User:WormTT/Adopt/Wikiquette/Test: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 20:08, 11 October 2012

Have a look at the conversation below:

What's the best car in the world? -- Rod

Probably something German or Japanese. -- Freddie

Like what -- Rod's Mate

I dunno, something like Volkswagon? -- Freddie

Volkswagon Passat --Passat Lover <-Postion:A

What do you want it for? -- Jane

Volkswagon Passat --Passat Lover <-Position:B

Well, the Passat lover clearly loves his Passat, but who is he replying to? In

1) Position A?

A-

2) Position B?

A-

3) An editor who has a low edit count seems awfully competent with templates. Should he be reported as a possible WP:SOCK?

A-

@@ Line 13: / Line 13: @@
 ) Position A?
+:A-
-:A- "Like what" by Rod's Mate
 ) Position B?
+:A-
-:A- "What's the best car in the world?" by Rod
 ) An editor who has a low edit count seems awfully competent with templates. Should he be reported as a possible [[WP:SOCK]]?
+:A-
-:A- No, because you should assume good faith, unless he is vandalizing the templates. A possible reason is that the editor has read a lot about templates before contributing. Also, edit count is not that accurate, because some editors make many small edits, while other editors make a few large edits.