Apple III: Difference between revisions
Apple III was succeeded by the Apple III Plus (not Apple IIc or Lisa) |
A2-computist (talk | contribs) →Design flaws: Removed erroneous heatsink information. |
||
| Line 55: | Line 55: | ||
==Design flaws== |
==Design flaws== |
||
According to Wozniak, the Apple III "had 100 percent hardware failures".{{r|byte198501}} [[Steve Jobs]] insisted on the idea of no fan or air vents – in order to make the computer run quietly. Jobs would later push this same ideology onto almost all Apple models he had control of – from the [[Apple Lisa]] and [[Macintosh 128K]] to the [[iMac]].<ref>[http://onscreen-scientist.com/?tag=fan-control First Cool, Now Quiet]</ref> To allow the computer to dissipate heat, the base of the Apple III was made of heavy cast aluminum, which supposedly acted as a heat sink. One undeniable advantage to the aluminum case was a reduction in RFI (Radio Frequency Interference), a problem which had plagued the Apple II series throughout its history. Unlike the Apple II series, the power supply was mounted – without its own shell – in a compartment separate from the logic board. The decision to use an aluminum shell ultimately led to engineering issues which resulted in the Apple III's reliability problems. The lead time for manufacturing the shells was high, and this had to be done before the motherboard was finalized. Later it was realized that there wasn't enough room on the motherboard for all of the components unless narrow traces were used. |
According to Wozniak, the Apple III "had 100 percent hardware failures".{{r|byte198501}} [[Steve Jobs]] insisted on the idea of no fan or air vents – in order to make the computer run quietly. Jobs would later push this same ideology onto almost all Apple models he had control of – from the [[Apple Lisa]] and [[Macintosh 128K]] to the [[iMac]].<ref>[http://onscreen-scientist.com/?tag=fan-control First Cool, Now Quiet]</ref> To allow the computer to dissipate heat, the base of the Apple III was made of heavy cast aluminum, which supposedly acted as a heat sink. One undeniable advantage to the aluminum case was a reduction in RFI (Radio Frequency Interference), a problem which had plagued the Apple II series throughout its history. Unlike the Apple II series, the power supply was mounted – without its own shell – in a compartment separate from the logic board. The decision to use an aluminum shell ultimately led to engineering issues which resulted in the Apple III's reliability problems. The lead time for manufacturing the shells was high, and this had to be done before the motherboard was finalized. Later it was realized that there wasn't enough room on the motherboard for all of the components unless narrow traces were used. |
||
[[File:Apple III+ case.jpg|thumb|left|200px|Apple III Plus showing the |
[[File:Apple III+ case.jpg|thumb|left|200px|Apple III Plus showing the RFI shield over the floppy drive and the cast aluminum case]] |
||
Many Apple IIIs failed because, as ''[[BYTE]]'' wrote, "the integrated circuits tended to wander out of their sockets".<ref name="moore198209">{{cite news | url=http://archive.org/stream/byte-magazine-1982-09/1982_09_BYTE_07-09_Computers_and_the_Disabled#page/n93/mode/2up | title=The Apple III and Its New Profile | work=BYTE | date=September 1982 | accessdate=October 19, 2013 | author=Moore, Robin | page=92}}</ref> The fix Apple suggested for this problem was to lift the Apple III off the desk until it was three inches in the air and then drop it, repeating the procedure until the symptoms disappeared. While the fix was quite effective, many purchasers found the process alarming.<ref>{{cite web|title=Apple III Chaos?|url=http://lowendmac.com/2013/apple-iii-chaos-apples-first-failure/}}</ref> |
Many Apple IIIs failed because, as ''[[BYTE]]'' wrote, "the integrated circuits tended to wander out of their sockets".<ref name="moore198209">{{cite news | url=http://archive.org/stream/byte-magazine-1982-09/1982_09_BYTE_07-09_Computers_and_the_Disabled#page/n93/mode/2up | title=The Apple III and Its New Profile | work=BYTE | date=September 1982 | accessdate=October 19, 2013 | author=Moore, Robin | page=92}}</ref> The fix Apple suggested for this problem was to lift the Apple III off the desk until it was three inches in the air and then drop it, repeating the procedure until the symptoms disappeared. While the fix was quite effective, many purchasers found the process alarming.<ref>{{cite web|title=Apple III Chaos?|url=http://lowendmac.com/2013/apple-iii-chaos-apples-first-failure/}}</ref> |
||
''inCider'' stated in 1986 that "Heat has always been a formidable enemy of the Apple ///",{{r|obrien198609}} allegedly caused by insufficient cooling and inability to dissipate the heat efficiently |
''inCider'' stated in 1986 that "Heat has always been a formidable enemy of the Apple ///",{{r|obrien198609}} allegedly caused by insufficient cooling and inability to dissipate the heat efficiently. Some users stated that their Apple III became so hot that the chips started dislodging from the board, the screen would display garbled data, or their [[Floppy disk|disk]] would come out of the slot "melted". In a technical bulletin, customers who were experiencing certain problems were instructed to lift the machine {{convert|3|in|mm}} and drop it in order to re-seat the chips on the logic board.<ref name="apconf"/> |
