Starship Troopers: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
Line 87: | Line 87: | ||
=== Politics === |
=== Politics === |
||
''Starship Troopers'' is a political essay as well as a novel. Large portions of the book take place in classrooms, with Rico and other characters engaged in debates with their History and Moral Philosophy Teachers, who serve as stand-ins for Heinlein. The overall theme of the book is to demonstrate that social responsibility requires individual sacrifice. Heinlein's Terran Federation is a [[meritocracy]], where [[suffrage]] belongs only to those willing to serve their society by two years of social service, instead of "anyone who is 18 years old and has a body temperature near 37 °C."<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Expanded Universe| pages=485}}</ref> This is in contrast to the democracies of the twentieth centuries, which according to the novel had collapsed because "people had been led to believe that they could simply vote for whatever they wanted . . . and get it, without toil, without sweat, without tears."<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Starship Troopers| year=1987| pages=93}}</ref> Indeed, Dubois, one of Rico's teachers, criticizes as unrealistic the famous passage of the [[Declaration of Independence (United States)|U.S. Declaration of Independence]] about "[[Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness]]." |
''Starship Troopers'' is a political essay as well as a novel. Large portions of the book take place in classrooms, with Rico and other characters engaged in debates with their History and Moral Philosophy Teachers, who serve as stand-ins for Heinlein. The overall theme of the book is to demonstrate that social responsibility requires individual sacrifice. Heinlein's Terran Federation is a [[meritocracy]], where [[suffrage]] belongs only to those willing to serve their society by two years of social service ("the franchise is today limited to discharged veterans," ch. XII), instead of "anyone who is 18 years old and has a body temperature near 37 °C."<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Expanded Universe| pages=485}}</ref> This is in contrast to the democracies of the twentieth centuries, which according to the novel had collapsed because "people had been led to believe that they could simply vote for whatever they wanted . . . and get it, without toil, without sweat, without tears."<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Starship Troopers| year=1987| pages=93}}</ref> Indeed, Dubois, one of Rico's teachers, criticizes as unrealistic the famous passage of the [[Declaration of Independence (United States)|U.S. Declaration of Independence]] about "[[Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness]]." Since there appear to be relatively few female soldiers--the book portrays some Navy captains and no infantry as being female---there are presumably few women voters. The book does not address this point. |
||
''Starship Troopers'' is also a vehicle for Heinlein's [[anti-communist]] views, best summed up by Rico's belief that "[c]orrect morals arise from knowing what man ''is''—not what do-gooders and well-meaning old Aunt Nellies would like him to be."<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Starship Troopers| year=1987| pages=186}}</ref> Characters attack [[Karl Marx]] (a "pompous fraud"), the [[Labor theory of value]] ("All the work one cares to add will not turn a mud pie into an apple tart...")<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Starship Troopers| year=1987| pages=92}}</ref> and [[Plato]]'s ''[[Republic (dialogue)|The Republic]]'' ("antlike communism" and "weird in the extreme").<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Starship Troopers| year=1987| pages= 181}}</ref> Despite this explicit denouncement of Plato’s republic, ironically the political system imagined by Heinlein mirrors the Republic in many ways. For example, Heinlein mirrors the caste system used by Plato and divides people in society into three distinct classes; ‘copper’ civilians, ‘silver’ guards and ‘gold’ voting citizens. One point of distinction is that Heinlein allows movement from one class to another, and no individual begins ‘higher’ than ‘copper’. |
''Starship Troopers'' is also a vehicle for Heinlein's [[anti-communist]] views, best summed up by Rico's belief that "[c]orrect morals arise from knowing what man ''is''—not what do-gooders and well-meaning old Aunt Nellies would like him to be."<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Starship Troopers| year=1987| pages=186}}</ref> Characters attack [[Karl Marx]] (a "pompous fraud"), the [[Labor theory of value]] ("All the work one cares to add will not turn a mud pie into an apple tart...")<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Starship Troopers| year=1987| pages=92}}</ref> and [[Plato]]'s ''[[Republic (dialogue)|The Republic]]'' ("antlike communism" and "weird in the extreme").<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Starship Troopers| year=1987| pages= 181}}</ref> Despite this explicit denouncement of Plato’s republic, ironically the political system imagined by Heinlein mirrors the Republic in many ways. For example, Heinlein mirrors the caste system used by Plato and divides people in society into three distinct classes; ‘copper’ civilians, ‘silver’ guards and ‘gold’ voting citizens. One point of distinction is that Heinlein allows movement from one class to another, and no individual begins ‘higher’ than ‘copper’. Heinlein's fears about communism are embodied in the Arachnids, the "ultimate dictatorship of the hive."<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Starship Troopers| year=1987| pages= 135}}</ref> The Arachnids are a society of "total communism" adapted to it by evolution. They lay their eggs in the thousands, and send their warriors off to battle without the slightest thought about casualties, in both cases a major advantage over the individualistic Terrans.<ref>{{cite book|last=Heinlein|title=Starship Troopers| year=1987| pages=152–53}}</ref> |
||
=== References to history === |
