Sellic Spell: Difference between revisions
Pslangeslag (talk | contribs) m Content tweak: "seeks to clarify and integrate" |
Pslangeslag (talk | contribs) m Language and content tweak: "version as published is furthermore incomplete, breaking off" |
||
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
== Dating and Composition == |
== Dating and Composition == |
||
The text's editor, [[Christopher Tolkien]], dates much of the composition and revision of the tale to the early 1940s.{{sfn | Tolkien | 2014 | p = 359}} In a note discovered among his papers, J.R.R. Tolkien claims to have "[put] it first into Old English".{{sfn | Tolkien | 2014 | p = 355}} However, Christopher Tolkien observes that this sequence of events is inconsistent with the textual evidence, since the earliest manuscript of the Modern English text was revised into a form that corresponds in several places to the Old English text.{{sfn | Tolkien | 2014 | pp = 404-406}} The Old English version |
The text's editor, [[Christopher Tolkien]], dates much of the composition and revision of the tale to the early 1940s.{{sfn | Tolkien | 2014 | p = 359}} In a note discovered among his papers, J.R.R. Tolkien claims to have "[put] it first into Old English".{{sfn | Tolkien | 2014 | p = 355}} However, Christopher Tolkien observes that this sequence of events is inconsistent with the textual evidence, since the earliest manuscript of the Modern English text was revised into a form that corresponds in several places to the Old English text.{{sfn | Tolkien | 2014 | pp = 404-406}} The Old English version as published is furthermore incomplete, breaking off before either of the two companions faces Grendel. The Modern English text exists in three (partial) manuscripts and two typescripts; Christopher Tolkien published the text of the later typescript along with the Old English translation and a discussion of the tale's revision history in 2014. |
||
== References == |
== References == |
||
Revision as of 05:44, 13 June 2014
Sellic Spell ([ˌsɛlːiːtʃ ˈspɛlː], an Old English phrase meaning "wondrous tale" and taken from the poem Beowulf)[1] is a short prose text written by J.R.R. Tolkien in a creative attempt to reconstruct the folktale underlying the narrative in the first two thousand lines of the Old English poem Beowulf.[2] Among other things, it seeks to clarify and integrate a number of narrative strands in the early medieval poem.[3] The resulting text is a loose variant of the Skilful Companions type of folktale, in which each of several characters (two or three in Tolkien's text, depending on the redaction) has a valuable but specific skill. Unlike in folktales of that type, however, the skills of Tolkien's characters do not supplement each other in the resolution of the narrative problem.
Dating and Composition
The text's editor, Christopher Tolkien, dates much of the composition and revision of the tale to the early 1940s.[4] In a note discovered among his papers, J.R.R. Tolkien claims to have "[put] it first into Old English".[3] However, Christopher Tolkien observes that this sequence of events is inconsistent with the textual evidence, since the earliest manuscript of the Modern English text was revised into a form that corresponds in several places to the Old English text.[5] The Old English version as published is furthermore incomplete, breaking off before either of the two companions faces Grendel. The Modern English text exists in three (partial) manuscripts and two typescripts; Christopher Tolkien published the text of the later typescript along with the Old English translation and a discussion of the tale's revision history in 2014.
References
- ^ Tolkien, J.R.R. (2014). Christopher Tolkien (ed.). Beowulf: A Translation and Commentary Together with Sellic Spell. London: HarperCollinsPublishers. p. 358. ISBN 978-0-00-759006-3.
{{cite book}}: Italic or bold markup not allowed in:|publisher=(help) - ^ Tolkien 2014.
- ^ a b Tolkien 2014, p. 355.
- ^ Tolkien 2014, p. 359.
- ^ Tolkien 2014, pp. 404–406.