||
Case designer [[Jerry Manock]] denied the design flaw charges, stating that tests proved that the unit adequately dissipated the internal heat. The primary cause, he claimed, was a major logic board design problem. The logic board used "fineline" technology that was not fully mature at the time, with narrow, closely spaced traces.<ref name="youtube.com">[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--7Br07QKMk Computer History Museum: Apple Industrial Designers Robert Brunner and Jerry Manock]</ref> When chips were "stuffed" into the board and [[Wave soldering|wave-soldered]], solder bridges would form between traces that were not supposed to be connected. This caused numerous short circuits, which required hours of costly diagnosis and hand rework to fix. Apple designed a new circuit board, with more layers and normal-width traces. The new logic board was laid out by one designer on a huge drafting board, rather than using the costly [[Computer-aided design|CAD]]-[[Computer-aided manufacturing|CAM]] system used for the previous board, and the new design worked. With normal-width traces there wasn't enough room for all of the components, so a separate daughterboard had to be designed for the RAM which would fit within the existing heatsink.{{citation needed|date=April 2012}} |
Case designer [[Jerry Manock]] denied the design flaw charges, stating that tests proved that the unit adequately dissipated the internal heat. The primary cause, he claimed, was a major logic board design problem. The logic board used "fineline" technology that was not fully mature at the time, with narrow, closely spaced traces.<ref name="youtube.com">[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=--7Br07QKMk Computer History Museum: Apple Industrial Designers Robert Brunner and Jerry Manock]</ref> When chips were "stuffed" into the board and [[Wave soldering|wave-soldered]], solder bridges would form between traces that were not supposed to be connected. This caused numerous short circuits, which required hours of costly diagnosis and hand rework to fix. Apple designed a new circuit board, with more layers and normal-width traces. The new logic board was laid out by one designer on a huge drafting board, rather than using the costly [[Computer-aided design|CAD]]-[[Computer-aided manufacturing|CAM]] system used for the previous board, and the new design worked. With normal-width traces there wasn't enough room for all of the components, so a separate daughterboard had to be designed for the RAM which would fit within the existing heatsink.{{citation needed|date=April 2012}} |
||
Revision as of 21:49, 16 September 2014
Template:Mac specs The Apple III (often rendered as Apple ///) is a business-oriented personal computer produced and released by Apple Computer that was intended as the successor to the Apple II series, but largely considered a failure in the market. Development work on the Apple III started in late 1978 under the guidance of Dr. Wendell Sander. It had the internal code name of "Sara", named after Sander's daughter.[1][unreliable source?] The machine was first announced and released on May 19, 1980, but due to serious stability issues that required a design overhaul and a recall of existing machines, it was formally reintroduced the following autumn.[2] Development stopped and the Apple III was discontinued on April 24, 1984, and the III Plus was dropped from the Apple product line in September 1985.[3]
The Apple III could be viewed as an enhanced Apple II – then the newest heir to a line of 8-bit machines dating back to 1976. However, the Apple III was not part of the Apple II line, but rather a close cousin. The key features business users wanted in a personal computer were a true typewriter-style upper/lowercase keyboard (as opposed to the Apple II which was based on a teletype keyboard) and 80 column display. In addition, the machine had to pass U.S. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Radio Frequency Interference (RFI) qualifications for business equipment. In 1981, International Business Machines unveiled the IBM Personal Computer (IBM PC) – a completely new 16-bit design soon available in a wide range of inexpensive clones. The business market moved rapidly towards the PC DOS/MS-DOS platform, eventually pulling away from the Apple 8-bit computer line.[4]
Despite numerous stability issues and a recall that included the first 14,000 units off the assembly line, Apple was eventually able to produce a reliable and dependable version of the machine. However, damage to the computer's reputation had already been done and it failed to do well commercially as a direct result. In the end, an estimated 65,000–75,000 Apple III computers were sold.[2][3] The Apple III Plus brought this up to ~120,000.[3] Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak stated that the primary reason for the Apple III's failure was that the system was designed by Apple's marketing department, unlike Apple's previous engineering-driven projects.[5] The Apple III's failure led to Apple reevaluating their plan to phase out the Apple II, and eventual continuation of development of the older machine. As a result, later Apple II models incorporated some hardware, such as the Apple Scribe Printer, a thermal printer, and software technologies of the Apple III.