=== References to history === |
Revision as of 17:29, 1 May 2006
File:Penis corrected.jpg | |
Author | Robert A. Heinlein |
---|---|
Genre | Science-fiction |
Publisher | G. P. Putnam's Sons |
Publication date | December, 1959 |
Media type | Print (Hardcover and Paperback) |
Pages | 263 (Paperback) |
ISBN | ISBN 0399202099 Parameter error in {{ISBNT}}: invalid character |
Preceded by | Methuselah's Children |
Followed by | Stranger in a Strange Land |
Starship Troopers is a science fiction novel by Robert A. Heinlein published in 1959. The first-person narrative is about a young soldier named Johnnie Rico and his exploits in the Mobile Infantry, a futuristic military unit equipped with powered armor. Rico's military career progresses from recruit to non-commissioned officer and finally to officer against the backdrop of an interstellar war between mankind and an insectoid species known as "the Bugs." Through Rico's eyes, Heinlein examines moral and philosophical aspects of capital punishment, juvenile delinquency, civic virtue, and necessity of war.[1]
Starship Troopers won the Hugo Award for Best Novel in 1960 and helped create a different genre of literature known as military science fiction. It is on the reading lists of the U.S. Army and U.S. Marine Corps, and is the only science fiction novel on the reading list at all four U.S. military academies. [citation needed] It has been adapted into several films and games, most famously the 1997 film by Paul Verhoeven. The novel has attracted controversy and criticism of its social and political themes, which some critics believe are militaristic.[2]
Background: The writing of Starship Troopers
Robert A. Heinlein wrote from a military background because he had been a commissioned U.S. Naval officer upon graduation from the U.S. Naval Academy. According to Heinlein, his desire to write Starship Troopers dates back to April 5, 1958, when he and his wife read a newspaper advertisement placed by the National Committee for a Sane Nuclear Policy calling for a unilateral suspension of nuclear weapon testing by the United States. In response, the Heinleins created the Patrick Henry League in an attempt to drum up support for the U.S. nuclear testing program. During the unsuccessful campaign, Heinlein found himself under attack both in and out of the science fiction community for his views.[3]
Heinlein stopped work on the novel that would become Stranger in a Strange Land and wrote Starship Troopers sometime during 1958 and 1959. Starship Troopers was first published in The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction in October and November 1959 as a serial called Starship Soldier. Although originally written as a juvenile novel for Scribners, it was rejected[4] and was eventually published as an adult novel by G. P. Putnam's Sons.[5] In many ways, Starship Troopers marked a turning point for Heinlein. Beforehand, he had mostly published juvenile novels for Scribner's. However, following their rejection of Starship Troopers, he ended his longstanding relationship with them, and began writing books with more adult themes.[6]
Plot summary
Template:Spoiler Starship Troopers is centered around Johnnie Rico, a soldier in the war against the Bugs, an alien arachnid-like race.
Characters in Starship Troopers
Major characters
- Juan "Johnnie" Rico - Son of a wealthy Filipino family who joined the Terran Mobile Infantry almost on impulse and over his parents' objections. He did his basic training at Camp Currie and was assigned as a Private to "Willie's Wildcats". His first engagement was the Battle of Klendathu. He was then transferred to "Rasczak's Roughnecks" aboard the Rodger Young, where he achieved the rank of corporal and survived several successful battles. He later entered Officer Candidate School at the encouragement of his friend Ace. Rico eventually became a lieutenant after commanding in the critically successful "Operation Royalty". At the end of the novel he is commanding a platoon back on the Rodger Young, with his father as platoon sergeant under him. Heinlein said in several interviews (in print, on National Public Radio, and during science-fiction convention presentations) that Rico did not survive the Klendathu drop which follows the final paragraphs of the book.
- Charles Zim - Originally career ship's sergeant, Juan Rico's boot camp instructor and platoon leader at Camp Arthur Currie. He later became the company commander at Camp Sergeant Spooky Smith. Eventually, he was one of the platoon sergeants under Rico's command during Operation Royalty. Zim took the initiative to raid an Arachnid "bughole", and captured the first brain bug. He was given a field commission of brevet captain with the permanent rank of first lieutenant.
- Lieutenant Colonel Jean V. Dubois - Rico's high school instructor in History and Moral Philosophy. He retired as a lieutenant colonel in the Mobile Infantry after he lost an arm. A letter to Rico during Basic Training boosts Rico's spirits and keeps him from resigning (and thus losing his opportunity of ever becoming a full Citizen).
- Sergeant Jelal - Career ship's sergeant, Juan Rico's platoon sergeant aboard the Rodger Young and de facto platoon leader after Lt. Rasczak's death. He eventually made captain, but lost his legs. Nicknamed "Jelly", and anyone who had made one combat drop could call him that to his face.
- Ted Hendrick - Mobile Infantry recruit who questioned the need to learn knife-throwing. Later court-martialed for disobeying orders and striking a superior officer (Sergeant Zim). Sentenced to ten lashes and Bad Conduct Discharge, instead of execution.
- Lieutenant Rasczak - Juan Rico's platoon leader in the Rodger Young. His platoon always called him "the Lieutenant", in tones of awe. He died in a drop after rescuing two of his soldiers; he was the only one in that raid who didn't make the retrieval boat. After the Lieutenant's death, a vote was taken among the cap troopers to rename the platoon "Jelly's Jaguars" and was passed unanimously; this was vetoed by Sergeant Jelal, and the unit retained the name Rasczak's Roughnecks.
