Schur product theorem

In mathematics, particularly in linear algebra, the Schur product theorem states that the Hadamard product of two positive definite matrices is also a positive definite matrix. The result is named after Issai Schur (Schur 1911, p. 14, Theorem VII) (note that Schur signed as J. Schur in Journal für die reine und angewandte Mathematik.)

Proof

Proof using the trace formula

It is easy to show that for matrices $M$ and $N$, the Hadamard product $M\circ N$ considered as a bilinear form acts on vectors $a,b$ as

$a^{T}(M\circ N)b=\operatorname {Tr} (M\operatorname {diag} (a)N\operatorname {diag} (b))$

where $\operatorname {Tr}$ is the matrix trace and $\operatorname {diag} (a)$ is the diagonal matrix having as diagonal entries the elements of $a$.

Since $M$ and $N$ are positive definite, we can consider their square-roots $M^{1/2}$ and $N^{1/2}$ and write

$\operatorname {Tr} (M\operatorname {diag} (a)N\operatorname {diag} (b))=\operatorname {Tr} (M^{1/2}M^{1/2}\operatorname {diag} (a)N^{1/2}N^{1/2}\operatorname {diag} (b))=\operatorname {Tr} (M^{1/2}\operatorname {diag} (a)N^{1/2}N^{1/2}\operatorname {diag} (b)M^{1/2})$

Then, for $a=b$, this is written as $\operatorname {Tr} (A^{T}A)$ for $A=N^{1/2}\operatorname {diag} (a)M^{1/2}$ and thus is positive. This shows that $(M\circ N)$ is a positive definite matrix.

Proof using Gaussian integration

Case of M = N

Let $X$ be an $n$-dimensional centered Gaussian random variable with covariance $\langle X_{i}X_{j}\rangle =M_{ij}$. Then the covariance matrix of $X_{i}^{2}$ and $X_{j}^{2}$ is

$\operatorname {Cov} (X_{i}^{2},X_{j}^{2})=\langle X_{i}^{2}X_{j}^{2}\rangle -\langle X_{i}^{2}\rangle \langle X_{j}^{2}\rangle$

Using Wick's theorem to develop $\langle X_{i}^{2}X_{j}^{2}\rangle =2\langle X_{i}X_{j}\rangle ^{2}+\langle X_{i}^{2}\rangle \langle X_{j}^{2}\rangle$ we have

$\operatorname {Cov} (X_{i}^{2},X_{j}^{2})=2\langle X_{i}X_{j}\rangle ^{2}=2M_{ij}^{2}$

Since a covariance matrix is positive definite, this proves that the matrix with elements $M_{ij}^{2}$ is a positive definite matrix.

General case

Let $X$ and $Y$ be $n$-dimensional centered Gaussian random variables with covariances $\langle X_{i}X_{j}\rangle =M_{ij}$, $\langle Y_{i}Y_{j}\rangle =N_{ij}$ and independt from each other so that we have

$\langle X_{i}Y_{j}\rangle =0$ for any $i,j$

Then the covariance matrix of $X_{i}Y_{i}$ and $X_{j}Y_{j}$ is

$\operatorname {Cov} (X_{i}Y_{i},X_{j}Y_{j})=\langle X_{i}Y_{i}X_{j}Y_{j}\rangle -\langle X_{i}Y_{i}\rangle \langle X_{j}Y_{j}\rangle$

Using Wick's theorem to develop

$\langle X_{i}Y_{i}X_{j}Y_{j}\rangle =\langle X_{i}X_{j}\rangle \langle Y_{i}Y_{j}\rangle +\langle X_{i}Y_{i}\rangle \langle X_{i}Y_{j}\rangle +\langle X_{i}Y_{j}\rangle \langle X_{j}Y_{i}\rangle$

and also using the independence of $X$ and $Y$, we have

$\operatorname {Cov} (X_{i}Y_{i},X_{j}Y_{j})=\langle X_{i}X_{j}\rangle \langle Y_{i}Y_{j}\rangle =M_{ij}N_{ij}$

Since a covariance matrix is positive definite, this proves that the matrix with elements $M_{ij}N_{ij}$ is a positive definite matrix.

Proof using eigendecomposition

Proof of positivity

Let $M=\sum \mu _{i}m_{i}m_{i}^{T}$ and $N=\sum \nu _{i}n_{i}n_{i}^{T}$. Then

$M\circ N=\sum _{ij}\mu _{i}\nu _{i}(m_{i}m_{i}^{T})\circ (n_{i}n_{i}^{T})=\sum _{ij}\mu _{i}\nu _{j}(m_{i}\circ n_{j})(m_{i}\circ n_{j})^{T}$

Each $(m_{i}\circ n_{j})(m_{i}\circ n_{j})^{T}$ is positive (but, except in the 1-dimensional case, not positive definite, since they are rank 1 matrices) and $\mu _{i}\nu _{j}>0$, thus the sum giving $M\circ N$ is also positive.

Complete proof

To show that the result is positive definite requires further proof. We shall show that for any vector $a\neq 0$, we have $a^{T}(M\circ N)a>0$. Continuing as above, each $a^{T}(m_{i}\circ n_{j})(m_{i}\circ n_{j})^{T}a\geq 0$, so it remains to show that there exist $i$ and $j$ for which the inequality is strict. For this we observe that

$a^{T}(m_{i}\circ n_{j})(m_{i}\circ n_{j})^{T}a=\left(\sum _{k}m_{i,k}n_{j,k}a_{k}\right)^{2}$

Since $N$ is positive definite, there is a $j$ for which $n_{j,k}a_{k}$ is not 0 for all $k$, and then, since $M$ is positive definite, there is an $i$ for which $m_{i,k}n_{j,k}a_{k}$ is not 0 for all $k$. Then for this $i$and $j$ we have $\left(\sum _{k}m_{i,k}n_{j,k}a_{k}\right)^{2}>0$. This completes the proof.

External links

• Bemerkungen zur Theorie der beschränkten Bilinearformen mit unendlich vielen Veränderlichen at EUDML