| Timeline of Apple II family |
|---|
 |
Design
The Apple III was designed to be a business computer and an eventual successor for the Apple II. While the Apple II contributed to the inspirations of several important business products, such as VisiCalc, Multiplan and Apple Writer, the computer's hardware architecture, operating system and developer environment were limited.[6] The Apple III addressed these weaknesses. According to Steve Wozniak, VisiCalc and Disk II had caused the Apple II's popularity, with 90% of sales going to businesses as opposed to the hobbyists that were its original market. Apple management intended to clearly establish market segmentation by designing the Apple III to appeal to the business market, leaving the Apple II to home and education users. Management believed that "once the Apple III was out, the Apple II would stop selling in six months", Wozniak said.[7]
The Apple III was powered by a 1.8 MHz Synertek 6502A or B[8] 8-bit CPU and, like some of the more advanced machines in the Apple II family, used bank switching techniques to address up to 256 KB of memory. Third-party vendors also produced memory upgrade kits that allowed the Apple III to reach up to 512 KB. Other Apple III built-in features included an 80-column, 24-line display with upper and lowercase characters, a numeric keypad, dual-speed (pressure-sensitive) cursor control keys, 6-bit (DAC) audio, and a built-in 140 KB 5.25" floppy disk drive. Graphics modes included 560x192 in black and white, and 280x192 with 16 colors or shades of gray. Unlike the Apple II, the Disk III controller was built into the logic board.
The Apple III was the first Apple product that allowed the user to choose both a screen font and a keyboard layout: either QWERTY or Dvorak. These choices could not be changed while programs were running, unlike the Apple IIc, which had a keyboard switch directly above the keyboard, allowing switching on the fly.
Software
_(8249708093).jpg)
A major limitation of the Apple II and DOS 3.3 was the way it addressed resources, which made it highly desirable for peripherals to be installed in standardized locations (slot 5 and 6 reserved for storage devices, slot 2 reserved for serial communication interfaces, etc.) This forced the user to identify a peripheral by its physical location, such as PR#6, CATALOG, D1, and so on.[9] The Apple III introduced an advanced operating system called Apple SOS, pronounced "apple sauce". Its ability to address resources by name instead of a physical location allowed the Apple III to be more scalable. Apple SOS also allowed the full capacity of a storage device to be used as a single volume, such as the Apple ProFile hard disk drive. Also, Apple SOS supported a hierarchical file system (HFS). Some of the features and code base of Apple SOS made their way into the Apple II's ProDOS and GS/OS operating systems, as well as Lisa 7/7 and Macintosh system software.
The Apple III also introduced a new BASIC interpreter called Apple III Business BASIC, and later an implementation of UCSD Pascal for more structured programming.
Because Apple did not view the Apple III as suitable for hobbyists, it did not provide much of the technical software information that accompanied the Apple II.[10] Originally intended as a direct replacement to the Apple II series, it was designed to be backwards compatible with Apple II software. However, since Apple did not want to encourage continued development of the II platform, Apple II compatibility existed only in a special "Apple II Mode" which was limited in its capabilities to the emulation of a basic 48 KB Apple II+ configuration. Special chips were intentionally added to prevent access to the III's advanced features such as its larger memory.[7] Since many business-oriented Apple II programs started requiring at least 64 KB of RAM (i.e. an 48 KB Apple II with an added 16 KB "language card") around the time the III was released, they were incompatible with the III, preventing some users from switching over.
