely Oppose	Resolutely oppose	Abstain	No Info	Oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Strong support	Oppose	15%
Geni	Oppose	Probable oppose	Oppose	Undecided	Oppose	Undecided	Oppose	Oppose	Abstain	Firmly oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Neutral	Oppose	No vote	Oppose	Oppose	0%
Hot Stop	Oppose	Probable oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Strong Oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Strong Oppose	Should withdraw	Obviously oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Strong Oppose	Strong Oppose	Oppose	0%
NWA.Rep	Strong Oppose	Probable oppose	Oppose	No Info	Strong Oppose	Hell No	Oppose	Strong Oppose	Likely Oppose	Obviously oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Oppose	Strong Oppose	Strong Oppose	Strong Oppose	0%
~~Maxim~~	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	Withdrawn	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	Withdrawn
~~PaoloNapolitano~~	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	Strong Oppose	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	Undecided	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	No Info	Not Eligible
S/N/O	8/0/9	5/0/9	4/5/8	5/0/2	4/3/4	4/0/6	7/1/6	5/1/11	4/1/3	10/0/7	6/4/7	5/2/6	8/5/4	5/3/9	6/4/7	4/0/13	7/2/8	8 Seats open

@@ Line 34: / Line 34: @@
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|94%
-|-
-| [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/Risker|Risker]]
-| <!--Badger Drink--> style="background:red;"|Oppose
-| <!--Carcharoth--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Probable support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Probable support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Slightly Reluctant Support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Strong Support
-| <!--Joe Gazz84--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| <!--Kiefer.Wolfowitz--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Strong Support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| <!--Regents-->style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:yellow;"|Neutral
-| <!--SG--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Strong Support
-| <!--Connolley--> style="background:red;"|Strong Oppose
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|88%
 |-
 | [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/Hersfold|Hersfold]]
@@ Line 75: / Line 55: @@
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|91%
 |-
-| [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/SilkTork|SilkTork]]
+| [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/Risker|Risker]]
-| <!--Badger Drink--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Strong support
+| <!--Badger Drink--> style="background:red;"|Oppose
-| <!--Carcharoth--> style="background:red;"|Probable oppose
+| <!--Carcharoth--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Probable support
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Probable support
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| No Info
-| No Info
-| Undecided
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:red;"|Oppose
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Slightly Reluctant Support
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Strong Support
-| <!--Joe Gazz84--> Abstain
+| <!--Joe Gazz84--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
 | <!--Kiefer.Wolfowitz--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Strong Support
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
 | <!--Regents-->style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
 | style="background:yellow;"|Neutral
 | <!--SG--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:yellow;"|No vote
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Strong Support
-| <!--Connolley--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| <!--Connolley--> style="background:red;"|Strong Oppose
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|82%
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|88%
 |-
 | [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/AGK|AGK]]
@@ Line 115: / Line 95: @@
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|85%
 |-
-| [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/Kirill Lokshin|Kirill Lokshin]]
+| [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/SilkTork|SilkTork]]
-| <!--Badger Drink--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| <!--Badger Drink--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Strong support
 | <!--Carcharoth--> style="background:red;"|Probable oppose
-| style="background:yellow;"|Neutral
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Probable support
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| No Info
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Lean support
+| No Info
 | Undecided
-| style="background:red;"|Weak Oppose
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| <!--Joe Gazz84--> Abstain
-| <!--Kiefer.Wolfowitz--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Indomitable Support
 | style="background:red;"|Oppose
+| <!--Joe Gazz84--> Abstain
-| <!--Regents-->style="background:yellow;"|Neutral
+| <!--Kiefer.Wolfowitz--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Strong Support
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| <!--Regents-->style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| style="background:yellow;"|Neutral
 | <!--SG--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:yellow;"|No Vote
+| style="background:yellow;"|No vote
-| <!--Connolley--> style="background:red;"|Oppose
+| <!--Connolley--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|66%
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|82%
 |-
 | [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/Roger Davies|Roger Davies]]
@@ Line 154: / Line 134: @@
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
 | style="background:lightgreen;"|69%
+|-
+| [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/Kirill Lokshin|Kirill Lokshin]]
+| <!--Badger Drink--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| <!--Carcharoth--> style="background:red;"|Probable oppose
+| style="background:yellow;"|Neutral
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Probable support
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Lean support
+| Undecided
+| style="background:red;"|Weak Oppose
+| <!--Joe Gazz84--> Abstain
+| <!--Kiefer.Wolfowitz--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Indomitable Support
+| style="background:red;"|Oppose
+| <!--Regents-->style="background:yellow;"|Neutral
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| <!--SG--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| style="background:yellow;"|No Vote
+| <!--Connolley--> style="background:red;"|Oppose
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|66%
 |-
 | [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/Worm That Turned|Worm That Turned]]
@@ Line 196: / Line 196: @@
 | style="background:yellow;"|Abstain
 | style="background:red;"|33%
+|-
+| [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/DeltaQuad|DeltaQuad]]
+| <!--Badger Drink--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| <!--Carcharoth--> style="background:red;"|Probable oppose
+| style="background:red;"|Oppose
+| No Info
+| No Info
+| style="background:red;"|Lean Oppose
+| Undecided
+| style="background:red;"|Weak Oppose
+| <!--Joe Gazz84--> style="background:yellow;"|No Vote
+| <!--Kiefer.Wolfowitz--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Tactical Support
+| style="background:red;"|Oppose
+| <!--Regents-->No Info
+| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
+| <!--SG--> style="background:red;"|Oppose
+| style="background:yellow;"|No Vote
+| <!--Connolley--> style="background:red;"|Oppose
+| style="background:red;"|Oppose
+| style="background:red;"|27%
 |-
 | [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/Jclemens|Jclemens]]
@@ Line 236: / Line 256: @@
 | style="background:red;"|Oppose
 | style="background:red;"|23%
-|-
-| [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/DeltaQuad|DeltaQuad]]
-| <!--Badger Drink--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| <!--Carcharoth--> style="background:red;"|Probable oppose
-| style="background:red;"|Oppose
-| No Info
-| No Info
-| style="background:red;"|Lean Oppose
-| Undecided
-| style="background:red;"|Weak Oppose
-| <!--Joe Gazz84--> style="background:yellow;"|No Vote
-| <!--Kiefer.Wolfowitz--> style="background:lightgreen;"|Tactical Support
-| style="background:red;"|Oppose
-| <!--Regents-->No Info
-| style="background:lightgreen;"|Support
-| <!--SG--> style="background:red;"|Oppose
-| style="background:yellow;"|No Vote
-| <!--Connolley--> style="background:red;"|Oppose
-| style="background:red;"|Oppose
-| style="background:red;"|27%
 |-
 | [[Wikipedia:Arbitration Committee Elections December 2011/Candidates/Eluchil404|Eluchil404]]