Minor characters
- Career Corporal "Ace" - Squad commander, Jelal's Platoon, Rasczak's Roughnecks. Assisted Juan Rico in the recovery of a wounded Dizzy Flores. When Rico first became Corporal and assistant section leader, he sparred with Ace in the showers to earn his respect. Although Ace won, he acknowledged Rico's intentions and helped him earn the respect of the entire Platoon. Later, Ace convinced Rico to pursue a career in the military, and enroll in Officer Candidate School
- Dizzy Flores - Male trooper of sixth squad, Jelal's Platoon, Rasczak's Roughnecks. During a raid, with Juan Rico acting as assistant section leader, the whole platoon nearly missed retrieval as Rico and Ace recovered the wounded Flores. Testament to the fighting spirit of the Roughnecks. Flores died in the retrieval boat on the way back up to the Roughneck transport, the Rodger Young.
- Private First Class Dutch Bamburger - Juan Rico's closest squadmate during Operation Bughouse, killed in action just before retrieval.
- Captain Frankel - Camp Currie Battalion Commander, involved in the trial of Cadet Ted Hendrick. Given the choice, saved Hendrick from the punishment of execution.
- N. L. Dillinger - Mobile Infantry recruit who deserted service. He was hanged for murdering a baby girl after kidnapping her for ransom. The trial was handled by the Infantry rather than the civil judiciary, despite the fact that Dillinger was AWOL.
- Fleet Sergeant Ho - Federal Service recruiting officer who swore in Juan Rico and Carl. He was "on display" with his legs and right arm missing. Johnnie met him after hours and learned that he wore prosthetics except when on duty, the missing limbs being intended to impress prospective recruits with the seriousness of their decision.
- Emilio Rico - Juan Rico's father, a wealthy Filipino businessman. He opposed Johnnie's plans to join the Mobile Infantry, but after the Bug War began and his wife died, he himself joined and eventually became a platoon sergeant.
- Major Reid - Juan Rico's History and Moral Philosophy teacher at Officer Candidate School.
- Carmencita Ibanez - Juan Rico's classmate that he had a crush on. She had a major influence on Rico's enlistment, and enlisted on the same day. Excelling in mathematics, she became a pilot.
- "Carl" - Juan Rico's best friend in High School. One of the major influences on Juan Rico's enlistment, Carl enlisted the same day as Rico, under Starside Research & Development. Carl was killed in action when the research station he was aboard, in orbit of Pluto, was hit by an Arachnid meteor strike.
Locations
- Terra (Earth) - Terran homeworld. Location of boot camp "Arthur Currie".
- Faraway - A Terran colony planet occupied by the Klendathu Arachnids.
- Hesperus - A Terran colony planet.
- Iskander - A Terran colony planet.
- Klendathu - Home planet of the Arachnids. Location of "Operation Bughouse".
- Planet P - A planet occupied by the Arachnids as a forward base, attacked and excavated by the Terran Mobile Infantry in "Operation Royalty". Location of first captured Arachnid leaders, and 3rd Lt. Juan Rico's first command as an officer.
- Sanctuary - A small planet with an orbital stardock. Headquarters of the Terran Federation Mobile Infantry.
- Sheol - An Arachnid colony planet, decimated by the Terrans.
- The Valley Forge - The corvette transport of "Willie's Wildcats", features the retrieval song "Yankee Doodle". It was destroyed in a collision with the Ypres over Klendathu during "Operation Bughouse", but both ships were later recomissioned for the second assault on Klendathu.
- The Rodger Young - The corvette transport of "Rasczak's Roughnecks", features the retrieval song "Rodger Young".
Major themes
Politics
Starship Troopers is a political essay as well as a novel. Large portions of the book take place in classrooms, with Rico and other characters engaged in debates with their History and Moral Philosophy Teachers, who serve as stand-ins for Heinlein. The overall theme of the book is to demonstrate that social responsibility requires individual sacrifice. Heinlein's Terran Federation is a meritocracy, where suffrage belongs only to those willing to serve their society by two years of social service ("the franchise is today limited to discharged veterans," ch. XII), instead of "anyone who is 18 years old and has a body temperature near 37 °C."[7] This is in contrast to the democracies of the twentieth centuries, which according to the novel had collapsed because "people had been led to believe that they could simply vote for whatever they wanted . . . and get it, without toil, without sweat, without tears."[8] Indeed, Dubois, one of Rico's teachers, criticizes as unrealistic the famous passage of the U.S. Declaration of Independence about "Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness." Since there appear to be relatively few female soldiers--the book portrays some Navy captains and no infantry as being female---there are presumably few women voters. The book does not address this point.
Starship Troopers is also a vehicle for Heinlein's anti-communist views, best summed up by Rico's belief that "[c]orrect morals arise from knowing what man is—not what do-gooders and well-meaning old Aunt Nellies would like him to be."[9] Characters attack Karl Marx (a "pompous fraud"), the Labor theory of value ("All the work one cares to add will not turn a mud pie into an apple tart...")[10] and Plato's The Republic ("antlike communism" and "weird in the extreme").[11] Despite this explicit denouncement of Plato’s republic, ironically the political system imagined by Heinlein mirrors the Republic in many ways. For example, Heinlein mirrors the caste system used by Plato and divides people in society into three distinct classes; ‘copper’ civilians, ‘silver’ guards and ‘gold’ voting citizens. One point of distinction is that Heinlein allows movement from one class to another, and no individual begins ‘higher’ than ‘copper’. Heinlein's fears about communism are embodied in the Arachnids, the "ultimate dictatorship of the hive."[12] The Arachnids are a society of "total communism" adapted to it by evolution. They lay their eggs in the thousands, and send their warriors off to battle without the slightest thought about casualties, in both cases a major advantage over the individualistic Terrans.[13]
References to history
During Operation Royalty, the Mobile Infantry occupies the surface of Planet P and has to blast the Arachnids out of their well-prepared underground bunker networks, which are similar to Japanese fortifications on islands like Iwo Jima. Following the First Battle of Klendathu, the Terran Federation is reduced to making hit-and-run raids on isolated Arachnid and Skinny bases, similar to the U.S. Navy between Pearl Harbor and the Battle of Midway. The loss of Rico's ship, the Valley Forge, during the Klendathu drop may have been inspired by the loss of Heinlein's former ship, the USS Lexington, which was sunk by the Japanese in 1942.