The Apple III had a System Utilities program, which allowed system reconfiguration and file manipulation. Another program, Selector III, was designed to integrate with the System Utilities program and launch various applications. The program was developed by ON THREE, a large Apple III user group. Another company, Quark Software, developed a competing product, Catalyst, the cruder interface of which was offset by program-switching capabilities and support for copy-protection, which enabled companies to license users to run programs from a hard disk without worrying that their software might be backed up or copied without permission. When Apple decided to bundle Catalyst with its new ProFile hard disk, Quark celebrated,[citation needed] but ON THREE continued to market and sell Selector III through their monthly magazine. Selector III remained commercially available and supported long after Quark discontinued its Apple III product line.
Peripherals
The Apple III had four expansion slots, a number that inCider in 1986 called "miserly".[11] Apple II cards were compatible but risked violating government RFI regulations, and required Apple III-specific device drivers; BYTE stated that "Apple provides virtually no information on how to write them". As with software, Apple provided little hardware technical information with the computer[10] but Apple III-specific products became available, such as one that made the computer compatible with the Apple IIe.[11] Several new Apple-produced peripherals were developed for the Apple III. The original Apple III came with a built-in real-time clock, which was recognized by Apple SOS. The clock was later removed from the "revised" model, and instead was made available as an add-on.
Along with the built-in floppy drive, the Apple III could also handle up to three additional external Disk III floppy disk drives. The Disk III was only officially compatible with the Apple III. The Apple III Plus required an adapter from Apple to use the Disk III with its DB-25 disk port. [12]
With the introduction of the revised Apple III a year after launch Apple began offering the ProFile external hard disk system.[13] Costing US$3499 for 5MB, it also required a peripheral slot for the ProFile controller card.
Revisions
Once the logic board design flaws were discovered, a newer logic board design was produced – which included a lower power requirement, wider traces and better designed chip sockets.[13] The $3,495 revised model also included 256 KB RAM as a standard configuration.[13] The 14,000 units of the original Apple III sold were returned and replaced with the entirely new revised model.
Apple III Plus
The Apple III Plus was introduced in December 1983, while discontinuing the revised III model, at a price of US$2995.[13] This newer version included a built-in clock, video interlacing, standardized rear port connectors, 256K RAM as standard, and a re-designed keyboard. The keyboard was designed in the style of the earlier beige Apple IIe.[13]
Owners of the earlier Apple III could obtain the newer logic board as a service replacement. A keyboard upgrade kit, dubbed "Apple III Plus upgrade kit" was also made available – which included the keyboard, cover, keyboard encoder ROM and logo replacements. This upgrade had to be installed by an authorized service technician.
Design flaws
According to Wozniak, the Apple III "had 100 percent hardware failures".[7] Steve Jobs insisted on the idea of no fan or air vents – in order to make the computer run quietly. Jobs would later push this same ideology onto almost all Apple models he had control of – from the Apple Lisa and Macintosh 128K to the iMac.[14] To allow the computer to dissipate heat, the base of the Apple III was made of heavy cast aluminum, which supposedly acted as a heat sink. One undeniable advantage to the aluminum case was a reduction in RFI (Radio Frequency Interference), a problem which had plagued the Apple II series throughout its history. Unlike the Apple II series, the power supply was mounted – without its own shell – in a compartment separate from the logic board. The decision to use an aluminum shell ultimately led to engineering issues which resulted in the Apple III's reliability problems. The lead time for manufacturing the shells was high, and this had to be done before the motherboard was finalized. Later it was realized that there wasn't enough room on the motherboard for all of the components unless narrow traces were used.
