Jump to content

I Accuse (1941 film): Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Cydebot (talk | contribs)
m Robot - Moving category Films of the Third Reich to Category:Films of Nazi Germany per CFD at Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2011 December 30.
No edit summary
Line 4: Line 4:


==Plot==
==Plot==
A woman suffering from multiple sclerosis pleads with doctors to kill her.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''Nazi Cinema'' p70 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref> Her husband gives her a fatal overdose, and is put on trial, where arguments are put forth that prolonging life is sometimes contrary to nature, and that death is a right as well as a duty.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''Nazi Cinema'' p70-1 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref> It culminates in the husband's declaration that he is accusing them of cruelty for trying to prevent such deaths.<ref>Robert Edwin Hertzstein, The War That Hitler Won p308 ISBN 399-11845-4</ref>
A woman suffering from multiple sclerosis pleads with doctors to kill her.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''National Socialist Cinema'' p70 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref> Her husband gives her a fatal overdose, and is put on trial, where arguments are put forth that prolonging life is sometimes contrary to nature, and that death is a right as well as a duty.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''National Socialist Cinema'' p70-1 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref> It culminates in the husband's declaration that he is accusing them of cruelty for trying to prevent such deaths.<ref>Robert Edwin Hertzstein, The War That Hitler Won p308 ISBN 399-11845-4</ref>


==Propaganda elements==
==Propaganda elements==
This film was commissioned by Goebbels at the suggestion of Karl Brandt to make the public more supportive of the Reich's T4 euthanasia program, and presented simultaneously with the practice of euthanasia in Nazi Germany.<ref>Pierre Aycoberry ''The Nazi Question'', p11 Pantheon Books New York 1981</ref> The actual victims of the Nazi euthanasia program [[Action T4]] were in fact killed without their consent, in the absence of their families.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''Nazi Cinema'' p69 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref> Indeed, one cinema goer compared it to the program and asked how abuses could be prevented from creeping in.<ref>[[Richard Grunberger]], ''The 12-Year Reich'', p 385, ISBN 03-076435-1</ref>
This film was commissioned by Goebbels at the suggestion of Karl Brandt to make the public more supportive of the Reich's T4 euthanasia program, and presented simultaneously with the practice of euthanasia.


SS reported that the churches were uniformly negative on the movie, with Catholics expressing it more strongly but Protestants being equally negative.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''Nazi Cinema'' p146-7 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref> Opinion in medical circles was rather positive, though bringing up cases where patients thought to be incurable had recovered.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''Nazi Cinema'' p147 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref> Legal professions were anxious that it be placed on legal ground, and the general population was supportive.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''Nazi Cinema'' p148 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref>
SS reported that the churches were uniformly negative on the movie, with Catholics expressing it more strongly but Protestants being equally negative.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''National Socialist Cinema'' p146-7 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref> Opinion in medical circles was rather positive, though bringing up cases where patients thought to be incurable had recovered.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''National Socialist Cinema'' p147 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref> Legal professions were anxious that it be placed on legal ground, and the general population was supportive.<ref>[[Erwin Leiser]], ''National Socialist Cinema'' p148 ISBN 0-02-570230-0</ref>


==References==
==References==

Revision as of 19:27, 21 August 2012

Ich klage an (Eng: I Accuse) is a 1941 German pro-euthanasia propaganda film directed by Wolfgang Liebeneiner.[1]

It was banned by Allied powers after the war.[2]

Plot

A woman suffering from multiple sclerosis pleads with doctors to kill her.[3] Her husband gives her a fatal overdose, and is put on trial, where arguments are put forth that prolonging life is sometimes contrary to nature, and that death is a right as well as a duty.[4] It culminates in the husband's declaration that he is accusing them of cruelty for trying to prevent such deaths.[5]

Propaganda elements

This film was commissioned by Goebbels at the suggestion of Karl Brandt to make the public more supportive of the Reich's T4 euthanasia program, and presented simultaneously with the practice of euthanasia.

SS reported that the churches were uniformly negative on the movie, with Catholics expressing it more strongly but Protestants being equally negative.[6] Opinion in medical circles was rather positive, though bringing up cases where patients thought to be incurable had recovered.[7] Legal professions were anxious that it be placed on legal ground, and the general population was supportive.[8]

References

  1. ^ "New York Times: Ich Klage An (1941)". NY Times. Retrieved 2010-10-30.
  2. ^ Cinzia Romani, Tainted Goddesses: Female Film Stars of the Third Reich p108 ISBN 0-9627613-1-1
  3. ^ Erwin Leiser, National Socialist Cinema p70 ISBN 0-02-570230-0
  4. ^ Erwin Leiser, National Socialist Cinema p70-1 ISBN 0-02-570230-0
  5. ^ Robert Edwin Hertzstein, The War That Hitler Won p308 ISBN 399-11845-4
  6. ^ Erwin Leiser, National Socialist Cinema p146-7 ISBN 0-02-570230-0
  7. ^ Erwin Leiser, National Socialist Cinema p147 ISBN 0-02-570230-0
  8. ^ Erwin Leiser, National Socialist Cinema p148 ISBN 0-02-570230-0