The Korean War had ended only five years before Heinlein began writing Starship Troopers, and the book makes several direct references to it, such as the claim that "no 'Department of Defense' ever won a war".[14] Heinlein also refers to the American prisoners of war taken in that conflict, including the popular accusations of Communist brainwashing.[15] After the Korean War ended, there were rumors that the Chinese and North Koreans continued to hold a large number of Americans.[16] Rico's History and Moral Philosophy class at Officer Candidate School has a long discussion about the need to never leave a single man behind, even at the risk of starting a new war. Again, these were fairly popular views in America and it's probably unsurprising that Rico concludes it "doesn't matter whether it's a thousand — or just one, sir. You fight."[17]
Military innovations
Powered armor
In addition to Heinlein's political views, Starship Troopers popularized a number of military concepts and innovations, some of which have since been utilized. Perhaps its most famous legacy is the concept of the powered armor exoskeleton used by the Mobile Infantry soldiers.[18] These suits were controlled by the wearer's own movements but powered to augment the actions. A trooper could, for example, jump upwards, and the powered leg joints would launch him off the ground while rockets kicked in for further propulsion. Dropped from orbit in individual egg-shaped heat shields, the troopers would parachute into enemy territory for quick hit-and-run operations. Armed with significant weaponry including flame throwers, high-explosive rockets, and occasionally nuclear weapons, the Mobile Infantry soldier had an arsenal that made him a one-man tank, with skills comparable to a modern-day fighter pilot.
One of the book's major creative feats is the rigorously coherent invention and depiction of the use of heavy infantry delivered to planetary surfaces for operations designed not only to serve political purposes but also to take and hold positions for intelligence gathering. The concept of Mobile Infantry, whose basic element is the single trooper, highly trained, encased in an armored suit, and delivered to the area of operations in a disposable re-entry pod, is unprecedented in literature, both military and otherwise. The weapons systems, tactics, training, and all other aspects of this futuristic elite force are completely envisioned, from the function of the armored suits to the training of personnel to the operational use of the suits in combat. Tactics are described in detail, and the weapons systems are tailored to the operational imperatives laid down by the plot.
Modern ramifications
While powered armor is Starship Troopers' most famous legacy, its influence extends deep into contemporary warfare. Almost half a century after its publication, Starship Troopers is on the reading lists of the United States Army[19] and the United States Marine Corps,[20][21][22] and is the only science fiction novel on the reading list at four of the five United States military academies. When Heinlein wrote Starship Troopers the United States military was a largely conscripted force, based on mass over maneuver. Today the U.S. Marine Corps has incorporated many ideas similar to Heinlein's concept of an elite all-volunteer, high-tech strike force, while the U.S. Army has also initiated a transformation program which may give it similar capabilities in the near future.[23] The Army has also taken steps towards powered armor warfare with Project Land Warrior, while DARPA has invested $50 million developing an exoskeleton suit for military use.[24] The influence of Starship Troopers also extends beyond doctrine; some of the more mundane pieces of technology used in the novel that can be found in a contemporary infantry unit are night vision goggles, thermal viewers, and digital terrain maps with unit positions.[25] In addition, references to the book keep appearing in military culture. According to the Urban Dictionary, during the 1993 Battle of Mogadishu, U.S. Army Rangers called their Somali opponents "Skinnies" after the aliens Rico fights at the beginning of the book,[26] and in 2002 a Marine general described the future of Marine Corps clothing and equipment by contrasting it with the Mobile Infantry.[27]
Controversy
To Heinlein's surprise,[28] Starship Troopers won the Hugo Award for Best Novel in 1960. By 1980, twenty years after its release, it had been translated into eleven different languages and was still selling strongly. However, Heinlein complained that, despite this success, almost all the mail he received about it was negative and he only heard about it "when someone wants to chew me out".[29]
Literary
The main literary criticism against Starship Troopers is that it is nothing more than a vehicle for Heinlein's political views. John Brunner compared it to a "Victorian children's book"[30] while Anthony Boucher, founder of The Magazine of Fantasy & Science Fiction, remarked that Heinlein had "forgotten to insert a story."[30] Alexei Panshin complained that the novel was overly simplistic — "the account of the making of a [marine]... and nothing more"[31] — and that the characters were simply mouthpieces for Heinlein: "At the end you know nothing of [Rico's] tastes, his likes and dislikes, his personal life. The course of the book changes him in no way because there is nothing to change — Rico remains first and last a voice reading lines about how nice it is to be a soldier... The other characters are even more sketchy, or are simple expositions of an attitude."[31] Richard Geib adds "The real life 'warriors' I have known are all more multi-faceted than anyone we meet in Starship Troopers. And the ones I know who have killed are much more ambivalent about having done so."[32] He further complained about the almost complete lack of sexuality among the characters and the absence of any serious romance, although it should be noted in this regard that Starship Troopers was originally marketed as adolescent literature.[32]
Militarism
Another complaint about Starship Troopers is that it is either inherently militaristic or pro-military. There was even a two year debate in the Proceedings of the Institute for Twenty-First Century Studies (PITFCS) that was sparked by a comparison between a quote in Starship Troopers that "the noblest fate that a man can endure is to place his own mortal body between his loved home and war's desolation"[33] and the anti-war poem "Dulce et Decorum Est" by Wilfred Owen.[30] Dean McLaughlin called it "a book-length recruiting poster."[30] Alexei Panshin, a veteran of the peacetime military, argued that Heinlein glossed over the reality of military life, and that the Terran Federation-Arachnid conflict existed simply because, "Starship troopers are not half so glorious sitting on their butts polishing their weapons for the tenth time for lack of anything else to do."[31] Joe Haldeman, a Vietnam veteran and author of the anti-war Hugo- and Nebula-winning science fiction novel The Forever War, similarly complained that Starship Troopers unnecessarily glorifies war.[34] Others have pointed out that Heinlein never actually served in combat, having been a Naval Academy graduate who was medically discharged for a tuberculosis infection and spent World War II as a civilian doing Research and Development at the Philadelphia Navy Yard.