Many Apple IIIs failed because, as BYTE wrote, "the integrated circuits tended to wander out of their sockets".[10] The fix Apple suggested for this problem was to lift the Apple III off the desk until it was three inches in the air and then drop it, repeating the procedure until the symptoms disappeared. While the fix was quite effective, many purchasers found the process alarming.[15]
inCider stated in 1986 that "Heat has always been a formidable enemy of the Apple ///",[11] allegedly caused by insufficient cooling and inability to dissipate the heat efficiently. Some users stated that their Apple III became so hot that the chips started dislodging from the board, the screen would display garbled data, or their disk would come out of the slot "melted". In a technical bulletin, customers who were experiencing certain problems were instructed to lift the machine 3 inches (76 mm) and drop it in order to re-seat the chips on the logic board.[3]
Case designer Jerry Manock denied the design flaw charges, stating that tests proved that the unit adequately dissipated the internal heat. The primary cause, he claimed, was a major logic board design problem. The logic board used "fineline" technology that was not fully mature at the time, with narrow, closely spaced traces.[16] When chips were "stuffed" into the board and wave-soldered, solder bridges would form between traces that were not supposed to be connected. This caused numerous short circuits, which required hours of costly diagnosis and hand rework to fix. Apple designed a new circuit board, with more layers and normal-width traces. The new logic board was laid out by one designer on a huge drafting board, rather than using the costly CAD-CAM system used for the previous board, and the new design worked. With normal-width traces there wasn't enough room for all of the components, so a separate daughterboard had to be designed for the RAM which would fit within the existing heatsink.[citation needed]
Earlier Apple III units came with a built-in real time clock. The hardware, however, would fail after prolonged use.[10] Assuming that National Semiconductor would test all parts before shipping them, Apple did not perform this level of testing. Apple was soldering chips directly to boards, and could not easily change out a bad chip if one was found. Eventually, Apple solved this problem by removing the real-time clock from the Apple III's specification rather than shipping the Apple III with the clock pre-installed, and then sold the peripheral as a level 1 technician add-on.[3]
Commercial failure
For a variety of reasons, the Apple III was a commercial failure. With a starting price between $4,340 to $7,800 US, it was more expensive than many of the CP/M-based business computers that were available at the time.[17] Little Apple III software was available besides VisiCalc,[10] and while sold as Apple II compatible, the emulation that made this possible was intentionally hobbled; thus it could not make use of the advanced III features (specifically 64 KB RAM or higher, required by many Apple II software titles written in Apple Pascal), which limited its usefulness.
Early Apple III users were told that they had to use existing 40-column Apple II word processors and spreadsheet programs, which hurt sales since those programs could be used in 80-column mode on the Apple IIs with the suitable hardware installed. It was not until several months after the Apple III was introduced that native 80-column business software became available.
Influence
The filesystem and some design ideas from Apple SOS, the Apple III's operating system, were part of Apple ProDOS and Apple GS/OS, the major operating systems for the Apple II series following the demise of the Apple III, as well as the Apple Lisa, which was the de facto business-oriented successor to the Apple III. The hierarchical file system influenced the evolution of the Macintosh: while the original Macintosh File System (MFS) was a flat file system designed for a floppy disk without subdirectories, subsequent file systems were hierarchical. By comparison, the IBM PC's first file system (again designed for floppy disks) was flat; likewise, later versions (designed for hard disks) were hierarchical.
See also
References
- ^ yes. Two Apple Failures: Apple III and Lisa[unreliable source?]
- ^ a b Apple III computer @ oldcomputers.net
- ^ a b c d e Linzmayer, Owen W. Apple Confidential 2.0: The Definitive History of the World's Most Colorful Company. pp. 41–43. ISBN 1-59327-010-0.
- ^ The Origin of the IBM PC
- ^ Wozniak, S. G. (2006), iWoz: From Computer Geek to Cult Icon: How I Invented the Personal Computer, Co-Founded Apple, and Had Fun Doing It. W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 0-393-06143-4.
- ^ The Apple III Project
- ^ a b c Williams, Gregg; Moore, Rob (January 1985). "The Apple Story / Part 2: More History and the Apple III". BYTE (interview). p. 166. Retrieved October 26, 2013.
{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link) - ^ "Apple Panic?".
- ^ Beneath Apple DOS, Chapter 6 Using DOS from Assembly Language
- ^ a b c d e Moore, Robin (September 1982). "The Apple III and Its New Profile". BYTE. p. 92. Retrieved October 19, 2013.
- ^ a b c O'Brien, Bill (1986-09). "And II For All". inCider. pp. 38, 94–95. Retrieved 2 July 2014.
{{cite news}}: Check date values in:|date=(help) - ^ "Archived - Floppy Disk Drives: Apple III Plus External Drive Adapter". Apple. February 19, 2012. Retrieved November 23, 2013.
- ^ a b c d e Apple III @ bott.org
- ^ First Cool, Now Quiet
- ^ "Apple III Chaos?".
- ^ Computer History Museum: Apple Industrial Designers Robert Brunner and Jerry Manock
- ^ Cite error: The named reference
avuqmbwas invoked but never defined (see the help page).
External links
