Boycott (novel): Difference between revisions
→Critical Reception: tag for advertising |
No edit summary |
||
Line 14: | Line 14: | ||
==Critical Reception== |
==Critical Reception== |
||
{{Advert|section|date=April 2013}} |
{{Advert|section|date=April 2013}} |
||
'''Boycott''' received a generally positive critical response, although some reviewers felt it might have been more tightly edited. Writing in the [[Irish Independent]] literary supplement, Irish novelist [[Dermot Bolger]] described ''Boycott'' as ‘A hugely ambitious debut novel. Murphy astutely backs up his narrative with minute research and well-drawn characters.' While Bolger felt that the book was 'a valuable piece of writing on a historical level' he also believed that the novel was slightly flawed through repetition and that better editing might have prevented ‘points being repeatedly hammered home’. But he concluded that ''Boycott'' was 'an engaging labour of love novel that deserved a wide readership'.<ref>Irish Independent review, Saturday Feb 9th 2013</ref> Playwright [[Frank McGuinness]] said: ‘''Boycott'' has all the marks of a mature novelist. The author’s command of language is impressive and his storytelling masterful. There is a great sense of urgency that motivates the book, which is perfectly paced and beautifully written. Its achievement is impressive.’<ref>O’Brien Press/''Boycott'' Launch’</ref> Books Ireland's Lucille Redmond felt that ‘some of the book’s descriptive passages could have been cut by two thirds without harming the story’, but overall believed it to be a ‘stirring and deeply researched story, a rattling yarn with the action racing along, brilliant twists, flawed heroes and evil villains’, <ref>Books Ireland review, February 2013</ref> |
|||
Sue Leonard of [[The Irish Examiner]] described the novel as ‘beautifully written, a skilful blend of fact and fiction’, and the Irish literary website |
Sue Leonard of [[The Irish Examiner]] described the novel as ‘beautifully written, a skilful blend of fact and fiction’, and the Irish literary website writing.ie said: The story gallops along and keeps the reader attentive and engaged with its lively, vivid, and varied writing. The [[Connemara]] Journal reviewer felt that the depiction of Charles Boycott was a little too ‘bombastic’, but described the novel as ‘gripping’. <ref>Connemara Journal/Online review Feb 12th 2013</ref> The UK’s New Books Magazine said that ''Boycott'' was ‘gripping from beginning to end…the historical realism is played out nicely throughout with vivid imagination, thought and process.’ <ref>New Books Magazine/’’Boycott’’ review Nov 15th 2012</ref> The books review website [[Goodreads]] gave ''Boycott'' a rating of 4.6 out of 5. <ref>Goodreads/Boycott: A Historical Novel</ref> |
||
==References== |
==References== |
Revision as of 11:52, 26 April 2013
Boycott is a novel by Irish author Colin C. Murphy, published in 2012. The story is based on the real-life events in Ireland surrounding Captain Charles Boycott, which led to the introduction of the word ‘boycott’ to the English language.