Defending Heinlein, George Price argued that "[Heinlein] implies, first, that war is something "endured," not enjoyed, and second, that war is so unpleasant, so desolate, that it must at all costs be kept away from one's home.[30] In a commentary on his essay "Who Are the Heirs of Patrick Henry?", Heinlein agreed that Starship Troopers "glorifies the military ... Specifically the P.B.I., the Poor Bloody Infantry, the mudfoot who places his frail body between his loved home and the war's desolation — but is rarely appreciated... he has the toughest job of all and should be honored."[35] The book's dedication also reads in part "... to all sergeants anywhen who have labored to make men out of boys."[36] However, he thoroughly disagreed that Starship Troopers was militaristic, arguing that the military personnel in the Terran Federation were not allowed to vote while on active duty — since "the idiots might vote not to make a drop"[37] — and that the military was thoroughly despised by many civilians. Interestingly, Heinlein also received some complaints about the lack of conscription in Starship Troopers (the military draft was the law in the United States when he wrote the novel).[38] Heinlein was always vehemently opposed to the idea of conscription and the advent of the modern U.S. all-volunteer military forces appears to have vindicated some of the ideas of Starship Troopers. The book is required reading within the U.S. Marine Corps for all junior enlisted ranks, because of its emphasis on small-unit cohesion, the fraternity of service, and its focus on the forward-serving, elite mobile infantry units, that so closely resemble the infantry units of the United States Marine Corps.
Vision of utopia
Another accusation is that the Terran Federation is a fascist society, and that Starship Troopers is therefore an endorsement of fascism. These analogies have become so popular that two of the corollaries of Godwin's Law state that once Heinlein is brought up during online debates, it is inevitable that someone will compare the book's society to that of Nazi Germany.[39] One could argue that the most famous proponent of these views is Paul Verhoeven, whose film version of Starship Troopers portrayed the Terran Federation wearing Nazi-like outfits.[40] Most of the arguments for this view cite the idea that only veterans can vote, and non-veterans lack citizenship. Ironically, according to Poul Anderson, Heinlein got the idea not from Nazi Germany or Sparta, but from Switzerland.[41] Often overlooked in this argument is that "veteran" is used to mean any person completing two (or more) years of civil service. Only a minority of the possible choices for service were military and the risks of military duty meant that the supermajority of citizens had not served their time in the military (being a war story, the novel of course focuses on those who are doing so).
Defenders of the book usually point out that, although the electoral franchise is limited, the government of the Terran Federation is democratically elected. There is freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and freedom of conscience. The political system described in the book is multiracial, multi-religious, and multi-ethnic. The protagonist Juan Rico is Filipino and others in his training group are American, Armenian, Japanese, German, and Turkish or Arab, and one or two have recognizably Jewish last names. Many also argue that Heinlein was simply discussing the merits of a "selective versus nonselective franchise."[30] Heinlein made a similar claim in his Expanded Universe.[42] The novel makes a related claim that "[s]ince sovereign franchise is the ultimate in human authority, we insure that all who wield it accept the ultimate in social responsibility — we require each person who wishes to exert control over the state to wager his own life — and lose it, if need be to save the life of the state. The maximum responsibility a human can accept is thus equated to the ultimate authority a human can exert."[43]
A more moderate accusation is that Heinlein's society is a utopia, and that his ideas sound good because they are never really tested. This interpretation includes critics like Robert A. W. Lowndes, Philip José Farmer, and Michael Moorcock. The latter wrote an essay entitled "Starship Stormtroopers" in which he attacked Heinlein and other writers over similar "Utopian fiction."[44] Lowndes accused Heinlein of using straw man arguments, "countering ingenuous half-truths with brilliant half-truths."[30] Lowndes further argued that the Terran Federation could never be as idealistic as Heinlein portrays it to be because he never properly addressed "whether or not [non-citizens] have at least as full a measure of civil redress against official injustice as we have today".[30] Farmer also agreed, arguing that a "world ruled by veterans would be as mismanaged, graft-ridden, and insane as one ruled by men who had never gotten near the odor of blood and guts."[30] Heinlein later denied that military service was the only way to earn the franchise and noted that the novel made this point explicitly, several times, for example when Rico is choosing preferences for assignment after enlisting. However, this issue is still controversial, even among the book's defenders, and James Gifford has declared that Heinlein is simply wrong on this point.[4] However, one character in the book, a recruiter, tells Rico that any adult may earn the franchise with two years of service, and that the government is required to find some duty for them to perform which is within their physical and mental capabilities. The objective is that all voters have earned the franchise through service rather than simply by reaching an arbitrary age.
