Talk:Rasmea Odeh

Edit warring

Background to this: after I created this article, despite his having been warned by a sysop not to follow my edits and hound me, Tiptoethrutheminefield followed me to this article.

Among his edits, he has three times reverted the entries of two editors (I am one) in the Persondata short description field: here (deleting entry by User:Waacstats; writing "false claim deleted"), and here (deleting entry by Waacstats; writing "Reverting vandalism by Waacstats"), and -- after in my edit summary restoring the Waacstats language I wrote "the refs indicate she is American and was convicted of terrorism", again a third time here (writing "Deleting blp violation").

It is clearly indicated in the article both that the subject is American. And that she was convicted of terrorism.[1][2][3]

I see no BLP violation, and I see no reason for Tiptoethrutheminefield to edit war against two other editors, especially after it has been explained to Tiptoe, and especially since Tiptoe is again hounding me. --Epeefleche (talk) 09:08, 9 November 2014 (UTC)

Please try to stop your support for blp violations. Terrorism is pov wording - as you should well know. Odeh is not an "American criminal", nor an "American terrorist". If you are deluded enough to think you have a complaint of substance against me, either put it up or shut up. However, I want to apologize to Waacstats for my "Reverting vandalism by Waacstats" edit summary. At the time I made the summary I thought he had just restored the deleted wording (American criminal), but after I realized he had changed the wording (though the new wording, American terrorist, was just as inaccurate, and just as unsuitable for a blp article). And since then we discussed the matter here [4], which further tells me that the purpose of Waacstats's edits was not vandalism. Tiptoethrutheminefield (talk) 17:56, 9 November 2014 (UTC)