Plot
Although the events surrounding Captain Charles Boycott that brought him to international attention occurred in 1879-80, the novel has parallel narratives alternating between this period and approximately thirty years earlier. The story centres on two brothers, Owen and Thomas Joyce, and begins when they are youths in 1848, at the height of The Great Famine. As the boys struggle to survive, their experiences (involving, among other things, coffin ships, workhouses and cannibalism), profoundly shape their attitudes in different ways towards landlordism and Irish freedom from British imperialism. [1] Thirty years later, Owen is a tenant on the Lough Mask Estate in County Mayo, which is run by the land agent, Charles Boycott. Boycott refuses to lower the rents and inspired by a famous speech by Charles Stewart Parnell, and with the encouragement of the local parish priest Father John O’Malley, the tenants embark on a campaign of ostracism of Boycott and his family. When Boycott writes a letter to the London Times, an editorial [2] sparks widespread interest and the story attracts international news coverage. [3][4][5][6] While Owen is at the forefront of the passive resistance campaign of ostracism, his brother, Thomas, believes that only violence can achieve an end to landlordism and ultimately bring about Irish freedom.[7] The brothers’ conflict becomes in effect a reflection of the wider attitude in Ireland during the second half of the 19th century, which saw different factions advocating either violent or non-violent action to achieve their aims. [8] The novel culminates in the British government despatching a large military force to protect Boycott, an event which ultimately brings the brothers directly into conflict with each other and provokes disturbing revelations about how they’d survived the famine thirty years beforehand. The novel also employs the device of beginning each chapter with a number of actual contemporary news reports from the international media. [9]
Themes
The novel explores the uses of non-violence or passive resistance as opposed to armed resistance in achieving political and social change.[10] It also explores the question of whether the British Government might have been responsible for an act of genocide in Ireland during the Great Famine, but does not exclude British victims of this often violent and traumatic period in Irish history.[11] The story also demonstrates an early example of how the interest of the international press can bring a relatively minor event to almost global attention.[12]
Critical Reception
This section contains promotional content. (April 2013) |
Boycott received a generally positive critical response, although some reviewers felt it might have been more tightly edited. Writing in the Irish Independent literary supplement, Irish novelist Dermot Bolger described Boycott as ‘A hugely ambitious debut novel. Murphy astutely backs up his narrative with minute research and well-drawn characters.' While Bolger felt that the book was 'a valuable piece of writing on a historical level' he also believed that the novel was slightly flawed through repetition and that better editing might have prevented ‘points being repeatedly hammered home’. But he concluded that Boycott was 'an engaging labour of love novel that deserved a wide readership'.[13] Playwright Frank McGuinness said: ‘Boycott has all the marks of a mature novelist. The author’s command of language is impressive and his storytelling masterful. There is a great sense of urgency that motivates the book, which is perfectly paced and beautifully written. Its achievement is impressive.’[14] Books Ireland's Lucille Redmond felt that ‘some of the book’s descriptive passages could have been cut by two thirds without harming the story’, but overall believed it to be a ‘stirring and deeply researched story, a rattling yarn with the action racing along, brilliant twists, flawed heroes and evil villains’, [15] Sue Leonard of The Irish Examiner described the novel as ‘beautifully written, a skilful blend of fact and fiction’, and the Irish literary website writing.ie said: The story gallops along and keeps the reader attentive and engaged with its lively, vivid, and varied writing. The Connemara Journal reviewer felt that the depiction of Charles Boycott was a little too ‘bombastic’, but described the novel as ‘gripping’. [16] The UK’s New Books Magazine said that Boycott was ‘gripping from beginning to end…the historical realism is played out nicely throughout with vivid imagination, thought and process.’ [17] The books review website Goodreads gave Boycott a rating of 4.6 out of 5. [18]
References
- ^ Boycott cover notes, Brandon Press edition, 2012
- ^ Times newspaper, October 18th 1880
- ^ New York Times/Series of reports/Sept – Dec 1880
- ^ La Presse/Le Monde reports Nov 1880
- ^ Zierikzeesche Nieuwsbode Holland Nov 17th-26th 1880
- ^ Sydney Morning Herald reports Nov 30th 1880
- ^ Goodreads/Boycott: A Historical Novel
- ^ Irish Independent review, Saturday Feb 9th 2013
- ^ Books Ireland review, February 2013
- ^ Irish Independent review, Saturday Feb 9th 2013
- ^ Goodreads/Boycott: A Historical Novel
- ^ ’’Boycott’’ Historical Epilogue, Brandon Press edition, 2012
- ^ Irish Independent review, Saturday Feb 9th 2013
- ^ O’Brien Press/Boycott Launch’
- ^ Books Ireland review, February 2013
- ^ Connemara Journal/Online review Feb 12th 2013
- ^ New Books Magazine/’’Boycott’’ review Nov 15th 2012
- ^ Goodreads/Boycott: A Historical Novel