Another controversial point is corporal punishment. The Terran Federation uses whippings for military discipline and also in civilian criminal justice. Characters speak of spankings or paddlings being used in child rearing. As the book was written at the beginning of Dr. Benjamin Spock's influence on the raising of children in American and European cultures, this is more a reflection on the practices of the time and of cultures in other parts of the world today which do not hold to the philosophy of Dr. Spock and his adherents. Indeed, in Mr. Dubois' class, Johnny Rico participates in a discussion that derides the introduction of psychoanalysis into childrearing in the twentieth century. This section is viewed by some as a direct attack on Dr. Spock's methods, a belief potentially supported by Spock's founding role in the Committee for a Sane Nuclear Policy, the organization to which Heinlein attributes his motivation for writing the novel.
Racism
The supposedly racist aspects of Starship Troopers involve the Terrans' relations with the Bugs and the Skinnies, who are viewed by some as stand-ins for the Japanese, Chinese, or Russians. Some people are also uncomfortable with the idea of an inter-species war, viewing it as similar to a race war. Richard Geib suggests that Heinlein portrayed the Arachnids as lacking "minds or souls... killing them seems no different than stepping on ants."[32] Both Robert Peterson and John Brunner believe that the nicknames "Bugs" and "Skinnies" carry racial overtones, Brunner using the analogy of "gook"[30] while Peterson suggested that "not only does the nickname 'Bugs' for the arachnids of Klendathu sound too much like a racial slur — think the derogatory use of the word 'Jew' — but Heinlein's characters unswervingly believe that humans are superior to Bugs, and that humans are destined to spread across the galaxy."[45] Considering that "bug" is even today a generic term encompassing insects and arachnids, some defenders of the story state the use of the label is natural given the described physical attributes of the Klendathu Arachnids. The terms may be considered similar to kraut, soldiers' slang for Germans, possibly used by Heinlein himself during his World War II naval service.
Robert A. W. Lowndes argues that the war between the Terrans and the Arachnids is not about a quest for racial purity, but rather an extension of Heinlein's belief that man is a wild animal. According to this theory, if man lacks a moral compass beyond the will to survive, and he was confronted by another species with a similar lack of morality, then the only possible result would be warfare.[30] In any case, the Arachnids are clearly not stupid (as Rico says, "Stupid races don't build spaceships!")[46] and in several places the novel expresses admiration for the efficiency of the Arachnid species, despite the fact that the Arachnids are supposedly an evil race. At the end of the novel, the main character Juan Rico is revealed to be Filipino when he states in casual conversation that his native language is Tagalog; this would seem to contradict accusations of racism against Asians.
Adaptations and influences
Film and TV adaptations
The novel has been recycled into comics, books, films, and television series, the best known being Paul Verhoeven's 1997 Starship Troopers. The film began development with the working title Bug Hunt,[47] but then a friend of Verhoeven pointed out the similarities between his script and the book. A license was subsequently obtained and the script edited to conform more to the book. However, according to the Internet Movie Database, Verhoeven claimed he never finished reading the novel, becoming both bored and depressed after the first few chapters.[48] This may explain the great dissimilarity between the book and the film, and the uproar among Heinlein's fans when the movie was released.[49]. The script reflects a merciless contempt for Heinlein's ideas, which are condemned as similar to Nazism. The film's uniforms, badges, and flags had German and Nazi origins and were clearly intended to imply that the society was racist -- against non-human species rather than human racial or national groups. The film included visual allusions to propaganda films such as Triumph of the Will and wartime news broadcasts. However, this satire was embedded in slickly produced action sequences with clever special effects.[50][51] Some wonder whether the satire went unnoticed by the audience who may have treated the movie as a simple gung-ho action movie.[52] Starship Troopers was also adapted into a series of comic books by Dark Horse Comics in 1997 and 1998 and although it was explicitly based on the films, the later issues featured a suit of powered armor similar to that of the book.[53] Other treatments more or less closely based on the book include a Japanese OVA series and accompanying manga made in 1988, entitled Uchû no Senshi, an animated series called Roughnecks: Starship Troopers Chronicles, and a 2004 sequel to the first movie, Starship Troopers 2: Hero of the Federation.
Video and board games
Starship Troopers was first made into a strategy/simulation board game by Avalon Hill in 1976. The design was a straight-forward attempt to bring to life the political-military system described in the book. In 1997, Avalon Hill released a completely different game, based on the movie, named Starship Troopers: Prepare for Battle [54].
In 1982, a programmer named Leo Christopherson wrote a game called Klendathu for the Tandy Color Computer. Oddly enough, even though the game was created fifteen years before the theatrical incarnation of Starship Troopers, the bugs bear a closer resemblance to its depiction of the arachnids than what was described in the novel. The gameplay was simple in nature, with the objective being to earn money by burning bugs.
Blue Tongue Entertainment via Atari released the computer game Starship Troopers: Terran Ascendancy in 2000, a top-down real-time tactics wargame [55].
A first-person shooter game titled Starship Troopers was released November 15, 2005, based on Paul Verhoeven's film version rather than on Heinlein's novel. It was developed by Strangelite Studios and published by Empire Interactive.
In 2005, Mongoose Publishing released a roleplaying game with a corresponding miniatures wargame, based on the "universe" of Starship Troopers (including the novel, movies, and television show).
Cultural references
Starship Troopers influenced many later science fiction stories, setting a tone for the military in space, a type of story referred to as military science fiction. John Steakley's novel Armor was, according to the author, born out of frustration with the small amount of actual combat in Starship Troopers and because he wanted this aspect developed further. Conversely, Joe Haldeman's anti-war novel The Forever War is popularly thought to be a direct reply to Starship Troopers, and though Haldeman has stated that it is actually a result of his personal experiences in the Vietnam War, he has admitted to being influenced by Starship Troopers.[34] Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card is also thought by many to have been either a direct response to or influenced by Starship Troopers. Card has flatly denied this, saying that he never read the novel and was influenced by The Forever War.[56] Harry Harrison wrote a satirical book called Bill, the Galactic Hero which he described as "a piss-take on Heinlein's Starship Troopers"[57] John Scalzi's novel Old Man's War is, according to the author, explicitly patterned after Starship Troopers.[58] In recent years, John Ringo's series Legacy of the Alldenata (also known as the Posleen series) featured a more explicit homage to Heinlein's book.
The 1986 James Cameron movie Aliens incorporated themes and phrases right out of the novel such as the terms "the drop" and "bug hunt" as well as the cargo-loader exoskeleton. The actors playing the Colonial Marines were also required to read Starship Troopers as part of their training prior to filming.[59] Starship Troopers is also thought to have influenced numerous computer and boardgames, including Tribes,[60] Terra Nova: Strike Force Centauri,[61] Fallout 2, Halo, Warhammer 40,000, Starcraft[62] and BattleTech. Also, the TV series Power Rangers: Lost Galaxy, in a possible reference, used the suits from the movie to form the military for their ship, Terra Venture.
The progressive rock band Yes had a song entitled Starship Trooper from their 1971 release, The Yes Album. The song is not based on the novel, but includes the lyric "Starship trooper, Go sailing on by." This might be seen as a mild criticism of the novel, given the band's distinctly anti-militarist stance.
Sarah Brightman and Hot Gossip had a UK hit single called "I Lost My Heart To A Starship Trooper" in 1978, responding to media interest in the "Star Wars" film, and only incidentally (or accidentally) referring to the Heinlein novel.
Notes
- ^ "ROBERT A. HEINLEIN: THE NOVELS". Luna-City.com. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Scott Rosenberg's critic of the movie from Salon.com, describing a fascist "G.I. Joe" novel". Retrieved 2006-04-18.
- ^ Heinlein. Expanded Universe. Baen Books. pp. 468–69, 481–82., page numbers vary depending on edition.
- ^ a b Gifford, James. "The Nature of Federal Service in Robert A. Heinlein's Starship Troopers" (PDF). Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Biographies of Robert and Virginia Heinlein". The Heinlein Society. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Causo, Roberto de Sousa. "Citizenship at War". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Heinlein. Expanded Universe. p. 485.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 93.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 186.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 92.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 181.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 135.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. pp. 152–53.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 133.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 184.
- ^ "DPMO: Korean War Missing Personnel". Retrieved 2006-03-04.. Similar accusations would be made during the Vietnam and Gulf Wars.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 178.
- ^ Weiss, Peter. "Dances with Robots". Science News Online. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Infantry Officer Basic Course: Recommended Reading List". 2005. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "ALMAR 246/96". 1996. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Commandant of the US Marine Corps: Official Reading List". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "2nd Battalion, 6th Marines. Battalion Commander's Reading List". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Pinkerton, James (2003). "Starship Trooperization". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Bonsor, Kevin. "How Exoskeletons Will Work". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Robel, Michael K. "Military Science Fiction and the Army Transformation". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Urban Dictionary:skinny". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Brig. Gen. James M. Feigley, Marine Corps Systems Command. Quoted in Brill, Arthur P. Jr. "The Last Ounce of Combat Readiness". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Heinlein. Expanded Universe. p. 482.. "I still can't see how that book got a Hugo".
- ^ Heinlein. Expanded Universe. p. 482.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k "Starship Troopers: The PITFCS Debate". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ a b c Panshin, Alexei. "Heinlein in Dimension". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ a b c Geib, Richard. ""STARSHIP TROOPERS" by Robert A. Heinlein. An opinion". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 91.
- ^ a b Haldeman, Joe (1998). "1998 SciFi.com interview". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Heinlein. Expanded Universe. p. 484.
- ^ Berkley Medallion paperback edition. The nitrosyncretic site's "Heinlein’s Dedications" incorrectly uses the "anywhere" word instead of "anywhen".
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 162.
- ^ Heinlein. Expanded Universe. pp. 483–84.
- ^ "RAH FAQ: "What are some of the topics that have been discussed to death on the net and/or are liable to cause a flamewar on alt.fan.heinlein and should be treated carefully?"". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Peterson, Robert (2000). "Starship Troopers: Film and Heinlein's Vision". Space.com. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Cite error: The named reference
weuve
was invoked but never defined (see the help page). - ^ Heinlein. Expanded Universe. p. 485.
- ^ Heinlein, Robert (1987). Starship Troopers. pp. 183–184.
- ^ Moorcock, Michael (1977). "Starship Stormtroopers". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Peterson, Robert (2000). "Militarism and Utopia in 'Starship Troopers'". Space.com. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Heinlein (1987). Starship Troopers. p. 152.
- ^ Farmer, Walt. "Wyoming, A History of Film & Video in the 20th Century". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Internet Movie Database: Starship Troopers Trivia". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Gardner, Max. "Review for Starship Troopers". BadMovies.Org. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Tobias, Scott. "Who Will Love The Brown Bunny? A Decade Of Underrated Movies". TheOnion.Com. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Murray, Noel. "Commentary Tracks Of The Blessed". TheOnion.com. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
{{cite web}}
: Unknown parameter|coauthors=
ignored (|author=
suggested) (help) - ^ Morgan, Kim. "The DVD Journal". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
{{cite web}}
: Text "Quick Reviews: Starship Troopers: Special Edition" ignored (help) - ^ "The Big DataBase of Comic Books: Starship Troopers". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Starship Troopers: Prepare For Battle!". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Starship Troopers: Terran Ascendancy". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Student Research Area: Orson Scott Card Answers Questions". 2000. Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Harry Harrison". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Hoffman, Douglas (2005). "Old Man's War: The Distaff View". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ "Internet Movie Database: Aliens Trivia". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ A training mission in Tribes 2 uses the phrase "on the bounce" from the novel
- ^ "Interview with Paul Neurath at RPGDot.Com". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
- ^ Heinlein was thanked in the credits of Starcraft."Full Cast and Crew for StarCraft". Retrieved 2006-03-04.
Editions
- June 1, 1960, Putnam Publishing Group, hardcover, ISBN 0-399-20209-9
- May, 1968, Berkley Medallion Edition, paperback, ISBN 425-02945-X
- January 1984, Berkley Publishing Group, paperback, ISBN 0-425-07158-8
- November 1985, Berkley Publishing Group, paperback, ISBN 0-425-09144-9
- November 1986, Berkley Publishing Group, paperback, ISBN 0-425-09926-1
- May 1, 1987, Ace Books, paperback, 263 pages, ISBN 0-441-78358-9
- October 1, 1995, Buccaneer Books, hardcover, ISBN 1-56849-287-1
- December 1, 1997, Blackstone Audiobooks, cassette audiobook, ISBN 0-7861-1231-X
- July 1, 1998, G. K. Hall & Company, large print hardcover, 362 pages, ISBN 0-7838-0118-1
- October 1, 1999, Sagebrush, library binding, ISBN 0-7857-8728-3
- January 1, 2000, Blackstone Audiobooks, CD audiobook, ISBN 0-7861-9946-6
References
- Angelo, Carlos. Robert A. Heinlein, Dean of Science Fiction Writers.
- Causo, Roberto de Sousa (February 21, 1998). "Citizenship at War". O Jornal da Tarde. pp. XX.
- Starship Troopers: The PITFCS Debate: A two year debate about the novel in a Science Fiction publication occuring immediately after its publication.
- Gifford, James (Year Unknown). "The Nature of Federal Service in Starship Troopers" (PDF).
{{cite journal}}
: Check date values in:|date=
(help); Cite journal requires|journal=
(help)
- Heinlein, Robert A. (2003). Expanded Universe. Baen. ISBN 0-7434-7159-8. Contains Heinlein's comments on the writing and the politics of Starship Troopers, as well as the polemical speech "The Pragmatics of Patriotism" on the moral basis of the military.
- "The Heinlein Society". Official Robert Anson Heinlein Estate Endorsed Website. Retrieved December.
{{cite web}}
: Check date values in:|accessdate=
(help); Unknown parameter|accessyear=
ignored (|access-date=
suggested) (help)
- Moorcock, Michael. Starship Stormtroopers, Cienfuegos Press Anarchist Review, 1978.
- Panshin, Alexei (1968). Heinlein in Dimension. Advent Publishers. ISBN 0911682120.
- Panshin, Alexei (Year Unknown). "Rite of Passage and Robert Heinlein".
{{cite journal}}
: Check date values in:|date=
(help); Cite journal requires|journal=
(help) Describes a correspondence with Heinlein over "Starship Troopers" in 1959.
- Pinkerton, James (May 2003). "Starship Trooperization". Tech Central Station Daily.
{{cite journal}}
: CS1 maint: year (link)
- Weuve, Christopher. Thoughts on Starship Troopers. Examines some of the issues surrounding Heinlein's version and Verhoeven's version.
See also
External links
- Starship Troopers title listing at the Internet Speculative Fiction Database
- [http://thereferats.net Milit
- Starry-Eyed Internationalists" versus the Social Darwinists by Rafeeq O. McGiveron. Examines Heinlein's transnational governments, including the Terran Federation.
- [http://www.space.com/sciencefiction/books/troopers_book_000610.html Milit
- Starship Troopers title listing at the Internet Speculative Fiction Database
arism and Utopia in 'Starship Troopers'] by Robert Peterson. Argues that Heinlein's Federation is a fascist government.
- Citizenship at War by Roberto de Sousa Causo. Review from a Brazilian newspaper.
- SciFi.Com book review by Craig E. Engler.
- Gotterdammerung.Org book review by Branislav L. Slantchev.
- SFReviews.Net book review by T. M. Wagner.
- "STARSHIP TROOPERS" by Robert A. Heinlein. An opinion by Richard Geib.
- "Thoughts on Starship Troopers" by Christopher W.